The DeWalt mid torque is perfect for tire rotations the smart wrench setting seems purpose built for breaking and setting lugs I love that I can fasten the lugs and it will hammer them once to set the rim then stop automatically. Vice versa when breaking loose the automatic lowering in rpm is perfect! I always grab my mid torque over the 899 for working with lugs! The only downfall is that their is only one speed while in reverse versus the high torque and even 12v that have variable speed for both directions. Edit: finished watching I can't believe the DeWalt didn't break that lug that is crazy it must be pretty damn tight I've maxed my 250 ftlb torque wrench and the mid breaks it like nothing.
I have that same older model 200 ft/lb ryobi impact wrench. I have only used it a few times, now it just overheat after taking off a couple 80 ft/lb lug nuts...kinda disappointed, but moved on to milwaukee, pretty good so far...and, nice comparison vid.
Those particular Ford lugnuts can be very hard to remove, especially if they haven't been off in a while. Even a good air impact will struggle. I've had to stand on a 2ft breaker bar sometimes to break them loose.
@Guitargreat I have the original 2002 blue 18v nicad ryobi tool kit and they all still work. I am not gentle with them either. I was able to adapt to the lithium without replacing my entire collection. I'm certain Dewalt is no different then Ryobi when it comes to longevity. Dewalt is not a Pro tool anymore. It's now a brand name company.
a friend gave me the Ryoby. it had been used and abused on a job site for several months. put it this way N distinguishable marking were left on the tool. so i didn't even know what model it is. until l you video. This Thing Is A Beast!! it has broken lug nuts loos that i said No Freekin Way!! its bad ass!! hope the new ones have the same balls.. Johnny Chain
Hey It has supprised me severl times with how power full it is, I feel like Ryobi under rates this tool. It has way more torque then 200 foot lbs that the web sit states. Thanks for watching.
Ryobi has been doing good the number one reason why I choose them for my 2019 tools is because the haven't changed their batteries plug. My old tools I had where craftsman professional 20v series and I cant find a battery anywhere I can even find a charger for them I've checked on Ebay and a charger cost $70 and I can only find cheap generic batteries and they still cost $68 each
EPIC! I have a set of 7 Ryobi tools that ive had for about 10 years and they all still work perfectly. There is a special deal at the orange home store (online only ) that ships free to store for $99 with the improved version rated @ 300 ftlb, battery and charger. Im buying it right now!
Wow, I'm surprised by that Ryobi. I figured that newer Dewalt would eat its lunch... I have the newer Ryobi P261. Its rated at 300 lbs. torque, but it still isnt brushless. Would be interesting to see how it compares. You brought up an interesting point about battery size and how it affects tool performance. It would be interesting to see a comparison of how different battery sizes affect the power output of a tool such as an impact wrench. I know the bigger batteries have a very noticeable effect on my Ryobi jetfan leaf blower. Definitely has more power right off the bat with the larger batteries. There's just less voltage drop with the larger batteries... Another great comparison, as usual... Thanks!
Good vid, any reason why you chose the DeWalt Mid Torque over the more powerful Milwaukee Mid Torque? I know Milwaukee seems to get a ton of praise for their warranty, that's what the pros use... I have had some issues with some of their tools a Mid-Torque that made a burning smell when new and a defective 5Ah battery right out of a new kit so I am not so convinced how great they are.
I just want with the mid torque because he was more comparable to the rail be both of them are between 200 and 400 foot pounds of torque, the high torque one is around a thousand for the DeWalt which is way higher than the Ryobi that's the only reason, yeah I wasn't impressed with it I feel like it's overrated for power I don't believe it has 400 foot pounds of torque at all where the real B says it has 200 but I feel like it's more around 3 to 350. Thanks for watching
The Ryobi is rated at 300 ft lbs. All my tools are Dewalt, so I'd pay the $40 extra to keep the battery interchangeability. Ryobi is looking good tho. 👍👍
Same here but ryobi has been impressing me lately. I'm considering getting my mother a ryobi kit for her birthday a year ago I would have never considered it.
Home Depot and Lowes have the DCF889M1 high torque impact on sale for $200 includes 4ah battery and charger!!! Probably don’t need anything that big but at that price why the hell not 🤷🏻♂️
Nice video Al, although I’m willing to wager that your 250 foot pounds of torque you were trying to put on that nut didn’t all make it into the threads of that bolt considering a good portion of it was lost by lifting up your work bench instead. That is why it was so easy for the Ryobi to break loose.
Charlie Ott While I agree about not necessarily getting full torque due to the table lifting while using the torque wrench, the Ryobi was able to loosen the nut after it was fully tightened by the DeWalt... It would seem that the two impacts are closely matched in power.
