basically, if your child struggles in math go with primary mathematics. If your child has no problem with mathematical concepts and needs to be challanged, go with dimensions math.
Thank you for this. My daughter raced through her first grade math book and is not quite ready for second grade. So we are looking for another 1st grade curriculum.
Very nice video, we love Dimensions but its wonderful to see them side by side like that. Even tho we use Dimensions I can see where Primary would appeal more to younger students due to the drawings. Thanks for this comparison!
@@user-vg8ez9cu6u No. Every time my child completes something on their own, it is an assessment. It lets me know what they know and don't know. I didn't see the need.
@@TheParentTeacherBridge Thanks for responding. I was asking because I heard people recommend Challenging Word Problems, Test Book and Intensive Practice alongside the PM series for targeted work. Good to know the Test book isn't necessary
@@user-vg8ez9cu6u From time to time I have used the intensive practice workbooks that correspond. Not every year and not every semester (hard finding the time). However, from the time I've used them, it has REALLY challenged my son to think differently and helped develop his math approaches. I would highly recommend. Just to give you an idea...My son is in 5B right now and we finished a 4A Intensive Practice workbook the other day.
Wonderful review. Thank you! I have been torn between dimensions and the new 2022 primary coming out in June 2021 (next week). I need a side by side with that version and dimensions.
Yep it’s going to be sold only on Rainbow resources and Christian bookstore sites. Not on the Singapore site because that is actually a different company from the primary version. Dimensions and primary are NOT made by the same company. They are competitors. It is up on Rainbow resources as pre order right now but only a few have images inside to view. I only found because I joined a Singapore Facebook group.
@@kimonanatee2501 are you sure? I found this in their site “Since those early years, Singapore math has become an established part of national and international conversations about math education. We’ve continually improved and expanded our programs to suit the diverse and ever-evolving needs of students and educators. Our latest series, Dimensions Math® PK-5, makes the Singapore math approach more accessible, affordable, and engaging.”
I know it’s confusing. What I learned in the group is that Singapore math inc is a distributor of Primary mathematics and that is why they sale primary mathematics on their website. Marshall Cavendish created the original Singapore primary mathematics and the other versions. Dimensions was created by Singapore Math Inc which is the owner of the Singapore Math website that we all have purchased both curriculums from. They are 2 separate companies. Nobody is sure yet if they will sell the new 2021 Primary version on Singapore Math website but for now the other 2 sites are selling them. One of the authors is a admin in the Singapore math Facebook group that I am in and she did a live showing the new curriculum and answered questions. Everyone had the same reaction that you have. If you are interested, the group is called “Homeschool Singapore Math Families.”
We use both Dimensions Math and Beast Academy. Dimensions Math is our core and Beast Academy is our enhancement. My daughter loves both. She's 6 years old now but started with Dimensions Math when she was 3 years old. Singapore Math helped her to develop abstract thinking which helps her with Beast Academy which we added this year. We keep a party each time she graduates to a new book which makes her very happy. My 3 year old just started Dimensions Math and loves it as well. I highly recommend getting the teachers guide. It's the most important resource for any homeschool program.
hello! i’m a singapore student and actually reason for the so called “hard papers” is to train problem solving skills so it really isn’t that hard, it’s all logic ngl
You’re welcome. Math is a tough subject. I hope you find what works for you. We did eventually end of switching to the good and the beautiful math. I have a review in my curriculum review playlist
Excellent review!!!!!!! I thank you so much for showing this - I am Those parents in limbo and not having my kids in the school and will be using homeschooling curriculums so I really appreciate this review you have helped me decide I will go with the dimensions. Maybe you have other videos on the rest of what we need to know like English language arts science etc.
I am so glad to know that you found this review helpful! And thank you so much for letting me know. Here is my full playlist of curriculum reviews ruclips.net/p/PLGhmFx-TBGjCB5Tq14dZFnfaS6ps8sJBf
I've never heard of the Singapore method I didn't know they regularly topped maths test results either. I enjoyed this it's interesting to see how math can be taught differently when you consider it's the same subject of that makes any sense x I prefer the colourful work books for kids x
we are using dimensions math and loving it so far but i’m questioning if getting the teacher guide is necessary for all levels. we bought it for this year because it was our first year using it but do you think it’s necessary?
