Johnny Depp claims text messages from his phone were not sent by him | LiveNOW from FOX
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 24 май 2022
- Johnny Depp faced rapid-fire cross-examination questioning during his second appearance testifying in his defamation trial against ex-wife Amber Heard. Depp was shown text messages sent from his phone including one that says "I need, I want, I take." Depp denied sending the text messages and implied someone else in his inner circle sent them.
Subscribe to LiveNOW from FOX! ruclips.net/user/livenowfox?su...
Where to watch LiveNOW from FOX: www.livenowfox.com/
Follow us @LiveNOWFOX on Twitter: / livenowfox
Raw and unfiltered. Watch a non-stop stream of breaking news, live events and stories across the nation. Limited commentary. No opinion. Experience LiveNOW from FOX.
It’s crazy how his texts are used against him but Amber refused to follow court orders to hand over her texts and iCloud data
Wait, seriously? That's insane. I bet that content is juicy. And would tell us exactly how many extra-marital relationships she had at the time.
@@mslinda8456, it is true, people can use somebody else’s phone to send messages that are fake
Yes the judge will inform the jury of amber’s refusal to hand over her phone data in the jury notes that she gives them before deliberations
That's insane couldn't they make her.
I didn't know that.
It's not a difficult thing for someone like your partner to send a text message from your phone to another person. This happens all the time.
Not really
It's true I say it bc my husband sometimes tell me to send msg to someone and I do it. Is normal in some relationship to do it. He also use my phone for the same reason.
@@eylinvillar5986 yeah that's weird. He has a history of talking like that
Its not difficult at all if someone else also has access to your phone..my wife has used mine to text people when she couldn't find hers or the battery was dead..so it's very possible
@@sonaliperera my husband & I use each other's phones all the time. I'm literally on his right now! My battery is low& charging.
these are ''Incoming '' Text !!! Those were sent TO him ! Not sent BY him. Hope the Jury see that
My mother was narcissistic and cruel, my sister had borderline personality disorder and made me her scapegoat, just like Whitney. The aggressive way of questioning JD by this lawyer stressed me out and made me cringe, reactivating the assaults I suffered. After these weeks of trial which made J. Deep relive all the abuse he suffered, having to endure this interrogation must have been particularly painful for him. I am filled with compassion for him and all the victims of violence and hidden abuse and I hope that he can resume the course of his life more serenely, also realizing that he was extremely courageous to dare to speak out and that 'it has thus enabled many people to free their speech.
I'm so glad this is over....I felt the same way you did and it is still affecting me...as you can see by my writing this on June18th...I've suffered so much abuse...I totally felt Johnny's pain...
Omg I am the same
Same
This lawyer is incredibly disrespectful, asking him a question, then not even letting him finish answer, cutting him off at the points where it is convenient for him
Scoffing and laughing too. Ridiculous.
So incredibly professional of him 🤦🏼♂️😂
he's a drug addict
That's what attorneys do under cross examination. His attorney did the same to amber. They are allowed to give more detail or answer in further detail under direct from their own attorney.
That’s what lawyers do
And the jury can clearly see that too. This attorney, I think it’s Rottenborn is grasping at straws and obviously it’s back firing on him.
The way Amber smiled at him. I wouldn't be surprised if she sent those messages from his phone... obviously I have no proof, but Amber knew this would go public and wanted it to go public. The amount of lies she has produced... I think shes evil to the bone
Magic, same thought occurred to me.
Same here 🖐️. I don't think we can all be wrong
@@mslinda8456 well, we know that she hasn’t complied with the court order to deliver her data…
She was always writing things and saying things like she was Johnny. Like on the mirror.
I have no doubt that she used his phone to write the texts. She's that type of person.
I personally know women that do that kind of thing all the time.
I thought the exact same thing.
What’s so heinous about asking for drugs while you’re in severe pain, bleeding profusely, and traumatized? Who wouldn’t?
He asked for cocaine and ecstasy. Most people wouldn't. Most people don't use them.
Asking for cocaine when you're bleeding ha ha behave.
I HAVE HAD A SMASHED FINGER BY A BIG ROCK NEARLY LOST THE TIP OF FINGER THE PAIN WAS TERRIBLE GOT SCARS TO THIS DAY ☝😪
Cocaine and x would make the pain worse with withdrawal. It doesn't make sense
@Lynn well he knows what cocaine does to blood so WHY would he ask for it? To make him bleed MORE? Also what grown ass man calls coke "whitey" and ecstasy "e-business?" 💀💀😭
Ambers face is disgusting when he says he didn’t send it like she obviously sent this as part of her plan many years ago!!! Johnny has admitted to everything else
No matter how beautiful you are outside. Your inner disgust makes your outer smell. And that angel like face start looking like a smelly turd just like amber. No offense but i have seen that tears are a woman's best weapon to make people beleive her.
If you look at the txt it plainly says incoming txt at the top of those txt so it does not say sent txt it says incoming to his phone not outgoing
“You understand her to be angry right?”
JD: “she was always angry yes” 💀 she definitely seems like the type who was NEVER happy about anything
i worked 2nd shift the whole Cybil Shepherd show and missed it, so now on Roku every episode is so much like Amber Heard. How did the writers so accurately predict the birth of such a woman. Or was Heard raised on Cybil.
He deserves so much better
And her gave her a life that most woman would be thrilled with!!
If you are married to a crackhead is hard tô be happy
Some women are like this, always angry about something and never satisfied with anything. These are the same type of women that will grind their SO into dust. They’ll get you to the point where you’re afraid of doing anything you’d naturally do, simply to keep them from yelling at you and point out your shortcomings. I’m happy for JD being rid of this woman.
The way she couldn't take her eyes off him when the lawyer read that text, then that smirk, says everything! She definitely sent those texts.
And I really hope the jury saw that and recognised it for what it was.
If she was a victim, there's no way she would be smirking like that. Imo she has given herself away in those few seconds.
