@runa yomozuki!! probably taking a bit to register the 1k+ likes for cg5, who knows edit: for anyone who thinks this as rude, i meant in popularity, not in something like bots.
This 100% confirms the theory that each ghost is about different times of happiness if that makes any sense. George is remembering what you had that was good, Brenda’s story is about what you have now, and Dave is about looking towards the future and knowing things will get better :)
Guys.. Kel made the story, Brenda made the dances that you see the characters do, Dave animated it, And George did the music, And they all sang together for the lyrics.
Dave is animating the Clover series, Kel and George are writing the lyrics to the songs to everyone's liking, and Brenda's the choreographer. Change my mind.
the messages from the ghosts songs: george: cherish the memories of your loved ones! brenda: always keep reaching your dreams! dave: *karma's a bitch* edit: oh god did I just foresee Jojo Siwa's song 2 years in advance oh god no
So, George's story is about overcoming his loss from the _past,_ Brenda's story is about overcoming the obstacles of the _present,_ and Dave's story is about looking forward to the _future_ no matter the circumstances?
Oh my, you’re a genius, I never even thought of that. George has to be over 100 years old at this point which we can piece together thanks to 100 Years, Brenda’s is a bit tricky, but thanks to Still Dancing we can deduce that she made it to old age, where she died of her disease, and with a bit more help from 100 Years it’s clear that George was the first ghost to find Kel, meaning that Brenda has to be younger than George. The most complicated is Dave, since his death was never shown, but I think I might be able to piece it together with help from Karma, I hope, but I am open to any suggestions.
Seems like in this one we don’t see how Dave passes like unlike Brenda who never actually got a chance to fulfill her dream or George who was still holding onto his past love, Dave accomplished everything he wished and proved everyone wrong so he died in peace with no reason to think of the past on his deathbed.
@@tehahhuatipgkkent1369 I think they are there to show the downs he had to dill with like my mom has always say where we see ups in succes there also comes the downs
George: Died of age/possible things from WWII Brenda: Died from (I assume) a desise that paralizes and kills nerve ends Dave: I have to only guess poisoning from his own ink. (Because wasn't lead a main ingredient in ink at the time?)
@@shaden.l.m.9506 pretty sure that Dave is the grandpa in help me who died .It would also explain during the song after this why it seems like the MC and Dave a close bond compared to the others.
George: dies happy thinking about his love Brenda: dies happy because she can still dance despite the disease that struck her Dave: dies happy because he just ended a rich man's career
@@konnigonconnie6226 that's the Harry potter interpretation however they can become spirits to guide others with stuff they dealt with and have succeeded in themselves like in this instance however there are many more interpretations you can have on spirits and ghosts and poltergeist alike
Kel: a sad child depression Dave: a man who never gave up George: a man who died but he still waited and still is Brenda: a woman whose daughter helped her until she died
That woman, isn't that Brenda's daughter/the woman who saved George during his heart attack? Same hair design, and she has the same bow as during Brenda's song and the dog-paw watch from George's. She is 100% a very important piece to the puzzle.
This comment was lost to the sea of comments, so here's another comment shortening it. George : Think about the *past* Brenda : Think about the *present* Dave : Think about the *future* Brenda's daughter is presumably is all 3 music videos, helping George, Brenda and Dave achieve their dreams. Moral of the series : Your actions affects the past, present and future. Think about the past, present and future, and make your actions according to it.
This song always cheers me up, I swear. I remember back in elementary school, when I'd show some classmates a drawing I'd redone 3-4 times and my heart was broken when one of them scribbled it out. Since then, I've always done my best to keep moving forward no matter what comes my way. Fast forward years later, and I'm still following my passion by pursuing art in college. Karma really is what you make!
My theory is, this confirms that the girl who picked up Dave's drawing, is Brenda's daughter (or someone related to Kel as how much it was hinted) which means she maybe is important to the story because with this video, I finished a timeline I made: *Still Dancing* - Brenda's daughter as a kid with her mother, Brenda *Karma (This video **1:30**)* - Brenda's daughter in her adolescence/adulthood (But still young considering her ponytail) *100 Years (The video timestamp for 100 years: **2:08**)* - Brenda's daughter married and has a child, and seeing old George hve a heart attack, taking him to the hospital. (Considering having a husband since she has a kid and her hairstyle became mature and adult-like) So, to sum it up, Brenda's daughter as a child saw her mother die of a paralysis illness, and then grows up normally, until running along Dave moving his stuff out of the studio, seeing a drawing and being delighted by it (after that event, it could be that either Brenda's daughter supported Dave as a friend until the end, or eventually getting married (Speculating the 2:16 scene where they are together) which leads to the 100 years video, where she is seen with a young boy with her on a picnic and taking george to the hospital after a heart attack. Now I dont think she'd be alive in 2020, so its probably just that the 3 ghost's ages are probably close (about 1890 to 1910) just meeting Brenda's daughter in different parts of their life (Being Brenda during her young adulthood as her mom, Dave probably in his 30s or 40s, and George at old age) Also I dont believe the war George fought for is WW1, his war could have been the 1948 WW2, when 50 million americans were drafted ranging from 21 - 45 years of age, sending them to war, so he could have been born around the 1890s - 1900s, because his love stayed during 1920 being 100 years of love until 2020, but only half of it was during living and half was during as a ghost and he broke up with his lover and then went to war, if it was during WW1, it would mean that it was during the 1890s, which would not make sense with the timing, so his life limit is 1970 (as when he was dead he still loved her, until 2020, also i do not speculate George being Brenda's partner because still has some loose strands to that theory), so he was probably drafted to war at 1948, then the remainder of those years living, from 1890-1900s to 1970 (a.k.a his life limit according to the song) so that means he was around 70-80 at that age. I agree about Dave being born at that date (speculated birth of Dave: 1900s-1910) the same way because it was about 1920-28 with the golden years of animation. Now with Brenda, She was possibly born around 1910 as 1920 was where dancing was popular, in her case tap dancing, fitting to her age being around 10 when seeing her inspiration, she probably got into her career around 20-25, being 1945 her speculated death, leading to Brenda's daughter being around 10-12 during her death, so Brenda's daughter is possibly born in the middle of her career and was born around 1930-35, so when she met Dave, she was around 20-25 around 1955-60 and Dave being around 30-40, so if she did have a kid, and meeting George can fit as she is around 30-35 (During 1970) when he met george having a heart attack. But if George did fight for WW1, the uniform would make sense (thanks to regetjet XD45) for him, but if it was that war the whole timeline I speculated would be a whole different can of worms, but then again it is a theory, so it does have some holes, but it patches up neatly dont'ya say? *Physical clues* (The T-shirt design also matches as it has the black and white stripes, and the appearance are similarly drawn, maybe not a coincidence) *Also just a theory of mine, feel free to reply and share your overview*
I mean it is speculated that Branda is Georges girl from 100 years and he couldn't be with her because either the army or he didn't want to give up her dream or something and then his daughter saves him and tells him what happened to her and he dies peacefully
I believe that George ad Brenda are Mels great-great-great-grandparents and Dave is her great- grandparent.Bc in Help Me at 2:21 you see a Wubby the Wolf poster behind Mels grandpas(cinsidering he IS her grandpa)most likely because Dave is Mels grandpas father.Also in Help me at 2:24 you see a hummingbird and a stuffed rabbit,and who are ghosts with the characteristics of a hummingbird and rabbit?George and Brenda,which brings me to my next conclusion that Brenda and George are married. In 100 Years at the start you see a woman wearing a hat,the same hat in Still Dancing at 0:53 on the floor.Then at 1:02 we see a letter in a chair which may be the same letter in 100 years at 0:55(we can't see what it says).You then see at 1:13 you see a hummingbird which atleast to me symbolizes George.
