He never understood love or friendship, and he firmly believed he was more clever than any other wizard. So he couldn't (or wouldn't) believe that anyone else could figure out what or where his horcruxes were.
Exactly. Voldemort was very Machiavellian - he understood fear but not love. He felt none of his followers would ever lie to him because they feared him too much. Instead, they were capable of lying to him because they feared Voldemort but they loved something or someone even more than their fear.
@@NecramoniumVideo The fight in the book is pretty epic, in general the fights in the books are much better than the movies. But in typical industry fashion, script writers think they can do better than the world beloved and critically acclaimed novel.
When Snape said "You have your mother's eyes", it was the first time Harry realized that Snape knew his mother. Every person who's ever said that to Harry was a friend of Lily's.
@@Tchika That one memory revealed that he was at school with her and knew her a bit, yes, but not that they were friends, let alone that he loved her. Harry was actually left with the impression that Snape despised Lily as a Mudblood.
@@christinabrock2893 right, I was trying to remember, how it was in the books, because in the movies they showed memories to Harry which implied more... But you're right, the memories didn't show any of those romanticising moments in the books
In the film, yes, but in the book, Harry already knows that Snape knew his mother in Book 5. And Snape once had an argument with Lily, Snape even taunted Lily with the word Mudblood.
@@KhrlIRD45 Snape didn't exactly "taunt" Lily with Mudblood; he yelled it out of frustration because he was being bullied by James and lost his cool. Still no excuse for him to say it.
I saw some of the behind the scenes for that. HBC basically shadowed Emma Watson for days, if not weeks, to get all her mannerisms. I think there's a scene where the directors calls her Helena, and she's like "Call me Emma"
@@lingodelfo5415 Yeah, the time tested method of, well, method acting. Most of the best actors use it and some have even been known to take it *really* far. Ryan Renolds for one...to no one's surprise.
Severus Snape is a beautiful example of a perfectly written tragic hero. A man who made grave mistakes and died trying to right his wrongs. He saw James, the man he hated, every time he looked at Harry but he saw the eyes of the woman he loved as well. He was incredibly flawed, took his hatred out on Harry but he was good in the end.
This happen when you have only watched movies . Snape is the person who told the prophecy to voldemort. Snape is the person who was death Eater before lilys death .
@@atuljha438 also, Snape wanted Dumbledore to save Lily, didn't give a fuck about James or Harry snuffing it. And you have to be a special kind of cruel to be a student's worst fear, in particular when said student have had his parents tortured beyond recognition. Snape was on the side of good, but he wasn't a good person.
@@atuljha438 and the book clearly explained that he didn’t expect Voldemort to hunt the potters in response to hearing the prophecy which is why he went to Dumbledore in the first place. He realized his grave mistake and tried his best to right his terrible wrong hence: perfect example of a tragic hero.
@@TheR15CTurning to Dumbledore to beg him to save Lily and Lily only. Therefore clearly no hero, tragic or not, but a villain trying to find redemption though still bad.
@@ryusukeminami52 and proceeded to protect Harry in ways that were finally explained in the chapter the Prince’s tale. If he were anything but a tragic hero then he wouldn’t have felt motivated to remedy his poor choices. Simple as that
I never understood why the films changed this, but in the books, after Harry learnt that he must die, he went to the forest with his invisibility cloak on, because he knew that ron and hermione would never let him go, and he himself can't bear saying goodbye to them...all he did was telling Neville that the snake must be killed, and that is exactly what he did
Yeah so true. I also find it annoying they had Hermione hug Harry but not have Ron hug Harry. If they were going to have him say good bye to them, Ron should’ve hugged him too or at least looked a little more upset. Just another moment where they made Ron look like a douche in the movies for no reason.
Yeah I always find these things totally under-acted. Not just in these movies but in general. That gut wrenching grief doesn't just flit across your face. It makes you collapse and wail and throw all logic out of the window
And Petunia. It's addressed in the books that Harry retuning to Petunia's home every summer is part of what protected him as it renewed his family blood bond. This whole movie is full of mothers including Ron and Ginny's mom who made space in her family for Harry.
@vert2552 This is actually the story of Ron Weasley who if he didn’t walk into Harry’s compartment on the train and made friends with him would have never had any of the allies that Harry did to help him defeat the dark lord/deatheaters. If it wasn’t for Ron making Hermione cry in the bathroom they would have never become best friends and there would not be a trio. Ron Weasley pulled this whole story to the end. 😂
Dumbledore's sister Ariana died during a fight between Dumbledore and Grindelwald when they were young and close. No one knows whose curse killed her. After the incident, Grindelwald ran away and became the greatest dark wizard of that era.
Dumbledores story could be a book on its own. The HP series is worth a read especially to those who watched the movies. It answers so many questions the movies couldn't fit in.
So to answer a question that you asked about the patronus "does that mean her true love was snape?". Short answer no, but love does effect patronus'. James' patronus was a stag (like Harry's) and Lilly's was a doe, making them the perfect counter parts for each other, and effectively soulmates as a patronus is kinda a reflection of the individual. However, strong love can actually cause your patronus to change which is what happens to Snape's patronus. He loves lily so much his pateonus changes to match hers. In the book this also happens to Tonks after she falls in love with Remus (and snape actually mocks her for this).
@@cariann2220Actually Snape being Snape, understood who the patronous resembled and actually mocked Lupin not really Tonks. Snape was petty and bitter and couldn't let go of his grudge. Though I understand his side, but he took it out on all innocent people even children, that is unacceptable and that is also why he mocked Tonks.
Even sadder about Remus and Tonks is they had a child who was now orphaned. Luckily Harry was named the Godfather (Remus had a much bigger role in the book and met with them while they were at Bill and Fleur's) and helped raise their son
The child also had at least one grand parent who raised him (Since I never read any background info I don't know whether Ted Tonks his grandfather was killed.)
@@sawanna508he was killed. In the books he was un the run along with dean thomas, who was muggleborn. The trio finds out later that they were captured and killed. ( fred and george held a silent moment for them on their underground resistance radio show, along with lupin and kingsley i do believe)
I wish they had my favorite part at the end. In the book, Ron told the kids that if they were not sorted into Gryffindor, they will disinherit them. And then says “But no pressure.” And Hermione is like, “Ron!” LOL😂😂
Sorry in advance for this VERY LONG essay. In HBP, Dumbledore was dying slowly and painfully due to the curse from the ring when he tried to destroy it, which is why he wanted Snape to kill him (as well as to protect Draco and cement his position with Voldemort). When Dumbledore said "Please" he was actually asking Snape to kill him. Voldemort created the Horcruxes in an attempt to cheat death. Appropriately, his name is French for "Flight of Death" or "Steal/Cheat of death". Also, he had planned to split his soul in 7 pieces, which means 6 horcruxes AND his physical body. Then he would become mortal and could therefore be killed. But he unintentionally made the 7th horcrux with Harry when he killed his parents (and tried to kill him), therefore there were 8 pieces of his soul. The horcruxes were destroyed in the order they were created - diary, ring, locket, cup, diadem, Harry and Nagini. The Resurrection Stone doesn't actually bring people back from the dead, it just temporarily calls the soul back to earth in a form between living people and ghosts. In the book, Harry stops on his way to the forest when he remembers the snitch. Seeing his dead loved ones not only gives him the strength and courage to go through with letting Voldemort kill him but their spectral form visible only to him act as Patronus' to get past the Dementors. Harry is in limbo (between life and death) when he meets Dumbledore at King's Cross, so he isn't really dead. That is because 1. He is the true master of all of the Deathly Hallows and therefore the true Master of Death, which doesn't make you immortal but simply means you accept death (which is also why he couldn't fight back). 2. It only killed the part of Voldy's soul (the Horcrux) that was in him and made him mortal. 3. He chose to go back (Dumbledore said he could still choose to die). Also, the reason Voldy had to be the one to kill Harry, as Dumbledore said, is because Voldy bound him to himself when he took his blood during his resurrection in GoF. Dumbledore knew that Harry would have to face him and "die" by his hand in order to trick Voldy into destroying the Horcrux inside Harry. He just couldn't let Snape know. Voldemort killed Snape because he thought the Elder Wand belonged to him since Snape killed Dumbledore. But he didn't realise that whoever disarmed Dumbledore is the one who owned the wand (not who killed him) which was Draco. And when Harry disarmed Draco in DH P1, he became the owner. Snape didn't just die to save Harry, I believe he also died to save Draco because he made the Unbreakable Vow to protect him. And when Voldy asked him who owned the Elder Wand, Snape said it belonged to him, but he knew the wand answered only to Draco and he knew Voldy would kill Draco once he realised that. That's why he didn't put up a fight against Nagini. At least that's how I see it. Snape saying "Look at me. You have your mother's eyes." to Harry is because Lily's eyes were the last thing he wanted to see. Snape loved Lily but Lily didn't love Snape, at least not as more than friends. And once he started dabbling in the dark arts she distanced herself from him and eventually fell in love with James who was also Snape's mortal enemy. The deeper meaning of Snape's patronus changing into a doe like Lily's is that Lily's Patronus only became a doe after she fell in love with James (to compliment his stag). In PoA when Dumbledore explained to Harry that when he cast his Patronus, it was, in a way, his father appearing to protect him (so Harry was partially right that it was his dad who saved him). Snape's Patronus changing into the same form that Lily's used to take was proof that she was still protecting Harry. Snape hated James (for good reason), but if his Patronus changed into the form that Lily's had taken only when she fell in love with James, it would mean that he had come to accept the choices that she had made and was genuinely determined to protect her son, in spite of his hatred for his father. If you watch carefully in the duel between Snape and McGonagall, you can see that Snape deflects a spell cast from McGonagall, which hits the Death Eater twins the Carrows behind him. This foreshadows which side Snape was truly on. And, while it's clear where Snape's loyalties lied, I keep seeing fans argue whether he was actually good or bad. But as Sirius and Dumbledore both said, everyone has a bit of both inside them. What matters is which path you choose to follow. For years Snape chose to follow Voldemort and was a legit Death Eater. He is a arguably the most complex character in the series. The way he treated Harry was despicable. Even if it was because of James it doesn't excuse it or explain his treatment of other people. He was a bitter person and a bully. BUT, he had played the double (triple?) agent all this time and he did it to save Harry, or more specifically, Lily's son. Snape, despite all his flaws, could love. The fact that he could love without having been loved himself is what made him good (as opposed to Voldemort). Harry and Voldemort's final duel plays out very differently in the book. It's a super intense confrontation in the Great Hall with EVERYONE watching. Harry tells Voldy the truth about Snape and the Elder Wand, before using a Disarming Charm to defeat him. His death is very human as he drops to the ground and leaves a body behind (they filmed that version: ruclips.net/video/rFMxRv2Zaj0/видео.htmlsi=7pYEUvBtE6wlvAbN). While the film version is more visually pleasing, it just doesn't feel as intense or final. It also goes against the original point that without magic, Voldemort dies just like any other man, and he was never actually as "special" as he believed. That's probably what I am most mad about regarding the book-to-film adaptations. Voldemort caused his death in three ways. Firstly, by "killing" Harry he unintentionally destroyed the Horcrux, as Voldemort was unaware of that. Secondly, he possibly forgot about Nagini due to his determination to kill Harry and remembered her after she died, and thirdly, as he was not the true owner of the Elder Wand, it recognised Harry as its owner and allowed his killing curse to rebound and kill him. In the book Harry learns Dumbledore's darkest secret: That he may have accidentally killed his sister Ariana (she is the portrait that Aberforth has to help Neville and the kids travel back and forth). Ariana had trouble suppressing her magic as she accidentally killed their mother and required constant care and attention. In a duel between Dumbledore, his brother Aberforth, and Dumbledore's friend-turned-enemy Gellert Grindelwald (According to JKR, Dumbledore was gay and in love with Grindelwald), Ariana was killed, and none of them knew who cast the spell that caused her death. Dumbledore was reliving this memory in the cave when he and Harry went looking for the locket in HBP. In the book Harry returns the Elder Wand to Dumbledore's grave, which would leave the wand without a master and cause it to lose its power. But before he does, he uses it to fix his. While breaking it is surely safer, it makes no sense why he didn't at least fix his wand first, since the Elder Wand is the only wand capable of mending broken ones! And Harry DOES lose the ability to speak Parseltongue after Voldemort kills the Horcrux inside him. Neville being the one to kill the snake and essentially kill Voldemort is quite poetic since he could have been "The Chosen One" as his birthday is also at the end of July and his parents had also defied Voldemort three times (as the prophecy said). It's never explained in the films though. I'm conflicted on the Malfoys. They were pure-blood fanatics (especially Lucius) and Draco was a bully. But Narcissa never seemed interested in any of it and in the end all she cared about was keeping Draco safe. That's why she told Voldemort that Harry was dead (which made it the second time Harry was saved by a mother's love). Also, notice how Draco didn't come when his dad called him but as soon as his mum called him he did? Some could argue that them leaving and not fighting with Voldemort was a statement in itself, but it could also be seen as cowardly. So I wish they had kept one scene in - when Harry revealed that he was still alive, Draco was meant to help him by throwing him his wand. The scene was filmed but not included in the final cut: ruclips.net/video/V6m4vuT_pME/видео.htmlsi=sYwtYueHmVskPSdD. Even though it wasn't in the book I am still mad they didn't keep it in. Before the scene was shot where Hermione is pretending to be Bellatrix, Emma Watson acted out the scene for Helena Bonham Carter so she would know how to act as if she were Hermione in this situation. So, essentially, this scene is Helena acting like Emma acting as Hermione acting like Bellatrix. Also, they couldn't use her wand because it was reported stolen so they would've known it was an imposter. If you really want to cry: When Harry reveals himself to be alive and everyone reacts with joy, if you look closely at George he starts saying 'Fred' before remembering that he is dead. Voldemort hugging Draco was not scripted but improv by Ralph Fiennes. Tom Felton genuinely didn't know how to react so the look of confusion and discomfort is real. Most of Voldemort’s speech was improv as well. I recommend reacting to the 20th anniversary special and maybe Fantastic Beasts (at least the first two). I also recommend taking the REAL Sorting Hat Quiz on wizardingworld.com to see what house you're in (I'm a proud Hufflepuff!).