Yea but it’s well known that it’s much easier to break a bolt loose than it is to tighten. I actually recently bought a Skidmore-Wilhelm and have already done experiments to prove that a impact gun can break bolts loose that are well out of the range they are able to put out when tightening. I will make a video soon when I get some time that shows this.
@@charlieott7469 That would be interesting to see. And I agree with that. It would have been better to use the truck lugnuts as a good comparison. He could've tightened (or loosened) them with the torque wrench in steps to find each tools max breakaway torque limits.
It’s very hard to perform an accurate test without the proper equipment but if I had to come up with a way it would be very similar to what you said. I would scrap the lug nut idea though because there’s too much of a chance of yielding the lug bolt and damaging it. Then I would get a piece of angle iron and put it in the vise and drill a hole in it for a 3/4” (grade 8) bolt and basically do what you said except on the 3/4” bolt and make sure there is a washer on the side you are turning and plenty of anti-seize on the bolt and face of the nut and washer. You could even tighten it as tight as the gun will get it and then see how much torque it takes to turn it a little more. The only problem is you need a torque wrench that goes higher than 250FT LB if you’re gonna use your method on tools that are rated as high as the ones he’s testing.
Torque specs are to keep the wheel on while at the same time not bending your hub/ rotor and screwing up your brakes. Highly Doubtful you will bend a rim from over torquing.the studs would snap first.
That ryobi... is fucking impressive! I am a believe now I may go buy a combo kit of this brand cause I am no professional but seems to be plenty around the house. FUCK YA!
Both reputable brands which generally meet their spec and the expectations of their target market, it's the random unbranded tools that really start to fall short of their promises.
Yes for the most part, I feel like the dewalt is a little over rated and This Ryobi is under rated. its close but im no U.L. Lab, If you like Impact wrench videos check out my latest one. ruclips.net/video/JofrYCG6zKk/видео.html Thanks for watching
@@Fluid36 not in the US! I believe they sell that same wrench under the Ridgid power tool brand here, which is another TTI company and Home Depot's house power tool brand. They are positioned above Ryobi but below other prosumer brands like their own Milwaukee in pricing
I have exact same Ryobi impact and I like it. Just recently opened it up and greased up hammer and it made a world of a difference it wouldn't heat up as fast as it use to with factory grease amount. So lube them up.
It is great but but, I kind if wish I would of gotten the half in drive instead of the 3/8 th, the torque dramatically goes down when you use an adapter.
@@Impact-OG The Milwaukee 1/2 & 3/8 stubby versions are rated the same torque, forward and reverse. Make sure you're using an impact extension, makes a big difference. Also, as you probably know, bigger batteries give better power. Extra long impact sockets are also available for getting around using extensions in some situations.
Yes I have the 3/8 Milwaukee stubby and I really liked it, but I wish I would of gotten the 1/2 inch. It will take off my lug nuts on the truck but I have to use a 3/8 socket because if I use an adaptor it cant do it. The adaptor will takes away the power of the tool. At least on the stubbys.
Its was a 30 dollar POS from Harbor Freight, and it did end up cracking on me And why do you care how I have it attached to my work bench? But thanks for watching
Yeah I don't see why it wouldn't work I don't think your tires would be torqued down to over 250 lb. I've used it to take off the tires on my Ford F-150.
I've noticed the Ryobi tools in the us don't look Very tough in briton the basic Ryobi 1/2 impact gun is 400 nm or 300 foot pounds and they are under rated I've took van bolts of that look like they have been welded on i do admit i flattened a 4 amp hour battery doing it took nearly 1 hour for 4 wheels and 1 hour for the tool could cool down god knows what the hammer looks like in side the gun
Hi. The Ryobi P260 has the same brush motor as the Craftsman C3 1/2 Impact. Both tools were originally rated around 200 ft lbs of max torque with their original NiCad batteries, however with 5-6ah lithium batteries, they're around 270 ft lbs of max torque. This particular tool design is now 10+ years old and still effective and relevant in 2020. I'm measuring 20.7 volts at full charge with my C3. The DeWalt 894 is supposedly rated at 340 ft lbs of max torque, but after watching this video, I'm very doubtful of that rating. The Milwaukee 2860 currently holds claim to trump the mid-torque market at 450 ft lbs of max torque. Until I see real world results however, I'm skeptical to believe! Best, Robert LearnChristianity.org
I tried my Milwaukee vs a 200usd eBay one. Out a 5/8 socket on both put them in vise facing each other.. a 5/8 x 3/4 long bolt. And hit the triggers . The eBay one got ripped apart .. end story ..
