Scientific Evidence for Plato's ATLANTIS - Randall Carlson's Research 101
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 июл 2024
- Hey Hunters,
I sat through hours and hours of Randall's RUclips to collate together a concise run through of the data he uses to back up the plausibility of Plato's Atlantis. I do recommend watching his stuff as I couldn't fit it all in but heres the main points for you to show your mum.
Randall's research can be found in his series here - • Randall Carlson Podcas...
#Atlantis #RandallCarlson #Plato
My grandma is from the Azores (Sao Miguel). She used to tell me a story growing up about Azores having another island. She said that explorers had loaded a boat with sheep, goats and cows. They left them all on the island and went back to the mainland to collect more supplies. When they returned, the island had sunk, never to be seen again.
Nice my family is from sao Jorge
@@zkkauffm9140 Nice ... mine is eclectic, but I can tie my shoe laces and wave bye-bye. So?
Azores are not the mountain tops of Atlantis
@@johnhough4445 Can you chew gum at the same time and not fall over your own feet?
@@zkkauffm9140
Nice, my family is from Atlantis.
Great job Jahannah.
@Luke C Atlantean shrimp
@Luke C More a colleague congratulating another on a job well done.
Yo Brien. Nice job finding those petroglyphs! Any idea what to call them?
Yes. And great appearance and great clarity. I've seen some bad videos in this aspect. Especially concerning ancient Egypt.
You sure?
a reason to ponder - The Sumerians spoke a language isolate suggesting they arrived from elsewhere around 10000 BCE . They brought city design technology , a written language , agriculture and irrigation , a math system and most importantly ( for me anyway ) 30 recipes for beer - but all hidden in plain sight , firmly recommend Irving Finkel youtube video's including the oldest version of the Ark with instructions on how to build one
I’ve seen a few of your videos now. I just wanted to say, your delivery is very wonderful, you have many different quarky things you put into the video, that make me surprise you don’t have even more subscribers to your channel. You’re brilliant at making videos, thank you for being you!
Really enjoyed that Jahannah. Azores landmass certainly needs closer study. Great job! 👍
Thanks Matt, I’m baffled why there isn’t more studies to address these findings. Too many findings to just ignore.
@@FunnyOldeWorld Being at the junction of 3 plate boundaries right on the mid-Atlantic ridge means it’s not an ideal place to have a civilisation because it would be a very seismically active and unstable place to live - probably always would have been. So that’s probably why it gets less attention and less consideration. But, a civilisation could have adapted to the environment - built polygonal masonry structures to withstand earthquakes, a volcanic soil would be great for agriculture and the sea was a perfect defence... so, it does deserve a closer look. Whenever I see a video like this it makes me want to research it further!
@@FunnyOldeWorld Hello Johanna ❣From Los Angeles California USA 🇺🇸. The glacial melt is part of it, would ocean would rise. Though, I did mention part of the sinking, the tectonic plate movements are also part of it. The part you may have missed, and science or historians may have missed is the other reason they can't find the remnants of the stone structures. The Sahara 🇪🇭 Desert 🏜 sand in case you never knew this: the sand travels in the Jetstream from Africa to Cuba 🇨🇺 Gulf of Mexico, as well as Florida 🇺🇸 and Georgia, and sometimes parts of the Atlantic coastline. You can see satellite footage or images of this happening, and it occurred 2 to 3 days ago. What am I getting to this: the results of thousands of years the sand, and dead sea life covering (Fossils) the once ago Atlantis Island. Let me know what you think
🙋👍❣
Hello ....Atlantis was found in the Pegasus Galaxy. I saw it on TV.....lol Great Video
Either of you guys seen any good evidence about the structures found off the coast of cuba?
No one believed Platos city of Troy was real either until they found it.
True,
Homer's city of Troy
@@jamesaron1967 true
Homer was writing a history, about 800 years after the events. Also he is not the only writer to mention Troy.
@@mattheweagles5123
You are all missing the point,
It was considered fiction until discovered as fact,
It doesn't matter who mentioned it, only that people didn't believe it to be true and was proven to be fact,
My new favorite channel 🙌 I can actually watch this with my son (4 years young)and not have to worry about bad language, inappropriate topics, etc.. Thank You so much *Palatka, Florida* 🙏
I love the way you put it all together. In 1978, I took a class in Plate Tectonics from Sir Edward Bullard at UCSD where I was majoring in Applied Physics. He and Ewing, who you mentioned, founded Marine Geophysics. Even he mentioned some of the anomalies you pointed out as being troubling when he and his fellows were mapping the Mid Atlantic ridge and putting together the theory of continental drift.
Randall Carlson’s sacred math/geometry was mind blowing! Love hearing him and Graham Hancock talk is amazing
Indeed. I found the bit on how ancient measurements align with their latitude fascinating
The correlations between measurements and their relationship with physical measurements of the Earth is too coincidental. And there is no such thing as coincidence, I believe, there are only misunderstood relationships. The use of 'true' compass directions. The alignment with stars that happen only once in history. The methods of construction. There was a very thought provoking documentary called The Great Pyramid K2019 which is well worth watching.
dandy Randy is blind to the obvious ... let me explain how blind he is ... clearly two ideas like the 'right triangle theorem' and 'squaring the circle' are vital to 'geometry' and 'sacred geometry' (Plato did offer that 'geometry will draw the soul toward the truth') ... however does dandy Randy ever ever ever offer the obvious? Which is *the FACT that the 12,000+ year old CHIRAL swastika idea IS the right triangle theorem incognito ... along with being an ancient method of trying to solve 'squaring the circle' puzzle.* PhDUHs will be awarded posthumously in the future
@@marklogsdon7437 the author/director Fehmi Krasniqi of that video/theory is full of shit IF you have truly studied all the theories on the Great Pyramid you would notice the mistakes he makes
would you mind sharing if there is a video or podcast episode you're referring to specifically?
Enjoyed the chat. The lost island of Atlantis is the great mystery of Pre-History, The Egyptian and Mayan text should be considered too. They didn't add a moral tale and embellish the story. But both clearly reflect what Plato said, an island in the ocean sank (covered by rising water) and was not seen again.
lgnd
The Immense weight of water could easily push down against one side of a crustal plate, changing everything. (Hy-Brasil)
Jahannah or Ddendyl? This is a Gilligan's Island question. As a disciple of the Electric Universe Theory, there is no doubt about Atlantis.