******* SPOILER IF YOU WANNA READ THE BOOKS ******* In the book, Harry becomes an Auror and eventually Head of Auror Office and Head of the Department of Magical Law Enforcement under Minister for Magic Kingsley Shacklebolt (Aurors are sort of the wizard police). Ginny becomes a professional Quidditch player and eventually the senior Quidditch correspondent at the Daily Prophet. Harry and Ginny get married and have three children: James Sirius, Albus Severus and Lily Luna. Harry is also very close to his godson Teddy Lupin and remains on "Christmas card terms" with his cousin Dudley. Aunt Petunia is believed to have passed away in 2020 (3 years after the epilogue). Hermione tracks down her parents in Australia and reverses the memory spell she cast on them. She works for the Department for the Regulation and Control of Magical Creatures and pursues her dream to improve conditions for underprivileged magical creatures like the house-elves. She becomes Deputy Head of the Department of Magical Law Enforcement and, eventually replacing Kingsley as Minister for Magic. Ron becomes an Auror but leaves after two years to work at Weasleys' Wizard Wheezes with his brother George. Hermione and Ron have two children: Rose and Hugo. Ron is also the godfather of Harry and Ginny's first son, James Sirius. Neville also becomes an Auror before changing his mind and becoming a Herbology teacher at Hogwarts and, eventually, Head of Gryffindor House. He also marries Hufflepuff Hannah Abbott. While the two don't have children, Neville is the godfather of Harry's second son, Albus Severus. Luna becomes a famous Magizoologist, discovering numerous magical creatures never before introduced to the Wizarding World. She marries Rolf Scamander, the grandson of Newt Scamander who is the protagonist of the Fantastic Beasts series. They have twin sons: Lorcan and Lysander. In my mind, Neville and Luna ended up together in the books too. The Malfoys are pardoned for their crimes because Lucius provides evidence against his fellow Death Eaters, and likely because of Narcissa's lie as well. Draco doesn't really have a job because he's so rich but he dedicates much of his time to the pursuit of alchemy. He marries Astoria Greengrass, the younger sister of a fellow Slytherin. She is not welcomed into the family because she doesn't share their racist pure-blood ideals, even after Draco stands up to his parents. The two have a son named Scorpius Hyperion. Unfortunately, Astoria dies young from a blood curse. Draco raises his son to be far more accepting than he was. At Hogwarts, Scorpius and Albus Severus, both in Slytherin, become great friends. McGonagall takes over as Headmistress and Hagrid stays in his position at Hogwarts. Finally, Umbridge is put on trial, found guilty and sentenced to life imprisonment for her crimes. So unfortunately she doesn't die but she gets punished for her crimes.
Yess, especially the part about how much better the book ended with the duel. I had no idea they filmed that version, I’ll definitely check out that link!
So to address a few more things, since I commented early in your recap. Neville and Ron both had inherited wands. Neville had his dad's, and Ron had his brother's. Both wands were broken, after which there was a noticeable improvement to their success in working spells. Because the wand chooses the wizard, they were essentially handicapped by having the wrong wand.
46:45 you said " where did he get that" ( Dumbledore's cursed hand) .. But you saw it at Half Blood Prince.. Dumby said to Harry.." I found one of that horcrux..The Ring.. Hard to find, and even harder to destroy" (Dumby showed his cursed hand while he said this)
More than that - the ring held the resurrection stone, which Dumbledore recognized and coveted. He didn't want to destroy the stone with the ring and received the curse as he took the stone from the ring, trying to use it to bring his sister back to life.
@@jzero4813 bro yes, that's true but these guys are newly watched the reaction video.. Your comment has so much details.. you dont need to suffocate them with details.. They will read the books and they will see.. No offence bro, dont misunderstand me but I can write more than you about details.. That cause confussion.. Simple and short general informations are easy to understand.. Because how much details, that much questions in their mind :))
Also you asked why Voldemort didnt just check himself if Harry was dead. In the book he actually does, but in a brutal fashion. He uses a high powered Cruciatus curse (the torture curse) on Harry and Harry almost bites through his tongue in an effort to stay quiet and not move during it. Its well established that Voldemort is arrogant in the knowledge of his power and would see that as enough proof because surely this insignificant boy could not keep quiet when the all mighty dark lord tortured him. Also, its speculated that Narcissa is more powerful then she shows because most definetly Voldemort checked her thoughts which means she's most likely a powerful occlumens on par with Dumbledore.
If i recall harry actually doesn’t feel the pain from that curse. I don’t remember why, since there is so many layers of protective spells surrounding him at this point
@@mattiasandersson8693 Oh thats right! Sorry, I think I read the biting the tongue thing in a fanfic or something and got the parts confused. Thanks for catching me on that
@@sawanna508 I imagine that anyone in Voldy's inner circle had to be able to protect their mind, otherwise he'd never keep them around because he'd always know their real thoughts, and he also wouldn't be able to reveal any plans or secrets to them, because they could be compromised by a mind reader. So for his own sake and their sake they'd have to be able to protect their minds.
I love in the scene where Pansy demands that someone grab Harry when Voldemort says they have an hour, Ginny steps in front of him, Cho steps up to the left of him, and Hermoine steps up on his right. Luna and the Patil twins step up too. The first people to protect Harry are the girls who cared most about him.
Oh please, PLEASE watch the "Return to Hogwarts" reunion. It's not just stale interviews... they actually return to the school... I think you'd both really like it.
Жаль только что половина каста не взяли, включая создателя Роулинг, по каким-то дурацким вбросам, но политика что поделать) Получается неполноценное возвращение
@@tomriddle4114 some, like Julie Walters, had major health issues. Understandable. Some due to other commitments. Yes, J.K. wasn't there because of politics or whatever you want to call it. Death had a role in a lot not being there either. Ever been to a reunion? Not everyone shows up but that doesn't make it less of a wonderful time.
The sword of Gryffindor was infected/infused with the basilisk venom when Harry killed it. Neville was born on the same day as Harry, he could have been the boy in Trelawny's prediction. It was symbolic that Neville killed the last horcrux with the sword of Gryffindor.
@@connie2558 The Prophesy stated "born at the end of July". Neville was born on the 30th, Harry on the 31st. More importantly, prophesies can only be found in the Dept of Mysteries by the person the prophesy is about. Harry didn't find the Prophesy; Neville did. And yes; Neville destroyed the last horcrux, which led to the discorporation/death of Voldemort.
@@chris...9497 No, not found. They can only be retrieved by those it's about, meaning only Harry and Voldemort can pick it up and take it. Other people can obviously go around looking for a specific prophecy and look at it. Malfoy had already found it, they were waiting there for Harry to pick it up.
@@chris...9497 nope, its about picking it up, touching it. by that point neville was already out of the prophecy as it mentions that the dark lord will mark him as his equal. Neville was out of the prophecy the night lily and james died.
Snape didn’t want to be a Gryffindor, yeah he wanted to be with Lily but in the books he’s very proud he was a Slytherin! He wanted Lily to be sorted into Slytherin instead.
Yup! In fact, he used to hang out with his slytherin friends who used to call themselves "deatheaters". Lily had asked him to leave them but he didn't and even insulted Lily by calling her a mudblood. And one major detail which they changed in the movies is that he had asked Voldemort "to kill the father and the boy but spare Lily".
What a wonderful reaction from you both! Quynh is such a pure and kind soul! I just wanted to come through the screen and give her a hug. It's always so refreshing to see people express real emotion, especially when this world seems so heartless at times. Thank you both! 💙
The two Death Eaters they mentioned as being on staff were the two people behind Snape during the confrontation in the Great Hall. When McGonagle was sending bursts of fire as Snape, if you watch carefully, you can see that two of them, rather than blocking them, he kind of redirects them, hitting both of those Death Eaters before he fled out through the window. One more act of heroism.
Not surprising Neville is so brave. Remember when Dumbledore said, "It takes a great deal of bravery to stand up to your enemies, but a great deal more to stand up to your friends." Neville's the one who won the house cup for Gryffindor that first year. Also, knowing how bravely his parents fought against Voldemort the first time, I'm not surprised he's got that fire in him. Amazing build-up to that moment.
That wand would not be much of a use to Harry because it didn't chose him. Beside it dosn't fit in because if Harry is disweapped he would lose the alligence of the Elder Wand.
Harry already has Draco's wand at this point. He doesn't need Draco's mother's wand. Besides, Draco would never do that, especially in front of Voldemort.
Clarification on Snape- Snape loved Lily as a child. Besides for being beautiful she was the first person who was good to him. They remained best friends till 5th year when Snape had many bad friends and aspired to be a death eater when he left Hogwarts. While being humiliated by James, Snape called Lily a Mudblood when she came to his defense. Later he apologized but Lily told him she can no longer ignore who he had become and who he wants to be. However Snape never stopped loving her and hating James. He hated Harry, who looked just like James, because Harry was the constant reminder that the women he loved married the man he hated. In the books, Snape overhears the prophecy about a boy will be born who has the power to vanquish Voldemort. When Voldemort interoperates the prophecy to mean Harry, Snape ask Voldemort to spare Lily so he can have her. However, Dumbledore, who knows Snape overheard it, convinces Snape to agree to be his spy in exchange for Dumbledore protecting not just Lily but the entire Potter family. Here Snape agrees, ONLY if Dumbledore agrees to never tell anybody that he is helping the good side. Snape worked as a "double agent" working for Dumbledore from that moment on. So Snape told Voldemort what night the Order was moving Harry from the Dursleys BUT using powerful magic, planted the idea in an order members head about using the potion to make 7 Harrys, hopefully ensuring Harrys safety through the attack. Snape would give enough information to make him Voldemort's most trusted advisor while withholding key information. In terms of the Elder Wand, no one knew that Dumbledore had it. Only Voldemort and Harry figure it out around the time of escaping Malfoys Manor. So Snape had no idea it was the elder wand or where Voldemort got it until Voldemort told him (when he was about to kill him). Snape did not know he was about to be killed and did not want to be because he still had the final information to give to Harry. That was not part of the plan.
You said one interessting/disturbing plot point. Dumbledore knew, that Voldemort knew, that he had the Elder Wand. He also knew that Voldemort would try to get and that (at least to the Wizarding Worlds folklore) the Elder Wand is past over by the death of the owner... knowing all this, Dumbledore still plans his death with Snape....in case you havnt noticed, with this arangement, Dumbledore is sentening Snape to death.
@@thomasnieswandt8805 exactly. while reading this chapter in the book the year it came out, I threw the book away from me cos I finally understood Dumbledore is a very manipulative and cunning guy but at the same time, he knew that if it doesn't happens that way, Draco will lose himself by killing him. So that part of Dumbledore at the same time totally was heartbroken himself cos he had huge respect for Snape as well. he is such a beautiful character and one of my favourite becos of that. such layered character and so many nuances .
Just to clear a few things up: 1) Dumbledore got the curse by putting the Grunt's Family Ring (the Ring Horcrux) on without having needing to, his biggest weakness was power so when he noticed the ring contained the Resurrection Stone even at his age he gave into weakness again (hence why he choose to be only a Headmaster instead of Minster for Magic because he didn't trust himself with that kind of power). 2) The Dumbledore brothers did have a falling out over Albus's lust for power & him going down a dark path with his friend Grindelwald (who's the main villain in the Fantastic Beasts series). Albus, Aberforth & Grindelwald got into a massive dual which ended up killing their little sister Ariana. Side note when Dumbledore drank from the Drink of Despair in the Half Blood Prince he was forced to relive that memory of the that dual where his sister died. 3) Voldemort died by having his own killing curse rebound onto himself, because harry was the Master of the Elder Wand the wand won't kill its actually master (hence why Dumbledore said Voldemort must be the one to kill Harry because he knew Voldemort would take the Elder Wand & while he meant for Snape to end up with it the plan was always to give it to Harry to protect him from Voldemort). 4) Snape was undercover because he was the one that gave half the prophecy to Voldemort which sent him after the Potters in the first place (and why he went to Dumbledore), he said he'd do "anything" to Dumbledore which was spy on Voldermort for him. 5) Snape & Lily relationship was breaking apart because Snape was super into the Dark Arts even against Lily's wishes he keep diving deeper & deeper into dark magic & their relationship ended when in a moment of anger Snape called Lily a "Mudblood" (after being bullied by James again). Because of Alan Rickman's great performance (and a little change for Movie purposes) people often confuse by Snape because he's motivation is different Book Snape only cared about revenge & Lily, Movie Snape was a Anti-Hero.
Yes! People who haven’t read the books don’t realize what Snape really is. Do I feel bad and get always, yes. But I also get he was always a bad person. A bully to most students and not a good guy.
27:18 "I've always wanted to use that spell." that is my favorite quote of the entire series. Granted other lines have a lot of weight too, but it really humanized McGonagall in a way we really never saw before.
re: Does Voldemort feel bad about killing other wizards? No, he has no empathy for them. But in the books especially, Voldemort is shown to almost worship magic, so pure-blood magic-doers would have some worth in his eyes.
Cool detail, after Harry saw him kill Dumbledore, he called him just Snape, but when he found out about the truth behind Snape's actions he called him Professor Snape again, it's like his respect kinda came back again after that moment.
Oh, man.... seeing Fred lying on the floor in the Great Hall dead is heartbreaking, especially seeing Ron break down in tears. (Hearing that Harry had to sacrifice himself to give them a chance of defeating Voldemort and the Death Eaters didn't help that grief.) Also, I was at the midnight premiere of The Deathly Hallows Part 2 in 3D. The scene where Mrs. Weasley took out Bellatrix got a massive cheer from the audience. 7 points I've made or seen in the past regarding Harry Potter: 1. The prophecy Professor Dumbledore mentioned in Professor Snape's memory that mentioned a baby born at the end of July was partially true. There were actually two: Harry Potter and Neville Longbottom. They were born in the same month and year, but Neville is only 1 day older than Harry. (Neville: 30 July 1980, Harry: 31 July 1980.) Voldemort had chosen to target a then 15-month-old Harry, thus marking him as his equal. Neville lived a life free of that fear with his grandmother, despite the constant painful reminder of his parents being permanently admitted to St Mungo's Hospital for Magical Maladies and Injuries after being tortured into insanity by Bellatrix Lestrange. 2. In the scene where Professor McGonagall steps in to protect Harry from Professor Snape....if you notice, he never raises his wand to actually attack her. He actually deflects the spells hurled at him at the two Death Eaters behind him, the Carrows....the very same pair that Neville said were forcing the students to practice the Cruciatus Curse on first years. 3. Voldemort's death after his battle with Harry wasn't supposed to look like he got snapped out by Thanos, and it wasn't just them isolated in the courtyard. In the book, Harry and Voldemort battle for the last time in front of everyone else, resulting in Voldemort dying as a mortal man once Neville sliced off Nagini's head. 4. Harry didn't snap the Elder Wand in the book version. He mends his original wand (the one he got in Philosopher's Stone from Ollivander's) with it, then returns it to Professor Dumbledore's grave. 5. I give HUGE props to Narcissa for straight-up lying to Voldemort after Harry confirmed that Draco was alive. It shows that neither she nor her son wanted the Death Eater life. 6. That one goblin who stared in shock as the Ukrainian Ironbelly burst through the floor of Gringotts seriously looked a bit like Donald Trump. 7. Before the war, during an Order Of The Phoenix meeting at Grimmauld Place after their son Teddy was born, Harry was asked by Tonks and Remus to be the godfather.