Nice videos kinda makes me sick when I see the dewalt everyone convinced me into being the best so I went all black and yellow crazy. Oh well if I ever get the chance to do it again I'll go with makita or Milwaukee I suppose.
Hey man dont limit your self by only using one brand, I see that all the time. Well I am a craftsman guy all the way or Im a dewalt guy all the way. I use what I find to be the coolest and most suited to my needs for stuff. My wife hates it that buy to much stuff, butt you can find good deals on batterys just keep a look out and you will find some deals.
Dewalt impact wrenches are under powered. If you want power , buy Milwaukee. I swapped from Dewalt. Dewalt impact wrenches are gutless. Even the Dcf899 is poor compared to Milwaukee’s high torque gun. Don’t take my word for it, try it yourself.
Fusion2016 They aren’t. I use mine daily ( I’m a technician ). It got tiring having to put down the dewalt and pick up the Milwaukee. I love Dewalt but I wouldn’t use dewalt impact wrenches. They suck.
Well they rate the Ryobi for 200 foot lbs of Torque on there web sit. And when I tested it, It was able to do 250 lbs with no problem, So I believe its more around 300 ft lbs of torque, its very under rated,
So basically these tools need a big huge battery to work at peak performance. I have the ryobi p261 that Couldn’t even break the lug nuts off my car today and they weren’t that tight
O and by the way I'm sure you do not know this yet and if you do buy now I'm glad but electric or battery powered impacts make their torque around 15 to 20 seconds and sometimes even 30 seconds of in pak then they make their real torque
Next time try doing milwaukee and porter cable tests I own 2 porter cable drivers a drill and impact driver id like to see what they are like if one is better than milwaukee
Yes the power from the ryobi is coming straight from the battery to higher capacity batteries give the guns more power. On paperwork my snap on 38 drive puts down 230' pounds of torque in actual working it's a long 300' pounds of torque with a for amp hour battery. When they brought out the 5M power battery I didn't buy the battery but I tested it the gun had 400 plus foot pounds of torque so those higher batteries give your good way more power but tragically most your guns well ahold out as long as they would with your normal batteries because they're not true impacts. Is the where snap on Mac O and Ingress saul are true impacts and They can take the abuse
Yeah I was not impressed by the dewalt, I feel that its way over rated and under powered. I would go with the high torque impact of there's its i think 199 for the kit at home depot. Thanks for watcing
@@Impact-OG what would you recommend that will take cake wheel nuts off without fail etc not truck just car wheel nuts ... cheap isn't always good lol so I would like to see whT ya opinion is now after this time thats passed
GudMusic4Lyfe yeah I should’ve elaborated but it’s true. Ryobi and Milwaukee are both separate companies, but they are indeed manufactured by the same Techtronic industries factory In Hong Kong. Milwaukee is obviously hands down better. not trying to take anything away from them. I use their tools
If both drivers have the same voltage battery, with the same aH (assuming real), then the one with the lower RPM (assuming real) will have the higher effective torque. There's absolutely no basis for stating, in this comparison, that the DeWalt in this video is in any way better than that Ryobi.
@@dustinstoecker6995 yeah I like to say that too, see AVE copied me and took all my funny sayings, see I have been around forever just not as popular as him.😂😂🤣🤣😅😅😅😅
lol, yes it does. Does it have everything to do with power? No, and that's why impact wrenches don't spin as fast as impact drivers. But it's clearly part of the overall equation. There's a reason why they dial back the max torque by lowering the max RPM through speed selector switches. Lower RPM = lower dynamic torque. Each blow hits less because you're spinning the hammer at a lower speed. Slower and lighter hammer blows to the anvil = less torque transferred to the fastener. You're literally wrong every time you make posts like these. Just stop.
Uh he isn't completely wrong there is more to making torque then JUST rpm and ipm. The gearing plays a huge roll in creating the force necessary to make these crazy numbers. Look at industrial cordless impact wrenches they can make thousands of ftlbs of torque with hardly any rpms they will literally be in the hundreds and still make 1500 ftlbs. Although saying rpm has nothing to do with power isn't completely accurate either... The rpm and ipm play a big part in usability, the lower the impacts the more torque transfers to the user this is the difference in an impact and a driver. It's all important in creating a handheld torque wrench that requires no brace 👌.
ruclips.net/video/sJVtccZE0vg/видео.html Just an example of how rpm and impact correlate to power. It is all engineered for certain applications you could have a 100rpm impact wrench that could exceed 300ftlbs but you wouldn't be able to grab it and break lugs by holding the handle right you would need a brace. Hytorq makes a torque wrench that literally uses no impacts just extremely low gearing and they have guns that accomplish 1500 ftlbs fastening.
