"The jurists [of classical Islam] reached the conclusion that Islam _requires_ consistent military action against unbelieving peoples if no treaty exists with them" (Abdal Hakim Murad, Cambridge University). Islam unquestionably advocates for and has historically practiced military expansionism for the purpose of spreading Islamic rule. Thus Islam means the sword in practice.
"The jurists [of classical Islam] reached the conclusion that Islam _requires_ consistent military action against unbelieving peoples if no treaty exists with them" (Abdal Hakim Murad, Cambridge University). I regard Abdal Hakim Murad (Timothy J. Winter) as arguably the most important Western Islamic thinker and Hamza Yusuf has even described him as an "Ayatollah" (a sign of God). He agrees that Islam spread by the sword but argues that it was not motivated by the ego (nafs) but by the desire to liberate non-Muslim peoples.
Quran says killing one innocent is like killing the whole humanity and illogical to say innocent people weren’t killed in these expansions, the Sahaba didn’t follow the teachings of Allah?
The sentence that who kills one man kills all men is a sentence plagiarised from the Jewish book The Babylonian Talmud. Muhammad probably got it by hearsay during his caravan journeys.
i’m sorry but the more i learn about islam the more i become uncomfortable by it. “everyone else did it” is not a good enough reason to go around and wage war on perfectly peaceful nations. and you can’t go and talk about how evil european colonialism is then defend islam doing a tamer version of the same thing. also the whole concept of “incentives” is basically just coercion. not to mention the fact that muslims literally captured slaves, including sex slaves, from these so called “necessary wars”. i’m trying to hold onto this deen but certain parts of it just disturb me to my core. idk what to do anymore
most of the time when muslim invade land they created civilization there and when europians colonise lands they mostly looted people there and divide the lands ,
Exactly.. I am also being uncomfortable Basically from Child marriage, slavery, expansionsl jihad, Forcing the defeated land... 1 offer for accepting Islam Or 2-Forcing Non believrs to pay jizya with humiliation 3- Or Non believers to be killed. Even though we say Islam is a religion of Peace...
The Moguls were not religious (Aurangzeb being the exception). The empire expanded in the pursuit of wealth and power. Like it or not, but the Sufis were highly influential in the spread of Islam in India.
So If gov or people across the world oppresses Muslims in the same way how Islam did in past is it justified? World must learn from this video and act accordingly.
Incentives: pay the jiziha, can't rebuild broken church or build a new one, muslims can marry you but Jew or Christian man can't marry islamic women. Influential jobs not given to jewish or Christian people....that was the 'general rule, few exceptions. No we are nor deceived Sir but thanks for your more open honesty
He just said he used Greed to spread truth @19.50. That's called cheating. What if others do the same thing to your people ?? What if others cheat too ??
That’s not cheating lol. The person that converts for the sake of money isn’t really a Muslim in the eyes of god, anyways he’s only cheating himself. But the overarching goal and the wisdom of god is that now his children are born into Islam and can be exposed to it and hopefully they can be enlightened by it. That’s just my two cents and that’s what I got out of the lecture.
They are free to try as they have free will and Muslim have rights to defend their land. You think USA isn't already invading Muslims countries in the name of liberating them? Don't think we don't know the war in (Iraq, Afghanistan, etc) ...
Subhann Allah, I love this man for his role in Islam. I love him for the sake of Allah. He presented this topic without sugarcoating it and I believe it makes sense when you don't adorn the truth. I am grateful that The Shahabas spread Islam with military conquest, enabling the likes of my Ancestors to see the beauty of Islam and chose it as a way of life. And I'm proud of their justice and good governance that led to the spread of Islam. When Obama visited Senegal, he purported Gay marriage and he was not shy or feel any discomfort to instill it to them despite it being contrary to their values and way of life. But for him, it's a champion idea, how comes muslims feel a embarrass about Offensive Jihad when it brought many to the faith. I'm not asking for Jihad in this modern age cuz there is no need for it, and the system of Dawah nowadays is pret ty effective.....
