How Britain Stole $45 Trillion from India with Trains | Empires of Dirt
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024
- There is a misguided idea that India should be grateful for the democracy, law and trains that the British Empire brought to their country. But along with these ‘gifts’, Britain also stole $45 trillion from India during its long and oppressive rule, which culminated in the biggest mass migration in human history during the Partition of India and Pakistan.
And those beloved trains? They became the sites of mass slaughter as violent clashes occurred when over four million people were uprooted from their homes and forced to trek to a Muslim-majority Pakistan and a Hindu-majority India. VICE World News host Zing Tsjeng reveals exactly why India shouldn’t be grateful for their trains.
Click here to subscribe to VICE: bit.ly/Subscrib...
Watch episode one of Empires of Dirt, looking at how the City of London and its financial institutions profited from slavery in America long after the slave trade was abolished: • How Banks Made Money F...
About VICE:
The Definitive Guide To Enlightening Information. From every corner of the planet, our immersive, caustic, ground-breaking and often bizarre stories have changed the way people think about culture, crime, art, parties, fashion, protest, the internet and other subjects that don't even have names yet. Browse the growing library and discover corners of the world you never knew existed. Welcome to VICE.
Connect with VICE:
Check out our full video catalog: bit.ly/VICE-Videos
Videos, daily editorial and more: vice.com
More videos from the VICE network: www. vic...
Click here to get the best of VICE daily: bit.ly/1SquZ6v
Like VICE on Facebook: vice
Follow VICE on Twitter: / vice
Follow us on Instagram: / vice
The VICE RUclips Network:
VICE: / vice
MUNCHIES: / munchies
VICE News: / vicenews
VICELAND: / vicelandtv
Broadly: / broadly
Noisey: / noisey
Motherboard: / motherboardtv
VICE Sports: / noc
i-D: / idmagazine
Waypoint: / waypointvice
Watch episode one of Empires of Dirt, looking at how the City of London and its financial institutions profited from slavery in America long after the slave trade was abolished: ruclips.net/video/rUfMkIx7Ypg/видео.html
Let's hope you widen this, Instead of always British Empire centric… how Portugal/Spain/France exploit their empires.
And journalists… if you were covering history properly, you could at least adopt a neutral tone instead of emotiveness to one side. One is a documentary with vivid language, the latter is virtue signalling.
@@mr.advocatusdiaboli1745 a
Do Algeria and French colonialism
How about a series on American imperialism starting with the United Fruit Company.
Britishers invaded many countries for spices....still uses none in their dishes
best comment in weeks hahaha ! I'll stole it from you
In a video by AIB there was a dialogue that tears have more flavours than British food. 😂😂😂
hahah! this is hilarious, as a British person I can attest
I love the butter chicken masala and naans when I was in India, so delicious!
🇬🇧😎
Thief is always a thief, even if it becomes a billionaire by stealing.
What?
Anyways you ain't even a Indian 😂
No guilt, no apologies, no begging for forgiveness, no prostrating, no, non, none at all.
Some says they aren't ashamed at all.
Because they become rich due to the money they stole
I've learnt more in 6 minutes than I did in school about that. The horrific pain of colonialism has caused
Andre Barrett two sides to every story, this vid is headlining, just for the views, it’s American journalism, she’s no more British than Ghandi
@@markc7099 oh yes, lets hear the other side on how willfully starving 4 millon people to death played out
Just shut up mate
Hari Starving 4 mill to death, have you been drinking, I’ve travelled most of India during the past 6 years, spent approximately 7 months there in different places, not just me but most Brits say the same thing and that is “ the feeling between Indians and the English is wonderful”, I’ve felt that many times, day in day out during my travels, 4 mill starved to death, your blaming The Brits, get real my friend, and don’t tell me to shut up.
@God Emperor your military would be dragged to death within a week for that misadventures mind you my white friend
@Dmitri Shostakovich Lol what kind of logic is that ?? If we didn't have unity, our country would've broken into 100+ pieces by now.
As a British born Indian. I don’t recall ever being taught this in school. Funny that…
_why would they teach us that ...just think of it_
"Think avar think"
Then you must’ve gone to a pretty bad school or didn’t go past GCSE level history, I’m literally learning about this in A level history.
@@Goatz99 isn’t that the point? To be taught this before GCSE when history is a mandatory subject? I did maths, science and economics for A levels many years ago
@@avarmauk I still have my AQA GCSE history revision guide which includes the causes and economic impact of Britains expansion into India. Not to mention all this information is readily available on the internet and at higher education.
@@Goatz99 what’s the internet?
From 1123-1860 India was recognised as THE richest country on Earth as 75% of ALL Eastern trade and 45% of ALL trade with Europe went through them. What has to be remembered is that when the East India Company went to India the literacy rate of the Indians was 37% when Britain left in 1947 it was 4%. That $45 trillion that is being quoted has been officially admitted by the British Govt as being 'Extremely Conservative' or to put it into 'Laymans' words - 'CHICKEN FEED', the figure that has been adjusted is stated to be somewhere in the region of $350/475 trillion!!. It boggles the mind as to just how rich India truly was long before the Maharajas sold out to the British. It's ironic that men like them who's own personal wealth made the Kings/Queens of not only Britain, but, Europe itself look like paupers sold out their own country for the promise of even more wealth - which ironically once the Moghuls were defeated with their help - NEVER MATERIALISED!!. As the General who led the British into the last battle against the Moghuls stated - "Once we've won this battle - then we'll go and piss their fires out next!!".
The British gained India with the help of the greedy and stupid Maharajas whom the Moghuls warned them would use as them as their attack dogs and then turn them into Lapdogs - GUESS WHO GOT THAT RIGHT!!.
No worries ! KARMA will always finish what was left unfinished !!
@Gurpreet Singh KARMA - aka THE ‘SHARIAH LAW OF RECIPROCITY’ APPLICABLE TO ALL HINDUS 🕉, MUSLIMS ☪️ CHRISTIANS ✝️ JEWS 🕎 ETC., -
WHAT GOES AROUND WILL COME AROUND 👍 REQUIRES LOTS OF ‘PATIENCE’ TO SEE 👀 IT HAPPEN !
@@robertwilkinson2889 ALSO 😇
@Daniel v xy nahh. Russia is the boss
Why you people keep pouring to UK then? Stay in your "great" land!
@@japantarzan3551 TO “EXECUTE” KARMA 👹 DUH! 🙄 🐒
They did a great job making this country now one of the poorest in the world,,
India isn't one of the poorest country
India is the 6th richest country in the world. What are you talking about?
Population and inbreeding are India's issues, they have a very strong economy, they just dont use toilets
@@vikas you're looking at how much the whole country produces. You have to look at the same amount per capita. It doesn't mean anything to make a lot of money when there's around 2 billion people there.
@@vikas it is 6th biggest economy not GDP
The British who ruled India in the past were like real life Joffery or Ramsey Bolton from Game of Thrones.
@subliminal juggernaut??? Didn't that happen everywhere?
@subliminal juggernaut seen a couple of spamming comments to make yourself feel good in the name of educating. It's a pity to note that your agenda can't go further as they're just as baseless as yourself.
Wherever the colonizers go, diseases follows them. Latin America wasn't captured by war alone, diseased colonists carries the pathogen. Mind & body, you came as vector of diseases. That's the reason colonialism cannot sustain. I take you as an equal. But don't cross the line by imposing colonialism as a kind of a beacon for development. With or without it, civilizational was bound to happen.
@subliminal juggernaut you are really funny mate. Your counter argument doesn't hold any value. Do you even know how many millions of Indians were killed under British Raj? Any guesses?
The museum of artefacts across UK is just called "chorbazar" in India . Fyi
@M yeah. Forget about Nazis then and all the bad thing they did to . And see how much good they did by bombing London.
Because HISTORY IS HISTORY!!
@M no one is sulking over. India has thousands of problems for which Brits aren't responsible. But at same time 1000 problem exists in India/subcontinent because of that empire.
Plus , oppressive regimes of past (like Germany and Japan) apologized for their crime against humanity.
How many time British Queen or PM apologized?? Just go read about Jaliawala,1857, Bengal Famine.
You cannot murder millions and then claim that we gave them democracy and rail?
@M THAT OLD LADY Of Your CALLED "QUEEN "is from that generation isn't she?
Plus the space program of India doesn't run on your peanuts. And it has saved countless lives and money through Satellite/disaster warning for which we used to pay those same looter who feel superior just because of their ancestors came here and looted this land and killed /raped it's people.
