I'm very proud to be the granddaughter of Irish emigrants....my parents were born in Brooklyn NY where my grandparents settled..one grandfather became an NYC firefighter, the other a NYC police officer....this story; however, was positively heartbreaking...💚☘️🗽🇺🇲🇮🇪
All those immigrants came to build a country. Nowadays democrat are importing people to destroy the economy. People who love to live from Welfare . Meanwhile punishing who make the county better.
My maternal great great grandparents went from ireland to new york and my grandfather and his wife settled in wilmington nc before having their 4 children, including my mom. My paternal great great great grandparents came from england and eventually made their way to texas and my great great grandpa was at the alamo before buying up alot of land in easterly texas which is sustaining my family to this day via oil ... My paternal grandmother also has a rich legacy in texas and through her, we became part of the daughters of the republic of texas. I love that my family kept track on s0 many sides of our heritage and that we still have the land that some of them walked on and were buried. ❤
@KatieMasada thank u for sharing...my 5 brothers n I are in the process of organizing dads military records n family history...I find it fascinating! My nephews n several brothers have been there n have been able to ascertain census records from those born in Ireland...I can't wait until we are finished with our " investigation"!
The 11 of the 14 Irish residents that left Ireland for America sadly perished on this doomed ship; but this documentary of the life story back in Ireland and in America is very beautiful !! Thanks so much for this wonderful documentary !! ❤️
This is heartbreaking. That's why people should leave the Titanic alone because it's a gravesite, not a tourist attraction or expedition. RIP Titanic passengers and Oceangate.
I agree with you. People should not be taking artefacts from it or going down to see it. It is a gravesite for 1,500 who never got a proper burial, in fact a gravesite now for 1505 after that submersible sinking. May they all Rest in Peace.
I agree visit titanic but don't build submersibles and charge folk exuberant amounts of money to visit titanic such as oceangate did ...., Stockton rush mentioned he was trying to preserve Titanic's memory by documentations of the wreck site this has already been done by the French nautile ship ... All oceangate was out for was greed n profit n to hell with passenger's safety.... Stockton rush was just blowing smoke in the faces of whoever this lying fool encounters 😢
And people don't visit gravesites on land??? This is a foolish notion. I'm onboard with saying that it shouldn't be made into tourist attraction or that you shouldn't be respectful, but there are a lot of answers to be found and mysteries surrounding Titanic. To make money out of it seems wrong, but what about other wrecks. Nobody cares about the sacrilige taking place there. If you have any decorum i don't see why visiting the Titanic would be morally wrong. Just show respect. That's all. Don't make light of it and yes, perhaps leaving artifacts down there is for the better. Enough is retrieved as it is now, so..... It's only good for us to see the real human tragedy and make us realise how we need to stop complaining about our First world problems, just like some First Class passengers did, sadly.
Thank you to whomever put this together and made this documentary! ❤ Thank you to the families of the survivors, and the families of lost loved ones.❤ I'll be heading to Ireland from America, Alabama, later this month, 9 days from today. When I get to Belfast, I shall remember the town and 14. I won't be able to recall all the names. But The LORD will know what's in my heart as He does whi.e I'm typing this. 3 of the 4 of my Grandparents are of Irish descendents. I finally visited last year, 2022. I'm going back to see the northern part of your country. Back in 1995, I visited Peggy's Cove, Nova Scotia and saw the v tributes there. I also visited Halifax and was lead to the graveyard for the victims of Titanic. I've love history and have always been fascinated about the story, event that changed Naval history. Of that I'm glad since I served in the US Navy upon a Navy ship. We had enough lifeboats. ❤❤ GOD BLESS 🙏❤🇺🇸
Extraordinary & impeccably shared story of the Titanic's maiden voyage! My maternal relatives came from Ireland @ 16 yrs of age. They all lived long, productive lives, with one of my Aunt's working for AT& T, where she was a telephone operator. ☎️ I loved hearing about her life & the lives of all my relatives. What courageous human beings they All were!
@@carlastewart6125 us Irish and Africans were treated very cruel but our people eventually broke away from slavery and intermarried together and lived together in peace there used to be signs in Business that said no Irish no black's no dog's I understand your pain it break's my heart God bless you and our ancestors
I feel bad for my people too! only they aren’t white with colored eyes. So they get discriminated They are also trying to come here for a better life leaving everything and risking their lives.
As a young boy I slept under a picture of Titanic sinking and bodies floating, my Grandmother told me about her sister Annie McGowan being on it and surviving, I walked with Annie to the church for her sisters funeral, I still have that picture in my home though the years have taken a toll on it!
The 1997 film makes it look like the majority of steerage passengers were Irish but this wasn't the case. There were 120 Irish in total on the Titanic. There were 165 Lebanese on board, of whom 123 died. Also there were almost as many Swedes, and half as many Finns, as Irish on board.
Not just those people, it isn't commonly known but there were also chinese and black passengers as well although there were only 2 chinese on board and 1 middle class black man
There were only 86 Lebanese onboard, but what's interesting about them was they had the highest percentage of women and children saved. There was a total of 32 Lebanese survivors, including 15 out of 24 women and 11 out of 13 children
The fact that they let the first and second class go first in the life boats is down right sickening everyone’s life should of been mattered that night
there were many reason why this happened; first and second class were closer to the deck; steward/stewardess had to wake up and pass along the message to each passenger, the upper crew had the information first; the corridors had many locked gates to keep steerage passengers from going to the first class, due to contamination reasons ( 3rd class was considered less hygenic), the ones that did find their way up to the deck were led by crew members with luck.
