I've talked to a couple audio engineers about Pink Floyd. I've said the same thing. Their music sounds so timeless. It doesn't have your typical 70s or 80s production standards stamped all over it, at least best I can tell.
My mom used to play it at guitar... it reminds me childhood... without my father... My mom was alone to raise us... and she played guitar a lot... It is a nice souvenir anyway
Alejandro Guerra agreed strongly. If you’re looking for good modern music, I wouldn’t go on the radio. There are plenty of great artists nowadays that don’t have the spotlight unfortunately.
@@koltukdegnegi2952 technically it's neither. Roger came up with the song, but a session classical guitarist is responsible for writing the fingerpicked guitar section of the song.
I am 69 and not hardly does a day go by I don't listen to Pink Floyd and Frequently Requested by my Children, Grandchildren, and Great Grandchildren. No Generation Gap when it comes to Pink Floyd. There music is timeless and ageless
I'm so sorry, please take my sympathy. Whe my Dad died in 2002 we played "shine on you crazy diamond" at his adoption. And nearly everyone was touched.
Wow, Martin. As poignant as it gets. RIP to your Mom. Great tribute that I wish I could’ve heard. I’m a fingerstylist myself (HD-35) and have been working on it for a few days. As it’s now taking good form, it is choking me up as I play it. Special period in my life - Frosh year in college.
This has always been my favorite piece of acoustic. Out of all the typical songs like "stairway to heaven" that all players have learned at some point, I'm amazed to find that no one has thought to learn this one. It is very moving. Absolutely amazing. Maybe I can be someone who will be able to play it : )
Do it, Brenda! It’ll not the most difficult to get the arpeggios down especially if you have some fingerstyle background. But playing it with the right dynamics and emotion is what makes so special. Gilmore didn’t like how he was playing it during recording so they brought in Joe DiBlasi (LA session legend) to nail in on a classical guitar. Sounds great on any (steel) 6-string imo. JerrysGuitarBar has a note-for-note tab. He’s great, btw.
Absolutely. I started playing this at a backyard campfire thingy. Buddy says “oh this one! I know tons of people who do this…” When i finished, he went “Whoaaa, dooood!!!” I said “i thought you knew tons who did this?” He said, “ohh yaaah, but never like this, never with such feeling and emotion!!!” A very honourable yet proud moment for me… 🤗 🎸 🔥 (Sorry no acoustic guitar emojee 😤🤷🏻♂️ )
Absolutely. I started playing this at a backyard campfire thingy. Buddy says “oh this one! I know tons of people who do this…” When i finished, he went “Whoaaa, dooood!!!” I said “i thought you knew tons who did this?” He said, “ohh yaaah, but never like this, never with such feeling and emotion!!!” A very honourable yet proud moment for me… 🤗 🎸 🔥 (Sorry no acoustic guitar emojee 😤🤷🏻♂️ ) Sorry if this is repeated, pretty good guitarist, but not so good on social media buttons 🤷🏻♂️🙃
David didn't write this guitar part, Pink Floyd didn't know what to do with this piece and eventually brought in a studio musician who came out with this mesmerising guitar part.
I don't know if it's only me, but I've heard a lot of music in my short life, and I think The Wall is one of the best albums of rock music ever made, at least top five if not the best.
This is the song that got me into Pink Floyd and still is my favourite My father used to play this on guitar a lot and I would always listen to this song when he played
Is There Anybody Out There? Is There Anybody Out There? Is There Anybody Out There? Is There Anybody Out There? Incredible Pink Floyd!!!! This song,according to me is one of the saddest pink floyd songs.....it makes me cry everytime I listen to................few words I can write......THANK YOU PINK FLOYD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This peace has entranced me since the first time I heard it 20 years ago. I started playing guitar so I could play this. Its haunting and just plain beautiful
This music is a pure wonder, it's beautiful, there is no denying it ; nostalgic, a bit sad, i LOVE it. It one of my favorite. In fact... it's so wonderful that i would have deserved to be much looonger ! (I always have the impression they are 2 to play :-))
Go learn to play it hope your a solid fingerpicker with experience alternate string thumb picking and shifting all the the fingers thumb up or down a string at will then yes its easy 🤪
Hello, I saw the film "the Wall", I was may be 13-14 years old.. That was a revelation for me and I started to play guitar 6 month later.. Thank you so much Pink Floyd.. Ma-téo I have 51 now 😢
The best part about this is that David didn’t play this on the album- he could never get it right but here he is playing it live and did a damn fine job at it. Shows his determination
You know, since Pink Floyd isn't going to be releasing anymore new music and they keep on re-releasing The Wall movie, you figure they could release a concert blu-ray of the original Floyd performing it live.