And look who is sulking. We don't need those billions of dollars. Neither we need thate looted money. All we need is just genuine apology for the Crime committed by empire .(government apology.)
@M No aid is given. It is called investment not aid. And if you want to give aid then return our trillion dollars. We would be much happier.
@M Largest armed forces is because of radical Islamists(Pakistan) and communist atheists(China). When you have two friendly wonderful neighbors surrounding your country then you don't need a military right? And you have trillion dollar aid?Lol what a joke? Show me the sources?
They are so ashamed of their deeds, that they couldn't even include them in their books.
@People who Use youtube and who told you that? we know about both sides of the coin, and thus can clearly say that the cons of the empire outweigh the pros.
You on the other hand, have no idea what the british empire did, and thus, can say that india should be thankful.
@People who Use youtube in indian history, 2 people - Akbar and Ashoka, nearly achieved a united India under common rule. Do you think in 200 years of fast improving communication services, no one could have united india? And then, just like the french revolutions, india couldn't have turned to democracy?
India was the LARGEST economy of the world, 23% share of the world gdp at that time. I don't think a country that rich would have been left in ruins without british "help". British was able to achieve unification because of its small size. India being the 7 th largest country, finds that difficult to do.
@People who Use youtube dude wtf is even your point? I know that a part of me is British, and it will never change. And honestly, i like it.
What i cannot bear is people claiming that the British Empire PURPOSEFULLY helped India, or any other country. You rule a country for 200 years, loot 45 trillion dollars from it, and killed more than 30 million people(way more). You introduce railways for your OWN good, so that you can transport loot material faster through the country. English Language was introduced to form a group of Indians, who were Indian in skin color, but British in mannerisms, so that British could communicate with the Indians. NONE of the changes were made to HELP Indians. At the end of a 200 year tyranny, the country comes out democratic, and you deserve thankfulness?
I don't expect Britain to pay back money it took, because how do you pay for innocent lives that were lost to the Empire? And, the present generation cannot be blamed for their ancestors' mistakes
All I ask is for the British to realize what it did was wrong, and to be sorry of what their ancestors did.
India doesn't need your money, as it is we have crossed your gdp.
just realize what you did was wrong.
Exactly. Most countries today have biased pro-nationalist history books.
@People who Use youtube what kind of good deeds? Examples please.
Not just India. African countries also suffered a lot during colonialism. Whenever I read stories about colonialism, it makes me feel dead inside.😥😥
African country’s suffered way worst
Good, then talk about mongol invasion in India
Belguim momento
@@vivekhjanapala4607 not all african ethopia was never colonized and not all african truly suffer because the king is the one selling the slave to british
@@vivekhjanapala4607 Also Russia. Russia is the worst colonizer in the history of the world.
“The sun never set on the british empire because even god couldn’t trust them in the dark.”
-Shashi Tharoor
if we replaced the biritish in the quote with someting jewish i wonder how many would call that racist
He is a chutya
I m indian
I hate when Indians
Blame Brits
It's more than 70 years
@@zeliang5101 slave
@@zeliang5101 You.
Win
England looted 45 trillion dollars from India and BBC news says India a poor country 😂😂😂
Get rid of the West and work together with China ...that is the only way for India
to get rid of the cycle of poverty....
@@CarpsterKing yeah thats a good option but what about ccp doing with uighurs
i wish they detail how they came up with that figure
@Donna Duns so what?
@@charananekibalijaun8837 and those investments garnered returns. We are happy to do business with uk and want to make the most out of our relationship, but your investments are in no way a favour to india. If Britain had such a problem they would have pulled out, but that doesn't happen, cuz even they make money by conducting business with india and indian companies especially in the it sector. y'all can pull out your investments any time, we can find 10 more investors to take your place. By your logic Britain had no right to leave the eu, simply cuz even the eu invested in the uk. But at the same time the uk funded the eu, so it wasn't really a favour was it bruv?
I mean, Brits even stole the word 'Loot' from India. What do you expect.
@Loli4lyf loot is a Hindi word
@Loli4lyf it sound the same "loot". Just the way you say in english
You cant "steal" sound, by that logic India stole the sound of trains CHOO CHOO from the UK. Stupid right?
@@chalmerz99 no we dont call train sounds choo choo 🤣🤣🤣
@@chalmerz99 Bro WTF is this sound dugadugaduga🤣🤣🤣🤣 we dont make this sound either😐
India's weakness was disunity among the small kingdoms, internal wars, religious differences and the absence of a strong empire after the Marathas. The British used this situation to the fullest to colonise India.
Actually before the Britishers arrived , there’s already a major genocide happening by Mughals particularly Aurangzeb.
Maratha empire rose to prominence but after 30 years of constant warfare as well as the unity factor of Shivaji was no more . Marathas was fighting against Mughals , Portuguese in Goa , nizam at Hyderabad, South Indian kings but after got won , they didn’t got a chance to consolidate rather it breaks off very easily in internal fighting .
Britishers did nothing just exploited the weakness by divide and rule policy , Indian kings hated each other more and they didn’t see Britishers as something of a coloniser at first . It’s just a trading company.
Fighting was there , but it comes with disunity among smaller kingdoms .
When you say British dont include ordinary working class people, they got nothing from slavery or india , but like mugs we celebrated empire day while living in poverty. So get over it.
u are one hundered percent correct, they saw the divide, and they exploited that, we were our worst enemies, we could of been the greatest counhtry on earth if hindus and muslims could just live together and understand at the end of the day , we r the same, we dont need two countries/
@@ankurchaudhary3515the British and Portuguese had set up factories in Bihar for saltpetre - weapons manufacturing - way back in 1500s
@@kingsmead646hated ? Nope... There was the old system of aryan Hindu vedic Arya kingdoms at occasional wars for political supermacy..the old Hindu immigrants of past didn't know the name India but Bharat - it's those who settled in foreign nations.
British: Your highness, we have literally looted even the word "Loot" from India.
NOTE: "Loot" is actually a Hindi(Indian language) word with the same meaning.
@Crinkly Dwarf no, there are lots of word in English that are from hindi, like jungle, and yes mother of all languages is sanskrit ( indian languages) and yes sanskrit is oldest language in the world. And also note that hindi is just simple form of sanskrit . Both languages writing format is same like in sanskrit vanarah which means monkey and in hindi it's vanar of so hindi is just modified form of sanskrit, so all languages are from sanskrit. And yes if you are talking about why Indians use english is that there are total. 26 official language and 19300+ mother tongue language in India. So english is just our way to communicate and also with foreigners as english is international language. And yes we learn indian english.
@Crinkly Dwarf Hi Looter
@Crinkly Dwarf yes it does hurt indeed and that's deep😢
@Crinkly Dwarf fyi english is a global language, so yeah we speak English like the rest of the world. And so do you.
@@ray...5174 sanskrit is not the oldest language in the world, Tamil is.
You can steal honey, but you will never know the art of making honey
@subliminal juggernaut vaccinations given to people in the perspection of saving the potential slaves and tax payers for their growth factors. You're talking about those vaccines?? Ain't you aware of tons of massacres happened to Indians by the Britishers.Freedom is worthier than anything. So stop justifying yourself and try to understand the feelings of Indians.
@subliminal juggernaut As you mentioned democracy we Indians have a recorded history of democracy in uttaramerur model of democracy in Tamil Nadu in 10th century , even before your so called britain kingdom is formed.So you better Know the history and the in depth knowledge of India before saying something...
@subliminal juggernaut yeah true I May suffer from the modern malaise of victimhood.But I am sure that you're suffering from non-acceptance towards truth,lack of knowledge and most importantly humanity...All the best for your ku🔥 life da 🌼nda maanae...👍
Keep makin we keep takin/indi hon free
@subliminal juggernaut yeah so your are telling us to believe in the white man's made up history and twisting the narrative according to your free will?
this ain't 17t 18th or 19th century ..
lol i get it , you picked this information from your hooded Klan brothers.. i don't blame you :P
Ruled India ruthlessly for 200 years, without giving rights to Indians.
After nothing left in India - We gave Democracy & Railway.
Indians did have rights, besides. What do you even mean by “rights”? They’re didn’t have rights when the British arrived they were still living under foreign Islamic rule. When the British left they had a greater understanding of what their rights should be through the European conception of human rights
@@Valencetheshireman927 you are still living under a rock . Stop defending something which was not good
@@shubhamgangwar4310 I live having read numerous books on the British empire and can the British empire overall was an objectively good thing. Just as the Roman Empire was.