From what I understand they are ready for Algebra 1. The creatives of Singapore math live created something for algebra one you can find it here www.highschoolmathlive.com/algebra-i-info-2020-2021.html
There are dozens, hundreds of other math curriculum on the market for both homeschool and public school. A parent or teen can sample and choose what they feel is the best transition from SM.
Depends on where your kid is at with math. Some kids are on track to take Algebra 1 in 7th or 8th grade because the parents mapped it out since K5 (i.e. the child starts grade 1 math in Kinder or they homeschool year-round for math which advances the child through years of math in a shorter span of time). The rest will take it in 9th or 10th. From what I hear, Singapore is excellent for Primary School. Gets top reviews from Well Trained Mind forum and rivals private school math if done correctly.The verdict is still out on their Middle School math program as they use an integrated approach for math for 7th-9th. The problem is if you ever have to put your kid back into public school they won't fit exactly into a Prealgebra, Algebra or Geometry course, as they've been working on bits and pieces of all three during each middle school year. The pro is that if you complete that program, I think your child would have gone through Algebra I and Geometry (and perhaps some bits of Algebra II). Many parents stop SM after grade 6 and move on to one of the following: (Classical): Dolciani, Foerster, etc. (Challenge): AOPS (Art of Problem Solving-the creators of Beast Academy) with Khan Academy, EPGY, or Dukes TIP. (Traditional/Public School at Home): Jacobs, Mcgraw Hill, Houghton Mifflin, Pearson, Mr. D math online, Chalkdust, Teaching Textbooks, etc. If your child took Algebra I in 8th grade then the math sequence for high school is usually as follows: Geometry (9th) Algebra II (10th/perfect timing for PSATs) Pre-Calculus/Trigonometry (11th) Calculus AB* (12) If child is taking Calculus at a Community College through dual enrollment (aka college credit program) then: Semester 1=Calculus AB Semester 2=Calculus BC Make sure your child takes CLEP tests as well. Super beneficial. Anyway. This is what the top private school kids do for math (along with math competitions and hiring private tutors).
@@MrsMomsHomeschool I started my daughter at 2A it wasn't easy for me to track. It seemed to be all over the place. I'm wondering why I'm struggling to get the daily process. Some days are very straight forward but others I just don't get what they're talking me to do. My main question is . . . since we started in 2, they don't tell us about the previous concepts so we're just left to fumble our way through. Any suggestions? I'm thinking about going back to Saxon even though I was so excited to learn math THIS way. 🤷🏻♀️
@@faithbelleg7465 did you get the teachers guide? Did you go with dimensions or Singapore? Dimensions has online help and Singapore’s teachers guides are pretty detailed
@@MrsMomsHomeschool dimensions because my kids tend to be ready for something more complex concepts and I like they have videos available if I need help explaining 🥳
basically, if your child struggles in math go with primary mathematics. If your child has no problem with mathematical concepts and needs to be challanged, go with dimensions math.
I’ve never looked at Singapore upclose. I can definitely see how their methods would be beneficial!
I like that they give you the choice in primary math to use common core or traditional. I know a lot of families arent a fan of common core.
Thank you for this. My daughter raced through her first grade math book and is not quite ready for second grade. So we are looking for another 1st grade curriculum.
Let me know what curriculum you went with. My son is at the same point almost.
Oh man I recognize those textbook covers at 4:06! Literally the same from my primary school days over 20 years ago!
Very nice video, we love Dimensions but its wonderful to see them side by side like that. Even tho we use Dimensions I can see where Primary would appeal more to younger students due to the drawings. Thanks for this comparison!
you're welcome!
We have primary. However, we DO order the Intensive Practice from Singapore from time to time. Those are what we use for a challenge. :)
The Parent Teacher Bridge we used primary for years and I like it too
Do you use the test workbook for PM?
@@user-vg8ez9cu6u No. Every time my child completes something on their own, it is an assessment. It lets me know what they know and don't know. I didn't see the need.
