"Ah! Sì, ben mio...Di quella pira" - AURELIANO PERTILE (1930)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 5 янв 2025

Комментарии • 194

  • @marcosani1400
    @marcosani1400 Год назад +8

    Pertile, una cometa del mondo lirico, inestinguibile guida luminosa del bel canto, che mai morrà nei nostri cuori. Grazie

  • @sergioghittoni4928
    @sergioghittoni4928 2 года назад +27

    Mio padre, grande fan dell'opera e loggionista alla Scala, lo considerava il miglior tenore del suo tempo. Passava le giornate sotto le finestre del suo albergo per ascoltarlo provare i suoi pezzi.

  • @bodiloto
    @bodiloto 6 лет назад +42

    un Artista Meraviglioso .

  • @1947Rollo
    @1947Rollo 10 лет назад +59

    Eh si,questo è proprio l'olimpo del canto e dell'interpretazione.

    • @andreamoriondo576
      @andreamoriondo576 3 года назад +1

      Vero!!😘😍

    • @mantralibre1367
      @mantralibre1367 3 года назад +4

      L'unico vocabolo che mi viene allá mente per de scrivere Pertile e' sublime. Stentoreo, una voce che spalanca le tombe. Che meraviglia!

  • @francescariccelli6841
    @francescariccelli6841 3 года назад +24

    Il tenore di Toscanini, preferito da Kraus e Domingo, è la dimostrazione a quali livelli possa giungere una voce nata non bella, ma divenuta quasi perfetta per lo studio, l'umiltà e la padronanza dello spartito. Studiato ancor oggi in Russia ( ed ovunque vi sia cultura operistica e buon senso ); la sua mezzavoce autentica, conquista di pochissimi tenori, è un memento forte di cosa si possa ottenere. Splendito il suo Otello! Peccato che per i più giovani il suo nome non dica niente...ottima immagine di una società ipoculturale...

    • @amedeofolco9988
      @amedeofolco9988 2 года назад +2

      Signora Riccelli,io ho 32 anni,sono tenore e ascolto Pertile da quando ho 7/8 anni. Quest'incisione nello specifico è la primissima cosa che ho ascoltato del Trovatore nella mia vita

    • @alberto7694
      @alberto7694 2 года назад +1

      Guardi io ho studiato in un conservatorio non sapevo nemmeno l'esistenza di questo tenore,grazie ad un melomane dell' opera ho scoperto tenori come lui ,ma di cosa stiamo parlando questo Paese é una vergogna ! Aveva ragione muti quando diceva che la cultura.musicale é scesa molto.

    • @valentinoproduction
      @valentinoproduction 2 года назад

      @@amedeofolco9988 v.pp

    • @rogerwalckiers292
      @rogerwalckiers292 2 года назад

      00

    • @rogerwalckiers292
      @rogerwalckiers292 2 года назад

      @@amedeofolco9988 9

  • @marcosani1400
    @marcosani1400 Год назад +7

    Pertile, una voce penetrante che sconvolge l'anima e e rimuove le oscurità nascoste dal tempo, per riportarne in luce i bagliori sopiti della lontananza. Grazie per aver postato questo miracolo musicale!

  • @vale86301
    @vale86301 6 лет назад +33

    Incredibile ,magnifico ,possente !!! Un tenore impressionante !!

  • @veneziola
    @veneziola Год назад +4

    No hay palabras ante una voz y un cantante tan grande, le caben todos los adjetivos del mundo. Uno de los mejores de la historia.

  • @theogoldberg8919
    @theogoldberg8919 2 месяца назад

    Grazie Roberto Alagna❤❤ per lasciarmi conoscere questa MASTER CLASS ASSOLUTA di voce !!!❤❤❤

  • @roideschats8799
    @roideschats8799 5 лет назад +19

    Aureliano Pertile, l'un des meilleurs ténors de tous les temps (la soprano et le baryton aussi sont bons !!)... quelle profondeur, quelle matière, quelle chair ! L'orchestre est super, et parfaitement dirigé, il ressent le "flux" et le "pulse" verdien... la vibrato de la voix est aussi au diapason de cette vibration verdienne... vraiment "le sang nous bat les veines" ... BRAVO !!!

