@@mikehawk8276 Well, Ringo was needed for Golden Slumbers, John wasn't, only John was needed to record Julia and only George to record Within You Without You
Absolutely. A doleful, sombre, narrative accompanied by evocative lyrics and desperate, almost urgent strings---it's a bit haunting and painful: a true classic.
A pop masterpiece. A powerfully poignant story told, with amazing lyrics and a wonderful arrangement, in two minutes. The urgent, plaintive strings take this song to level far above most others.
I am 9 years late but I ADORE this song, I really admire the way he tells the story, thank you sir Paul for paving the way for young songwriters like me!
When I was a little p of a girl my teacher who was a guitar playing non habit nun played this very song for us and I absolutely fell in love with this beautiful dark song. I was in the fourth grade and she was an amazing teacher. 😍😘
This song is empathy manifested into sound. I could be mistaken, but I am fairly certain the lyrics were inspired as simply as observing someone from afar and imagining what there life was, is and could be.
Nice to see a lefty playing the guitar and really never noticed until now that Paul does play left handed and I'm right handed but have always played left handed don't know why but can't play right handed.
No good reaaon for anybody else trying to repage this song. this is exactly the way it should always be done: a good, powerfull strings orchestra, and Paul Mcartney. any other invention ia useless.
Comrade JulyN78 - The Party™ has issued initiatives to completely break down society and degrade culture so the state can take total control. This will require everyone to hand in any 70s rock albums by white artists. Despite most rock being ideologically beneficial compositions, the band members themselves must be photoshopped less white - before being erased from the Collective Consciousness - particularly Led Zeppelin, Jethro Tull and Yes. Citizens will then have their albums replaced with Bruno Mars, Rihanna and Linda Ronstadt, as well as Islamic Progressive music & Rage against the Machine. MTV will no longer tolerate bands acting "white" by singing in English correctly, having above average tunes, playing their own instruments or using intelligent lyrics. Bourgeois values and the memory of them must be erased from the Collective Consciousness with the help of historical revisionism in the academia, news media, and the Party's branches in the entertainment sector. The proletariat will then undergo re-education and be released from ungood thoughts, by instilling a culture of materialism, physical beauty, sex and financial success without effort or practical ability.
I know it's sacrilege to say this, but I wish McCartney would write a an extended 4-5 minute version of this. It always feels like it ends too soon, which is obviously part of the appeal (it always leaves you wanting more). But it would feel like such a release to listen to this song, at least once, without having that final feeling of slight disappointment.
When you hear good music growing up it never leaves you 56 now loved the music of Mr Lennon and Mr McCartney since I was in the womb , somehow I don't think later stuff will have the same effect ? I think we have been rather lucky ?
Ah, look at all the lonely people Ah, look at all the lonely people Eleanor Rigby Picks up the rice in the church where a wedding has been Lives in a dream Waits at the window Wearing the face that she keeps in a jar by the door Who is it for? All the lonely people Where do they all come from? All the lonely people Where do they all belong? Father McKenzie Writing the words of a sermon that no one will hear No one comes near Look at him working Darning his socks in the night when there's nobody there What does he care? All the lonely people Where do they all come from? All the lonely people Where do they all belong? Ah, look at all the lonely people Ah, look at all the lonely people Eleanor Rigby Died in the church and was buried along with her name Nobody came Father McKenzie Wiping the dirt from his hands as he walks from the grave No one was saved All the lonely people (ah, look at all the lonely people) Where do they all come from? All the lonely people (ah, look at all the lonely people) Where do they all belong?
Lyrics by John Lennon, music by George Martin and Paul McCartney. Chorus by Harrison. Why didn't they include demo of Eleanor Rigby in the upcoming Revolver 2022 re-release? Paul didn't want the truth to come out?
Eleanor Rigby PAUL Mc CARTNEY - tradução Ah, olhe todas essas pessoas solitárias! Ah, olhe todas essas pessoas solitárias! Eleanor Rigby Recolhe o arroz em uma igreja onde aconteceu um casamento Vive em um sonho, espera na janela Usando uma máscara que guarda em um jarro ao lado da porta Para quem será? Todas as pessoas solitárias De onde todas elas vêm? Todas as pessoas solitárias De onde todas elas são? Padre McKenzie Escrevendo as palavras de um sermão que ninguém ouvirá Ninguém se aproxima, vejam ele trabalhando Remendando o buraco em suas meias à noite quando não há ninguém por perto E com o que ele se importa? Todas as pessoas solitárias De onde todas elas vêm? Todas as pessoas solitárias De onde todas elas são? Ah, olhe todas essas pessoas solitárias! Ah, olhe todas essas pessoas solitárias! Eleanor Rigby Morreu na igreja e foi enterrada junto com o nome de sua família Ninguém apareceu Padre McKenzie Limpando a sujeira de suas mãos enquanto se afasta do túmulo Ninguém foi salvo Todas as pessoas solitárias (ah, olhe todas essas pessoas solitárias!) De onde todas elas vêm? Todas as pessoas solitárias (ah, olhe todas essas pessoas solitárias!) De onde todas elas são?
