2019 BMW X5 vs 2019 Volvo XC90 - CRASH TEST

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 9 май 2019
  • 2016 Volvo XC90 40 mph driver-side small overlap IIHS crash test
    Overall evaluation: Good
    2019 BMW X5 40 mph driver-side small overlap IIHS crash test
    Overall evaluation: Good
    #CrashTest #BMWX5 #VolvoXC90
    "SUBSCRIBE NOW"
  • Авто/МотоАвто/Мото

Комментарии • 6 тыс.

  • @michaelknight141
    @michaelknight141 2 года назад +6061

    Wow, respect for the engineers. Great job. Passed all tests, even with different cars.
    Very good wall.

    • @Legendendear
      @Legendendear 2 года назад +127

      xD
      Got me in the first half

    • @AIexanderHartdegen
      @AIexanderHartdegen 2 года назад +62

      You're comment made me laugh. Unfortunately, I can't keep of my mind thinking when I look those kind of video that if there was an airbag on my mum's car, she would be always alive.

    • @jeremygong4190
      @jeremygong4190 2 года назад +9

      Wow, respect to the tests. Great job. Passed by all different cars!

    • @michaelknight141
      @michaelknight141 2 года назад +21

      @@AIexanderHartdegen sorry to hear that 😔
      of course, in no way I want to reduce the respect for the great work they do on airbags and car security. It’s amazing what’s possible with today’s technology and it saves many peoples lifes every day ✌🏻

    • @AIexanderHartdegen
      @AIexanderHartdegen 2 года назад +13

      @@michaelknight141 yes... Airbags save many lifes. I made many years ago a thesis on how accelerometers work. And it's a very sharp technology. Only for rich people when it came out... But hopefully for everybody now.

  • @aravinds1023
    @aravinds1023 3 года назад +7380

    The BMW front grill flies beautifully...

  • @vampirbacon
    @vampirbacon 2 года назад +1795

    Volvo developed the three-point seatbelt in the 50s. In order to increase the safety of all vehicle occupants, they decided not to apply for a patent. Good guy Volvo ❤️

    • @wpgc2
      @wpgc2 2 года назад +119

      They patented it but share with the industry without royalty. They also pioneered the systematic crash test similar to what NHTSA and IIHS are doing today.

    • @dima.jiharev
      @dima.jiharev 2 года назад +66

      Volvo is a pretty cool guy, eh saves lives and doesn't afraid of anything!

    • @martinkorjus7607
      @martinkorjus7607 2 года назад +70

      After that everyone in car industry agreed to share all patents and knowledge about safety for free, because safety is more important than money.

    • @vivianchas9872
      @vivianchas9872 2 года назад +16

      I love Volvo! Best in the world! Will never drive any other kind.

    • @M_H_H
      @M_H_H Год назад +8

      Patent craze only started after Apple company founded

  • @Sethi_Sahab
    @Sethi_Sahab 2 года назад +414

    That bmw grill got eject mode.. Can be used in any new bmw

    • @rauftaj
      @rauftaj 2 года назад +4

      it's so you can swap it out for a performance grill.

    • @x5-acousticguitarstuff.2
      @x5-acousticguitarstuff.2 2 года назад +8

      My BMW X5's Grill, goes into Eject Mode every time I stop at a Red Light.

    • @carlypot9421
      @carlypot9421 2 года назад

      So does the Volvo hood.

    • @OnDaBeatBoy
      @OnDaBeatBoy 2 года назад

      and gladly that thing is so ugly 😂😂

    • @mcterb7142
      @mcterb7142 2 года назад

      lol that thing just kept driving on.

  • @gheorghedinca3417
    @gheorghedinca3417 4 года назад +5331

    0:33 that grill is still good to sell tho

  • @warrenb8228
    @warrenb8228 2 года назад +4136

    The airbags make it look like you wouldn’t even get whiplash. Awesome. I’m going to go crash my car as soon as possible.

  • @darrylbirdsall2342
    @darrylbirdsall2342 Год назад +122

    You will notice that in the front small overlap crash tests where Volvos are crashed, the front wheel is sheered off, as was also the case in this test. The front wheel of the BMW was crushed back into the rear of the engine compartment and possibly into the footwell area - but not the case with the Volvo, which is something to think about.

    • @bobjohnson205
      @bobjohnson205 6 месяцев назад +1

      At least with the BMW, you'll know where to find your front wheel and not have to go looking for it like with the Volvo! lol

    • @mikimus3583
      @mikimus3583 5 месяцев назад

      Ye and the BMW kinda just flew away and the volvo was still on the ground

    • @user-uj6wh1eb2p
      @user-uj6wh1eb2p 3 месяца назад

      Is finding your wheel really your first priority after a crash like that lol.. ​@@bobjohnson205

    • @hidefmatt
      @hidefmatt 2 месяца назад

      @@mikimus3583 I'd say the opposite. The bmw was almost stationary wrt direction of impact but rebounded perpendicularly, cvf the volvo which glanced off the barrier and was still moving forward quite quickly after the impact - i.e. forces much much higher in the BMW. BMW performed well but Volvo was better as might be expected.

    • @jr1885
      @jr1885 Месяц назад +2

      Meh. If that were the case, the BMW wouldn’t have scored perfect. Yes, some cars will push the wheel into the compartment. Not in this case. Both are very safe, and I would even say the BMW is better for whiplash injuries according to the video.

  • @rauftaj
    @rauftaj 2 года назад +96

    As you could see, the Volvo slid off the barrier and kept going. This is Volvo's literal best small overlap feature. To minimize impact, it's designed to slide off. They also invented the three way seatbelt. Most car manufacturers would patent this. But Volvo was kind enough to actually share this feature to other car manufacturers to improve cabin safety. This is why Volvo is always ahead. But the grill ejection feature on small overlaps on BMW's help retain the value of the grill, so you can sell it and afford the repairs of the small overlap damage. See the grill ejection feature in action at 0:33. (The grill ejection feature isn't real, but it's funny how the x5 reacted to the small overlap by letting go of the front grill).

