I was a CSS aspirant but when I started to read and research to prepare for the exams, I changed my mind, because I know that I won't have power to change this system, I would either go mad or corrupt in the end. So, I chosed to remain in a profession where at least I could change some minds, the only solution of this pathetic situation is to first, make people aware of it, rest comes later. Looking forward to the next video...
@@naeemsindhu1419 there is difference between bravery and stupidity. We live in a country where people don't give a damn when a person like firdous ashiq is appointed, then removed humiliatingly and then appointed again, what a mere officer can do here? First we need to make people realize that "this is an Abnormal system" , its worst sort of psychological slavery imposed and justified by internal and external force's fear, economical backlash and religion....
@@naeemsindhu1419 ashir azeem is the example of the person who tried changing things for good. What happened to him and may be thousands like him? It is a gradual process, it will take time may be a decade to take decisions in our(civilian's) hands. The small part we can play and raising our voice repeatedly
Ashir Sir, you've dissected the root cause of Pakistan's current crisis like very few have done. Very eloquent as always. My respect for you has increased bcz you accepted you were on wrong side of the perspective when you thought that Army is our only saviour. Yes they are our defendants, but not our Maalik.
Thank you sir. I have learnt a lot from your knowledge of the system. These things are not taught in school. I appreciate your effort and would request to continue with increased frequency of uploads
What a man and what a foresight! I am listening to him in June 2023 and I have witnessed the very words he uttered. 30:08 Exact same script and policies being applied once again and we were dumb enough to be tricked and fooled for so many years. What a pity we are as a nation!
What an enlightening vlog. When people like AA emigrate to other countries nobody can imagine what an unimaginable loss Pakistan sustains. Let's hope and pray those in control of our country's politics and institutions take note of what has been elaborated by the current vloger. God bless you, AA.
Wow...Wow....Wow, when a political party starts emerging with true people, Establishment kicked them off.... and that is exactly happened with PTI later after one year of your video...........what a great predictions by Sir Ashir Azeem.
Dear Sir, all you are discussing is true in its sense, and there is not a second thought on it, I must say, you are a deep thinker and some what a sensitive person, which every body should be as a human being. Some time, we are going forward to that path, the end of which is nothing, and then we think, that why we have choosed that way, paid my attention and time, but then time has gone and never come back. So For keeping on the right track, we must have right and accurate manual with us, which is no doubt a quran, so I strongly recommend you, please keep this manual with you, while you are in the thinking process and trying to find the solution of the matters. I am a big fan of yours, and appreciate your feelings, and am listening you, since long. Un till next, Take care and Regards Aamir
@@hassansajjad4883 it's because of people like you, they come and do what they do. If you are happy with GHQ then scrap the sham democracy make the great Bajwa your chief marshal law administrator.
@@shahrozekhurram9836 hahaaaha that why i guess you deserve people like diesel nawaz zardari who make billions and keep puppet like you feeding on some bucks Btw your great judiciary freed dr asim today who made 500 millions farewell to your useless democracy And one thing if GHQ do this ,why your honorable politicians keep licking military boots to make them PM have some integrity and face the situation.Dont sent people like m zubair to COAS and beg for favors and them blame army There is no solution for your personal grudges
یہ سچ تبھی بولا جا سکتا ھے کہ جب بولنے والا ادھر موجود نہ ھو. ھم لوگ سچ مانتے ھوے بھی سچ بول نہیں سکتے کیونکہ لاپتہ نہیں ھونا چاھتے. بر حال آپ کا شکریہ درست راستہ دکھانے کا
Aashir Azeem ! You are too good to fit in this corrupt system. I do hope if Riasat e Madina system replaces it during our lives then you will be a strong pillar of it. Stay blessed.
سر آپ کا تجزیہ اور باتیں سو فیصد درست ھیں ۔آج پاکستان کےجو حالات ہیں اس کی ذمہ دار ھماری اسٹیبلشمنٹ ھے اور اس اسٹیبلشمنٹ میں کون ہیں وہ سب پاکستانی جانتے ہیں لیکن بدقسمتی سے کوئی بھی ان سے سوال نہی کرسکتا
Kudos on the continuation of your series. Few days back at literary festival on topic of political structure of pakistan, I put across my question on how can we move towards full democratic state from the hybrid regime state, where I was answered that on ground level the political culture needs to be changed. Now, regardless of the power manipulation at the top of the pyramid by the establishment, there requires an equal efforts on our side to change the political culture by getting politically awared at maximum of the matters around ourselves so that the individual vote casting must be more meaningful than a mere formality. So, a big thanks to you Sir for unfolding these hard time facts to mature our understanding of the lethal establishment. Your words will be spread across. Bests
Sir ais trha aap humse baten kia kren. Ais mulk ne humen sare zindagi jahil rkha. Aapka content lakhon me log dekhte hn zyada tr log apki baton pe implement krte honge(i do), aur ais trha ais ka impact family and working place tak jaata h. Like the way establishment has power , you also hv got thr power that is "we" who listen you.
I'm watching this video on Oct 20,2022. Almost 1 year after this LIVING LEGEND uploaded it. We all Pakistanis should trust his words because this is precisely what is happening in our country right now. As Imran khan was removed forcefully from govt by our #Saith & handed it over to those people(Kachara Party) who are rejected by the people.As he said in the video at 29mint.
