Vocal Coach reacts to The Beatles - Help!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 фев 2025

Комментарии • 219

  • @BethRoars
    @BethRoars  Год назад +6

    📖 Get your signed copy of my album Fable here: www.bethroars.com/shop
    ☀ Find me on Spotify: open.spotify.com/artist/1W0He1MTuQoG0Yt2ccmhyL?si=b5qm82DmSRip8L4abe2-nw
    🥁 Become a Patreon Supporter: www.patreon.com/bethroars

    • @panoslymperidis6748
      @panoslymperidis6748 Год назад

      if you are taking suggestions, check Hannah Wicklund & The Steppin Stones, i think you are really gonna like them.

  • @greendruid33
    @greendruid33 Год назад +26

    The Beatles are one of those bands that will remain so iconic, probably for hundreds of years. Their complex chord shifts, the fact that all four of them could sing well, and that they all were capable of writing their own songs in their own separate careers after the Beatles will continue to define them throughout the ages. Their trippy studio stuff is really my favourite though. I love watching this video and just concentrating on Ringo in the back. He didn't do any backing vocals on this one and because of the prop of the board and saw-horses he didn't have a practical way of being at the drums. He's pulling faces throughout the video and just hamming it up. Must have been a fun thing to record for all of them.

  • @boosuedon
    @boosuedon Год назад +16

    The chemistry of their harmonies was very special, an "I.D." stamp on everything that they did.

  • @stevedahlberg8680
    @stevedahlberg8680 Год назад +28

    Such an incredibly beautiful and catchy song and yet poignant, knowing in retrospect what was going on.

  • @imonlybleeding8021
    @imonlybleeding8021 Год назад +12

    Great reaction/analysis. When you pointed out Paul peeking out over John's shoulder, I had been watching Ringo. He just spent most of the video just sitting in the back with his umbrella, leaning every which way trying to get his face in the picture. I became a fan of the Beatles thanks to my parents, as well as aunts/uncles. But curiously enough, my grandfather was also a fan. He wasn't a fan of much music from that era, but he did like the Beatles, and it was because they could sing harmony, and do it well. He was a barbershop quartet guy, so he respecred their ability to sing as a group.

  • @sourisvoleur4854
    @sourisvoleur4854 Год назад +6

    I love the call-and-response here where the response actually gets ahead of the call (so to speak) and Paul and George are responding to John's words before he even says them.

  • @firedoc5
    @firedoc5 Год назад +10

    Having been born in 1965 when Beatlemania was in full swing, by the time I was 3 or 4 it was lucky I had babysitters and friends that loved them exposing me to their music as long as I can remember. Watching "Yellow Submarine" is one of my fondest memories and remembering how upset people were when they split up. Thanx for working your magic and being able to react to them. Love ya.

    • @BethRoars
      @BethRoars  Год назад +3

      Wow, I can only imagine how awesome it was to watch "Yellow Submarine" as a kid. Thank you for sharing your story with me and for appreciating my reactions. You rock!

    • @edmundpower1250
      @edmundpower1250 Год назад +1

      One of my favourite songs of all time

  • @Beatles4Sale.
    @Beatles4Sale. Год назад +109

    Hoping one day she will pick a best McCartney vocal like, Maybe I’m Amazed, Oh! Darling, or Helter Skelter. The album versions…

    • @stevedahlberg8680
      @stevedahlberg8680 Год назад +3

      Absolutely, it really shows what he can do. And for the early beatles, his rendition of Little Sally is just mind-blowing. They frequently closed out their shows with it in Hamburg, and audiences would just go nuts. In fact, the manager of the venue tried to write it into their contract that they weren't allowed to ever play it anymore, but fans would yell for it and they would inevitably end up playing it, and then people would go wild, throw stuff around the room and just go crazy. The guy even tried nailing the bar stools into the wooden floor to keep them from being thrown around, lol.

    • @yorkvillevic6528
      @yorkvillevic6528 Год назад +3

      Maybe Im amazed
      It is up there with Let it Be

    • @Brandi6666
      @Brandi6666 Год назад +5

      Everybody has their favorite Beatle. Johns play on words always impressed me.

    • @mattcarroll5603
      @mattcarroll5603 Год назад +4

      ​@Brandi6666 I can honestly say that I don't have a favorite. I like each of them for their individual styles and talents. As a group, they were amazing!