@@philippjulien8549 LOL. Ddendyl is a friend who is married to a nice woman who I know also. Real tough to think of her or look at her in any other way than just a good friend. Jahannah seems really smart and is entertaining to listen too. All I will say.
@John Brennan Cool.
I only recently found your channel - I enjoy your animated delivery and how you translate much of it to easier terms. Keep it up!
The BIGGEST mistake history and geography make is trying to overlay human history on the current topography when it was obviously completely different.
My thoughts exactly
+ bending history into our perspective and historical timeline in religious, social, political, economical and even scientific terms. We tend to act asif little existed before our current status quo. This screwed up putting all the pieces together... and adapting history to new facts found is out of the question because it doesn't help or fit our current narrative.
@@esteban80 I would argue that religion is the primary factor in that list. ruclips.net/channel/UCvHqXK_Hz79tjqRosK4tWYA
Agreed. I also think another mistake we make is trying to equate our "civilisation" with the ancients. We are a material society where what you own is almost what defines you, whether it's the latest car or the degree that you got. Said like Forrest Gump - "life is like a shit sandwich, the more bread you got, the less shit you eat"
Civilisation to me is a group of people in an area working together to look after the group, so everyone does their part for the community in their own way and there is food and shelter for all.
That they had advanced technology is well known since we today cannot build the things they did. Only the type of technology is a mystery.
Maybe they didn't have or need all the "stuff" we hold up as the pinnacle of evolution, like plastic, maybe they were highly spiritual and didn't care for material things.
Maybe they didn't need to burn fossil fuels for electricity -- I've seen vids of supposed ancient nuclear power generators, and the pyramids (and other ancient sites) are said to have something to do with energy (whether spiritual or electric is still unclear)
Or perhaps any metal there was rusted away in the 9000+ years since the catastrophe. Then again, maybe some things made it -- like the antikythera mechanism.
The biggest mistake is mankind thinking it knows "anything" about the planet we live on. Save for high flow eruptions or massive pole accumulations that could add uneven weight, I think the planet is, for the most, part balanced on its axis. While you are correct that everything is different, different does not mean untraceable. If you are unfamiliar with Kircher's map, look it up, flip it around and look at the two western islands. Now go on en-gb.topographic-maps and take a look at Newfoundland and everything east of the Hudson and south of the St. Lawrence. They were pinched by Atlantis when it collided with the east coast giving it the distinct shape it has now vs the rounded shape depicted in every ancient map. If you want to know what the east coast originally looked like look at the east coast of Asia. Just think of North and South Korea as Florida and the rest should pop into view for ya.
When you consider that a majority of the world"s population was and still is located on the coasts, a global deluge easily could have wiped out most of pre-historical sites and put them several hundred meters under water today. I think we need to be looking just offshore of continents and islands for more of our past.
There were actually a minimum of 4 great deluges. In Critias it is written "Now the city in those days was arranged on this wise. In the first place the Acropolis was not as now. For the fact is that a single night of excessive rain washed away the earth and laid bare the rock; at the same time there were earthquakes, and then occurred the extraordinary inundation, which was the third before the great destruction of Deucalion". I have been working a little on a timeline for past events (fire, water, quakes etc.). If one can work with only common sense and a general understanding of forensics when using bathymetric, topographic, and google earth viewers, it becomes actually quite easy to see that what happened in the Atlantic calls into question just about "everything" we think we know about this planet.
Ya that is the logic of it,and ofc other places that had a massive hight shift in that time.
You could search for the term: “doggerland”. It’s about a land mass between the Netherlands and great Britain which is now underneath sea level but was actually above it in prehistoric times and they are fiding cool little artefacts in this area now and then.
If the land became exposed to the tide it wouldn’t take long at all to chisel away the buildings until it was smooth stone
Blame it on the glaciers- their demand for water denuded the world oceans by hundreds of feet. The Mediterranean was at some point cut off from the Atlantic and almost dried up, as evidenced by the massive layers of salt beneath the current bottom; still actively mined.
Just found and watched your video after watching Randall Carlson’s rebuttal to some of the comments on your video (he gave positive feedback to your efforts and was a cheerleader of sorts). I also watched most of the 10 hours of his work. You did an excellent job of condensing his work!:). I love topics that fundamentally change the typical mainstream narrative of history, geology, archaeology, physics… most of these topics diverged from mainstream support biblical writings (or the other way too). The beauty of science is it’s (true science)ability to report facts and possible conclusions that may change based on further information. Thank you, keep it up. God Bless you
The beauty of Science is that it is self-correcting. The shame of carlson is that he sticks to his lies in the face of 100% contradictory evidence.
Love the synopsis! Just discovered your channel. Can’t wait to go back and dig through your previous work!
I've always loved the mystery of Atlantis, and I think you do a great job telling it. I've heard a lot of people talk about the Younger Dryas flood, but I hadn't heard anyone get into the details of how it would effect tectonic plates. Great video!
I have become obsessed with these vids! Congrats JJ they are epic. You have reignited my passion for ancient history! Keep on pushing!!!
ruclips.net/video/sBJHvaXAs9Y/видео.html
This is my first episode I love your channel that I have watched. I've been a Randall Carlson follower for years. WELL DONE!!!
I enjoyed (and learned from) your synopsis of the Atlantis presentation and really appreciate that you supported your presentation with additional sources and visual aids. Informative and entertaining! Thanks much 👍
Thank you for bringin up that Atlantis was more than just 1 city. People tend to forget that part.
A successful civilisation could have originated in Southern Spain, spread to a large, clement mid-atlantic island, down the West coast of Africa and on to Meso-america leaving traces in all those areas. To discount the possibly is to close the mind.
It wasn't. a city it was. a Venus Colony ...
@@egroegization
the Atlantic Ridge was the Continent of Agartha (Atlantis)
@John Brennan
263k yrs ago Mu, was submerged in a Earthly Cataclysm ...
2Ethnycities, fled to Hollow Earth to survive,
Japanese an a Polynesian ppl ...
That is was a massive continent which means it couldn't be the azores. Well done on proving carlson to be a complete gonad.
Funny how current science will accept all Plato’s math, science and philosophical concepts as a bedrock for our knowledge. Then we discount his Atlantis documentation pure fiction.
When there's a mythical element involved, the scientific "communities" are generally very dismissive. I.e. Younger Dryas.
So interesting
You are right mate. They are cherry picking the facks to suit their own agenda. So you either believe it or not.
It's not funny. Plato did not "document" Atlantis, nor do scientists refer to him for anything. Plato is a great writer, maybe you should read him rather than spreading garbage.
