Yeah, the original studio version always sounds great. I didn't know that Nightwish actually performed playback for some TV shows because the show insisted on that. I guess you sometimes need to do stuff like that for marketing.
@@MikkoRantalainen Yeah, it must be weird for professional musician to "play" with playback when they know they can play perfectly for real. Like "I pretend to do my job instead of really doing it". But as you said, it's marketing - basically a live music video.
@@MikkoRantalainen I am ancutally not sure if it was like that on that award show or if they just swapped the audio in the editing afterwards. Because you can't hear any noise from audience etc.
@@georg3607 Tuomas has just one keyboard on the stage. I think the real minimum for Amaranth is two. See for example the making of video here: ruclips.net/video/vhEfHTyG5W8/видео.html
It's pity Jukka couldn't continue showed power in the drums. And about Anette,I always liked her own style despite some fans didn't do. She always was emotional and with a great interpretation and acting in the songs. I'm happy for her that she has continued singing on her own way and who supports her too.
To set up a show for one live song would be massively time consuming and expensive and the good folk that organised the show have not the time or money to do that for ever act !!! Just be so much hassle. Thing is they won and they looked like they were just having fun with it. And I have to say she looked absolutely beautiful moving and owning that stage like a Boss. This was the best times for Nightwish. It’s a shame their becoming a tribute band now days because most don’t perform as this line up anymore. I wish them all the very best.
I was there to support a group and didn't know who Nightwish were, but was hooked after their Performance. Can't believe it's been 15 years since ECHO 2008 😅
Yes, it is all playback, because that's what the TV show wanted. It has nothing to do with Anette's voice quality - even though I think Floor Jansen, the current lead singer, is much better in almost every way. You can check out the real live version of Amaranth here and see what Anette sounds like: ruclips.net/video/Ba0IQOZDsIo/видео.html - Amaranth official live version ruclips.net/video/rNrTTJrsq_w/видео.html - Amaranth official training session
@@rheboi i have not been to a real concert. Why are they supposed to dance and move? People like you piss me off. I enjoy music by my ears, no need to express the joy of it by moving around..
I have to say this. The first time i watched this video i was very disaapointed because they're were a band of not showing on tv or stuff like this, i thought for a moment hat they wanted to be more mainstream but anyways at the end i accepted. Also, it pissed me off that they "had" to do a playback. Anyways, i will love them no matter what until I die.
Организовывать живое шоу ради одной песни бессмысленно и дорого, особенно на тв, поэтому было проще пустить фанеру, уже не первый раз такое замечаю, например вот это шоу ruclips.net/video/iDOOksnpvkk/видео.html. Даже телеканал тот же самый. Почитайте первый закрепленный комментарий, там человек подробно объяснил
14 years after it's release i discovered it,YEAH........Nightwish...metal? This song isn't, it's melodic,very catchy. It's more rock and she's a popsinger, her voice works very well in this song ..... heard Ghost love score Wacken13 too and that was so amazing....the journey through their works continues.
This isn't the actual live performance, someone took the video of thr performance but the audio is from the album, the quality is too sharp yo be a live performance
This was the best Nightwish line-up...
Annette look very beautiful
Jukka is always playing like his life depends on it, solely, greater inspiration, greatest showmanship!
thank you! the ultimate drummer. technique, showmanship, fuckin' passion!
Por fin encontré este video!!!! Anette una genia ni hablar de los demás miembros.
Floor
this song is my alltime favourite (of nightwish)
Ella es tan hermosa y su voz es increíble.
Tiene una hermosa voz Anette
Klipy od téhle zpěvačky jsou pro mne top.
Anette did very well here! Outstanding performence.
Yeah, the original studio version always sounds great. I didn't know that Nightwish actually performed playback for some TV shows because the show insisted on that. I guess you sometimes need to do stuff like that for marketing.
@@MikkoRantalainen Yeah, it must be weird for professional musician to "play" with playback when they know they can play perfectly for real. Like "I pretend to do my job instead of really doing it". But as you said, it's marketing - basically a live music video.
@@MikkoRantalainen I am ancutally not sure if it was like that on that award show or if they just swapped the audio in the editing afterwards. Because you can't hear any noise from audience etc.