I don't know why the first violins are slurring at 0:22. Why not stay faithful to the original? And the descending chromatic figure in the violas is very quiet in the mix. And why is Paul playing the guitar in this?
Idk why they slurred and idk why they mixed it the way they did and idk why Paul is playing the guitar, but it really doesnt matter that much, if Paul was fine with it why shouldn't we be?
Paul already had the chords on piano. George did an amazing job but he just had to transpose the chords to strings. Also Paul was heavily involved in the process and even suggested it to be played “dry” (without vibrato), which adds to its greatness.
100 years from now people will look back at the Beatles and they will be in the same class as Mozart and Beethoven, musical geniuses.
Absolutely
Nope.
@@tarikn.g.dabbous3323 scram
we re already doing it now
@willyboose ur a goof
Note that this song has zero percussion. The beat, rhythm and drama are provided solely by the staccato of the string instruments.
The original recording doesn't have guitar and keyboards either. It is just a 9 piece string ensemble and the voices of Paul, John and George.
Who needs Ringo
Amazing
Paul is Mozart and Vivaldi of the modern time
@@mikehawk8276 Well, Ringo was needed for Golden Slumbers, John wasn't, only John was needed to record Julia and only George to record Within You Without You
I'm probably not far from the truth if i regard this as one of his 5 best songs ever.
Definitely my favorite song
One of the Best songs ever
Absolutely. A doleful, sombre, narrative accompanied by evocative lyrics and desperate, almost urgent strings---it's a bit haunting and painful: a true classic.
A jewel
A pop masterpiece. A powerfully poignant story told, with amazing lyrics and a wonderful arrangement, in two minutes. The urgent, plaintive strings take this song to level far above most others.
I am 9 years late but I ADORE this song, I really admire the way he tells the story, thank you sir Paul for paving the way for young songwriters like me!
If this song isn’t played at my funeral, i am not going.
I do prefer Sinatra's MY WAY...
I do prefer Sinatra's MY WAY...
When I read this I said to myself. That's funny.
@@gillehrer2824 Lame, everyone uses it.
NJDEVIL91923 what it your funeral is on the morning like at dark and then it’s sunrise and they play here comes the sun
The brilliance of McCartney and Martin.
this song is literally my favourite EVER
One of my friends passed away Thursday and I feel so sad and alone!
Best wishes from the future - I hope you are happier now.
Zo mooi met dat orkest en zangers erbij. Echt prachtig!
Laten we nog zo lang mogelijk van Paul genieten!
When I was a little p of a girl my teacher who was a guitar playing non habit nun played this very song for us and I absolutely fell in love with this beautiful dark song. I was in the fourth grade and she was an amazing teacher. 😍😘
Excellent, and glory to George Martin in Heaven for guiding the Beatles to pen beautiful songs like this.
This is a never dying song for ever! Hope future world will interprete BEATLES!
The best live version of this song
I love this song because everyone deep inside are lonely!
He nailed it... as good as it ever was
what a sad song 😥 I feel lonely
Im 27 , lonely too.
Jeffrey Sweetland you’re not lonely, I’m here with you 😊
Where do you both belong...?
@@alxl.929 hahahaha, yeah that's the question, we come from our Ego.
This is the saddest song I have heard in my life we used to sing this in music class
I love it! The strings orchestra just really brings it out and I love Paul McCartney's voice!
Sir Paul McCartney, simply unique....
beatles , MAGICIANS !!!!! SAY NOTHING JUST STAY SILENCE
So many, many beautiful songs Paul had left for us...an incredible legacy...
One of my favorite song. Thanks Paul.❤
Wow! So awesome
This song is empathy manifested into sound.
I could be mistaken, but I am fairly certain the lyrics were inspired as simply as observing someone from afar and imagining what there life was, is and could be.