Yasir qadri is from Pakistan, women from this area was sold as slaves to, so much the price of slaves women dropped, this is arab history and people of Pakistan will never cry for those women. That's why people of India can never trust these people, the divide is too strong. Who can you trust someone who have no sympathy for your own DNA?
1/5th of the Ganeemath ( plunder) from caravan raids dubbed as wars was for "Allah and his Apostle' it is said in the Qur'an. But what did Allah do with his share is a mystery. .
@@kailaskamlellu1655when there's a war ( war is built into the system) part of the plunder consisted of slaves. Boys were taken castrated and sold in the market. Women and girls too were employed as sex slaves. It was business..
There was no battle of Tabuk as there was no Roman army planning to attack Arabs. Romans had come off a 26 yr war with Persian empire so both empires were decimated and not in any shape to start another war.
Yes by showing economic and military dominance...how is that not using the sword too? How do u show military dominance? You wave the sword and conquer 😂
Who worships a cross? Christians? I have no idea why muslims, who are always outraged if you misrepresent them, cannot represents Christians accurately? Christians do not worship a cross: the cross _represents_ or _symbolises_ the love of God in the sacrificial death of Christ on the cross. It is not the cross that is worshipped; but God through the symbolism of the cross. When muslims treat the Qur'an with holy reverence do they worship a book? No. Let's be fair.
In my opinion all the Quran asserts about Christianity is very close to or actual straw manning. Ironically it undercuts the claims they make about the Quran
Wanna try to summarise this so correct me if i'm wrong. Islam wasn't spread by the sword, but the islamic 'empire' was spread by the sword. With motivation that there is islamic conversion via political governance n exhibiting islamic values in the community. Unlike other religions, islam truly belives that it is the true religion so it must be shared with the world, and at the time the most effective method was through governance. Not to mention that some parts of the world do attain Islam through da'wah and trading expeditions. Also at that time, military conquests are a norm to instill political power. Today, conquest is not the option to spread islam anymore because the world as a whole has reached a point of peace (subjective) and there are more ways and options to spread da'wah to all over the world
Truth is Islam, Christianity, Hinduism, etc has so many dark in the past😢 Islam still has till today, if you want to argue just look at how many churches were burnt by Muslimis in Pakistan on 16th Aug 2023.
The very fact Islam spread by the sword snd firced its ideology on people then kster in bring blasphemy and apostasy laws makes it fundamentally evil and a mockery to God's Law, commandments and the prophets. This is how Jesus summarised the law and the prophets: Matthew 7:12 [12]Therefore, whatever you want men to do to you, do also to them, for this is the Law and the Prophets.
12:19 from here on your teaching is questionable! Yes, you could stay to be a Christian, but only if you could afford to pay the MONEY for the Jizya and church buildings were not allowed to be repaired. There were as well other inconveniences. I'm not sure, but I think, this changed under Colonialism..
So the muslims brought the normalcy of 'civilisation', i.e., 'peace' through violence. Why should the muslims be different? Well, because they are supposed to be inspired by God, who is presumably above the normalcy of civilisation. Buddhism was non-violent and yet it spread all over Asia. Christianity was non-violent for 4 centuries and it 'conquered' the Roman Empire
How if the Muslims were the only religion that didn't attack non-combatants, women and children, aloud other religions to live as citizens. In comparison to Christianity, Hinduism, Jainidm and Buddhism
How if the Muslims were the only religion that didn't attack non-combatants, women and children, aloud other religions to live as citizens. In comparison to Christianity, Hinduism, Jainidm and Buddhism
In some areas of the world it was, in others it wasn’t. I’m here in England 6 miles from Canterbury where English Christianity was established in 597 and no, it was spread by preaching and elite adoption not by violence
I think Islam was initiall spread by the sword, but it has a long history and it wasn't always that way. I'm an American who was basically raised secular and I appreciate Islam influence in my country I think. They oppose the rainbow fascist agenda which means a lot to me. I think this was a fair lecture coming from a Muslim.