@@hassansajjad4883 don't know about that but what matters is that this book describes quite correctly the way military transformed itself into the biggest industrial and land owning conglomerate in the country...say, just for example, it was funded by RAW, CIA or MOSSAD, does that make this book a lesser truth??
"To determine the true rulers of any society, all you must do is ask yourself this question: Who is it that I am not permitted to criticize?" (Kevin Alfred Strom) just implement this and i am sure you would not be surprised.
I guess u r a very good mathematician play brilliantly with constants and variables upto the right conclusion. Very much impressed by Ur maturity of thinking. Stay safe and keep educating the people of Pakistan. ❤
I have exactly the same opinion for ages now. Its straight forward but people still do not want to understand. Your way of communication is very clear and excellent. I hope people understand it. State and Seth is the main reason of all this mess. Stay blessed.
@lucas Ayub ne aisi rassi pakri k 2 dam jin ki bijli abhi tak isramaal kr rahy hain usi ne bnaye. Us k baad 50 saal mei koi politician na bna saka.. but is qoum ko ek almia ha jo inhen jotay marta ha isko sar mei bithatay hain jesay bureacracy ko aur jo inhen sar per bithata hai inhen jotay martay hain
@@Fawad_99 brother dont you know what ayub did with quaid's sister.. she flew to bangladesh and said that Muslim League was formed in Dhaka,not in karachi,pindi or ict.. we should highlight the issues which are geniune.. baki jo dam ki baat hai ayub khan ney apni jaib sey nai banwaya tha,hmaray tax payers k paisay say hi bana tha.. or uskay agay jo uskay baitay k kissay hain ap un sey waqif hogay..
@@Mega764 wohe tu mei bhe keh rha hun k baki 50 saal mei bhe jis ne bnwana tha tax k pesun se he bnana tha apne pesun se ni bnwana tha.. zardari aur nawaz sharif se tu phr bhe hazar darjay behtar tha.. in ki tu auladon ki bhe ghulami krni pary gi is qoum ko
@@Fawad_99 yes u r right..but zardari or nawaz ko yeh log laye thay,just because of there own interests..we all are aware of NRO..according to COP 1973 we are given freedom to movement,but y we are not given permission to go into cantt or sadr region.. everywhere there is a checkpost... baki papa jan sey aap wakif hongein.. i am not against army,i am against there breach of law..
Army is involved in all tenantories and all retired people from other institutes are connected directly or indirectly in having the relevant business. This should be stopped at all.
If Supreme Court instructed Sindh Govt to give the contract to FWO there was a very solid reason behind that. They wanted the job to be done on ground and not only on paper. We cannot paint a picture putting all the blame on establishment in a nation of 99% corrupt people.
Ashir bhai bohat axa lagta hae apko dekh kar or sun ka , jarii rakhann , bohat si awam hae jin kon is awareness ki zaroorat hae or awam isko samjh raha hain , proud of you ! ..
A thorough analytical look into the prevailing 'Establishment' existing in our system of governance. Aashir Bro The problem is that the civilian government has its own laws/policies etc, while the Military/Army has its own. So, the two are in a continuous struggle to wield their authority. At the end the Army wins, because it has been 'allowed' to do so since 1956. A 'Militarised Democracy' is what controls and runs Pakistan. As a common civilian I refuse to look at this bigger picture, and am happy and content with what Pakistan has to offer for a more or less comfortable and simple life. Solving such a labyrinthine issue of a better democratic Establishment is beyond our powers. Do you honestly believe that the Army will agree to going back to their barracks and borders? I doubt it. Truly appreciate your brilliant detailed videos on our country. Brings back a lot of cherished memories. Blessings.☺️🙏👍
Afghanistan & kashmir are two bogeyman that are used to usurp power. There is no solution to these conflicts as these are gravy trains for some sacred cows. Meanwhile, due to these festering issues and the defence expenditures associated with them our economy has tanked. No country can survive without trading with its neighbours. 3/4 neighbours have a strained relationship with Pakistan. With a weak economy, the power differential between Pakistan and its Eastern neighbour has increased. Had our economy 3x the present size & linked with india, modi would have thought twice about annexing kashmir. If Generals can employ Indians at their pizza company, why can't Pakistani businessmen interact with Indian counterparts
“The project of corporate globalization has cracked the code of democracy. Free elections, a free press and an independent judiciary mean little when the free market has reduced them to commodities on sale to the highest bidder.”
I as an Afghan always try telling my pakistani friends about what their army generals are doing to my country for the sake of their power and politics but they won't listen to a word I say and start assuming that I am a hater or a "namak haram". The bitter truth is that the pakistani establishment is ruining the lives of those who won't get tired defending them blindly and unlimited. Pakistanis need to understand that no organization is sacred and if given a free hand and supported blindly these organizations can put your lives and future at stake.
@@JK-cn6gf Namak haram are not All afghans but these people don't talk against Army but they talk against Punjab people and races of Pakistan and against Pakistan. Army is not Pakistan, likewise, we're a state and Army is part of state but not state itself. Afghans says "lar ao bar yao Afghanistan" these slogans are in no way in our interest. These are sponsored by India to divide Pakistan on racism and to conspire against two nation theory. U can say whatever to Army but not our country. We're not your enemies, why u people are against people.
At last, Sir you realize that establishment is the key figure who doesn't want this country to grow.. they are acting like feudals but in a modern way...I fully agree with you Sir.. God bless you, may the people of Pakistan could be educated so they should think more realistically and keep a side all the emotional national anthems which meant to make them fools....