I believe that George ad Brenda are Mels great-great-grandparents and Dave is her great- grandparent.Bc in Help Me at 2:21 you see a Wubby the Wolf poster behind Mels grandpas(cinsidering he IS her grandpa)most likely because Dave is Mels grandpas father.Also in Help me at 2:24 you see a hummingbird and a stuffed rabbit,and who are ghosts with the characteristics of a hummingbird and rabbit?George and Brenda,which brings me to my next conclusion that Brenda and George are married. In 100 Years at the start you see a woman wearing a hat,the same hat in Still Dancing at 0:53 on the floor.Then at 1:02 we see a letter in a chair which may be the same letter in 100 years at 0:55(we can't see what it says).You then see at 1:13 you see a hummingbird which atleast to me symbolizes George. Next part is that G & B had a girl who grew up and we see her again in 100 years at 2:10 and I do believe that child is Mels grandfather.And child is Daves child and so Dave is Mels grandfathers father.Now all we need is a final song to finish it off.
Notice how we ever see him actually alive again after the guns fire. It’s symbolic. It’s implying he was assassinated. So yeah, they did show his death, just not directly.
@@generalkuros56 well let's hope what Scrapy said was just a theory, it would be horrible if Dave's boss got to him... maybe Karma wasn't there for Dave when he needed it most :(
@@GellygirlButRUclips was that his boss what I got from it was he pitched his idea the fat man said no so he went and maid it anyway and when it become a huge the fat man got mad and ether killed him or had him killed but I still say karma was on his side cuase the murder whoud be linked back to him plus think about it the show whoud probably get even bigger if he died cause more people whoud talk about it so ether way the fat man messed up
My dad is 72 years old and I showed him this video asking him to guess what year this was made and he said "it's probably around the 70's or 80's". When I told him it was released last year he was shocked and amazed. This shows how good of a recreation of the 80s vibe it is
Fun fact: every song in this album has the word crazy except for “still dancing” nice. (just so people know what i mean: Help me: “crazy, i might be going crazy-,” 100 Years: “they call me crazy,-” Karma: “My joy will only drive you crazy!)
Dave's lil dance he does when he's presenting Wubby to the rich guy is so cute and funny! (This is my favorite Clover song by far, though all of them are amazing!)
Ghost lessons! George: Cherish your memories and your loved ones, they’ll get you through the tough times. Brenda: Put your mind to it, and you can achieve your dreams no matter what others say. Dave: Who cares what they think? The ones who keep trying to put you down are a waste of your breath, focus on what you love and let karma give them their due.
I think this Song really teaches you about not giving up, but also not to take revenge, because the people who wronged you will be wronged, and to forgive. This is nice.
George: my gf left me but I'm still grooving. Dave: the company didnt want my cartoon ideas but I'm still grooving. Brenda: I have a very dangerous disease that is slowly killing me... But I'm still grooving.
According to Irish tradition, those who find a four-leaf clover are destined for good luck, as each leaf in the clover symbolizes good omens for faith, hope, love, and luck Kel: hope George: love Brenda: faith Dave: karma (luck?)
As someone who was both bullied as a child consistently and is about to publish a book (Itll be done being edited by me eventually!) I can't express how much I needed this song in my life. Thanks for making it impactful and just an absolute banger.
George's Lesson: Keep people in your heart even after they're gone. Brenda's Lesson: Think optimistically and don't let anything stand in your path. Dave's Lesson: *E a t T h e R i c h .*
Nah bendy watched his animations and was like " (deep inhale) why cant I be friends with this guy and why couldnt i have been animated by this very clearly sane animator"
I think that it’s sad to believe, but in the final scene, I think that it’s a metaphor for Dave getting shot by the rich guy, as shown by the hunters shooting and then him as a ghost, but the rich guy drowning in papers means that he was caught for killing Dave and got what he deserved.
Or3o saved my life i was thinking on offing myself by putting a bag over my head (i was depressed at the time ) while i was scrolling thought YT late at night and then i found 100 years and it made me think of my love life and legit made me cry myself out of it. so all i can say is thanks
alternate title: deranged animator kills 4 men with nothing but a pen and a hand-drawn wolf but seriously, these songs are wonderful and i hope you never stop producing.
All of the ghosts are the little girl's ancestors. Brenda and George had a daughter who we see as an adult in 100 Years, and as a child in Still Dancing. The woman we see with Dave in this is the same girl. I think Dave might be Kel's grandfather.
@@dakotathompson3384 Hum I think dane is a great grandfather because, brenda and george had a daughter who marry with dave, but in 100 years there is a boy with brown hair with george daughter, but this boy is not the father of kel (because her father has black hair) i think this boy is the old man who died in Help me
As someone who really wants to become an animator, this song really hit right in the feels. I never really have the most faith in my drawings sometimes, sometimes even thinking they'll never get anywhere apart from the bin. But its songs like this that make me realize: I can do it. I can be an animator. I do have faith in my drawings. Oh, and the fact the song is such a bop too helps as well. :)
@@backgroundcharacter3153 Thanks bud. That really means a lot, honest to god it does. And you know what? You're right. Somewhere out there is an audience that wants to see my stuff. And if their out there, then I'm going to make them glad they decided to stick around in the first place!
@@whitefang2312 Thanks! I'm glad still dancing helped you out too! I'll be honest all of these songs are tear jerkers, but karma really hit right in the sweet spot!
Okay so theorie: Brendas daughter is the girl that fist helped and married Dave. Later on a picnic with their son she saves the life of George who was having a heart attack in a park. He later dies in the hospital tho. Also idk why but her and Daves kid kinda has the same head shape as kels grandfather, leading me to believe that the kid in fact later becomes Kels grandfather, making dave her great grandfather. This means Brenda is the „oldest“ ghost, followed by George, later Dave, and at last Kels Grandfather Edit: Coming to think of it, Brenda does look a lot like the women in georges song, plus they were dancing together. If She and George actually were married, then Georges song isn’t about being left despite still loving a person, but about dealing with the death of his deceased wife Brenda
1st reply We're no strangers to love You know the rules and so do I A full commitment's what I'm thinking of You wouldn't get this from any other guy I just wanna tell you how I'm feeling Gotta make you understand Never gonna give you up Never gonna let you down Never gonna run around and desert you Never gonna make you cry Never gonna say goodbye Never gonna tell a lie and hurt you We've known each other for so long Your heart's been aching but you're too shy to say it Inside we both know what's been going on We know the game and we're gonna play it And if you ask me how I'm feeling Don't tell me you're too blind to see Never gonna give you up Never gonna let you down Never gonna run around and desert you Never gonna make you cry Never gonna say goodbye Never gonna tell a lie and hurt you Never gonna give you up Never gonna let you down Never gonna run around and desert you Never gonna make you cry Never gonna say goodbye Never gonna tell a lie and hurt you (Ooh, give you up) (Ooh, give you up) (Ooh) Never gonna give, never gonna give (Give you up) (Ooh) Never gonna give, never gonna give (Give you up) We've known each other for so long Your heart's been aching but you're too shy to say it Inside we both know what's been going on We know the game and we're gonna play it I just wanna tell you how I'm feeling Gotta make you understand Never gonna give you up Never gonna let you down Never gonna run around and desert you Never gonna make you cry Never gonna say goodbye Never gonna tell a lie and hurt you Never gonna give you up Never gonna let you down Never gonna run around and desert you Never gonna make you cry Never gonna say goodbye Never gonna tell a lie and hurt you Never gonna give you up Never gonna let you down Never gonna run around and desert you Never gonna make you cry Never gonna say goodbye Never gonna tell a lie and hurt... get rickroled m8
Also, I loved the metaphor for the lawsuit, when I first saw it, I thought it simply magic, but now, I know that it could mean that the Evil Buisnessman was going to steal Wubby, so he sewed him, with piles of papers, coming from a pen.
Going over what i believe to be Karma's plot: Dave, as a young child, already knew what he wanted to be, an animator. he already had a character in mind, but bullies attempted to discourage him of his dreams. Instead, he powered through and got a job at a large animation business. His first pitch would be Wubby's show, which was rejected, and cost Dave his job there. When he left, a woman saw one of his drawings of Wubby and decided he'd be someone to invest in, allowing Dave to start his own company. The product was a smash hit, leading to Dave getting a movie premiere. While he was at the theatre, however, the owner of the company from before hired a hitman. The hitman was successful initially, but was found out and it was revealed that the company owner had hired him, essentially blowing back in his face. The company quickly went bankrupt, taking the owner down with it.