Well said Gem
New to your channel, so glad I found it. Love everything and anything about ancient civilizations
We live in such great times - here I am eating my late lunch and enjoying a fun, truthful and honest resume of Randal Carlson's work. It so engaging and funny and articulate! On top of it all eloquently presented by a gorgeous lady... What more do you want? Thank you for awesome channel and respect for your hard work in putting all of this together!
Great job! I saw Randall on the Joe Rogan show, I'm sure you know he was singing your praises on how you explained his 10 hours of lecture. I'd love to see you spend a session on the joe rogan show and get the 3+ hour time that Joe does with guests on this passionate subject he and so many others have. 😎👍 and again, you have explained your points, perfectly. WOW! .. thank you
This channel is amazing, and the very easy way she explains it is great, it makes it very easy to understand.
Well done. I've heard a lot of theories about Atlantis, but your research has brought new information to my attention, and, like you say, this location is indeed plausible.
Love your channel... love your videos, and enthusiasm... I could listen to you for hours...!! Thanks for sharing your research and knowledge... ❤
Excellent presentation. Your beauty and the beauty of your delivery are captivating. Keep up the great work! Will reccomend your channel to others!
I've seen everything Randell, excellent recitation. I enjoy your videos, and I especially enjoy your enthusiasm. Keep the faith and the fun. 👍👏
Excellent, Jahannah, your understanding of the extremely complicated transition from the Pleistocene into the Younger Dryas is absolutely wonderful. It is an enormously complicated process, both geologically, hydrostatically, and climactically that many of us are trying to puzzle together. I want to welcome you to the group of truth-seekers who are attempting to recover our lost history by scientifically investigating any and all shreds of evidence that can lead us to a clearer understanding of our true history. Primarily, because history repeats itself and through knowledge and wisdom hopefully, we can avoid the errors of our ancestors.
My first time viewing your channel and really enjoyed it; love your passion and delivery, well done. I am fascinated by ancient history and especially anything to do with Atlantis; Plato's writings and a number of other historical sources hold an abundance of intriguing clues about Atlantis and appreciate you pulling together a very good synopsis of the mid-Atlantic ridge investigations. All the very best...again, love the passion ... keep searching.
Found your channel yesterday. I'm hooked. Nice seeing someone else that is as passionate about as I. Cheers from Texas mlad.
Superb work, I say.
Your ability to get to the essence of Randall's findings, is rare, and needed.
Thank you, Jahannah.
He has so much more!!! Just trying to get the basics
@@FunnyOldeWorld I've been a follower of Randell and his various endeavors for well over a decade.
It will prove for you to be a great adventure. His early interests in geology and mine have a common
genesis ... My early stomping grounds also included the ancient glacial boundries ~ in Wisconsin.
I can do it in one sentence. Total bollocks.
Well, aren't you the clever one.
Love this! It’s such an intriguing hypothesis. I agree too that it’s not about finding remains of a super technological society but one that fostered high functioning civilizations like Egypt that came later or were the remnants of an Atlantean culture.
They could have been progressing simultaneously, or Egypt was the outer extent of the culture at least, before the western civilization collapsed..
Saw you on Kosmographia and took Randal's recommendation/link to your wonderful podcast which I genuinely enjoyed, thank you.
This is an awesome video. I could chill and watch all day!
Three things, you may already have taken on board, Jahannah:
1 The Berbers of North Africa have an unusual blood group.
2 The Dogon tribe of Africa had advanced knowledge of Sirius' twin.
3 Plato's mention of Elephants is far more likely applicable to an Africa neighbour than to Santorini.
Elephants have lived all over the globe. Gomphotheres lived in North America around 13,000 years ago.
The Basque people also have an unusual blood group and there are some interesting astronomical traditions all over Europe. Maybe this all points to Atlantis truly being widespread/somewhat global
The Dogon knowledge has nothing to do with Sirius. Unfortunately most people believe this disinformation. The do no research so just believe the loudest voice. If anyone did the research I did they would know (maybe not). The Dogon celebrations relate to the position of the Sun the Earth Jupiter and Saturn. There would be those who know and probably they are also responsible for the disinformation. Anyone else know what happened on the original start date. Only those who have seen my research. Exploring History on facebook.
What you alluded to when talking about the younger dryas cataclysm was that before the Ice sheets melted the Oceans were 400ft lower than today. So anything that is currently less than 400ft below the ocean surface would have been above it during the ice age.
Correct. One of those is the "mythical" island of Hy-Brasil.
actually closer to 2miles ...
10.5k yrs ago the Atlantic Ridge was well above water ...
The pyramid discovered, on the seafloor near Azores is just over 40mtres below the surface ...
the average depth of the Atlantic Ocean, from the top of the Atlantic Ridge, 1.5 miles to less than a quarter mile ...
@@gordonpeacman2126 There's literally no evidence whatsoever to back your claims.
You have to consider that all of the major terrain features on the ocean floor have been mapped though, and there are no Islands below the surface out in the Atlantic that would qualify until you get to the Azores or the Canary Islands.
@@slappy8941 isostatic depression & rebound at the azores. Not islands, but seamounts.
You did a wonderful job, very well explained. Look forward to watching more of your videos
Great video! Love Randall Carlson’s work and you are a pleasure to watch present… Keep up the great work!! 💯💯
This was like a 5 part series and INCREDIBLY well done! He went out of his way to not make any assumptions and just look at the data. The evidence is staggering.
Curious what your take on it will be
@Luke C insightuful
This is a great video, I’ve been watching Randall and his amazing research for years, ever since he first appeared on Joe Rogan! I really love when Randall and Graham Hancock get together and talk about their shared research, it is all so interesting
I love it when Randall and hopkirk. Get together great viewing.
Same, they're so intelligent, interesting, and clever. Joe Rogan just let's them teach, which I appreciate.
You are so compelling I love your channel and your vivacious energetic humorous delivery of fascinating subjects.
Right away I thought your theories reminded me of bright insight...then realised you're friends. Brilliant, my way of thinking. I'm gonna love this channel .Subbed
that background is from AC Odyssey DLC. I love how they depicted Atlantis!
Yeah it’s amazing 🤩
@@FunnyOldeWorld Have you seen Bright Insight's videos on Atlantis?
@@FunnyOldeWorld Your theory is more than likely correct.
ruclips.net/video/iiXEL70xmzk/видео.html&ab_channel=Suspicious0bservers !!!