    • @jeffreymiller5462
      @jeffreymiller5462 Год назад +3

      John's original version was not this upbeat. It was a sad ballad, but they were the Beatles, so John was convinced to speed it up.

  • @pdt1060
    @pdt1060 Год назад +45

    Never heard of these guys before a couple weeks ago but I see great things in their future. Maybe even a top 10 single!

    • @BethRoars
      @BethRoars  Год назад +3

      😂

    • @Y-two-K
      @Y-two-K Год назад

      But where the trap hi hats??

    • @terrys8978
      @terrys8978 Год назад +1

      Maybe they'll even make a movie or 2

    • @shrewdness
      @shrewdness 11 месяцев назад +1

      @@terrys8978 yep, and they will make it to the toppermost of the poppermost!!!

  • @francisallen4298
    @francisallen4298 Год назад +6

    Nice, Beth. Haven't heard that in a while! Spot on about the counter melody. Always loved that aspect of the song. 🙋🎸🎹

  • @juanita6479
    @juanita6479 Год назад +19

    John's voice and the effect of echo harmonies sound fabulous, and then George and Ringo with those quick looks to be noticeable is adorable, they used to do naughty and silly videos because they didn't like to mime just sing.
    Well John wrote this upbeat song because of the roller coaster of the fame and George wrote 'Nowhere to go' referring to the same and of course in his style much more slow but revealing, unfortunately never properly released only a demo can be heard, but it's worthy.

  • @rbspider
    @rbspider Год назад +1

    The movie was really fun. I loved the sound track. I usually click off one of these channels the moment they interrupt the song but I like how you added some performer information and didn't just stop to say wow, let me hear that again.

  • @richardjacobs7632
    @richardjacobs7632 Год назад +2

    Everyone wants to sing like their hero’s! Their vocals were always dynamic!

  • @vernhoke7730
    @vernhoke7730 Год назад +4

    Great song and a great movie.
    The soundtrack has so many amazing songs in it.
    If memory serves me correctly I saw this in the theater when it came out.

  • @bobbelleci9995
    @bobbelleci9995 Год назад +9

    I really liked the way John sang like this even if it was a throatier melody. Really good stuff. 😊

  • @cjmacq-vg8um
    @cjmacq-vg8um Год назад +3

    i like your voice analysis. this song, album and movie, all titled "help!," released in mid-1965, was the height of "beatlmania." it statred in november 1963 with the release of their 2nd album, "with the beatles" and became a global phenomenon with their u. s. debut on the ed sullivam show in february 1964. throughout 1966 touring became an utter nightmare so they quit touring and live tv performances. this is when they transitioned from a mop-top, pop-rock band and blossomed into a more mature approach to their songwriting and they revolutionized studio music production.
    they performed live on tv once in 1968, november, on the david frost show where they performed "hey jude." and in january 1969 they performed live together for the last time on the rooftop of EMI studios which was filmed for the movie "let it be" and released in may 1970. although they didn't perform live they did film several music videos from 1967 through 1969.
    there are many music videos from their beatlemania days as well. this film of "help!," of course, is a lip-synched tv performance. but i don't know what tv show it origonally aired on. the beatles are so fascinating on so many levels; their history, origins, fashion styles and musical progression over a short period of only 6 or 7 years, their ups and downs. and no matter what their personalities and their music always shown through. the beatles were a remarkable social, cultural and musical experience. once you're turned onto them its hard not to get hooked! thanks for the video.

  • @capitalinvestmentconsultan1679
    @capitalinvestmentconsultan1679 Год назад +2

    Yes great voice young lady, love it. Star.

  • @7137159381
    @7137159381 Год назад +2

    Amazing as it seems, there are millions of young people who have never heard of the Beatles or listened to their music!!

  • @AL13NM
    @AL13NM Год назад +2

    It''s hard to pick but this is one of my all time favorite Beatles songs, lyrically and Musically! AND I am eagerly awaiting my signed Vinyl copy of YOUR new album, BETH!!!

  • @phillipdycaico5949
    @phillipdycaico5949 11 месяцев назад +3

    I’m 66 and this song has more meaning than when I heard it as a youth.

  • @madreh7549
    @madreh7549 8 месяцев назад

    Help! I was 10 years old when I first heard it and Felt in love instantly, Was the Help movie that I was watching since that till now 46 years later I'm still in love with them!!