How if the Muslims were the only religion that didn't attack non-combatants, women and children, aloud other religions to live as citizens. In comparison to Christianity, Hinduism, Jainidm and Buddhism
Those who live by the sword die by the sword. Matthew 26:52 8:40
So Islam was spread by sword
No it wasn't, you clearly didn't listen. Muslims never forced people to convert.
@@premtimzogiani bro he literally just said we shouldn't sugar coat it and now here you are trying to sugar coat it 😂
@@BinaryTechnique What are you talking about man? Just listen the speech to the end. They did not force people to convert.
They didn't force conversion, but did demand religious minorities paid protection money under the guise of a special tax.
Christianity by tanks ...
Finally I got my detailed Answer after a long search. Alhamdulillah ✨Very well explained 👍 jzk khairen kasseera
"The jurists [of classical Islam] reached the conclusion that Islam _requires_ consistent military action against unbelieving peoples if no treaty exists with them" (Abdal Hakim Murad, Cambridge University). Islam unquestionably advocates for and has historically practiced military expansionism for the purpose of spreading Islamic rule. Thus Islam means the sword in practice.
Thanks for sharing. Jazākallāhu Khair.
Alhamdulillah and thanks for speaking the truth. May Allah increase you in knowledge and help you to speak the truth. Ameen!
"The jurists [of classical Islam] reached the conclusion that Islam _requires_ consistent military action against unbelieving peoples if no treaty exists with them" (Abdal Hakim Murad, Cambridge University). I regard Abdal Hakim Murad (Timothy J. Winter) as arguably the most important Western Islamic thinker and Hamza Yusuf has even described him as an "Ayatollah" (a sign of God). He agrees that Islam spread by the sword but argues that it was not motivated by the ego (nafs) but by the desire to liberate non-Muslim peoples.
Very well explained. AH
Quran says killing one innocent is like killing the whole humanity and illogical to say innocent people weren’t killed in these expansions, the Sahaba didn’t follow the teachings of Allah?
The sentence that who kills one man kills all men is a sentence plagiarised from the Jewish book The Babylonian Talmud. Muhammad probably got it by hearsay during his caravan journeys.
Yasir qadhi is truly sent by Allah.Every doubt of mines is gone.
The rest of us are sent by Satan?
What
i’m sorry but the more i learn about islam the more i become uncomfortable by it. “everyone else did it” is not a good enough reason to go around and wage war on perfectly peaceful nations. and you can’t go and talk about how evil european colonialism is then defend islam doing a tamer version of the same thing. also the whole concept of “incentives” is basically just coercion. not to mention the fact that muslims literally captured slaves, including sex slaves, from these so called “necessary wars”. i’m trying to hold onto this deen but certain parts of it just disturb me to my core. idk what to do anymore
most of the time when muslim invade land they created civilization there and when europians colonise lands they mostly looted people there and divide the lands ,
Just compare what Jesus taught and lived in the Bible and what Muhammed taught and lived in the Quran. Who is the best example?
@@senkat8747 both are great example
Exactly.. I am also being uncomfortable
Basically from Child marriage, slavery, expansionsl jihad,
Forcing the defeated land... 1 offer for accepting Islam
Or 2-Forcing Non believrs to pay jizya with humiliation
3- Or Non believers to be killed.
Even though we say
Islam is a religion of Peace...
@@mohdfaiez44 Jesus is far far superior to Muhammad. Sorry to burst your bubble
Good explain.
Good explain
The Moguls were not religious (Aurangzeb being the exception). The empire expanded in the pursuit of wealth and power. Like it or not, but the Sufis were highly influential in the spread of Islam in India.
@Richard's Package I learnt about the spread from Deobandi scholars, who were more Sufi inclined.
@@muhammedk9648 without moguls there would be no Islam in India?