  • @nicolacarrara7202
    @nicolacarrara7202 Год назад +1

    Pericle non sbagliava un colpo sempre perfetto inpeccabile

  • @juancarlosbelletti6335
    @juancarlosbelletti6335 Год назад +2

    Que Terorazo que debe de haber sido que voz entradora y sonora que debe de haber tenido. Estas grabaciones son muy viejas y sin embargo veo y escucho un vozzarron tremendo .que suerte que tuvieron aquellas personas que lo pudieron escuchar personalmente. MARAVILLOSO❤❤

  • @juriinov6378
    @juriinov6378 4 года назад +12

    Великий тенор А.Пертиле. Сколько души и страсти в его голосе! Мне кажется,что запись Трубадура с Пертиле и Гранфорте лучшая из всех

  • @道-p2e
    @道-p2e 4 года назад +9

    Ph.D of tenors, finest craftsmanship!

  • @georgesaliba9978
    @georgesaliba9978 4 года назад +12

    What a superb technique!

  • @cimbassovr
    @cimbassovr 3 года назад +4

    AURELIANO PERTILE ARTISTA FANTASTICO E STRAORDINARIO.
    UN MITO LEGGENDARIO!!!

  • @JoseMurillo-ki6yx
    @JoseMurillo-ki6yx 3 года назад +6

    Che tenore ! Che scuola ! Bravissimo!!!

  • @tonneinsbillardclub1308
    @tonneinsbillardclub1308 6 лет назад +20

    mama mia che voce!

  • @renatogiusti5664
    @renatogiusti5664 8 лет назад +18

    Aureliano Pertile grande Tenore Preferito da L'immenso Arturo toscanini E sempre Emozionante Ascoltarlo la sua. Chiara adizion e e perfezione della voce grazie buon 2017 Renato

    • @yp3424
      @yp3424 5 лет назад +2

      Il "sommo" Toscanini.

  • @alfonsodamore8400
    @alfonsodamore8400 9 лет назад +24

    este señor seguro está en la lista de los grandes

  • @ricardobedini5345
    @ricardobedini5345 4 года назад +7

    Aureliano !!!!FANTASTICO !!!!!!! D R A M A T I C O * * * * * !!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @familypondman
    @familypondman 2 года назад +2

    THE BEST TENOR EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @alragarp
    @alragarp 11 лет назад +19

    ÚNICO!!!!!

  • @shirleyrombough8173
    @shirleyrombough8173 5 лет назад +16

    I have never heard him. How wonderful. Maybe he was the best of the best. I am thrilled by his voice and am totally grateful to whoever posted these videos of this true maestro. Bravissimo for the perfection of this complete artist and thanks from the heart to you tube.

  • @armandonazarenocerutti9860
    @armandonazarenocerutti9860 3 года назад +8

    MARAVILLOSO COMO SIEMPRE !!! EN TODAS SUS INTERPRETACIONES. ME PERMITO DECIR QUE ES EL ÚNICO TENOR QUE JAMÁS DESAFINA, CAMBIA EL RITMO O REALIZA CALDERONES SIN FIN. UN GRAN ARTISTA/MÚSICO.

  • @miguelemiliovidal2150
    @miguelemiliovidal2150 2 года назад +2

    Este sí es un Trovador - Manrico -, magistral

  • @ricardobedini5345
    @ricardobedini5345 5 лет назад +7

    Extraordinario . . . Bellisimo * * * * *

  • @leonardopizzella7834
    @leonardopizzella7834 4 года назад +7

    Excelente Pertile!!!! Entre los 3 mejores Manrico junto a Corelli y Bjorling

  • @maratzulpuev8898
    @maratzulpuev8898 3 года назад +3

    Perfect

  • @santividal9387
    @santividal9387 2 года назад +2

    This recording is imo the GOAT

  • @jeanaborilova9717
    @jeanaborilova9717 4 года назад +4

    What a voice!!!

  • @pietrolera
    @pietrolera 7 лет назад +13

    Eccezionale.....orgoglio Padovano !

    • @francescopiotto9510
      @francescopiotto9510 6 лет назад

      anche vicentino, ha studiato a Vicenza :D e aveva anche la casa in zona stadio :D

    • @alejandrobertuola5901
      @alejandrobertuola5901 4 года назад +1

      @@francescopiotto9510 Vèneto insomma!!! Saluti da un argentino figlio di trevisani.