  • @juanprime8827
    @juanprime8827 Год назад +1

    Hi Beth, When I was 6-8 years old (1972) I heard the Beatles for the first time and I was not used to their voice, however they had a very special magnetism, they sang relaxed but at the same time wild.

    • @BethRoars
      @BethRoars  Год назад +2

      Hi Juan, thank you for sharing your experience with the Beatles. I can relate to what you said about their voice and their magnetism. They were truly unique and amazing artists. I love how they could sing with such ease and passion at the same time. What is your favorite song by them?

    • @juanprime8827
      @juanprime8827 Год назад +1

      @@BethRoars Each Beatles album is unique, with a character completely distinct from the others. I really like the Revolver and Sgt. Pepper era. Songs like 'Walrus' and 'Tomorrow Never Knows' are my favorites from that time.

  • @johnriley7312
    @johnriley7312 Год назад +1

    I just love Ringo sitting in the background 😆😆

  • @williamvorstelman2151
    @williamvorstelman2151 10 дней назад

    Great review I can see you really understand the beatles "progression" unstoppable

  • @stevedotwood
    @stevedotwood Год назад

    He had an excellent voice! Ringo is the smart one in here, he took his precautions and "helped" himself.

  • @StanSwan
    @StanSwan Год назад +9

    Many of John's songs were not meant to be upbeat but in the early days they were pushed to make upbeat, short, and fast pop songs. Help has to be the prime example but "There's a Place" is far more sad lyrics set to the four happy mop top's beat. Gabrielle Aplin did an amazing cover about ten years ago that is how the song was intended to sound. It is amazing.

  • @JoeKentMagic
    @JoeKentMagic 2 месяца назад

    There's always been something about those 3 Bass notes ... EPIC !

  • @aaronsensei7637
    @aaronsensei7637 Год назад +12

    I enjoy this version because it is the original. However I grew up with John Farnham and he really unpacked and explored the deeper meaning.

    • @sjng68
      @sjng68 Год назад +2

      I agree, in fact I didn't hear the original until I was an adult (my parents weren't really Beatles fans) and it was difficult to believe it was the same song after having listened to the Farnham version all my life.

  • @westfield90
    @westfield90 Год назад

    I love John’s voice on so many of his songs , but especially this one.

  • @genebrenner855
    @genebrenner855 Год назад +2

    A nod to Beatles recording engineer Norman Smith (died 2008) who found a way to record the Beatles right from the beginning in the studio while attempting to capture the excitement he heard on their live performances. That's why they sound so good right from the get-go. His last work with the Beatles was "Rubber Soul".

  • @DougFrantz
    @DougFrantz Год назад +7

    What's it called when the harmony leads the main vocals as happens in parts of this song? It's an interesting effect where we get the words ahead of the main track.

  • @Michael-xn1we
    @Michael-xn1we 4 месяца назад

    Man I'm a buyer products and subscribe to your channel just recovering The Beatles and you're so insightful you're very interesting and intelligent thank you thank you for your analysis thank you thank you

  • @Suloleipuri
    @Suloleipuri Год назад +1

    So good LOVE IT ❤❤

  • @LusiaEyre
    @LusiaEyre Год назад +1

    I really like this one and it is one of the special ones because you don't get live performances of it anymore. There are covers by other artists, but I couldn't find a single instance of either Beatle performing it since. Both Paul and Ringo don't shy away from performing Beatles songs. Often with other artists. But it seems that the ones where John was the leading voice are left untouched.

  • @charlier711
    @charlier711 Год назад

    Thanks Beth for covering such a classic.

  • @phengkimving
    @phengkimving Год назад +1

    Nice sweet lovely reaction. Long live Ringo-George-Paul-John's music!! I don't believe John really hated his own voice. I believe he said he hated his own voice because he was intoxicated by his fame and wanted to be considered more formidable. In the song video I admire Paul for appearing to be acceptingly happy with being #2 in the band. Of course in later years Paul approached being #1, which made John unhappy and was 1 of the factors that led John to instigate the breakup of the Beatles.