Pink floyd must of been my 20th or so concert i have ever been to and it is the ONLY one I went to sober.....(well maybe a valume or 2) but NOT drunk and I went to the concert called pulse and I was on the floor 4th row back...I swear I had died and gone to heaven...they are the only band I have ever heard live that sounds like they do on cd...exactly....I wanted to be in a lounge chair and just kick back...the best concert in the world...would pay a shitload of money to see them again!
Pink Floyd.. for me is the only band that truly transcends all time and space... if there is higher dementions.. this is the type of music that resides there
PRAISE KING JESUS BEAUTIFUL JUST SO Brief IS THERE ANY BODY OUT THERE THAT HEARS MY PRAYERS OH YES I WILL NEVER LEAVE YOU NOR FORSAKE YOU THANKS A MILLION KING JESUS ❤
Wow, I was 1 year 25 days old when they gave this concert. This album is the only music album I don't listen because I am scared of losing my mind. Absolute greatness..
I remember reading somewhere that who actually performed it on the album is unknown, as Gilmour was unsatisfied with his take on it, cool to see that he eventually performed it live!
pause at exactly 1:30 when the big camera flash happens...just keep clicking pause and play in short quick "pulses", and you will be able to see the whole wall light up before your eyes!
I want to see Roger doing the Wall someday. I will be looking forward to and at the same time dreading the time this song comes on, because how it moves me and creeps me out at the same time. One of the best songs on the Wall for sure....as well as one of the absolute best the Floyd has done.
i had this wholeee album on my ipod from my aunts BF, (he had the live version of it :):)) then i had to sync my ipod with a new computer and o how i miss that album.. wonderful piece of work that makes you think and think..
me too. i was falling asleep and i was listenening to this album for the first time. i fell asleep and when i woke up i still had my ipod on. this song came on and i was trippin. i was like "What the fuck??". then the guitar kicked in and i was like "OHHH....hehe"
What the fuck are you talking about. The show was never performed in Glasglow and never in the month of May. They never did an encore in this show either.
floyd were on tour with roger at this point,if you know what i mean roger is the pinkfloyd,he wrote almost all of the lyrics himself, most of the music was roger too. comfortably numb was meant to be on david gilmours solo album but they were out of time, so he put it forward to roger who obviously thought that it would fit into the wall a treat,
this gave me chills down my spine! i watched it with no lights on. soo yaa i'm afrid to move! knowing(or guessing) my house is hounted! i'm pirtty sure it is soo yaa!
Fun fact - on the album version of this song, the acoustic part was not played by Gilmour. It seems he was not happy with his final recording, so they hired a session player for the same.
one of my favorite pieces off one of my all-time favorite albums. Love the background vocals kicking in at 2:20. I remembered reading years ago that the version that made it to the album was played (maybe-?) by the co-producer Bob Erzin ; that Gilmour got very frustrated trying to get it 'just right' in the studio and finally gave up. Don't know how true that is...
Very true, gave album credit to the session player they brought in although they mis-remembered his first name. Joe DiBlasi - LA session legend. And how about the violin at 2:30ish? 3 notes? Wow.
Within the first forty seconds of this video, Roger’s question was answered. “Is there anybody out there?” The audience cheers in adulation. Yes, we are here! Roger: never listened.🙏🏼🇺🇸
I've talked to a couple audio engineers about Pink Floyd. I've said the same thing. Their music sounds so timeless. It doesn't have your typical 70s or 80s production standards stamped all over it, at least best I can tell.
Agree.
I couldn't tell that this album was made in the 70's i couldn't even guess
My mom used to play it at guitar... it reminds me childhood... without my father...
My mom was alone to raise us... and she played guitar a lot...
It is a nice souvenir anyway
she knew good test of music
Gilmour is simply amazing in this...with just a few notes on an acoustic he weaves a beautiful song...why can't music today be this stunning?
two words: record companies
because it's not on the radio... go to spottify
Alejandro Guerra agreed strongly. If you’re looking for good modern music, I wouldn’t go on the radio. There are plenty of great artists nowadays that don’t have the spotlight unfortunately.