    • @alvisedoge4426
      @alvisedoge4426 3 года назад +1

      Di Montagnana dove è nato anche Giovanni Martinelli.

  • @germanquintero10121946
    @germanquintero10121946 3 года назад +3

    MAGNIFICOS

  • @Verist4
    @Verist4 3 года назад +2

    Unico! Inmenso! Sublime! Titan!

  • @Наталья-с6ю5й
    @Наталья-с6ю5й 5 месяцев назад

    Какой восторг! В такого страстного трубадура и я бы влюбилась! Наравне с франко Корелли это для меня настоящие герои. Благодарю от всей души. С уважением, Натали.

  • @nicoletadandu2166
    @nicoletadandu2166 2 года назад +3

    Voce e interpretazione! Meraviglioso!!!♥️♥️♥️

  • @shirleyrombough8173
    @shirleyrombough8173 5 лет назад +8

    All of the remarks about Pertile sound so much better in Italian. I can't contribute in Italian but I can read the language well enough to make out the meanings and to love to read them. Thanks to you all!

  • @Agorante
    @Agorante 6 лет назад +55

    I was sure wrong about Pertile. I had heard some of his recordings and thought he was Ok but not as good as his great reputation. I appreciate a singer by what I hear not by their press clippings. But this tremendous recording tells me - I was wrong. This kind of vocalism is rare and should be recognized. Pertile was great and now his greatness has been revealed to me.

    • @tarisiosfever350
      @tarisiosfever350 6 лет назад +6

      His the Master of transmitting the emotional intensity to the musical phrase as tension of the same...

    • @darklord220
      @darklord220 6 лет назад +3

      Amen. All it takes is an accurate recording. That goes for a lot of artists of this era.

    • @DionIsaiah
      @DionIsaiah 5 лет назад +4

      I was thinking the same thing, but I'm listening more to him when I heard a interview of Franco Corelli expressing his admiration for Pertile. Now I can hear so much how each sound identical. Pertile is the greatest tenor I've ever heard.

    • @alvarodecampostabacaria4223
      @alvarodecampostabacaria4223 5 лет назад +6

      His history speaks.. he was the king of La Scala in the 30s (in the 30s!!). .. he was Toscanini's tenor.. he was HUGE and you can see why!

    • @Tico4president
      @Tico4president 4 года назад +1

      Are there any good recordings of Caruso?

  • @pilouetmissiou
    @pilouetmissiou 3 года назад +2

    Bellissimo davvero....non conoscevo la voce se non di nome...

  • @ksopranotv2940
    @ksopranotv2940 4 года назад +4

    Grande !

  • @sgnmath1234
    @sgnmath1234 5 лет назад +8

    Fabulous recording.
    Better than others of this wonderful tenor.

  • @antoninolicata6425
    @antoninolicata6425 3 года назад +10

    Con tutto rispetto per quei 12 pollice giù, lasciatemi dire che non capite una minchia. Saluti

  • @harrybencosme5016
    @harrybencosme5016 6 лет назад +7

    Me gusta su modo de respirar, atacando frases al final, muy buen detalle particular.

    • @adammrva2569
      @adammrva2569 5 лет назад

      Skoda ze tato technika je iba na nahravkach...

  • @terrycloth6380
    @terrycloth6380 4 года назад +3

    Wow!! fabulous! Wow!!!

  • @essevikt
    @essevikt 5 лет назад +3

    O Artista straordinario!

  • @esterbruno8604
    @esterbruno8604 4 года назад +3

    Magnifico 🌟🌟🌟

  • @Wolts1983
    @Wolts1983 2 года назад +1

    La voce ideale per Manrico! Grande artista.

  • @livliv2958
    @livliv2958 3 года назад +1

    Wow, never heard of this awesome tenor before! Fantastic rendition!

  • @alekseiisaev9763
    @alekseiisaev9763 4 года назад +2

    Безупречно!!! Фантастика!!!

  • @IRA77GEOTENORE
    @IRA77GEOTENORE Год назад

    Intensity is not real, this is from the Superior World!❤️

  • @extrasalt4595
    @extrasalt4595 6 дней назад

    In my opinion, there is a parallel with Tito Gobbi. Neither possessed a conventionally beautiful voice, yet used it to great effect. Hoomeyow!!