  • @987jof
    @987jof Год назад +1

    Ringo nailed the Umbrella in this track 🤘

  • @SidneyJohnson-p2n
    @SidneyJohnson-p2n 3 месяца назад

    All of the Beatles songs were really wonderful

  • @oscararzate7956
    @oscararzate7956 Год назад +4

    Los gigantes de la música universal y como lo dije alguna vez espero no ofender a nadie pero son de los grupos que su música cambiaron al mundo 🌍 gracias H. Prrj ❤ bien Big Beth 👏👏🍀🍀

  • @jamiemacdonald436
    @jamiemacdonald436 Год назад +3

    Ringo just holding the umbrella always makes me smile 😁

  • @varunagoonasekera7329
    @varunagoonasekera7329 3 месяца назад

    There is a movie which The Beatles did of the song "Help" and in the beginning they perform on stage. I really like to know what part of the song and how much John Lennon contributed and how much Paul McCartney contributed and also George Harrison and Ringo Starr 🎸🎸🥁 Great review by the way!

  • @kirby1ist
    @kirby1ist 9 месяцев назад

    I have only ever seen the Movie version ( 100 times or so lol ) Thanks for the new video, thanks for the great analysis, never really saw the counters ( again film right ) have a great day Beth

  • @MLawrence2008
    @MLawrence2008 Год назад +6

    Thank you Beth, great reaction. For me (as a tech nerd) this song is really special. It was the first time I ever heard sampled music on a computer. Way back when I had all my own teeth and no grey hairs I had a Commodore 64 computer. Someone sampled the first 50 seconds or so of 'Help' and distributed it as a Demo. It used all 64k of memory in the computer, took over 2 minutes to load off of a cassette tape, was not great quality and was mono, but.................... WOW Sampled music!!!!!!!!!!!!! MP3 was not even a pipe dream at this time. People would visit our house just to hear me play this demo! How the world and technology have moved on since then.
    p.s. When the 50 seconds were done, you had to restart the computer and load from tape again! LOL

  • @justitia257
    @justitia257 Год назад

    Beautiful reaction, Gorgeous Beth. Grazie mille

  • @Blitzkrieg_england
    @Blitzkrieg_england Год назад +1

    The Beatles is my favorite band 🎸

  • @richardjacobs7632
    @richardjacobs7632 Год назад

    Energy of the group was always the attraction!

  • @motfc8
    @motfc8 Год назад

    One off my karaoke favs!🤗

  • @jimhurst6168
    @jimhurst6168 Год назад +1

    I loved Ringo in this video, was he the one that was providing the HELP since he was holding the umbrella 😮

  • @marysweeney7370
    @marysweeney7370 Год назад +2

    A favorite song of mine from that period is We Can Work it Out. I hope you get the chance to react to it.

  • @brianhildreth9099
    @brianhildreth9099 9 месяцев назад

    I love me some Beth!!! ❤

  • @RoadienicknamedRory
    @RoadienicknamedRory Год назад +3

    At 4:55 , you can tell George was NOT told about the fake snow that came down on his head! 😂

  • @cathyortiz1280
    @cathyortiz1280 Год назад

    Great song with great lyrics. John's songs were always my favorite. You should watch the movie - great fun!😊

  • @robertscola4762
    @robertscola4762 Год назад +2

    Can’t wait for you to react to the new Beatles song

  • @juansalazar7882
    @juansalazar7882 Год назад

    My favorite band of all time

  • @pianoman7151
    @pianoman7151 Год назад

    They also did a movie "Help" a musical/comedy in 1965 with the song "Help" as the theme song.

  • @larrylindgren9484
    @larrylindgren9484 8 месяцев назад

    A band that came at the perfect time to be monstrous. They'd sell records today but not the insane numbers they did then. Everything they released seemed to be a number 1. One year in 1964 they have 25 of the top 100 songs on the chart at the same time. That's insane. Most singers and groups don't even have 25 songs they would ever chart let alone at the same time.

  • @Kevinatwork1
    @Kevinatwork1 7 месяцев назад

    I seem to remember that when John first played Help to George Martin, it was at a slower beat. I'm not sure who suggested it be played at the pace we all know today but that's where the juxtaposition of the happy beat with dark lyrics comes from.

    • @Kevinatwork1
      @Kevinatwork1 7 месяцев назад

      Further to my comment prior, George Martin definitely siggested a faster pace for Please Please Me, their first major hit

  • @dathorndike4908
    @dathorndike4908 3 месяца назад +1

    I always kind of feel bad for Ringo in this video. All he gets to do is hold the umbrella

  • @mylcioquites3133
    @mylcioquites3133 5 месяцев назад

    Beatles forever, nunca irão existir um grupo musical igual aos Beatles eles eram perfeitos em tudo

  • @beaandjuno
    @beaandjuno 10 месяцев назад

    The movie is my fave, so funny and the birth of music videos

  • @BRIANZ969
    @BRIANZ969 Год назад +1

    They can do no wrong- Well-I love the Beatles-what could be wrong about that

  • @coldlakealta4043
    @coldlakealta4043 Год назад

    The title song to "Help" is standard Hollywood stuff. The title song to "Hard Days Night", with its iconic opening riff, is classic 60s rock'n roll. I know which one is on my play list.