What an incredibly tragic group..they seemed so excited and eager, despite living through hard times, and must have been such an adventure and fun to all travel together, only to have it go so wrong and so many young lives lost.
This is just about the most powerful, most interesting and well done documentary I have ever watched. Thank you to everyone associated with it and God bless those who perished.
Being Irish American I was intrigued by this story. My great grandfather and his younger sister came in the 1890's as "unaccompanied minors" , having been recently orphaned.
I was in Lahardane last week while the Titan submersible was missing and visited the memorial site in the village. Grandparents birthplace and still have family at the foot of Nephin.
Absolutely loved this. I've seen titanic about 30 plus times. I cry every time. To see this perspective just adds another more real level to it. So sad yet beautiful to see the legacy those survivors left.
Another story from the Titanic. This time from Ireland☘. I didn't know that. This story was once forgotten, but thank you to the descendants👏🏼 to started embrace this legacy and every year making a ritual🕯 ceremony to commemorate their 14💚 ancestors. And I believe all 11 of them are in heaven🕊 by now. Thank you for sharing this great story🙏🏼
As an Irish American I absolutely fell in love with this documentary, I've always found reenactments like this to be a very powerful tool for teaching and storytelling. However there were some mistakes that as a historian on the White Star Line i really cringed at. Many documentaries exaggerated Titanic's place in history for dramatic and romantic effect. Titanic wasn't built for speed. White Star gave up on the Blue Riband after Teutonic and Majestic both won it 20 years earlier. White Star's improvements for Third Class spaces started WAY before Titanic. Here's the timeline: In the late 1870s, aboard the Oceanic class liners, as well as Britannic and Germanic, they started enclosing open berths into 20 berth dormitories. When Teutonic entered service in 1889, both she and Majestic introduced two berth and four berth cabins for married couples and families with children. In 1898 and 1899, Cymric and Oceanic featured smoke rooms, general rooms and updated dining areas with fitted tables and swivel chairs. In 1901, Celtic featured multiple large scale dining rooms in Third Class spaces as well as over 400 two-, four- and six-berth cabins available for both single men and women. Dormitory style cabins containing about 600 beths were located forward for single men but were only used when they were fully booked. Adriatic was the last to feature dormitory cabins. In 1909, Laurentic and Megantic were the first two offer all Third Class passengers cabin berths
James Cameron was so touched by the Irish immigrants he took special care to make their small role as accurate as possible in his movie. Look up the story of the woman who played the mama and how she learned the story she read the kids to sleep with while the boat sank. ❤
Yet another layer of this tragedy. The arrogance of the builders to ignore the tradition of christening the ship. The book of Psalms has prayers for those who go to sea because the ocean can go wild in a minute. I feel so sad that innocent people lost their lives because of human greed and pride. Thank you for posting this poignant story.
What I find so appealing about the surviving ladies is their modesty and quiet, unassuming dignity, especially compared to what we might see in the general population today. They suffered a catastrophe so profound as to be incomparable to any I can think of today except maybe 9/11. Just to have lost so many family members, but in such a violent and unexpected way would be traumatic beyond measure. That they suffered the equivalent of what is today called PTSD for years is undoubtable. And yet they didn't bare their souls and anguish in public as we're accustomed to seeing today, but quietly got on with their lives in the best way they could. And they really were successful as well. I have the feeling that the fact they got to experience as young adults what we call the Roaring 20's, with all its exuberance and vitality accompanied by bright, cheerful music I think may have been very therapeutic to them. These were their child-bearing years and all seem to have raised wonderful children who remembered being loved in return. I can also understand their reluctance to talk about the experience as well--as mentioned it caused them tremendous water associated phobias that last the rest of their lives.
I was looking for this documentary because I’m half Irish and I know for sure my ancestors came from that ship my grandfather’s grandmother was Irish and his grandfather was black they are from new york
This was a really interesting story that connects you to the people we seldom hear about as individuals people with names instead of just the “Irish immigrants in steerage”. What I didn’t like was the cut scenes with guys being interviewed and giving inaccurate information that is tailored to suit a narrative rather than the truth. It starts right around 28:00 if you want to see what I’m talking about. Those two guys, I presume “historians”, start right in on there being locked doors, chained and locked gates, blocked stairways and stewards waiting at every route of escape to keep 3rd class from getting up to the boat deck. The problem was just how complex the ship was to navigate and the fact 3rd class was the furthest away from the boat deck and when they were designing the ship they they didn’t really make it a priority to make access from 3rd class and crew / machinery spaces deep in the ship and the boat deck promenade a super fast, efficient route. They designed the stairways, corridors, ladders, etc around ventilating trunks, steam and water plumbing and other machinery and engineering spaces while also maximizing space for passengers and cargo in any way they could. Truthfully there were stewards helping lead third class passengers from the 3rd class lounge areas within the stern up and forward to the boat deck and getting them in line to get on an open seat in a boat. While first (and to a lesser extent second) class were surely given some advantages through the night, both intentional and not, there is no evidence that Titanic’s crew did anything to keep 3rd class passengers from getting up to or into the boats once they made it to them.