LOVE YOU 🧡 SIR U ARE GREAT Ap idareu mein hotey hoey uske draw backs bta rhe Hein ye rare hota he Kia aur bhi ap ke fellows ap se agree krte Hein? Mein sbhi army ko uske role ki waja se hate krta tha BUT U HAVE CHANGED MY PERCEPTION Thanks
Hope one day u become Army chief and Change this corrupt system of Feudal generals. Rule of Law and honesty, loyalty of the soldier to the nation is the first priority. No dignified soldier who breeds on nation's tax can't try to control n enslave nation. Standing with constitution and Considering Prime Minister as the final authority, everyone is under P.M and Pakistan's interest is in strong, Independent Prime minister.
Finally some one spoke up, Pakistanis needs 100 people like you and world will see what they'll do with MUQADAS GAYE. All the PAPA JOHN'S and New Zealanders will not find a place to hide inshAllah
SIR slute you ALLAH apko khush rakhen apke lieay hamesha duaen hen ap jesy hzaron lakhon zehen mulk sy bahir bethy hen or yehi hmary mon pe bht bra tmacha hy thats it .
"if they want to do they can" I also have this gut feeling but people here mix it up with "Shaheed ki jo mout ha wo qoum ki hayat ha" 😐 kdr sir Mary bnda ja k 😪
Very impactful. Pl keep sharing your valuable experience with us. We as a nation have been deprived of from every basic thing. We need an eternal solution.
Power never concedes. Establishment/Army has to be forcefully removed with the current structure, and execute punishments prescribed in the constitution to set a precedent. That is the only way.
Huge respect for you sir, I always find very few negative comments on your videos. Coz youthyaas never understand you are saying. Allah bless you. Keep educating us.
Beta sub khuch sun kar hi reply Kya tha. Lekin app ki problem yeh ha k app abhi bohat chotay ho. Isi lye app ko sunne or samjhne men kafi der lag jati ha. Thoray Baray ho jao ga to galdi samjh Jaya karo ga. Mene sirf samjh ki baat ki ha. Ab is baat ko samjhne ka lye bhi app ko kafi time chahye ho ga....
Ghats basically civilian army, all.power.concemtrate don oen hand and no repurcursion for their actions, they know they will nwver lose the "election" people dont have choice, same party policy that will never change
دعا ہی کرسکتے ہیں اچھے کی امید اور بدترین کیلئے تیار رہناچاہیی ۔ اللہ تعالیٰ آپ سے راضی ہوں ۔👍🏻🌹 اسلام میں ہم سب کیلئے دونوجہانوں کی بھلائیاں ہیں ۔ اللہ تعالیٰ سیدھے راہ پہ چلائیں ہم کو ۔۔۔
@@Eddymr12 haven't you heard? People (especially journalists) tend to go missing in Pakistan. And when they do appear out of thin air, their simple explanation usually is that had gone for a random out of the blue trip to Pakistan's beautiful and scenic Northern Areas (Shumali Ilaqajat in urdu) but we know where they've been right? Wink wink 😉😉
@@Eddymr12 lol... you know what, ur absolutely right. It actually doesn't have much to do with a civil war. I guess i put it in there because that's the reel running at the back of everyone's mind every time they think about being the dissenting voice, or screaming out "Viva la Revolucion"!!! Bro this country has been flipped on it's head infront of our very own eyes. Watching actual journalists getting out casted like lepers! Why the mouthpieces are living it up. And the most upsetting part is the fact that people around u are watching the very same thing yet they see a completely different story. Like being in a hitchcock show, watching tv with a friend and yet both of u walk home having watched two completely different shows! Let's see if u can make sense of that 😊
This was all going well until 24mins then you change your stance and I can see only one thing from the following; 1, 5th Generation hybrid warfare 2, N- League pumping money 3, Old age problems
I was very clear about what you said.. and the way you express its fabulous.. simply you telling you life experience and the love for the. green flag always shwon in your video.. so no body can give you label of agent or ghaddar.. Love you ashir.. i almost watch all you vlog .. from dhuwan to malik ... man you inspire people..
Imam mehdi will fix this issue. I mean it’s impossible to “control” power without greater power and we don’t want it to be done through an opposite-invasive power! No worries we’re almost there since the signs have almost showed up.... thinking positive!
This is just stupidity, neither jesus will come back nor mehdi. Once a person goes from the world he never come back. Give me just one example that someone came back to world. This is just insane. Koy mehdi koy nae ayga yeh sub kahanian hen.
جرنیل اور ان سے متصل لوگوں نے پاوں اس قدر مضبوطی سے جما لیئے ھے کہ شاہد اب یہاں بغیر کسی انقلاب کے اس شکنجے سے ملک کو نہیں چھوڑیا جا سکتا۔ آپ لوگوں کو وہ ادراک دے رہے ھے جو انسان میں جبلی طور پے تو موجود ھوتا ھے لیکن پاکستان میں رہنے والوں سے شاہد یہ جبلت چھین کر یہ بات با آور کرا دی گئی ھے کہ پاکستان ہمیشہ ایک خطرے سے دوچار ھے جس کا حل صرف جرنیلی حکمرانی ھے۔ رب العالمين آپ کو سلامت رکھے، آمین
These True words must be written on gold...... We need people like u in politics, u must come to Pakistan and should make ur own political party and this is the solution..,.