If you’re offended by that that wasn’t my intention but I can look at these things and look at the primary evidence like everyone can.
@@Valencetheshireman927 i just feel so bad . I know how badly we were treated in our own country . My people starved to death and people in comment section are still defending those acts . Your current generation is not responsible for this but atleast you guys can admit that what your forefathers did was very wrong
@@shubhamgangwar4310 I can admit when what my distant ancestors did was wrong yes but its nowhere near as bad as Indians sometimes claim it was. They say the British and Muslim empires were all evil but then their ethnic empires and colonialisms are all totally justified! The hypocrisy
Majority of Indians won't forget and forgive...
@@annc8829 Limey.
Nah, Brits gave you democracy pr else communism wld have killed 45 millions Indians instead like what the Yankees said.
@@deepone5005 so, a totalitarian British government in India gave democracy to India ? Britain is not a democracy but a monarchy itself. Wtf ?
@@arcane3464 I guess the concept of constitutional monarchy and parliamentary democracy is lost on you. You really are demonstrating the wonderful Indian education system
@@piggysew797 if u can't get away with your own 'constitutional monarchy' then you should not really have a moral right to lecture those who have ' parliamentary democracy' atleast. I m intelligent, u r educated. That's the difference.
"Sun never set on British Empire, because even God couldn't trust the British in dark." -Shashi Tharoor
that's deep
Damn
You could at least give the credits to shashi tharoor since it's his quote
Shashi Tharoor dialog Vipin vnd
@@chiraggowda8419 lol
They looooooooooted the temples and god knows what else.
@Tom Johnson no they came here for their a Annual yoga retreat or spiritual bullshit these white folks come to India for .. such great adventures .. gtfoh 😂😂
Don't forget about the Mughals that took so much more
@@mamtabhandari2696 the Mughal empire was an Indian empire, you absolute numpty. Are you saying that cos they were muslim?
And also all the biggest coloured as well as clear diamonds.
@@911beats You dumb biscuit, it wasn't. What ever could be convwrted was converted into islam and what ever could be looted, was looted and sent to turkey and arab.
READ FFS before blabbering.
My grandmother migrated from Sahiwal (Pakistan) to Delhi (India) in 1947 at the age of 7. Yesterday I showed her a few pictures of her hometown in Pakistan and I almost felt I could see tears in her eyes. She had no clue you could still find pictures of such an old and less known village in Pakistan. She told me she was really happy to see pictures again after so many years. It just made my day ^^ I'm happy I'm able to use the technology in my hands to make her happy! 😊 The stories she's told me made me realize the struggles of the common person during the partition. It was really painful to imagine how she and her family had to leave everything they had and move to a completely new place.
Hey bro could you please call me
I'm doing a documentary about this
@@alex17252 well you're clearly misinformed then :) the only good thing they did was unify us. The killings, famines, racism and looting never did good to the subcontinent .
@@akhildandufilms hi while I wouldn't be comfortable with that I could give you any information you need over here :)
Thank you so much
Now come to the point: What about Kohinoor??
Благодарность Vladimir 🙏
Do you speak English Mr putin
@@jimmykysor5813 well I speak 4 more languages other than russian
@@xrxnpop1222 *YES*
@@xrxnpop1222 What?
When I went for study tour to India, I saw that in many monuments n palaces only two or four precious stones were left on once heavily embellished walls. It was sad how a part of history is missing .
For example - the Taj Mahal 😞
I think you are not indian from your mindset
@@dipeshnegi4282 I'm you fool
@@bkp22 kya
English nahi aati kya?
@@dipeshnegi4282 नहीं भाई अनपढ़ हू
And today, some Brits will say "get out of my country". No, you were in mine for 400 years, so I'll be here for 400 years.
I like how Islam is invading Uk ...karma
@David Charles Francis Topham de Vere Beauclerk Karma is the one to like
True
Lol
@@supersaiyan2648 what you talking about? Too much fox news?
A Netflix series should be made on British rule in India
BBC would claim it a propaganda
But leads need to be generic black strong lesbian women.
Unlike the Germans, the British aren't taught about their "true history", no wonder many think it was not "that bad".
It wasn’t that bad
the British royal are actually German background look it up
@Tom Johnson yep prime example of denial right here. British good , nazi bad.
Tom Johnson The British empire was just as bad as Nazi Germany. Scientific racism (the basis of the Nazi ideology) was born in Britain. Over a course of four centuries the British empire was the key instigator of the systematic annihilation of the indigenous cultures of three entire continents as they colonized their lands. Entire peoples and languages that no longer exist thanks to British colonialism. The British enslaved millions of Africans and purposefully caused mass famines killing millions in places ranging from Ireland to Bengal. The British didn’t solely plunder the Indian subcontinent, but also large swathes of East Asia, the Middle East, Africa and the Americas. As it occupied all of these places, the British empire played on sectarian/ethnic/religious tensions and conflict in the lands of the people they subjugated in order to effectively rule. This is still the basis for major contemporary conflicts all over the Indian subcontinent, the Middle East and Africa.
All of these atrocities are but a few of the crimes committed by the British Empire and can easily compete with those of Nazi Germany. This also applies to many European Empires including the Belgian, French, Spanish and Portuguese Empires. The reason that these empires were not seen to be as bad as Nazi Germany is because they mostly targeted non-whites whom the Europeans considered as barely human and inherently inferior to them. Nazi Germany is solely seen as this paragon of evil (rightly so, but other European empires are just as bad) is because Nazi Germany did to Europeans what European colonialism did to the rest of the planet for centuries.
Tom Johnson Everyone who was occupied by the British Empire: the British Empire was terrible and killed, enslaved and subjugated millions while looting their lands and resources
Proponents of the British Empire: you are still the half-witted subhumans that we colonized a century ago; the British empire developed and contributed a lot to your countries
*Most well dressed thieves ever.*
Haha 😂🤣
Well Watch urself.... Without British n westerners , India could never develop Military power n science and technology "
Even after the end of British empire, u loved to fight in the name of religions n caste n still a country with soo many poverty n corruption
@Sania Sania Lmao it's insane to see people like you
See in your logic , then British n westerners are still looting India n world Lol
A day will come when you will say Microsoft company n Apple company is looting money from India 🤦♂️
Its not looting, it's called establishing multinational company n u should know that all the technology n development in India is all bcz of Western influence
@Sania Sania Lmao wat does it it mean? "Countries upgrade these thing" ??
Watever the fact is East asian n westerners are playing the most vital role in development in science and technology
@Sania Sania Lmao 🤦♂️ First IT technology itself is developed by Englishman n it was keep on development
India is one of the country who adopted IT technology frm westerners..... do u hav sth more to say?
"Greatest thieves of all time"
S they are living in our money
@Matthew Clarke we want to just change your attitude
And also drug dealers
@@lawrenceash307 Then I think India should conquer Britain now. Britain is nothing in front of India now in terms of army. You will be dusted.
@@lawrenceash307 wow, quit being so proud of the damn empire and realize the horrendous effects it has had on the entirety of the sub- continent
I watched this because my sons university in London, England is teaching students about the barbaric ways of the British Empire and how British policies in India resulted in millions of Indian deaths. If the dead were put head to foot they would stretch from Dover in England to the borders of Scotland - 85 times.
That's what you get for being undeveloped and inferior. Had you been pushing the boundaries a defense would of been possible, but your ancestors were subhumans and you live in a world now where everything around you from your capitalism to your house to your internet was invented by a white man.
@Sarthak Rajput But you'll never erase 200 years of subjugation to us whites. As an Indian you'll never live it down, now keep working on that toilet training Bhararyia
@@iwx2672 first go learn some maths..
@@iwx2672 whoa still so evil
@@iwx2672 How uncivilised
Britan be like,"We are gonna build an Empire and india is gonna pay for it"
America is already there. Don't worry too much because it's rich as well.
Divided us Hindu Muslim made us split our country how they're gonna pay for such sin
Spot on
@@meow-gy2lw spot is empty, but you can have everything if you find anything at all.
And they did. Boss move
Even the diamond of the Queen's crown is stolen from Indian temple which they consider their pride
Right
dammmm izzit true...
@@BennieGoh Yeah.....