Timestamp would be helpful
she can smirk all she wants all shes proven is he's done drugs thats all her lies have been exposed the jury sees her foul face too they arent stupid she wont be smirking at the end of this
@@miranx5735 12:30 ✌🏼
@@charlyjgm much appreciated ❤️
Says everything does it? lol
There is CLEARLY a handle of the glass bottle where Johnny is pointing at. The handle is turned upside down and is pretty big. How can this lawyer simply deny this?
Interesting!
He's desperate.
Because he’s born rotten
Amber's lawyer was talking about a "handle" of vodka. It's a 1.75L sized bottle. He was trying to say that there wasn't enough glass to account for a bottle of that size. At the same time Depp was referring to a literal bottle handle. I think Depp's strategy is to confound opposing lawyers by requiring literal explanations for everything.
@@jobney well Amber's lawyer is trying to say you can't see any kind of handle, but it's NOT a good picture at all for details 💀💀 you can barely see the broken glass and there's no closeup for the lawyer to even go off about the handle....
People want to hate on this trial because it involves celebrities but this is representative of much greater issues that have nothing to do with being famous or not.
Yes, women taking advantage of the "me too" domestic abuse bs movement for easy money and to permanently damage a man's reputation.
This trial prove that men can be victim of domestic abuse, that women can be compulsive liars and that anyone should be innocent until proven guilty
This trial represents everything the Red Pill movement stands regarding false accusations against men and why marriage should no longer be an option for a man.
"You could have typed that up last night"
He finally gets how this works.
No literally bc they didn't even have enough copies 😭
ABSOLUTELY RIGHT 💔
Have lawyers done that type of thing before? Curious
@@aishaalamoudi599 You calling Johnny Depp by his last name, and Amber Heard by her first name, like you know her, proves your bias, "Pro". As sad as her psychiatrist using her title to try and pass off personal opinion as unbiased professional conclusion. STFU, mark.
@@aishaalamoudi599 on weed bro?
So disgusting. These are incoming text messages not sent messages. At first I felt sorry for AH lawyers but now I think they are vile human beings.
yes!!! glad someone sees it too
Suprised no one else noticed!!
I think his legal team would realize an error like that
Yes, they could just tell her sorry madame your case is weak you will lose, bye.
Odd that he'd admit to flappy fish market cmguzzler/mollusk split penis but not that.
The strength of conviction we heard when he said "that's ludicrous", says it all.
It’s crazy how Johnny gets shut down immediately if he continues talking for even one extra second. Even though he’s incredibly mindful to not do so. Whereby Amber can speak forever and ever with no consequences. Unbelievable! She looks so happy when the slightest thing in her mind is going her way! Even though she knows they are lies.
Everything he says favours him, whereas the longer amber was talking, the more bs she was able to tell. I think it was a strat because she built that web of lies and slipped
Amber's lawyers wanted him to stop talking so he couldn't defend himself. Johnny's lawyers wanted Amber to keep talking but the more she did the deeper the hole she dug for herself
It didn’t help her tho… she just looked stupid
And Amber goes on forever without objections from Camill lets her explain her reaction yet Rottenborn won't let Johnny answer an questions
It's disgusting how rude Rottenborn is
can't help but say, he's doing his job. it's this witch he's working for that's making him do this, otherwise the shoe could be on the other foot
They are desperate.
@@RemTV idgaf if he's "doing his job" they could at least have the courtesy of letting the man answer the damn questions
He stepped up his game tho gotta gave him credit for that
@@RemTV yea he’s doing his job but u the difference is that he’s reaching very hard by using incoming texts aka depp received not sent them and stating that Johnny sent em, then he brings up something irrelevant to the case from 17 years ago that depp won’t remember and uses it to try & insinuate he’s hiding something for not remembering
So frustrating for him when he’s trying to say his side and the lawyer won’t let him finish and making him out to be lying. She looks suspect as she lowers head but slyly looks up when the text messages are being read out to him. I think she sent those texts from his phone. Don’t believe or trust what she says for one second. She is deceitful and calculating. JD has burdened this stress for 6 years.
Yes I think he's just now finding out that she did this and she was embarrassed. That's why she reacts like that, covering her face and putting her head down.
Poor guy was in a lot of pain with. He lost some of finger to bone amber might clean up some glass for picture may be different pictures
Jail mates rip from out wall and never hurt finger like that was liquid bottle and she threw two of them might be first or second bottle of pictures
Not sure I understand the purpose of these questions. What is the point?
Omg This lawyer is pissing me of let the man speak damn 🤦🏻♀️ he can’t even finish a sentence without being spoken over what a joke 😤😤
"Which question would you like me to handle first?"
🤣🤣
..In this trial I don't know whether to laugh or cry!..
🙈
You can tell simply by his reaction. And I realize he's an actor. But the way he said "I'm sorry, can you repeat that?" Like he couldn't believe its even a possibility that they have any evidence that suggests he said that. He even said "Thats ludicrous." He didn't make excuses or try to explain, or say maybe I was drunk or this or that. He said "Pull up whatever you want but there's no way I said those words." And I believe him.
He's right he did not write that... those are "INCOMING" messages from somebody else.
Right?!?
Nah, they explained this on Law & Crime today because of the misinformation around it. That was a message in his Assistant Stephen's phone. It was sent from Depp to him. That is why it says incoming. Stephens text messages from Depp are part of evidence not just the text messages in Depp's phone he sent out.
What??
Exactly. It clearly says incoming at the top.
incoming..as in it's not Johnny's phone they're reading the messages on its the person he sent it to.
My sister is borderline narcissist too and AH is a lot like her. My sister has admitted texting people from her boyfriend’s phone. They’re extremely cunning, vile, ruthless, vindictive, and just plain evil!
I have a friend (A) who did exactly that from (B) her female friend’s phone. She believed B liked a guy (C) and when B went to bathroom, A picked B’s phone from the table and sent a message to (C) telling him she’d be waiting for him naked.
B was confronted by C about the text which had been erased from B’s phone by A after she sent the text. But B was able to figure out who the sender was because she remembered leaving her phone on the table. Needless to say, A and B are no longer friends.
@@picilocarnal yep…that’s what my sister did….just deleted her messages after she sent them. Definitely not unheard of to do it.