No doubt you are speaking truthful, it's harsh reality meri marhoma dadi Allah usko jannat main jaga de, river chenaab ki dosri traf District Muzaffar Garh ky aik village main army exercises krnay ati thi logon ki faslon main deray jama lenay, agr kisi ko army walay martay kisi chori ky shak main tu pora village usko shakhs ko achoot bana deta, meri dadi hamain lassi ky jug,makhan or rotiyan diti ghee main chopri hoi or kehti ja meray beton ko de kr ajao. Aj main young aqal or baligh insan hon harsh reality dekh Kr dukh hota hay or afsos hota hay. Us waqt dhuwan drama ata tha apko dekh Kr hum baray howay hn. Establishment ko mazboot bananay walay ap log hn. Aj yeah itni taqatwar hay awaam ka kachumar nikal kr bhe awaam ko hi galiyan detay hn. Dhoka,fraib or businesses Allah ki amaan. Border ki traf munh krnay ka kaha yeah buhat genious hn yeah kehtay hn hum border bhe mehfooz bana lain gy or mulki internal matters bhe hum hi sanbhal lain gy. Qom ki izzat or kashmir aj bhe cheekh cheekh Kr dhuai de rha hay 70 saal say. I am sure agr hamari foj sirf borders py rehti or war exercises itni krti or dushman ky munh sy kashmir na ata yeah mumkin nahi tha.
Love your opinion about establishment misuse of power and responsibility. Keep posting these videos. Lots of Pakistanis needs to be awaken from their military romance. We need a real change. Period.
I was a CSS aspirant but when I started to read and research to prepare for the exams, I changed my mind, because I know that I won't have power to change this system, I would either go mad or corrupt in the end. So, I chosed to remain in a profession where at least I could change some minds, the only solution of this pathetic situation is to first, make people aware of it, rest comes later. Looking forward to the next video...
you missed the chance to change the system, you have to be brave to do anything anyway....
@@naeemsindhu1419 there is difference between bravery and stupidity. We live in a country where people don't give a damn when a person like firdous ashiq is appointed, then removed humiliatingly and then appointed again, what a mere officer can do here? First we need to make people realize that "this is an Abnormal system" , its worst sort of psychological slavery imposed and justified by internal and external force's fear, economical backlash and religion....
@@naeemsindhu1419 ashir azeem is the example of the person who tried changing things for good. What happened to him and may be thousands like him?
It is a gradual process, it will take time may be a decade to take decisions in our(civilian's) hands. The small part we can play and raising our voice repeatedly
You made the right decision!
@Muhammad Usama why brother do you want her address to send vigo😏
Pakistan needs more people like you. Love your channel and all the videos
بھائی محنت لگتی ہے درخت پر تھوڑی اگتے ہیں
پاکستان میں ٹرینڈ بدلنا پڑے گا
کیسی نہ کیسی نسل کو قربانی دے کر سمت تو بدلنی پڑے گی نہ
That made me cry at last! Aj tk men apki baton py doubtful rehta tha mgr sch h k ye sb sach ha .
cry??? Are u kidding me ?
Ashir is 100% right.
M 556 is a 6 of 5 56 cz, sscsvwwz..
Ashir Sir, you've dissected the root cause of Pakistan's current crisis like very few have done. Very eloquent as always. My respect for you has increased bcz you accepted you were on wrong side of the perspective when you thought that Army is our only saviour. Yes they are our defendants, but not our Maalik.
Thank you sir. I have learnt a lot from your knowledge of the system. These things are not taught in school. I appreciate your effort and would request to continue with increased frequency of uploads
Sir sey pochuuuuu Malik movie aur drama Dhaun kiskay tattay chat kar banae !!!!!!!
Ashar Bhai please keep posted us atleast every week...
Han yar
Exactly But i think he doesn't have time to read comments
@@mahnoorawan6554 and I..........
Producing quality content isn't that easy, it takes time.
@@ali.shuwani75 pl
P
P
P
yup cant disagree on this one. all true seeing it from past 10 years in business.
What a man and what a foresight! I am listening to him in June 2023 and I have witnessed the very words he uttered. 30:08
Exact same script and policies being applied once again and we were dumb enough to be tricked and fooled for so many years. What a pity we are as a nation!
What an enlightening vlog. When people like AA emigrate to other countries nobody can imagine what an unimaginable loss Pakistan sustains. Let's hope and pray those in control of our country's politics and institutions take note of what has been elaborated by
the current vloger. God bless you, AA.
Wow...Wow....Wow, when a political party starts emerging with true people, Establishment kicked them off.... and that is exactly happened with PTI later after one year of your video...........what a great predictions by Sir Ashir Azeem.
You are our Proud Aashir bhai ❤️
Real Hero real Pakistani 💖
Totally agree with you, but the establishment will never ever give up there powers easily.
Whole nation will Salute you one day.IA
ahi rona ty roo ry aa eni dar da😂😂
Dear Sir, all you are discussing is true in its sense, and there is not a second thought on it, I must say, you are a deep thinker and some what a sensitive person, which every body should be as a human being.
Some time, we are going forward to that path, the end of which is nothing, and then we think, that why we have choosed that way, paid my attention and time, but then time has gone and never come back.
So For keeping on the right track, we must have right and accurate manual with us, which is no doubt a quran, so I strongly recommend you, please keep this manual with you, while you are in the thinking process and trying to find the solution of the matters.
I am a big fan of yours, and appreciate
your feelings, and am listening you, since long.