This song really helped me. I was at a summer camp and some guys in my cabin made fun of my art and instead of get back at them for it I just told myself “Revenge only delays and my times not worth the waste. Cause karma’s gonna help me anyways, watch out, karma’s what you make.” Thank you, it really helped me.
Wait hold on! What if Dave never died by the end of the video. I know it sounds crazy but hear me out. At the end of the video you don't see Dave as an actual ghost, but a drawing of him as a ghost. Since you don't see him ever actually die, he still could be alive and with Kel. As for how she gets the lessons, it's because Dave is there to help her, with Brenda and George's daughter by his side with her knowledge about there experience in life. That's why he can also draw the other two as their ghosts as well as his to fit in. Plus, you don't see a bird in his video like all the other ones had. I know there are probably holes in my theory, but that's what I think is happening. Tell me what you think so I can try to figure it out. Thanks!
@@afacelessidiot946 That's where the holes are in my theory, but thanks for bringing it up... I don't know. I was just going off of this video and the differences it had with Brenda and George in regards to how they are seen dead.
“Karma’s what you make” This song’s unironically got some of the best words to live by. “Don’t bother trying to get back on those guys, life’ll do it for you.”
THEORY TIME ya know the theory that the t-shirt girl was brenda's daughter this might have been disproven bc her hair is different but assuming it isnt a diferent person this might be them giveing us a sense of timeline, aka saying that brenda died 1st then george then dave the girl also indicates that about the time george died she knew dave and this wouldent happen if she wasnt a recurring character the only reason im making this theory is bc she comes up in every song so to recap shirt girl is brenda's child and is an adult by george's video when he dies, but is in some sort of relationship with dave (as friends or otherwise is unclear) while he is in his 30s-40s
And probably the girl was an ancestor of clover. They seem to gone through alot and they wanted to do something for clover thanks to the girl that helped them back then. Clover was insecure and wasn't supported of her interest on music so the ghost's probably wanted to help her since her probably ancestor helped them back then. Brenda died first when the girl was a child. Grew up, met george in the park as he got a heart attack and saying not to give up on love. And met Dave and helped him bring his dream to life. The 3 probably weren't able to repay her so they decided to help her ancestor clover instead :D Just a theory tho but it seem to fit right in to me
I love this little story. A woman who loved dancing but was paralyzed, a man who still loved a woman after 100 years, and another man, who never gave up on his animation and made it bug. and all of them after death come together to help this little girl who's grieving and having many problems.
Theory; 1:28 Has anyone ever noticed that this one woman persists through all of these ghosts stories? Somewhat linking them of some sorts. She appears in George’s story to help him to the hospital, and she’s here in Dave’s story. Now you may think; “she didn’t appear in Brenda’s story!” Now this may seem like a stretch, but what if she was the girl giving Brenda advice on how to “keep dancing anyway”? Just some food for thought. Edit: ok she’s definitely the same person in every video. And I’m pretty sure she’s the mother/grandma in the living on video too.
I know this story is fictional, but it's pretty much exactly like the story of Alan Becker. He's one of the best animators I've ever seen, but he was taken advantage of in the past and also was turned down by Pixar. Now, he's super famous and an insanely great animator. This story reminds me of that :)
Theory: Brenda, george and Dave are the representation of entertainment George is singing, he lived a healthy life, and talking bout music in general music was never forgotten Brenda is dancing, at the first few years she lived normally but became ill, dancing was quite popular when Brenda was a kid, then when she became an adult dancing slowly.dies and faded away, so Brenda also slowly dies, Then Dave at first is harrased since animation still hasn't took of yet and Dave still had a hard time since many people see animations as childish then more people appriciated it So basically what I'm saying is that if they're genre of entertainment is dying or forgotten they also die, ik stupid theory but it's the best I can come up with
Now this is coming from someone who hasn't watched the other vids yet, so I don't actually know shit, but your theory sounds really good based on what you point out about the characters, i.e. you've supported your claim well. You get a Well Done from this random stranger. Also, with your theory in mind, I can't help but wonder what else we might see that could fit into it.
Honestly this theory makes alot of sense but I think it more applies to the styles not the medium and that it never really dies even if it falls out of fashion They live on as ghosts able to pass their knowledge on The new generation's style may be different but they same spark lives on Which makes sense for the style of these songs and their music videos An older style of music remade with a different flare while still taking the blueprint from old masters of their craft The same applies to the animation having the spirit of the old style but with new flare and technique for the modern era And the experience from what held them back can help guide the new generation Dave faces ridicule from others being shunned for his art but in the end over comes his tormentors by instead of resenting them being determined to be better than them by not retaliating at them but focusing on his craft and proving them wrong not with his words but with his actions Like a modern day artist being put down by parents or other authority for perusing a seemingly useless skill But perusing their passions regardless to prove them wrong Then later supporting other struggling artists going through the same And connecting with others they wouldve never met without their "useless hobby" George was never recognized for his work he tried endlessly to get the recognition he was looking for and while he never found it he never let himself be put down and continued to pursue his passion till the very end Like modern day musicians who while talented is overshadowed by others who made it into the public eye first Always working to get the credit for the work they do and reach their fullest potential and seeing that even if you arent the star of the world's stage You run your own show Brenda while being unable to completely overcome her obstacle she learns to do great things even with these ever present issues Like someone struggling with mental illnesses that cant just be gotten rid of And while we may struggle and we may suffer and have our bad days You learn to live on even with these things being ever present And in the end live an even better life than anyone could believe (I dont know enough about the culture surrounding dance as an art form to equate this to a modern day struggle of dance but if someone does have something that fits here I would love to hear it)
@@cmdAHYT well I guess kel could represent us.. the stereotypical new gen... We rely on these forms of entertainment to keep us from crumbling apart.. that's why the three ghosts of entertainment helps kel instead of KELling her... I'm cringe lpl
![OC Animatic - Ship in a Bottle [ FLASH WARNING! ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SocVqKJsYsA/mqdefault.jpg)
It's a Clover Christmas! 🌲🍀
First comment :D
Yus
@runa yomozuki!! probably taking a bit to register the 1k+ likes for cg5, who knows
edit: for anyone who thinks this as rude, i meant in popularity, not in something like bots.
It's a CG5 Christmas too!!
🍀🍀🍀
each character's motivations:
George: love
Brenda: passion
Dave: TO PROVE THE HATERS WRONG
Dave: SPITE
@@cristian-ionutapostol8018 people are so spiteful, we will do something harmful to ourselves to prove a point. It’s a helluva motivator
@@randomtechpriest2644 Spite is the most powerful fuel for us
No: a pen is the best weapon
Quite literally
@@GhaniKeSawah It really is.
This 100% confirms the theory that each ghost is about different times of happiness if that makes any sense. George is remembering what you had that was good, Brenda’s story is about what you have now, and Dave is about looking towards the future and knowing things will get better :)
Oh shite you rite
God, this spoils the mood but you made me remember the ghosts of christmas past, present and future...
Thats highly accurate OwO
@@sureindubitably3771 it came out on Christmas too
Ghost of time
Guys..
Kel made the story,
Brenda made the dances that you see the characters do,
Dave animated it,
And George did the music,
And they all sang together for the lyrics.
I love this idea!
@Unicorn Bee NO THIS IS REALLY TRUE
wow
it all make sense now!
I think George would write and Kel would make the song lolA
Watch out...😏
What a joy to sing for Dave. Thank you for trusting me, OR3O🙏
Nice voice you got there, can I have it?
AWESOME JOB CALEB. YOU HAVE AN AMAZING VOICE
CALEB YOU'RE THE ONE WHO SANG IN THIS?! SO THAT'S WHY ITS FAMILIAR!
You did such a great job on the voice
Oh yeah that makes sense that you sang this. Hi Caleb!
George: Appreciates the *past*
Brenda: Lives in the *present*
Dave: Plans for the *future*
Good eye
Omg ur right
so are they technically the ghosts of past, present and future?
Ah yes, a christmas carol all over again
TRUEEEEEEEEEEEE
Dave is animating the Clover series, Kel and George are writing the lyrics to the songs to everyone's liking, and Brenda's the choreographer. Change my mind.