@@TheParentTeacherBridge Thanks for responding. I was asking because I heard people recommend Challenging Word Problems, Test Book and Intensive Practice alongside the PM series for targeted work. Good to know the Test book isn't necessary
@@user-vg8ez9cu6u From time to time I have used the intensive practice workbooks that correspond. Not every year and not every semester (hard finding the time). However, from the time I've used them, it has REALLY challenged my son to think differently and helped develop his math approaches. I would highly recommend. Just to give you an idea...My son is in 5B right now and we finished a 4A Intensive Practice workbook the other day.
Wonderful review. Thank you! I have been torn between dimensions and the new 2022 primary coming out in June 2021 (next week). I need a side by side with that version and dimensions.
I’m glad I could help! I didn’t know they were coming out with a new version!
Yep it’s going to be sold only on Rainbow resources and Christian bookstore sites. Not on the Singapore site because that is actually a different company from the primary version. Dimensions and primary are NOT made by the same company. They are competitors. It is up on Rainbow resources as pre order right now but only a few have images inside to view. I only found because I joined a Singapore Facebook group.
@@kimonanatee2501 are you sure? I found this in their site
“Since those early years, Singapore math has become an established part of national and international conversations about math education. We’ve continually improved and expanded our programs to suit the diverse and ever-evolving needs of students and educators. Our latest series, Dimensions Math® PK-5, makes the Singapore math approach more accessible, affordable, and engaging.”
I know it’s confusing. What I learned in the group is that Singapore math inc is a distributor of Primary mathematics and that is why they sale primary mathematics on their website. Marshall Cavendish created the original Singapore primary mathematics and the other versions. Dimensions was created by Singapore Math Inc which is the owner of the Singapore Math website that we all have purchased both curriculums from. They are 2 separate companies. Nobody is sure yet if they will sell the new 2021 Primary version on Singapore Math website but for now the other 2 sites are selling them. One of the authors is a admin in the Singapore math Facebook group that I am in and she did a live showing the new curriculum and answered questions. Everyone had the same reaction that you have. If you are interested, the group is called “Homeschool Singapore Math Families.”
@@kimonanatee2501 oh wow you are knowledgeable! We actually switched to TGTB math for my little one and beast academy for my son
We use both Dimensions Math and Beast Academy. Dimensions Math is our core and Beast Academy is our enhancement. My daughter loves both. She's 6 years old now but started with Dimensions Math when she was 3 years old. Singapore Math helped her to develop abstract thinking which helps her with Beast Academy which we added this year. We keep a party each time she graduates to a new book which makes her very happy. My 3 year old just started Dimensions Math and loves it as well. I highly recommend getting the teachers guide. It's the most important resource for any homeschool program.
Great advice! Thank you!
Seriously just asking this question you’re a great resource. Thanks for these videos
you are so welcome
Thanks so much for this video. I've decided to go with Dimensions Math after watching this comparison. The information was very helpful.
Suzanne Montgomery I’m so glad to hear that it helped you decide
hello! i’m a singapore student and actually reason for the so called “hard papers” is to train problem solving skills so it really isn’t that hard, it’s all logic ngl
Thank you for that information!
Thank you so much for this. I was torn between which books to choose, but I know exactly what I want now (Dimensions). Thank you again.
You’re welcome!
Thank you for this video. I think we use primary. My child struggles a little in math.
You’re welcome. Math is a tough subject. I hope you find what works for you. We did eventually end of switching to the good and the beautiful math. I have a review in my curriculum review playlist
Excellent review!!!!!!! I thank you so much for showing this - I am Those parents in limbo and not having my kids in the school and will be using homeschooling curriculums so I really appreciate this review you have helped me decide I will go with the dimensions. Maybe you have other videos on the rest of what we need to know like English language arts science etc.
I am so glad to know that you found this review helpful! And thank you so much for letting me know. Here is my full playlist of curriculum reviews ruclips.net/p/PLGhmFx-TBGjCB5Tq14dZFnfaS6ps8sJBf
I've never heard of the Singapore method I didn't know they regularly topped maths test results either. I enjoyed this it's interesting to see how math can be taught differently when you consider it's the same subject of that makes any sense x I prefer the colourful work books for kids x
gary jones yes it’s a great math program!
I had never heard of Dimensions math before this video thanks for sharing.
Life in the Mundane really? But you have heard of Singapore math right?
@@MrsMomsHomeschool Yes I have heard of that just not the dimensions aspect
Life in the Mundane gotcha 😊
I bought primary for level 1 but I'll be switching to dimensions for level 2.