  • @gerardomr8231
    @gerardomr8231 Год назад

    BEAUTIFUL BETH ROARS ❤️😍💋

  • @scipiom4578
    @scipiom4578 Год назад

    I listened to Phonograph Electronique and Power of the Wolf, and genuinely enjoyed both of the songs.

  • @stratcat3216
    @stratcat3216 Год назад

    Ringo still cracks me up :)

  • @baaaalls
    @baaaalls Год назад

    My favorite thing about this video is watching Ringo trying to be seen all the way in the back

  • @shaunoday3646
    @shaunoday3646 Год назад +1

    I'm sure there were Beatles song found on the flipside of their albums I still haven't heard lol

  • @SnappingTurtle250
    @SnappingTurtle250 8 месяцев назад

    They have potential

  • @tomgruitt6563
    @tomgruitt6563 Год назад

    Yes!

  • @Ebichuchu
    @Ebichuchu 11 месяцев назад

    It’s so interesting that John was only 25 when he did this, probably even younger when he wrote this, and is talking about very relatable feelings for that age even if you’re NOT wildly famous 😂 I’m 26 and think it’s so weird Paul was younger than me in this video 🥴

  • @dubasciver3234
    @dubasciver3234 Год назад

    Beth, you just have one of the sweetest personalities. You are a lovely gal.

  • @ManubibiWalsh
    @ManubibiWalsh Год назад

    You should react to Monkberry Moon Delight by Paul McCartney. Probably his most bizzarre and incredible and fun vocals, and the song is insanely catchy too. The Lovers That Never Were or Maybe I’m Amazed, too. He really has incredible vocals, especially in his solo career.

  • @mattthemarine46
    @mattthemarine46 10 месяцев назад

    Some of the best singers come out of the United Kingdom

  • @dirknash
    @dirknash Год назад

    was surprised still couldnt find a video of you reacting to cara mia by jay and americans so figured id suggest it

  • @thomastimlin1724
    @thomastimlin1724 Год назад

    It was the title song for the HELP movie. check out the movie have a few laughs.

  • @BC-ui9yt
    @BC-ui9yt Год назад

    I'm re-reading Mark Lewishon's "Tune in" (which I HIGHLY recommend, btw) and he mentions how even in the very early Quarrymen days, it was apparent that Lennon and McCartney's voices blended well together. Beth, can you explain that? I'd love to hear it!

  • @Michael-xn1we
    @Michael-xn1we 4 месяца назад

    Thank you for your analysis and your insight it's a beautiful analysis of this I appreciate what you say about John Lennon's voice so I will subscribe and buy your products with love Michael Carter

  • @jonbrooks5246
    @jonbrooks5246 Год назад +1

    Love Help and interesting reaction.
    I would love to see you react to She’s Not There by the Zombies and Midnight Confessions by the Grass Roots, Beth!

  • @charlieknowlton7003
    @charlieknowlton7003 Год назад +1

    What has been observed before is, that the backing vocals ,instead of echoing the lead singer like many songs, lactually lead into John's lyrics.

  • @damonmoon436
    @damonmoon436 Год назад

    please, do more Beatles!!

  • @jonathanwetherell3609
    @jonathanwetherell3609 Год назад

    Days of my childhood. I saw the film in the local cinema.

  • @izzykhach
    @izzykhach 25 дней назад

    I've been looking for that 1985 Lincoln Mercury commercial. Can't find it.

  • @manjula123badri
    @manjula123badri 7 месяцев назад

    Deep Purple's cover is wonderful as well. Rod Evans is a great singer.

  • @Tonystony1984
    @Tonystony1984 Год назад

    Would love to hear you react to Just Like Starting Over 😎👍

  • @boschytroop
    @boschytroop Год назад

    You need to hear the Roxette acoustic cover. Adds a more dramatic call for "Help"

    • @hstdriver6616
      @hstdriver6616 Год назад

      I'm going to listen to it right now!