It’s not Gilmour’s song.Roger made this masterpiece
@@koltukdegnegi2952 technically it's neither. Roger came up with the song, but a session classical guitarist is responsible for writing the fingerpicked guitar section of the song.
No one could ever begin to convince me that Pink Floyd wasn't the best band that ever was.
He didnt compose it
I am 69 and not hardly does a day go by I don't listen to Pink Floyd and Frequently Requested by my Children, Grandchildren, and Great Grandchildren.
No Generation Gap when it comes to Pink Floyd. There music is timeless and ageless
69 lol
69 nice
How TF you have great grandchildren at 69
ABSOFUCKINGLUTLY!. BLESS U ALL
still alive? 2020?
This is one of my favorite solos ever
this song used to scare the hell out of me when I was a kid...I always pictured someone wandering around in the pitch black after the end of the world
😂
Hey you scared me as a kid.
Ten years later the world has ended
@@synthhero1347
Is there anybody.....out there....🥺
@@manifestgtr damn you came back 10 years later
I played this song at my moms Rosary on my Martin D41. Brought a lot of my family to tears as I played for her one last time :(
I'm so sorry, please take my sympathy.
Whe my Dad died in 2002 we played "shine on you crazy diamond" at his adoption. And nearly everyone was touched.
Wow, Martin. As poignant as it gets. RIP to your Mom. Great tribute that I wish I could’ve heard.
I’m a fingerstylist myself (HD-35) and have been working on it for a few days. As it’s now taking good form, it is choking me up as I play it. Special period in my life - Frosh year in college.
The greatest damn band to ever do any damn thing ....
Absolutely
This has always been my favorite piece of acoustic. Out of all the typical songs like "stairway to heaven" that all players have learned at some point, I'm amazed to find that no one has thought to learn this one. It is very moving. Absolutely amazing.
Maybe I can be someone who will be able to play it : )
Do it, Brenda! It’ll not the most difficult to get the arpeggios down especially if you have some fingerstyle background. But playing it with the right dynamics and emotion is what makes so special. Gilmore didn’t like how he was playing it during recording so they brought in Joe DiBlasi (LA session legend) to nail in on a classical guitar. Sounds great on any (steel) 6-string imo. JerrysGuitarBar has a note-for-note tab. He’s great, btw.
Am ascending -> descending -> C -> Em
Absolutely. I started playing this at a backyard campfire thingy. Buddy says “oh this one! I know tons of people who do this…”
When i finished, he went “Whoaaa, dooood!!!” I said “i thought you knew tons who did this?” He said, “ohh yaaah, but never like this, never with such feeling and emotion!!!”
A very honourable yet proud moment for me…
🤗
🎸 🔥
(Sorry no acoustic guitar emojee 😤🤷🏻♂️ )
Absolutely. I started playing this at a backyard campfire thingy. Buddy says “oh this one! I know tons of people who do this…”
When i finished, he went “Whoaaa, dooood!!!” I said “i thought you knew tons who did this?” He said, “ohh yaaah, but never like this, never with such feeling and emotion!!!”
A very honourable yet proud moment for me…
🤗
🎸 🔥
(Sorry no acoustic guitar emojee 😤🤷🏻♂️ )
Sorry if this is repeated, pretty good guitarist, but not so good on social media buttons 🤷🏻♂️🙃
The most relaxing music to attain serenity in our mind. Thank you Great David Gilmour.
David didn't write this guitar part, Pink Floyd didn't know what to do with this piece and eventually brought in a studio musician who came out with this mesmerising guitar part.
@@Kreative3DMedia ok ok
Thanks RUclips for preserving and spreading this for ten long years.
Make that 13!
@@rikusferreira2532 15 🙋♂️
@@MrHamsterworld SHEESH💥
I don't know if it's only me, but I've heard a lot of music in my short life, and I think The Wall is one of the best albums of rock music ever made, at least top five if not the best.
"Enter the exciting world of reading."
"It's fun"
Brilliant
This is the song that got me into Pink Floyd and still is my favourite
My father used to play this on guitar a lot and I would always listen to this song when he played
Is There Anybody Out There?
Is There Anybody Out There?