The texts say “incoming” tho. Not outgoing. Johnny didn’t write it
Wow you would really throw your sister under the bus like that? Damn girl
I feel for you. I'm only just coming to terms with my sister's nature and I'm having therapy to try to understand our relationship. I'm only just starting to fully understand 'projection' and seeing Amber demonstrate this so blatantly, helps me to see and identify it in my sister. It's like an extreme defensiveness strategy. My sister's long term boyfriend is more abusive than her from what I can tell. He has access to all of her passwords and I know this because she told me. I've sent her emails in the past and he has replied as her! How do I know? Because my sister is dyslexic and he is not - he's the complete opposite!
THOSE ARE NOT HIS MESSAGES. If you look closely you will see the “Direction”, it clearly states those words in the text message on JD phone were INCOMING! Wow, really hope I’m not the only one that noticed that. It’s very obvious in his testimony that he never said any of that.
Why would you assume that those messages were on JD's phone? Wouldn't it make far more sense if they were 'incoming' on Mark Deuter's phone??
@@timapple6586 Because AH lawyer stated that the messages were provided by JD, meaning they were from his phone. These are messages that JD received.
@@srdjankovic yes, I heard this on law and crime yesterday, I hope his lawyers do say something about this in closing because those messages were clearly incoming and like you said came from his phone. They pointed out that the other message, which he admitted to, was outgoing
The lawyers of Heard also appeared very nervous during this hearing, for some reason...
That's not how litigation discovery works. They get same texts from multiple sources. They may have used the wrong exhibit, ie, the ones from the other person's phone. But to the best of my knowledge, JD admitted to writing all but one of the texts he was accused of writing in this trial.
There is nothing wrong with Johnny that a complete retraction or vindication would not cure. He is a gentle man, a kind man, and a generous man. He has been tortured by this insane harpy for years. I hope he wins, and she loses, and that Amber is prosecuted for perjury, along with her lying sister.
I truly hope Depp wins.... He didn't deserve to have his reputation and career ruined because of lies.
These sorts of cases are always geared to protecting the women even if clearly in the wrong. The system likes making men look like brutes.
He does deserve it. He’s a cu*t who has lied !
@@ryustreetfighter8722 a lot of them are 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅 look up the STATS
His ANGER is apparent- very very very apparent
He has won hands down 💯 easy...... she has been caught lying on more than 1 occasion by the judge as well lol.....
"I've could have asked for a teddy bear". He's awesome.
I had an anaphylactic reaction to ibuprofen, woke up in the hospital and did indeed have my childhood teddy bear with me. Don’t know how or when. Was great fun as a 26 year old going home the next day with teddy bear in hand….
Loved that!!
I find it highly improbable that Johnny would send such messages in such a tone. People normally match their verbal speech to their "text" speech, if that makes sense. Johnny is laid back, calm and even tempered, even when angry. I doubt he would use that many exclamation points in a message
U right that says text direction incoming meaning he didn't send those msg it just shows how rotenn rotenborn is trying to put words on others mouth. And Jhonny knew himself and had trust in himself and it was not him who send that message .
That is not Johnny Depp, totally out of character. They are grasping for straws. There would be a pattern, Kate Moss would have come out and destified. There is no pattern, it’s made up.
That's the thing. The 2 texts in question say INCOMING. So someone else as sent it to him from a group chat
TONE? OMG. I think you must have skipped much of the trial if you found JD's texts "laid back". I wish I could unhear/unread them.
Maybe he was confused by the text messages because as you see the most disgusting one's were actually incoming text messages which I don't think he realized at the time so maybe he was trying hard to remember when he sent thos because they say " incoming" so he didn't actually send those which can be easily seen by the fact that the women mentioned in the text is called "molly" molly doesn't sound like anyone johnny depps ever been romantically involved with which make sense since the texts were "incoming"
Text should not be admissible in court unless,they are proven 100% without a doubt came from that person! It is so easy to manipulate somebody’s phone if they are asleep or unaware that someone has their phone
They were INCOMING texts sent to his phone the one he claimed he wrote is my favorites
Right. He didn’t write the Molly texts.
Also like there are fake texting apps.
Unfortunately it doesn't work like that. When you used any texting apps, accs, sim cards you practically signed the t&c that anything sent by you is YOUR intellectual property & the responsibility goes to you. It's hard to be proven otherwise. I've been sabotaged like that before & I damn near lost the case because of that.
look im glad he won, but those texts make him look really bad, and I wouldnt wanna admit i wrote that either. They were probably his. Still doesnt mean she wasnt a narc and a nightmare
It's crystal clear that she sent those messages, the way she just sits there and stares at him while smirking at the messages being read out. Such a vile creature.
Look at the texts. The text messages were SENT to Johnny Depp and READ by Johnny Depp - if you look at the text evidence presented in court today. Rottenborn made a HUGE mistake!!
They are incoming messages, I don’t understand how it’s gone unnoticed
@H no it went unoticed look at the transcript it says him(owner) and all the messages are incoming even BORNROTTEN said that these were from his phone they are so fcking dumb the legal team didnt notice but jury has the evidence they can see incoming and this whole cross would be huge loss for AH team
“I was in great pain and distress, so I could have asked for a teddy bear as well.” I love everything JD says 💙
Of course u do lolololol. Good thing u aren't on the jury
@H yup
@H which wasn't even by him. Jokes on you
@@reneerakes7677 who won the court case?? JOHNNY DID.
JUSTICE HAS BEEN SERVED.
@@GGS348 i
No, he is claiming the texts clearly marked INCOMING to his phone that the lawyer read as him sending them were NOT SENT by him
It’s possible that they were fake but there’s no proof of what you’re saying give proof? No
Just loved the way he said "which question would u lik me to answer first"...very calm and composed human being...LOV U JD ❤️💗
Dude, someone is playing dirty. this whole trail amber has been emotionless, now she's all smiles and talking to people? Nope, not buying it. Fabricated evidence?