DeWalt replaces snap on equivalent at a fraction of the cost. The dcf894 and Milwaukee mid torque pretty much set the standard in this cost bracket of impacts.
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
For the price and performance for the typical home owner/DIYer you can’t beat Ryobi. I own a lot of their products and love em.
🖐 same here , love my ryobi tools sold my blues and bought the green and went lithium. 👍
My dad still uses his 20+ year old Ryobi battery powered tool with new batteries amazing tools
I've got that Ryobi unit and have used it on old rusty vehicle bolts. It's taken off lug nuts, chassis bolts, skid plate bolts, and even axle nuts!
Yes it has been able to take off almost everything I have tryed it on. They way under rated it!!!
Been using ryobi for a long time so I was enthused to see this video. I just recently picked up a few Milwaukee impacts and my lord. They are insane!
The DeWalt mid torque is perfect for tire rotations the smart wrench setting seems purpose built for breaking and setting lugs I love that I can fasten the lugs and it will hammer them once to set the rim then stop automatically. Vice versa when breaking loose the automatic lowering in rpm is perfect! I always grab my mid torque over the 899 for working with lugs! The only downfall is that their is only one speed while in reverse versus the high torque and even 12v that have variable speed for both directions.
Edit: finished watching I can't believe the DeWalt didn't break that lug that is crazy it must be pretty damn tight I've maxed my 250 ftlb torque wrench and the mid breaks it like nothing.
I have that same older model 200 ft/lb ryobi impact wrench. I have only used it a few times, now it just overheat after taking off a couple 80 ft/lb lug nuts...kinda disappointed, but moved on to milwaukee, pretty good so far...and, nice comparison vid.
Those particular Ford lugnuts can be very hard to remove, especially if they haven't been off in a while. Even a good air impact will struggle. I've had to stand on a 2ft breaker bar sometimes to break them loose.
Thanks for the info about the Ford!
Nice review man, pretty impressed with the Ryobi battery tools lately. Thanks
Loosening torque on a nut is about 15% less. So your test is spot on. And a bit.
Thanks man 👍👍👍
Thats crazy that the Old RYobi is just as good as the new brushless Dweilt impact.
Its not just as good its just a poor test
@Guitargreat I have the original 2002 blue 18v nicad ryobi tool kit and they all still work. I am not gentle with them either. I was able to adapt to the lithium without replacing my entire collection. I'm certain Dewalt is no different then Ryobi when it comes to longevity. Dewalt is not a Pro tool anymore. It's now a brand name company.
Mark Hill thats not dewalts best one
Its the mid torque not the 889 or 899.
Ryobi great for having around the house, for everyday work Dewalt all the way. (From those two)
a friend gave me the Ryoby. it had been used and abused on a job site for several months. put it this way N distinguishable marking were left on the tool. so i didn't even know what model it is. until l you video. This Thing Is A Beast!! it has broken lug nuts loos that i said No Freekin Way!! its bad ass!! hope the new ones have the same balls.. Johnny Chain
Hey It has supprised me severl times with how power full it is, I feel like Ryobi under rates this tool. It has way more torque then 200 foot lbs that the web sit states. Thanks for watching.
Ryobi has been doing good the number one reason why I choose them for my 2019 tools is because the haven't changed their batteries plug. My old tools I had where craftsman professional 20v series and I cant find a battery anywhere I can even find a charger for them I've checked on Ebay and a charger cost $70 and I can only find cheap generic batteries and they still cost $68 each
you could rebuilt your old battery packs
Nice comparison! I just bought the 894 a few weeks ago. Great mid range impact!
The best one😀
EPIC! I have a set of 7 Ryobi tools that ive had for about 10 years and they all still work perfectly. There is a special deal at the orange home store (online only ) that ships free to store for $99 with the improved version rated @ 300 ftlb, battery and charger. Im buying it right now!
You look so cold every time I watch these videos good job I really appreciate it
Wow, I'm surprised by that Ryobi.
I figured that newer Dewalt would eat its lunch...
I have the newer Ryobi P261.
Its rated at 300 lbs. torque, but it still isnt brushless.
Would be interesting to see how it compares.
You brought up an interesting point about battery size and how it affects tool performance.
It would be interesting to see a comparison of how different battery sizes affect the power output of a tool such as an impact wrench.
I know the bigger batteries have a very noticeable effect on my Ryobi jetfan leaf blower. Definitely has more power right off the bat with the larger batteries.