I wont...
Because I agree with you
More like Kel makes the instrumentals and George writes the lyrics but you're onto something
I cant change someone's mind if i agree with them
You are a genious why would we change your mind
I won't
the messages from the ghosts songs:
george: cherish the memories of your loved ones!
brenda: always keep reaching your dreams!
dave: *karma's a bitch*
edit: oh god did I just foresee Jojo Siwa's song 2 years in advance oh god no
y e s
Why did I laugh at this
True
@@soupcan2 Haha, when translated into ‘English’ it turns into “And it is”.
@@Gelatinous_Creature holy sh- for real?
Rich dude: **rejects Dave’s idea**
Dave: *Imma bout to end this whole man’s career*
Rich dude : dies by papers
Lol!
Is that a joke which the simple Russian will not understand?
@@anynum6864 rich man turned into a paper stump of a tree simple :D
rich dude : HAH KARMA IS NOT GONNA HELP YOU
karma : so you have chosen death
I find is strange and a little mysterious that we didn’t actually see how he died. Music was amazing and the animation was incredible
Maybe from old age?
I was thinking he got shot, somehow.
Tbh i think he is the girls uncle who we saw in the hospital because he has the wolf poster
I think he got assasinated, i don't have anything to back it up, but there's a lot of guns there
I know right with the other 2 the death was made clear to us but with him we're only given a vague ending for rivalry between him and the bad guy
BE STRONG, THIS IS NOT A DRILL, THIS IS NOT A DRILL, GET READY FOR AMAZING MUSIC
Yessss
Omg it's already here
Yas
This is my favourite character out of the 4, I'm really exited!
yes. just yes
George: Love
Brenda: Hope
Kel: Luck
Dave: *KARMA.*
It's more of that revenge and hate don't get you ennywer in life and that you need to lett this go to be free and not haunted by it
So technically his faith was to become famous nice
fr
So,
George's story is about overcoming his loss from the _past,_
Brenda's story is about overcoming the obstacles of the _present,_
and
Dave's story is about looking forward to the _future_ no matter the circumstances?
Ooooh , it's true !
Oh my, you’re a genius, I never even thought of that. George has to be over 100 years old at this point which we can piece together thanks to 100 Years, Brenda’s is a bit tricky, but thanks to Still Dancing we can deduce that she made it to old age, where she died of her disease, and with a bit more help from 100 Years it’s clear that George was the first ghost to find Kel, meaning that Brenda has to be younger than George. The most complicated is Dave, since his death was never shown, but I think I might be able to piece it together with help from Karma, I hope, but I am open to any suggestions.
@@LisaVGG Now I'm almost scared to find out how Dave died
@@judesliggoo I hear you there
Cristmas Carol: OR3O addition
"I don't believe in superstition"
*Becomes a ghost after death
lol
LMAO
He got shot
But bro he said it's in his intuition tho?
Big bruh moment
Seems like in this one we don’t see how Dave passes like unlike Brenda who never actually got a chance to fulfill her dream or George who was still holding onto his past love, Dave accomplished everything he wished and proved everyone wrong so he died in peace with no reason to think of the past on his deathbed.
That might be why he isn't portrayed at his youngest or "best" In his ghost from.
But then what’s with the guy who fired him? Why was with he with the guys who tried to kill his creation?
@@tehahhuatipgkkent1369 I think they are there to show the downs he had to dill with like my mom has always say where we see ups in succes there also comes the downs
same
@@farbinnuha5409 just like that one guy...
George: story about love
Brenda: story about determination
Dave: *_got hunted with guns and won with paper_*
The pen is mightier than the sword oh wait theres no swords
George: Died of age/possible things from WWII
Brenda: Died from (I assume) a desise that paralizes and kills nerve ends
Dave: I have to only guess poisoning from his own ink. (Because wasn't lead a main ingredient in ink at the time?)
@@shaden.l.m.9506 The disease you’re looking for is Polio, I believe.
@@shaden.l.m.9506 pretty sure that Dave is the grandpa in help me who died .It would also explain during the song after this why it seems like the MC and Dave a close bond compared to the others.
gun made of metal
metal from rock
paper beat rock
George, Brenda, and Dave all had one thing in common, they never let anyone stop what they love.
True true
So keep holding on to your Dreams
@@amarthon6597 i see what you did there
@@rosette4268 where?
@@amarthon6597 you know the new clover song?
George: dies happy thinking about his love
Brenda: dies happy because she can still dance despite the disease that struck her
Dave: dies happy because he just ended a rich man's career
lmao
he ended a rich guys career
Lol that’s gonna be me ngl
No because he finished his life long dream
But there must’ve been something they weren’t happy about right? If I remember right you turn into a ghost because you weren’t happy about something
@@konnigonconnie6226 that's the Harry potter interpretation however they can become spirits to guide others with stuff they dealt with and have succeeded in themselves like in this instance however there are many more interpretations you can have on spirits and ghosts and poltergeist alike
Everyone: omg he's already my fav character even before we knew him!!!
Me: *always has been*
🔫
Always will be
lol same
He will always be a favorite, I might try drawing Wubby
@@littlesounder1932 Yea Plas try it I'm sure it'll turn out grear
Kel: a sad child depression
Dave: a man who never gave up
George: a man who died but he still waited and still is
Brenda: a woman whose daughter helped her until she died
That woman, isn't that Brenda's daughter/the woman who saved George during his heart attack?
Same hair design, and she has the same bow as during Brenda's song and the dog-paw watch from George's.
She is 100% a very important piece to the puzzle.
Oh my god it all makes sense now
Damn what a lucky gal... Wait hold on what if that woman was also dave's wife?
@@i-4419 idk might be i guess
Now this just means Dave is younger out of all of them or the girl might just be someone else
Oh dam that crazy
This man attacked his boss with drawings of his fursona at the end
YEH
Yes
i have never been so offended by something i 100% agree with
Classic tactic
*Karma is what you make*
Boss: rejects wubby he wolf
Dave: I'm bout to end the mans whole career.
This needs about a million likes
Dave didn't end his career. Karma did
Boss: This show wont work, now leave!
Karma: are you sure about that?
Excuse me, hes the big boss man
my auntie : rejects my Drawing
my mom and karma : ah…you chose death?with pleasure…
Rich guy:I fear nothing
Paper: * exists *
Rich Guy:I have one fear
No joke bit I fear fire a little more
@@Spring_Proto_Gaming HAH BECAUSE YOUR, I GET IT!
@@Spring_Proto_Gaming OHHH I GET IT
@@HuskTehBozo indeed
@@tonka4201 yep
rich dude: *rejects daves drawing*
dave: im boutta end this mans whole carreer
True dat
Dave gets a mini gun with paper as ammo
Oh helll yea
@@krisgabrielgurapo9990 karma and wubby: no u
Literally
I think Dave’s the only guy without a depressing story is this series.
He does have the depress part,right at the start he was bullied by his classmates but ended up being a rich animator when he grew up
I think it should have been depressing, but he just kept trying
This animation is the animation when they show daves backstory
His lifed was destined to have a depressing story, but he work hard to change that and get a happy ending
@Pupsickle! *Kel
This comment was lost to the sea of comments, so here's another comment shortening it.
George : Think about the *past*
Brenda : Think about the *present*
Dave : Think about the *future*
Brenda's daughter is presumably is all 3 music videos, helping George, Brenda and Dave achieve their dreams.
Moral of the series : Your actions affects the past, present and future. Think about the past, present and future, and make your actions according to it.
I'd just caught on that the same girl supported both Dave and George, it makes sense for that to be Brenda's daughter.
Right
yes
Alex yes
Sry but who is who?
This song always cheers me up, I swear. I remember back in elementary school, when I'd show some classmates a drawing I'd redone 3-4 times and my heart was broken when one of them scribbled it out. Since then, I've always done my best to keep moving forward no matter what comes my way. Fast forward years later, and I'm still following my passion by pursuing art in college. Karma really is what you make!