    • @Chris371M
      @Chris371M 2 года назад

      I'm pretty sure Volvo patented the three-point belt.

    • @rauftaj
      @rauftaj 2 года назад +3

      @@Chris371M They didn't.

    • @jianwei2009
      @jianwei2009 8 месяцев назад +1

      It should be illegal to patent anything that is in strong public interests.

    • @praveenm6204
      @praveenm6204 7 месяцев назад

      thanks.. can you please paste the time stamp where the sliding happened

    • @bobjohnson205
      @bobjohnson205 6 месяцев назад +1

      BMW should patent that grille ejection feature!

  • @SoferPeOZN
    @SoferPeOZN 3 года назад +1748

    Dont scroll further, the whole comment section is about the grill

    • @adamhlali8106
      @adamhlali8106 3 года назад +9

      Sorry man but that grill got stuck and took my scroll button with it.

    • @TheRazmatazum
      @TheRazmatazum 3 года назад +3

      Thanks for the heads-up mate..✌🏻

    • @ShaggszzDvr
      @ShaggszzDvr 3 года назад +3

      Just came back to say, you were right

    • @SoferPeOZN
      @SoferPeOZN 3 года назад

      @@ShaggszzDvr told ya =)

    • @SoferPeOZN
      @SoferPeOZN 3 года назад +2

      @Johnson Long i see you are a man of culture as well

  • @brianjones8126
    @brianjones8126 3 года назад +1391

    0:34 I just saw that grill passing by my house yesterday heading east.

    • @Mayank_MediumG
      @Mayank_MediumG 3 года назад +21

      Lol that was good 🤣😂🤣

    • @hikarthikyadav
      @hikarthikyadav 3 года назад +1

      Haha

    • @priyansh.o1_
      @priyansh.o1_ 3 года назад +2

      That was a good one .😂😂

    • @tita7197
      @tita7197 3 года назад

      Ha ha

    • @tapper701
      @tapper701 3 года назад +8

      I salvaged it, have hotdogs, hamburgs & steak on it cooking as we speak ...

  • @21xxx21
    @21xxx21 2 года назад +150

    Contrary to what people might think, the BMW is actually pulled forward by the grill not by the engine which is why the grill kept going after the car was stopped by that corner.

    • @TioMogi
      @TioMogi Год назад +8

      Exactly, that's why the new BMW grills are bigger - to increase the total horsepower! Honestly the new grills are so big/great I'm not even sure why they bother keeping the engines at all anymore.. just seems like extra weight for no reason

  • @alex_org1458
    @alex_org1458 2 года назад +84

    The designers did a great job! Excellent aerodynamic properties of the “radiator grill”!

  • @TanukiGamePlays
    @TanukiGamePlays 2 года назад +1525

    I loved the grill’s ejection system.

    • @vondahe
      @vondahe 2 года назад +76

      Agree but it sad that you need to have a catastrophic collision to get rid of that abomination.

    • @ravenbonanza1522
      @ravenbonanza1522 2 года назад +7

      Guaranteed to fly off without a scratch upon impact or your money back 🤣🤣🤣

    • @extrm161
      @extrm161 2 года назад

      ruclips.net/video/o1D2q_YAxwQ/видео.html
      This deserve moree .

    • @fynkozari9271
      @fynkozari9271 2 года назад +3

      What is the Indestructible wall they used? Vibranium?

    • @schtekar
      @schtekar 2 года назад +7

      The grill said "aight, imma head out"

  • @vaanchitkundlia57
    @vaanchitkundlia57 2 года назад +1173

    The momentum transfer of that volvo was insane, like a F1 car designed to break in big pieces absorbing most of the impact! The way impact decelerated was bonkers. Fine engineering indeed!

    • @johnnymatias3027
      @johnnymatias3027 2 года назад +33

      Yeah the capture at the end showed it, the BMW with its tires off the ground because more energy transferred to the whole structure of the car, whereas the Volvo's crushed better and parts came off, absorbing enough of the energy of the crash that the wheels never really left the ground like the BMW did. I'd probably trust the Volvo more in a roll over risk incident, but the BMW is of a higher general quality and driving experience, and tbh between these two, I might take the BMW. I'll make that decision when I hear the Bang and Olufsen sound system in the Volvo, I work on them but haven't listened to that one yet, only the Harmon Kardon which left much to be desired. I liked the premium system in the 2019 Nissan Maxima more than the HK Volvo system lol.

    • @megatronusorionpax4900
      @megatronusorionpax4900 2 года назад +84

      @@johnnymatias3027 Volvos are pretty underrated as luxury vehicles

    • @suprajew60
      @suprajew60 2 года назад +26

      @@johnnymatias3027 consider some of the worse engines in production are BMW, some are fantastic, but most are horrific, and customer service is something to be desired, please research, not everyone is in a great financial situation, dont get stuck with a dog 👍🏻👍🏻

    • @magnummax78
      @magnummax78 2 года назад +5

      I know JACK SQUAT about engineering, yet I could tell I’d rather be in the Volvo for this test: well, me not being a total dummy…🤷🏾‍♂️

    • @64lash81
      @64lash81 2 года назад +3

      @@suprajew60 just ignore the N47 from 2008-2010 engines and you are gonna be fine

  • @seb1things1
    @seb1things1 2 года назад +17

    There is one very important thing here, as why I would chose and have chosen Volvo, that is the G Force felt inside the car. That is what will keep your internal organs in one piece. Volvo has managed to get lower G Force at impact. Best example is in this clip. See how the Volvo just lets all parts fly and it just moves away almost forward. The BMW is still great and safe, but the G Force is stronger, as it almost gets to a stand still before rolls away.

  • @vc8160
    @vc8160 Год назад +6

    The deflection and energy dissipation from the volvo is amazing! I guess that’s why they are the leaders in Safety!

  • @andreixrt9866
    @andreixrt9866 2 года назад +818

    Legend says the bmw grill is still traveling around the universe

    • @ozoneXpnG
      @ozoneXpnG 2 года назад +24

      Nah!... Yesterday I saw him in my backyard with his wife and children and grilling bbq 😁🤩 for his family...