There's just less voltage drop with the larger batteries...
Another great comparison, as usual... Thanks!
Awesome video I have the latest three speed Ryobi and its fucked brilliant 360NM
Good vid, any reason why you chose the DeWalt Mid Torque over the more powerful Milwaukee Mid Torque? I know Milwaukee seems to get a ton of praise for their warranty, that's what the pros use... I have had some issues with some of their tools a Mid-Torque that made a burning smell when new and a defective 5Ah battery right out of a new kit so I am not so convinced how great they are.
I just want with the mid torque because he was more comparable to the rail be both of them are between 200 and 400 foot pounds of torque, the high torque one is around a thousand for the DeWalt which is way higher than the Ryobi that's the only reason, yeah I wasn't impressed with it I feel like it's overrated for power I don't believe it has 400 foot pounds of torque at all where the real B says it has 200 but I feel like it's more around 3 to 350. Thanks for watching
The Ryobi is rated at 300 ft lbs.
All my tools are Dewalt, so I'd pay the $40 extra to keep the battery interchangeability. Ryobi is looking good tho. 👍👍
Hey thanks for the comment, but my Ryobi is the older model P -260 and the Ryobi sit rates it at 200 foot lbs of torque. The new one is 300 ft lbs.
Same here but ryobi has been impressing me lately. I'm considering getting my mother a ryobi kit for her birthday a year ago I would have never considered it.
Home Depot and Lowes have the DCF889M1 high torque impact on sale for $200 includes 4ah battery and charger!!! Probably don’t need anything that big but at that price why the hell not 🤷🏻♂️
Nice video Al, although I’m willing to wager that your 250 foot pounds of torque you were trying to put on that nut didn’t all make it into the threads of that bolt considering a good portion of it was lost by lifting up your work bench instead. That is why it was so easy for the Ryobi to break loose.
Charlie Ott
While I agree about not necessarily getting full torque due to the table lifting while using the torque wrench, the Ryobi was able to loosen the nut after it was fully tightened by the DeWalt...
It would seem that the two impacts are closely matched in power.
Yea but it’s well known that it’s much easier to break a bolt loose than it is to tighten. I actually recently bought a Skidmore-Wilhelm and have already done experiments to prove that a impact gun can break bolts loose that are well out of the range they are able to put out when tightening. I will make a video soon when I get some time that shows this.
@@charlieott7469
That would be interesting to see.
And I agree with that.
It would have been better to use the truck lugnuts as a good comparison.
He could've tightened (or loosened) them with the torque wrench in steps to find each tools max breakaway torque limits.
It’s very hard to perform an accurate test without the proper equipment but if I had to come up with a way it would be very similar to what you said. I would scrap the lug nut idea though because there’s too much of a chance of yielding the lug bolt and damaging it. Then I would get a piece of angle iron and put it in the vise and drill a hole in it for a 3/4” (grade 8) bolt and basically do what you said except on the 3/4” bolt and make sure there is a washer on the side you are turning and plenty of anti-seize on the bolt and face of the nut and washer. You could even tighten it as tight as the gun will get it and then see how much torque it takes to turn it a little more.
The only problem is you need a torque wrench that goes higher than 250FT LB if you’re gonna use your method on tools that are rated as high as the ones he’s testing.
@@charlieott7469
Agreed.
You can screw a aluminum rim up by torquing down that much. Aluminum rims have pretty important torque specs!
Yes that is why I always use the same tire and rim, If I were to crack it or damage it I have an extra one!!
Torque specs are to keep the wheel on while at the same time not bending your hub/ rotor and screwing up your brakes.
Highly Doubtful you will bend a rim from over torquing.the studs would snap first.
Awesome video brother!
Is that a Yost vice?
That ryobi... is fucking impressive! I am a believe now I may go buy a combo kit of this brand cause I am no professional but seems to be plenty around the house. FUCK YA!
Both reputable brands which generally meet their spec and the expectations of their target market, it's the random unbranded tools that really start to fall short of their promises.
Yes for the most part, I feel like the dewalt is a little over rated and This Ryobi is under rated. its close but im no U.L. Lab, If you like Impact wrench videos check out my latest one.
ruclips.net/video/JofrYCG6zKk/видео.html
Thanks for watching
Is that a masterforce torque wrench the handle looks familiar I have the digital one from masterforce from menards there lifetime warranty
Just subscribed to your channel. Fellow Minnesotan 👍🥶
Decker that sounds very familiar, Did you go to Como High school???
No sir. I was born and raised up north. Bemidji area. Currently live up near the Canadian border. Land of windows walleyes and hockey sticks.