I am sure that she has. Jahannah and Jimmy have collaborated before.
@@johnnyrocket4357 If Jahannah has seen them, it would be interesting to hear her views.
Your best video ever. Thank you for summarising Randall Carlson's 10 hours in such an entertaining way. Your quirky enthusiasm is very infectious :)
You mix beauty (presentation), humour & rigorous well referenced scientific historical sources which is a feat !!!!! Very and hugely well done and well presented !! Your doing a great service to humanity with this !! !!!
Thank You 💖 !!!
SIMP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Loved this!! Thanks for citing your research😊❤ please keep these coming!!
Over ten years ago I was determined to find the whereabouts of Atlantis that fit all of the major criteria Plato recorded in detail: Location, the size and specific dimensions as well as physical features described by Plato, which remained after the cataclysm. I studied bathymetric maps of the world's oceans made in the 1970's and found only one place where the main island of Atlantis with the famous circular port city could have been. Even after the Island's cataclysmic demise, enough geological evidence remains as to it's original size and physical features. It is located off the coast of northwest Africa and for thousands of years the remaining mountain tops which surrounded the fertile calderic valley have been referred to as the Isles of the Blessed, or the Isles of the Dead in the West by the Egyptians and others. They remained unoccupied out of respect, until the Portuguese found them in the 1460's green and lush, named them Cape Verde Islands and proceeded to make them sugar plantation and thirsty cotton fields barren. They are sitting on a mega volcanic structure about 355 miles in diameter, shaped like a Bundt cake with a large hole in the middle, now several hundred feet bellow sea level. This used to be a volcanic caldera, the fertile valley matching the length and width provided by Plato, crisscrossed by fresh water canals, surrounded by mountains with steep cliffs reaching down to the Atlantic ocean. This roughly 345 mile long valley sloped down lengthwise north to south, slightly curving to the southwest where the famous circular port city of Atlantis was located. The city comprised of a central island with three circles of water and two of land, itself was about 27 stadia (4.99 km) in diameter and had a large waterway several miles long leading out through a canyon into a bay on the west side of the island. From there ships could use the northeast trades to sail west towards the Caribbean islands and what were referred to as the Ladies of the West, and on to Mesoamerica , then use the Gulf stream and North Atlantic Gyre to sail back to the Azores and Spanish coast, into the Atlantean colonies in the Mediterranean and then back along the West African coast to the Canaries and back to Atlantis port city using the Canary Current. The Atlantean empire was comprised of many islands and coastal colonies in the Mediterranean and on both shores of the Atlantic. It was not a continent but a Kingdom just as large. Not one large island but an Island nation who did not build the walls around the port city's circular land rings in order to keep out invaders, but to keep out the steadily rising sea water. In the end, earthquakes and tsunamis, also a massive calderic collapse and a volcanic eruption near the port city of which there is evidence from 10,000 BCE, Atlantis was devastated and lost beneath the magma, waters and sands of the ocean. This megavolcanic mound sits on top of a vast magma plume or hot spot, and situated right in the middle of Pangaea was the cause of the splitting of that land mass starting 200 million years ago.What became North America ripped away first and drifted to the northwest, leaving the volcanic supper mound in it's present location. The African plate didn't move much but Florida used to be attached to Africa and was between it and the CVI's. The Gulf of Mexico is the hole which remained from where it used to surround Cape Verde Seamount and which developed a new seafloor as it drifted away.
Marie Tharp, a geologist and cartographer, created detailed bathymetric maps of the ocean floor from sonar soundings taken over the years. Later seabed relief maps with clear contrast to show depth and height of features were printed. A spectacular detailed map of our planet's ocean bottoms was published in The Atlas of the Oceans in 1977, Atlantic Bathymetry pgs.114-117,© Paris Match; And in Earth Facts by EARTHBOOKS, 1990, map pgs.18-19,© Hatchette/Guides Bleus.
If you find these maps you will see what the CVI's are sitting on. The less detailed maps don't show this feature, and neither do the satellite images which are blurry and don't reveal what lies beneath the accumulated sediment near the continental shelves or around islands.
Yes! Atlantis was exactly where the Egyptians recorded it as being and all the dimensions and physical details are accurately written down by Plato. We have detailed bathymetric maps now which did not exist at the turn of the 19th century when all the Spiritualists were speculating about this Island. And even today good bathymetric maps are hard to find. The Cape Verde Islands are caught in the center fold of map books or just off the page where Africa is shown. And when you manage to find them on a map, they are only shown as tiny little circles. Atlantis even found, remains an obscured location as it's mountain top remains did for 11,000 years. The Isles of the Blessed, sacred guardians of the entombed Atlantians, where few dared trespass until the greed of the slave traders made them valuable.
My father who was into stories of Atlantis,would of loved this trove scientific literature that’s parsed out that points to it existing. To bad it’s 31 years late!
This little essay deserves more likes
watch "bright insight" about atlatis
The eye of the Sahara
@@marquise7200 Sorry, but the EYE is ten times larger than the measurements Plato said the Egyptians documented.
The capitol port city with it's central island dedicated to Poseidon, and it's three rings of water, two of land, total to 27 stadia (4.99 kilometers) across. The EYE is roughly said to be 48 kilometers in diameter.
I’ve been following Randal for years. He opened my mind to so many exciting things! Thank you for for your dedication to science and discovery! Subscribed!
Meaning he has no credentials and has never produced any research that stands up to scrutiny.
@@drstevej2527 Both are valid concerns of course. However I would posit this, the current "scientific research " we have on early ancient history IS being proven wrong with actual scientific method. As it stands our understanding of true ancient history could be off at least 5 to 10 thousands.
Sadly though when confronted with any evidence that challenges their established chronology of ancient history, all of those various disciplines choose to bury their heads in the sand and just try to ignore what is beginning to take shape before their very eyes.
Personally I would love to see those Sciences be more flexible and actually put more time and resources into researching the possibilities that we may have been off on our understanding and that continuously keeping 19th and early 20th century views regarding history is more of a detriment and misuse of their disciplines.
As to Atlantis, I will simply say this. Plato felt it necessary to write it down. As he also did the City of Troy as well. One has been discovered to be real so far, the other we have yet to locate.
There are a great many things that were recorded back then that we have been told is Myth or Legends. And yet we seem to be finding proof of actual existence in a great many of them. Yes there is obviously some "artistic license " taken in the stories of Plato, that does not mean however that the base of it isn't true. When it comes to history, archeology, and most especially the ancient world, I tend to keep an open mind while also not being gullible either.