@@bobangry7605 LOL HOW MANY MOGULS IN INDONESIA
lol cope. Y’all were converted by Afghans and mongols
I advise those interested to read The Preaching of Islam by T. W. Arnold. He explains it well. He provides the alternative perspective
So If gov or people across the world oppresses Muslims in the same way how Islam did in past is it justified? World must learn from this video and act accordingly.
Its really different your just dumb😂
Incentives: pay the jiziha, can't rebuild broken church or build a new one, muslims can marry you but Jew or Christian man can't marry islamic women. Influential jobs not given to jewish or Christian people....that was the 'general rule, few exceptions. No we are nor deceived Sir but thanks for your more open honesty
He just said he used Greed to spread truth @19.50. That's called cheating.
What if others do the same thing to your people ?? What if others cheat too ??
That’s not cheating lol. The person that converts for the sake of money isn’t really a Muslim in the eyes of god, anyways he’s only cheating himself. But the overarching goal and the wisdom of god is that now his children are born into Islam and can be exposed to it and hopefully they can be enlightened by it. That’s just my two cents and that’s what I got out of the lecture.
Logic and reasoning is Islamophobic
They are free to try as they have free will and Muslim have rights to defend their land.
You think USA isn't already invading Muslims countries in the name of liberating them?
Don't think we don't know the war in (Iraq, Afghanistan, etc) ...
Subhann Allah, I love this man for his role in Islam. I love him for the sake of Allah. He presented this topic without sugarcoating it and I believe it makes sense when you don't adorn the truth. I am grateful that The Shahabas spread Islam with military conquest, enabling the likes of my Ancestors to see the beauty of Islam and chose it as a way of life. And I'm proud of their justice and good governance that led to the spread of Islam. When Obama visited Senegal, he purported Gay marriage and he was not shy or feel any discomfort to instill it to them despite it being contrary to their values and way of life. But for him, it's a champion idea, how comes muslims feel a embarrass about Offensive Jihad when it brought many to the faith. I'm not asking for Jihad in this modern age cuz there is no need for it, and the system of Dawah nowadays is pret
ty effective.....
Obviously Islam was spread by giving out dawah pamphlets at the local bazaar
😂😂😂😂
🤣🤣
is there not a part of koran that speaks of dividing the spoils of war ? en to make slaves of the woman ?
Yes but Islam also said those who set free a slave will get heaven
Yasir qadri is from Pakistan, women from this area was sold as slaves to, so much the price of slaves women dropped, this is arab history and people of Pakistan will never cry for those women.
That's why people of India can never trust these people, the divide is too strong.
Who can you trust someone who have no sympathy for your own DNA?
@@andresdefoliosa515 but why make someone slave in the first place ?
1/5th of the Ganeemath ( plunder) from caravan raids dubbed as wars was for "Allah and his Apostle' it is said in the Qur'an. But what did Allah do with his share is a mystery. .
@@kailaskamlellu1655when there's a war ( war is built into the system) part of the plunder consisted of slaves. Boys were taken castrated and sold in the market. Women and girls too were employed as sex slaves. It was business..
There was no battle of Tabuk as there was no Roman army planning to attack Arabs. Romans had come off a 26 yr war with Persian empire so both empires were decimated and not in any shape to start another war.
That's what ex-muslims are saying all this time...
Shabir Ally and mufti Abu layth , doesn't agree with his conclusion , amazing
Who cares it’s serah it’s writing ✍️ 😂
All true comments removed,why you afraid the Truth
Vienna 1683
Yes by showing economic and military dominance...how is that not using the sword too? How do u show military dominance? You wave the sword and conquer 😂
Who worships a cross? Christians? I have no idea why muslims, who are always outraged if you misrepresent them, cannot represents Christians accurately? Christians do not worship a cross: the cross _represents_ or _symbolises_ the love of God in the sacrificial death of Christ on the cross. It is not the cross that is worshipped; but God through the symbolism of the cross. When muslims treat the Qur'an with holy reverence do they worship a book? No. Let's be fair.