  • @silvanogiusti813
    @silvanogiusti813 5 лет назад +13

    Ho 15 anni e adoro l’opera

    • @secretofsinging
      @secretofsinging 5 лет назад +4

      Bravo, piccolino !!!

    • @beniaminoson6318
      @beniaminoson6318 5 лет назад

      È verro?

    • @paolopizzirani7784
      @paolopizzirani7784 4 года назад +2

      Salute, è per l'anima tua! Bisogna nondimanco t'avvii all'udir i cantori serii, gli artisti autentici - tra i quali e gli scadenti v'è di modestini una pletora... E coll'assuefazione alla mediocritá l'orecchio può bentosto, specie se tróvicisi alle prim'esperienze d'ascolto, andar godendone, per giunger a non sapere più scevrar, a un certo punto, il grano dalla crusca. Per ciò un onesto, saputo e consigliato suggeritore in questi casi riescirebbe a te avvantaggioso quantomai.

    • @ritapapiri
      @ritapapiri 4 года назад +3

      Continua così. Sarai felice.

    • @esterbruno8604
      @esterbruno8604 4 года назад +4

      Bravo! 👏

  • @kraustexkraustex5390
    @kraustexkraustex5390 Год назад

    La mejor versión de la historia, la del gran Aureliano Pertile en 1930

  • @italopera6036
    @italopera6036 4 года назад

    A very smart and clever, and also instructed artist. Better than those of 50 years later. Thanks to Martnuzzi, really !

  • @lospazio
    @lospazio 4 года назад +4

    It seems that human beings were different back in those days. No present day male Earthlings can sing this way.

  • @juanjoperabilbo
    @juanjoperabilbo 5 лет назад +2

    Es curioso que Pertile no aparezca en las listas preferentes de muchos criticos.
    Sin embargo deberia estar siempre entre los cinco mejores de la historia de la opera

    • @carlocolombo5799
      @carlocolombo5799 5 лет назад +1

      Talvez porque el timbre de su voz era algo aspero. Pero Callas tambien tenia un timbre de voz non tanto suave...

    • @flavioeduardobatista438
      @flavioeduardobatista438 4 года назад

      O mesmo com relação a Carlo Bergonzi

  • @pippofan
    @pippofan Год назад

    Very nice. The tempo seems a bit slow.

  • @pedroalonsoruiz7907
    @pedroalonsoruiz7907 6 лет назад +6

    El favorito de Kraus

    • @lydiaguarro
      @lydiaguarro 5 лет назад +2

      y de muchos otros, como el gran Toscanini.

    • @jimdrake-writer
      @jimdrake-writer 4 месяца назад

      In a conversation I had with Alfredo Kraus, he told me that the two tenors from whom he learned the most were Pertile for phrasing and interpretation, and Lauri-Volpi for teaching him proper breathing to enable him to sing long phrases.

  • @antoniomarrone8978
    @antoniomarrone8978 4 года назад +3

    O TENOR!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @andreaprandi4711
    @andreaprandi4711 5 лет назад +9

    Erano seduti in 4 e giocavano a briscola. B.Gigli, E.Caruso,T.Schipa,A.Pertile. E tutti avevano l' Asso di briscola. Non si sa chi ha vinto. Oggi vince il baritono Placido Domingo. Amen

    • @albertospadaro4743
      @albertospadaro4743 4 года назад +1

      Io sul tavolo metto schipa pertile corelli e di Stefano

    • @andreaprandi9960
      @andreaprandi9960 4 года назад +1

      Sono giusti affari tuoi e del tuo sentire

    • @eugeniogentili1048
      @eugeniogentili1048 4 года назад +1

      Domingo è finito da un pezzo, ha quasi 80 anni.

    • @eugeniogentili1048
      @eugeniogentili1048 4 года назад +5

      Comunque i più grandi Manrico nella storia sono stati Corelli del Monaco Pertile Bonisolli Tucker Nikolov Merli Filippeschi Atlantov Giacomini Vichers ecc.