Great points! The only thing is Neville killing Nagini didn’t save Ron and Hermione, it happened in the courtyard where they bring Harry back, thinking he’s dead. Many things happened at once and it’s SO good, so much more climactic! Tons of people streamed onto the grounds to join the fight (villagers and parents of students and such), the student body once again broke free of the Silencio curse Voldemort kept trying to use (his curses couldn’t hold them because Harry died for them and gave them blood protection like his mom did for him), Harry leapt out of Hagrid’s arms and covered himself with his invisibility cloak, and best of all…Neville had been put in the full body bind curse, the sorting hat forced on his head and set on fire. At that moment he also broke free of the curse, pulled the hat off, pulled out the sword and killed Nagini who was around Voldemort’s neck. The sword can be presented to any worthy Gryffindor in a moment of need.
@@lyds6382 It's hilarious how much more cinematic the books are than the movies, typical movie writers thinking they can do better than one of the best selling authors of all time. In the books all fights are better, they're very easy to follow, very clearly described so easy to imagine. In the movies it's all weird, people just stand around waiting for the other actor to do a spell, or they use wands like guns. In the movies almost all spells just send people flying, and same spell has different effect depending on the scene.
Apparently they filmed a version like that, where his body is just lifeless on the ground! I don’t remember the link but you can look it up, I much prefer it.
Also in the book, the final fight happens infront of the whole school and Harry is telling basically a recap of the 7 books to Voldemort, but Voldemort does not believe him and....well...
I’m pretty sure the pure blood thing was always an infatuation with certain wizards. Salazar was the first to insist they make the wizarding school pure-blood only.
So a few things to know. The tale of the Deathly Hallows actually plays in front of you through the two movies. Voldemort killed for power. Snape died for love and harry greeted death like an old friend. As for Harry not dying there can be so many ways people go off it being he didn’t die because he had all the pieces of the Deathly Hallows. However if you go back to the first movie it does show that harry has a protection spell from his mother’s love casted before she died. And that’s why he could not die in that movie. However the spell was meant to ware off after he turns a certain age. But if you remember in the 4th movie. Voldemort took his blood and that’s why the spell actually still happened. So although yes he was a horcrux he did also survive from his mother’s love. Also for the headmasters hand he got the curse from the ring he had destroyed. It does say it in movie 6.
Don't forget that he was the master of the Elder wand. In the book, Voldermort uses cruciatus on him, but it doesn't hurt him. Same with the death curse.
😮 Oh I didn't think about that about the Three Brothers! Antiochus was Dumbledore with the Elder Wand. Severus Snape was Cadmus with a betrothed who died too soon and he wanted her back. And Ignotus was obviously Harry, with the cloak. And so you'll know, Aberforth's patronus is a goat. Harry's was a stag of course, and Harry had cast his to chase away death eaters near Aberforth's bar, the Hog's Head. He hustled the heroes in and stalled the death eaters saying he cast his own and he said he set off rye caterwauling charm alarm. "I saw a stag." "A stag? It's a goat!" and he cast his goat patronus. Part of Snape's memories was showing him checking Dumbledore's blackened hand. The ring was a horcrux. In its setting was the resurrection stone. Dumbledore had forgotten it was a horcrux and tried it on. Voldemort had put an insidious curse on it. Albus wanted to bring his family back.
Also, the age was 17. That's also the age the Ministry's trace stops tracking you. So: freedom from snooping ministers and freedom to leave home and be killed.
Harry's protection spell from his mother was not meant to wear off when he turned 17. That's the whole reason Voldemort couldnt kill him. You're confusinfg it with Dumbledore's spell that protected him while he lived with the Dursley. This is the one that stopped working when he turned 17.
I've watched your playlist from the beginning and it's been really fun since I can feel you guys also had fun and actually pay attention to a lot of things! Thanks for the reaction, expecting more series to come, subbed!
Snape loved Lily, but Lily did NOT love him, she only saw him as a friend. Snape started to hang out with pureblood supremacists in school to fit in. Lily still tried to be friends with Snape after that because she figured he was being led astray, but one day Snape called her a 'mudblood'; Lily was just like Hermione, she was born to muggle parents. Snape tried to apologize, but Lily saw that Snape was going down a dark path and she dropped the friendship. After they left Hogwarts, Snape basically joined the Nazi party of the wizarding world in order to get more powerful, fit in, and/or possibly win Lily back with his power. HE was the one who delivered the prophecy to Voldemort, which foretold of a child born at the end of July would be Voldemort's foe (Neville and Harry); Snape believed it to be Neville's family, but Voldemort believed it was Harry's. That's when Snape turned, asking Dumbledore for help. BUT in the books, at first he asked only that Lily be kept safe as he didn't care for Harry or James. And even after switching sides, Snape continued to mistreat Harry for the sins of his father. Sooooo yes, Snape wasn't completely "bad", but he wasn't completely all "good" either. And also yes, Harry tried to redeem Snape's image to the wizarding world after the war.
@@ChelseaChfy-ex1ponot really. James actually did a lot of maturing in his final years in school, whereas Snape didn’t. He ended up joining the death eaters
There actually is an escape from gringotts ride at universal studios Orlando. They have two Harry Potter sections one at islands of adventure (hogsmeade) and one at universal studios (diagon alley) . Both sections are connected by the hogwarts express.
Fun fact about this movie, Maggie Smith was battling cancer during filming but told no one until much later after filming wrapped. Also, the part where the Dark Lord hugs Draco was 100% improvised.
Pure blood elitism is basically racism. It's been around since forever. Salazar Slytherin was a pureblood elitist. That was over a thousand years ago. Voldemort didn't really turn people to the dark side, Voldemort gave people who were essentially racist a powerful wizard to rally behind.
The sorting hat does analyse you and place you, but you can overrule it. It wanted to place Harry is Slytherin, but Harry kept thinking “not Slytherin” so it placed him in the 2nd most fitting. “It is our choices, Harry, that shows who we truly are, far more than our abilities”
@@lenakohl2339 partly, as is mentioned a lot throughout the series: they have many likenesses, Harry possesses many qualities of Slytherin, and that the heir of Slytherin has part of his soul inside Harry might have tipped the scale for the hat.
The hat will take your chose into consideration but you cannot actually over rule it. Neville begged and begged the hatbto place him in Hufflepuff because he didn't feel brave but the hat pu/ him in Gryffindor anyways.
@@MrPozaidon Those qualities are shared by Slytherins and Gryffindors, the disregard for the rules. Harry is truly a Gryffindor and the hat was confused by the part of Voldemort inside him.
Harry has a strong thirst to prove himself (i.e. ambition) so he has strong Slytherin qualities. He would have fitted in any House really as he actually shows qualities of all four houses in quite strong abundance: he's a hard worker at things he is interested in (Hufflepuff), he's plenty intelligent enough for Ravenclaw and is more open-minded than Hermione, he's brave and true which make him a Gryffindor. Hermione also shows qualities that make her suitable for all four houses, but she's probably more suited to Hufflepuff+Gryffindor overall (yes, Hufflepuff - she's a hard worker, as well as intelligent, and much of her accomplishment is from effort as well as aptitude, she lacks certain qualities that would make her more suited to Ravenclaw).
Fun fact : Snape in the scene where he fights Minerva, he wasn't attacking back, he just mislead the spells to properly hit the death eaters next to him and them left.
The spend a lot more time in the book with Harry finally learning some of Dumbledore’s past and not all of it is good. There is a bit more payoff when Harry tells Aberforth that he still trusts Dumbledore.
Oh god I’m only 20 minutes in and I’m crying at everything 😂😂 I love reactions it really brings back some of the thrill of watching it for the first time knowing that it’s your first time and that you don’t know what to expect.
Always interesting that so many American reactors struggle to let go of the Elder wand when harry breaks it at the end ... "But, but, but, we might need its power!" Whereas most Brits are like "Good riddance, that was one evil piece of wood!" 🤣🤣🤣
@@xenbuffMe, too. But as a Yankee, I wasn't attached to the wand because Why would HP keep it. It represents so much pain? I wondered why HP didn't return it to its rightful owner, Dumbledore. It was torn from Dumbledore's hands in the coffin. Returning it would've been really touching
@LA_HA sure it is touching to return the most powerful weapon to a corpse. Letting anyone who wants to desecrate corpses bring the wand back. Might be generations but someone could find it and start another conga line of murder and violence in the name of power.
56:08 "That is gonna be the most awkward hug he's ever had" well, Voldemort doesn't have any single person that he could be loved so he never hug someone 😂
I needed this so bad today. I've been checking everyday waiting for this reaction. Allowing us to experience this journey with you guys has been a wonderful and cherished experience.
I dont know if you noticed, but when Harry, Ron, and Hermione are running through the courtyard, each magical creature they encounter represents some of the books/movies. Acromantula (giant spiders) were Aragogs children and represented the second movie/book. The dementors represented the third movie/book. The giant represented the fifth movie/book when they met Grawp. Fenrir Geyback feeding on Lavender represented the sixth movie/book given thats when we first meet him. I always thought that was clever nod to those who have been following the books/movies.
Are you guys watching fantastic beasts after finishing HP?? It is not the greatest but it expands the wizard world and it will give you a bigger depth about dumbledore. And the monsters are cute and amazing lol
@@acciomess I would have gladly skipped all 3 of them. The lesser of 3 evils was the last one just because... SPOILER ...I appreciated the scene in which they *stated out loud* that Grindelwald&Dumbledore were in love.
FINALLY you guys!! First time a reactor notices the parallel between Snape and Lily saying "always" 😊❤ I'm sure you already know by now but Snape was older than Lily, thus already sorted into Slytherin
I love Narissa Malfoy...I would like to dress up like her for Halloween and do the grey and black hair. "He's only a boy." Dumbledore's hand was injured when he was destroying the horcrux attached to the ring in which the Resurrection Stone was set. Dumbledore knew he would die so he had determined his death at Snape's hand would be the best course of action to gain Voldemort's trust, and because Draco had been designated to kill him, Dumbledore expected Draco would disarm him...thus taking control of the Elderwand. Even if Harry had not taken Draco's wand, the Elderwand would not be under Snape's control.
My aunt was just in the UK and stopped at Kings Cross where they have a Harry Potter Store, she got me the elder wand and sent it to me, just got it yesterday so this is perfect timing!!!!❤️❤️❤️
@@nickreacts6394 if you want a wand designed based on your personality there a cool site called Fantasy by Numbers that has wands made from real wood where you can take a quiz similar the house quiz that will design a wand for you. You can also build one yourself from all the different parts and colors they have to choose from. Highly recommend.
Guys, i just find this react and i highly recommend you read at least the three final chapters of Deathly Hollows... Harry walking under the invisible cloak seeing all the dead and the castle destruction, the scenes on the pensieve showing snape's story, the discription of Harry's feelings towards the end knowing he must die, his walk out of the castle to face death, his last chat with Dumbledore at Kings Cross, the last duel of Voldie and Harry and the descripton of the end (wich unlike the movie portrais Voldemort dying like a normal human being) IS PURE GOLD.
Escaping on the dragon was actually Harry's idea in the book. In the book Voldemort has been separated from the parts of his soul in the horcruxes that he doesn't feel it when they're destroyed...unlike the movie which is all mixed up on that subject. 36:20 That's Fiendfyre. Very hard to control and extremely dangerous. It can destroy horcruxes but Hermione didn't even dare think about using it. Snape is a very grey character. He did something very brave but he was still not a good person by any means.
The Fiendfyre spell is the one Voldy uses in the fight with Dumbledore at the ministry in HBP. Voldy, being a much more skilled wizard than Goyle, knows how to keep in under control. Also, it was Crabbe in the book, rather than Goyle. But they're pretty much interchangeable. The actor that played Crabbe got into some legal trouble, so he wasn't available for the movie.
Someone below pointed out that Snape, the master duelist, managed to "accidentally" deflect one of McGonical's spells into the Carrow twins, taking them out. If you look, when he runs, he bounces first to one Carrow, then the other, before going through the window. He was taking their wands on his way out.
This story is one where you wish you hadn’t heard of it so you can discover it for the first time again ❤ totally worth reading the books. Also, I think Wen would have a blast watching Willow, with Val Kilmer… more magic and lots of fun 🎉
Proposed way for Umbridge to die: She somehow manages to escape from Azkaban, goes on the run, gets all the way to Hogsmeade, hides in the Dark Forest, and then gets trampled by the centaurs, and then eaten by the acromantulas.
When Dumbledore asked If Snape started liking Harry, and Snape casted his patronus, it’s the same of lily’s. Snape is not telling he likes Harry, he’s telling Dumbledore that he have never forgot or had stopped loving Lily. That’s why he said “always”.
Best Dolores Umbridge character death, courtesy of The Emperor’s New Groove: “First, I’ll turn her into a flea, a harmless little flea. Then I’ll put that flea in a box. Then I’ll put that box inside of another box. Then I’ll mail that box to myself, and when it arrives, I’ll SMASH IT WITH A HAMMER!”
Dumbledore used the ring that they showed in the half blood Prince after they watched Slughornes memory. It had the resurrection stone in it initially and was a Gaunt family heirloom. The Gaunts are Voldemorts ancestors and they go into deep detail regarding this in the books. Dumbledore wanted to use the stone to bring his sister back but it backfired if i remember correctly. He then placed the stone in the snitch for Harry to make him master of death. You dont need to kill the previous owner to win the wand that was just part of the lore.