    • @hstdriver6616
      @hstdriver6616 Год назад

      Yep, it's a good cover. A lot more feeling in the Roxette version. Marie sounds like she means every single word!

  • @undergroundwarrior70
    @undergroundwarrior70 Год назад

    From my understanding, when John Lennon wrote "Help" he was going through some depression and he did not feel comfortable with himself physically because he had gained some weight. The 1965 film 'Help' with The Beatles (their second film feature) is pretty good and funny. Some critics didn't care for it too much, and they thought it was not as good as their first film feature 1964 'A Hard Day's Night', which it was Ringo Starr came up with that saying, and John Lennon and Paul McCartney wrote the song. Need to watch both films, both of them are very good.

  • @tludden
    @tludden Год назад

    McCartney has a nice live lead with the Beatles with, “Can’t Buy Me Love.” That would be a good one to critique.

  • @coffee-xg6my
    @coffee-xg6my Год назад

    Yes, using a sound alike is still done for copyright purposes. Because it was the actual recording of the Beatles "Help" that the owner of the recordings wouldn't allow Ford to use, You have to understand, there is a copyright for the composition and a separate copyright for the sound recording itself. Two separate copyrights. So, most companies who want to use a song will have a different artist record the song if they cant afford to pay for the rights of use for the recording or if they are denied permission to use it. All they have to do is have a mechanical license issued from the Publisher to do their own recording of it if they are going to use it for purposes of selling a service or product. But the copyright holder of the recordings can outright deny permission to use the actual Beatles recording itself for any purpose.

  • @capitalinvestmentconsultan1679

    Please remember, John was down, #How can you laugh when you know I'm down. The boys laughed at John, trying to cheer him up.

  • @binxbolling
    @binxbolling 3 месяца назад

    You'd be surprised how many people haven't heard Beatles songs.

  • @reneleroux7669
    @reneleroux7669 Год назад

    FYI: Geoff Castelucci performs a cover of the Beatles song "Blackbird". Pretty interesting.

  • @3rdstone1
    @3rdstone1 Год назад

    Excellent video as usual. Now, I'd love to see and hear you react to another Beatles song released just within this one: Paper Back Writer (I think its 1966?). There's a full promotional video on YT An excellent guitar-riff that goes on through the song, McCartneys brilliant bass playing, but most of all: Those harmonies! I'm ´totally certian you would appreciate that one

  • @vovindequasahi
    @vovindequasahi Год назад

    You should watch the movie Help!

  • @jeffmartin1026
    @jeffmartin1026 Год назад +1

    At this point they were under contract for 2 (or 3?) LPs and 3 single releases a year, plus they had made 2 movies and done several full tours. They were also starting to write more introspective songs at this point. The B side to this song is "I'm Down", written by Paul.

  • @mickeygregg359
    @mickeygregg359 3 месяца назад

    I’d like to hear your take on a sadly neglected sleeper from that era: “Farewell Song” on the album “Live at Winterland ‘68” by Big Brother and the Holding Company featuring Janis Joplin.
    -
    -

  • @NemoMurphy-dm3jh
    @NemoMurphy-dm3jh 4 месяца назад

    Check out the Deep Purple version of this song. The music fits the words much better.

  • @StephenKiely-y3j
    @StephenKiely-y3j 10 месяцев назад

    More impressed with you .your simply gorgeous

  • @Frahamen
    @Frahamen Год назад +2

    I think the song have something to do with a tiger in a basement who only calms down if you whistle Beethoven's 5th symphony to it, but I could be wrong...

  • @evillemike2009
    @evillemike2009 Год назад +2

    This sounds a lot like one of the "Lennon & McCartney" tunes that John wrote pretty much on his own.
    And your observation about the snappy upbeat music behind some pretty melancholy lyrics is a good one. They made kind of a habit of doing that. The one that always comes to mind for me is This Boy - a lover's lament, but in the happy hopeful key of D. Whether they intended it that way - or it was just the Yin-n-Yang of a moody John plus a sunshiny Paul - it comes out as the everyday genius of The Beatles.

    • @AppleCorp3
      @AppleCorp3 Год назад +2

      Paul’s contribution was the counter melody. A great example of how they collaborated - maybe not straight 50/50 like Rogers & Hammerstein, but an important contribution that really adds something special.

  • @rorygay3529
    @rorygay3529 4 месяца назад

    My mother took us to this movie.