In my opinion all the Quran asserts about Christianity is very close to or actual straw manning. Ironically it undercuts the claims they make about the Quran
It was. No need for 30 min lecture.
Which religion Taliban,Al Qaeda, ISIS and Boko haram following ? And what they are doing ?
….so you are so sure you are right, you allow yourself to do dirty tricks to get them to convert….what version of Taqqiya is this?
yes it was
Wanna try to summarise this so correct me if i'm wrong. Islam wasn't spread by the sword, but the islamic 'empire' was spread by the sword. With motivation that there is islamic conversion via political governance n exhibiting islamic values in the community. Unlike other religions, islam truly belives that it is the true religion so it must be shared with the world, and at the time the most effective method was through governance. Not to mention that some parts of the world do attain Islam through da'wah and trading expeditions. Also at that time, military conquests are a norm to instill political power.
Today, conquest is not the option to spread islam anymore because the world as a whole has reached a point of peace (subjective) and there are more ways and options to spread da'wah to all over the world
🤣😀😂
99.9 percent of historical Muslims convert because of that very political invasion.
It all started from Muhammad's time
@farsi your clown 🤡
Truth is Islam, Christianity, Hinduism, etc has so many dark in the past😢 Islam still has till today, if you want to argue just look at how many churches were burnt by Muslimis in Pakistan on 16th Aug 2023.
People converted be so they didn’t want to be 2nd class citizens😊
The very fact Islam spread by the sword snd firced its ideology on people then kster in bring blasphemy and apostasy laws makes it fundamentally evil and a mockery to God's Law, commandments and the prophets.
This is how Jesus summarised the law and the prophets:
Matthew 7:12
[12]Therefore, whatever you want men to do to you, do also to them, for this is the Law and the Prophets.
The Ottomans did force conversions at times. Otranto for example ...
12:19 from here on your teaching is questionable! Yes, you could stay to be a Christian, but only if you could afford to pay the MONEY for the Jizya and church buildings were not allowed to be repaired. There were as well other inconveniences. I'm not sure, but I think, this changed under Colonialism..
So the muslims brought the normalcy of 'civilisation', i.e., 'peace' through violence. Why should the muslims be different? Well, because they are supposed to be inspired by God, who is presumably above the normalcy of civilisation. Buddhism was non-violent and yet it spread all over Asia. Christianity was non-violent for 4 centuries and it 'conquered' the Roman Empire
Islam spread by the sword and zaziya tax.
How if the Muslims were the only religion that didn't attack non-combatants, women and children, aloud other religions to live as citizens. In comparison to Christianity, Hinduism, Jainidm and Buddhism
A religion of sword.
How if the Muslims were the only religion that didn't attack non-combatants, women and children, aloud other religions to live as citizens. In comparison to Christianity, Hinduism, Jainidm and Buddhism
Many kings and nation have attacked others but not in the name of religion.
But Muslims attacked in the name of religion.
Nope, but Christianity was
He just admitted it 😂
Uhh...
Ever heard of Theodosius the second.
Are you a Muslim?
In some areas of the world it was, in others it wasn’t. I’m here in England 6 miles from Canterbury where English Christianity was established in 597 and no, it was spread by preaching and elite adoption not by violence
Who worship Kaba black stone ?
I think Islam was initiall spread by the sword, but it has a long history and it wasn't always that way. I'm an American who was basically raised secular and I appreciate Islam influence in my country I think. They oppose the rainbow fascist agenda which means a lot to me. I think this was a fair lecture coming from a Muslim.
How if the Muslims were the only religion that didn't attack non-combatants, women and children, aloud other religions to live as citizens. In comparison to Christianity, Hinduism, Jainidm and Buddhism
Hehehehhehe…. Without lies , islam will die.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
It means indirect way used to convert to muslim. Another easy way to have more than one wife in india
So in other words, Islam is staler colonialism with Islamic supremacy.