No, he finds the ring in early summer after year 5, he puts it on immediately when he recognizes the resurrection stone, he could not resist the temptation, he says so himself. The ring then curses him, and Dumbledore destroys the ring. Soon after Dumbledore tells Snape what happened. Snape then says that he can keep Dumbledore alive for a year, and that's when Dumbledore puts his final plans into motion. By the time Dumbledore goes to pick up Harry in the latter half of the summer holidays, he already has the cursed hand and knows he'll die and already plotted with Snape about the Draco situation.
@@Eagle3302PL you are correct. Sorry I phrased it wrong. I didnt mean that he got cursed in half blood prince i was merely referring to the fact that they showed the ring in that scene. Dumbledore had already been cursed at the start of the movie.
Fun fact: This film was nominated 3 categories at the Oscars: Best Art Direction, Best Visual Effects, and Best Make up. Art Direction - Lost to Hugo Visual Effects - Lost to Hugo Makeup - Lost to The Iron Lady
To answer your question, "Why does Voldemort have to do it?": Voldemort was unable to Kill Harry because of Lily's protection spell (This was the same reason Harry became 'the boy who lived'). The ancient magic that dumbledore told Lily about has a specific condition to activate: Willingly sacrificing oneself to protect loved ones; Lily's sacrifice ensured that the person who kills her can no longer harm people she loved. Ironically, this actually makes Voldemort the only person in the world who can destroy the horcrux inside Harry WITHOUT killing the original Harry as well. Voldemorts killing curse would only affect the piece of himself inside Harry. Dumbledore figured out this was the only way to destroy the horcrux inside Harry without killing Harry along with it. Furthermore, as a result of Harry's *willing* sacrifice to protect his friends and family, Voldemort was no longer able to kill any more people on Harry's side because Harry activated the same protection magic his mother used when he was a babe.
Lily's magic became obsolete when Voldemort used Harry's blood to resurrect himself. Harry possessed all the deathly hallows at the time of his death, so he became the master of death and was able to come back instead of "go on"
58:54 remember, u can only get the sword of griffondor if u have the heart of a true griffondor. The people that pulled the sword out of the sorting hat are Harry, nevil, and snape. I absolutely love that nevil gets the big scene of killing nagini and finding the sword
Also something I really hate that the movies didn't include was after Dumbledore says "Don't tell me now you've come to care for the boy?" they just go to him summoning his Patronus which was the same as Lily's again showing how much he loved her since his Patronus changed into hers which only happens if you truly love someone. In the books after Dumbledore says that line Snape yells' "FOR HIM!!??" then he summons his patronus. Sadly he did truly hate Harry since he represents how he lost the love of his life to one of his most hated enemies. He only protected him because of how much he loved Lily.
A GREAT scene from the books that doesn't make it in the movie; Harry is in the castle in the middle of the fight and sees a door bust open. Out of the door comes a herd of desks bewitched to gallop in a stampede-like fashion. Out with them flies McGonagall, her hair all messy, yelling "CHARGE!" and leading the desks to battle. Still makes me laugh when I picture that.
Another great book scene is Kreacher leading the castle's house-elves into the battle, screaming that he is doing it for his master, Harry. In the books, Harry pities and befriends Kreacher and he becomes completely devoted to Harry (nobody had ever treated him well before).
McGonagall's power should definitely be respected but I would never bet against Snape. If you had to pick a champion and your life depended on it, Snape would be my choice in that fight.
There are quite a few things that are never explicitly stated by Rowling anywhere. One of them is actually the exact way that the Elder Wand works. The whole "it belongs to the wizard who defeated the last owner" is kind of actually just fan canon and isn't completely official. Another thing that doesn't really have an explicit definitive answer is how Harry came back. Two of the prevalent theories are that he was either the Master of Death by being the true owner of the Elder Wand, the owner of the Invisibility Cloak and the owner of the Resurrection Stone, or that he was still tethered to life through Voldemort because some of Harry's blood lived within Voldemort and that blood still contained Lily's protective spell.
And the reason that Snape had to wait to tell Harry that he was a horcrux until the right time. Was that if the Master of Death theory is correct, Harry would have to face death? Truly believing that he was about to die. That would be the only way that he could truly Master death. If he went into the forest thinking that he would be able to come back then he would not have truly mastered death
Another theory is that Harry could never be killed by Voldemort because of his mother's sacrifice (mother's love). And when he cast the killing curse, it killed the only part of Harry it could: the part of Voldemort's soul within him.
Wand inheritance in general is inconsistent, but it appears that wands have some level of awareness and allegiance they themselves pick. Harry surviving is explained in the novel, due to Voldemort using Harry's blood to revive himself they are both protected by Lily's sacrifice, also Harry is the Elder Wand's master so it refuses to kill him. So when Voldemort casts the killing curse, curse which doesn't kill the body but kills by ripping the soul out of it, Voldemort kills his own soul fragment, while Harry's soul is untouchable to Voldemort's curses. Later on Harry and others are protected by protection magic from Harry sacrificing himself for everyone.
@@Eagle3302PL I pretty much agree with all of that, but those still are just fan theories. It's never actually explicitly explained how the elder Wand chooses its master. Harry's explanation of how him disarming Draco of a separate wand may not actually have meant anything. It's really just Harry's theory. Also, it's never explained how the killing curse actually works. The idea that it separates the soul from the body is yet another thing that us fans have come up with as an explanation, but is never actually explicitly stated in any of Rowling's writings.
It's more Alan you love for his acting skills! IF you have not checked them out, have look at "Sense and Sensibility" where he is Colonel Brandon or "Snow Cake" - he is perfect on this one or "Robin Hood, Prince of Thieves" - he was awesmee as the Sherrif as well. He was just an awesome actor (like Gary Oldman, Ralph Fiennes and Helena Boham Carter as well) Thank you for making my evening ! Happy sunday
So the reason Voldy died during the duel happened for a reason described afterward: Harry was the true master of the Elder Wand. Once Voldy became a mortal the Elder Wand sensed that his master was being attacked by Voldy so it allowed the killing curse to rebound into Voldy. If you rewatch right before Harry disarms Voldy you will see the green aura seeping into Voldy's arm that quickly spreads (indicated by his skin turning dark) and it eventually consumes him
Yes. I believe Voldemort was able to kill Harry in the woods because Harry wasn't fighting back. But when Harry chose to fight, he had "power the Dark Lord knows not" and the wand recognizing Harry as it's owner rebounded Voldy's killing curse back to him.
I haven't read the books, but it always seemed Snape stayed undercover because he could best help Harry. You may not have noticed, but when Snape escaped by bursting through the window, the last thing he did was incapacitate the 2 death eaters behind him.
In the finale battle, Harry said Expelliarmus as always and Voldy said Avadakebra, but because the wand belong to Harry all this time, the wand could harm his master but refuse to kill his master so the curse bounced back to Voldy and killed him, in the book Voldy just drop dead, but in the movie they wanted a more cinematic dead, that I actually dislike, I think dropping dead is a more "normal" way to died and Voldy never wanted to be ordinary, so is just fitting.
24:20 “That was bad-ass of McGonagal, right?” No. That was bad as of Snape. He deflected all her spells, didn’t hurt her, knocked out the Carrows, and escaped without a scratch. That is bad ass.
I haven't listened to your discussion yet or watched the reaction, but you should read up on the theory that Neville Longbottom could be the chosen one as well. He fits all the criteria that it requires.
It’s not really a theory. Harry and Neville were the two options the prophecy could have been talking about (they both fit all the criteria). Harry is “the chosen one” because Voldemort chose him. Harry was a half blood, just like Voldemort, so Voldemort saw him as a bigger threat.
Yeh it’s not a theory. The prophecy spoke of a boy that fit both Neville and Harry. Voldermort cemented the prophecy in stone by marking Harry as his equal.
1:04:05 Nick: Harry looks a lot like his father. Me: Except for his eyes, he's got his- Harry (behind me): Mother's eyes, I know. Me: WTF? How did you get in my house!?
The Death eaters that were in Hogwarts with Snape, The Carrows ,were killed by Snape by deflecting that spell professor McGonagall shot at him. It happens so quick it's easy to miss
Re: extended cut - they do have one - the books 🤣🙂🙃 I'm teasing, but a lot of your theories and questions are answered in the books. I'm so glad that they're doing the TV series, and are planning to go in depth with it! There's so much (understandably, because goodness, the movies would be impossibly long) missing from the movies, so I'm so excited for those who haven't read the books to get deeper into the series!! (I wasn't trying to be snarky with the book comment, just letting you know there's a lot more in the books)
Dumbledore's hand was damaged from the ring. It was a horcrux but he wanted to wear it and it cursed him. Severus contained it as well as he could but it was still going to spread.
Remember the story of the Three Brothers? The Elder Wand -the MOST poerful wand EVER made. The Cloak of Invisibility & the Resurrection Stone (in the story-the Peverell brother "brought back" his lost love but she was too sad to "be" in the world,so she ultimately hung herself. So it seems that the Resurrection Sone brought back the spirit of a person, perhaps neither in life or death @ the same time. @ the end of the movie, the Stone raised the spirits of all those Harry most loved - Lilly, James, Sirius & Remus, all those whose strength he needed, to face Voldemort when going to his death.
@ 59:10 - I think the spells Molly used on Belatrix were "Petrificus Totalus" (total body binding/petrification) and then "Bombarda Maxima" (the massive explosion spell) that Umbridge used in Order of the Phoenix to destroy the entrance to the Room of Requirement.
judging from the scene with Olivander regarding the wands and how they "think", it appears the reason they didn't want to hand over Bellatrix's wand is that the wand could reveal Hermione was not Bellatrix. especially if any of the goblins had studied wand lore and could "communicate" with them like Olivander
Voldemort had no reason to suspect Narcissa would lie to him about Harry being dead because he has never understood love. It’s his greatest weakness
He never understood love or friendship, and he firmly believed he was more clever than any other wizard. So he couldn't (or wouldn't) believe that anyone else could figure out what or where his horcruxes were.
Exactly. Voldemort was very Machiavellian - he understood fear but not love. He felt none of his followers would ever lie to him because they feared him too much. Instead, they were capable of lying to him because they feared Voldemort but they loved something or someone even more than their fear.
Really it was because he could just read her mind and find out, what he doesn't know is she's a powerful Occlumens, like Snape.
@@janeryan2709 They couldn't lie, Voldemort is a Legillimens.(Unless they were Occlumens like Snape and Narcissa.
Bella too @@brittanylewandowski6200
a detail i love is that snape never cast any spell against mcgonagall and instead sent her spell against the evil siblings behind him
i was just coming to say this :)
Not in the book though, they have a real fight.
and before escaping he took their wands
@@NecramoniumVideo The fight in the book is pretty epic, in general the fights in the books are much better than the movies. But in typical industry fashion, script writers think they can do better than the world beloved and critically acclaimed novel.
I missed that thank you!
When Snape said "You have your mother's eyes", it was the first time Harry realized that Snape knew his mother. Every person who's ever said that to Harry was a friend of Lily's.
But Harry also saw Snape's memories in the 5th book...? 🤔
@@Tchika That one memory revealed that he was at school with her and knew her a bit, yes, but not that they were friends, let alone that he loved her. Harry was actually left with the impression that Snape despised Lily as a Mudblood.
@@christinabrock2893 right, I was trying to remember, how it was in the books, because in the movies they showed memories to Harry which implied more... But you're right, the memories didn't show any of those romanticising moments in the books
In the film, yes, but in the book, Harry already knows that Snape knew his mother in Book 5. And Snape once had an argument with Lily, Snape even taunted Lily with the word Mudblood.
@@KhrlIRD45 Snape didn't exactly "taunt" Lily with Mudblood; he yelled it out of frustration because he was being bullied by James and lost his cool. Still no excuse for him to say it.
Helena Bonham Carter playing Hermione playing Bellatrix is some of the best acting out there!
She's just a dude playing a dude, playing another dude 😂
Yes!!!
I saw part of an interview with her, apparently those scenes were also really fun for her.
I saw some of the behind the scenes for that. HBC basically shadowed Emma Watson for days, if not weeks, to get all her mannerisms. I think there's a scene where the directors calls her Helena, and she's like "Call me Emma"
@@lingodelfo5415 Yeah, the time tested method of, well, method acting. Most of the best actors use it and some have even been known to take it *really* far. Ryan Renolds for one...to no one's surprise.
Harry's first words about Snape; " Who is that Professor?"
Harry's last words about Snape; " He was the breavest man I have ever known"
Severus Snape is a beautiful example of a perfectly written tragic hero. A man who made grave mistakes and died trying to right his wrongs. He saw James, the man he hated, every time he looked at Harry but he saw the eyes of the woman he loved as well. He was incredibly flawed, took his hatred out on Harry but he was good in the end.
This happen when you have only watched movies . Snape is the person who told the prophecy to voldemort. Snape is the person who was death Eater before lilys death .
@@atuljha438 also, Snape wanted Dumbledore to save Lily, didn't give a fuck about James or Harry snuffing it. And you have to be a special kind of cruel to be a student's worst fear, in particular when said student have had his parents tortured beyond recognition.
Snape was on the side of good, but he wasn't a good person.
@@atuljha438 and the book clearly explained that he didn’t expect Voldemort to hunt the potters in response to hearing the prophecy which is why he went to Dumbledore in the first place. He realized his grave mistake and tried his best to right his terrible wrong hence: perfect example of a tragic hero.
@@TheR15CTurning to Dumbledore to beg him to save Lily and Lily only. Therefore clearly no hero, tragic or not, but a villain trying to find redemption though still bad.
@@ryusukeminami52 and proceeded to protect Harry in ways that were finally explained in the chapter the Prince’s tale. If he were anything but a tragic hero then he wouldn’t have felt motivated to remedy his poor choices. Simple as that
I never understood why the films changed this, but in the books, after Harry learnt that he must die, he went to the forest with his invisibility cloak on, because he knew that ron and hermione would never let him go, and he himself can't bear saying goodbye to them...all he did was telling Neville that the snake must be killed, and that is exactly what he did
Yeah so true. I also find it annoying they had Hermione hug Harry but not have Ron hug Harry. If they were going to have him say good bye to them, Ron should’ve hugged him too or at least looked a little more upset. Just another moment where they made Ron look like a douche in the movies for no reason.