My theory is, this confirms that the girl who picked up Dave's drawing, is Brenda's daughter (or someone related to Kel as how much it was hinted) which means she maybe is important to the story because with this video, I finished a timeline I made:
*Still Dancing* - Brenda's daughter as a kid with her mother, Brenda
*Karma (This video **1:30**)* - Brenda's daughter in her adolescence/adulthood (But still young considering her ponytail)
*100 Years (The video timestamp for 100 years: **2:08**)* - Brenda's daughter married and has a child, and seeing old George hve a heart attack, taking him to the hospital. (Considering having a husband since she has a kid and her hairstyle became mature and adult-like)
So, to sum it up, Brenda's daughter as a child saw her mother die of a paralysis illness, and then grows up normally, until running along Dave moving his stuff out of the studio, seeing a drawing and being delighted by it (after that event, it could be that either Brenda's daughter supported Dave as a friend until the end, or eventually getting married (Speculating the 2:16 scene where they are together) which leads to the 100 years video, where she is seen with a young boy with her on a picnic and taking george to the hospital after a heart attack.
Now I dont think she'd be alive in 2020, so its probably just that the 3 ghost's ages are probably close (about 1890 to 1910) just meeting Brenda's daughter in different parts of their life (Being Brenda during her young adulthood as her mom, Dave probably in his 30s or 40s, and George at old age)
Also I dont believe the war George fought for is WW1, his war could have been the 1948 WW2, when 50 million americans were drafted ranging from 21 - 45 years of age, sending them to war, so he could have been born around the 1890s - 1900s, because his love stayed during 1920 being 100 years of love until 2020, but only half of it was during living and half was during as a ghost and he broke up with his lover and then went to war, if it was during WW1, it would mean that it was during the 1890s, which would not make sense with the timing, so his life limit is 1970 (as when he was dead he still loved her, until 2020, also i do not speculate George being Brenda's partner because still has some loose strands to that theory), so he was probably drafted to war at 1948, then the remainder of those years living, from 1890-1900s to 1970 (a.k.a his life limit according to the song) so that means he was around 70-80 at that age. I agree about Dave being born at that date (speculated birth of Dave: 1900s-1910) the same way because it was about 1920-28 with the golden years of animation. Now with Brenda, She was possibly born around 1910 as 1920 was where dancing was popular, in her case tap dancing, fitting to her age being around 10 when seeing her inspiration, she probably got into her career around 20-25, being 1945 her speculated death, leading to Brenda's daughter being around 10-12 during her death, so Brenda's daughter is possibly born in the middle of her career and was born around 1930-35, so when she met Dave, she was around 20-25 around 1955-60 and Dave being around 30-40, so if she did have a kid, and meeting George can fit as she is around 30-35 (During 1970) when he met george having a heart attack.
But if George did fight for WW1, the uniform would make sense (thanks to regetjet XD45) for him, but if it was that war the whole timeline I speculated would be a whole different can of worms, but then again it is a theory, so it does have some holes, but it patches up neatly dont'ya say?
*Physical clues* (The T-shirt design also matches as it has the black and white stripes, and the appearance are similarly drawn, maybe not a coincidence)
*Also just a theory of mine, feel free to reply and share your overview*
I mean it is speculated that Branda is Georges girl from 100 years and he couldn't be with her because either the army or he didn't want to give up her dream or something and then his daughter saves him and tells him what happened to her and he dies peacefully
I believe that George ad Brenda are Mels great-great-great-grandparents and Dave is her great- grandparent.Bc in Help Me at 2:21 you see a Wubby the Wolf poster behind Mels grandpas(cinsidering he IS her grandpa)most likely because Dave is Mels grandpas father.Also in Help me at 2:24 you see a hummingbird and a stuffed rabbit,and who are ghosts with the characteristics of a hummingbird and rabbit?George and Brenda,which brings me to my next conclusion that Brenda and George are married.
In 100 Years at the start you see a woman wearing a hat,the same hat in Still Dancing at 0:53 on the floor.Then at 1:02 we see a letter in a chair which may be the same letter in 100 years at 0:55(we can't see what it says).You then see at 1:13 you see a hummingbird which atleast to me symbolizes George.
I believe that George ad Brenda are Mels great-great-grandparents and Dave is her great- grandparent.Bc in Help Me at 2:21 you see a Wubby the Wolf poster behind Mels grandpas(cinsidering he IS her grandpa)most likely because Dave is Mels grandpas father.Also in Help me at 2:24 you see a hummingbird and a stuffed rabbit,and who are ghosts with the characteristics of a hummingbird and rabbit?George and Brenda,which brings me to my next conclusion that Brenda and George are married.
In 100 Years at the start you see a woman wearing a hat,the same hat in Still Dancing at 0:53 on the floor.Then at 1:02 we see a letter in a chair which may be the same letter in 100 years at 0:55(we can't see what it says).You then see at 1:13 you see a hummingbird which atleast to me symbolizes George.
Next part is that G & B had a girl who grew up and we see her again in 100 years at 2:10 and I do believe that child is Mels grandfather.And child is Daves child and so Dave is Mels grandfathers father.Now all we need is a final song to finish it off.
oop-
It sounds probable.
Boss Man: *tries ripping up Wubby*
Dave: *So you have chosen, death.*
@꧁ YJDP JOHN ꧂ Dave: ‘walks ahead and pulls out his pen *menacingly* ‘
“Omae wa mou shinderu!”
@@its_secret5375 dave: i invoke my stan! WUBBY
@@meeptowner8440 NANI DESKA
@@meeptowner8440 Dave: I summon Wubby in attack mode
Everyone else: *makes theories on the girl being Brenda's daughter*
Me: Dave is left-handed
Omfg yeah lmao
I am too
lol
I’m also left handed so?
Your comment has 69 likes
George: Never stop loving
Brenda: Dont give up
Dave: Dont listen to those who put you down
Ghost Life Lessons
Ghost afterlife lessons
well my life lesson is never fart in front of your girlfriend on your first date
it was wet i think a little shit came out as well
Lol
True
So we got a guitarist, dancer, animator and a kid that is getting bullied in school(?) however they are all singers, what a unique group
I feel like they could be a great band for some reason lol
A soldier, a dancer, an animator, and a kid walk into a bar...
The kid actually wants to be a musician if im not mistaken
And three fourths of them are dead
@@familyfriendlypgclean1487 ;-;
Unlike the other two stories with the three ghosts, Dave's death wasn't shown. That's nice. He probably died peacefully of old age.
Notice how we ever see him actually alive again after the guns fire. It’s symbolic. It’s implying he was assassinated. So yeah, they did show his death, just not directly.
@@scrapywrappy6758 Oh no...
I figured the fat man got him some way
@@generalkuros56 well let's hope what Scrapy said was just a theory, it would be horrible if Dave's boss got to him... maybe Karma wasn't there for Dave when he needed it most :(
@@GellygirlButRUclips was that his boss what I got from it was he pitched his idea the fat man said no so he went and maid it anyway and when it become a huge the fat man got mad and ether killed him or had him killed but I still say karma was on his side cuase the murder whoud be linked back to him plus think about it the show whoud probably get even bigger if he died cause more people whoud talk about it so ether way the fat man messed up
*Help Me*
After *100 Years*
I'm *Still Dancing*
This must be *Karma*
Omygod you're right
AFTONS FATE
Clever
POG
*That's rough buddy...*
better than Jojo's version
JAJAJA
AHAHAHA
Lol
OMG THAT'S WHAT I THOUGHT 😂
Well spotted.
My dad is 72 years old and I showed him this video asking him to guess what year this was made and he said "it's probably around the 70's or 80's". When I told him it was released last year he was shocked and amazed. This shows how good of a recreation of the 80s vibe it is
The animation style is rubber like, prolly from the 1930's
Nothing like this was being made in the 80's? This is distinctly 30' Fletcher studio animation.....
LAST YEAR!!!!!!!
It’s supposed to be the 20s lmao
@@memegraveyard9502 his dad is 72 give him some slack
When those bullies ripped up his drawing my first thought was: “time to drop kick some overgrown fetuses”
it took me 30 seconds to understand this very cursed comment
Oof
Agreed
XD
WHEEZE
Fun fact: every song in this album has the word crazy except for “still dancing” nice. (just so people know what i mean: Help me: “crazy, i might be going crazy-,” 100 Years: “they call me crazy,-” Karma: “My joy will only drive you crazy!)
is that really a fun fact?
theory time
🍷
Actually I think it does say crazy in still dancing
@@rosie662 i dont think so, I checked it multiple times
Dave's lil dance he does when he's presenting Wubby to the rich guy is so cute and funny!