In other words: This is a perfect song.
What a masterpiece !
Изумительно
How did he write such a magnificent song at such a young age . Amazing ! ✌️☮️
Amazing
Lovely, fantastic, moving!
This will be my wedding song
God, I hope not. I wish you well and long happiness.
He's still got it 👍🏻 ❤️❤️❤️
My favorite song ever i love this song and Paul his vocals very good Lennon and McCartney ❤❤❤❤❤
Nice to see a lefty playing the guitar and really never noticed until now that Paul does play left handed and I'm right handed but have always played left handed don't know why but can't play right handed.
He wrote and sang this song 40 years ago. Thank you
More like 55 years ago
@@leonardwashington6456 it was in 2007.
Masterpiece
Just fabulous Paul! Paul we Love You!
Wow how deep is his voice now!?Still got the voice of an angel though.his voice is the type that never get boring 😀👌🏻
simply fantastic
and SUPERB accompaniment
Wonderful experience
THANK YOU KINDLY‼️
🥂💫
👊🔥
🪖
Demais....é uma satisfação muito grande presenciar o talento musical do Paul McCartney
Love this song!
What amazes me is Paul could write such a dour song and not be a miserable person in everyday life.
Inmortal y eterna
Magistral
This song as well as A day in the life, burns all the competitors of the Beatles
My song
You just can't get over how wonderful Paul and the BEATLES WERE AND ARE XXXXXXXX
This is a song about ghosts - lost souls- and the loss of spirituality in the modern era
There is no song better
These people sing better than people singing live in the present day!
bruh this was 2007, this was the present day
bruh this was 2007, this was the present day
@@2000andhate no
Not even close
Legend
Genius
I'm speechless!
Sehr gut!
EXCELENTE
THE WORLD SPCAIL BEATLES BAND EVER WHAT EVER HAPPEN TO THEM ALWAYS BE IN PEOPLES HEART❤ AND THEIR MUSIC NEVER DIES ❤🎸🎸🎸🥁
Сам себе ставлю лайк-ИЗУМИТЕЛЬНО❤
No good reaaon for anybody else trying to repage this song. this is exactly the way it should always be done: a good, powerfull strings orchestra, and Paul Mcartney. any other invention ia useless.
+JulyN78 Yes July !:)
I'm fvcking lonely
Comrade JulyN78 - The Party™ has issued initiatives to completely break down society and degrade culture so the state can take total control. This will require everyone to hand in any 70s rock albums by white artists.
Despite most rock being ideologically beneficial compositions, the band members themselves must be photoshopped less white - before being erased from the Collective Consciousness - particularly Led Zeppelin, Jethro Tull and Yes.
Citizens will then have their albums replaced with Bruno Mars, Rihanna and Linda Ronstadt, as well as Islamic Progressive music & Rage against the Machine.
MTV will no longer tolerate bands acting "white" by singing in English correctly, having above average tunes, playing their own instruments or using intelligent lyrics. Bourgeois values and the memory of them must be erased from the Collective Consciousness with the help of historical revisionism in the academia, news media, and the Party's branches in the entertainment sector.
The proletariat will then undergo re-education and be released from ungood thoughts, by instilling a culture of materialism, physical beauty, sex and financial success without effort or practical ability.
@@kayharker712 i think you've taken too many psychs my man
@@kayharker712 What the actual FUCK are you going on about?
2:00 I love how violent sounding the strings become.
It’s the ultimate funeral song
Superb
Es una canción hermosa.
I so love this song x
This is amazing
Amo!
Que coisa mais linda!
Paul is said to be worth 1.2 billion, I can't even wrap my mind around.
I know it's sacrilege to say this, but I wish McCartney would write a an extended 4-5 minute version of this. It always feels like it ends too soon, which is obviously part of the appeal (it always leaves you wanting more). But it would feel like such a release to listen to this song, at least once, without having that final feeling of slight disappointment.
I'm on a cloud to Heaven
When you hear good music growing up it never leaves you 56 now loved the music of Mr Lennon and Mr McCartney since I was in the womb , somehow I don't think later stuff will have the same effect ? I think we have been rather lucky ?
This song is for ALL the lonely people...
Thank you. Now that I am very old, loneliness is my constant companion.
Ah, look at all the lonely people
Ah, look at all the lonely people
Eleanor Rigby
Picks up the rice in the church where a wedding has been
Lives in a dream
Waits at the window
Wearing the face that she keeps in a jar by the door
Who is it for?