Yeah I always find these things totally under-acted. Not just in these movies but in general. That gut wrenching grief doesn't just flit across your face. It makes you collapse and wail and throw all logic out of the window
Solo dos palabras: David Yates
Harry is saved by 2 mothers.. At the beginning his own mother saved him and she died, at the last Malfoy's mother saved him and tell lie...
And Petunia. It's addressed in the books that Harry retuning to Petunia's home every summer is part of what protected him as it renewed his family blood bond. This whole movie is full of mothers including Ron and Ginny's mom who made space in her family for Harry.
The whole point of the story is the power of love and more specifically, a mother's love.
And Molly Weasley saved him countless times in so many ways, large and small.
@@llanitedave going like that we can say this is a story of a bus drivers who in IV saved him by driving him around
@vert2552 This is actually the story of Ron Weasley who if he didn’t walk into Harry’s compartment on the train and made friends with him would have never had any of the allies that Harry did to help him defeat the dark lord/deatheaters. If it wasn’t for Ron making Hermione cry in the bathroom they would have never become best friends and there would not be a trio. Ron Weasley pulled this whole story to the end. 😂
Dumbledore's sister Ariana died during a fight between Dumbledore and Grindelwald when they were young and close. No one knows whose curse killed her. After the incident, Grindelwald ran away and became the greatest dark wizard of that era.
Aberforth was also part of the dual. So out of the three of them, it's unknown whose curse killed Ariana.
Dumbledores story could be a book on its own.
The HP series is worth a read especially to those who watched the movies. It answers so many questions the movies couldn't fit in.
Dumbledore is gay ?
So to answer a question that you asked about the patronus "does that mean her true love was snape?". Short answer no, but love does effect patronus'. James' patronus was a stag (like Harry's) and Lilly's was a doe, making them the perfect counter parts for each other, and effectively soulmates as a patronus is kinda a reflection of the individual. However, strong love can actually cause your patronus to change which is what happens to Snape's patronus. He loves lily so much his pateonus changes to match hers. In the book this also happens to Tonks after she falls in love with Remus (and snape actually mocks her for this).
Imagine calling a wolf pathetic when you got a doe lol
@@cariann2220I think perhaps he was calling himself “pathetic” in that moment, as he knew it was already the same situation in his case
@@cariann2220Actually Snape being Snape, understood who the patronous resembled and actually mocked Lupin not really Tonks. Snape was petty and bitter and couldn't let go of his grudge. Though I understand his side, but he took it out on all innocent people even children, that is unacceptable and that is also why he mocked Tonks.
@@cariann2220definitely projection on Snape’s part.
In fact, Snape is the only (former) death eater with a patronous.
Even sadder about Remus and Tonks is they had a child who was now orphaned. Luckily Harry was named the Godfather (Remus had a much bigger role in the book and met with them while they were at Bill and Fleur's) and helped raise their son
The child also had at least one grand parent who raised him (Since I never read any background info I don't know whether Ted Tonks his grandfather was killed.)
@@sawanna508he was killed. In the books he was un the run along with dean thomas, who was muggleborn. The trio finds out later that they were captured and killed. ( fred and george held a silent moment for them on their underground resistance radio show, along with lupin and kingsley i do believe)
@@sawanna508 Yeah his grandfather Ted was killed and he was actually named Teddy "Ted" in his honor.
I love Lupin, and Tonks. I think the characters got royally screwed in the novies.
Andromeda Dracos other aunt is still alive so she can take care of her grandchild
I wish they had my favorite part at the end. In the book, Ron told the kids that if they were not sorted into Gryffindor, they will disinherit them. And then says “But no pressure.” And Hermione is like, “Ron!”
LOL😂😂
And when the kids are confused by everyone staring at them (maybe Harry never told them about his fame?), Ron told them, "oh, I'm terribly famous!"
Sorry in advance for this VERY LONG essay.
In HBP, Dumbledore was dying slowly and painfully due to the curse from the ring when he tried to destroy it, which is why he wanted Snape to kill him (as well as to protect Draco and cement his position with Voldemort). When Dumbledore said "Please" he was actually asking Snape to kill him.
Voldemort created the Horcruxes in an attempt to cheat death. Appropriately, his name is French for "Flight of Death" or "Steal/Cheat of death". Also, he had planned to split his soul in 7 pieces, which means 6 horcruxes AND his physical body. Then he would become mortal and could therefore be killed. But he unintentionally made the 7th horcrux with Harry when he killed his parents (and tried to kill him), therefore there were 8 pieces of his soul. The horcruxes were destroyed in the order they were created - diary, ring, locket, cup, diadem, Harry and Nagini.
The Resurrection Stone doesn't actually bring people back from the dead, it just temporarily calls the soul back to earth in a form between living people and ghosts. In the book, Harry stops on his way to the forest when he remembers the snitch. Seeing his dead loved ones not only gives him the strength and courage to go through with letting Voldemort kill him but their spectral form visible only to him act as Patronus' to get past the Dementors. Harry is in limbo (between life and death) when he meets Dumbledore at King's Cross, so he isn't really dead. That is because 1. He is the true master of all of the Deathly Hallows and therefore the true Master of Death, which doesn't make you immortal but simply means you accept death (which is also why he couldn't fight back). 2. It only killed the part of Voldy's soul (the Horcrux) that was in him and made him mortal. 3. He chose to go back (Dumbledore said he could still choose to die). Also, the reason Voldy had to be the one to kill Harry, as Dumbledore said, is because Voldy bound him to himself when he took his blood during his resurrection in GoF. Dumbledore knew that Harry would have to face him and "die" by his hand in order to trick Voldy into destroying the Horcrux inside Harry. He just couldn't let Snape know.
Voldemort killed Snape because he thought the Elder Wand belonged to him since Snape killed Dumbledore. But he didn't realise that whoever disarmed Dumbledore is the one who owned the wand (not who killed him) which was Draco. And when Harry disarmed Draco in DH P1, he became the owner. Snape didn't just die to save Harry, I believe he also died to save Draco because he made the Unbreakable Vow to protect him. And when Voldy asked him who owned the Elder Wand, Snape said it belonged to him, but he knew the wand answered only to Draco and he knew Voldy would kill Draco once he realised that. That's why he didn't put up a fight against Nagini. At least that's how I see it.
Snape saying "Look at me. You have your mother's eyes." to Harry is because Lily's eyes were the last thing he wanted to see. Snape loved Lily but Lily didn't love Snape, at least not as more than friends. And once he started dabbling in the dark arts she distanced herself from him and eventually fell in love with James who was also Snape's mortal enemy. The deeper meaning of Snape's patronus changing into a doe like Lily's is that Lily's Patronus only became a doe after she fell in love with James (to compliment his stag). In PoA when Dumbledore explained to Harry that when he cast his Patronus, it was, in a way, his father appearing to protect him (so Harry was partially right that it was his dad who saved him). Snape's Patronus changing into the same form that Lily's used to take was proof that she was still protecting Harry. Snape hated James (for good reason), but if his Patronus changed into the form that Lily's had taken only when she fell in love with James, it would mean that he had come to accept the choices that she had made and was genuinely determined to protect her son, in spite of his hatred for his father.
If you watch carefully in the duel between Snape and McGonagall, you can see that Snape deflects a spell cast from McGonagall, which hits the Death Eater twins the Carrows behind him. This foreshadows which side Snape was truly on. And, while it's clear where Snape's loyalties lied, I keep seeing fans argue whether he was actually good or bad. But as Sirius and Dumbledore both said, everyone has a bit of both inside them. What matters is which path you choose to follow. For years Snape chose to follow Voldemort and was a legit Death Eater. He is a arguably the most complex character in the series. The way he treated Harry was despicable. Even if it was because of James it doesn't excuse it or explain his treatment of other people. He was a bitter person and a bully. BUT, he had played the double (triple?) agent all this time and he did it to save Harry, or more specifically, Lily's son. Snape, despite all his flaws, could love. The fact that he could love without having been loved himself is what made him good (as opposed to Voldemort).
Harry and Voldemort's final duel plays out very differently in the book. It's a super intense confrontation in the Great Hall with EVERYONE watching. Harry tells Voldy the truth about Snape and the Elder Wand, before using a Disarming Charm to defeat him. His death is very human as he drops to the ground and leaves a body behind (they filmed that version: ruclips.net/video/rFMxRv2Zaj0/видео.htmlsi=7pYEUvBtE6wlvAbN). While the film version is more visually pleasing, it just doesn't feel as intense or final. It also goes against the original point that without magic, Voldemort dies just like any other man, and he was never actually as "special" as he believed. That's probably what I am most mad about regarding the book-to-film adaptations.
Voldemort caused his death in three ways. Firstly, by "killing" Harry he unintentionally destroyed the Horcrux, as Voldemort was unaware of that. Secondly, he possibly forgot about Nagini due to his determination to kill Harry and remembered her after she died, and thirdly, as he was not the true owner of the Elder Wand, it recognised Harry as its owner and allowed his killing curse to rebound and kill him.
In the book Harry learns Dumbledore's darkest secret: That he may have accidentally killed his sister Ariana (she is the portrait that Aberforth has to help Neville and the kids travel back and forth). Ariana had trouble suppressing her magic as she accidentally killed their mother and required constant care and attention. In a duel between Dumbledore, his brother Aberforth, and Dumbledore's friend-turned-enemy Gellert Grindelwald (According to JKR, Dumbledore was gay and in love with Grindelwald), Ariana was killed, and none of them knew who cast the spell that caused her death. Dumbledore was reliving this memory in the cave when he and Harry went looking for the locket in HBP.
In the book Harry returns the Elder Wand to Dumbledore's grave, which would leave the wand without a master and cause it to lose its power. But before he does, he uses it to fix his. While breaking it is surely safer, it makes no sense why he didn't at least fix his wand first, since the Elder Wand is the only wand capable of mending broken ones!
And Harry DOES lose the ability to speak Parseltongue after Voldemort kills the Horcrux inside him.
Neville being the one to kill the snake and essentially kill Voldemort is quite poetic since he could have been "The Chosen One" as his birthday is also at the end of July and his parents had also defied Voldemort three times (as the prophecy said). It's never explained in the films though.
I'm conflicted on the Malfoys. They were pure-blood fanatics (especially Lucius) and Draco was a bully. But Narcissa never seemed interested in any of it and in the end all she cared about was keeping Draco safe. That's why she told Voldemort that Harry was dead (which made it the second time Harry was saved by a mother's love). Also, notice how Draco didn't come when his dad called him but as soon as his mum called him he did? Some could argue that them leaving and not fighting with Voldemort was a statement in itself, but it could also be seen as cowardly. So I wish they had kept one scene in - when Harry revealed that he was still alive, Draco was meant to help him by throwing him his wand. The scene was filmed but not included in the final cut: ruclips.net/video/V6m4vuT_pME/видео.htmlsi=sYwtYueHmVskPSdD. Even though it wasn't in the book I am still mad they didn't keep it in.
Before the scene was shot where Hermione is pretending to be Bellatrix, Emma Watson acted out the scene for Helena Bonham Carter so she would know how to act as if she were Hermione in this situation. So, essentially, this scene is Helena acting like Emma acting as Hermione acting like Bellatrix. Also, they couldn't use her wand because it was reported stolen so they would've known it was an imposter.
If you really want to cry: When Harry reveals himself to be alive and everyone reacts with joy, if you look closely at George he starts saying 'Fred' before remembering that he is dead.
Voldemort hugging Draco was not scripted but improv by Ralph Fiennes. Tom Felton genuinely didn't know how to react so the look of confusion and discomfort is real. Most of Voldemort’s speech was improv as well.
I recommend reacting to the 20th anniversary special and maybe Fantastic Beasts (at least the first two). I also recommend taking the REAL Sorting Hat Quiz on wizardingworld.com to see what house you're in (I'm a proud Hufflepuff!).
******* SPOILER IF YOU WANNA READ THE BOOKS *******
In the book, Harry becomes an Auror and eventually Head of Auror Office and Head of the Department of Magical Law Enforcement under Minister for Magic Kingsley Shacklebolt (Aurors are sort of the wizard police). Ginny becomes a professional Quidditch player and eventually the senior Quidditch correspondent at the Daily Prophet. Harry and Ginny get married and have three children: James Sirius, Albus Severus and Lily Luna. Harry is also very close to his godson Teddy Lupin and remains on "Christmas card terms" with his cousin Dudley. Aunt Petunia is believed to have passed away in 2020 (3 years after the epilogue).
Hermione tracks down her parents in Australia and reverses the memory spell she cast on them. She works for the Department for the Regulation and Control of Magical Creatures and pursues her dream to improve conditions for underprivileged magical creatures like the house-elves. She becomes Deputy Head of the Department of Magical Law Enforcement and, eventually replacing Kingsley as Minister for Magic. Ron becomes an Auror but leaves after two years to work at Weasleys' Wizard Wheezes with his brother George. Hermione and Ron have two children: Rose and Hugo. Ron is also the godfather of Harry and Ginny's first son, James Sirius.
Neville also becomes an Auror before changing his mind and becoming a Herbology teacher at Hogwarts and, eventually, Head of Gryffindor House. He also marries Hufflepuff Hannah Abbott. While the two don't have children, Neville is the godfather of Harry's second son, Albus Severus.
Luna becomes a famous Magizoologist, discovering numerous magical creatures never before introduced to the Wizarding World. She marries Rolf Scamander, the grandson of Newt Scamander who is the protagonist of the Fantastic Beasts series. They have twin sons: Lorcan and Lysander. In my mind, Neville and Luna ended up together in the books too.
The Malfoys are pardoned for their crimes because Lucius provides evidence against his fellow Death Eaters, and likely because of Narcissa's lie as well. Draco doesn't really have a job because he's so rich but he dedicates much of his time to the pursuit of alchemy. He marries Astoria Greengrass, the younger sister of a fellow Slytherin. She is not welcomed into the family because she doesn't share their racist pure-blood ideals, even after Draco stands up to his parents. The two have a son named Scorpius Hyperion. Unfortunately, Astoria dies young from a blood curse. Draco raises his son to be far more accepting than he was. At Hogwarts, Scorpius and Albus Severus, both in Slytherin, become great friends.
McGonagall takes over as Headmistress and Hagrid stays in his position at Hogwarts.