Is There Anybody Out There?
Is There Anybody Out There?
Incredible Pink Floyd!!!!
This song,according to me is one of the saddest pink floyd songs.....it makes me cry everytime I listen to................few words I can write......THANK YOU PINK FLOYD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This peace has entranced me since the first time I heard it 20 years ago. I started playing guitar so I could play this. Its haunting and just plain beautiful
i woke alone at 4:15am with this playing in my mind... now 5:00am I am quite enjoying this vid...thanx a ton
My favourite Pink Floyd song.Timeless
This music is a pure wonder, it's beautiful, there is no denying it ; nostalgic, a bit sad, i LOVE it. It one of my favorite.
In fact... it's so wonderful that i would have deserved to be much looonger !
(I always have the impression they are 2 to play :-))
3 chords and a relatively simple arpeggio. Get the tab, learn it! It's a fun song to play.
Easy to play
Get the tab... an acid one ;)
The hardest part of this song is my pinky finger hard to reach the thing
Go learn to play it hope your a solid fingerpicker with experience alternate string thumb picking and shifting all the the fingers thumb up or down a string at will then yes its easy 🤪
@@jacobfoley9430 this guy gets it
Hello, I saw the film "the Wall", I was may be 13-14 years old.. That was a revelation for me and I started to play guitar 6 month later.. Thank you so much Pink Floyd..
Ma-téo
I have 51 now 😢
Que BELLA melodia, tan corta y simple , es similar a cualquier pieza de musica clasica.
this song make my heart ache...Gilmour is simply beautiful on the acoustic
The best part about this is that David didn’t play this on the album- he could never get it right but here he is playing it live and did a damn fine job at it. Shows his determination
First I've heard of that. 🤔
Wow.... amazing. That guitar is enough to bring tears to anyones eyes.
It's a really fun song to play. I played it for my sister who has never heard the song before and she got goosebumps.
Timeless
this is my favorite song to play on my guitar. Its not really that hard but yet it is so fun and beautiful to play.
You know, since Pink Floyd isn't going to be releasing anymore new music and they keep on re-releasing The Wall movie, you figure they could release a concert blu-ray of the original Floyd performing it live.
@RobDoen ruclips.net/video/BwI1RmYaVB0/видео.html
I believe this is the most beautiful acoustic guitar work in music. It flows so well.
Pink floyd must of been my 20th or so concert i have ever been to and it is the ONLY one I went to sober.....(well maybe a valume or 2) but NOT drunk and I went to the concert called pulse and I was on the floor 4th row back...I swear I had died and gone to heaven...they are the only band I have ever heard live that sounds like they do on cd...exactly....I wanted to be in a lounge chair and just kick back...the best concert in the world...would pay a shitload of money to see them again!
Pink Floyd.. for me is the only band that truly transcends all time and space... if there is higher dementions.. this is the type of music that resides there
the beginning chills me to the bone!
PRAISE KING JESUS BEAUTIFUL JUST SO Brief IS THERE ANY BODY OUT THERE THAT HEARS MY PRAYERS OH YES I WILL NEVER LEAVE YOU NOR FORSAKE YOU THANKS A MILLION KING JESUS ❤
my favorite guitar piece on this album :D gives me chills every time i hear it
Totally agree - the Aussie Floyd are stunning. Was lucky to see their Wall Tour last year at the Albert Hall - truly brillant.
i'm 43 years old and this never get old.
Classically melodic and beautifully spacey. Right up there with High Hopes as two of their hidden gems.
I always thought this would be a perfect song to start off a concert
Wow, I was 1 year 25 days old when they gave this concert. This album is the only music album I don't listen because I am scared of losing my mind. Absolute greatness..
I remember reading somewhere that who actually performed it on the album is unknown, as Gilmour was unsatisfied with his take on it, cool to see that he eventually performed it live!
Me too
lonelyness....its very much out there and in there....but you must see it
RIght to my #COVID19 playlist
gives me the chills
this song is amazing! it was also in the movie "the wall". love this song!
Take me back in time. That's why I'm here
David canta ca DUMNEZEU!
Fie binecuvantat!
pause at exactly 1:30 when the big camera flash happens...just keep clicking pause and play in short quick "pulses", and you will be able to see the whole wall light up before your eyes!
You lucky bastard... I wish I could have seen Pink Floyd live... Would have been amazing! Now all I can hope for is a reunion tour.