Un till next,
Take care and Regards
Aamir
People should rule not GHQ! That's Democracy!
which people zardari Nawaz sharif? if thats democracy then we are happy with GHQ
@@hassansajjad4883 it's because of people like you, they come and do what they do.
If you are happy with GHQ then scrap the sham democracy make the great Bajwa your chief marshal law administrator.
@@shahrozekhurram9836 hahaaaha that why i guess you deserve people like diesel nawaz zardari who make billions and keep puppet like you feeding on some bucks
Btw your great judiciary freed dr asim today who made 500 millions farewell to your useless democracy
And one thing if GHQ do this ,why your honorable politicians keep licking military boots to make them PM have some integrity and face the situation.Dont sent people like m zubair to COAS and beg for favors and them blame army
There is no solution for your personal grudges
@@hassansajjad4883 I'm a soldier myself!
@@hassansajjad4883 please open up your mind for the country and not one institution.
Justice Waqar Seth RIP ko salam
Please continue to share your worthy views....👍👍👍
یہ سچ تبھی بولا جا سکتا ھے کہ جب بولنے والا ادھر موجود نہ ھو. ھم لوگ سچ مانتے ھوے بھی سچ بول نہیں سکتے کیونکہ لاپتہ نہیں ھونا چاھتے. بر حال آپ کا شکریہ درست راستہ دکھانے کا
Sir you are doing a great job. As you are so far away this is what you can do. Teach. Hopefully people will understand what you are trying to say.
I've never seen any journalist who has explained the whole system the way you have broken down things in details in such profound mannner.
Sir I am listening your vlog in year 2022 and your words fulfill each and every word you said... Our Establishment is repeating same thing...
Thank you Ashir Bhai for opening our eyes
I wish you all the best for your non-stop struggle to motivate a nation like Pakistan. ❤🙏🏻💓
Probably the only Pakistani intellectual youtube channel explaining the truth in its simplest way. Your video is always awaited!!
Aashir Azeem ! You are too good to fit in this corrupt system. I do hope if Riasat e Madina system replaces it during our lives then you will be a strong pillar of it. Stay blessed.
🙄
سر آپ کا تجزیہ اور باتیں سو فیصد درست ھیں ۔آج پاکستان کےجو حالات ہیں اس کی ذمہ دار ھماری اسٹیبلشمنٹ ھے اور اس اسٹیبلشمنٹ میں کون ہیں وہ سب پاکستانی جانتے ہیں لیکن بدقسمتی سے کوئی بھی ان سے سوال نہی کرسکتا
Kudos on the continuation of your series.
Few days back at literary festival on topic of political structure of pakistan, I put across my question on how can we move towards full democratic state from the hybrid regime state, where I was answered that on ground level the political culture needs to be changed.
Now, regardless of the power manipulation at the top of the pyramid by the establishment, there requires an equal efforts on our side to change the political culture by getting politically awared at maximum of the matters around ourselves so that the individual vote casting must be more meaningful than a mere formality.
So, a big thanks to you Sir for unfolding these hard time facts to mature our understanding of the lethal establishment.
Your words will be spread across.
Bests
Sir ais trha aap humse baten kia kren. Ais mulk ne humen sare zindagi jahil rkha.
Aapka content lakhon me log dekhte hn zyada tr log apki baton pe implement krte honge(i do), aur ais trha ais ka impact family and working place tak jaata h. Like the way establishment has power , you also hv got thr power that is "we" who listen you.
Keep teaching us like a great professor.
I'm watching this video on Oct 20,2022. Almost 1 year after this LIVING LEGEND uploaded it. We all Pakistanis should trust his words because this is precisely what is happening in our country right now. As Imran khan was removed forcefully from govt by our #Saith & handed it over to those people(Kachara Party) who are rejected by the people.As he said in the video at 29mint.
To understand how big a chunk of economy of Pakistan is controlled by Army, i suggest everybody to read the book " Military Inc." by Ayesha Siddiqa
لنک
btw can you please tell who funded for that book
@@hassansajjad4883 don't know about that but what matters is that this book describes quite correctly the way military transformed itself into the biggest industrial and land owning conglomerate in the country...say, just for example, it was funded by RAW, CIA or MOSSAD, does that make this book a lesser truth??
Lo g new dimension...
@@shoaibqamar2723 im not trying to sound blind army lover ke fouj ne qurbanian di..wo sab....let be just logical
App ki har youtube video is like a new episode of duuwa drama :)
Dua karna Last Episode na aye
I wish you long healthy and prosperous deendar life ameen
"To determine the true rulers of any society, all you must do is ask yourself this question: Who is it that I am not permitted to criticize?" (Kevin Alfred Strom) just implement this and i am sure you would not be surprised.
Actually they converted from savior to traders
I guess u r a very good mathematician play brilliantly with constants and variables upto the right conclusion. Very much impressed by Ur maturity of thinking. Stay safe and keep educating the people of Pakistan. ❤
Really pleased to meet you at Costco Burlington
I have exactly the same opinion for ages now. Its straight forward but people still do not want to understand. Your way of communication is very clear and excellent. I hope people understand it. State and Seth is the main reason of all this mess. Stay blessed.
Thank you for educating us!
sure.... waisay tu app sbhe he unday say niklay haen... pappoo haen... app....
😃😃😃🤣🤣🤣😃😄😄
@@iqbhum Thank you for your useless comment!
Fully agreed with you and true picture of system ❤
Establishment wants to enjoy the authority without being accountable. So what can be better than the hybrid system for this.