Finally, Umbridge is put on trial, found guilty and sentenced to life imprisonment for her crimes. So unfortunately she doesn't die but she gets punished for her crimes.
@@Heida77I love how thorough you were in your comments - shows you're definitely a Potterhead 😊Sincerely, a fellow Hufflepuff
Yess, especially the part about how much better the book ended with the duel. I had no idea they filmed that version, I’ll definitely check out that link!
@@Heida77 After seeing what it was like in Azkaban I think I would rather die.
@@westiefan1 Yay Hufflepuffs! Always afraid no one is gonna read my long ass comments 😆
26:43 Most don't notice but just to the left you can see Slughorn drinking liquid luck after he came out the door.
So to address a few more things, since I commented early in your recap. Neville and Ron both had inherited wands. Neville had his dad's, and Ron had his brother's. Both wands were broken, after which there was a noticeable improvement to their success in working spells. Because the wand chooses the wizard, they were essentially handicapped by having the wrong wand.
You'd really think Hogwarts would implement a wand scholarship to make sure students were able to achieve their full potential 😂
movie snape: "hide them, hide them all. I beg you."
book snape: "okay I told him to kill the husband and son and spare her"
what i kinda love about neville is in the first movie dumbledore called him brave. it just shows how dumbledore sees people’s true self
46:45 you said " where did he get that" ( Dumbledore's cursed hand) .. But you saw it at Half Blood Prince.. Dumby said to Harry.." I found one of that horcrux..The Ring.. Hard to find, and even harder to destroy" (Dumby showed his cursed hand while he said this)
More than that - the ring held the resurrection stone, which Dumbledore recognized and coveted. He didn't want to destroy the stone with the ring and received the curse as he took the stone from the ring, trying to use it to bring his sister back to life.
@@jzero4813 bro yes, that's true but these guys are newly watched the reaction video.. Your comment has so much details.. you dont need to suffocate them with details.. They will read the books and they will see.. No offence bro, dont misunderstand me but I can write more than you about details.. That cause confussion.. Simple and short general informations are easy to understand.. Because how much details, that much questions in their mind :))
Also you asked why Voldemort didnt just check himself if Harry was dead. In the book he actually does, but in a brutal fashion. He uses a high powered Cruciatus curse (the torture curse) on Harry and Harry almost bites through his tongue in an effort to stay quiet and not move during it. Its well established that Voldemort is arrogant in the knowledge of his power and would see that as enough proof because surely this insignificant boy could not keep quiet when the all mighty dark lord tortured him. Also, its speculated that Narcissa is more powerful then she shows because most definetly Voldemort checked her thoughts which means she's most likely a powerful occlumens on par with Dumbledore.
Narcissa is Bellatrix sister who daught Draco occlumens. So either Bellatrix daught her to or the Black sisters are naturally gifted in that ability.
If i recall harry actually doesn’t feel the pain from that curse. I don’t remember why, since there is so many layers of protective spells surrounding him at this point
@@mattiasandersson8693 Oh thats right! Sorry, I think I read the biting the tongue thing in a fanfic or something and got the parts confused. Thanks for catching me on that
@@sawanna508 Thats a good point. The Black family as a whole were very powerful so thats entirely possible.
@@sawanna508 I imagine that anyone in Voldy's inner circle had to be able to protect their mind, otherwise he'd never keep them around because he'd always know their real thoughts, and he also wouldn't be able to reveal any plans or secrets to them, because they could be compromised by a mind reader. So for his own sake and their sake they'd have to be able to protect their minds.
I love in the scene where Pansy demands that someone grab Harry when Voldemort says they have an hour, Ginny steps in front of him, Cho steps up to the left of him, and Hermoine steps up on his right. Luna and the Patil twins step up too. The first people to protect Harry are the girls who cared most about him.
Oh please, PLEASE watch the "Return to Hogwarts" reunion. It's not just stale interviews... they actually return to the school... I think you'd both really like it.
Omg I hope they do! 😭
Absolutely! It's wonderful!
Жаль только что половина каста не взяли, включая создателя Роулинг, по каким-то дурацким вбросам, но политика что поделать) Получается неполноценное возвращение
@@tomriddle4114 some, like Julie Walters, had major health issues. Understandable. Some due to other commitments. Yes, J.K. wasn't there because of politics or whatever you want to call it. Death had a role in a lot not being there either. Ever been to a reunion? Not everyone shows up but that doesn't make it less of a wonderful time.
I haven’t heard of that before
The sword of Gryffindor was infected/infused with the basilisk venom when Harry killed it. Neville was born on the same day as Harry, he could have been the boy in Trelawny's prediction. It was symbolic that Neville killed the last horcrux with the sword of Gryffindor.
Neville was born one day before Harry not the same.
@@sawanna508 forgot I believe the prophecy was the month? could have been Neville or Harry.
@@connie2558 The Prophesy stated "born at the end of July". Neville was born on the 30th, Harry on the 31st.
More importantly, prophesies can only be found in the Dept of Mysteries by the person the prophesy is about.
Harry didn't find the Prophesy; Neville did.
And yes; Neville destroyed the last horcrux, which led to the discorporation/death of Voldemort.
@@chris...9497 No, not found. They can only be retrieved by those it's about, meaning only Harry and Voldemort can pick it up and take it. Other people can obviously go around looking for a specific prophecy and look at it. Malfoy had already found it, they were waiting there for Harry to pick it up.
@@chris...9497 nope, its about picking it up, touching it. by that point neville was already out of the prophecy as it mentions that the dark lord will mark him as his equal. Neville was out of the prophecy the night lily and james died.
Snape didn’t want to be a Gryffindor, yeah he wanted to be with Lily but in the books he’s very proud he was a Slytherin! He wanted Lily to be sorted into Slytherin instead.
Pretty typical of Snape, Lily always had to be the one to sacrifice in their "friendship".
@@maraudentium2607 yeah thought that when I typed it lol
Yup! In fact, he used to hang out with his slytherin friends who used to call themselves "deatheaters". Lily had asked him to leave them but he didn't and even insulted Lily by calling her a mudblood. And one major detail which they changed in the movies is that he had asked Voldemort "to kill the father and the boy but spare Lily".
Dumbledore’s hand was cursed when he wore Tom Riddles ring (the Guant Family Heirloom, it was a horcrux too)
Gaunt, not Guant.
What a wonderful reaction from you both!
Quynh is such a pure and kind soul! I just wanted to come through the screen and give her a hug. It's always so refreshing to see people express real emotion, especially when this world seems so heartless at times. Thank you both! 💙
The two Death Eaters they mentioned as being on staff were the two people behind Snape during the confrontation in the Great Hall. When McGonagle was sending bursts of fire as Snape, if you watch carefully, you can see that two of them, rather than blocking them, he kind of redirects them, hitting both of those Death Eaters before he fled out through the window. One more act of heroism.
Just wanted to say that imo Warwick Davis gives a fantastic performance as Griphook and deserves some praise.
he was indeed amazing as both Griphook and Professor Filius Flitwick.
Not surprising Neville is so brave. Remember when Dumbledore said, "It takes a great deal of bravery to stand up to your enemies, but a great deal more to stand up to your friends." Neville's the one who won the house cup for Gryffindor that first year. Also, knowing how bravely his parents fought against Voldemort the first time, I'm not surprised he's got that fire in him. Amazing build-up to that moment.
That “always” always gives me goosebumps even if i watch it over and over again
i hate that they didnt include the scene where Draco threw a wand to Harry at the end, it would be a nice redemption moment for him
That wand would not be much of a use to Harry because it didn't chose him. Beside it dosn't fit in because if Harry is disweapped he would lose the alligence of the Elder Wand.
I hate that they cut the scene of Petunia leaving her home and also Dudley's farewell to Harry.
Harry already has Draco's wand at this point. He doesn't need Draco's mother's wand. Besides, Draco would never do that, especially in front of Voldemort.
@@sawanna508the point though, is it would show Malfoy taking the right side
@@jessicamacaulay7462& would completely change his character from the books so good thing they cut it
"Its a school they learned" 😂😂😂😂 i have watched DOZENS of reactions to HP and you guys were one of my favourites! A great final reaction!!! ❤😊
Thank you so much!
Clarification on Snape- Snape loved Lily as a child. Besides for being beautiful she was the first person who was good to him. They remained best friends till 5th year when Snape had many bad friends and aspired to be a death eater when he left Hogwarts. While being humiliated by James, Snape called Lily a Mudblood when she came to his defense. Later he apologized but Lily told him she can no longer ignore who he had become and who he wants to be. However Snape never stopped loving her and hating James.
He hated Harry, who looked just like James, because Harry was the constant reminder that the women he loved married the man he hated.
In the books, Snape overhears the prophecy about a boy will be born who has the power to vanquish Voldemort. When Voldemort interoperates the prophecy to mean Harry, Snape ask Voldemort to spare Lily so he can have her. However, Dumbledore, who knows Snape overheard it, convinces Snape to agree to be his spy in exchange for Dumbledore protecting not just Lily but the entire Potter family.
Here Snape agrees, ONLY if Dumbledore agrees to never tell anybody that he is helping the good side.
Snape worked as a "double agent" working for Dumbledore from that moment on.
So Snape told Voldemort what night the Order was moving Harry from the Dursleys BUT using powerful magic, planted the idea in an order members head about using the potion to make 7 Harrys, hopefully ensuring Harrys safety through the attack.
Snape would give enough information to make him Voldemort's most trusted advisor while withholding key information.
In terms of the Elder Wand, no one knew that Dumbledore had it. Only Voldemort and Harry figure it out around the time of escaping Malfoys Manor. So Snape had no idea it was the elder wand or where Voldemort got it until Voldemort told him (when he was about to kill him). Snape did not know he was about to be killed and did not want to be because he still had the final information to give to Harry. That was not part of the plan.
You said one interessting/disturbing plot point. Dumbledore knew, that Voldemort knew, that he had the Elder Wand.
He also knew that Voldemort would try to get and that (at least to the Wizarding Worlds folklore) the Elder Wand is past over by the death of the owner... knowing all this, Dumbledore still plans his death with Snape....in case you havnt noticed, with this arangement, Dumbledore is sentening Snape to death.
@@thomasnieswandt8805 exactly. while reading this chapter in the book the year it came out, I threw the book away from me cos I finally understood Dumbledore is a very manipulative and cunning guy but at the same time, he knew that if it doesn't happens that way, Draco will lose himself by killing him. So that part of Dumbledore at the same time totally was heartbroken himself cos he had huge respect for Snape as well. he is such a beautiful character and one of my favourite becos of that. such layered character and so many nuances .
Just to clear a few things up:
1) Dumbledore got the curse by putting the Grunt's Family Ring (the Ring Horcrux) on without having needing to, his biggest weakness was power so when he noticed the ring contained the Resurrection Stone even at his age he gave into weakness again (hence why he choose to be only a Headmaster instead of Minster for Magic because he didn't trust himself with that kind of power).
2) The Dumbledore brothers did have a falling out over Albus's lust for power & him going down a dark path with his friend Grindelwald (who's the main villain in the Fantastic Beasts series). Albus, Aberforth & Grindelwald got into a massive dual which ended up killing their little sister Ariana. Side note when Dumbledore drank from the Drink of Despair in the Half Blood Prince he was forced to relive that memory of the that dual where his sister died.
3) Voldemort died by having his own killing curse rebound onto himself, because harry was the Master of the Elder Wand the wand won't kill its actually master (hence why Dumbledore said Voldemort must be the one to kill Harry because he knew Voldemort would take the Elder Wand & while he meant for Snape to end up with it the plan was always to give it to Harry to protect him from Voldemort).
4) Snape was undercover because he was the one that gave half the prophecy to Voldemort which sent him after the Potters in the first place (and why he went to Dumbledore), he said he'd do "anything" to Dumbledore which was spy on Voldermort for him.
5) Snape & Lily relationship was breaking apart because Snape was super into the Dark Arts even against Lily's wishes he keep diving deeper & deeper into dark magic & their relationship ended when in a moment of anger Snape called Lily a "Mudblood" (after being bullied by James again). Because of Alan Rickman's great performance (and a little change for Movie purposes) people often confuse by Snape because he's motivation is different Book Snape only cared about revenge & Lily, Movie Snape was a Anti-Hero.
Yes! People who haven’t read the books don’t realize what Snape really is. Do I feel bad and get always, yes. But I also get he was always a bad person. A bully to most students and not a good guy.
27:18 "I've always wanted to use that spell." that is my favorite quote of the entire series. Granted other lines have a lot of weight too, but it really humanized McGonagall in a way we really never saw before.
re: Does Voldemort feel bad about killing other wizards?
No, he has no empathy for them. But in the books especially, Voldemort is shown to almost worship magic, so pure-blood magic-doers would have some worth in his eyes.
I literally have been refreshing my RUclips all day waiting for this 👉👈
Cool detail, after Harry saw him kill Dumbledore, he called him just Snape, but when he found out about the truth behind Snape's actions he called him Professor Snape again, it's like his respect kinda came back again after that moment.
Oh, man.... seeing Fred lying on the floor in the Great Hall dead is heartbreaking, especially seeing Ron break down in tears. (Hearing that Harry had to sacrifice himself to give them a chance of defeating Voldemort and the Death Eaters didn't help that grief.) Also, I was at the midnight premiere of The Deathly Hallows Part 2 in 3D. The scene where Mrs. Weasley took out Bellatrix got a massive cheer from the audience.
7 points I've made or seen in the past regarding Harry Potter:
1. The prophecy Professor Dumbledore mentioned in Professor Snape's memory that mentioned a baby born at the end of July was partially true. There were actually two: Harry Potter and Neville Longbottom. They were born in the same month and year, but Neville is only 1 day older than Harry. (Neville: 30 July 1980, Harry: 31 July 1980.) Voldemort had chosen to target a then 15-month-old Harry, thus marking him as his equal. Neville lived a life free of that fear with his grandmother, despite the constant painful reminder of his parents being permanently admitted to St Mungo's Hospital for Magical Maladies and Injuries after being tortured into insanity by Bellatrix Lestrange.
2. In the scene where Professor McGonagall steps in to protect Harry from Professor Snape....if you notice, he never raises his wand to actually attack her. He actually deflects the spells hurled at him at the two Death Eaters behind him, the Carrows....the very same pair that Neville said were forcing the students to practice the Cruciatus Curse on first years.