Fascinating subject this one is though, and admittedly I'm leery about Atlantis claims. That said, this definitely one of the better presentations. And he does mention. Where each of his pieces of information came from. And most of those were scientific studies, so there is at least something to look at and wonder at least. 😉
@@TheStefan6969
According to whom? Name ONE scholarly body that supports that assertion. Name one scholarly body that supports this claim that our current dating regarding civilization is off by 5000 let alone 10000 years.
There has never been so much as a toothpick found that supports the notion of an Atlantis. If a modern city were abounded today there would be ruins and artifacts that would survive for 50000 years yet nothing from Atlantis has ever been found.
It’s not a coincidence that none of this is being offered by anyone with standing and credentials. It’s exclusively a function of fringe pseudoscientific nonsense.
Claiming that there is evidence of a flat earth theory does not mean that geography is in denial because it rejects these nonsense claims.
@@TheStefan6969 Well said Ian. I appreciate your open mindedness. Have a great day!
@@drstevej2527 spoken like a trained Muppet.
Great stuff! I love Carlson's work to. Been listening to his lectures for 10 years now!
Beautiful and smart!! She has my attention. Sooo glad I found your channel.
How you have not got a million subscribers is beyond me. you make each topic very easy to understand and the enthusiasm you have is totally infectious ive been watching you only for a little while now and im really enjoying your videos thankyou for you hard work.
I often turn my screen side-ways, turn off the volume, wish I was 25 years younger and have the perfect mate for intense life defining pillow talk.
I know why she hasn't gotten to 1M subscribers yet. She may do research (if you call watching other youtube videos research) but she doesn't write out her presentation. She makes up her monologue as she goes and it's dreadful to listen to. She's searching for the right word, stammering, and generally looking unprofessional. Stop wasting my time. If she had written this out ahead of time, it would most likely be more interesting, it would be more coherent, and it would be tighter. And I might have watched the entire video especially since it probably would end up about half as long.
@@warpso wow ok first of all if you think you can do better then please do and perhaps we will flock to watch your videos oh sorry you have and you have only 4 subscribers.... damn so much venom for a person just making a youtube maybe because she has more people interseted in what shes saying than you have?... has this hurt you? is this why you are projecting?? AND Secondly she makes a lot of us happy watching her as you call in unprofessional videos... hence the 154k subscribers buddy... ANYWAYS PEACE LOVE AND LIGHT. im out......
@@lorrenpickering2153 I was not trying to be venomous just direct. It's a critique. No I don't think I could do better. My videos are basically for friends. You seem to have more emotional investment than I do. Although I suppose I was frustrated and disappointed that her delivery doesn't jive with my expectations. But I'm not projecting and no this has not hurt me. I really hope she improves over time and I will continue to check in to see if she does. She has a lot of passion and knowledge. And I would be very interested to hear what she had to say if she didn't stumble and go off on tangents all the time. It's like she's counting on her cuteness more than her competence and to me that is not professional. I stand by my main tenet that she could be more successful if she were to have her script planned out ahead of time. I believe this for Professor Geek as well. I'm a big fan of his content but he's so clumsy delivering it that I too often lose interest. I'm glad she makes you happy -- that's awesome. Peace to you, but I'm not your buddy, buddy (paraphrased from South Park).
Damn the editing and b roll footage is next level on this vid!
Great video! Thanks for sharing🙏🏼
Thanks, the best analysis of the potential location for Atlantis based on science I’ve ever heard!
Great job!
I watched JRE with Randall Carlson recently who gave you a shout out 😊, he is a true treasure of information. Thank you for sharing your enthusiasm for this subject with us, I also believe in Atlantis, there are many verbal stories passed down through generations in many cultures that are still being told today & no doubt the majority of them have very truthful origins. It makes me wonder sometimes, there must of been people who were from the city of Atlantis that were away from there at the time of its destruction & no doubt they traveled elsewhere & built monuments wherever they went helping to pass on their knowledge of Astronomy, Mathematics, Agriculture, guiding people to become more civilised in memory of the City they loved & missed. I sure it’s true.
SO why is there no genetic evidence? Why did they avoid spreading plants and animals across their massive empire? Why is there not one single piece of evidence ever found?
Love listening to you, agree whole heartily with what your saying. Enjoy your content, more please
Absolutely brilliant breakdown of Atlantis so interesting thanks for sharing 🙏🏼👍🏼👍🏼
This is the third video of yours that I've watched and the first where you asked for a like/subscribe... and you did it in the last ten seconds. I really, really wish that more people o RUclips would follow your example!
You got mine, btw. :)
So glad you're doing this. Have you watched Dr Michael Heiser's work on Atlantis? I reckon you should definitely take a look!
There are manuscripts before Plato (Homer, Hesiod, Pindar, and Hellanicus) that mention a “sacred circular entity somewhere West of Gibraltar..." Keep them coming!
I also would love to hear your thoughts on the Richat structure.
Directly off the coast of San Juan, on the seafloor of the Bahamas is a Domed city 10miles in diameter, residence to millions of Atturians,
Is that Atlantis??
No it's not, the , Capital City of the Agarthian continent was Atturias.
That's cool.
@@kidcreole6749 LOL LOL LOL sure thing kid
Refueled my aircraft in the Azores, In the middle of January, coming from Germany ( Ice Storm ) the Azores were 70 degrees and the cactus was in full bloom !
Love the copper chisels logo! Keep doing what you do, it’s beautifully done.
This is fascinating. I grew in the 80s, intrigued by this mistery. There was so little information and a lot of ridiculous speculation. I stopped looking, and just by chance, I found this. Thank you!
Richat structure, and the wash out to the atlantic, Cabo Verde is where we need to be looking due to the destruction (washout) of the African Sea towards the Cabo Verde islands.
Thats not it, thats a plasma discharge event.
yep, Richat Structure fits the description, its south of ATLAS mountains, and you can literally see the ship docks on google Earth
Several videos about it, the earliest from 2008 called "visiting Atlantis"
@@hawaiiguykailua6928 I believe both are very likely true. Bright Insight has done many videos outlining the possibility of the Eye of Africa being the site of Atlantis.
Does make sense. Bordered by the Atlas mountains as well.
Wrong. You can't find what never existed.
I feel that this idea that civilization began around 6000 years ago was established at a time when many historians and archaeologists were creationists and believed the world was not much older than 6000 years and it created a dogma in the foundations of our understanding of history that still persists today.