جی بالکل باقی ساری قوم بہت ایماندار ہے اور سیاستدانوں کی کیا ہی بات ہے۔
آوے کا آوا ہی بگڑا ہوا ہے۔
@lucas Ayub ne aisi rassi pakri k 2 dam jin ki bijli abhi tak isramaal kr rahy hain usi ne bnaye. Us k baad 50 saal mei koi politician na bna saka.. but is qoum ko ek almia ha jo inhen jotay marta ha isko sar mei bithatay hain jesay bureacracy ko aur jo inhen sar per bithata hai inhen jotay martay hain
@@Fawad_99 brother dont you know what ayub did with quaid's sister.. she flew to bangladesh and said that Muslim League was formed in Dhaka,not in karachi,pindi or ict.. we should highlight the issues which are geniune.. baki jo dam ki baat hai ayub khan ney apni jaib sey nai banwaya tha,hmaray tax payers k paisay say hi bana tha.. or uskay agay jo uskay baitay k kissay hain ap un sey waqif hogay..
@@Mega764 wohe tu mei bhe keh rha hun k baki 50 saal mei bhe jis ne bnwana tha tax k pesun se he bnana tha apne pesun se ni bnwana tha.. zardari aur nawaz sharif se tu phr bhe hazar darjay behtar tha.. in ki tu auladon ki bhe ghulami krni pary gi is qoum ko
@@Fawad_99 yes u r right..but zardari or nawaz ko yeh log laye thay,just because of there own interests..we all are aware of NRO..according to COP 1973 we are given freedom to movement,but y we are not given permission to go into cantt or sadr region.. everywhere there is a checkpost... baki papa jan sey aap wakif hongein.. i am not against army,i am against there breach of law..
Very good knowledge 👍 thanks love you sir..... AP ki bat samajhne k lie aqal chahiey jo k awam k pas nei agley 70sal bhi asey hi chale ga.......
Army is involved in all tenantories and all retired people from other institutes are connected directly or indirectly in having the relevant business.
This should be stopped at all.
People like you are real heroes of Pakistan. May Allah give people of pakistan wisdom to think like this.
Waalekum Assalam Aashir brother, u r my most fvrt actor,
🇵🇰🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🇵🇰
Wow .... Ashar Bhai you always give us reasoning of thinking what's happening around us.... May Allah bless you...
If Supreme Court instructed Sindh Govt to give the contract to FWO there was a very solid reason behind that. They wanted the job to be done on ground and not only on paper. We cannot paint a picture putting all the blame on establishment in a nation of 99% corrupt people.
Ashir bhai bohat axa lagta hae apko dekh kar or sun ka , jarii rakhann , bohat si awam hae jin kon is awareness ki zaroorat hae or awam isko samjh raha hain , proud of you ! ..
Army should mind her own job. Just and just to defend the country to be totally fair.
And let nawaz and zardari loot the country? That won't happen my son
Ashir Bhai Meine Apko Sunna Shuru Kiya To Apne Videos Banane Mai Susti Shuru Krdi
only traitors can disagree with you...May Allah Bless You...
Yar pehlay yeh ghaddari k fatway to band karo, freedom of thought and speech is the pinnacle of a progressing society
A thorough analytical look into the prevailing 'Establishment' existing in our system of governance. Aashir Bro The problem is that the civilian government has its own laws/policies etc, while the Military/Army has its own. So, the two are in a continuous struggle to wield their authority. At the end the Army wins, because it has been 'allowed' to do so since 1956. A 'Militarised Democracy' is what controls and runs Pakistan. As a common civilian I refuse to look at this bigger picture, and am happy and content with what Pakistan has to offer for a more or less comfortable and simple life. Solving such a labyrinthine issue of a better democratic Establishment is beyond our powers. Do you honestly believe that the Army will agree to going back to their barracks and borders? I doubt it. Truly appreciate your brilliant detailed videos on our country. Brings back a lot of cherished memories. Blessings.☺️🙏👍
Afghanistan & kashmir are two bogeyman that are used to usurp power. There is no solution to these conflicts as these are gravy trains for some sacred cows. Meanwhile, due to these festering issues and the defence expenditures associated with them our economy has tanked. No country can survive without trading with its neighbours. 3/4 neighbours have a strained relationship with Pakistan. With a weak economy, the power differential between Pakistan and its Eastern neighbour has increased. Had our economy 3x the present size & linked with india, modi would have thought twice about annexing kashmir. If Generals can employ Indians at their pizza company, why can't Pakistani businessmen interact with Indian counterparts
“The project of corporate globalization has cracked the code of democracy. Free elections, a free press and an independent judiciary mean little when the free market has reduced them to commodities on sale to the highest bidder.”
I as an Afghan always try telling my pakistani friends about what their army generals are doing to my country for the sake of their power and politics but they won't listen to a word I say and start assuming that I am a hater or a "namak haram". The bitter truth is that the pakistani establishment is ruining the lives of those who won't get tired defending them blindly and unlimited. Pakistanis need to understand that no organization is sacred and if given a free hand and supported blindly these organizations can put your lives and future at stake.
Great
@@JK-cn6gf Namak haram are not All afghans but these people don't talk against Army but they talk against Punjab people and races of Pakistan and against Pakistan. Army is not Pakistan, likewise, we're a state and Army is part of state but not state itself. Afghans says "lar ao bar yao Afghanistan" these slogans are in no way in our interest. These are sponsored by India to divide Pakistan on racism and to conspire against two nation theory. U can say whatever to Army but not our country. We're not your enemies, why u people are against people.