Yeah she must all of a sudden be very confident. And after all of the evidence against her, how can she even give a smirk is beyond me unless they think they have something
Earlier they used a photoshop picture as evidence
@@anthonybrito2610 fr had me weak loool
@@ellieeveritt Maybe someone promised her protection *cough *cough elon musk
Yeah theyre up to something
This is the worst cross Ive ever heard. He's rushing, not letting him answer, and is trying to catch him in small errors of recollection, PROVING NOTHING. WHAT A JOKE. THAT IS DEFINITELY SOMETHING AMBER WOULD SAY, THAT 'I WANT I NEED I TAKE'. DEFINITELY AMBER.
Yeah he is rushing because they are running out of time. Plus the messages that johnny said he did not write he didn't. If you look at the top right corner it says incoming. The one that's like a paragraph talking bad about amber that one say outgoing. Top right corner.
he's coming off like a bully, like Amber
The same could be said of Depps lawyers during their cross examination of Heard
yes, and amber has narcissistic qualities so she would definitely be the one to say "I need this, and I need that, and I I I I me me me me" 🙄
They are incoming texts menaing he received them he didnt write them. Rottenborn is a moron.
THAT LAWYER IS A JERK. No he’s not just “doing his job” he’s being completely aggressive, rude, disrespectful and more. Foul and vile.
They are running out of time. They are desperate
Do we know when the trial will finish? Poor JD. Thank God for his amazing lawyers and the patient judge.
He doesn’t know how to form sentience’s LOL
chileeee....☕🍿🤓
Yeah he's quite the lil passive aggressive smart ass. I think he's jealous of Depp
Those texts were labeled as “incoming” meaning he received the texts not sent them. Surprised his lawyers didn’t pick up on this. Not surprised her lawyers tried to pretend they were his texts.
This type of aggressive, quick-fire interrogation is presumably designed to goad and provoke JD to get angry 🤨
You got that right! This is entirely designed to shake J.D up & upset him. He's not allowed to answer the questions, he's disrespected, they're picking apart nothing because they have nothing. Grasping at straws. J.D his ability to stay calm in ALL situations just shows who he REALLY is. He doesn't let anything ruffle him. He's confident & strong in who he is. Screw A.H & her bizarre, mediocre staff
I'd be embarrassed representing her. There goes their careers because She is clearly lying & unstable as well as a cheater & an abuser.
this is how the courtroom works during cross examination. it’s a the process used on anyone on the stand. the same was done to amber, you can see this when camille vasquez was questioning her.
exactly! I got angry and am a peaceful person
Heard's team is like her. That's why she chose them. They're all abusive liars.
I don’t care much about the case but these comments are so biased .
When johnnys female attorney cuts people off because she is saying “that’s all I’m asking” when they are explaining, to get to the point, people will comment “oh she’s amAzInG!!”
When ambers attorney starts to also not let people over talk and just get the answer you guys go “ oh he’s SoO RuDe”
Even if you think their side is wrong , is it really that hard to be equally objective about the techniques they use? It’s the same. Get your answer without letting them over talk and make excuses for themselves. That’s what they are trying to do. This isn’t a conversation , it’s them asking specific questions for specific answers .
Atleast be objective and stop romanticizing one side all the time
The jerk of an attorney won’t allow Johnny to talk, to defend himself.
I have said this all along since court case has started. Someone on here said that attorney doesn't need to listen to him . I said listening is a great skill. 🙄🙄🙄🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
he drives me crazy- hes always like this
He wants his questions to go on record and doesn't care if he gets a response or not. Remember "if you say something often enough it becomes the truth".
@@aishaalamoudi599 i agree with the fact tht they are all lawyers and all have their ways --correct
Actually JD loved it cus he got the opportunity to drag out time.
They have like 1,25 hour left. And JD has like 7.
AH’s face when the text messages are brought up is almost a guilty smirk like she knows she set him up by sending those texts off of his phone and now I believe he’s genuinely shocked seeing them because he probably hadn’t before.
The looks on her face when these text were read..just proofs she was behind the text
The txt say that they are incoming to his phone I just saw that it doesn’t say they are sent from his phone it’s says incoming txt
How can the lawyers not see this it says incoming to his phone not outgoing txt but incoming
GUYS, LOOK AT THE PICTURE.
The texts are "INCOMING", not outgoing. Meaning he couldn't write them. They were sent to his phone.
it says incoming because he obviously didn't send the text to his own phone but to somebody else.
@@bastieinsteiger6379 ...idk if you're repeating me or trying to argue something
@@user-vl9bw1lw1u His.. notice the participants on the left? Depp (owner) and Stephen Deuters.
@@miantava It's deuders' phone.
@@sarahcusack wouldnt it say the 2 participants are (owner) and Johnny depp, if that were the case? Would it even be allowed for AH's attorney to gain access to Deuter's phone records & use them as evidence?
Amber wouldn’t be the first person to send messages from somebody else’s phone, as that person.
It’s actually more common than you might think…
Unfortunately those are dated 2017
My son does it all the time! I don't care cos I hate texting - but still .......
@@elizabethedwards4686 They are also marked as "incoming" messages. You can see it at 12:01
@@elizabethedwards4686 spoofing was available back then, people could go online and enter the number to send a message to, the number you want to show the message is from, then type the message and send. On the receiving end it would show the message as being sent from that phone number but that phone wasn't used or have an record of the message.
@@mithras666 Why would they pull the texts from someone else's phone instead of Depp's? They have all of Depp's messages, I don't think we know about them having other people's.
Considering both Depp's insistence that he didn't write them and that they're incoming, the context being misrepresented seems more likely to me.
Isn’t it funny how Johnny’s team lets Amber Heard answer questions, tell a story and build context, while Amber’s team cuts him off instantly and never allows him to explain context? Hmm, I wonder why.
They gotta play dirty. And they are trying to get a rise out of Johnny to cause him to lose his temper
Except for when Amber is flat out lying then she gets scolded. which is all the time.
Double standards favoring the woman.....giving her freedom to talk while restricting the man's freedom to talk.
They are all trash in the turd herd.
When has Amber ever answered with a simple yes or no? And this guy expects Johnny to? Insane.
I was thinking the same thing !