Rip ❤to all the people who lost Thier lives on titanic and ❤to all who survived . I'm glad they have never been forgotten and are always remembered with❤ love
Amazing document, I just saw the movie yesterday because last time I saw it I was 15 now iam 20 and I was smoking weed , bruh that was the most amazing movie with drama ever I love that highly recommend
So very sad the tragedy of the TITANIC so sad that the ship could have been built with bulkheads the full height of the ship’s deck however this wasn’t the case so many people lost because of greed over safety.
White Star Line never had any christening ceremony for their liners. It was a custom they have been following for years. It was not a show of arrogance. Not only Titanic, none of their steamers had a christening ceremony for their launch. The official names of the steamers were already displayed on a large board in front of the liners during their construction.
I couldn’t imagine being on a sinking ship, like the Titanic is absolutely terrifying. I actually wrote a song about the Titanic disaster. It’s featured on my album disaster of the Titanic and crazy world.
Okay... I don’t know why people keep saying Titanic was “unsinkable” nobody, absolutely nobody from White Star Line advertised it as “unsinkable” During the sea trials Captain Smith said “she’s practically unsinkable.” But nowhere in print did White Star Line say “unsinkable.”
Actually it was advertised by the White Star Line as unsinkable, something they denied later in court, along with how the ship couldn't possibly have broken in half and every survivor was lying. BUT thousands of Flyers posted all around London and even distributed with certain newspapers promised the Titanic to be "a one-of-a-kind Ship of Dreams; The largest, most luxurious ship in the world, and the safest; guaranteed unsinkable." Then after it sank right away, The White Star line lead a huge smear campaign against printing presses for 'taking liberties', as if they hadn't ordered those flyers themselves. In truth, being massive and unsinkable were literally the selling points the Titanic was famous for before the ship was even completed. James Cameron actually owns some of those original flyers, and If you watch the making of Titanic the movie, they'll show you that these flyers were scattered all over the ground and pavement where passengers were boarding. It was a slogan repeated in the ship yards where the shipwrights would journal that they were building "a masterpiece that would sail forever", and there are many hand written letters to America from people who perished that have been donated to the museums saying things like they 'would soon be onboard the grandest ship in the world. It can't sink, so don't worry about me.' Local gossip over tea time called the ship 'unsinkable', so much so that the public convinced itself of this new reality the same way that the public does today with things that gain global anticipation and excitement, only to end up being a huge disappointment, like the 'most spectacular final season' of Game of Thrones. Noah Brandt worked on the Southampton docks and wrote to his sister that "Everyone says it can't be sunk. I'm eager to be joining her crew in just a few voyages." Then, after it did sink, the New York post and London papers printed that "the unsinkable has sank". So Idk how you got the impression that no one called the ship unsinkable, but many ships sank back then killing hundreds of people, but only the Titanic gained so much fame, because it was viewed as a reminder from God to stay humble and never think ourselves infallible.
I am planning to write my own Titanic Story about these two ten year old cousins who sailed on the Titanic and Survived the nightmare of the shipwreck with their own courage and witts and their broken friendship but with great cost obviously meaning their families from their parents and older siblings did not survive and the sinking of the Titanic brings the two cousins relationship more closer and helps them reconcile and everyone who had actually sailed on The Titanic plays a part in the cousins story from Captain Smith Bruce Ismay Thomas Andrews Benjamin Gutinhiem and his Italian butler and his mistress and John Jacob Aster and Maddlin Aster and Molly Brown and Mr and Miss Strous and Wallace Hartley and the rest of the band even the Officers from William Murdoch James Moody and Henry Wild and even Charles Lightoller.
5:40 to 6:30 This is why I personally feel that LIFE's nature is that of a burden and not a blessing. Giving birth to someone is like giving a life full of struggles wrapped in a gift box. And feeling happy about it. So many people's lives are spent in poverty, tough labor and poor lifestyle, and low nutrition because of factors they couldn't control. The laws, the economy, and the general joblessness because of Ireland's geography and history.
The sad part is , even if there were enough lifeboats , many still would have died .The reason is , that The Titanic sank too fast to load over a thousand people , into the lifeboats .
Pay attention!...It was also shown in another documentary/interpreted movie...Cpt Smith opted his priorities to attend 11am Catholic Mass than to conduct the "fire drill/abort ship" drill to the passengers n crew! He'd known then, "something wrong" bout to occur.
Some details are misleading.. Titanic was not the first ship to be thought unsinkable. Olympic and Titanic together were considered "practically unsinkable" due to their new water tight door design. Though White Star never really declared their steamers unsinkable it was the journal Shipbuilder which first wrote about the safety features of the new mammoth liners. When the Olympic survived the collision with HMS Hawke it became a reality in the public minds that these liners would never sink.
Olympic construction started in December 1908 Titanic construction started in early 1909 and it was not the fastest ship and was launched in 1910 not 1911.....too many mistakes here
I hope white star lines got sued for being so negligent!!!!! Who gives them right to decide who lives and dies????? There is a special place in hell for such people!!!!!
Also to give $25 that's just over $700 in today's money. You could kida equate it to let's say for example you slipped on the floor at Walmart and had to go to the hospital and all you got from Walmart was oh we're sorry here is $700... um.. excuse me..
Titanic the Shocking Truth by Andrew Newton is food for thought states that the the Titanic was swapped with her sister ship Olympic which was in several accidents and deemed unseaworthy .