It would have had nothing to do with creationism. Those sites and their theories developed in 1800s would have had little ability to think beyond those timelines.
Not sure why but i read your comment as “when many historians and archaeologists were cartoonists” 🤣
Then why is any knowledge that proves historical events in the bible being repressed?
@Shimmy Shai ok but how do they came to say 9000 years ?
@@enigma9971 exactly . Because saying that the bible is historically accurate. Would change so much for the world. They will do their best to hide it. I mean look at Nicola Tesla. He appreciated the bible for it's accuracy even though he didn't consider himself a Christian. .. 😂. They make movies about bible times and seemingly don't care to read the actual account .. so on and so forth. Its all one pattern
You're wonderfully authentic and for lack of a better word, inspirable. Thank you!
An excellent presentation there Jahannah James, enjoyed it muchly. Glued to the screen you might say. Cheers from Marc MacD, an Aussie in Dubai.
Don't forget we also have our own Atlantis in the North Sea: Doggerland. Last part of it went down around 8200 years ago. It stretched between Brittian, The Netherlands, Germany and Denmark. Many archaeological finds have been made there on the seabed and even human remains have been found.
true also an old frisian tale tells that the frisian people came from a sunken land near that region
i'm going to check that out. thanks for mentioning that. I bet it's quite interesting. cheers.
@@dammitanothername i heard this from one of Robert Sepehr video another great youtube channel
We need to send couple trillion gallons of water into deep space then we can get the metal detectors out
No cloudwind, you make the mistake thinking that the city of Atlantis is in the Atlantic ocean. But Greeks say that the city of Atlantis is in the "Sea of Atlas" which is the Atlas mountains. Sorry dude, but ancient Greek is confusing, that why they have the old saying "it all Greek too me".
Mic drop, can’t find mic, drops scissors..... on the floor laughing🤣🤣🤣🤣
You are a jewel.
I just stumbled on this. My first of your videos. Fascinating! I love your style, don't change. 🙃
I've liked your video, have subscribed and now leaving a comment.
You Are A Pleasure to Watch! Boom, I said it!
Very informative in a oh so easy to follow young woman :) Keep doing what you're doing!!! Absolute brilliance in delivery, organization and quirkiness! You make history very very engaging :)
As someone who has been resurrecting Atlantean academia, I appreciate this video immensely.
It really warms my heart ♥
cool - can you fwd me some links to critical ideas / research ?
As a curious observer, with no dog in the fight, I remember learning that the earth is not solid like a marble or a bowling ball. It is more like a beach ball. Put pressure at the equator and the poles will bulge up and conversely, put pressure at the poles ( as with lots of ice ) and the area at the equator will bulge up. The combination of elevating the land and lowering the ocean level by locking the water into great ice sheets could produce a livable area where Plato said. As Jahannah just taught me, the ancient ocean currents would wrap around it and possibly create an ideal place to live. With the ice melting in a relative short time, the land under Canada would rebound up ( which ancient coastlines prove has happened ) and the equator would sink down. This coupled with the influx of the melted ice could submerge that land. It could be hard to discover since for thousands of years the dessert sands of the Sahara have blown west and possibly covered much of what was there.
Isostatic depression
Doesn't work. The Azores are separated by channels over a mile deep.
Thanks. Another exceptional presentation. Definite food for thought. I concur completely.
Saw you on with Randall Carlson and enjoyed the discussion. Subscribed 👍
I found this very interesting and useful, great job. This type of approach is a great way to get people who believe in alternative history/time lines, interested into the actual science and evidence behind the theories. Which I believe is very important, you don't want to base your idea's just on theories with no evidence, and we must accept there might be evidence that counters what we believe.
I certainly don't believe all of the mainstream archelogogical timelines and explanations, but when you actually research some of these things there is evidence to back up a decent amount of what they say. That doesn't mean they are 100% correct, I simply mean you can see how they got that interpretation from the evidence in front of them.
However this is a great example that the alternative history believer's have a strong case and are simply saying, 'hey this is/was possible'. And in this case it has to be acknowledged (like you said) Plato managed to be incredibly accurate with a potential place and timeframe, that alone warrants serious consideration by the mainstream not just the usual snubbing as 'mumbo-jumbo' as they like to say.
Again, great job on this one.
As an interesting historical footnote....
The archipelago is believed to have been discovered around 1427 by Portuguese navigator Dioo de Silves, who initially landed on the Azores islands of Santa Maria and Sao Miguel.
Upon landing, they discovered the statue of a man astride a horse, pointing out to sea. The base was inscribed with an unknown script.
Apparently, the royal family of Portugal wanted no dispute over their claim to having been the first to discover the islands. The statue was removed to Lisbon, where it then disappeared.
Interesting.
That’s sad if true
So there's no evidence for this claim. File under complete shite.
Wow I just discovered your channel!
Thank you!
Love your presentations!!!
Just subbed. Been watching a lot of your vids and liking every single one. It's a nice change to see a female doing ancient history. I watch a lot of male RUclipsrs that do ancient history/mystery and I enjoy them. It's just a nice change to see a fellow female here.🥰
All the Randall you can handle!
lol
I would pay extra to hear him say that.
Randal was live on Grimarica (RUclips show) talking Atlantis while she went live with this premiere. Guess who got more views talking about Randles ideas? Not even close 58 views for Randal 1,800 for Lady quoting Randles ideas In 28min of publishing.
@@michaelstiller2282 true. Although, I've listened to probably every word Randall has ever said on the internet/podcast, if I see a Jahannah video I know I'm in for a smart and funny experience. And on top of that, let's just be honest here guys, she's our ancient history dream girl! Yes I'm big simpin' and proudly lol
@@michaelstiller2282 randall had few series several hours long about this on "his" podcast kosmographia cca year and half ago, it has now cca 20.000 views, sad world we living in, hopefully JJ will make it known to more ppl with this episode, theres never enough info about this
Fascinating. Thank you for sharing.