@@rjd8434 Oh ok i see, we had a cabin up by hibbing for 20 years, just out side of floodwood.
I have the p261 3 speed it’s brushed too I’m still waiting for a brushless ryobi impact wrench
@@Fluid36 not in the US! I believe they sell that same wrench under the Ridgid power tool brand here, which is another TTI company and Home Depot's house power tool brand. They are positioned above Ryobi but below other prosumer brands like their own Milwaukee in pricing
I have exact same Ryobi impact and I like it. Just recently opened it up and greased up hammer and it made a world of a difference it wouldn't heat up as fast as it use to with factory grease amount. So lube them up.
That might be a good idea I actually have never thought about doing that. Thanks watching
Thanks for the vid!
Yeah man thanks for watching
I just ordered the Ryobi P1833 kit at Home Depot for $129 as it was the best price to performance I could afford.
Yeah buddy you will like it, That is my problem I like all the tools lol
Good mod, keep up the good work.
Hey thanks man.
How do you like that Milwaukee stubby? I was debating on getting one haven’t done so yet.
It is great but but, I kind if wish I would of gotten the half in drive instead of the 3/8 th, the torque dramatically goes down when you use an adapter.
Making Stuff and Breaking Stuff with Al what if you already had a 2767 would you still get the 1/2 stubby? I have 2767 and it is a MONSTER!!!
@@Impact-OG The Milwaukee 1/2 & 3/8 stubby versions are rated the same torque, forward and reverse. Make sure you're using an impact extension, makes a big difference. Also, as you probably know, bigger batteries give better power.
Extra long impact sockets are also available for getting around using extensions in some situations.
Yes I have the 3/8 Milwaukee stubby and I really liked it, but I wish I would of gotten the 1/2 inch. It will take off my lug nuts on the truck but I have to use a 3/8 socket because if I use an adaptor it cant do it. The adaptor will takes away the power of the tool. At least on the stubbys.
@@Impact-OG Ah, I see. Ima lil slooowwww...drool
Impressive vice. Badly installed and then mis-used and the ears didn't break off.
Its was a 30 dollar POS from Harbor Freight, and it did end up cracking on me And why do you care how I have it attached to my work bench? But thanks for watching
Great testing!!
Thanks man:)
With Ryobi some of them won’t go up to 300 pounds torque it says it on the manual but they could probably go up a little higher than that
My mechanic is the SOB over tighten my alloy wheels over 250 lb/ft.
Yes I get people asking all the time about that. They are asking what kind of impact can take off the lug nuts because they cant get them off by hand.
You need a new mechanic .
Your lucky you didn't get a flat tire or snap off a wheel stud .
The p261 version of the Ryobi would have removed 300 ft lbs with ease,I remove Ford F150 axle nuts torqued to 295 ft lbs within 3-4 sec.
Gshock714
Those lug nuts require way more than 300 ft/lbs, due to rust, etc etc.
I’m wondering about long term reliability of the two brands.
Don't let the brand foul you the
ryobi 1/2 impact wrench is a damn good gun Fraction of the price
Great video keep up the good work.
Hey thanks I really appreciate the feed back and comment..
R.P.M’s I thought we measured by the minute
Thanx from the left coast near the Krapitol of California
Anyone think this old ryobi will take on pulley bolts or crankshaft/harmonic balancer bolts???
You know maybe it depends on if you cant get in there with it, its very big and not easy to get in tight places.
@@Impact-OG Nice! I didnt even think of that.
Great video my brother.
Thanks man !!!!!!!
Good video for brushed that Ryobi did ok crazy
Can i use the Ryobi to remove my Durango tires?
Yeah I don't see why it wouldn't work I don't think your tires would be torqued down to over 250 lb. I've used it to take off the tires on my Ford F-150.
This tool with a socket can remove the lug nuts, but it won't remove your tires.
@@georgeburns7251 Hahahaha Steve you know what he meant...
@W Jack thats cuz he torque them to 300. Most normal people dont torque their tires. And most tires dont use that much torque
I am looking for something I can put in the trunk of my car and plug into my cigarette lighter when need to change a tire. Which one should I get?