    • @anveshkumar23
      @anveshkumar23 2 года назад +1

      Ha ha ha.....😂😂😂...I didn't noticed first!

    • @fenixmaker
      @fenixmaker 2 года назад +2

      So that's what i saw in the nightsky yesterday

    • @bcdm999
      @bcdm999 2 года назад +1

      It just passed the manhole cover

    • @lilkurd2000
      @lilkurd2000 2 года назад

      Cheap copy paste from an 2 year old comment.. sad ppl give you likes

  • @williamscoggin1509
    @williamscoggin1509 2 года назад +776

    The Volvo crush and energy deflection built into its body and frame design is definitely Superior in this. More energy was transferred into the BMW passenger area by the car coming to a quicker stop. The Volvo crushed in a way that deflected the energy off to the side more instead of into the cab area. That is one of the Volvo kept rolling further which means the people within its cabin received less energy and would theoretically receive less forced trauma injuries. Small differences in design make a huge difference in the life of the person or his family that is in that car. Hats off to these engineers! 👍🏻

    • @XerxesGustav
      @XerxesGustav 2 года назад +78

      Looking at the data the acceleration values are BMW 94 G left, 38 G right foot. Volvo: 27/16 G, so yea, quite the difference in this test.

    • @MrScreamCream
      @MrScreamCream 2 года назад +14

      But what about rolling into other traffic After the crash? Is there no brake System ?

    • @robertgittings8662
      @robertgittings8662 2 года назад +1

      *Is Scoggin a Nordic name?*

    • @barbarat5729
      @barbarat5729 2 года назад +30

      @@MrScreamCream Let me tell you what would happen if any other cars hit the Volvo. They fold up like accordions.
      I love my old Volvo.

    • @comradehabibi4451
      @comradehabibi4451 2 года назад +7

      @@MrScreamCream they do have post collision braking system

  • @WorldAviationTravel
    @WorldAviationTravel 2 года назад +5

    Обратите внимание как вольво не поглощает удар полностью и переводит движение кузова в сторону! Это лучшее

    • @bingo2828
      @bingo2828 4 месяца назад

      да тоже заметил как проскальзывает как будто

  • @apigk4330
    @apigk4330 2 года назад +3

    विकल्प बहुत मिलेंगे,
    मार्ग भटकाने के लिए।
    संकल्प एक ही रखना,
    मंजिल तक जाने के लिए।
    मंजील चाहे जितनी भी ऊँची हो परंतु रास्ते हमेशा अपने पैरो के निचे ही होते है।
    खुद के ऊपर विश्वास रखो साहेब फिर देखना एक दिन ऐसा आएगा घड़ी दूसरे की होगी और समय आपका..
    जिंदगी एक बार मिलती है बिल्कुल गलत है, सिर्फ मौत एक बार मिलती है जिंदगी हर रोज मिलती है।🤗🤗

  • @fzesmokyy1594
    @fzesmokyy1594 2 года назад +321

    x5 and xc90 being classed „mid sized“ may just be the most american thing I‘ve seen in a long time lol

    • @RandomHondaGuy
      @RandomHondaGuy 2 года назад +3

      Tbf they are. If compared to the x7

    • @user-ky6zl7qc7m
      @user-ky6zl7qc7m 2 года назад +25

      @@RandomHondaGuy xc90 is massive tho

    • @RandomHondaGuy
      @RandomHondaGuy 2 года назад +7

      @@user-ky6zl7qc7m X5 is like Xc60, x7 like xc90

    • @dzengerink
      @dzengerink 2 года назад +22

      @@RandomHondaGuy haha no, x5 and xc90 are fullsize in Europe, and competitors. For American and particularly Asian (Chinese) market BMW has developed the x7, volvo didnt do that yet. The x7 is clearly a step above rhe x5 and xc90 in every way. You can get a x7 here, but you rarely see one.

    • @RandomHondaGuy
      @RandomHondaGuy 2 года назад

      @@dzengerink what ever you say

  • @Djafffarov
    @Djafffarov 3 года назад +1368

    I liked the way that Volvo left half of the car and drove further. Like Ikea, even without missing some elements you can still build your furniture.

    • @AdolfHitler-si3ze
      @AdolfHitler-si3ze 2 года назад +23

      Volvo=Geely

    • @gihansandeepa3961
      @gihansandeepa3961 2 года назад +23

      @@AdolfHitler-si3ze geely is shit

    • @AdolfHitler-si3ze
      @AdolfHitler-si3ze 2 года назад +10

      @@gihansandeepa3961 a couple of years ago, they were busted by Australian authorities for using asbestos based engine gaskets. They had to withdraw from the Australian market and coming back strongly under a different skin called Volvo

    • @Magicvision333
      @Magicvision333 2 года назад +15

      More whiplash on the Volvo plus the drive further could've hit another car resulting in more bodily injury or fall off a cliff

    • @gumgum1907
      @gumgum1907 2 года назад +5

      @@AdolfHitler-si3ze So is fucking BMW for morron

  • @tom201090
    @tom201090 2 года назад +38

    Another good safety feature of Volvo's is that, if they hit someone they are designed so the person is more likely to go up onto the bonnet and survive, rather than beneath the vehicle. There is a crash test video of this happening...at a press event I think, albeit accidently, the collision sensors (which I think were designed in this vehicle to pick out vehicles not pedestrians) didn't pick up the person who was standing directly in front of the moving car (which I think was an XC90) with tripod and camera and got hit by the car.

  • @taneyat6_33
    @taneyat6_33 2 года назад +6

    I miss my X5, it was too expensive to maintenance. However I felt so safe in it compared to my current car made out of fiberglass

  • @egeraenn7972
    @egeraenn7972 4 года назад +848

    0:33
    BMW Grill: I Believe I Can Fly

    • @Ghost.447.
      @Ghost.447. 4 года назад

      🤣🤣

    • @Kyle5836_main
      @Kyle5836_main 3 года назад

      🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @asdqwr123
      @asdqwr123 3 года назад +1

      ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋgood

    • @ejohnson3131
      @ejohnson3131 3 года назад +4

      Then the radiator screams and reaches out like "Please don't go!"