All the lonely people
Where do they all come from?
All the lonely people
Where do they all belong?
Father McKenzie
Writing the words of a sermon that no one will hear
No one comes near
Look at him working
Darning his socks in the night when there's nobody there
What does he care?
All the lonely people
Where do they all come from?
All the lonely people
Where do they all belong?
Ah, look at all the lonely people
Ah, look at all the lonely people
Eleanor Rigby
Died in the church and was buried along with her name
Nobody came
Father McKenzie
Wiping the dirt from his hands as he walks from the grave
No one was saved
All the lonely people (ah, look at all the lonely people)
Where do they all come from?
All the lonely people (ah, look at all the lonely people)
Where do they all belong?
Exactly the way the song should be played live every time. Not having the orchestra does it no justice whatsoever
great job!!
Lyrics by John Lennon, music by George Martin and Paul McCartney. Chorus by Harrison. Why didn't they include demo of Eleanor Rigby in the upcoming Revolver 2022 re-release? Paul didn't want the truth to come out?
Real music none of this modern pop crap. This is talent and he wrote this in his twenties.
Nice song
Beautiful song ! I suggest to whoever will read my comment, to search in internet the version played by The Zoot
ИЗУМИТЕЛЬНО.
0:36 it looks like if he wanted to kill paul
Eleanor Rigby PAUL Mc CARTNEY - tradução
Ah, olhe todas essas pessoas solitárias!
Ah, olhe todas essas pessoas solitárias!
Eleanor Rigby
Recolhe o arroz em uma igreja onde aconteceu um casamento
Vive em um sonho, espera na janela
Usando uma máscara que guarda em um jarro ao lado da porta
Para quem será?
Todas as pessoas solitárias
De onde todas elas vêm?
Todas as pessoas solitárias
De onde todas elas são?
Padre McKenzie
Escrevendo as palavras de um sermão que ninguém ouvirá
Ninguém se aproxima, vejam ele trabalhando
Remendando o buraco em suas meias à noite quando não há ninguém por perto
E com o que ele se importa?
Todas as pessoas solitárias
De onde todas elas vêm?
Todas as pessoas solitárias
De onde todas elas são?
Ah, olhe todas essas pessoas solitárias!
Ah, olhe todas essas pessoas solitárias!
Eleanor Rigby
Morreu na igreja e foi enterrada junto com o nome de sua família
Ninguém apareceu
Padre McKenzie
Limpando a sujeira de suas mãos enquanto se afasta do túmulo
Ninguém foi salvo
Todas as pessoas solitárias (ah, olhe todas essas pessoas solitárias!)
De onde todas elas vêm?
Todas as pessoas solitárias (ah, olhe todas essas pessoas solitárias!)
De onde todas elas são?
This is the saddest song I ever heard in my life we sang this song in 6th grade music class
Спасибо Господи , что я жил. К в 60 х и я все это слушал на бобинах р нас виниле такого качества которое будет к только очень у финансовых богачей.
I think you've got a bad luck, this man is not Paul, he is Billy shepherd,don' you know?
Dios se reencarno
ДА🎉
This Backing Vocals job description: singing with sir Paul Macartney. How much cooler can a job be?
Класс.
Absolute fucking hammer blow!
all spectators were singing at that moment.. 100%..
This is similar to Kansas' version, which I think is the best version of this song.
Sir Paul … una Sinfonia immortale in poco più di due minuti , che altro aggiungere ?
The delay between audio and video always mucks with me
ne kadar yaylı olursa olsun bana hep az geliyor bir türlü yetmiyor,
I don't know why the first violins are slurring at 0:22. Why not stay faithful to the original? And the descending chromatic figure in the violas is very quiet in the mix. And why is Paul playing the guitar in this?
Idk why they slurred and idk why they mixed it the way they did and idk why Paul is playing the guitar, but it really doesnt matter that much, if Paul was fine with it why shouldn't we be?
Do caralho!
too much f. talent in beatles!!
Billy Shears?
ta bien
George Martin should be credited with most of the orchestral arrangement as Paul was not there yet. Masterpiece!
Paul already had the chords on piano. George did an amazing job but he just had to transpose the chords to strings. Also Paul was heavily involved in the process and even suggested it to be played “dry” (without vibrato), which adds to its greatness.
Experimental, a bit underground. Better bass Guitar performance than voice.
Who really wrote this song? the most dominant.
nadie habla español T
00:36 Dats Tobias Sammet? Lol