(This is my favorite Clover song by far, though all of them are amazing!)
The dislikes are from his boss’s alternative accounts
& the shooters right at the final chorus
I put a dislike
@@שלומיוינר bruh
I didnt like this song, it feels rusht, to repiting, not to catshy and unlike all the other songs in the series it has nothing to do w death
@@שלומיוינר dude.. You didn't need to dislike tho, ya could have just left without leaving a mark
Brenda: Dancing Ghost
George: Romantic Ghost
Dave: *K A R M A G H O S T*
Edit: *Holy moly i never-*
Fair enough
No, no, he has a point.
I mean yes but also yes
The scariest type
Oh my bakery It Right
This is dave
-Never gives up
-Super creative
-Very friendly
Be like Dave
@@Cherika119 never gonna let you down
@@lgkk5028 Never gonna run around and desert you
@@chadhamster4202 never gonna make you cry
@@lgkk5028 never gonna say goodbye
@@tsuky1354 never gonna tell a lie
Ghost lessons!
George: Cherish your memories and your loved ones, they’ll get you through the tough times.
Brenda: Put your mind to it, and you can achieve your dreams no matter what others say.
Dave: Who cares what they think? The ones who keep trying to put you down are a waste of your breath, focus on what you love and let karma give them their due.
Merry Christmas to all people who pass through here!☃️🎄
Merry Christmas 🎄🎄🎁
Merry Christmas :D
Merry Christmas
Merry Christmas to you too
Merry Christmas
My house: silent
My family: asleep
Me seeing this: * the LOUDEST yell at 2 a.m.
Same lol, I had to actually bite my tongue so I didnt burst out giggling
My mom was like: woha, what happened? What's wrong with you?
Santa Claus probably got scared.
@@yourlocalpuertoricanidiot8972 yeah he must of
Same
George: composed the music for the videos
Brenda: does the Choreography for the videos
Dave: draws the animation for the videos
I think George would write the lyrics and Kel would compose the music instead.
@@charlesdacat that’s a good idea, I was just thinking George would do it because he is shown playing a guitar so he know how to play instruments
Kel: edit the videos
@@spoiled_birthday_cake 😆
plot twist it's all real and she has 3 ghosts helping her make music
I think this Song really teaches you about not giving up, but also not to take revenge, because the people who wronged you will be wronged, and to forgive. This is nice.
Just realized each character is one of the leaves on a 4 leaf clove
Kel: luck
George: love
Brenda: hope
Dave: faith
Holy crap I did not notice that!
You just realised that?
Yes
Or30 's channel banner says "clover faith, hope and luck".
I think it'd be more faith on kel and luck on dave, since we see his story now he was really lucky on the succes and his character.
I like the “oooooooooooooooooooooo”s going across the screen
Same! I thought it was so cool.
it's ironic, this song is not as animated as the others, but it is not a tragedy
Yea which is ironic since hes an animatior
I love how he didn't give up and how fame never got to his head
Be like dave
It’s sad how most RUclipsrs are doing the opposite (example like lankeybox or any crappy RUclips Short Videos).
He protect
He attack
Most importantly karma got his back
and now
And now
And now
no
And now
George: my gf left me but I'm still grooving.
Dave: the company didnt want my cartoon ideas but I'm still grooving.
Brenda: I have a very dangerous disease that is slowly killing me... But I'm still grooving.
Wowee
Everyone's grooving until they find out Kel is near to dying due to depression
@@SingularPhasmid w h y
@@misterglass8298 thank you for assuring me it's a good thing
Oof.
George: Love
Brenda: Dancing
Dave: *PAPER*
Nah nah. KARMA
@@blankdessert Yes
Its not letting other people stop you
BAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAH
According to Irish tradition, those who find a four-leaf clover are destined for good luck, as each leaf in the clover symbolizes good omens for faith, hope, love, and luck
Kel: hope
George: love
Brenda: faith
Dave: karma (luck?)
As someone who was both bullied as a child consistently and is about to publish a book (Itll be done being edited by me eventually!) I can't express how much I needed this song in my life. Thanks for making it impactful and just an absolute banger.
people: dislike
Literally everyone: *watch out, karma's what you make*
30 people disliked in 2 hours.
HOW?!?!
Me to the 63 people that disliked: listen here you little...
@@shroomish778 had some dislikes hours before the premiere even started
@@shroomish778 bots
@@joaogarcia1685 bots indeed
remove the t and replace it with y
Imagine this: clover made by the ghosts
Animation: Dave
Music and choreography: Brenda
Lyrics: George
Publishing: Kel
YYOOOOOOO THAT'S SO FUCKING AWESOME
This need more likes
That would be flipping amazing
Omg yas
Thinking outside the box. I love it.
George's Lesson: Keep people in your heart even after they're gone.
Brenda's Lesson: Think optimistically and don't let anything stand in your path.
Dave's Lesson: *E a t T h e R i c h .*
i like Dave
@@freshbread4039 you should see the French revolution then!
@@kalidos7681 i like the French Revolution
I just ate dinner.
Why am I hungry again-
Dave sounds like a Robin Hood of good cartoons but he is only stealing fans passively
My parents don’t really like the idea of me becoming an artist when I’m older, but this song keeps me hopeful, and I know I’ll make it!!
Hell yeah! I believe in you and your dream! ❤
@@Lie_Nalthank you! ❤ it’s been getting to the point where I’ve considered running away more and more
That karma wolf was one hell of a comfort character to Dave. He kept him all the way from childhood to his death.
That is something amazing with art, you can find a character that will comfort you from childhood, to death
People who spam posts on Reddit be like: "Karma is what you make"
Haha, noice
Lol true
Lol
I smell a meme template
Uh oh
Headcanon: Wubby’s show is what put Bendy the Dancing Demon out of business 👀
Nah bendy watched his animations and was like " (deep inhale) why cant I be friends with this guy and why couldnt i have been animated by this very clearly sane animator"
YES we finally know the answer
Joey's Karma
Nice
Boris: You
Wubby: The guy she tells you not to worry about
"Ahh, it feels so good to sing out after silence
I’ve had enough and you can’t keep me quiet"
I fell this much.
I think that it’s sad to believe, but in the final scene, I think that it’s a metaphor for Dave getting shot by the rich guy, as shown by the hunters shooting and then him as a ghost, but the rich guy drowning in papers means that he was caught for killing Dave and got what he deserved.
i saw somewhere else but the theater scene reminded them of lincolns assassination, maybe thats what happened
@@LocseryuOfficial Yeah, I thought he was going to get shot there when I watched it first.
@@acevajcner9719 lol
Karma
Wow
The rich man: I’m about to end this mans whole career
Dave: *uno reverse* I’m about to end this whole mans career
The rich man: NOOOOO hes too strong
Wubby: YAY Dave is the Best !
Love the username. Very nice.
who called?
Sorry I ruined the perfect 400
George: *sad love story*
Brenda: *sad story about almost giving up on her dreams*
Dave: *you guys are so cliché*
Them: 👁👄👁
no it's more like
@@bxeproductons4427 what?
@@SeRo0o0o thay no have eyes or mouths
@@bxeproductons4427 Oh I get it now lol.
( )
Or3o saved my life i was thinking on offing myself by putting a bag over my head (i was depressed at the time ) while i was scrolling thought YT late at night and then i found 100 years and it made me think of my love life and legit made me cry myself out of it. so all i can say is thanks
OR3O: **Uploads Dave's music video/story**
Theorists: *"Oh yeah, its all coming together.."*
Others: *"After years, finally I have them all.."*
♡◇♤♧
tru, tru.
@@yourlocaltraumademon Nice
"I drew my way out of the dark"
*Are you sure about that, colorless man.*
Lmbo
"LMBO"
Ahem EMKAY! R/IHADASTROKE!