@@BennieGoh yup
lol kohinoor name is probably persian it belonged to Mughals which was taken by Nader shah
British doesnt tell their barbaric & cruel colonial history to younger generation in school textbooks.
like other country's
@Indian Atheist yh i think India is a peace country i wish your country was the leader of the un
@Indian Atheist no i find India to be chilled out compared to the rest of the world
Winners write history. You don't know what that's like
@Indian Atheist the fact that u feel this way
Isn't it suspicious ? I mean if india did anything bad they wouldn't obviously teach u
Underrated theives of all time, i remember my grandfather telling stores of his father getting beated by british raj sepoys and seizure of his land.
I'd say the US has beaten the UK in being the best thieves.
hahaha
@@MS-ux6ze don't laugh you thief. One day UK will be doomed because of their misdeeds. Karma never spare anyone 👍
@Amelia Jones Atheist myself but it certainly seems like the UK is intent on making itself suffer- and its past, present, and future outlook are inherently warped by the evil legacy of its empire.
As Franz Fanon wrote (I'm very poorly referencing here, mind)- European imperialism created, in effect- the degeneration of both the colonized and the colonizer- in the case of the colonizer (such as Britain) it comes from the racialized, ethnicized, religious notions of supremacy and bigotry- it comes from the development and economic dependence on plunder and dehumanization of the rest of the world- and so on.
You can see it with the UK's slow descent from grace (if it can ever be said to have been in grace- certainly not as empire, not any rightful grace anyways) since the loss of its empire. And even to this day, with the self-destructive nature of British politics (and that of the whole Anglosphere, which I'll count as in part other than the US which is its own thing and nearing its own decline/rot). There's an inherent racism and ethnocentricism in British identity stemming from its history as empire- there's an inherent alienation from much of humanity, or even much of Europe as the "other" in contrast to the Brit- it's a social ill that will likely remain for generations onwards due to the evils of empire.
@@VishvendraSingh-go3zd cope.
Well they made the trains for themselves.
They would have taken the trains with them if they could have.
Haha, exactly!!! The ones left out here are the ones we most definitely know they can't really take it with them, if they can, they would😆
@@kevinsyiem6021 what why can't they take them
Hahah😂😂😂
@@charananekibalijaun8837 They didn't bring it brother...they got it build here....n yeah you are right...m still in the process of learning...long way to go.😊
@@charananekibalijaun8837 N i bet that truth hurt. 😂
They looted our jwell 'Kohinoor' and now proudly exhibits in their queen's head.
@Lawrence Weston
It belongs to the souther temples alauddin khilji looted from temple
@Lawrence Weston muslim ruler looted it from temple and named it kohinoor..and it had no name before it because there were thousands of diamond in india and no diamond had its own name ...
@Lawrence Weston STOP! We have EVERY SINGLE FUCKING right to the diamond. It was stolen from a hindu temple idiot. The Muslim ruler ordered his guards to steal it, and he named it the Kohinoor. IT DID NOT BELONG TO MUSLIM RULERS!!!!! It was found in Andhra Pradesh, SOUTH INDIA, where the majority were HINDUS.
@Lawrence Weston Yes it was named, it was found in the Kollur Mine of Andhra Pradesh. And it was named the Syamantaka by a hindu priest. And I'm a south indian by the way. It was recorded.
@Lawrence Weston When did I say I like all North Indians?! I believe that SOME think that they are better than us and I don't believe that. But no indian prime ministers were born in pakistan?! You realize north india and south india is in the same country, and pakistan is a different country, right? I live in US, and most of my friends are north indians. I don't want to divide our country, I love all indians. Your South Indian "friends", just want to start drama.
2:25 - this woman is not afraid to keep it real!
She is a paid presenter. She is working of a script.
@@binagarten4667 job is different from getting money spreading fake news. If this was fake you could have said, she is doing for money. But this is real and "she doesn't fear" doesn't mean she is being paid. "She doesn't fear" means she doesn't fear the unjustified punishment by UK's govt. or related bodies who will try to supress her, even this video or channel might be in trouble for unraveling the truth. Today's people accept the wrong roots but complain about wrong fruits.
Yeah probably i could see some of those proud 59% Brits here...
@People who Use youtube and I bet you are blind folded Britisher
If you want to read some history from India I can give pdf link also
@People who Use youtube so what are you trying to say?...
@People who Use youtube i think you are not aware of your colonial dark history towards us INDIAN'S , so educate yourself first before commenting and laughing on us , see today's global comparison with India and britain.😏
@People who Use youtube OK then why Britain was silence on these claimed issue regarding torturing and looting over Indians during those days of EIC ????(East India company) , everybody knows around the world what was the true face of colonisation by British😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣 , don't make the whole world laugh by replying these bullshit , meaningless logic ,stop fooling yourself ,just educate yourself by gaining true knowledge regarding Britain's work history towards other Nations , not only with India i mean.
Indian’s kind-heart hospitality welcoming nature destroyed them in past !!
Yeah kimda regret the fact that we were so caught up in our own bullshit that we didnt stop the brits and now we hear het over it .Its the past
Well idk abt u buty grandpa was born then and great unckes died while fighting in a lathi charge
Not entirely. It was extremely easy to invade through modern day Afghanistan as as the Afghans and Persians discovered in the 1740s . Without these invasions the British would never have got a toe hold in the country. However going the other way was extremely difficult as the British discovered to their cost. There is a good reason why Indian rulers did not expand much beyond their boundaries at any rate to the north.
Sadly, it still is.
@@billbogg3857 «easy to invade threw afghanistan» maybe in the past but afghanistan is a death zone today even the soviet union a world super power with the most modern military failed to conquer the mujaheeden in their horses. I dont think india needs to worry about their afghan border at all.
@@truebeliver453 Yes indeed the Moghuls tried it ,the Brits tried it , then the Russians failed and now the Americans are getting out. Maybe the world will realise that no one can control it .
PROUD TO BE INDIAN!!!!!!!
We r developing soon we'll all make india a developed country 🌍😈
🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧😜
Literally one Brit was arguing that it was a suffering on both the sides🤣
@@shlokrathod8077 Yeah keep enjoying on my money son
@@basicnoob3832 I didn't say that there weren't brutal regimes than the British one, just that when an army invades someone, then you know who the persecuted is
@@basicnoob3832 can I tell you about the bengal famine that killed 30 lac people?Can I tell you the inhumane treatment of Slaves?
@@basicnoob3832 The Maratha Empire didn't persecute it's own people, rather we were very lucky to have Maratha Empire,we got saved from the Mughals only due to that empire.
Im happy covid made your scamland suffer
Not to mention they tried to blackmail Captain Jack Sparrow relentlessly
Bastards
India stands with Jack sparrow
India loves Jack Sparrow. He single handedly fought East India company. Absolute badass.
@@kunalshetty7144 Captain Jack Sparrow
@@Himansshh ofc my apologies 😌
India suffered “humiliation” for two centuries under the British colonial rule. Looted $45 trillion and millions of cultural genocide
And millions of people died.
@@gringopapi6985 The British did built up the infrastructure and if it wasn't for them I don't think my himalayan state would have any roads or services and trust me all these are fools who only blame british it's just that blaming islamic empire would be looked down as being Hindu extrimist.
@@gringopapi6985 Devastating famines occurred regularly during British colonial rule. Try reading an actual history book sometime.
yourstory.com/2017/08/british-raj-famines
they staved to death, but tbh at the time britz were invading they was already fighting multiple country's like Pakistan, France and Dutch. UK just took over really and made easy money pfft
I believe all of this is excluded from the history books of Brits.
It's not
I learnt about this pre gcse so everyone learns this
lol they don't even look at what they did in Ireland. Never mind the rest of the world. They think they're the innocent ones.
@ much appreciate your honest reply.
It's not. It's a little less than 4% of the actual story. That's all.
I still can't believe that Churchill is given so much respect even after being aware of his true nature.
And Mahatma Gandhi Was a Racist Who Forced Young Girls to Sleep in Bed with Him. Everyone has a dark-side. Half my population would be dead and i’d be under nazi occupation right now if it weren’t for Churchill. You just gotta be grateful for the good they did but also remember the negatives as well. But if your Indian i don’t expect you to like him.
@Manoj Kumar what? He was a racist ‘and’ forced young girls to sleep with him. You can be both
@@oj3458 Exactly dude I want my Indian Peeps to understand that "one man's enemy might be other man's friend" . Understand the facts,not everything needs an emotional logic.
How da fk respected Churchill cme here in topic
I still can't believe people like you exist
but in reality British empire has helped the the world to reach today's modern world...