My family is from the South..Cork mostly. One side is from the North. Derry but also going way back grandfathers side was on the NW coast. You know I began reading and researching, just digging and searching finding out things that was so painful, things I felt I wish I hadn’t have learned. Not sure what to do with the anger or pain often, now I do ask for the truth is all. Don’t we all deserve the truth, teaching kids history that is made up stories is not ok. Anywho with all the research and talking with family about our family..old stories and all…I realized that our families went through so much they didn’t talk about it much or at all, afraid to talk, there’s generational trauma, there’s staying quiet bc God forbid one poked the bear ya know what that means. Still to this day there’s issues with this because well a certain country has claim to land, it’s bordered off but in Ireland, there Is discrimination still it’s just sad really. The last part of our country that is colonized still..it’s been oh like 900 plus years of that. Staying silent was Survival and then the generations to follow just didn’t know what was never spoken. I am proud to speak of the truth of our people and land, it’s quite healing, we talk openly of slavery, the killing and starvation that was and is genocide, those who fled and so on, it’s freeing to my soul and to family legacy, Irish legacy to be a voice for what’s true and righteous, the pain is there but what’s bigger is the love and gratitude we have, we come from immense strength, we are strong people..we are connected to our kin to the land to the ways..To think I’m alive because of who survived and kept going, no matter what. I am so grateful. ✨
You're a Yank! Drop the historical victimhood unless you have been a victim yourself. "generational trauma"....grow up Karen! I'm English and have more Irish blood in my little toe than you have in your entire body and I'm not bleating about things that happened hundreds of years ago. You might want to look a bit closer to home if you're appointing blame for abuses against native populations. Repeat after me: I am American, NOT Irish! :D
An immigrant is a person who comes to a foreign land (foreign to the immigrant), an emigrant is a person who leaves a place where he/she used to live. Now, considering that the documentary deals with Irish people leaving Ireland to emigrate to the United States (but most of them sadly don't make it) they are emigrants.
What a heart breaking story from such a small town. God bless all that lost their life's aboard the Titanic.
I know very heartbreaking but interesting to learn about
If those who died knew & followed Jesus they are happy with Him as I write
😢❤❤❤
Heartbreaking and heartwarming. Sweet and bittersweet. Very insightful. RIP those who's dream never came to pass.
I'm very proud to be the granddaughter of Irish emigrants....my parents were born in Brooklyn NY where my grandparents settled..one grandfather became an NYC firefighter, the other a NYC police officer....this story; however, was positively heartbreaking...💚☘️🗽🇺🇲🇮🇪
All those immigrants came to build a country. Nowadays democrat are importing people to destroy the economy. People who love to live from Welfare . Meanwhile punishing who make the county better.
What a great legacy for your family ! Certainly very proud !!!
My grandparents on my dad's side went to new York from Ireland to that's where my father was Born also
My maternal great great grandparents went from ireland to new york and my grandfather and his wife settled in wilmington nc before having their 4 children, including my mom.
My paternal great great great grandparents came from england and eventually made their way to texas and my great great grandpa was at the alamo before buying up alot of land in easterly texas which is sustaining my family to this day via oil ...
My paternal grandmother also has a rich legacy in texas and through her, we became part of the daughters of the republic of texas.
I love that my family kept track on s0 many sides of our heritage and that we still have the land that some of them walked on and were buried. ❤
@KatieMasada thank u for sharing...my 5 brothers n I are in the process of organizing dads military records n family history...I find it fascinating! My nephews n several brothers have been there n have been able to ascertain census records from those born in Ireland...I can't wait until we are finished with our " investigation"!
Had a great uncle die on Titanic. He was a waiter in one of the restaurants.
Wonderful documentary. It's great what their ancestors are doing.May God be with them always.
The 11 of the 14 Irish residents that left Ireland for America sadly perished on this doomed ship; but this documentary of the life story back in Ireland and in America is very beautiful !! Thanks so much for this wonderful documentary !! ❤️
You're very weclome!
They were called the Adergoole 14.
This is heartbreaking. That's why people should leave the Titanic alone because it's a gravesite, not a tourist attraction or expedition. RIP Titanic passengers and Oceangate.
I agree with you. People should not be taking artefacts from it or going down to see it. It is a gravesite for 1,500 who never got a proper burial, in fact a gravesite now for 1505 after that submersible sinking. May they all Rest in Peace.
I agree visit titanic but don't build submersibles and charge folk exuberant amounts of money to visit titanic such as oceangate did ...., Stockton rush mentioned he was trying to preserve Titanic's memory by documentations of the wreck site this has already been done by the French nautile ship ... All oceangate was out for was greed n profit n to hell with passenger's safety.... Stockton rush was just blowing smoke in the faces of whoever this lying fool encounters 😢
And people don't visit gravesites on land??? This is a foolish notion. I'm onboard with saying that it shouldn't be made into tourist attraction or that you shouldn't be respectful, but there are a lot of answers to be found and mysteries surrounding Titanic. To make money out of it seems wrong, but what about other wrecks. Nobody cares about the sacrilige taking place there.
If you have any decorum i don't see why visiting the Titanic would be morally wrong. Just show respect. That's all. Don't make light of it and yes, perhaps leaving artifacts down there is for the better. Enough is retrieved as it is now, so.....
It's only good for us to see the real human tragedy and make us realise how we need to stop complaining about our First world problems, just like some First Class passengers did, sadly.