    • @magdiibragimov8792
      @magdiibragimov8792 3 года назад +1

      BMW is the shit

  • @itzgodlikexsexe6067
    @itzgodlikexsexe6067 3 года назад +885

    This looks like an easy way to swap out the BMW grill for a m peformance one

    • @mtrenfield7824
      @mtrenfield7824 3 года назад +8

      Hahahaha you're terrible 🤣

    • @wirooudejans4939
      @wirooudejans4939 3 года назад

      That’s why i don ‘t bye a volvo

    • @DoorisJ
      @DoorisJ 2 года назад

      Maybe a little too easy 😳

  • @user-sb5wr7mo9q
    @user-sb5wr7mo9q 2 года назад +16

    Очень интересно, красиво, но малоинформативно!
    Нужно было цифры добавить, пояснения!!! Текстом, звуком!

    • @PretentiousStuff
      @PretentiousStuff 2 года назад

      Ок

    • @victorpriceE23
      @victorpriceE23 11 месяцев назад

      Мне кажется что и без цыфр понятно,что Вольво лучше!При ударе, БМВ отбросило в сторону,что могло легко повлиять на пешехода,который попытался увернуться от удара.Или для любого транспорта,который оказался бы рядом.Кроме Этого, водитель БМВ,имел больше касания головой на подушках,чем водитель Вольво!Но лично мне,понравилось как себя повел автомобиль в момент столкновения,а именно Вольво!Он практически неизменил траекторию.........

  • @laurinharms
    @laurinharms 8 месяцев назад +1

    That grill of the bmw didn’t even think about stopping

  • @waldoinaz
    @waldoinaz 2 года назад +472

    Fastest tire change I’ve ever seen. The tire was off in under a second.

    • @ronaldo9120
      @ronaldo9120 2 года назад +6

      U so funny dude, with that joke, can be a famous conedian!!

    • @vroom3257
      @vroom3257 2 года назад +2

      But what did it cost 😂

    • @xgod_odin827
      @xgod_odin827 2 года назад +2

      Lightning mcqueen’s staff does better

    • @Wannes_
      @Wannes_ 2 года назад

      You must have missed Mission Impossible 2
      They didn't just remove a tire in under a second, they changed it in the blink of an eye !

    • @raydhanes
      @raydhanes 2 года назад

      Also, the alloy, cut in half pieces.

  • @ELy-cs8lh
    @ELy-cs8lh 2 года назад +512

    Imagine being a pedestrian just dodging an accident just to be sliced like an apple by a BMW grill being launched at you.

    • @obedofficial.
      @obedofficial. 2 года назад

      Lol

    • @Jan-yh6nm
      @Jan-yh6nm 2 года назад +14

      The grill is actually plastic

    • @MrVegchel
      @MrVegchel 2 года назад +18

      I bet you’re fun a parties

    • @Dante-vf4sd
      @Dante-vf4sd 2 года назад

      But it kept going down the road....

    • @Jan-yh6nm
      @Jan-yh6nm 2 года назад +27

      @@MrVegchel i bet you don‘t get invited to partys

  • @spideyboii1957
    @spideyboii1957 Год назад +3

    The X5 grill was like : nah I aint wanna crash😂

  • @rudolfhuijs4526
    @rudolfhuijs4526 2 года назад +2

    Very objective comparison, a 2016 XC90 vs a 2019 X5.

  • @ni55an
    @ni55an 2 года назад +112

    0:33
    BMW's grill: *catapulted
    Factory worker: hmm... that's why I have remaining bolts

    • @mcdev6868
      @mcdev6868 2 года назад +1

      It just keeps driving lol. But actually these are just clipped, no bolts used and it is not so eassy to get them off by hand.

    • @ntandoqeloiv9089
      @ntandoqeloiv9089 2 года назад

      HAhahahahahahahahahahahahaha

    • @ottonormal3354
      @ottonormal3354 2 года назад +1

      as a BMW factory worker, we dont use bolts for the grill. ;)

    • @justarandomguy3969
      @justarandomguy3969 2 года назад

      hahaha, your funny, bolts for a grill, thats the funniest shit i have heard in 20 years

    • @ni55an
      @ni55an 2 года назад

      @@justarandomguy3969 that was a point of the comment

  • @sannydjon2578
    @sannydjon2578 3 года назад +2395

    Тоже ищешь русский комент?

    • @user-jd7xt1ej4g
      @user-jd7xt1ej4g 3 года назад +24

      Ага

    • @phantom0590
      @phantom0590 3 года назад +8

      Нет

    • @ildarny5828
      @ildarny5828 3 года назад +6

      Нет. Перевожу комменты на английском. (Изучаю этот язык)

    • @grvin7641
      @grvin7641 3 года назад +3

      Странно, что не 40, не 50 процентов перекрытия удар. Т.е.методика априори нарушена. Т.с.показательные выступления, ах ах ах

    • @phantom0590
      @phantom0590 3 года назад +14

      @@ildarny5828 попробуй порнхаб. Очень увлекательно.

  • @Snaproll47518
    @Snaproll47518 Год назад

    I’m old enough to remember when U.S. car manufacturers howled about having to install $25 lap belts in cars. Lap belts that many refused to wear. Those were the days of cars that rotted out in 5-years and roadside breakdowns were common. Car safety and reliability have come a long way since the 1960s. I bought my last American car -actually assembled with Mexican parts- in 1986.

  • @rohithrj2044
    @rohithrj2044 2 года назад +1

    Adv for the cement?