@@IrfanKhan-resistance They blame people of Pakistan specially Punjab but they will never blame Soviets, Nato , US
(actual invade) and Afghan warlords
Very briefly explain the past 70 year
keep posting
At last, Sir you realize that establishment is the key figure who doesn't want this country to grow.. they are acting like feudals but in a modern way...I fully agree with you Sir.. God bless you, may the people of Pakistan could be educated so they should think more realistically and keep a side all the emotional national anthems which meant to make them fools....
Proud of Establishment
Sir , I am lieutenant, currently posted in karachi. I totally agree with you.
LOVE YOU 🧡 SIR U ARE GREAT
Ap idareu mein hotey hoey uske draw backs bta rhe Hein ye rare hota he Kia aur bhi ap ke fellows ap se agree krte Hein?
Mein sbhi army ko uske role ki waja se hate krta tha BUT U HAVE CHANGED MY PERCEPTION
Thanks
Hope one day u become Army chief and Change this corrupt system of Feudal generals. Rule of Law and honesty, loyalty of the soldier to the nation is the first priority. No dignified soldier who breeds on nation's tax can't try to control n enslave nation. Standing with constitution and Considering Prime Minister as the final authority, everyone is under P.M and Pakistan's interest is in strong, Independent Prime minister.
@@variety-the-spice there are many more but they don't openly talk about it.
@@IrfanKhan-resistance thankyou
Finally some one spoke up, Pakistanis needs 100 people like you and world will see what they'll do with MUQADAS GAYE.
All the PAPA JOHN'S and New Zealanders will not find a place to hide inshAllah
Love you sir stay blessed ❤️
SIR slute you ALLAH apko khush rakhen apke lieay hamesha duaen hen ap jesy hzaron lakhon zehen mulk sy bahir bethy hen or yehi hmary mon pe bht bra tmacha hy thats it .
Waiting for a long time❤❤❤
Kamal ho gaya sir g. Allah ap lambi umer day. Ameen Ap nay meri soch ko words deya shukriya.
عاشر صاحب کم از کم 100 سے اوپر قسطیں بنیں گی۔۔۔۔۔
This is what happened with Imran khan today, thanks sir for so much valuable information about system.
"if they want to do they can" I also have this gut feeling but people here mix it up with "Shaheed ki jo mout ha wo qoum ki hayat ha" 😐 kdr sir Mary bnda ja k 😪
Very impactful. Pl keep sharing your valuable experience with us. We as a nation have been deprived of from every basic thing. We need an eternal solution.
13:30 hamayun akhtar & haroon akhtar & jahangir tareen Nexus
Immensely brilliant analysis. Have no words how to appreciate your point of view. Salute to you
You nailed it Sir. The evil game of army establishment could be understand here. No offence but what the Pakistani army is planning for future ?
Very thorough and comprehensive analysis. Eye opener and mind Blowing. God Bless you.
Power never concedes. Establishment/Army has to be forcefully removed with the current structure, and execute punishments prescribed in the constitution to set a precedent. That is the only way.
true. As he mentioned previously there has to be a private force which can counter the shenanigans of Army!
Huge respect for you sir, I always find very few negative comments on your videos. Coz youthyaas never understand you are saying. Allah bless you. Keep educating us.
Sir, Please don't give prolong breaks between videos. We waiting anxiously to listen to you
Aashir Bhai, Allah aap ko apnay Hifz o Aman main rakhay. Aameen
Video complete hwi nahi aor comment ary "Jeety raho" "first viewer" , flana ty tamkana. Gal ty suno ena d.
Hahahha true .
Haha
Beta sub khuch sun kar hi reply Kya tha. Lekin app ki problem yeh ha k app abhi bohat chotay ho. Isi lye app ko sunne or samjhne men kafi der lag jati ha. Thoray Baray ho jao ga to galdi samjh Jaya karo ga. Mene sirf samjh ki baat ki ha. Ab is baat ko samjhne ka lye bhi app ko kafi time chahye ho ga....
True
Agreed 👍 with you sir, a great informative vlog and I think each and every Pakistani should watch this even the establishment.
Sir how do you like Chinese systems that has one party system that why decision come fast and they do rapid progress
because there is one party system in china, its government can do whatever it wants with Uyghurs muslims because there is no opposition.
Ghats basically civilian army, all.power.concemtrate don oen hand and no repurcursion for their actions, they know they will nwver lose the "election" people dont have choice, same party policy that will never change
دعا ہی کرسکتے ہیں اچھے کی امید اور بدترین کیلئے تیار رہناچاہیی ۔ اللہ تعالیٰ آپ سے راضی ہوں ۔👍🏻🌹
اسلام میں ہم سب کیلئے دونوجہانوں کی بھلائیاں ہیں ۔
اللہ تعالیٰ سیدھے راہ پہ چلائیں ہم کو ۔۔۔
sir . is there any contact medium your mail or else to share some thoughts?
Listening to this in May 2022 and realizing how true Sir Ashir's words are.
Am i the only one thinking this shit's going to end with a civil war? probably
so Shumali ilaqajat anyone?
shumali ilaqajat? wdym?