Yeah man. Really uplifting. My musical and poetical hero. Nice one. Shared.
One hell of God knows .....sound ! I can ertainly voucher myself for O/Floyd enthusiastic fan !❤
This is a very beautiful yet very sad song.
Wish this was longer. Way too short for such a great song.
pink floyd is altijd goed geweest, artiesten uit het verleden die hebben waarde ik wou dat ik ze sprak.
Thank you, such great footage and beautiful audio..shine on
I love pink floyd ! esspecialy gilmour! wanna be like him..
this almost makes me cry. soooooooooooooo beautiful
I still think that this song is beautiful.
I want to see Roger doing the Wall someday. I will be looking forward to and at the same time dreading the time this song comes on, because how it moves me and creeps me out at the same time. One of the best songs on the Wall for sure....as well as one of the absolute best the Floyd has done.
40 years later, and he's still wondering if there's anybody out there.
The second song I learned to play. It thought me a lot.
Wow--very moving--nice touch with the background vocals kicking in at around 2:20. Thanks Domokon...
Still the best live show I ve ever seen
@john63van a hidden gem, indeed! one of my all-time favorites.
i had this wholeee album on my ipod from my aunts BF, (he had the live version of it :):)) then i had to sync my ipod with a new computer and o how i miss that album.. wonderful piece of work that makes you think and think..
me too. i was falling asleep and i was listenening to this album for the first time. i fell asleep and when i woke up i still had my ipod on. this song came on and i was trippin. i was like "What the fuck??". then the guitar kicked in and i was like "OHHH....hehe"
i saw the same concert on the 1st of may in glasgow, amazing, couldnt believe the encore they did as well, what a bonus
What the fuck are you talking about. The show was never performed in Glasglow and never in the month of May. They never did an encore in this show either.
Here in 2020, still epic as hell
shivers. everywhere.
Such a beautiful song.
Got a lots to say.....best not to say anything ! .... ...love it is all i can say !❤❤❤❤❤
just amazing i wanna play it now and put on youtube u can watch it
floyd were on tour with roger at this point,if you know what i mean
roger is the pinkfloyd,he wrote almost all of the lyrics himself, most of the music was roger too. comfortably numb was meant to be on david gilmours solo album but they were out of time, so he put it forward to roger who obviously thought that it would fit into the wall a treat,
love this song
Hermoza melodia
this gave me chills down my spine! i watched it with no lights on. soo yaa i'm afrid to move! knowing(or guessing) my house is hounted! i'm pirtty sure it is soo yaa!
My husband was in a coma for 14 yrs. I always felt that deep in his severely damaged brain, he would be asking this very question.
this melody is haunting
Super still, after all these years...
after hearing this version, I wonder if I can still play it. used to a lot, back in the day...
it gave me goosbumps
The name is ''s There Anybody Out There?-The Wall Live '80''
It is a DVD containing the concert of 1980 and it was published in 2000
So beautiful...
Fun fact - on the album version of this song, the acoustic part was not played by Gilmour. It seems he was not happy with his final recording, so they hired a session player for the same.
awesome song
i would love to be able to play the guitar like that, gilmour is the greatest, no contest
Genius!
Enter...there is my heart...come here...
Deep into our soul.......
that nostalgia
great of a great
Yeah, I hear a lot of good things about them. I would love tosee them!
one of my favorite pieces off one of my all-time favorite albums. Love the background vocals kicking in at 2:20. I remembered reading years ago that the version that made it to the album was played (maybe-?) by the co-producer Bob Erzin ; that Gilmour got very frustrated trying to get it 'just right' in the studio and finally gave up. Don't know how true that is...
Very true, gave album credit to the session player they brought in although they mis-remembered his first name. Joe DiBlasi - LA session legend.
And how about the violin at 2:30ish? 3 notes? Wow.
incredible, sound quality or otherwise...
perfect acoustic
yeah, but the guy who actually played it on the 'The Wall" record album gives it a pretty good shot too. cheers!
Es como estar en un sueño❤
the lights are realy cool :D
Fantastic PINK FLOYD!!!
Within the first forty seconds of this video, Roger’s question was answered. “Is there anybody out there?” The audience cheers in adulation. Yes, we are here! Roger: never listened.🙏🏼🇺🇸