  • @harkiibeats
    @harkiibeats 3 года назад +1199

    lets be real, no one searched for this

  • @pantyhose-art
    @pantyhose-art 3 года назад +1489

    Painful to watch

    • @rosemaryfriedw124a8
      @rosemaryfriedw124a8 3 года назад +70

      More painful if you're inside the BMW. Inside Volvo, you'll be getting out scratchless

    • @stephanmayer1104
      @stephanmayer1104 3 года назад +16

      Women in Pantyhose, absolutely... to look at you is much, much better ☺️

    • @foxxyguy2681
      @foxxyguy2681 3 года назад +34

      Fiqih Hakim My friend was very injured because he crashed his Volvo xc40 into a wall and flipped over so no matter what type of car you can still get injured in an accident.

    • @V4zz33
      @V4zz33 3 года назад +14

      Why? That Beemer wouldn't have used its left blinker anyway...

    • @foxxyguy2681
      @foxxyguy2681 3 года назад +7

      Ferenc Fajkusz that joke was funny in 2015 bruh it isn’t funny anymore lol

  • @ThomasAlkaersig
    @ThomasAlkaersig 2 года назад +3

    It's quite clear how much better the Volvo fairs in protection it's passengers by deflecting the impact, yet they basically get the same rating. I think maybe the system needs a little tweak.

  • @dantheman3022
    @dantheman3022 2 года назад +3

    That volvo didnt even slow down..........drove right on through the barrier....what a badass !

  • @vi8946
    @vi8946 2 года назад +292

    After this crash, Volvo continued its life as a 3-wheeler. It didn't stop 😅

    • @sallalooz
      @sallalooz 2 года назад +28

      That is actually good, because the person inside the car would feel less force in an accident. As for the BMW it didn't deflect the accident so the dummy would see more force. So the volvo would suck less.

    • @MrRadulaur
      @MrRadulaur 2 года назад +4

      @@sallalooz you don't have any idea what are you talking about! The car must remain as close as possible to the initial impact so it won't affect other car in traffic!

    • @sallalooz
      @sallalooz 2 года назад +4

      @@MrRadulaur haha...It seems like i don't know what i am talking about. Do you mind sharing more about your thesis. It would be amazing to see a crash simulation comparing both or maybe something you can share. Seems like you have deep insight. Educate me please

    • @miguelvalentine3954
      @miguelvalentine3954 2 года назад +5

      @@sallalooz that car will probably flip somewhere down the road

    • @steffenrosmus9177
      @steffenrosmus9177 2 года назад +2

      From XC 90 to Reliant Robin in 2 seconds.

  • @Jeffovski
    @Jeffovski 2 года назад +83

    Much respect to the guys driving these test-cars. They risk their life’s so that we can feel safe…

  • @user-fi1xu1pp7p
    @user-fi1xu1pp7p 2 года назад +1

    0:33 Lol that Spongebob and Mr. Krabs song was in my head: A grill is a grill .....

  • @leoscrazy493
    @leoscrazy493 Год назад +3

    My both kidneys are safe

  • @miikoCACAT
    @miikoCACAT 3 года назад +69

    Its so inspiring with the music especially the part where the BMW grill flew beautifully.

  • @ClassierAunt
    @ClassierAunt 3 года назад +44

    0:33
    " BMW crashes. "
    BMW's mouth: WEEEEEEEEEE.

  • @mariuspetre1613
    @mariuspetre1613 2 года назад +3

    The volvo was so smooth..didn't even needed airbags for that crush...

  • @AbdulRahmanNoor
    @AbdulRahmanNoor 2 года назад +1

    As laypersons, most of us would look at a crash like this in real life and think, "wow that expensive car got completely totalled" while in reality that crumpling and breaking away probably helped save the driver's life.
    Cars that are built more stiff may look better after a crash but harm the driver.

  • @-_______________________.___
    @-_______________________.___ 3 года назад +47

    They need to add a "Very Good" evaluation. These results are vastly better than the results found on other "Good" crashes.

    • @basengelblik5199
      @basengelblik5199 2 года назад +1

      Amazing ... Awesome ... Fabulous ... Could be next level beyond "Vastly"

    • @narukami597
      @narukami597 2 года назад +6

      They do all this carefully calculated testing and then rate with the vague terms bad, good, very good etc? Even a 10 point scale sounds too basic. I'd expect them to rate on a scale of 0 to 100.

    • @termitreter6545
      @termitreter6545 2 года назад +1

      Tbf you cant really see from the visuals how dangerous the crashs are. Like the forces and distortion on the dummies.

  • @tedspeed3338
    @tedspeed3338 3 года назад +22

    The grille didn’t even slow down.
    “I got places to be!”

  • @leocabral9197
    @leocabral9197 2 года назад +2

    That volvo even moved the wall xD

  • @igorparhikov8044
    @igorparhikov8044 2 года назад +2

    Автомобили такого класса и должны быть самыми безопасными,

  • @davidcho9761
    @davidcho9761 4 года назад +80

    That bmw grill is ejector grill,
    Like in aircraft 00:33

  • @georgevavoulis4758
    @georgevavoulis4758 3 года назад +7

    Love the way both vehicles moved to the right so controlled and stable not like the Jeep that rolled over

  • @lastminutesolutions
    @lastminutesolutions 2 года назад +7

    Volvo is incredible. Seems almost like a smooth impact

    • @41IVI4
      @41IVI4 2 года назад

      The only problem I saw was that the door crumbled and allowed shrapnel to come into the car.

  • @jayw3197
    @jayw3197 2 года назад

    which is the safer car between the two? I am having hardtime deciding which to buy for wife and myself.

  • @Zunimassa97
    @Zunimassa97 4 года назад +123

    0:32 lol the Beamers grill is like 'I must keep going'.

  • @DP-sb5jg
    @DP-sb5jg 2 года назад +91

    dont forget that volvo's seatbelts tighten on impending crashes and it pulls the chair down in an angle like bucket seats in race cars, and the headrest follows you. at least on the 2016+ volvo xc90. i dont know about the older models or bmw's. the crush zone took all the impact rather quickly which propelled the car to the right or straightforward but kept going. i wonder if the brake system was engaged, why it kept rolling? not sure if brakes are a factor or not included in the overall of things, bc again the volvo will have auto braking at less than 30mph or if the computer calculates an oncoming crash. it happened to me, a car was behind me and started to get really close on the highway where i was going 70mph. the xc90 automatically tighten my seatbelt, brought down my seat, and it lightly started to brake. the car behind me backed off and kept a distance. i know that volvo's in europe tailights will blink if the car behind it is too close, but i wonder if it does something similar to US consumers of xc90's??