All the policies , discoveries , social and political reform were damn great thats how the British ruled the world and rest by other European powers
Just a example of my south asia
south asia was divided in many kindoms before British arrival.. the south asian kingdoms were very "poor comparin to Western power 'at that time" and majority tax revenue was from agriculture
So then many kings there decided to let Westerners "portugees , etc to open the trade and industries in large scale where British empire not only opened the industries but also ruled over subcontinent ( very clever ) and created utilities and employment then economy rises for both Britain and south asian
From the beginning , south asian had been rising voice against British empire for governing the country except British ( as British didn't hav ancestral history) which resulted today's independent countries "india , pakistan, etc
After gaining independence, we can clearly see the downfall in economy where the new countries again fought in the name of land and government was higly corrupted ( i'm talkin abt after the independence but today is different )
All the colonized counties had gained many utilities and great social and political reform bcz of British empire yah but no one appreciate " cuz there's a word which is pretty well known ie. LOOT
Which is baseless cuz All those colonized countries were part of British empire so the wealth is also part of it where british took many ancient stuffs in their mainland Britain ( central government) now some countries want to claim and want britain to put them back where they actually belong
I guess its their "colonized countries" own fault that they wanted full independence which make them new independent countries so baseless to claim those stuffs as We human also belong to "one" civilisation so then why dont we all live together ?? It was better to be part of Britian where the ancient history could be shared as one country Or Gaining independence and do some development and learning the history instead of scratchin history
....
ruclips.net/video/mEX13GrLwqg/видео.html
Queen called india “Jewel in crown”. While whole crown is loot.
.. including the word 'loot'
@Jason Tempel they haven't even apologize for what they have done
Geo MS I feel that
@Truth Teller There's a reason why the company was named East 'India' Company in 1600. You illiterate Goon.
Danny Jackson what about wales and Northern Ireland?
Nothing but bs propaganda
What knowledge do you have sir 😂😂😂😂😂
@@Thebeastclub01 the 45 trillion claim is utter nonsense made up by a marxist that has been debunked by real economists, their's and Britain's many times. It's a political truncheon to get the nationalist further and racism going. A figure so absurd I'm amazed even the most gullible believe it.
@@UTSarethya ur right it's was maybe more then 43trillion.
@@bipinbisht7827 ah the gullible racists are here
Indeed brits r brainswashed thru propaganda about colonialism
After reading so many comments, I can still see arrogance in British people forget about acknowledging mistakes, as mentioned in the video; they are still proud of it.
being prideful for the good isnt the same as being prideful about the ton of good they did
@hydra the British empire didn't do any good anywhere they went
Yes they feel very proud of their empire and want to resurrect it
ruclips.net/video/p4u7Yv25l58/видео.html
Yet 5 million Indian's voluntered to fight for the British Empire in WW2, GO FIGURE.
Really? All I see is xenophobic Indians slagging off Brits and demanding a fantastical $45 trillion reparations. Most Brits don't even think about the empire, since they had nothing to do with it and they have their own lives to be living, while you sit at your keyboard and stew in your bitterness.
The stuff Britain has done to India is so undermentioned in history
Ohh is it
@FBI nah I didn't learn crap about it
@FBI no I never hear of it I only hear of the Irish killings
FBI it’s mentioned, but it’s glorified, and none of its atrocities are mentioned in public teaching
How about Britain 🇬🇧 and America 🇺🇸. Pay 💰 back what they stole and owe. Then we can get passed the bull. What does the world court do???
Let's talk about Sri Lanka next, I still wonder how many gems snatched from the Island! it's better the world gets to know these things!
Maybe they could go on both sides? Look at the positives?
@M it's not a video game you can't literally get over the thousands of things they've looted and killed millions of people who were innocent.
@@studygram_ Modern India without British rule
If British had not conquered vast territories within India and brought it under a single rule:
There would be no unified India. Instead there would have been multiple principalities which would have undergone different political, social and cultural histories to become different countries.
Without unification, social reforms would have been hard to come by and the country or the principalities would have been socially regressive.
Strong rulers would have turned the fortune of a few principalities and made it richer, however the rest of the country would have been much poorer than what they are today. Condition of states with fewer resources would have been much worse.
With access to education restricted to an elite few, large portions of the country would still have been illiterate.
Illiteracy would have led to slow industrialization and advancement in science and technology.
Caste would have played a much more significant role in day to day life (than it does today) and would have hampered growth.
There is a good chance China would have annexed a few statelets with its territory.
There would be no unified religion called hinduism. Instead the various sects of modern day hinduism would have become independent religions. Hindi would have met the same fate.
Masses who fell to famines would have still fallen to various wars waged by native warlords.
This aged well
More of this in our education and media, please. Every historical crimes should be recorded and taught to each generations.
45 trillion is a lie.
They perfected the tactics they used in India in Ireland
Ireland still colony....
and scotland
Thanks
Truth same can be said for Scotland still occupied to this day and has nuclear weapons based here that we do not want
A little known fact is that the British Empire also stripped the assets and natural resources from across the north of England. The countryside is literally littered with old coal and lead mines and canals and railways where they transported away the natural resources worth trillions to make themselves wealthy. It makes me so sad to think about this.
To all those who from any parts of the world
Beware of the Brits who are trying their
Best to justify the fact that colonialism of India was good.
Uh huh
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Well, it's *Lakshman Seth* and other merchants who invested in EIC which then recruited Indian people into its army and overthrew the sultanate of Bengal. Lakshman Seth did this to get control of the business. It was just like conflicts between Chinese merchants and emperors. So, it's the Indian Hindu kings and merchants who actually helped the British to take on Mughal emperors. Because under mughal rule, India was rich and so-called lower catse Indians started working in textile mills and they converted to Islam leaving Hindu caste system which is dominated by upper caste who were kings, merchants, priests. So, they helped British to destroy the handlooms and overthrow the Mughals so that majority of Indians, who are so-called lower caste, cant prosper and overpower the status quo of upper caste kings, merchants, priests.
Sadly, no one talks about these facts.
@@rajadhirajmaharaj based on the ones deeds you can not justify......your point...matter is what they did as a whole
@@rajadhirajmaharaj abe copy paste karke phirse bak raha hai. Mera pichla comment padh.
“The more you take, the less you have”
-Master Oogway
Our research finds that Britain’s exploitative policies were associated with approximately 100 million excess deaths during the 1881-1920 period, write Sullivan and Hickel[British Raj(1904-1906)/Wikimedia
Experts agree that the period from 1880 to 1920 - the height of Britain’s imperial power - was particularly devastating for India. Comprehensive population censuses carried out by the colonial regime beginning in the 1880s reveal that the death rate increased considerably during this period, from 37.2 deaths per 1,000 people in the 1880s to 44.2 in the 1910s. Life expectancy declined from 26.7 years to 21.9 years
Good thing they couldn't carry the palaces and forts.
@chantu mantu Literally everything inside British museum
They carried everything inside the forts and palaces. Didn't even leave behind the gods and goddesses statues
Indias "atithi devo bhav" Destroyed them self
*Karma*
You are right definitely we are not unite in past and present time . That's dark truth and we accept it
@@techtronics6121 India was the richest country also known as the golden bird. We didn't want the technology even the trains and bridges were meant for the company's own benefit. We could have got it in future when world started to become modern. We also gave our vocabulary, technology, methods and items to Britain. We could have even had our own industrial revolution if Britain left us forsaken
@@techtronics6121 I was referring to the part when you called my country economically and technologically weak when British entered India , which is false. You should have used the word 'left' rather than 'entered'.
@@techtronics6121 get ur facts right India was technologically and economically weak after they left..do u think Columbus was a retard to set out to find India at all cost soo much tht they even named the native Americans, RED INDIANS
Initially i thought it was $45M.
Holy smokes. $45T ?!!!
This is with adjusted inflation though.
Somehow I can see where Shashi tharoors ask or repetitions comes from... I means in terms of actuals
And still the damage of lives and property isn't considered. India was producing 24% of the whole world mfg goods at that time.
@gdpm the industrial revolution in Britain was mostly funded from their plunder of bengal
@@missaleromanum5614 Numbers are not the point.
The point is the westerners screwed our forefathers.
And even if the westerners gave us their daughters for marriage as compensation, it still wouldn't be enough for the damage and years of exploitation that they have done.
Every indian need to see this 🇮🇳🇮🇳
We’re rich cuz if u 😬
Specially those liberals
Worst of all British passed on the idea of “Divide and Rule” to the future Politicians of India which was and still is used to rule.