HE DIDN'T SEND the "Molly" messages! Look at the info, it says INCOMING. Meaning he received them. This was such a despicable thing to do from Amber's lawyers.
Those are messages that came from Johnny's phone to Mr. Dooder's (sp?) phone. That's why they say "incoming". They still sound very out of character for Depp.
To have “normalized” relationships where AH physically hits and verbally abuses friends, sister, intimate partners, etc. and does it DAILY like “it’s a walk in the park” is fu*#%ng SICK and TWISTED. This woman belongs behind bars away from people.
AGREED!!!!
Totally agree, EVEN IF! She some how wins this case, every one in America knows who she really is and i think will no longer have any career in Hollywood. Alot of people dislike/ hate her and movie companies arent going to gamble with that.
So do her lawyers.
@@JM-qt5mg Agree. Everyone in the world will know!
I will say she should be in some mental hospital
Johnny Depp is a G. I could have wanted a teddy bear. I hope he wins his case! She should never be able to get a contract in a movie ever again. I'm glad he exposed her!!..
Trust me she wouldn’t even without this as everyone knows that she is such a bad actress lol
"which question would you like me to handle first?" 🤣😂👏👏👏
Actually some of the texts turned out not to be from him, and the record showed that. AH's lawyers messed that up because the sources were redacted.
They should had cleared that up after he said it wasn’t him !
This attorney is so aggressive, he's so unnecessarily hostile. It doesn't look good for their side. He's trying to assert control, but it comes across as him being desperate and off balance.
So rude it’s unreal,
He's trying the movie style, where lawyers get aggressive and witness slips and confess to the crime 🤣
I mean that’s the point . It’s how Camille also behaved . It’s their job .
Nah. He’s polite.
@@Inannarising haha 😂
How are they even allowed to do this when SHE did not hand over her records and data?? The court system is screwy and corrupt!
Bravo Bravo Bravo
The message says "INCOMING" and why is this a group chat? There's many people in the "participants"
It means he received this, because if he sent this it should be "OUTGOING" and there should only be two participants.
This is the first time Rottenborn brought that up. Because this isn't Johnny's text.
She claims she lost her phone 😒
@@Natas_Nico08518 Uh-huh.
@@Natas_Nico08518 i don’t think you need the actual phone to get your text messages. It’s stopped in servers.
It's amazing that throughout this trial this is the only time he is claiming that he didn't say or write something when there is evidence that he did. He also looks totally confused about these texts. I believe he did not send this.
Sis, look at the text! It clearly says "incoming" before the body message. The text were incoming not outgoing
Just look at ambers reaction while reading them out. She sent them herself I’m convinced of that
The direction in the text message shows INCOMING doesn't that mean he received them? The other ones that were shown until now and were sent by him , the direction was outgoing🤔
This still doesn't prove physical abuse and sexual assault.
They've yet to prove that to prevent Amber from losing.
It's a defamation trial, Johnny brought to sue Amber for the op-ed she wrote in the Washington Post which damaged his reputation and career, she is denying she wrote it about him, she is counter suing him saying she has lost work and earnings, but even if he loses this trial he has got his reputation back, which I think is all he wanted from this, I hope he realises how much he's loved 😍
Imagine being a lawyer who never gets hired after representing someone who is clearly not the victim 😬
Why won't they be hired again? There is plenty of other people like amber heard out there looking for lawyers like them.
They'll get clients that don't pay attention to things like this. To their dismay I'm sure.
Yeah not how that works
then any lawyer who ever defended the guilty person would be screwed LOL
Regardless the client is innocent or not, lawyers are there to protect them from potential abuses. Lawyers don't make their clients innocents, they protect them from potential abuse of authority. 😊 If the lawyer knows her client is at fault, their role is not to twist the truth but find legal ways to lessen the penalty/sanctions imposed against her. If the lawyer knows her client is innocent, they'll find legal ways to prove that she's innocent.
Remember, despite how cruel the suspect is, she will remain an innocent until proven guilty.
So let's not blame the lawyers. Blame Amberturd. Because she's the one presenting false evidence. I hope her lawyers sue her and the "experts" she hired who validated and claimed that her evidence were not faked.
As someone who is abused on a daily basis just like JD, I thank him for letting the world know, it isn't just women that has to live though this.
As a Man, I am having to deal with this without the power to finacially fight this.
Life is too short. I hope u find the strength to walk away from anything that hurts u x
Thank you
How couldn’t they just point out the incoming and the other one is out coming to the messages … ?!!! I hope the jury sees that !!
What? The pictures being shown are from his assistant, Stephen Deuters' phone. The texts are incoming to his phone from Depp.
her lawyers are so unprofessional and annoying, they cut him off when he tried to explain, like they don't want the truth to reveal 🤦🏽♀️
Yeah AH's team hates context. They just fish for answers that sound good without context and as soon as they manage to fish out a "yes" or a "no", they practically run away so nothing is specified.
If that doesn't make it obvious that there's something to hide, I don't know what would.
THOSE TEXTS ARE INCOMING! PRAY THE JURY & HIS TEAM CATCH THAT 🙏🏼 HE DID NOT SEND THEM
Incoming to his phone or was that printed text shown incoming to the recipient
@@muzzy9267 all the other texts from JD shown were 'outgoing' ... there is smthing fishy abt these.
Where are AH,s text messages? She refused to hand them over. If they can't scrutinize her text messages, then his should not be either.
"She was always angry, yes..." Classic !!! 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏🇬🇧🍀
If Johnny’s lawyers could question in re direct, “did Amber have your phone’s password/passcode?”
If that question is affirmative, then it is a valid argument that Amber had access to Johnny’s phone and could have made and sent that text message.
He could have been passed out, and she used his finger or face to unlock it... ?
these messages are from 2017 after they were split up
The lawyer of Turd admitted Johnys assistant had access to the phone so..
She did not have access to his phone after they split up.
Objection ! Speculation - Leading
Who wouldn't be intoxicated living with someone like her jeez. Nightmare lol
😝😝😝😝
lol are you sure of what you are saying ?! have you lived with a drunk millionaires 55 yo junky ?!