Theres no bodies there,,Its more like the scene of an accident
Thank you to whomever put this together and made this documentary! ❤ Thank you to the families of the survivors, and the families of lost loved ones.❤ I'll be heading to Ireland from America, Alabama, later this month, 9 days from today. When I get to Belfast, I shall remember the town and 14. I won't be able to recall all the names. But The LORD will know what's in my heart as He does whi.e I'm typing this. 3 of the 4 of my Grandparents are of Irish descendents. I finally visited last year, 2022. I'm going back to see the northern part of your country. Back in 1995, I visited Peggy's Cove, Nova Scotia and saw the v tributes there. I also visited Halifax and was lead to the graveyard for the victims of Titanic. I've love history and have always been fascinated about the story, event that changed Naval history. Of that I'm glad since I served in the US Navy upon a Navy ship. We had enough lifeboats. ❤❤ GOD BLESS 🙏❤🇺🇸
Extraordinary & impeccably shared story of the Titanic's maiden voyage! My maternal relatives came from Ireland @ 16 yrs of age. They all lived long, productive lives, with one of my Aunt's working for AT& T, where she was a telephone operator. ☎️ I loved hearing about her life & the lives of all my relatives. What courageous human beings they All were!
As an Irishman this breaks my heart my heart 💔 goes out to my people ☘️🙏🇮🇪🚢.
@@carlastewart6125 us Irish and Africans were treated very cruel but our people eventually broke away from slavery and intermarried together and lived together in peace there used to be signs in Business that said no Irish no black's no dog's I understand your pain it break's my heart God bless you and our ancestors
I feel bad for my people too! only they aren’t white with colored eyes. So they get discriminated They are also trying to come here for a better life leaving everything and risking their lives.
@@LVQuinn83 চয়ন
@@AH23323 ডহববকনম
চয়ন
As a young boy I slept under a picture of Titanic sinking and bodies floating, my Grandmother told me about her sister Annie McGowan being on it and surviving, I walked with Annie to the church for her sisters funeral, I still have that picture in my home though the years have taken a toll on it!
One of her daughters looks a lot like Marilyn Monroe. The surviving stories were nice to hear.
Titanic, a legend that refuses to end
A true legend never dies.
The 1997 film makes it look like the majority of steerage passengers were Irish but this wasn't the case. There were 120 Irish in total on the Titanic. There were 165 Lebanese on board, of whom 123 died. Also there were almost as many Swedes, and half as many Finns, as Irish on board.
Not just those people, it isn't commonly known but there were also chinese and black passengers as well although there were only 2 chinese on board and 1 middle class black man
I'm quite sure there are probably documentaries about those from other countries....this happens to be about the Irish...
Rip. God bless their families
There were only 86 Lebanese onboard, but what's interesting about them was they had the highest percentage of women and children saved. There was a total of 32 Lebanese survivors, including 15 out of 24 women and 11 out of 13 children
@@pedroguerrero3862 there were 8 Chinese passengers.
Each and every soul on Titanic has a story, unfortunately we will never know everyone’s story. May they Rest In Peace 😢
The fact that they let the first and second class go first in the life boats is down right sickening everyone’s life should of been mattered that night
there were many reason why this happened; first and second class were closer to the deck; steward/stewardess had to wake up and pass along the message to each passenger, the upper crew had the information first; the corridors had many locked gates to keep steerage passengers from going to the first class, due to contamination reasons ( 3rd class was considered less hygenic), the ones that did find their way up to the deck were led by crew members with luck.
@@Mia-ly7os There were no gates between classes below deck.
It was also a different time period.
Twr ttt3t
The life boats were made for first and second class. The company wasn’t concerned with saving the folks in steerage.
What an incredibly tragic group..they seemed so excited and eager, despite living through hard times, and must have been such an adventure and fun to all travel together, only to have it go so wrong and so many young lives lost.
This is just about the most powerful, most interesting and well done documentary I have ever watched. Thank you to everyone associated with it and God bless those who perished.
Y 9 ooh thru 68
Being Irish American I was intrigued by this story. My great grandfather and his younger sister came in the 1890's as "unaccompanied minors" , having been recently orphaned.
This made me weep. I feel for those poor souls. May they rest in peace. Love ❤️💐
I am from Belgium. 27 Belgians were on the titanic only 7 survived.
@@s5mphone701 Do you really think you are funny?
@@eviken1982 well im happy I can laugh about all the drama I encountered there
Not all from the same city. That’s the point of this story.
I would like to hear their story
If possible can you go to @HistoricTravels RUclips Channel and ask him to look into your story.
I was in Lahardane last week while the Titan submersible was missing and visited the memorial site in the village. Grandparents birthplace and still have family at the foot of Nephin.
Absolutely loved this. I've seen titanic about 30 plus times. I cry every time. To see this perspective just adds another more real level to it. So sad yet beautiful to see the legacy those survivors left.
This is a very powerful story from the few that was saved on the Titanic in a little town in Ireland. ❤️
When one believes that they are invincible causes a mindset that is hard to comprehend!
Another story from the Titanic. This time from Ireland☘. I didn't know that. This story was once forgotten, but thank you to the descendants👏🏼 to started embrace this legacy and every year making a ritual🕯 ceremony to commemorate their 14💚 ancestors. And I believe all 11 of them are in heaven🕊 by now. Thank you for sharing this great story🙏🏼
I need to get a DNA test.
This story should be huge.