    • @adyg777
      @adyg777 2 года назад +1

      Всё что вы описали, есть также и в бма и даже больше.

    • @dpatterson9540
      @dpatterson9540 2 года назад +2

      @@adyg777 I had no idea. Thanks!

    • @reaperreaper9593
      @reaperreaper9593 2 года назад +17

      All seat belts tighten during an impact. That is why they always have to be replaced after their charges fire.

    • @dpatterson9540
      @dpatterson9540 2 года назад +1

      @@reaperreaper9593 yes this i know. With the 360 cameras, it tightens when it calculates an impact will occur. Way before. Often no accident happens. It's a good signal to be more vigilant of what's around you or to prepare yourself mentally. Lol.

    • @alg7096
      @alg7096 2 года назад +12

      @@reaperreaper9593 Its different in a volvo. Trust me. When I got the xc90 a couple of times the seatbelt pulled me into my seat like no other seatbelt ever has. Way different than any other car I had before that. Its definitely not the same.

  • @lordofdrones
    @lordofdrones 2 года назад

    I'm surprised at how little and low volume sound comes from these, I guess Hollywood really did a number on us.

  • @EliGaffke
    @EliGaffke 2 года назад +1

    That grille flying off reminds me of this old guy I work with, when he screams at people his dentures fly out. He has a short temper, so we get to see it happen a lot.

  • @sreyash3997
    @sreyash3997 3 года назад +48

    Grill: "My time has come. Change da world"

  • @ShitHappensRLY
    @ShitHappensRLY 3 года назад +247

    What curious is how XC90 changes direction after the impact, it's a lot smoother so people in car won't suffer so much forces applied in different directions.

    • @dearbulls
      @dearbulls 3 года назад +15

      They got a strong A shaped frame if you check their structure

    • @r.gelmers6580
      @r.gelmers6580 2 года назад +41

      Yes, the Volvo's mitigation is superior to the BMW's. More force is transferred to the occupants in the BMW, leading to more severe injuries.

    • @johnnyjohn4898
      @johnnyjohn4898 2 года назад +32

      Yes and No. Because the Volvo ricochet also has an disadvantage, it could be thrown outside of street (and there could be anything, anyone etc) or a parapet causing Double Impact.😏🤔

    • @benplus2053
      @benplus2053 2 года назад +25

      Im not sure if those forces in different directions are a good thing. Comparing how that head is bouncing off the airbags at 0:45 and 1:12, id prefer to be inside BMW and not have my neck twist as if flies diagonally.

    • @mariusmuresan8248
      @mariusmuresan8248 2 года назад +15

      Observe and compare the impact on dummy's neck. The one in BM was better off.

  • @TheRustyCracker
    @TheRustyCracker 2 года назад +14

    You can tell quality difference between Volvo and bmw just cause of the front grills

    • @carlypot9421
      @carlypot9421 2 года назад +5

      I liked how the entire Volvo hood flies off.

  • @dutchuncle3310
    @dutchuncle3310 2 года назад +6

    This doesn’t give me any real information without expert explanation of the results, extremely uninformative.

  • @sahil01s
    @sahil01s 3 года назад +176

    Volvo's front grill is so loyal, no matter what I ain't leaving you

  • @sebasr4526
    @sebasr4526 4 года назад +441

    No one:
    Litterally no one:
    RUclips: Don't you want to know which car is safer? The BMW X5 or the volvo XC90?
    Me: SURE

    • @thomaspersson688
      @thomaspersson688 3 года назад

      sebas R no difference

    • @p.aradise
      @p.aradise 3 года назад +1

      I looked this up

    • @oczhaal
      @oczhaal 3 года назад +7

      The Volvo, clearly. It deviates the energy of the impact much better. You can see on the airbag that the print of the dummy 's face is way lighter. The BMW absorbs all the energy of the impact, meaning that a bigger part of it goes to the driver.

    • @user-ss7qs4ps1i
      @user-ss7qs4ps1i 3 года назад

      They're both unsave

    • @ramonzimmermann3995
      @ramonzimmermann3995 3 года назад

      @@oczhaal 😂😂😂

  • @ajaydhalvaniya520
    @ajaydhalvaniya520 Год назад +2

    The BMW front grill flies beautiful...

  • @artemlysiak7902
    @artemlysiak7902 4 месяца назад

    What does yellow A in Volvo means? It’s better then G in BMW or worse?

  • @Bigalinjapan
    @Bigalinjapan 2 года назад +164

    Most impressive thing is actually speed of the airbags...

  • @salarghoreshi
    @salarghoreshi 3 года назад +165

    Am I the only one who noticed that it's a 2016 XC90 and not a 2019???

    • @raph5907
      @raph5907 3 года назад +6

      Volvo 2016 vs blw 2019

    • @TheIceMurder2
      @TheIceMurder2 3 года назад +4

      Clickbait

    • @nielsvandenkieboom5034
      @nielsvandenkieboom5034 3 года назад +1

      It says 2016 in the description though. Odd clickbait.

    • @TheIceMurder2
      @TheIceMurder2 3 года назад

      @@nielsvandenkieboom5034 You had to click on the video first before reading the description hence clickbait...

    • @nielsvandenkieboom5034
      @nielsvandenkieboom5034 3 года назад

      @@TheIceMurder2 I agree, it is clickbait. I said odd because why put the correct number in the description if you're going to lie in the title anyway 😂

  • @joom7340
    @joom7340 2 года назад +12

    Love to see that beam ng made their game more realistic! Can’t wait to see what else they can improve!