SNAKE
I'd be thinking fondly of the Freddy Kruger days lol
I am really surprised he found the energy to work at all!!!!! I am a therapist and my clients whom have experienced this kind of trauma usually end up lying in bed beeing suicidal. If she lived where I come from she would NOT be a free woman...
Poor Johnny depp. She wrote that. There was a picture of her holding a sign that said that. She did that crap.
*Incoming texts. All of the other texts from Johnny’s phone that were his were labeled Outgoing. These were labeled incoming. Seriously… put 2 and 2 together. These were from his friend.
He confirmed so many other texts that were on the 'yikes' side of normal, so I do believe him when he says he didn't send those ones. When living with someone it is not difficult to send a message on their phone without their knowledge.
The messages say "Him (Owner)" so this is Depp's phone and then it reads "Direction: Incoming". All other messages are listed "Direction: Outgoing" that Depp admits to sending.
So these are messages Depp's phone RECEIVED. Not messages Depp's phone sent. It's a very bad error on their part and no one caught it.
@@sarcasm-83 unless shown evidence messages are from the assistants phone ??????
@@mariahscurry19 It clearly lists participants;
"Him (Owner)"
"Stephen Deuters"
Owner indicates the owner of the phone. If "Owner" indicated the owner of the messages they couldn't display exchanges with, for example Bettany and Depp in the same form AND there would be zero point there to be information about "Direction: Incoming/Outgoing"
Oh and they have said that "Him" always refers to Depp. "Her" would refer to Amber and everyone else mentioned is listed by name.
@@mariahscurry19 If you look at the other text shown you can again see it listing the "him(owner)" in participants, but the direction is "outgoing". Though, I can't understand how Amber's team would be that stupid. It might have another explanation like you said.
Yikes side of normal? If a regular guy did it y'all would burn him at stake, fascinating how many excuses y'all can conjure for a celebrity you like.
In this case tho, this is cleary not a message sent by him, but sent to him, since it's collected from his phone.
Can someone please explain how whether he took drugs or not at any time has any bearing on Amber Heards claim that he was abusive toward her. He is not on trial for drug taking but they keep harping on about it.
You're absolutely right about that, but that's the only case they have, which is basically nothing...
Just to destroy his character and make the jury look at him poorly like he has an obscure memory of events
Yeah cause it's the only thing she can talk bad about him lol
The psychiatrist that was playing expert witness on Heard's dollar tried to. Very poorly.
They're just trying to paint a bad picture of him.
THOSE WERE MARKED INCOMING 🤣 how did the legal team miss that
There’s far more proof here than just “incoming.” Look at status at the bottom. On the other texts Johnny actually sent, it reads SENT.
On these texts however, it reads READ.
These texts say READ and INCOMING. Not sure what’s so hard about this. Johnny’s phone… “read” and “incoming.” There are 3 participating parties listed on the left, so this is a group chat.
And thus, OBVIOUSLY these were written by his friend Stephen Deuters, or another unnamed friend, and you don’t have to be a rocket scientist to see that. 🙄
Truthfully the amount of coke and pills Johnny AND Amber has consumed during the relationship has no revelance to this case. Amber's team is so desperate that they're trying to catch Johnny on a lie without realizing that he knows exactly what they're up to.
It does, since they are attempting to portray that he wouldn’t even remember what he’s done because he’s always high. That’s the main reason they keep bringing it up. It’s to create doubt in the jury about his version of events. That even if he THINKS he’s telling the truth, he could be wrong. But they fail to address that Amber was also drinking or high in those situations as well.
Dont be so dumb! The issues these two have had is all connected to all the booze and drugs they consumed, which all cause horrendous mood swings.
"Tell the world, Johnny, tell them, 'Johnny Depp, I, a man, I'm a victim too of domestic violence'. And see how many people believe or side with you"....
Ook that probably was told under stress. I hope one day you’ll have a daughter and she’ll marry a man twice her age and he’ll send degrading texts about her. Maybe that day you’ll learn something.
@@jolinejoline2471 get off RUclips amber, you have a lawsuit to lose
@@jolinejoline2471 you don’t tell your abuser that kind of stuff “under stress”, you know that saying things like that will put your life in danger. She wasn’t afraid of him, he wasn’t the abuser.
@@jolinejoline2471 And because Amber may have been 'under stress' it's ok that she cut off his finger too? Or defacated in his bed? Or lied on the stand and perjured herself several times? Or beat Johnny numerous times? I could go on but we'd be here all night. Stress does not absolve people of responsibility or guilt my dear, and do you not think that poor Johnny was under stress too? Make it make sense.
@@jolinejoline2471 ahahaha ur caught again! Ur caught again ! Ahahaha Beauty without brain amber! Switch to porn
4:24- even the lawyer doesn’t recall look at the shock in his face haha
"Uh, which question would you like me to answer first?" HAHAHA I freaking love this man!
The trial is about to end and all of the sudden AH lawyers decided to show those text messages? They are so desperate and it's hard to believe they were written by JD.
That's because they weren't written by him. They were incoming, as it clearly stated on the sheet, but somehow they overlooked it. The other claim about him saying MOLLY and " I take what I want,when I want", was also not a text. It was from an old teen magazine article on Johnny from 1995, as in 27 years ago. And we all know that the magazines in the 90's got away with writing, just about anything fabrication they wanted.
No wonder Johnny looked so confused about those messages.
@@me77ki 🤔
@@me77ki i think that meant in coming on her phone, not his and they wouldn't make an error so obvious as that, his team would leap on that immediately. I expect she sent them from his phone, what a truly vile creature she is!
@@rjim1 the text records where pulled from his phone, tho not hers. She refused to release hers.
Because of the judge’s ruling on hearsay she wasn’t allowed to show the text messages until now but by his own testimony he ‘opened the door’ for her to show the messages during his rebuttal. So this is the first time she’s been allowed to show it only because of the courts rules.
Did anyone notice that the "Direction" of these texts are "Incoming" vs outgoing? This suggests that they were sent by someone else. Surely, the defense is aware of this. What a vile tactic to try and score some points with the jury.