I’m a grown man but had tears more than once.
It’s the Canavan story
What a beautiful documentary. And to read all the related comments, hair raising stuff.
My grandfather's family is from Belfast Ireland. So this really hits home for me.
why? Belfast is a city in the UK, this documentary is about peasants in the republic of Ireland, different people
@@ajrwilde14 There are poor Irish folks on both sides of the border, and, in 1912, all Ireland was a part of the UK.
@@ajrwilde14 Sigh, idiot. Northern Ireland didn't exist then, all of Ireland was united.
As an Irish American I absolutely fell in love with this documentary, I've always found reenactments like this to be a very powerful tool for teaching and storytelling.
However there were some mistakes that as a historian on the White Star Line i really cringed at. Many documentaries exaggerated Titanic's place in history for dramatic and romantic effect.
Titanic wasn't built for speed. White Star gave up on the Blue Riband after Teutonic and Majestic both won it 20 years earlier.
White Star's improvements for Third Class spaces started WAY before Titanic. Here's the timeline:
In the late 1870s, aboard the Oceanic class liners, as well as Britannic and Germanic, they started enclosing open berths into 20 berth dormitories.
When Teutonic entered service in 1889, both she and Majestic introduced two berth and four berth cabins for married couples and families with children.
In 1898 and 1899, Cymric and Oceanic featured smoke rooms, general rooms and updated dining areas with fitted tables and swivel chairs.
In 1901, Celtic featured multiple large scale dining rooms in Third Class spaces as well as over 400 two-, four- and six-berth cabins available for both single men and women. Dormitory style cabins containing about 600 beths were located forward for single men but were only used when they were fully booked. Adriatic was the last to feature dormitory cabins.
In 1909, Laurentic and Megantic were the first two offer all Third Class passengers cabin berths
It was more than 100 years ago, we’ve had two world wars since then, and we hear more about the Titanic.
For some odd reason this is relaxing to watch
I can’t imagine the idea of leaving home knowing full well that I might never see my family or friends again. So sad.
@bethanycousineau197 . That is why it was called An American Wake.
Aww so tragic lovely young boys and girls from addergoole Ireland Resting in peace. 😢😢 ❤❤❤
I get the term American wake now thank you
James Cameron was so touched by the Irish immigrants he took special care to make their small role as accurate as possible in his movie. Look up the story of the woman who played the mama and how she learned the story she read the kids to sleep with while the boat sank. ❤
Incredible documentary. Thank you for sharing their story. ♥️
Yet another layer of this tragedy. The arrogance of the builders to ignore the tradition of christening the ship. The book of Psalms has prayers for those who go to sea because the ocean can go wild in a minute. I feel so sad that innocent people lost their lives because of human greed and pride. Thank you for posting this poignant story.
What I find so appealing about the surviving ladies is their modesty and quiet, unassuming dignity, especially compared to what we might see in the general population today. They suffered a catastrophe so profound as to be incomparable to any I can think of today except maybe 9/11. Just to have lost so many family members, but in such a violent and unexpected way would be traumatic beyond measure. That they suffered the equivalent of what is today called PTSD for years is undoubtable. And yet they didn't bare their souls and anguish in public as we're accustomed to seeing today, but quietly got on with their lives in the best way they could. And they really were successful as well. I have the feeling that the fact they got to experience as young adults what we call the Roaring 20's, with all its exuberance and vitality accompanied by bright, cheerful music I think may have been very therapeutic to them. These were their child-bearing years and all seem to have raised wonderful children who remembered being loved in return. I can also understand their reluctance to talk about the experience as well--as mentioned it caused them tremendous water associated phobias that last the rest of their lives.
I believe 75% of the women onboard survived due to the "women and kids" first. So these women were very unlucky.
GOD be with them always.
I was looking for this documentary because I’m half Irish and I know for sure my ancestors came from that ship my grandfather’s grandmother was Irish and his grandfather was black they are from new york
This was a really interesting story that connects you to the people we seldom hear about as individuals people with names instead of just the “Irish immigrants in steerage”.
What I didn’t like was the cut scenes with guys being interviewed and giving inaccurate information that is tailored to suit a narrative rather than the truth. It starts right around 28:00 if you want to see what I’m talking about. Those two guys, I presume “historians”, start right in on there being locked doors, chained and locked gates, blocked stairways and stewards waiting at every route of escape to keep 3rd class from getting up to the boat deck. The problem was just how complex the ship was to navigate and the fact 3rd class was the furthest away from the boat deck and when they were designing the ship they they didn’t really make it a priority to make access from 3rd class and crew / machinery spaces deep in the ship and the boat deck promenade a super fast, efficient route. They designed the stairways, corridors, ladders, etc around ventilating trunks, steam and water plumbing and other machinery and engineering spaces while also maximizing space for passengers and cargo in any way they could. Truthfully there were stewards helping lead third class passengers from the 3rd class lounge areas within the stern up and forward to the boat deck and getting them in line to get on an open seat in a boat. While first (and to a lesser extent second) class were surely given some advantages through the night, both intentional and not, there is no evidence that Titanic’s crew did anything to keep 3rd class passengers from getting up to or into the boats once they made it to them.
Rest in peace to the 11 who perished in the disaster
Wonderful people and story, thank you😢
The fellow that narrates this, sounds like the same guy who narrated Angela's Ashes, nice. Thanks very much.
That was Frank McCourt...I don't believe it's him...