The divide and rule which you credit to the British was an Indian idea, the caste system predates the British rule.
@@TheFiretonic divide and rule was a policy used by British to create divide between Hindu - Muslim after the 1857 war of independence which led to the collapse of the east India company. Just trying to educate you.
@@TheFiretonic Moron. The caste system was introduced by the British. India had varna system which was by profession not by birth
Hmm, ironic that person with roots from CHIINA right now is so obviously trying to divide INDIA and BRITAIN with a view to rule from CHINA. Seondly it was the aristocracy in BRITAIN that stole hugely from their own working people within BRITAIN too. It is those working people who survive today despite the dark satanic mills and mines and trenches. We everyday people are always stronger UNITED against the 1% with all the money and power. Don't fall for the divide and rule VICTIM mentality suggested and funded by those who want to rule you today. INDIA and its people are great and smarter than that and don't need to lower themeselves to VICTIMS while CHINA PRC watches on and laughs.
@@Nimmie111 But when you're born into your job your born into a caste
this video should be shown in schools during H I S T O R Y lessons.
45 Trillion is UTTER FANTASY ........ would lucky to be Ten Billion at the very best .....BTW the RAJ finished 73 years ago ....SAVVY????
@@296Echo still didn't give our money back
@@divineflu34567 ZZZZZZZZZZ 45 Trillion reasons you shoyld go back to sleep
Alternative history lessons for low iq students
@@divineflu34567 your never getting it back >:)
my grandmother's family migrated to Lahore from Dehradun in 1947 losing her father and 5 year old brother in the process 🇵🇰
I’m sad to hear that, I’m from Pakistan also 🇵🇰
Sad to hear, from india 🇮🇳
Dehradun is very beautiful city...I live there sometime
@@vaibhavkaushik5998 Her family lived on Rajpor road. My grandma studied in St. Joseph's Acadmy till grade 6. We still have her exam marksheets from 1941.
@@wkeklaalal1577 rajpur road 😭😳 quite nice area
Hmmmmm, many white supremacist in the comments.
I don't get it why the dislikes?
These are facts.
LMAO maybe if you read tharoor the politician with no degree in anything but political science.
@ Lol, So you think that British were forgiving and colonized nation out of their Goodness and Kindness.
Research a Lil about Bengal famines and Churchill's fat hands all over the man made massacre
@@haronmenezes4562 bengal famine was all on the Japanese taking your food and killing your people after mass invading. my granddad died in India helping you fight the Japanese off and giving you impedance after. be grateful or right now Indian would be greater Japan and you would either be a slave or more realistically dead.
@Steffen Bodar why thou
@Steffen Bodar No. Pakistanis & Indians were ONE before British India. Pakistan’s blood boils too.
British used "Divide and rule" to break good friendships & started wars.
So never accuse anyone blindly.
This is coming from a person who is from India.
They should do a show like this on America and France’s dealing.
Shhh, we supposed to keep that secret.
What wait? I've never heard about this before.. please explain am interested to know
See how that works? The above poster denied us talking about the US and French imperialism. We so good, we are, we so good.
Shivu anir
What? I just think it would be a good idea for people to learn about the things their countries did. I’m American and I think to many Americans aren’t aware of what America did on places like Hawaii, Central America. I also think the fact that France forced Haiti to pay reparations to slave owners until the 1940’s for their freedom is something people should know.
Just because you learn news facts it doesn’t take away from others. Suffering isn’t a contest
@@msoda8516 Don't forget Vietnam
Stole 45 trillion dollars, divided the country in three parts. Create the still on going conflicts between India and Pakistan. Sab mil k zor se bolo from both India and Pakistan, British KMKB 🤣😂.
British KMKB
PAKISTAN KMKB
@@manojsati5775 British KMKB Sati Manoj KMKB 😂😂
@@aeymed bro you're Pakistani
@@kunalsinghdedha76 yes brother.
British Ka mkb😂😂
As a British. I too fucking hate the empire, not our country.
India was richest country and contributed 25% of World GDP before British arrived... at that time most India was ruled by Marathas. Brits defeated Rajpoots, Sikhs, homs, Nizam , Bengal and Marathas and French at last. There was no Hindu Muslims division before british. They created it inside India for there own benefits and l00ted nation and divided it later which still is bruise on Indian nation.
Hell, even the word "loot" itself was taken from hindus
"There was no Hindu Muslims division before british." hahahaha are you serious? You mean apart from all the wars and killing they did for centuries before the British arrived. Learn some history. Muslims haven't ever lived peacefully with anyone and never will. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muslim_conquests_in_the_Indian_subcontinent#:~:text=Muslim%20conquests%20in%20the%20Indian%20subcontinent%20mainly%20took%20place%20from,kingdoms%20in%20the%208th%20century.
@@AnyoneCanSee yes there was division but not specifically as such. Like who would have imagined separate nation on basis of religion or look at pics of Sindhi Hindus and muslms . you can't find any difference. Both look same.
@@AnyoneCanSee during the Islamic Golden age there were a few caliphate's that we're very inclusive and didn't make islam mandatory, not making any comments on India but your brash generalization just discredits anything else you say, especially when it's patently false. conquering has been a part of humanity since the dawn of civilization, chill with the ignorant moral relativism.
@@loopydoopi The East India Company was founded by John Watts and George White, two English merchants from the 17th century. Take your antisemitism elsewhere.
Their queen even has our kohinoor diamond in her crown how shame less they can be.
Bro like you i also thought that it was stolen but its not it was gifted by our indian king maharaja ranjith singh to the queen!! Ab gift diya hai toh wapis kaise denge vo
@@rushikeshbagade4839 it's a lie Britain is saying it was gifted, in reality it was not
@@sidnapses1444 actually our supreme court has also said that it was gifted a case was also filed to bring it back but it was gifted you can researvh about it in books or net
rishikesh bagade dont let things like “FACTS” and “TRUTH” get in the way of some good propaganda meant to incite anger and hate.
I wonder which country would benefit from India abandoning its allies...
We have treated India so badly. I’m disgusted.
Of course they don't teach this in school. Would like to see a video Britain's demise on Africa
They also don't teach about the Soviet Union in British schools. We get taught a lot of unnecessary things in history and miss out most of the important bits.
It's hard to learn from history if they don't teach us the most important lessons like this.
@@samhardingham5591 there's a reason for it. If you get too smart you'll question authority. I don't think they taught history in my school
@@brotherskutnu8585 I know the french were very late to get rid of most of that but what are they still doing to exploit their former colonies?
@@samhardingham5591 When it comes to the English education system, schools/colleges decide which parts of history get taught. For example, the college that I go to does Communist Russia 1917-53 and the British Empire 1858-1968 whilst others may do for example about life in Britain and tsarist russia as the main exam content. Same with GCSEs
actually in english gcse we learn about animal farm wich is all about the balshavik revolution
Still many of our Indians think that they'd be great if they were ruled by the British. But they all forgot the fact that how these Britishers were mercilessly killed our people, made the vicious partition which yet to be cured, enjoyed ceremonies while our people starved to death, created artificial damages in the north-east and other parts of the country during the WW2. Like these the list will go further. They did few good reforms with everlasting scars in India. Therefore if any Indian wish to praise the British then know the real history and their true colours before doing that.
@@alex17252 Your comment sounds gibberish. Most of the contemporary issues in the world are happening all due to the seeds that were sown by the greedy British and other European countries. Literally looted, murdered and did endless crimes against humanity. Yet British people study and some think that their crown rule had enlightened its colonies. Like the same some outdated people say something like your claim however I've never heard about that. The Europe's wrong history and perception about other countries have been unraveled by the real historians these days. The world is awaken now and the West is not powerful anymore. So stop kidding!!!
Imagine that 45 trillion can make india another great country if it true.
They can easily develope the whole world!
idiot. 45 trillion is calulated by todays standards with exponential interest. the gross national domestic output per years of the richest nations on the time were upto one million dollars in the 19th century. The maharajas possibly could generate a few hundred thousand dollars per year GDP.
@@charananekibalijaun8837 yea.. actually vice should have detailed reasonings for mentioning that figure .. that is A LOTTTT... a billion dollars is a lot .. 45 trillion is like 45000 billion .. not justifying how they came up with that figure can be slandering to the brits and spreading hate.. irresponsible journalism.