3. Voldemort's death after his battle with Harry wasn't supposed to look like he got snapped out by Thanos, and it wasn't just them isolated in the courtyard. In the book, Harry and Voldemort battle for the last time in front of everyone else, resulting in Voldemort dying as a mortal man once Neville sliced off Nagini's head.
4. Harry didn't snap the Elder Wand in the book version. He mends his original wand (the one he got in Philosopher's Stone from Ollivander's) with it, then returns it to Professor Dumbledore's grave.
5. I give HUGE props to Narcissa for straight-up lying to Voldemort after Harry confirmed that Draco was alive. It shows that neither she nor her son wanted the Death Eater life.
6. That one goblin who stared in shock as the Ukrainian Ironbelly burst through the floor of Gringotts seriously looked a bit like Donald Trump.
7. Before the war, during an Order Of The Phoenix meeting at Grimmauld Place after their son Teddy was born, Harry was asked by Tonks and Remus to be the godfather.
Great points! The only thing is Neville killing Nagini didn’t save Ron and Hermione, it happened in the courtyard where they bring Harry back, thinking he’s dead. Many things happened at once and it’s SO good, so much more climactic! Tons of people streamed onto the grounds to join the fight (villagers and parents of students and such), the student body once again broke free of the Silencio curse Voldemort kept trying to use (his curses couldn’t hold them because Harry died for them and gave them blood protection like his mom did for him), Harry leapt out of Hagrid’s arms and covered himself with his invisibility cloak, and best of all…Neville had been put in the full body bind curse, the sorting hat forced on his head and set on fire. At that moment he also broke free of the curse, pulled the hat off, pulled out the sword and killed Nagini who was around Voldemort’s neck. The sword can be presented to any worthy Gryffindor in a moment of need.
@@lyds6382 Thank you for that correction
Love point 6😂
@@lyds6382 It's hilarious how much more cinematic the books are than the movies, typical movie writers thinking they can do better than one of the best selling authors of all time. In the books all fights are better, they're very easy to follow, very clearly described so easy to imagine. In the movies it's all weird, people just stand around waiting for the other actor to do a spell, or they use wands like guns. In the movies almost all spells just send people flying, and same spell has different effect depending on the scene.
@@farfaraway4285 Why thank you
In the books Voldemort died like a normal human with his body intact which is different from his movie death.
Apparently they filmed a version like that, where his body is just lifeless on the ground! I don’t remember the link but you can look it up, I much prefer it.
Also in the book, the final fight happens infront of the whole school and Harry is telling basically a recap of the 7 books to Voldemort, but Voldemort does not believe him and....well...
Salazar Slytherin I think was one of the first to be adamant about “pure bloods.”
I’m pretty sure the pure blood thing was always an infatuation with certain wizards. Salazar was the first to insist they make the wizarding school pure-blood only.
So a few things to know. The tale of the Deathly Hallows actually plays in front of you through the two movies. Voldemort killed for power. Snape died for love and harry greeted death like an old friend. As for Harry not dying there can be so many ways people go off it being he didn’t die because he had all the pieces of the Deathly Hallows. However if you go back to the first movie it does show that harry has a protection spell from his mother’s love casted before she died. And that’s why he could not die in that movie. However the spell was meant to ware off after he turns a certain age. But if you remember in the 4th movie. Voldemort took his blood and that’s why the spell actually still happened. So although yes he was a horcrux he did also survive from his mother’s love. Also for the headmasters hand he got the curse from the ring he had destroyed. It does say it in movie 6.
Don't forget that he was the master of the Elder wand. In the book, Voldermort uses cruciatus on him, but it doesn't hurt him. Same with the death curse.
In the book, Dumbledore had actually used Lily's death in a spell to protect Harry at the house of his only living relatives through Lily's sister.
😮 Oh I didn't think about that about the Three Brothers! Antiochus was Dumbledore with the Elder Wand. Severus Snape was Cadmus with a betrothed who died too soon and he wanted her back. And Ignotus was obviously Harry, with the cloak.
And so you'll know, Aberforth's patronus is a goat. Harry's was a stag of course, and Harry had cast his to chase away death eaters near Aberforth's bar, the Hog's Head. He hustled the heroes in and stalled the death eaters saying he cast his own and he said he set off rye caterwauling charm alarm. "I saw a stag."
"A stag? It's a goat!" and he cast his goat patronus.
Part of Snape's memories was showing him checking Dumbledore's blackened hand.
The ring was a horcrux. In its setting was the resurrection stone. Dumbledore had forgotten it was a horcrux and tried it on. Voldemort had put an insidious curse on it.
Albus wanted to bring his family back.
Also, the age was 17. That's also the age the Ministry's trace stops tracking you. So: freedom from snooping ministers and freedom to leave home and be killed.
Harry's protection spell from his mother was not meant to wear off when he turned 17. That's the whole reason Voldemort couldnt kill him. You're confusinfg it with Dumbledore's spell that protected him while he lived with the Dursley. This is the one that stopped working when he turned 17.
I've watched your playlist from the beginning and it's been really fun since I can feel you guys also had fun and actually pay attention to a lot of things! Thanks for the reaction, expecting more series to come, subbed!
Snape loved Lily, but Lily did NOT love him, she only saw him as a friend. Snape started to hang out with pureblood supremacists in school to fit in. Lily still tried to be friends with Snape after that because she figured he was being led astray, but one day Snape called her a 'mudblood'; Lily was just like Hermione, she was born to muggle parents. Snape tried to apologize, but Lily saw that Snape was going down a dark path and she dropped the friendship. After they left Hogwarts, Snape basically joined the Nazi party of the wizarding world in order to get more powerful, fit in, and/or possibly win Lily back with his power.
HE was the one who delivered the prophecy to Voldemort, which foretold of a child born at the end of July would be Voldemort's foe (Neville and Harry); Snape believed it to be Neville's family, but Voldemort believed it was Harry's. That's when Snape turned, asking Dumbledore for help. BUT in the books, at first he asked only that Lily be kept safe as he didn't care for Harry or James. And even after switching sides, Snape continued to mistreat Harry for the sins of his father. Sooooo yes, Snape wasn't completely "bad", but he wasn't completely all "good" either. And also yes, Harry tried to redeem Snape's image to the wizarding world after the war.
I really hope they read this! Well said!!
Lily was a basic B. Had the hots for the school bully jock James Potter.
@@ChelseaChfy-ex1ponot really. James actually did a lot of maturing in his final years in school, whereas Snape didn’t. He ended up joining the death eaters
There actually is an escape from gringotts ride at universal studios Orlando. They have two Harry Potter sections one at islands of adventure (hogsmeade) and one at universal studios (diagon alley) . Both sections are connected by the hogwarts express.
They're also working on a new section that includes HP and Fantastic Beasts.
Fun fact about this movie, Maggie Smith was battling cancer during filming but told no one until much later after filming wrapped. Also, the part where the Dark Lord hugs Draco was 100% improvised.
Pure blood elitism is basically racism. It's been around since forever. Salazar Slytherin was a pureblood elitist. That was over a thousand years ago. Voldemort didn't really turn people to the dark side, Voldemort gave people who were essentially racist a powerful wizard to rally behind.
So, basically, Trump
@@toroplz4225 LMAO NOT AT ALL. You liberals are actually insane. Name ONE racist thing trump has said. I can name SEVERAL Joe Biden has...
@@toroplz4225 Completely unnecessary reply
@@GMDTurbo perhaps. Still true, though
The death eaters are the KKKs of wizard kind
The sorting hat does analyse you and place you, but you can overrule it. It wanted to place Harry is Slytherin, but Harry kept thinking “not Slytherin” so it placed him in the 2nd most fitting. “It is our choices, Harry, that shows who we truly are, far more than our abilities”
I think it wanted to place him in Slytherin because of Tom Riddle's soul part in him.
@@lenakohl2339 partly, as is mentioned a lot throughout the series: they have many likenesses, Harry possesses many qualities of Slytherin, and that the heir of Slytherin has part of his soul inside Harry might have tipped the scale for the hat.
The hat will take your chose into consideration but you cannot actually over rule it. Neville begged and begged the hatbto place him in Hufflepuff because he didn't feel brave but the hat pu/ him in Gryffindor anyways.
@@MrPozaidon Those qualities are shared by Slytherins and Gryffindors, the disregard for the rules. Harry is truly a Gryffindor and the hat was confused by the part of Voldemort inside him.
Harry has a strong thirst to prove himself (i.e. ambition) so he has strong Slytherin qualities. He would have fitted in any House really as he actually shows qualities of all four houses in quite strong abundance: he's a hard worker at things he is interested in (Hufflepuff), he's plenty intelligent enough for Ravenclaw and is more open-minded than Hermione, he's brave and true which make him a Gryffindor. Hermione also shows qualities that make her suitable for all four houses, but she's probably more suited to Hufflepuff+Gryffindor overall (yes, Hufflepuff - she's a hard worker, as well as intelligent, and much of her accomplishment is from effort as well as aptitude, she lacks certain qualities that would make her more suited to Ravenclaw).
Another thing the movies don’t tell you is that Harry sacrificed himself like his mom so no one could be harmed by Voldemort
Fun fact : Snape in the scene where he fights Minerva, he wasn't attacking back, he just mislead the spells to properly hit the death eaters next to him and them left.
The spend a lot more time in the book with Harry finally learning some of Dumbledore’s past and not all of it is good. There is a bit more payoff when Harry tells Aberforth that he still trusts Dumbledore.
In the books when they are in vault not only do the multiply they burn them as sell
Oh god I’m only 20 minutes in and I’m crying at everything 😂😂 I love reactions it really brings back some of the thrill of watching it for the first time knowing that it’s your first time and that you don’t know what to expect.
12:41 yes, they have her wand. but they know it was stolen
It gives me faith in humanity that you cried. Empathy is a gift. Always.
Always interesting that so many American reactors struggle to let go of the Elder wand when harry breaks it at the end ... "But, but, but, we might need its power!" Whereas most Brits are like "Good riddance, that was one evil piece of wood!" 🤣🤣🤣
Now, I'm gonna have to watch Brits reactions to it 😅
@@xenbuffMe, too. But as a Yankee, I wasn't attached to the wand because Why would HP keep it. It represents so much pain? I wondered why HP didn't return it to its rightful owner, Dumbledore.
It was torn from Dumbledore's hands in the coffin. Returning it would've been really touching
@LA_HA sure it is touching to return the most powerful weapon to a corpse.
Letting anyone who wants to desecrate corpses bring the wand back. Might be generations but someone could find it and start another conga line of murder and violence in the name of power.
@@LA_HA in the books Harry returns the Elder Wand to Dumbledore's coffin
@@Step_AG Nice. Thank you for letting me know. I don't remember what was in the books. It's been forever since I read them and I only read them once
56:08 "That is gonna be the most awkward hug he's ever had"
well, Voldemort doesn't have any single person that he could be loved so he never hug someone 😂
I needed this so bad today. I've been checking everyday waiting for this reaction. Allowing us to experience this journey with you guys has been a wonderful and cherished experience.
I dont know if you noticed, but when Harry, Ron, and Hermione are running through the courtyard, each magical creature they encounter represents some of the books/movies. Acromantula (giant spiders) were Aragogs children and represented the second movie/book. The dementors represented the third movie/book. The giant represented the fifth movie/book when they met Grawp. Fenrir Geyback feeding on Lavender represented the sixth movie/book given thats when we first meet him. I always thought that was clever nod to those who have been following the books/movies.
Harry is also losing some one important to each of the six previous books turing Deathly Hallows.
@@sawanna508 Hedwig, Dobby, Lupin, Mad Eye, ? , Snape ?
@@ptitepeluche05 Fred, perhaps, for Book 5 (representing Dumbledore's Army)
Are you guys watching fantastic beasts after finishing HP?? It is not the greatest but it expands the wizard world and it will give you a bigger depth about dumbledore. And the monsters are cute and amazing lol
I love the first fantastic beasts, definitely in my top 3 from the hp universe. The other two were totally forgettable
@@jokinhaaa my feelings about it are completely reverse lol. I’m not a fan of the fist one though
@@acciomess I would have gladly skipped all 3 of them. The lesser of 3 evils was the last one just because...
SPOILER
...I appreciated the scene in which they *stated out loud* that Grindelwald&Dumbledore were in love.
The first one is a fantastic movie, the rest are crap.
I like all 3 of them which surprises me…..I was prepared to be disappointed…lol!
FINALLY you guys!! First time a reactor notices the parallel between Snape and Lily saying "always" 😊❤
I'm sure you already know by now but Snape was older than Lily, thus already sorted into Slytherin
I love Narissa Malfoy...I would like to dress up like her for Halloween and do the grey and black hair. "He's only a boy."
Dumbledore's hand was injured when he was destroying the horcrux attached to the ring in which the Resurrection Stone was set. Dumbledore knew he would die so he had determined his death at Snape's hand would be the best course of action to gain Voldemort's trust, and because Draco had been designated to kill him, Dumbledore expected Draco would disarm him...thus taking control of the Elderwand. Even if Harry had not taken Draco's wand, the Elderwand would not be under Snape's control.
My aunt was just in the UK and stopped at Kings Cross where they have a Harry Potter Store, she got me the elder wand and sent it to me, just got it yesterday so this is perfect timing!!!!❤️❤️❤️
What an excellent gift! I need an Elder Wand myself...
@@nickreacts6394 if you want a wand designed based on your personality there a cool site called Fantasy by Numbers that has wands made from real wood where you can take a quiz similar the house quiz that will design a wand for you. You can also build one yourself from all the different parts and colors they have to choose from. Highly recommend.
I was waiting until you were done with the whole series so that way I have something to binge watch while I also work.
Guys, i just find this react and i highly recommend you read at least the three final chapters of Deathly Hollows... Harry walking under the invisible cloak seeing all the dead and the castle destruction, the scenes on the pensieve showing snape's story, the discription of Harry's feelings towards the end knowing he must die, his walk out of the castle to face death, his last chat with Dumbledore at Kings Cross, the last duel of Voldie and Harry and the descripton of the end (wich unlike the movie portrais Voldemort dying like a normal human being) IS PURE GOLD.
Escaping on the dragon was actually Harry's idea in the book.