Brilliant video, here’s my cheeky subscribe, really enjoyed this video and look forward to watching more of your channel. Thanks 😉👍🏼👍🏼
Great video, Jahannah! I'm now wiser than I was 22 min and 49 sec. ago, and a new subscriber! Is the argument against the Richat Structure being the actual capital city that Plato describes still, largely, that it looks too much like what Plato described? Even down to its near exact dimensions. I mean, how corny, how obvious, how lazy can we get? And yes, I realize that no one has ever seen or heard a duck that, in fact, turned out to be a duck. That just doesn't happen. Plato didn't say that Atlantis fell to the "bottom" of the sea, but that it became impassable because of an impenetrable mud tsunami - as it were - that all but buried the city. All of your points are spot on, Jahannah, but Plato did tell of a city - in ridiculous detail - that you can, literally, super impose over the Eye of the Sahara. Ring formations that are littered as far as the eye (pun intended) can see with the red, white and black stones he mentioned...probably rubble from the cataclysm that has slowly eroded to the surface after 11,000 years. And, yes, it is beyond the Pillars of Hercules...down the western coast of northwest Africa to a point where there was ocean access to the Richat in wetter, greener times. Say hi to your dad!
It sure is interesting that every single ancient civilization we know of had highly advanced astronomical knowledge, knowledge that we in the modern era were ignorant of until the last few centuries or so. Logic and evidence dictates that there must have been an ancient civilization capable of traveling around the globe with full knowledge of where they wanted to go and how to get there. I personally have asked the same question since I was in my teens (I'm now 52); "How is it that everywhere people went during the so-called 'Age of Discovery' they found people already living there?" The only exception is Antarctica and that's only because it's not possible for humans to live off the land or sea there.
Everything we have been taught about ancient history is wrong!
It's not interesting at all.
The lack of western civilization having significant astronomical knowledge until now is a result of just a few factors......
First the Roman empire imploded inward on itself, leaving most of its European colonies/outposts reeling and ready for invasion.
Then the rise of Christianity and its science strangling mandate was the true dark ages.
Without that and the rise of Islam after it we could have reached the age of reason 500-1000 years earlier.
People seldom realise that the Greco-Romans had a basic steam engine in the 1st century CE.
A steam engine 1800 years before it transformed industry and travel.
If the Roman empire hadn't fallen, hadn't embraced Christianity, had beaten back the Turks instead of withdrawing.....
Let's just say that the marvels of today would be more like Europe in Elizabethan Tudor times by comparison to where we could have been.
@@douglascain6404 I dunno about the school you went to but the one I did taught ancient history like a childs book.
ie a few random interesting facts and done.
Back to your math problems kids!
Learning ancient history doesn't help you get a job, unless the job is archaeology or museum curator.
If you really expect that to change you are more than a little bit foolish.
@DigitalTrucker, even Antarctica may have been livable in ancient history. The Piri Reis map shows the coastline of Antarctica without ice. Charles Hapgood would be a good guy to search for on RUclips. The North and South Poles have changed position by significant distances and even if have geo-magnetically have flipped numerous times. Every major earthquake or comet/asteroid impact has the potential to change the Earth's tilt
Azores is the highest peaks of the Island of Athera ....
Excellent video with lots of details and cientific sources.
Very interesting stuff. Thank you
Your enthusiasm and intellectual honesty are absolutely infectious. So glad I found your channel. Please never stop!
Wonderful breakdown. Was Watching Randal again On JRE so checked in. So much land was lost not just Islands but all the very populated coastal areas. I'm very sure there was an advanced civilization on Earth and maybe many before. Imagine what evidence would be left of us if all our Datacentres and smartphones turned back to dust.
Mount Rushmore and.....that's about it.
If only we could drain the oceans 400m
😅😂🤣🥲
….😥indeed
Advanced does not mean those civilizations had cell phones. It means they had a civilization such as towns, cities, trade routes, laws and engineering. The word advanced is a loaded term.
@@bighands69 Sliding scale I would say. A chisel is advanced so is a SpaceX Raptor engine.
Great presentation! Makes sense that a planet (which are starting to make popular) hit in the middle of a smaller Atlantic Ocean, and popped islands and mountains down to a lower altitude.
Thank you for the excellent or close to excellent presentation of what you found.
Cool video, thanks for the amazing content Jahannah ✌
Jahannah i hope you know i'm planning to have you as a secondary teacher for the younger people around me. I think the jahanna and jimmy combo is solid and maybe some Ben and Brien mixed in
We should open a school
@@FunnyOldeWorld you most definitely should!
@@FunnyOldeWorld :) reminds me of an 80s Music Video. Van Halen. I would have had excellent grades.
How about a show like Joe Rogan and jahannah gets paid million's.
@@FunnyOldeWorld Randall Carlson can be our professor X and the rest is you and me as Jane and Logan the rest we can find out hehe
Atlantis part 1 of 2:
Around 12,800 years ago, it was nearing the end of the days of the Atlantis civilization. The Atlantis culture had existed for several thousands of years. It began with the west-to-east migration of indigenous people of North & South America, eventually creating the colony of Atlantis in the area of the islands we call the Bahamas & Cuba, though the land masses looked different in those times due to large ice sheets covering North America & other land masses & lower sea levels. The Bahamas, along with Cuba, are the remnants of the main island of the Atlantean civilization, which also stretched into North, Central, & South America, as well as across the Atlantic Ocean & into what we call Europe & the Mediterranean areas & northern & western Africa. The main islands of Atlantis were off the coasts of North, Central, & South America. Much of the history was lost, & because much of what we’ve been told about Atlantis has come from Greek resources/people, many people tend to think that Atlantis architecture was like Grecian architecture; it is not. Aztec architecture is the closet we have to the Atlantean architecture; it includes large stone blocks, the types of pyramids now found in central & south America. However, it did change slightly when they went to the area of the Mediterranean; the closest representation would be the Minoan architecture, specifically the Temple of Knossos on the island of Crete. Home to an ancient Atlantean colony, which is known as the Labyrinth Temple & the Legend of the Minotaur, for the Atlanteans were bull worshipers. The Atlanteans adopted some of the Grecian style architecture but maintained their own style. In the architecture of the Temple of Knossos, the structures & pillars there are not the type found in the area of Greece; they are painted & shaped differently, & it represents more the Atlantean decoration because the pillars are red & black & the stones are white. In the remnants of the labyrinth in the Temple of Knossos on Crete, you will see that it was an initiation labyrinth from the culture of Atlantis, & when you follow the traces of the labyrinth that are dug into the ground & lined with stone, you will find, at the end of each turn, a large crystal buried in the rocks of the labyrinth. This was so that at each station they could meditate & resonate with those crystals & work their way through the labyrinth in the sense of a particular ritual that will allow you, at the end, to allow your mind to open up to new understandings, new information, new initiations of the cosmos. This came from ancient Atlantean times. In the days before the destruction, which