Unless the gov used for themselves instead of peoples
@@charananekibalijaun8837 I'll complete what it means for UK and India:- for india it means another way of being looted and for the " Great" Britain it's another means for milking their cash cow.
britin say india is poor huh,they are having our 45T$ in their pockets and laughing at us
have SHAME
Lmao we dont use dollars you hyporcrite you scam for a living
Not all of that 45 trillion was sent to Britain , mutch of it was into the empire and quite a lot was actually Red invested into India
Note: they spent 30% of the money on their empire, from this 8% went to india, and the other money was used in cold war.
But you Mordern day india is a little cowrdly.
France and the holy roman empire made crusader armies to defend europe from muslims, india was not able to do that. And Even though britain was poorer than india after independence they still joined the cold war, something which india did not join. Forget UK! Even pakistan joined the cold war. and that is the main reason USA wanted to support pakistan in 1971 war. Forget that, India is literally called "Socialist, democratic secular federation of india" It literally has communist ideologies within it. It is the politicians who made the country poor not the people. and btw you guys think europe was never invaded. Watch history of europe by polandball 19, You will understand the number of times india was invaded was nothing compared to eastern europe
So, by your definition, it is only the British who have ever invaded to steal and conquer. In your words (and I paraphrase), ‘we travelled to learn’. Didn’t the Maratha Empire persecute their own people? They launched six invasions of Bengal and invade Afghanistan.
How about the Mughal Empire who sustained their empire by military conquest. Didn’t they also trade heavily with Europeans thus making their Empire larger and richer. Before them, didn’t the Delhi Sultanate persecute and murder across their Empire.
And if we move away from the Indian sub-continent, how about all the various Chinese dynasties, the Mongol empire which stretched from Central Europe, across the Indian sub-continent and East to Japan. The Japanese invasions of China and Korea. The Ancient Egyptian Empire, the Byzantine Empire, the Spanish in South and Central America, the French in Vietnam, the Germans and the Belgium’s in parts of Africa, the Dutch in Indonesia, the Romans, the Saxons and the Vikings invasions of Britain and many other places. The Moors invasions of Southern Europe, the tribal wars across Western Africa, which supplied most of the salves for the transatlantic slavery trade, the Russian empire etc etc etc. There has been hundreds of Empires across the globe. All did terrible things to gain control and maintain power. Many also did great things as well. Don’t try and paint the British as the only race to have persecuted others. As for slavery, it has existed since the beginning of civilization. Instead of spouting your ignorant nonsense and threats, why don’t you concentrate on improving modern India. How about tackling the rape epidemic sweeping the nation, or the Caste systems that protects the rapists. Just for starters. Or maybe recognize the British for some of the good they have done. For example the 20%+ of the world’s inventions and discoveries that the British are responsible for. The millions of lives saved by the discovery of penicillin by a Scottish scientist for example?
@Crinkly Dwarf yes i believe that india lost but not because your soldiers was powerfull more trained but because of lack of unity , because of several betrayals and even your small soldiers was not strong enough to face indian kings . And you win the world war just beacuse of indian soldiers . even your general said that indians soldiers are the bravest of the brave. before colonising india your country was the poorest of the poor and after colonising the golden bird(india) you people was like (WE ARE ELON MUSK , WE ARE BILL GATES, WE ARE JEFF BEJOS, WE ARE MARK ZUCKERBURK).
It is not the fault of British people that they feel proud of the empire. Their school history books have conveniently erased the horrors of the colonial rule...
@A H lol...we do admit it. plenty of British people want to give, for example, the contents of the British Museum back. ruclips.net/video/x73PkUvArJY/видео.html
@A H your taking about rich elites. Your everyday working class person had no say or no influence in any of this. Yet you want to blame them as they are "British " from many generations ago..move on
We are busy educating our children about the rest of the world because you know, we've been everywhere.
@A H Acutally exaclibur is right, in the UK we're often taught about the numerous victories and role the Empire played in WW2 or the Napoleonic Wars but little to nothing about the numerous famines or massacres. It's like we're taught to appreciate the scale of the achievement the Empire represented, but fail to question or even contemplate the morality of our ancestors actions.
@@olyjfitness this is what fucks me off about some of these comments, working class people weren't the ones benefiting from any of these stolen riches from British colonies. Wholesale judgement of British citizens based on the unscrupulous ethics of rich folk from another era, it's idiotic.
And the thing is, if the British hadn't done it, the Dutch or Portuguese would have done exactly the same.
Every action has an equal and opposite reaction.
This rule applies everywhere
No body wields the power forever, when the wheel turns everything will be paid in the same way
I hope i can see that with my eyes
Many countries have build railways without having to have been colonized - Shashi tharoor
Yes, Japan is an example
@@sandeeppreagle777 Japan is a colonizing manic and just as worst as Germany. Bad example.
@@sandeeppreagle777 actually Japan did go through a rapid phase of westernization.
@Tommy Vercetti yup and that's why I hate Japanese military and the god dam government
4
N
Meanwhile Some arrogant British Nationalist: "Sorry , I can't hear it oh wait I can't even see it"
True
I dont get it
Just like in Japan denying the atrocities
I am deef we are god but we are deef
@@xrxnpop1222 oh so you are God you can't say that mad guy
Brits even stole gems from Taj Mahal's walls. No one can stoop as low as them lol
@@capturedflame They are Birtish descendants afterall.
And India wouldn't have done the same if it was the dominant country, in the old times land switched hands all the time
Metal Gorilla78 no they wouldn't have, the GDP was 25% of the world, yet they never invaded other countries, enslaved cultures. They didn't even have a Navy.
@@metalgorilla7865 But it wasn't and the truth is all of the jewels and artifacts are stolen by the East India Company band of thugs.
@bye girl The Royal jewel collection is well catalogued, the history of where they were looted from are all documented.
Will you also make a video about the disgusting things ghandi did or does that go against your anti-britain campaign? Like how he would force young girls to sleep in his bed naked to “test” himself
anti - -British its the truth
also there is no proof of it and it was whores not girls
@@iam7389 there is no proof of the 45 trillion, there’s a lot more proof about what kind ghandi did ruclips.net/video/fTxNSU2k6l4/видео.html
@James Matthews and your population is known for creeping into womens and girls dm’s
This video is entirely a copy of Shashi Tharoor’s Oxford speech, only much less enthusiastic.
Well noted!
Video is copied but the history is 100% right
History remains the same shashi doesn't own a copyright to the history.
Those who haven't watched Shashi Tharoor's speech can watch it here. ruclips.net/video/f7CW7S0zxv4/видео.html
Flamin Mongrel thanks for enlightening me I didn’t know. Thankyou so much Bro. You so Intelligent bruh😊😊😊
I feel whole info in the video was taken from Shashi Tharoor's literature who published several books on the British Empire in India. The video should have mentioned the sources.
Comment needs to be upvoted more!
Thats all you walk away from this with?
No , in terms of the railways it was more detailed .
Dude ur idiot. Shashi just reproduced others stuff without any original research. Read dr swamy's reset for entire expalanation of economics of it.
@@JS-fp2rbwhat citations . Go read his book theres entire expalanation from start till now.
Looting resources and money is one thing but they're responsible for around or above 100 million indian people deaths. They plundered our economy, let our people starve to death💔
some rich individuals got richer not the country or people, remember the british working class were and are slaves too and have been killed more by the british empire
the average brit in those days was a slave worker a servant a miner for these rich too then sent to their deaths in wars to protect their slavemasters wealth
they even stole the finest diamond engraved from one of India's historical sites only to be on Britain's queen's crown. Nothing is surprising about stealing and looting of British in that era.
Pakistan also claim it ironically. I say let those two sort out which one wants it first before we give anything back.
@@alexpalmer4825 It needs to go to the mother first, i.e India.
@@alexpalmer4825 there was no pakistan when it was looted. They took it from India
Well if Mughal empire won the war, I’m pretty sure they would do the same to British treasures. Not my fault we won
@@alexpalmer4825 Ok, first get your queen agree to return it. We will sort it out between ourselves.
5 minutes to show what England truly is... humanity's curse.
Well, that is 𝘚𝘢𝘷𝘢𝘨𝘦.
Nope without it modern technology and democracy would be almost non-existent.
@@cosmicwitness3390 Greece would like to have a word.
@@cosmicwitness3390 you are so ignorant is not even funny
@@spooked2104 Basically if it wasn't even for the British India would not even be India. It would just be a bunch of small different countries.