    • @anonymousdude1010
      @anonymousdude1010 4 года назад +3

      Eugenio Gentili: Non hai messo il Manrico con la M maiuscola. Ogni grande cantante aveva quel ruolo che alla fine non interpretava ma impersonava (come Mario Del Monaco Otello, Tito Gobbi Scarpia, Nazzareno De Angelis Mefistofele, etc.). Dipendeva anche dalla presenza scenica e dal temperamento, senza nulla togliere agli altri grandissimi interpreti dello stesso ruolo e agli altri ruoli interpretati dallo stesso artista.
      Manrico era un giovinetto di 16 anni, tutto fuoco e passione, uno spirito nobilissimo di apparenti umilissime origini. Negli anni la tradizione ha ingemmato la parte di Manrico di puntature spettacolari che quando non si eseguono torniamo a casa da teatro un po' così.
      Tutto questo lungo preambolo per non dimenticare il Manrico per antonomasia: Giacomo Lauri-Volpi.

  • @игорьбабий-о5ю
    @игорьбабий-о5ю 5 лет назад +6

    красмый не красивый тембр поет величай ший из теноров все хоть кто то имел уши сердце душу мозги учинилисьименно у него величай шего мне повторимого единсственного богом хранимого настоящими любимого

  • @giovannievangelista6218
    @giovannievangelista6218 4 года назад +13

    "Aureliano Pertile è il più grande tenore di tutti i tempi". (Alfredo Kraus)

    • @arepo
      @arepo 3 года назад +1

      Kraus never said such a thing. RUclips is full of niceties one singer allegedly said about another, never ever backed up by any evidence. For shame. Don't put your lie in Kraus mouth.

    • @alvisedoge4426
      @alvisedoge4426 3 года назад +2

      Si lo ha detto in una intervista alla TV spagnola ed io ho la registrazione di quella intervista.

    • @arepo
      @arepo 3 года назад

      @@alvisedoge4426 Why not link to the interview? I would be sorry to believe Kraus as stupid as most fans trolling RUclips with nothing better to do than proclaim their favorite the "greatest ever", but if you say he sank so low, link to the interview.

    • @alvisedoge4426
      @alvisedoge4426 3 года назад +1

      The interview is present in you tube. It last not less than 1 hour and is in espagnol.

    • @alvisedoge4426
      @alvisedoge4426 3 года назад +1

      Entrevista a Alfredo Kraus del 1994

  • @juanjoperabilbo
    @juanjoperabilbo 5 лет назад +2

    si Pedro. kraus siempre lo mencionaba como la referencia de mas calidad

  • @alfredalfred3571
    @alfredalfred3571 2 года назад +1

    only Corelli is close to that whit the electricity in the voice !!!

  • @Бриндулэн
    @Бриндулэн 4 года назад +1

    Пертиле-бог!!!

  • @pedroalonsoruiz7907
    @pedroalonsoruiz7907 6 лет назад +6

    Técnica toda.

  • @silvanogiusti813
    @silvanogiusti813 5 лет назад

    😯😯😯😯

  • @bernatriera5437
    @bernatriera5437 5 лет назад

    Debe ser la grabación pero el agudo final es un Si

    • @enriquesayagues1843
      @enriquesayagues1843 Год назад

      Es lo que está en la partitura de Verdi. El usual do no es de Verdi. Es un agregado.

  • @fredycastropinzon7342
    @fredycastropinzon7342 5 лет назад +7

    A la altura de Mario del Mónaco y franco Corelli

  • @alfredbernasek7485
    @alfredbernasek7485 4 года назад +3

    OHNE ZWEIFEL EINER DER BESTEN

  • @ottimi8jp
    @ottimi8jp 7 лет назад +2

    さすが!

  • @pedroaranguren6160
    @pedroaranguren6160 3 года назад +1

    Me encantó, tremenda técnica....pero mi debilidad con el Manrico de Bonisolli es más fuerte.....Bonisolli era tan poderoso, heróico y carismático haciendo a Manrico que parecía que iba a saltar del escenario con su espada...

  • @gemmadestate3216
    @gemmadestate3216 6 лет назад +5

    Verdi gli é più congeniale di altri autori più moderni.