  • @paulastephenson1862
    @paulastephenson1862 Год назад

    I keep buying Volvos and this is why. Years ago I walked away from a crash with only a few cuts and bruises instead of major injuries in a 1993 Volvo 240 wagon. I've never bought anything but Volvo since.

  • @_Everyone__
    @_Everyone__ 2 года назад +12

    This makes me glad that there is no solid metal blocks along the roads, those trees though - can still do plenty damage.

    • @dantheman3022
      @dantheman3022 2 года назад +2

      No solid metal blocks ?????
      You live under a rock ????
      Metal and concrete barriers are everywhere !!!

  • @Ginx-pe4si
    @Ginx-pe4si 4 года назад +19

    When you look at this, look at how the roof flexes and where the movement of the metal ripples to.

    • @RAiNfORAiNbOW
      @RAiNfORAiNbOW 4 года назад

      they seem the same to me, what did you see?

    • @plopping-wetlyacademyofmot9639
      @plopping-wetlyacademyofmot9639 4 года назад +3

      You're just seeing energy dispersed throughout the unibody..
      (The energy has to go somewhere)
      Its what the safety cage is designed to do; absorb and disperse crash energy.

    • @Ginx-pe4si
      @Ginx-pe4si 4 года назад

      @@plopping-wetlyacademyofmot9639 exactly, primary and secondary damage.

    • @theILOVEFDP
      @theILOVEFDP 3 года назад

      Volvo's have always been built to keep the riders safe. If you look at the damage done to the outside of the car. Volvo builds most things (or at least use to) so with impact they go outward rather than inward towards the riders. The hood completely disconnects from the car, along with part of the side panel that could possibly get lodged into the car or into the windshield. However, it also has a lot to do with how the energy is dispursed in a crash and whether it'll trigger any of those points at all.

  • @bluebeam5012
    @bluebeam5012 9 месяцев назад

    I like the effect where the dummy’s makeup comes off 😂 so realistic

  • @SerP46
    @SerP46 Год назад +1

    Во время просмотра заболела шея...
    Не нужна тебе , Вовка,эта машина👍, ©Кот.

  • @itsshalevfromtaxidashcamer9390
    @itsshalevfromtaxidashcamer9390 3 года назад +90

    *0:33** Grill: "Ai'ght, imma head out."*

  • @projectx5154
    @projectx5154 2 года назад +130

    I like how Volvo just says screw the tire, go straight. It reduces the impact on the driver, there's not much force being applied to him. I don't know if it's intended but it's a pretty smart idea if it is

    • @jonnymauser811
      @jonnymauser811 2 года назад +31

      It is. Volvo mastered vehicle safety.

    • @jonnymauser811
      @jonnymauser811 2 года назад +17

      There even is dynamite in the axles of newer cars so they blow off the wheel. Otherwise thw front left turns in your footspace which can be fatal.

    • @martinlund9524
      @martinlund9524 2 года назад +9

      @@jonnymauser811 I think they first improved this on 960/S/V/90 face lift. Before 740/940 there was a bigger risk for this.

    • @DoorisJ
      @DoorisJ 2 года назад +1

      And theres a post crash braking system, to safely bring you to a stop

    • @Max200012
      @Max200012 2 года назад +6

      @@jonnymauser811 bruh what lmao, dynamite? Source for that?

  • @_xd43l
    @_xd43l 2 года назад +1

    I have a problem with the front crash structure design of the Volvo. In the test it works great by transferring the momentum. But to archive that, Volvo made the front crash structure more "pointy". That means it can easier penetrante the structure of other cars in case of a front-end collision, putting their occupants at a greater risk of injury.

    • @tomasreznicek
      @tomasreznicek 2 года назад

      Buy volvo, not other cars then 😉

    • @_xd43l
      @_xd43l 2 года назад

      @@tomasreznicek buying a Volvo doesn't help you when you are hit by another one...

  • @poonsterx
    @poonsterx 2 года назад

    Where can I buy that wall?

  • @500hp
    @500hp 3 года назад +80

    0:50 - Решетка радиатора у БМВ даже после крушения - опасное оружие.

    • @BadBoy-fo2fn
      @BadBoy-fo2fn 3 года назад +3

      И?? Кто выиграл??🤔🤔🤔

    • @alemdibagindir5940
      @alemdibagindir5940 3 года назад

      @@BadBoy-fo2fn не знаю но по крештест 2020года 1.Тесла. 2.Вольво. 3.Ягуар. бмв 7.Или 9 забыл

    • @user-kt2zs5cr1r
      @user-kt2zs5cr1r 3 года назад

      Еркебулан Мадибек мерс на первом месте

    • @qton7814
      @qton7814 3 года назад +4

      @@user-kt2zs5cr1r он не может быть на первом месте, посмотри в инете и больше не делай вбросв

    • @BadBoy-fo2fn
      @BadBoy-fo2fn 3 года назад

      @@qton7814 сами немцы пишут, Ауди и БМВ догонят Мерс в 2021 году. Статистика не моя

  • @zickau
    @zickau 4 года назад +95

    0:33 BMW X5 crashed..
    Front Grille : Aight imma head out!

  • @asgeiryn
    @asgeiryn 2 года назад +7

    The thumbnail makes it look like the BMW came out victorious out of the comparison. But when you watch the video the BMW is so rigid that it lost almost all of its forward momentum and was launched up and sideways. Where as the Volvo, while suffering more "cosmetic" damage merely changed direction and slowed down over a much greater distance. If there was an occupant G censor it would show much more force inside the BMW

    • @Femaqui07
      @Femaqui07 2 года назад

      Yeah.. tell that to the technicians.. xD

  • @maximpasechnik4828
    @maximpasechnik4828 2 года назад +1

    Normal car* 4-6 air bags
    Car during crush test* over999999 bags

  • @UltraInstinctYiik
    @UltraInstinctYiik 3 года назад +88

    Bruh, the Volvo legit said "no u" and drove away from that crash on three wheels. Svedish engineering

  • @aleksandarvasiljevic8934
    @aleksandarvasiljevic8934 4 года назад +305

    Bmw grill is a bird 😂😂

    • @muckbo_jae
      @muckbo_jae 4 года назад +11

      0:34

    • @kabanmf
      @kabanmf 4 года назад +3

      AHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

    • @user-gw7rw5ib8y
      @user-gw7rw5ib8y 4 года назад +2

      Lolololololol

    • @omarramadneh1966
      @omarramadneh1966 4 года назад +1

      Thats why they put a kia grille on new models, our favorite grille flew away 🤦‍♂️😂

    • @SJK_42
      @SJK_42 4 года назад

      이호재 어 한국인?