Acknowledgement is enough we don't want revenge
True bro. At least that and perhaps the Kohinoor too
@@muneermammikutty3245 they're actually willing to give the Kohinoor back, the problem is Pakistan and Afghanistan are also claiming it, so England is waiting for the 3 countries to come on an agreement on to whom the diamond should go. Considering that India and Pakistan won't agree on anything, we wont be getting it anytime soon
You couldn’t take revenge even if you wanted to 😂
@@EM-xg2ib Why would they ? Times have changed. But India can take down the Island in few days if it wants to, 20 warheads are enough to submerge the island, our missile range is upto Atlantic ocean though. Uk stands nowhere without NATO.
@@EM-xg2ib Well don't forget we are home to some of the bravest people on Earth Gurkhas, Sikhs, Rajputs, Marathas and when you came here disguised as traders we weren't together, now we are your puny island has accumulated lot of bad karma which will be payed accordingly in due time
What about french ,spanish empiress all those europeans empires rulec the world!!!!!!
They're all different branches of the same tree bro
Well it's good that atleast there are some british people who look at their empire and the atrocities they committed with shame rather than pride
I think it’s a mixed bag. I’m from merseyside. No one ever looks at how Liverpool had a lower life expectancy than the likes of India. My English ancestors have never left this country. Born into poverty worked until a death in their 20s. But acknowledging the good the empire did is a completely different thing. The empire was a short term evil but probably a long term legend. People who celebrate the empire are pathetic but there’s a stark contrast between those to celebrate and those that admire.
@M I wouldn't have hatred if Brits living today weren't such jerks to others. I know British people today are not responsible for what happened in past, but still majority Brits mock others and says colonialism was good and should be brought back. They still mock African countries and former colonies and call them slaves and are Racist af
@@rhythmkhandelwal2940 without Britain the world still sits in a dark age of disease and squalor. You can’t refute the things they say regardless of how annoying they are. Unfortunately for the rest of the world British exceptionalism is somehow very real, the people that brag about it couldn’t be less representative of it if they tried though. Most Nobel prizes per capita, over 55% of significant invention still comes from Brits and if your legal system functions it’s probably British. A 6 toothed dole scrounger from Scunthorpe shouldn’t be able to claim the title but unfortunately they can and will because it’s the only good title they can ever hold
Lmao Its hilarious how an average Indian talk sht about British empire without having any knowledge
@@nanilama7016 well by your comment it seems that you must have also seen the above video.If not please do watch it and get the gist of it before saying "average Indian" without "any knowledge" of the British Empire, of which I believe you must have done a Ph.D. on by your comment.
Colonial history taught in Britain: PG-13
Colonial history taught in India: R-rated
Colonial history taught at the Cellular Jail light and sound show: NC-17
Colonial history taught in India is safely sanitised.
@@TheGuruNetOn That's not "Sanitized" according to brits, too much listing of british crimes for their taste XD
@@rohithm3508
*"There would be no India"*
What makes you think i have a problem with that?
*"Without Unification social reforms would be hard"*
That is assuming all of India follows the same culture, which it doesn't. Some cultures of India are more progressive than others.
*"Conditions of the states with few resources would've been worse"*
So what? Why should i care? My state is not a landlocked desert, it would've been fine.
*"Large portion of the country would still be illiterate"*
When you Brits left India, it had a 10% literacy rate. Brits KEPT India illiterate.
Brits destroyed India's native industries so that Indians would be dependent on overpriced imports from UK. Brits shot down ships of Indian merchants out of Jealousy, Brits made India's Economy poorer than it was under Mughals, India had a GDP growth rate of 0.55% under British rule, whereas Brits enjoyed the fruits of Industrial Revolution by exploiting India's resource!! No, British Rule was a cancer on India, even when Brits left India, they created a Civil War.
*"China would've annexed a few territories"*
Why do you think you Brits were better than the imperial Chinese!? You destroyed our economy&native industries and kept us illiterate. And you still have precious artefacts stolen from India in your British Theif Museum.
*"independent sects would have become different religions"*
And WHY do you think i have a problem with that? I don't care about Hinduism outside of my Ethnicity, i don't care about hindi either.
*"Masses that fell to famines would've fallen to Wars"*
Great way to rationalize British Invented famines, except you're ignoring all wars British fought on Indian soil that killed countless Indians. You're a delusional Historical Revisionist! The Imperial British were a PARASITE, FULL STOP
@@alex17252
*There would not have been an India
*
Did you not read my old Reply? I repeat, WHAT MAKES YOU THINK I HAVE A PROBLEM WITH THAT?
*"Many social reformers in India supported British rule"*
They can go to Hell. Mughal Empire was producing about 25% of the world's industrial output up until the 18th century, Brits DESTROYED India's native industries and brought it down to *2%.*
*"it rose to 18 percentage at 1947"*
According to Govt's Census Data, literacy rate of India in 1947 was *12%* where did the extra *6%* come from? British kept the overwhelming majority of Indians illiterate and educated a few just to efficiently administer India.
*"For further information watch Oxford speech.
"*
I don't want to listen to India's Colonizers justifying their imperial Conquest of India. It is up to India to decide whether British rule was legitimate or not and majority of Indians believe it wasn't, that's the final word.
Thanks Zing Tsjeng for all the efforts in keeping us aware of the past history. We were not taught this in school. All Indians should watched this.
Are you historian is you are not better don't tell me about it because Chinese gunpowder which discover in China in Chinese tang dynasty and some European say them discover it even lie or spam in RUclips and it you is not historian better don't tell me because world is big many history to learn some are hidden and lie.
@@alex17252 in that case go correct her, if what u r saying is TRUE then she might face consequences..,n if you are saying all this stuff here in this comment section where most people won't even understand what u r saying, then just f off, so basically I wouldn't believe it until u actually go n get 'Your Research' published...
So much colonial angst towards the rise of non white countries and so much amnesia about the unspeakable colonial history of the West. Then after WW2 these people labeled themselves as the freedom loving, non racists of the world. And it worked. It's unraveling bit by bit now, but it's been largely successful with such domination on soft power and public opinion.
Amazon- I am the richest
Tesla- Oh! Come on!!
British East India company- You guys are cute...
An Era Of Darkness by Sashi Tharoor, has encapsulated each and every aspect of the video, only in detail. Read An Era of Darkness for more insight on colonialism.
When i was a kid, i looked up to these countries and wish my country was like them. i was in for big surprise lol.
@Tom Johnson philippines =/
@Tom Johnson oh for sure, this video has inaccuracies no doubt. My comment is not just about this video but i understand what you mean.
wasn't your country colonized by japan
@@basicnoob3832 during WW2, yes.
Thank you recognising the BENGALI GENOCIDE by BRITISH
Thank you. Someone mentions.
India doesn't need the world to cry on what Britain did to her, we want people to be aware. Just that. :)
yeah we don't want anything except return our cultural items from the British museum and remember the crimes the British empire did to india (and other nations too). It's a lesson.
Exactly what you said, mate. Hi from Sydney Australia 😎
• •••• come get them then if india is that arsed about it
@@ryanhall478 are you a spokesperson of the museum? cos they've already refused on grounds of "preserving cultural items" which aren't even there.
• •••• I’m not no, what has that got to do with anything? It’s don’t know much about the whole situation but did India actually try instead of making a phone call and asking for them back?
Honestly it's not that Britain committed so many atrocities around the world that angers me that much. It's more of the fact that they still have the audacity to lecture on human rights after all the damage they've done.
The world has changed - not the same it was in the 19th Century. Indians were exploited by other Indians - still do over seven decades after independence.
They also never admit anything and keeps denying them
They haven't included anything on this in their curriculum and history lessons.
You’re wrong, Britain is completely different to what it was in the days gone by, just like many countries and cultures. Britain is the multicultural hub of the world and has endeavoured to right it’s wrongs, to blame the actions of its past on its current inhabitants is also wrong.
So many attrocities ???? You make them sound like moslems..
Don't cry for us, we don't want that, we know our problems and we're dealing with it slowly. All we want is just learn the history and then laugh on our post colonial democratic non invasive efforts to deal with poverty and slums.🙃
Are You still having a Post Colonial Hangover. ! !
Coz By watching only Slums of India (makes 2%) of Entire Population of 1.35 billion Meanwhile, 54% are Middle Class. 30%middle , Stop Watching Only One sided video just like your History Book.
@@sasmalprasanjit2764 I live in slum and live isn't as worse as they show in movies. It's hard but not that. And yea we have huge ammount as middle class family. So, it might help us to grow too.
@@sasmalprasanjit2764 funny how the streets all look like slums though ....
Need w doctor
No one cries for you