Wasn't actually Frank Mccourts voice. Someone else narrated the story. This man, Andrew Bennett.
Like most Irish in Canada, our family migrated from Ireland during the potato famine of the 1840's and 50's
Rip ❤to all the people who lost Thier lives on titanic and ❤to all who survived . I'm glad they have never been forgotten and are always remembered with❤ love
fantastic story
Amazing document, I just saw the movie yesterday because last time I saw it I was 15 now iam 20 and I was smoking weed , bruh that was the most amazing movie with drama ever I love that highly recommend
lmao.. love it
welcome to the club youngin
Very sad but informative. Things you thought you knew are not necessarily so.
Heartbreaking….God rest their souls🙏🙏🙏
So very sad the tragedy of the TITANIC so sad that the ship could have been built with bulkheads the full height of the ship’s deck however this wasn’t the case so many people lost because of greed over safety.
Very interesting .
So well done.
Iam so sorry for the people who lost their lives in this accident.
So this is why most if us have Irish roots lol. Beautiful Documentary TY
I doubt it with a surname like Slavinski LOL.
@UCs24EPZ0mG-MeUzmR5RxeQQ People have mother’s.
@@JimmyFranceable right you never know. I have an English surname yet my mother is from Mexico.
White Star Line never had any christening ceremony for their liners. It was a custom they have been following for years. It was not a show of arrogance. Not only Titanic, none of their steamers had a christening ceremony for their launch. The official names of the steamers were already displayed on a large board in front of the liners during their construction.
So sad. 🤧
I couldn’t imagine being on a sinking ship, like the Titanic is absolutely terrifying. I actually wrote a song about the Titanic disaster. It’s featured on my album disaster of the Titanic and crazy world.
Dang a whole village lost ppl. I know I came from strong Irish stock but this is too much
16:14 - what's the name of the song?
Most amazing story ever
Okay... I don’t know why people keep saying Titanic was “unsinkable” nobody, absolutely nobody from White Star Line advertised it as “unsinkable”
During the sea trials Captain Smith said “she’s practically unsinkable.” But nowhere in print did White Star Line say “unsinkable.”
Actually it was advertised by the White Star Line as unsinkable, something they denied later in court, along with how the ship couldn't possibly have broken in half and every survivor was lying. BUT thousands of Flyers posted all around London and even distributed with certain newspapers promised the Titanic to be "a one-of-a-kind Ship of Dreams; The largest, most luxurious ship in the world, and the safest; guaranteed unsinkable." Then after it sank right away, The White Star line lead a huge smear campaign against printing presses for 'taking liberties', as if they hadn't ordered those flyers themselves. In truth, being massive and unsinkable were literally the selling points the Titanic was famous for before the ship was even completed.
James Cameron actually owns some of those original flyers, and If you watch the making of Titanic the movie, they'll show you that these flyers were scattered all over the ground and pavement where passengers were boarding. It was a slogan repeated in the ship yards where the shipwrights would journal that they were building "a masterpiece that would sail forever", and there are many hand written letters to America from people who perished that have been donated to the museums saying things like they 'would soon be onboard the grandest ship in the world. It can't sink, so don't worry about me.'
Local gossip over tea time called the ship 'unsinkable', so much so that the public convinced itself of this new reality the same way that the public does today with things that gain global anticipation and excitement, only to end up being a huge disappointment, like the 'most spectacular final season' of Game of Thrones.
Noah Brandt worked on the Southampton docks and wrote to his sister that "Everyone says it can't be sunk. I'm eager to be joining her crew in just a few voyages."
Then, after it did sink, the New York post and London papers printed that "the unsinkable has sank". So Idk how you got the impression that no one called the ship unsinkable, but many ships sank back then killing hundreds of people, but only the Titanic gained so much fame, because it was viewed as a reminder from God to stay humble and never think ourselves infallible.
People say this to add a bit of drama to the story.
@@s5mphone701oh for crying out loud ismay himself said that about the ship many times even 2 months after it sank
I am learning about the titanic in school are u spying on me?
Don't worry Potato Head you're in good company !! ☺️
Yes
Very good tale.
Watching this after the Titan imploded and the 5 perished. RIP to all that lost their lives on the Titanic and the Titan 🙏🏽
I am planning to write my own Titanic Story about these two ten year old cousins who sailed on the Titanic and Survived the nightmare of the shipwreck with their own courage and witts and their broken friendship but with great cost obviously meaning their families from their parents and older siblings did not survive and the sinking of the Titanic brings the two cousins relationship more closer and helps them reconcile and everyone who had actually sailed on The Titanic plays a part in the cousins story from Captain Smith Bruce Ismay Thomas Andrews Benjamin Gutinhiem and his Italian butler and his mistress and John Jacob Aster and Maddlin Aster and Molly Brown and Mr and Miss Strous and Wallace Hartley and the rest of the band even the Officers from William Murdoch James Moody and Henry Wild and even Charles Lightoller.
Very sad situation
It’s interesting that so many people had premonitions. And were offended for not blessing the ship.
R.I.P.
5:40 to 6:30
This is why I personally feel that LIFE's nature is that of a burden and not a blessing. Giving birth to someone is like giving a life full of struggles wrapped in a gift box. And feeling happy about it.
So many people's lives are spent in poverty, tough labor and poor lifestyle, and low nutrition because of factors they couldn't control. The laws, the economy, and the general joblessness because of Ireland's geography and history.