These texts were sourcrd from Deuter's phone, that's why they say "incoming". 🤦🏽♀️
I'm so disappointed that Depp's team didn't catch that in the re-direct.. even more disappointed that these kinds of clips are now making rounds for millions, without there being any clarification and so few noticing it. But it indeed does clearly show that Him (Owner) verifies it as Depp's phone (Other participant is named) and the direction of the message "Incoming", so it was indeed received, not sent.
Yes, Because they were turned over by the recipient he sent them too! Unbelievable how you people could support this man! You obsessed fans refuse to believe and acknowledge anything he's done wrong and blame her, or someone else! I'll bet you supported OJ too and still think he's innocent too, despite the huge amount of evidence! Ok...🙄...smh..
@@nicoleangel4383 Oh the irony.
It's clearly said in court that "him" always refers to Depp. Stephen Deuters is named as a recipient. "(owner)" after the recipients name indicates the owner of the phone. It reads 2 recipients "him(owner)" and "Stephen Deuters". The Direction is incoming.
Every thing he has done wrong he has admitted and I fully admit to. None of it is pretty to look at, but none of it means that the VERY severe claims are also true.
If Amber's claims were true, she would not be on photos next day having managed to conceal everything, she would be in the hospital or hiding with a horribly swollen face because that is what several punches from an adult would do.
"He beat cabinets" doesn't translate to him doing it to people. Amber has not appeared scared in any audio or video she submitted to evidence. She has sounded like a woman who relies that she can mock her in any way she wants and not get touched.
do you really think they are that stupid? The screenshot was taken from Stephen Deuters' phone. i think that's common sense. And before someone responds with some new fabricated excuse, Johnny confirmed it himself at 9:50 which you would already know if you actually listen to what's being said in this video. you all sound delusional
I love how Johnny caught the text that wasn’t his. It was shown on Court TV they had proof that wasn’t his text,, the one about Molly! He caught it, spoke up! That Rottenborn tried to pull as fast one but he caught it! And said the plane plane! Johnny cracked me up- good going JD and I’m so thrilled as all of us are that the TRUTH prevailed ! He was totally honest and spoke his truth! ❣️
“I wanna make sure we’re on the same page here.”
“I don’t think we are.” 😂😂😂
I can totally imagine Amber Heard taking his phone and sending texts to help build her gold-digging case while she was taking all those photos! Her lawyer is annoying as she and the rest of her posse! Ugh...
B/tch is capable of anything.
They are INcoming messages not OUTgoing... someone Texted HIM
@@Sofia-do2fc Yes, there are others he refers to as coming from his phone.
@Jennifer Stalcup hope the jury notice this detail
Johnny strait up was like "no that's not me, id never say anything like that" and the lawyer was like "yes it was", didn't amber have the password to his phone as well has his security and buddies?? Amber could have taken his phone and texted the person that and then deleted them off his phone after screenshotting it and sending it to herself.
Her face had the look of oh Inwrote thise let's see if they believe it is him.
Well the texts were incoming so not sent by him.
She's proud she set him up here
Right! I have a friend who's jealous current wife argued with his previous wife through his phone. Current wife then deleted the conversation. Ex wife wouldn't let him see their kids for months. It happens all the time. These messages were only read to further smear him
😘I’m team Amber and Johnny wrote those text..,🧐 both sides are Drug addicts. So I pick drug amber!!!
I do recall I was being under great stress so I could have asked for a teddy bear as well 🤣🤣🤣
AH had shown us how capable she is in doing evil stuff… It’s not impossible that she might be the one behind those text messages. She is a manipulator and really twisted.
So clear that Amber was one hell of a successful gaslighter. From the nail polish, to copying his hand writing to this. Damn.
He's grasping for straws... Trying to call into question his memory. At this point it's meaningless. She had no marks on her, no pictures, no witnesses. In an air of social media if he ever laid a hand on her she'd of put the picture all over the Internet.
Her lawyer's are absolutely horrible
His reply she was always angry it was a given...love it
I wouldn’t doubt if Amber grabbed his phone to text as if it were him! She’s that vile.
AGREE
They were received msgs he never sent them!!
They are incoming messages
Yeah those texts Johnny Depp doesn’t remember says DIRECTION: INCOMING - it’s not an outgoing text message that he sent. How can $million lawyers on both sides miss that?????
@@mrwrightc7 one of his seen someone point it out on Twitter so hopefully they address it.. but agreed how can you miss that
The fact that they're not even letting him answer is what the f*** why is the judge allowing this??
Well the attorney is the one asking the questions so since it's his time he can judge what's important and what's not, his job is to get the answers he wants, plus he has time he has to respect. Imagine asking a question and the witness is saying other unnecessary things to the answer YOU want, even if it was your witness you wouldn't want that. So technically, the judge isn't doing anything wrong, his time, he's in control, when Johnny's lawyer 's time comes he can clarify or give the chance for depp to respond and clarify that.
However, you can see them scared, their case is built on lies and standing on shaky ground, so they're being scared and not acting like the righteous party, otherwise they wouldn't need to stop him every time
@@pacman780 Stop defending unprofessional behavior.
@@killyourtelevision999 unfortunately “unprofessional” and “lawyer” tend to go hand in hand 😭 it’s only the judges fault if they’re being unethical or aggressive
@@killyourtelevision999 excuse me, are you a law professional by any means?
@@killyourtelevision999 But it is professional behavior lol
Amber whispering to the seated lawyer, "This is the stuff I sent from his phone, teeheehee."
I feel so bad for Johnny having to air all this out in the public eye with him being such a private person just because she's narcissistic!! I know everything he's saying is 1000% true too as my mother was mentally ill with the same thing which I moved from MN to AZ to start over from and then ten yrs ago my 14yr old daughter was diagnosed with borderline personality disorder and bipolar which I put up with until she was 22 and I had to make her get her own place as I had survived Leukemia and a dbl-stem cell transplant and she was actually wearing on my health and I was going rapidly back downhill!! Even on medication my daughter, which is going to be 24 next month, still does not function or interact very well in society. The best way to describe these mentally ill personality types is "a person w/out a soul!!" It is impossible for these types of personalities to process anything like normal brain does!