I've noticed the Ryobi tools in the us don't look Very tough in briton the basic Ryobi 1/2 impact gun is 400 nm or 300 foot pounds and they are under rated I've took van bolts of that look like they have been welded on i do admit i flattened a 4 amp hour battery doing it took nearly 1 hour for 4 wheels and 1 hour for the tool could cool down god knows what the hammer looks like in side the gun
Hi. The Ryobi P260 has the same brush motor as the Craftsman C3 1/2 Impact. Both tools were originally rated around 200 ft lbs of max torque with their original NiCad batteries, however with 5-6ah lithium batteries, they're around 270 ft lbs of max torque. This particular tool design is now 10+ years old and still effective and relevant in 2020. I'm measuring 20.7 volts at full charge with my C3. The DeWalt 894 is supposedly rated at 340 ft lbs of max torque, but after watching this video, I'm very doubtful of that rating. The Milwaukee 2860 currently holds claim to trump the mid-torque market at 450 ft lbs of max torque. Until I see real world results however, I'm skeptical to believe! Best, Robert LearnChristianity.org
Those were put on with a pneumatic gun. way more power than cordless.
I tried my Milwaukee vs a 200usd eBay one. Out a 5/8 socket on both put them in vise facing each other.. a 5/8 x 3/4 long bolt. And hit the triggers . The eBay one got ripped apart .. end story ..
Nice videos kinda makes me sick when I see the dewalt everyone convinced me into being the best so I went all black and yellow crazy. Oh well if I ever get the chance to do it again I'll go with makita or Milwaukee I suppose.
I will say the dewalt 899 high power hasn't let me down yet tho it's pretty strong.
Hey man dont limit your self by only using one brand, I see that all the time. Well I am a craftsman guy all the way or Im a dewalt guy all the way. I use what I find to be the coolest and most suited to my needs for stuff. My wife hates it that buy to much stuff, butt you can find good deals on batterys just keep a look out and you will find some deals.
Dewalt impact wrenches are under powered. If you want power , buy Milwaukee. I swapped from Dewalt. Dewalt impact wrenches are gutless. Even the
Dcf899 is poor compared to Milwaukee’s high torque gun. Don’t take my word for it, try it yourself.
@@Paul-vn5mi I have, they are pretty well equal
Fusion2016 They aren’t. I use mine daily ( I’m a technician ). It got tiring having to put down the dewalt and pick up the Milwaukee. I love Dewalt but I wouldn’t use dewalt impact wrenches. They suck.
Hey man great video! I really need to know is the 400nm ryobi strong enough to loosen/tighten crankshaft bolts off?
You know I'm not 100 percent sure, what is the bolt torque stew if it's under 300 lb of pressure it probably would break it loose.
@@Impact-OG OR BREAK THE BOLT IN THE CRANKSHAFT.
I could have swear the Ryobi at HD printed 300 ft/lb.
No this is the older model, if you go to RYobi website it says 200 foot pounds of torque, But it puts out way more than that.
Thanks for watching.
There good for 300 ftp ? For Ryobi
Well they rate the Ryobi for 200 foot lbs of Torque on there web sit. And when I tested it, It was able to do 250 lbs with no problem, So I believe its more around 300 ft lbs of torque, its very under rated,
So basically these tools need a big huge battery to work at peak performance. I have the ryobi p261 that Couldn’t even break the lug nuts off my car today and they weren’t that tight
Do same test and add the Ridgid 18v
FASTFUN but with the dewalt dcf899
Try the Milwaukee on those wheel nuts
that review is coming soon I have the milwaukee and the makita going at it next.
Why ? Do you want to see the Milwaukee blow up ?
@@rumchaser1able Fire means ratings, and in this case subsribers? burn baby burn!
@@cameranmanner4701 it would definitely implode
What's the model # on the ryobi
O and by the way I'm sure you do not know this yet and if you do buy now I'm glad but electric or battery powered impacts make their torque around 15 to 20 seconds and sometimes even 30 seconds of in pak then they make their real torque
Please do a Milwaukee 2767-20 vs ingersoll rand w7152 battle to the death
Next time try doing milwaukee and porter cable tests I own 2 porter cable drivers a drill and impact driver id like to see what they are like if one is better than milwaukee
Thank you!
Can you review and test 108vf impact wrench sir? Im from malaysia support your video
It takes less torque to brake the bolt 🔩 than your torqueing too
nice video dude
THANKS
People don't cry about 300 ft pounds torque for lug nuts ?????
On my video they just talking about the tread ,and torque up to 150 lb. ((
I was wondering if we'd see a follow up video on how to replace studs. Seems like a bad idea to stretch them out like that.
Think the ryobi is 300 now.
Anyone can say what they want... The Ryobi more than held its own..
Next jigsaw ryobi!! Thx for ur videos from Denmark!
Wow Denmark!!! Thank you so much. I will see what I can do..