Good point
Lmao
Lmao
alternate title: deranged animator kills 4 men with nothing but a pen and a hand-drawn wolf
but seriously, these songs are wonderful and i hope you never stop producing.
oh my god that makes so much sense, imma add onto it, a deranged man with a pen who's obessed with karma
BREAKING NEWS: A MAN HAS FALLEN INTO THE RIVER IN LEGO CITY!!
@@patchesthejaybird8431 HEY!
Unfortunately this series is over, this is the last song in Clover. (At least I think so)
True
Idk why but Dave looks very huggable to me. A great song as always!
All of the ghosts are the little girl's ancestors. Brenda and George had a daughter who we see as an adult in 100 Years, and as a child in Still Dancing. The woman we see with Dave in this is the same girl. I think Dave might be Kel's grandfather.
He could be the old man who dies in Help Me.
@@dakotathompson3384 I think that was Kel's grandfather so you're probably right.
Woah
im speechless after reading the replies
@@dakotathompson3384 Hum I think dane is a great grandfather because, brenda and george had a daughter who marry with dave, but in 100 years there is a boy with brown hair with george daughter, but this boy is not the father of kel (because her father has black hair) i think this boy is the old man who died in Help me
As someone who really wants to become an animator, this song really hit right in the feels. I never really have the most faith in my drawings sometimes, sometimes even thinking they'll never get anywhere apart from the bin. But its songs like this that make me realize: I can do it. I can be an animator. I do have faith in my drawings. Oh, and the fact the song is such a bop too helps as well. :)
Keep at it, people out there enjoy all kinds of stuff. There is bound to be an audience for whatever your making👍
@@backgroundcharacter3153 Thanks bud. That really means a lot, honest to god it does. And you know what? You're right. Somewhere out there is an audience that wants to see my stuff. And if their out there, then I'm going to make them glad they decided to stick around in the first place!
@@rileya6438 I love your optimism! I'm glad this song helped you so much; Just Dancing particularly helped me
Dude I'm having the same problem. I'm believing in my self as well
@@whitefang2312 Thanks! I'm glad still dancing helped you out too! I'll be honest all of these songs are tear jerkers, but karma really hit right in the sweet spot!
Nobody:
Dave:
say sike right now
You must be a kid trying to use the nobody: format and it doesn’t work here, it’s a punchline without a setup so it doesn’t make any sense
The real knowledge of sans has been spoken
the sans and the agender have spoken ( go lgbtq+ btw im an ally ❤️)
Dave:
I’m about to end this boss's whole career.
I have the "Watch out! Karma's what you make!" stuck in my head
The girl Dave married is the same girl that helped George when he had a heart attack under that tree
didn't ask but thank for the information :D
@@ravenghost-kh9gy At first glance your comment seems rude
IT ALL CONNECTS
Underrated useful comment
@@jackanderson313 no im not rude im just joking
Okay so theorie:
Brendas daughter is the girl that fist helped and married Dave. Later on a picnic with their son she saves the life of George who was having a heart attack in a park. He later dies in the hospital tho. Also idk why but her and Daves kid kinda has the same head shape as kels grandfather, leading me to believe that the kid in fact later becomes Kels grandfather, making dave her great grandfather.
This means Brenda is the „oldest“ ghost, followed by George, later Dave, and at last Kels Grandfather
Edit: Coming to think of it, Brenda does look a lot like the women in georges song, plus they were dancing together. If She and George actually were married, then Georges song isn’t about being left despite still loving a person, but about dealing with the death of his deceased wife Brenda
OMG HOW LONG DID IT TOOK TO FIND THAT OUT I WOULD HAVE NEVER FIGURED THAT OUT!!!YOU ARE A GENIUS!!!!
Edit:YOU DESERVE 100K+ LIKES!!!!
Time stamp for Dave’s son cuz I can’t find the son
It would make sense that brenda's the oldest since there wouldn't be a cure or medication for a disease like that back then
@@Justme_1213 its in Georges song 100 years at the end where he haves a heart attack
Most people assume that the daughter is Brenda and georges daughter
Nobody:
OR3O:
*Posts video about animating*
Me:
*Am I the only one who finds it cool that it's an animation about an animation?*
you could have just said that last line but you just had to try to turn it into a meme
@@levimckenna8344 you could have not said anything at all if you didn't like it
@@MarigoldtheFox y'all could both not fight and end up tainting a good joke...
@@totallynottitan126 okay you right. Sorry
I was finding this comment lol
Another one of the songs on my playlist in NIGHT MODE for motivation and nostalgia.
People in his city: "WoW yOuR sTyLe It'S sO rEaLiStIc"
Lol
Lol
Lol
Lol
No one:
Litterly no one:
The replies of this comment: lOoOl
George:Love
Brenda:Dancing
Dave:ART AND KARMA
1st reply
We're no strangers to love
You know the rules and so do I
A full commitment's what I'm thinking of
You wouldn't get this from any other guy
I just wanna tell you how I'm feeling
Gotta make you understand
Never gonna give you up
Never gonna let you down
Never gonna run around and desert you
Never gonna make you cry
Never gonna say goodbye
Never gonna tell a lie and hurt you
We've known each other for so long
Your heart's been aching but you're too shy to say it
Inside we both know what's been going on
We know the game and we're gonna play it
And if you ask me how I'm feeling
Don't tell me you're too blind to see
Never gonna give you up
Never gonna let you down
Never gonna run around and desert you
Never gonna make you cry
Never gonna say goodbye
Never gonna tell a lie and hurt you
Never gonna give you up
Never gonna let you down
Never gonna run around and desert you
Never gonna make you cry
Never gonna say goodbye
Never gonna tell a lie and hurt you
(Ooh, give you up)
(Ooh, give you up)
(Ooh) Never gonna give, never gonna give
(Give you up)
(Ooh) Never gonna give, never gonna give
(Give you up)
We've known each other for so long
Your heart's been aching but you're too shy to say it
Inside we both know what's been going on
We know the game and we're gonna play it
I just wanna tell you how I'm feeling
Gotta make you understand
Never gonna give you up
Never gonna let you down
Never gonna run around and desert you
Never gonna make you cry
Never gonna say goodbye
Never gonna tell a lie and hurt you
Never gonna give you up
Never gonna let you down
Never gonna run around and desert you
Never gonna make you cry
Never gonna say goodbye
Never gonna tell a lie and hurt you
Never gonna give you up
Never gonna let you down
Never gonna run around and desert you
Never gonna make you cry
Never gonna say goodbye
Never gonna tell a lie and hurt...
get rickroled m8
@@scotto210 god dammit
@@scotto210 did it take you a year to type that
Kei: Sadness.
@@scotto210 COme On
I first thought he sounds like Caleb.He is voiced by Caleb.
Caleb?
Ohhhhh, the guy who voiced him, now I see the name
Also, I loved the metaphor for the lawsuit, when I first saw it, I thought it simply magic, but now, I know that it could mean that the Evil Buisnessman was going to steal Wubby, so he sewed him, with piles of papers, coming from a pen.
3:11 I love how Dave looks in this scene, it's just like: "Wow that worked?"
"It's not like i'm in a cartoon... right? Oh forget it, Wubby is real and there are two ghosts and a girl in front of me"
I laughed at this harder than I should’ve
[this comment got deleted]
Where’d you get that from we never see his death
@@Meowie171 given he was at the weird thing at the theater before going into the light of the projector…
Think of Abraham Lincoln
Going over what i believe to be Karma's plot: Dave, as a young child, already knew what he wanted to be, an animator. he already had a character in mind, but bullies attempted to discourage him of his dreams. Instead, he powered through and got a job at a large animation business. His first pitch would be Wubby's show, which was rejected, and cost Dave his job there. When he left, a woman saw one of his drawings of Wubby and decided he'd be someone to invest in, allowing Dave to start his own company. The product was a smash hit, leading to Dave getting a movie premiere. While he was at the theatre, however, the owner of the company from before hired a hitman. The hitman was successful initially, but was found out and it was revealed that the company owner had hired him, essentially blowing back in his face. The company quickly went bankrupt, taking the owner down with it.
And that's Karma folks!