You're disgusting. To put your own sole experience of BPD mental illness on everyone else and call them soulless. Are you also a racist because you were robbed by a black man? Shows just how much compassion you hold, you may have more of your mother in you than you'd dread to think.
Howccan she be actress with all these personality
BPD is not an illness, it's a personality disorder. Biploar is an illness and does not in any way resemble not having a soul. What you are talking about is a sociopath and a psychopath. They have no or limited amydala which causes the lack of empathy and therefore the "soul"of a human. Sociopathy and psychopathy are not illnesses either hence there is no treatment possible. AH is very clearly a psychopath. She ticks every single bit of the Hare checklist. Psychopaths are diagnosed narcissists, which is a personality disorder. Again, not an illness. Just be aware of the facts when talking about mentally ill people. Theeres enough stigma or is.
@@facelesstunes8608 You really should know who and what your talking about as well!! I've lived with these people my ENTIRE life. They are mentally unwell! It is a chemical imbalance in their brain. I have been to enough doctors with my daughter to have learned. Also, don't be so fast to attack a person because they are not saying things as LITERAL as you would like them to. People are entitled to speak and use what words they FEEL as they are talking about something personal they have dealt with or went through!!
She emphasized how often he would pass out. Gave her a lot of free time to grab his phone and further try to damage him. His addiction was exacerbated by her cruelty, mockery and agenda to destroy him. It's her turn to endure mockery and disgust. Unlike him, she deserves it.
Or maybe her cruelty was exacerbated by his addiction.
Are you speculating Amber knew Johnny's phone PIN? What's your evidence, if any?
@@GoLakers3900 yes because a spouse couldn't grab an active phone after someone passed out that they were actively trying to blackmail.
@@catherineo8689 Lol, sure. "It's his fault I was cruel and abusive"
How does that sound to you? Sounds like an abuser to me.
@@catherineo8689 lol so it’s okay to abuse someone who’s going through a phase of addiction? Lol good luck to you in life
The most damning evidence they have against him are some random quotes and text messages. Actions speak louder than words and anyone can say anything over text, especially under the influence of drugs or alcohol.
On a side note I love all of Johnny's ties.
Someone TEXTED HIM . INCOMING MESSAGE
Exactly doesn't prove anything
Someone else could have easily texted from his phone.
@@lizgee5331 Apparently they're not even from his phone. They forgot to redact the number when they first showed them to Depp and people watching traced it and apparently found the owner.
The more this unfolds the more I’m convinced she auditions for Gone Girl and decided she would do it in real life since she didn’t get the part. Bc this is clearly a methodical plan on her end. She took pictures and recorded things, set up witnesses and therapists. You have to be deeply disturbed to do this to someone.
I hated Rottenborn not letting him ever finish a sentence, but Johnny gave it right back to him
All those messages were incoming, not outgoing messages. He didnt send them. That's why there is a direction label above the message. If he sent it, it would say outgoing.
Hope the jury notices this
Also it just says him. and the lawyer said that him refers to Johnny lol like wtf.
@@guyferrari1841 yeah him is referred to jd. And her is referred to niki minaj
Great point
@popcornedplanet do something lol
She is a disgrace!! She's probably the one that wrote the text messages from his phone while he was passed out. You can tell that's the kind of person she is, all about herself!!!! The lawyer drilling Johnny is downright rude, won't let him get any words in!!!
Look at that text message again, it says "incoming" that means somebody (probably her) sent it to Johnny's phone!
See the text direction man it's says incoming not outgoing. They're miss representing in front of the jury.
I loved the...."I was in great pain....I could have asked for a teddy bear!"
"you did read that right, yes" 🤣
They're "INCOMING" messages, not "SENT" messages. Do they think Johnny's lawyers and the jury won't notice that?
It says incoming because we are looking at the messages as sent from his personal assistant Me. Deuters phone. They were incoming to his assistant and sent by Mr. Depp. Btw Mr. Depp’s team submitted these texts to the court.
@@rocketshortsmango1905 it was requested by Heards team. When Depp's team requested Heards texts to be submitted Heards team denied it. Probably the only smart thing they've done.
@@rocketshortsmango1905 nope. The lawyer clearly said they were from Johnny to his assistant. He LIED. They are incoming to Johnny's phone.
@@Dawn2Dusk23 yes they were from Johnny To his assistant - As seen from his assistants phone. Because we are looking at this from the assistance phone they are incoming to his assistant but sent by Johnny. So they are incoming to the assistant.
@@Dawn2Dusk23 No, they didn't lie, actually. These texts originated from Johnny Depp's phone, and neither he nor his team are disputing this. Johnny is only disputing whether he typed them himself or someone else sent them _from_ his phone.
I promise you, if these were texts that someone sent _to_ Johnny Depp's phone originally, A. Johnny and his team would quickly discern that and point it out, and B. Heard's team would never submit them as evidence, because the absurdity of the lie would quickly be revealed, and it would end their case on the spot. They're bungling lawyers on her side, but they're not insane, lol.
God bless him! I hate he is having to go through this to prove he did not physically abuse Amber.
This is his lawsuit, he’s suing her not the other way around. You can hate it, but this is what he said, and his words are truly as he said “grotesque”.
To prove you DIDN'T abuse someone is beyond the possible. And unnecessary, as usually/in many countries it's the accuser who has to prove his claims. Noone would accuse sb else of < not having abused>... 👀
@@Nikita-zo4gp this whole case is to prove that he DIDN’T abuse her and that it’s all a lie. This whole lawsuit that HE sued her for is about proving that he didn’t abuse her. So are you saying that he brought about a lawsuit that was impossible for him to win because he wanted to spend six weeks in court and months preparing?
He is the accuser in this case he is accusing her of lying about him abusing her so he has to prove his case that he didn’t ever abuse her. And let me say this one more time He. Is. Suing. Her.
@@rocketshortsmango1905 Temper, temper. You don't get it all.
@@Nikita-zo4gp Which is why he is an idiot for bringing this to court.
Let him answer the question
She is always angry🤣🤣