I was just looking into these yesterday! Thank you for the video!
You’re welcome!
we are using dimensions math and loving it so far but i’m questioning if getting the teacher guide is necessary for all levels. we bought it for this year because it was our first year using it but do you think it’s necessary?
I don't think it is necessary at all.
I'm looking into Singapore math for my son 🙂
Good choice
So great!! I have been seriously wondering what the difference is. TY so much! (=
you are so welcome!
Thank you for all your videos
You’re so welcome 😉
What happens after 8th grade? What do homeschoolers do beyond that if they've started with SM?
From what I understand they are ready for Algebra 1. The creatives of Singapore math live created something for algebra one you can find it here www.highschoolmathlive.com/algebra-i-info-2020-2021.html
There are dozens, hundreds of other math curriculum on the market for both homeschool and public school. A parent or teen can sample and choose what they feel is the best transition from SM.
Depends on where your kid is at with math. Some kids are on track to take Algebra 1 in 7th or 8th grade because the parents mapped it out since K5 (i.e. the child starts grade 1 math in Kinder or they homeschool year-round for math which advances the child through years of math in a shorter span of time). The rest will take it in 9th or 10th.
From what I hear, Singapore is excellent for Primary School. Gets top reviews from Well Trained Mind forum and rivals private school math if done correctly.The verdict is still out on their Middle School math program as they use an integrated approach for math for 7th-9th. The problem is if you ever have to put your kid back into public school they won't fit exactly into a Prealgebra, Algebra or Geometry course, as they've been working on bits and pieces of all three during each middle school year. The pro is that if you complete that program, I think your child would have gone through Algebra I and Geometry (and perhaps some bits of Algebra II).
Many parents stop SM after grade 6 and move on to one of the following:
(Classical): Dolciani, Foerster, etc.
(Challenge): AOPS (Art of Problem Solving-the creators of Beast Academy) with Khan Academy, EPGY, or Dukes TIP.
(Traditional/Public School at Home): Jacobs, Mcgraw Hill, Houghton Mifflin, Pearson, Mr. D math online, Chalkdust, Teaching Textbooks, etc.
If your child took Algebra I in 8th grade then the math sequence for high school is usually as follows:
Geometry (9th)
Algebra II (10th/perfect timing for PSATs)
Pre-Calculus/Trigonometry (11th)
Calculus AB* (12)
If child is taking Calculus at a Community College through dual enrollment (aka college credit program) then:
Semester 1=Calculus AB
Semester 2=Calculus BC
Make sure your child takes CLEP tests as well. Super beneficial. Anyway. This is what the top private school kids do for math (along with math competitions and hiring private tutors).
@@user-vg8ez9cu6u this was a super helpful comment. Thank you!
Which of these are you liking better for your child?
I like Singapore better but we switched to beast academy after using Singapore and dimensions for a few years
I'm not sure if I understand this. Why would the newest version be common core? As homeschoolers, I'm intentionally avoiding that.
I agree with you. The older ones gave you the option to chose
@@MrsMomsHomeschool I started my daughter at 2A it wasn't easy for me to track. It seemed to be all over the place. I'm wondering why I'm struggling to get the daily process. Some days are very straight forward but others I just don't get what they're talking me to do. My main question is . . . since we started in 2, they don't tell us about the previous concepts so we're just left to fumble our way through. Any suggestions? I'm thinking about going back to Saxon even though I was so excited to learn math THIS way. 🤷🏻♀️
@@faithbelleg7465 did you get the teachers guide? Did you go with dimensions or Singapore? Dimensions has online help and Singapore’s teachers guides are pretty detailed
@@MrsMomsHomeschool I have Primary Mathematics 2A (Singapore) and I do use the Home Instructor Guide.
What is Common Core?
Is that something to do with the US curriculum?
Super helpful, thank you for helping me decide!
You’re welcome! Which did you chose?
@@MrsMomsHomeschool dimensions because my kids tend to be ready for something more complex concepts and I like they have videos available if I need help explaining 🥳
@@Omommawrites good choice 😃
thank you for your insight!!!
ASMR for Moms you’re welcome
Thank you for this!
Melinda Payne you’re very welcome
Do you need the manipulatives for this?
No you do not