In the book Voldemort has been separated from the parts of his soul in the horcruxes that he doesn't feel it when they're destroyed...unlike the movie which is all mixed up on that subject.
36:20 That's Fiendfyre. Very hard to control and extremely dangerous. It can destroy horcruxes but Hermione didn't even dare think about using it.
Snape is a very grey character. He did something very brave but he was still not a good person by any means.
In the books, the diadem gets destroyed by the fire :)
@@lenakohl2339 yup
The Fiendfyre spell is the one Voldy uses in the fight with Dumbledore at the ministry in HBP. Voldy, being a much more skilled wizard than Goyle, knows how to keep in under control.
Also, it was Crabbe in the book, rather than Goyle. But they're pretty much interchangeable. The actor that played Crabbe got into some legal trouble, so he wasn't available for the movie.
Of course Steve Kloves had to make it Hermione's idea, as he does so many other lines and ideas. It gets quite tiresome.
Someone below pointed out that Snape, the master duelist, managed to "accidentally" deflect one of McGonical's spells into the Carrow twins, taking them out. If you look, when he runs, he bounces first to one Carrow, then the other, before going through the window. He was taking their wands on his way out.
This story is one where you wish you hadn’t heard of it so you can discover it for the first time again ❤ totally worth reading the books. Also, I think Wen would have a blast watching Willow, with Val Kilmer… more magic and lots of fun 🎉
Proposed way for Umbridge to die: She somehow manages to escape from Azkaban, goes on the run, gets all the way to Hogsmeade, hides in the Dark Forest, and then gets trampled by the centaurs, and then eaten by the acromantulas.
YOU HAVE TO DO THE 20 YEARS ANNIVERSARY REUNION REACTION!!
When Dumbledore asked If Snape started liking Harry, and Snape casted his patronus, it’s the same of lily’s.
Snape is not telling he likes Harry, he’s telling Dumbledore that he have never forgot or had stopped loving Lily. That’s why he said “always”.
54:48 one of my favorite examples of a Slytherin having nerves of steel. 😅🐍 and Snape, of course. It's a cool layer to Slytherin. Fun reaction guys.
Best Dolores Umbridge character death, courtesy of The Emperor’s New Groove:
“First, I’ll turn her into a flea, a harmless little flea. Then I’ll put that flea in a box. Then I’ll put that box inside of another box. Then I’ll mail that box to myself, and when it arrives, I’ll SMASH IT WITH A HAMMER!”
Dumbledore used the ring that they showed in the half blood Prince after they watched Slughornes memory. It had the resurrection stone in it initially and was a Gaunt family heirloom. The Gaunts are Voldemorts ancestors and they go into deep detail regarding this in the books. Dumbledore wanted to use the stone to bring his sister back but it backfired if i remember correctly. He then placed the stone in the snitch for Harry to make him master of death. You dont need to kill the previous owner to win the wand that was just part of the lore.
No, he finds the ring in early summer after year 5, he puts it on immediately when he recognizes the resurrection stone, he could not resist the temptation, he says so himself. The ring then curses him, and Dumbledore destroys the ring. Soon after Dumbledore tells Snape what happened. Snape then says that he can keep Dumbledore alive for a year, and that's when Dumbledore puts his final plans into motion. By the time Dumbledore goes to pick up Harry in the latter half of the summer holidays, he already has the cursed hand and knows he'll die and already plotted with Snape about the Draco situation.
@@Eagle3302PL you are correct. Sorry I phrased it wrong. I didnt mean that he got cursed in half blood prince i was merely referring to the fact that they showed the ring in that scene. Dumbledore had already been cursed at the start of the movie.
Fun fact: This film was nominated 3 categories at the Oscars: Best Art Direction, Best Visual Effects, and Best Make up.
Art Direction - Lost to Hugo
Visual Effects - Lost to Hugo
Makeup - Lost to The Iron Lady
To answer your question, "Why does Voldemort have to do it?": Voldemort was unable to Kill Harry because of Lily's protection spell (This was the same reason Harry became 'the boy who lived'). The ancient magic that dumbledore told Lily about has a specific condition to activate: Willingly sacrificing oneself to protect loved ones; Lily's sacrifice ensured that the person who kills her can no longer harm people she loved.
Ironically, this actually makes Voldemort the only person in the world who can destroy the horcrux inside Harry WITHOUT killing the original Harry as well. Voldemorts killing curse would only affect the piece of himself inside Harry. Dumbledore figured out this was the only way to destroy the horcrux inside Harry without killing Harry along with it. Furthermore, as a result of Harry's *willing* sacrifice to protect his friends and family, Voldemort was no longer able to kill any more people on Harry's side because Harry activated the same protection magic his mother used when he was a babe.
Lily's magic became obsolete when Voldemort used Harry's blood to resurrect himself. Harry possessed all the deathly hallows at the time of his death, so he became the master of death and was able to come back instead of "go on"
@@kweeniepiez Yes, the otherreason is the elder wand belonged to Harry already, and so the Elder Wand would never harm Harry.
58:54 remember, u can only get the sword of griffondor if u have the heart of a true griffondor. The people that pulled the sword out of the sorting hat are Harry, nevil, and snape. I absolutely love that nevil gets the big scene of killing nagini and finding the sword
Also something I really hate that the movies didn't include was after Dumbledore says "Don't tell me now you've come to care for the boy?" they just go to him summoning his Patronus which was the same as Lily's again showing how much he loved her since his Patronus changed into hers which only happens if you truly love someone.
In the books after Dumbledore says that line Snape yells' "FOR HIM!!??" then he summons his patronus. Sadly he did truly hate Harry since he represents how he lost the love of his life to one of his most hated enemies. He only protected him because of how much he loved Lily.
A GREAT scene from the books that doesn't make it in the movie;
Harry is in the castle in the middle of the fight and sees a door bust open. Out of the door comes a herd of desks bewitched to gallop in a stampede-like fashion. Out with them flies McGonagall, her hair all messy, yelling "CHARGE!" and leading the desks to battle. Still makes me laugh when I picture that.
Another great book scene is Kreacher leading the castle's house-elves into the battle, screaming that he is doing it for his master, Harry. In the books, Harry pities and befriends Kreacher and he becomes completely devoted to Harry (nobody had ever treated him well before).
@@jenniferwilson2637 absolutely! I love the complete 180 change in Kreacher once he's shown compassion. Thanks for bringing that one up too!
Btw canonically McGonagall is stronger than Snape even if it's not clear here. If he didn't run, she would end him.
Canonlly Snape is stronger.
I think it would've been a close fight if snape really did want to harm her.
McGonagall's power should definitely be respected but I would never bet against Snape. If you had to pick a champion and your life depended on it, Snape would be my choice in that fight.
@@brittanylewandowski6200 it's McGonagall
@@ansoniaraton1 it's canon bro the writer said it
There are quite a few things that are never explicitly stated by Rowling anywhere. One of them is actually the exact way that the Elder Wand works. The whole "it belongs to the wizard who defeated the last owner" is kind of actually just fan canon and isn't completely official. Another thing that doesn't really have an explicit definitive answer is how Harry came back. Two of the prevalent theories are that he was either the Master of Death by being the true owner of the Elder Wand, the owner of the Invisibility Cloak and the owner of the Resurrection Stone, or that he was still tethered to life through Voldemort because some of Harry's blood lived within Voldemort and that blood still contained Lily's protective spell.
And the reason that Snape had to wait to tell Harry that he was a horcrux until the right time. Was that if the Master of Death theory is correct, Harry would have to face death? Truly believing that he was about to die. That would be the only way that he could truly Master death. If he went into the forest thinking that he would be able to come back then he would not have truly mastered death
Another theory is that Harry could never be killed by Voldemort because of his mother's sacrifice (mother's love). And when he cast the killing curse, it killed the only part of Harry it could: the part of Voldemort's soul within him.
Wand inheritance in general is inconsistent, but it appears that wands have some level of awareness and allegiance they themselves pick.
Harry surviving is explained in the novel, due to Voldemort using Harry's blood to revive himself they are both protected by Lily's sacrifice, also Harry is the Elder Wand's master so it refuses to kill him. So when Voldemort casts the killing curse, curse which doesn't kill the body but kills by ripping the soul out of it, Voldemort kills his own soul fragment, while Harry's soul is untouchable to Voldemort's curses.
Later on Harry and others are protected by protection magic from Harry sacrificing himself for everyone.
@@jenniferwilson2637 It's not a theory, it's what happens, I think it might even be stated in the book.
@@Eagle3302PL I pretty much agree with all of that, but those still are just fan theories. It's never actually explicitly explained how the elder Wand chooses its master. Harry's explanation of how him disarming Draco of a separate wand may not actually have meant anything. It's really just Harry's theory. Also, it's never explained how the killing curse actually works. The idea that it separates the soul from the body is yet another thing that us fans have come up with as an explanation, but is never actually explicitly stated in any of Rowling's writings.
Escape from Gringott's is my favorite ride at Universal Orlando.
Really hope I can make it there with Quynh one day!
It's more Alan you love for his acting skills!
IF you have not checked them out, have look at "Sense and Sensibility" where he is Colonel Brandon
or "Snow Cake" - he is perfect on this one
or "Robin Hood, Prince of Thieves" - he was awesmee as the Sherrif as well.
He was just an awesome actor
(like Gary Oldman, Ralph Fiennes and Helena Boham Carter as well)
Thank you for making my evening !
Happy sunday
Rickman's Colonel Brandon is the perfect man. Always.
So the reason Voldy died during the duel happened for a reason described afterward:
Harry was the true master of the Elder Wand. Once Voldy became a mortal the Elder Wand sensed that his master was being attacked by Voldy so it allowed the killing curse to rebound into Voldy. If you rewatch right before Harry disarms Voldy you will see the green aura seeping into Voldy's arm that quickly spreads (indicated by his skin turning dark) and it eventually consumes him
Yes. I believe Voldemort was able to kill Harry in the woods because Harry wasn't fighting back. But when Harry chose to fight, he had "power the Dark Lord knows not" and the wand recognizing Harry as it's owner rebounded Voldy's killing curse back to him.
NOT VOLDY 💀💀💀
I haven't read the books, but it always seemed Snape stayed undercover because he could best help Harry. You may not have noticed, but when Snape escaped by bursting through the window, the last thing he did was incapacitate the 2 death eaters behind him.
In the finale battle, Harry said Expelliarmus as always and Voldy said Avadakebra, but because the wand belong to Harry all this time, the wand could harm his master but refuse to kill his master so the curse bounced back to Voldy and killed him, in the book Voldy just drop dead, but in the movie they wanted a more cinematic dead, that I actually dislike, I think dropping dead is a more "normal" way to died and Voldy never wanted to be ordinary, so is just fitting.
24:20
“That was bad-ass of McGonagal, right?”
No. That was bad as of Snape.
He deflected all her spells, didn’t hurt her, knocked out the Carrows, and escaped without a scratch.
That is bad ass.
I haven't listened to your discussion yet or watched the reaction, but you should read up on the theory that Neville Longbottom could be the chosen one as well. He fits all the criteria that it requires.
It’s not really a theory. Harry and Neville were the two options the prophecy could have been talking about (they both fit all the criteria). Harry is “the chosen one” because Voldemort chose him. Harry was a half blood, just like Voldemort, so Voldemort saw him as a bigger threat.
Yeh it’s not a theory. The prophecy spoke of a boy that fit both Neville and Harry. Voldermort cemented the prophecy in stone by marking Harry as his equal.
1:04:05
Nick: Harry looks a lot like his father.
Me: Except for his eyes, he's got his-
Harry (behind me): Mother's eyes, I know.
Me: WTF? How did you get in my house!?
The Death eaters that were in Hogwarts with Snape, The Carrows ,were killed by Snape by deflecting that spell professor McGonagall shot at him. It happens so quick it's easy to miss
They weren't killed just knocked out, hence why he took their wands before going out the window. The Carrows survive the Battle of Hogwarts.
Re: extended cut - they do have one - the books 🤣🙂🙃
I'm teasing, but a lot of your theories and questions are answered in the books. I'm so glad that they're doing the TV series, and are planning to go in depth with it! There's so much (understandably, because goodness, the movies would be impossibly long) missing from the movies, so I'm so excited for those who haven't read the books to get deeper into the series!!
(I wasn't trying to be snarky with the book comment, just letting you know there's a lot more in the books)
Dumbledore's hand was damaged from the ring. It was a horcrux but he wanted to wear it and it cursed him. Severus contained it as well as he could but it was still going to spread.
Remember the story of the Three Brothers? The Elder Wand -the MOST poerful wand EVER made. The Cloak of Invisibility & the Resurrection Stone (in the story-the Peverell brother "brought back" his lost love but she was too sad to "be" in the world,so she ultimately hung herself. So it seems that the Resurrection Sone brought back the spirit of a person, perhaps neither in life or death @ the same time. @ the end of the movie, the Stone raised the spirits of all those Harry most loved - Lilly, James, Sirius & Remus, all those whose strength he needed, to face Voldemort when going to his death.
Yes! I've been eagerly waiting for this one! So hard to keep quiet.
@ 59:10 - I think the spells Molly used on Belatrix were "Petrificus Totalus" (total body binding/petrification) and then "Bombarda Maxima" (the massive explosion spell) that Umbridge used in Order of the Phoenix to destroy the entrance to the Room of Requirement.
I can't believe I'm so early to this. Was looking forward to your reaction, hope you have enough tissues.
judging from the scene with Olivander regarding the wands and how they "think", it appears the reason they didn't want to hand over Bellatrix's wand is that the wand could reveal Hermione was not Bellatrix. especially if any of the goblins had studied wand lore and could "communicate" with them like Olivander
You always save my evenings! 😊 You two are so cute together btw
Thank you! :)
When they protect the castle. Chills every time
I’ve been crying all night after being yelled at & abused by my mom so I’m so happy to see that this came out so I can feel a little bit better 🥹🫶🏼
I’m so sorry, hope you’re feeling better soon 💕
Damn, girl. I am no contact with my so called 'mother'. So I understand the heartbreak. Hugs to you.
So sorry to hear this! I hope you are ok and that things get better soon
😢 sorry about that and I can relate> my parents doesn't accept alot of my decisions as an adult
at least you know that we are with you, hopefully things will get better! I hope you enjoyed this reaction as much as you hoped for
That slight grin on Harry’s face as he sees Voldemort dying is PRICELESS!