  • @yanzstarking
    @yanzstarking 2 года назад

    Kapan punya begini

  • @volovomias3221
    @volovomias3221 2 года назад +1

    It’s actually funny, a lot of people were saying that the Volvo is dangerous because it doesn’t stop when colliding, and istead just slides forward. BMW’s previous version actually did that, it just stopped on impact, but now they have done the same thing as Volvo on how the car crumbles on impact, so it slides similarily off.

  • @danroll81
    @danroll81 2 года назад +78

    Amazing how well the Volvo disperses the energy, no bounce! Superb job!

    • @miguelvalentine3954
      @miguelvalentine3954 2 года назад +3

      So you're ok with the fact that the Volvo didn't actually stop

    • @Menethorable
      @Menethorable 2 года назад +6

      @@miguelvalentine3954 isnt that a Good thing?

    • @miguelvalentine3954
      @miguelvalentine3954 2 года назад +3

      @@Menethorable think the the potential damage it can do b4 it comes to a stop.

    • @BarryMDHo
      @BarryMDHo 2 года назад +16

      @@miguelvalentine3954 Engineers have learned long ago that vehicle crumple and breakaway zones act to absorb and deflect energy reducing injury. Formula 1 racing has seen injury and death reduction due to these principles. The more ubrupt "stop" of the BMW is contrary to this, whereas the Volvo is far superior. Look it up.

    • @tjay84
      @tjay84 2 года назад +5

      And notice how the wheel breaks off instead on going into to foot compartment..

  • @tryout5492
    @tryout5492 4 года назад +691

    2019 BMW vs 2016 VOLVO. Don't lie

    • @alexandrevachez3294
      @alexandrevachez3294 4 года назад +45

      Thanks you!

    • @endireitabrasil1719
      @endireitabrasil1719 4 года назад +5

      Sabe de nada inocente. Este volvo é um 2019 também

    • @victorbathory6668
      @victorbathory6668 4 года назад +27

      @@endireitabrasil1719 1:33 min. Volvo 2016

    • @banhbao2266
      @banhbao2266 4 года назад +15

      Oh Shit, i missed it. Wondering how good 2019 xc90 this day.

    • @alexzhou7
      @alexzhou7 4 года назад +14

      are u sure in 2019 their selling a different model? Could be a 2019 model, just hasn’t changed from 2016

  • @reeanimationgaming1034
    @reeanimationgaming1034 2 года назад

    How fast are they going?

  • @SupereKrakersik
    @SupereKrakersik 2 года назад +7

    Volvo slipped on wall so smooth. It must had generated much less energy than BMW. Lesser energy lesser damage to passengers

    • @johndododoe1411
      @johndododoe1411 2 года назад

      Smashing the car doesn't generate energy, it consumes it, leaving less energy to smash the passengers.

    • @SupereKrakersik
      @SupereKrakersik 2 года назад

      @@johndododoe1411 you clearly missed my point. There is given ammount of kinetic energy car has when going with certain velocity. Bending parts of car as you said consumes this energy. Volvo clearly slipped on obstacle smoother. What it means is that it lost less speed so it created less kinetic energy so impact was less damaging for passengers

  • @angelherg1997
    @angelherg1997 4 года назад +257

    I feel as though these tests would be better with actual humans, I have a few co-workers I would like to volunteer.
    Please contact me for their information.

    • @mgogomgogo7266
      @mgogomgogo7266 4 года назад +2

      Ha ha,u funny mate

    • @aaabbb-gd8nk
      @aaabbb-gd8nk 4 года назад +6

      Yes yes. Same here. I can suggest a whole dept of people and u can run tests everyday.

    • @mohammad2969
      @mohammad2969 4 года назад +2

      My Boss would like to volunteer for this demo

    • @mohammad2969
      @mohammad2969 3 года назад +2

      @Sewan & Sawen Creations
      Agreed
      But there are situations and responsibilities where you can't leave your job and stuck with the vultures

    • @angelherg1997
      @angelherg1997 3 года назад +4

      Life is too short not to have fun and take everything too seriously. It was just a joke, I actually like my co-workers.

  • @MegredyPhotoStudio
    @MegredyPhotoStudio 3 года назад +55

    RUclips suggestion:
    Crash test of two of the cars you can't afford?
    Me:
    Yeah, sure..

    • @jupanulkyrre1234
      @jupanulkyrre1234 3 года назад

      You could drive safe one day till than angels be with you!

    • @ophthodoc
      @ophthodoc 3 года назад

      I was lucky to buy an XC90 this year. I love it. It was between these two cars actually! I hope you get one of them some day.

  • @rbg9116
    @rbg9116 2 года назад

    What is the vehicle speed in the test?

  • @machomb
    @machomb 2 года назад +12

    In this particular test Bmw crash seemed a bit less violent for the driver than volvo.

  • @kevinjones5560
    @kevinjones5560 2 года назад +14

    I’ve had 7 Volvos and my S60 saved my life when I was totaled by an 18 wheeler. I have a new XC90 now.

  • @pbjracing14yearsago49
    @pbjracing14yearsago49 3 года назад +12

    Grille at 0:33
    change da world.
    my final message. Goodb ye

  • @Turgineer
    @Turgineer 7 месяцев назад

    0:34 Front grille: **continues to advance**

  • @JXSTXLLER
    @JXSTXLLER 2 года назад +1

    Damn! Let's see how many legends watching to this in 2022 ???
    : )