I jus wanna cry
Why was Ireland so poor? Government officials?
Read about Britain and Ireland reactions. Also read about potato famine. Oh look up protestants and catholics in Ireland.
God bless them ❤
I wish I could ask the McDermott family if she kept the hat she went back for. If she held on to it all those years.
The sad part is , even if there were enough lifeboats , many still would have died .The reason is , that The Titanic sank too fast to load over a thousand people , into the lifeboats .
Pay attention!...It was also shown in another documentary/interpreted movie...Cpt Smith opted his priorities to attend 11am Catholic Mass than to conduct the "fire drill/abort ship" drill to the passengers n crew! He'd known then, "something wrong" bout to occur.
Some details are misleading.. Titanic was not the first ship to be thought unsinkable.
Olympic and Titanic together were considered "practically unsinkable" due to their new water tight door design. Though White Star never really declared their steamers unsinkable it was the journal Shipbuilder which first wrote about the safety features of the new mammoth liners.
When the Olympic survived the collision with HMS Hawke it became a reality in the public minds that these liners would never sink.
Olympic construction started in December 1908 Titanic construction started in early 1909 and it was not the fastest ship and was launched in 1910 not 1911.....too many mistakes here
I did not know it wasn’t blessed. That’s terrible
I hope white star lines got sued for being so negligent!!!!! Who gives them right to decide who lives and dies????? There is a special place in hell for such people!!!!!
Oh please!...Back then...legal suits and arson were not "recognized" as in this century...It's " so common!"
Also to give $25 that's just over $700 in today's money. You could kida equate it to let's say for example you slipped on the floor at Walmart and had to go to the hospital and all you got from Walmart was oh we're sorry here is $700... um.. excuse me..
This is a perfect example of out world - rich take the boats!
so how is ireland today
Titanic the Shocking Truth by Andrew Newton is food for thought states that the the Titanic was swapped with her sister ship Olympic which was in several accidents and deemed unseaworthy .
All that money wasted on luxury while they skimmed on safety. How tragically ironic it wouldn’t be of use for that reason. 😒
I like titanic and this is an amazing documentary highlighting the story of people on board. But lets not forget they screwed up Native Americans
A sad story
I'm so Sorry bout no of Your List 3:29
Annies legacy died with her. If she because a nun, there were no decendents. How sad...but that's what she chose.
Her legacy lives with every student that she taught.
Tragic
❤ Hero's
Titanic never claimed to be the fastest liner on the oceans.
Alot of the passengers that jumped with a lifebelt on died from a broken neck. It was a design fail
Patrick Canavan saved so , many my father is Tommy Canavan
My great grandfather was on the Titanic. He was from Italy and his name was Fabrizio de Rossi. A big smokestack fell on him. He did not survive.
You just stole this story from the 1997 movie 😂😂
My grandparents on my dad's side came to the US from Ireland lucky for me they didn't come here on the titanic
Beautifully done 😢🙏
My family is from the South..Cork mostly. One side is from the North. Derry but also going way back grandfathers side was on the NW coast. You know I began reading and researching, just digging and searching finding out things that was so painful, things I felt I wish I hadn’t have learned. Not sure what to do with the anger or pain often, now I do ask for the truth is all. Don’t we all deserve the truth, teaching kids history that is made up stories is not ok. Anywho with all the research and talking with family about our family..old stories and all…I realized that our families went through so much they didn’t talk about it much or at all, afraid to talk, there’s generational trauma, there’s staying quiet bc God forbid one poked the bear ya know what that means. Still to this day there’s issues with this because well a certain country has claim to land, it’s bordered off but in Ireland, there Is discrimination still it’s just sad really. The last part of our country that is colonized still..it’s been oh like 900 plus years of that.
Staying silent was Survival and then the generations to follow just didn’t know what was never spoken. I am proud to speak of the truth of our people and land, it’s quite healing, we talk openly of slavery, the killing and starvation that was and is genocide, those who fled and so on, it’s freeing to my soul and to family legacy, Irish legacy to be a voice for what’s true and righteous, the pain is there but what’s bigger is the love and gratitude we have, we come from immense strength, we are strong people..we are connected to our kin to the land to the ways..To think I’m alive because of who survived and kept going, no matter what. I am so grateful. ✨
You're a Yank! Drop the historical victimhood unless you have been a victim yourself. "generational trauma"....grow up Karen! I'm English and have more Irish blood in my little toe than you have in your entire body and I'm not bleating about things that happened hundreds of years ago. You might want to look a bit closer to home if you're appointing blame for abuses against native populations. Repeat after me: I am American, NOT Irish! :D
Amen
Can someone do a documentary on Joseph Laroche the only black man on titanic
What an awful way to die !!! Such preventable disaster !!!!! Imagine seeing women and babies in that freezing water !!! 😞🙏
This is the same documentary called "Voices of the Titanic."
This documentary makes me see now in time of refugees coming to Europe for good future but not knowing of what happens on the vast deep water.
Someone spelt immigrants wrong just a fyi ...great video thanks for the sharec
An immigrant is a person who comes to a foreign land (foreign to the immigrant), an emigrant is a person who leaves a place where he/she used to live. Now, considering that the documentary deals with Irish people leaving Ireland to emigrate to the United States (but most of them sadly don't make it) they are emigrants.
He wanted to rival that!! AFRICA