    • @Ilvermibaleno
      @Ilvermibaleno 6 лет назад +2

      Gemma D'estate Senta come canta il verismo di Giordano o Cilea ma anche lo stesso Puccini. Pertile è un faro per qualsiasi cantante. Maestro di stile, tecnica, passione e intelligenza vocale e interpretativa. Saluti.

    • @Nangis123
      @Nangis123 4 года назад +1

      Pertile was a verismo tenor ,this was his live repertory .It was the verismo era and going against the fashions of his day was more than he was prepared to do ,assuming he was aware his verismo style was wrong in Verdi ,or cared. Falling on the hands of Toscanini who was all pro-verismo didn't help matters . He premiered one or two Mascagni too,and Mascagni wanted "my singers to shout ,shout,shout" Well, Pertile certainly obliged him ,more the pity because his first recordings show he could sing without shouting . People are mislead as to his repertory .His bread-and-butter repertory was NOT Verdi ,it was a mixture of Giordano ,Cilea ,Zandonai ,Mascagni ,all the minor verismo composers of his time plus a bit of Puccini . Fedora ,Andrea Chenier ,Francesca da Rimini , Adriana Lecouvreur ,this was Pertile's rep ,not the occasional Aida and the even less than occasional Trovatore ,what a weird idea .Trovatore is still belcanto . In all his seasons in Rome Pertile didn't sing even one live Trovatore . He happened to record Trovatore only because of Toscanini's influence , Toscanini used to cast his utility singers in everything .Had those recordings been planed later than 1928-1930 ,after Toscanini's influence waned ,the casting would have been different .Toscanini did more to undermine belcanto and Verdi with his systematic miscasting ,than all the other Italian conductors of the time combined .

    • @eugeniogentili1048
      @eugeniogentili1048 3 года назад

      Piu' di 4 ore di Aureliano Pertile ruclips.net/video/LCCrtlzeOmg/видео.html

  • @ursuladietze2094
    @ursuladietze2094 6 лет назад +5

    Non hanno schelto bene purtroppo... I suoi partner in quest' aria assomigliano piccole insettine vocalmente vicino a lui... :-))

    • @marcomartinengo4972
      @marcomartinengo4972 4 года назад +1

      NON TUTTI. pER ESEMPIO CORELLI, DEL MONACO, DI STEFANO, SONO PARI A LUI

  • @ottorinoperuzzi7051
    @ottorinoperuzzi7051 4 года назад +2

    Mi dispiace caro fortunato pertile aveva una dizione perfetta Mario delmonaco tenore drammatico formidabile mancava nell acuto supremo come il grandissimo Corelli

    • @zuzzo7
      @zuzzo7 3 года назад

      ... ma, come, ... Corelli mancava nell'acuto supremo, ... se ha cantatato POLIUTO dove, alla fine del I atto, emette un RE NATURALE SOVRACUTO e, nel III atto, RE bemolle sovracuto ... ???

    • @Nangis123
      @Nangis123 3 года назад +1

      The written score of Poliuto isn't high as in extreme range , and live FC was not at all disinclined to transpose down when he didn't feel like singing in key ,there are enough live excerpts on utube of Pira and Turandot on utube in which he transposed down .He never sang the Norma high C live .He did sing a C# VERY rarely and never alone by himself ,only with a soprano so she could cover for him if something went wrong or he changed his mind in the last moment and didn't sing it
      Pertile's diction is far from perfect , in fact he advocated "imperfect" diction where vowels are concerned .What AP advocated was blending the five Italian vowels which in speaking are all different,so in singing the result was a vowels mush particularly in the passagio : 'a' blended with 'o' , 'i' with 'u' ,'u' with 'o'

    • @mino7520
      @mino7520 2 года назад

      Parole sante ! Non si puo fuggire della realita.

  • @Shahrdad
    @Shahrdad 3 года назад +1

    Great singer, though he too skips the written trills.

    • @juanloaezaviadas500
      @juanloaezaviadas500 3 года назад

      Great observation. I think the only tenor I've heard doing them properly is Bergonzi (at least in the Phillips set). Can you think of any other?

    • @Shahrdad
      @Shahrdad 3 года назад

      @@juanloaezaviadas500 Ben Heppner did them, as did Joseph Schmidt, who could trill beautiful. Listen to him sing Una furtiva lagrima.