Much better video
Yes the power from the ryobi is coming straight from the battery to higher capacity batteries give the guns more power. On paperwork my snap on 38 drive puts down 230' pounds of torque in actual working it's a long 300' pounds of torque with a for amp hour battery. When they brought out the 5M power battery I didn't buy the battery but I tested it the gun had 400 plus foot pounds of torque so those higher batteries give your good way more power but tragically most your guns well ahold out as long as they would with your normal batteries because they're not true impacts. Is the where snap on Mac O and Ingress saul are true impacts and They can take the abuse
your table biase the torc setup
OK thanks for your opinion
This stopped me buying the dewalt in all honesty I seen reviews on draper stormforce cheap but seems good reviews
Yeah I was not impressed by the dewalt, I feel that its way over rated and under powered. I would go with the high torque impact of there's its i think 199 for the kit at home depot.
Thanks for watcing
@@Impact-OG what would you recommend that will take cake wheel nuts off without fail etc not truck just car wheel nuts ... cheap isn't always good lol so I would like to see whT ya opinion is now after this time thats passed
@@Impact-OG sorry I am uk so need a brand to look for
I think you meant “meant” when you said ment,gnome sayin’?
yes see you got it hahahaha
please never torque your wheel nuts that tight! you will stretch the wheel stud
And warp the rotors.
I only use mine to take off the lug nuts and use a torque wrench to tighten to the right foot pounds of torque.
Super 👌
Makita is very precise I think that would be better for diy
its all about the battery.
Yes it really is, I have done tons of testing on it.
thanks for watching
Makita dtw285 get them lug nuts off not bad the dewalt and ryobi tools
Yeah that Makita 1/2 impact is crazy Powerful
Milwaukee can take those lugs off
GudMusic4Lyfe ryobi is now made by same company as Milwaukee
@@billt7283 lol the some funny shit, i have nothing to give to that lol
I Use a 1/4 in brushless Milwaukee impact with 3/8 to 1/2 adaptor and it loosens lugs. Once in a while it fails and have to use lug wrench.
GudMusic4Lyfe yeah I should’ve elaborated but it’s true. Ryobi and Milwaukee are both separate companies, but they are indeed manufactured by the same Techtronic industries factory In Hong Kong. Milwaukee is obviously hands down better. not trying to take anything away from them. I use their tools
The Dewalt has 600 foot pounds of brake away torque in high mode.
No it's rated for 300.. it at least mine is.
If both drivers have the same voltage battery, with the same aH (assuming real), then the one with the lower RPM (assuming real) will have the higher effective torque. There's absolutely no basis for stating, in this comparison, that the DeWalt in this video is in any way better than that Ryobi.
Chooch....tou arent AvE stop
I will say ripem as much as I want. Thanks for watching
@@Impact-OG i didnt say ripem. I said chooch
@@dustinstoecker6995 yeah I like to say that too, see AVE copied me and took all my funny sayings, see I have been around forever just not as popular as him.😂😂🤣🤣😅😅😅😅
@@Impact-OG negative
Rpm has nothing to do with power
lol, yes it does.
Does it have everything to do with power? No, and that's why impact wrenches don't spin as fast as impact drivers. But it's clearly part of the overall equation.
There's a reason why they dial back the max torque by lowering the max RPM through speed selector switches. Lower RPM = lower dynamic torque. Each blow hits less because you're spinning the hammer at a lower speed. Slower and lighter hammer blows to the anvil = less torque transferred to the fastener.
You're literally wrong every time you make posts like these. Just stop.
Uh he isn't completely wrong there is more to making torque then JUST rpm and ipm. The gearing plays a huge roll in creating the force necessary to make these crazy numbers.
Look at industrial cordless impact wrenches they can make thousands of ftlbs of torque with hardly any rpms they will literally be in the hundreds and still make 1500 ftlbs. Although saying rpm has nothing to do with power isn't completely accurate either...
The rpm and ipm play a big part in usability, the lower the impacts the more torque transfers to the user this is the difference in an impact and a driver. It's all important in creating a handheld torque wrench that requires no brace 👌.
ruclips.net/video/sJVtccZE0vg/видео.html
Just an example of how rpm and impact correlate to power. It is all engineered for certain applications you could have a 100rpm impact wrench that could exceed 300ftlbs but you wouldn't be able to grab it and break lugs by holding the handle right you would need a brace. Hytorq makes a torque wrench that literally uses no impacts just extremely low gearing and they have guns that accomplish 1500 ftlbs fastening.
Dewalt is crap
Your crap
India is crap
DeWalt replaces snap on equivalent at a fraction of the cost. The dcf894 and Milwaukee mid torque pretty much set the standard in this cost bracket of impacts.