actually covered a large span of time, there was a very large “main� comet that came into our solar system & took up an eccentric orbit that crossed the path of Earth’s orbit twice each year, & for a period of time rained down upon the Earth, as the comet broke up, various remnants that impacted the Earth & caused great destruction. These cometary fragments twice a year bombarded the north American & Atlantic region for over two decades, each year, twice a year. The obliteration was nearly complete of anything that existed in those areas in that time, which is why we don’t see much at all of what was there. It started relatively small, & mostly bombarded the ice shelves & the Eastern seaboard of the Americas, many chunks falling into the Atlantic Ocean causing tsunamis. Eventually, the main body of the comet finally penetrated the atmosphere & struck in the Atlantic Ocean gouging out a crater in the ocean floor & caused massive tsunamis at least 300 feet high in all directions radiating out from the Atlantic. This was the final obliteration of the idea of Atlantis cultures on the eastern seaboards of North, Central, & South America, it included tsunamis that struck the western seaboards of Europe, Africa, & into the Mediterranean; this is the beginning of the legendary flood of Noah. In those ancient times before the final destruction, since there were many cometary impacts & since they could observe the main comet arcing through the sky before it ever hit, they understood, by plotting its trajectory, & after some of the fragments began to impact the Earth, that their time was running out. Many of them fled to other areas to preserve their culture, knowledge, & civilization, going into South America, parts of Central America, parts of Africa & parts of Europe, & all the way into the beginnings of the culture that became Egypt, bringing their knowledge, technology, & architecture, into the understanding of what it took to build the great pyramids in Egypt. From this main comet, which still today provides meteor showers at certain times of the year including around Halloween, we still find what we call the Taurid meteor showers, which are the remnants of that comet shooting through our skies. But now, the remains are very small & burn up in our atmosphere, & they serve as a reminder of those days when the sign of a comet in the sky were terrifying; the civilization’s collective memory of that comet is a reason why comets developed the reputations of being bad omens of destruction; it came specifically from that comet that destroyed Atlantis. Comets were also referred to in ancient times as dragons, as they crossed the sky with their burning tails. Many different legends of comets & other things developed from this one experience, which began an age on Earth that we have labeled the Younger Dryas period. This radically shifted the climate. The cometary impacts into the thick ice shelves on the North American continent caused much flooding, much run-off, & that spilled into the oceans over time raising the ocean levels so that today they are 250 – 350 feet higher than at that time, submerging most of the Atlantean islands that were in the Atlantic Ocean. This is why it is so challenging to find any remnants of that civilization today, though there are still things waiting to be discovered
well written and articulated.
Thanks for the info. I will read it over and over so I can recite it word for word. 👌👌👌❤️
@@quercus3290 eh... maybe... but paragraphs are just so.... you know... predictable :)
Where did you find this particular info?
We are still waiting for part 2
Excellent explanation.. great work 👍
Nice job of presenting scientific evidence. I like your enthusiasm as you went through everything. It's nice to see an open-minded critical thinker these days!
Winner winner chicken dinner, another awesome video😁
Great video! There are also some very interesting ruins in the Azores and Canary Islands that are worth looking into as well. The architecture is very strange and are pretty much ignored by most of the scientific community due to the questions they raise. The problem is the 'scientific community' ignores the evidence because they do not want Atlantis to exist. It would prove the accepted historic model to be wrong.
It is a push to suggest that the archeology industry is science. Many in that industry will rally against science if it counters their theories.
I am not convinced of Atlantis as of yet but I am also not convinced by the established theory.
I was watching another Video, don't remember what exactly? Had to do with an Archeological Discovery. Like this Video, I was reading through the Comments.
A Professor, commented on the Teachings, at his University. How his fellow Professors, Won't Teach, some newer Findings? They Teach, according to the Study Books. Even though, the newer Findings have been Verified?
People, are reluctant to Accept Changes!
In different places, I've noticed people speak of different Archeological Sites, that Archeologists refuse to Investigate?
I suppose, there's a Concern, that they will Discover Our History Is Not what we are told!
They could be, concerned about their Reputations?
They seem, more concerned about Supporting the Lies, versus finding the Truth?
There is the Possibility, that they already know the Truth? In order to keep their Funding, they are required to tow the current Lies?
Who knows for sure??
Peace
What are these structures in the canary’s? I go there often
It's not that the scientific community doesn't want Atlantis to exist, it's that the scientific method's core concept is to actively try to disprove a hypothesis. If the hypothesis is : "Atlantis existed and sat there" ; then the goal is to disprove that. It's basically narrowing things down to what's actually possible via a process of elimination. If it can be disproved, then it's false, and we have to make another hypothesis to test out. That's how we pursue scientific knowledge. What we actually know is stuff that can be replicated and predicted, what we think we understand is "theories", i.e., hypotheses that haven't been disproved yet. But gathering and intersecting a pile of maybe evidence is not the scientific method, because that's trying to prove something to be true, and that's at the opposite of the scientific method.
For Atlantis, the main problem here is that whether in the case of it sitting in the Azores or in the Eye of the Sahara, if its end was truly cataclysmic, then it's been completely wiped, and there will be 0 evidence either way. We can only hypothesize. We're talking either about 11000 years of erosion, assuming it was in the Azores and wasn't completely destroyed by the sinking, or about a tsunami that created a landslide in Mauritania, that has been observed between the coast of Mauritania and Cape Verde, meaning, yes, in the water, along with tsunami debris. There will be no actual evidence, there will be no remains of human civilization, so those hypotheses will remain just that, hypotheses.
Most of science regarding archaeology is basically modern humans hurting their feet on remains of ancient civilizations after having stumbled on them by inadvertence, like broken pottery, human bones, or weapons. Anything that is either directly human or at least man-made, that stood the test of time. Here we're all fantasizing (which is great, I am fascinated by it, but it's still just fantasizing) about a story of a maybe real city, that was written about by a guy that died more than 2000 years ago, but was still closer to us than he was to the city he's describing, and who doesn't have the technological advancement that we have nowadays, and somehow he would have a clearer idea of history before him than we do before us. That's very different from the scientific community "not wanting it to have existed", in fact most scientists would be super excited if there was a compelling lack of evidence to disprove it, and a compelling quantity of evidence to prove it ; they've probably just come to terms with the fact that there will never be any strong evidence.
Personally I'm more allured to the Eye of the Sahara hypothesis… at least we can see the rings, and can guess some major axes between the rings.
Quite enjoyable to watch, with or without sound.
This is so cool! Nice job.