KARMA AF
Omg that is an amazing Theory
Watch out, Karma's what you make.
@@sharonxiaoyunhou2615 what*
Gonna be honest- was genuinely scared this was gonna lead up to Dave’s cause of death being his boss killing him out of jealousy-
That is the same thing I thought
MY GODS I TOUGH I WAS ALONE.
It might have been, it's unclear
So he died of old age? Or what
@@Substant I’m guessing old age, considering in the animation we see him “defeating” his old boss. I’m seriously praying it was that and NOT murder
This song really helped me. I was at a summer camp and some guys in my cabin made fun of my art and instead of get back at them for it I just told myself “Revenge only delays and my times not worth the waste. Cause karma’s gonna help me anyways, watch out, karma’s what you make.” Thank you, it really helped me.
The people who are waiting for this know what true dedication is
Thanks 😎
Thx
Thx
yes
Lmao I’ve been around since 100 years
Walt Disney: I am the best animator. Dave: hold my rejected childhood drawings
Edit: MOM I’M FAMOUS
Brilliant
*claps*
Yes
Magnificent
The girl made him famous
The reason we don’t see Dave’s cause of death is because George is about the past, Brenda’s about the present, and Dave’s focus is only on the future
My theory is probably he got assassinated
hey its kinda like charles dickens
Wait hold on!
What if Dave never died by the end of the video.
I know it sounds crazy but hear me out. At the end of the video you don't see Dave as an actual ghost, but a drawing of him as a ghost. Since you don't see him ever actually die, he still could be alive and with Kel. As for how she gets the lessons, it's because Dave is there to help her, with Brenda and George's daughter by his side with her knowledge about there experience in life. That's why he can also draw the other two as their ghosts as well as his to fit in. Plus, you don't see a bird in his video like all the other ones had. I know there are probably holes in my theory, but that's what I think is happening. Tell me what you think so I can try to figure it out. Thanks!
@@someperson9613 But don’t we see his ghost in “Help me?”
@@afacelessidiot946 That's where the holes are in my theory, but thanks for bringing it up... I don't know. I was just going off of this video and the differences it had with Brenda and George in regards to how they are seen dead.
“Karma’s what you make” This song’s unironically got some of the best words to live by. “Don’t bother trying to get back on those guys, life’ll do it for you.”
Kel: The problem
George: The talk about facing the past
Brenda: The talk about how to face the present
Dave: The talk about looking to the future
Sooo they are time travels then?
oohh thats intresting
wrong, dave is “ no u “
It's the Ghosts of Christmas Past!
Wow, you opened my eyes in a metiforacle way
THEORY TIME
ya know the theory that the t-shirt girl was brenda's daughter
this might have been disproven bc her hair is different but assuming it isnt a diferent person this might be them giveing us a sense of timeline, aka saying that brenda died 1st then george then dave
the girl also indicates that about the time george died she knew dave and this wouldent happen if she wasnt a recurring character
the only reason im making this theory is bc she comes up in every song
so to recap
shirt girl is brenda's child and is an adult by george's video when he dies, but is in some sort of relationship with dave (as friends or otherwise is unclear) while he is in his 30s-40s
or maybe is is young brenda?
@@imprettycoolifyouknowme i doubt it
Btw there is a clover wiki in the description with all your answers (also on the wiki Brenda’s daughter is Dave’s mom)
And probably the girl was an ancestor of clover.
They seem to gone through alot and they wanted to do something for clover thanks to the girl that helped them back then.
Clover was insecure and wasn't supported of her interest on music so the ghost's probably wanted to help her since her probably ancestor helped them back then.
Brenda died first when the girl was a child. Grew up, met george in the park as he got a heart attack and saying not to give up on love. And met Dave and helped him bring his dream to life. The 3 probably weren't able to repay her so they decided to help her ancestor clover instead :D
Just a theory tho but it seem to fit right in to me
@@patboi7384 her name is Kel-
if that helps
I love this little story. A woman who loved dancing but was paralyzed, a man who still loved a woman after 100 years, and another man, who never gave up on his animation and made it bug. and all of them after death come together to help this little girl who's grieving and having many problems.
I thought Kel was a guy!
☺️
You pls be nice
@@whitepolarbear7182 sure
@@astropan2765 same
Theory; 1:28 Has anyone ever noticed that this one woman persists through all of these ghosts stories? Somewhat linking them of some sorts. She appears in George’s story to help him to the hospital, and she’s here in Dave’s story. Now you may think; “she didn’t appear in Brenda’s story!” Now this may seem like a stretch, but what if she was the girl giving Brenda advice on how to “keep dancing anyway”? Just some food for thought.
Edit: ok she’s definitely the same person in every video. And I’m pretty sure she’s the mother/grandma in the living on video too.
I know this story is fictional, but it's pretty much exactly like the story of Alan Becker. He's one of the best animators I've ever seen, but he was taken advantage of in the past and also was turned down by Pixar. Now, he's super famous and an insanely great animator. This story reminds me of that :)
If he got a job at Pixar he might not have been as famous now and AvA, AvA Shorts and AvM wouldn't have happened
And also Disney himself
Guys. They didn't show us how Dave Died because they didn't want to find us crying
O H N O
maybe he died of old age like George?
I think that final scene was something like his imagination,he might got shoot dead
he didn't die hes immortal
I actually think we DID see him die, just not in this video.
Theory: Brenda, george and Dave are the representation of entertainment
George is singing, he lived a healthy life, and talking bout music in general music was never forgotten
Brenda is dancing, at the first few years she lived normally but became ill, dancing was quite popular when Brenda was a kid, then when she became an adult dancing slowly.dies and faded away, so Brenda also slowly dies,
Then Dave at first is harrased since animation still hasn't took of yet and Dave still had a hard time since many people see animations as childish then more people appriciated it
So basically what I'm saying is that if they're genre of entertainment is dying or forgotten they also die, ik stupid theory but it's the best I can come up with
Now this is coming from someone who hasn't watched the other vids yet, so I don't actually know shit, but your theory sounds really good based on what you point out about the characters, i.e. you've supported your claim well.
You get a Well Done from this random stranger.
Also, with your theory in mind, I can't help but wonder what else we might see that could fit into it.
Nah, it isn’t stupid.
Honestly this theory makes alot of sense but I think it more applies to the styles not the medium and that it never really dies even if it falls out of fashion
They live on as ghosts able to pass their knowledge on
The new generation's style may be different but they same spark lives on
Which makes sense for the style of these songs and their music videos
An older style of music remade with a different flare while still taking the blueprint from old masters of their craft
The same applies to the animation having the spirit of the old style but with new flare and technique for the modern era
And the experience from what held them back can help guide the new generation
Dave faces ridicule from others being shunned for his art but in the end over comes his tormentors by instead of resenting them being determined to be better than them by not retaliating at them but focusing on his craft and proving them wrong not with his words but with his actions
Like a modern day artist being put down by parents or other authority for perusing a seemingly useless skill
But perusing their passions regardless to prove them wrong
Then later supporting other struggling artists going through the same
And connecting with others they wouldve never met without their "useless hobby"
George was never recognized for his work he tried endlessly to get the recognition he was looking for and while he never found it he never let himself be put down and continued to pursue his passion till the very end
Like modern day musicians who while talented is overshadowed by others who made it into the public eye first
Always working to get the credit for the work they do and reach their fullest potential
and seeing that even if you arent the star of the world's stage
You run your own show
Brenda while being unable to completely overcome her obstacle she learns to do great things even with these ever present issues
Like someone struggling with mental illnesses that cant just be gotten rid of
And while we may struggle and we may suffer and have our bad days
You learn to live on even with these things being ever present
And in the end live an even better life than anyone could believe
(I dont know enough about the culture surrounding dance as an art form to equate this to a modern day struggle of dance but if someone does have something that fits here I would love to hear it)
That's a good theroy
@@cmdAHYT well I guess kel could represent us.. the stereotypical new gen... We rely on these forms of entertainment to keep us from crumbling apart.. that's why the three ghosts of entertainment helps kel instead of KELling her... I'm cringe lpl
They did a great job, I really like this type of music, the composition, the animation, everything was well done, please keep making music like this