@@Eddymr12 haven't you heard? People (especially journalists) tend to go missing in Pakistan. And when they do appear out of thin air, their simple explanation usually is that had gone for a random out of the blue trip to Pakistan's beautiful and scenic Northern Areas (Shumali Ilaqajat in urdu) but we know where they've been right? Wink wink 😉😉
@@mmd2156 i get wym, but how does that relate to a civil war bro
@@Eddymr12 lol... you know what, ur absolutely right. It actually doesn't have much to do with a civil war.
I guess i put it in there because that's the reel running at the back of everyone's mind every time they think about being the dissenting voice, or screaming out "Viva la Revolucion"!!!
Bro this country has been flipped on it's head infront of our very own eyes.
Watching actual journalists getting out casted like lepers! Why the mouthpieces are living it up.
And the most upsetting part is the fact that people around u are watching the very same thing yet they see a completely different story.
Like being in a hitchcock show, watching tv with a friend and yet both of u walk home having watched two completely different shows!
Let's see if u can make sense of that 😊
@@mmd2156 yes i can make sense of that bro You are really onto something man🔥🔥🔥
Love you sir. Jitna aap k lectures sa sikhnay ko milta ha utna 4 years university ma parh k ni mila tha. Stay blessed 🌹❤️🙏
This was all going well until 24mins then you change your stance and I can see only one thing from the following;
1, 5th Generation hybrid warfare
2, N- League pumping money
3, Old age problems
the country is going into ruins and gutter because pmln is pumping money and army men don't have power
I was very clear about what you said.. and the way you express its fabulous.. simply you telling you life experience and the love for the. green flag always shwon in your video.. so no body can give you label of agent or ghaddar..
Love you ashir..
i almost watch all you vlog .. from dhuwan to malik ... man you inspire people..
Imam mehdi will fix this issue. I mean it’s impossible to “control” power without greater power and we don’t want it to be done through an opposite-invasive power! No worries we’re almost there since the signs have almost showed up.... thinking positive!
Imam mehdi😂😅
This is just stupidity, neither jesus will come back nor mehdi. Once a person goes from the world he never come back. Give me just one example that someone came back to world. This is just insane. Koy mehdi koy nae ayga yeh sub kahanian hen.
@@IrfanKhan-resistance
👍👍
God bless you and your family 🙏 hallelujah God help us 🙏 God give you power 🙏 hallelujah God justice 🙏 hallelujah
جرنیل اور ان سے متصل لوگوں نے پاوں اس قدر مضبوطی سے جما لیئے ھے کہ شاہد اب یہاں بغیر کسی انقلاب کے اس شکنجے سے ملک کو نہیں چھوڑیا جا سکتا۔
آپ لوگوں کو وہ ادراک دے رہے ھے جو انسان میں جبلی طور پے تو موجود ھوتا ھے لیکن پاکستان میں رہنے والوں سے شاہد یہ جبلت چھین کر یہ بات با آور کرا دی گئی ھے کہ پاکستان ہمیشہ ایک خطرے سے دوچار ھے جس کا حل صرف جرنیلی حکمرانی ھے۔
رب العالمين آپ کو سلامت رکھے، آمین
Behtareen.
Looking vry handsome nd cute at the same time how do u do that😏😎😋
Excellent.. Well explained and to the point. Salute to you sir. We need people like you in Pakistan. May Allah give courage to people of Pakistan IA
God bless you.sir
These True words must be written on gold......
We need people like u in politics, u must come to Pakistan and should make ur own political party and this is the solution..,.
No doubt you are speaking truthful, it's harsh reality meri marhoma dadi Allah usko jannat main jaga de, river chenaab ki dosri traf District Muzaffar Garh ky aik village main army exercises krnay ati thi logon ki faslon main deray jama lenay, agr kisi ko army walay martay kisi chori ky shak main tu pora village usko shakhs ko achoot bana deta, meri dadi hamain lassi ky jug,makhan or rotiyan diti ghee main chopri hoi or kehti ja meray beton ko de kr ajao. Aj main young aqal or baligh insan hon harsh reality dekh Kr dukh hota hay or afsos hota hay.
Us waqt dhuwan drama ata tha apko dekh Kr hum baray howay hn. Establishment ko mazboot bananay walay ap log hn. Aj yeah itni taqatwar hay awaam ka kachumar nikal kr bhe awaam ko hi galiyan detay hn. Dhoka,fraib or businesses Allah ki amaan. Border ki traf munh krnay ka kaha yeah buhat genious hn yeah kehtay hn hum border bhe mehfooz bana lain gy or mulki internal matters bhe hum hi sanbhal lain gy. Qom ki izzat or kashmir aj bhe cheekh cheekh Kr dhuai de rha hay 70 saal say. I am sure agr hamari foj sirf borders py rehti or war exercises itni krti or dushman ky munh sy kashmir na ata yeah mumkin nahi tha.
what a great analysis. Love you sir
He is absolutely Right
یہ وطن ہے باجے والوں اور پیزا والوں کا عوام ہیں غلام ان کے
Love your opinion about establishment misuse of power and responsibility. Keep posting these videos. Lots of Pakistanis needs to be awaken from their military romance. We need a real change. Period.
سر جہاں تک میری انفارمیشن ہے دنیا میں جتنے بھی contry ہے اسٹیبلشمنٹ کے بغیر نہیں چل سکتی یہ میری اپنی رائے ہیں
Totally agree but they do have demarcated separation of power
Yes. Totally agree.
Great analytical analysis : Entanglement of state & saith .
Love to listen to your videos. Keep enlightening people.
Out standing effort