    • @juanloaezaviadas500
      @juanloaezaviadas500 3 года назад

      @@Shahrdad Thank you! I will

    • @Nangis123
      @Nangis123 3 года назад +1

      Bergonzi never did any trills live .In the modern recording studio ,with endless technical possibilities ,they're all lions ... LOL . As to how many times he transposed down , better not think about ,and better not think at all about the many times his top sounded constricted even AFTER he'd transposed down .Utublers are very adept at cherry picking ,picking on a tiny detail to justify their preference ,but a tiny detail does not make a performance . Neither the trill mentioned by Shahrdad nor the transpositions and constriction mentioned by me are enough to decide whether CB was suited to Verdi .He wasn't in my opinion but that opinion is based more than cherry picking

    • @Shahrdad
      @Shahrdad 3 года назад +1

      @@Nangis123 Trills are not "tiny details." The composer wrote them and wanted them sung. If a pianist or a violinist played a concerto and skipped all the trills, nobody would say, "Oh, that was a tiny detail." They'd be tarred and feathered and run out of town on a rail. Trovatore is riddled with trills. Azucena alone has 22 written trills in just Stride la vampa. All the other leading characters, are asked to trill as well.
      As for Bergonzi, I always admired his taste and elegance, but I often found the top constricted as well. It certainly never had the ring and freedom of a Corelli.

  • @marcolanchini3177
    @marcolanchini3177 4 года назад +2

    grande ma le opere vano cantate in tono come diceva Volpi

  • @dragoslavaleksic6328
    @dragoslavaleksic6328 4 года назад +1

    this is not high C: it is H

  • @arepo
    @arepo 3 года назад +2

    Totally fuori stile but appeals to those who confuse Verdi with verismo.

  • @jefffrederick694
    @jefffrederick694 4 года назад +2

    The notes are there but there is something disturbing for me in his tone. The tone is not pure.

    • @annaruocco8097
      @annaruocco8097 3 года назад

      tone deaf.

    • @annaruocco8097
      @annaruocco8097 3 года назад

      I'am sorry but I feel compelled to say again that you must be tone deaf.sorry.

  • @giovannifortunato6118
    @giovannifortunato6118 5 лет назад +2

    Ascoltare quella di Del Monaco del 1955. Molto meglio. Perfetta. Qui molti fraseggi sono incerti. Personalizza troppo. Non è una interpretazione scolastica. Ma è comunque un grande.

    • @andreaprandi9960
      @andreaprandi9960 4 года назад +1

      Ma tu credi di essere un grande intenditore? Ripensaci

    • @fabriziosarcinelli7566
      @fabriziosarcinelli7566 4 года назад +1

      Del Monaco e Pertile furono due divinità, e discutere quest'ultimo è un atto di ignoranza
      Si ravveda

    • @giovannifortunato6118
      @giovannifortunato6118 4 года назад

      Cosa c'entra adesso essere intenditori, o ancora peggio ignoranti. E' sempre inevitabile ascoltare e confrontare, criticare costruttivamente. Sono due grandi, diversi, ma questa interpretazione rispetto all'altra mi pare un tantino incerta, anche se di altissimo livello.

    • @Nangis123
      @Nangis123 4 года назад +1

      @@giovannifortunato6118 But you know mdm wouldn't touch the role live with a 10 ft pole ,don't you? Sang five performances of it after which he couldn't drop it fast enough . What a singer does in the recording studio with help from half a dozen techies and the possibility of repeating a take as often as necessary ,is one thing ,and singing the role live is another .Pertile on the other hand did sing the role live relatively often for about a decade . I'm not participating in the kindergarted debate "who is better" ,debate so dear to the heart of the common utube fan ,I'm just saying there's a very different risk singing a role live .When a singer does a role live ,repeatedly ,it shows he is confident enough his technique will see him through the exigencies of the role . When a singer declines singing a good ,popular role which is an audience draw , it shows he is afraid of the technical difficulties

    • @rubi1944
      @rubi1944 2 года назад

      Bisogna pensare che questa è una edizione del ´30. Ma dire che è una interpretazione un tantino incerta, mi fa sorridere.

  • @BaroneVitellioScarpia1
    @BaroneVitellioScarpia1 2 года назад

    This Leonora is awful.