@@georg3607 Tuomas has just one keyboard on the stage. I think the real minimum for Amaranth is two. See for example the making of video here: ruclips.net/video/vhEfHTyG5W8/видео.html
@@MikkoRantalainen You are right. Didn't think about that
i missed this line up
It's pity Jukka couldn't continue showed power in the drums. And about Anette,I always liked her own style despite some fans didn't do. She always was emotional and with a great interpretation and acting in the songs. I'm happy for her that she has continued singing on her own way and who supports her too.
The best moments....
Sad this award show was filmed at a morgue. That crowd is DEAD!!!!!
The echo award is dead too
the best singer of Nitghwish...
indeed
Echo awards is play back and it's not live concert Okey?
Accept it and enjoy Anette's beautiful presentation ❤ and the Amaranth from DPP.
To set up a show for one live song would be massively time consuming and expensive and the good folk that organised the show have not the time or money to do that for ever act !!! Just be so much hassle. Thing is they won and they looked like they were just having fun with it. And I have to say she looked absolutely beautiful moving and owning that stage like a Boss. This was the best times for Nightwish. It’s a shame their becoming a tribute band now days because most don’t perform as this line up anymore. I wish them all the very best.
Sad these tv shows make them lip sync... they were having such fun anyway though!!! Look at Emppu at 1:14 :')
yeah and not even trying to hide it. That's sad!
Theres not live presentations in the program! This demand a early preparation and they don't knew who will win after all!
I was there to support a group and didn't know who Nightwish were, but was hooked after their Performance. Can't believe it's been 15 years since ECHO 2008 😅
Amaranth is Anette!
Yes, it is all playback, because that's what the TV show wanted.
It has nothing to do with Anette's voice quality - even though I think Floor Jansen, the current lead singer, is much better in almost every way.
You can check out the real live version of Amaranth here and see what Anette sounds like:
ruclips.net/video/Ba0IQOZDsIo/видео.html - Amaranth official live version
ruclips.net/video/rNrTTJrsq_w/видео.html - Amaranth official training session
in her own way for sure, but not in songs anette was involved, because they were written for her - but you are right!
3:34 EPiC PLayBaCk
Voice programation, asshole!
What the hell is with the audience??? Stunning music and they're dead? Love this song!!!
what is the audience supposed to do?
@@JanoyCresva66 dance, let the music move them... standing around like a bunch of mannequins just looks wrong... have you never been to a concert?
@@rheboi i have not been to a real concert. Why are they supposed to dance and move? People like you piss me off. I enjoy music by my ears, no need to express the joy of it by moving around..
@@JanoyCresva66 I piss you off? Wow doesn't take much does it? Take a chill pill and get over it..
@@rheboi well yes, ppl without emotions - don´t care about this scum :)
Great vocal performance. The rest of the band looked the part! :)
Dude its not live.
❤❤❤
the best show with Anette.. playback
Live my ass, this is studio version
Damn. that scream in the beginning...
every comment is the same thing. yes, we get it, she was lip syncing
Not only she, the band was too
Thank God! Nightwish’s image was saved.
Play back is very stranger
Why are two of the award videos blacked out?
I have to say this. The first time i watched this video i was very disaapointed because they're were a band of not showing on tv or stuff like this, i thought for a moment hat they wanted to be more mainstream but anyways at the end i accepted. Also, it pissed me off that they "had" to do a playback. Anyways, i will love them no matter what until I die.
yeah, i also can´t understand this, but at least 2 years later :P
ФАНЕРА!!!
Организовывать живое шоу ради одной песни бессмысленно и дорого, особенно на тв, поэтому было проще пустить фанеру, уже не первый раз такое замечаю, например вот это шоу ruclips.net/video/iDOOksnpvkk/видео.html. Даже телеканал тот же самый. Почитайте первый закрепленный комментарий, там человек подробно объяснил
Anette arrazou.
Floor 😊
Pena que é Playback e a Plateia pareçe formada por Zumbis.
Anette ta gata demais aí, que Bombomzinho.
Não é playback. É programação. Nao sabe, nao fala besteira
Está editado o vídeo ao vivo é esse ruclips.net/video/T_ysv9KEjo8/видео.html
14 years after it's release i discovered it,YEAH........Nightwish...metal? This song isn't, it's melodic,very catchy. It's more rock and she's a popsinger, her voice works very well in this song ..... heard Ghost love score Wacken13 too and that was so amazing....the journey through their works continues.
🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤😍😍😍😍😍 Anette so beautiful🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤
Alejandro Coman Vc ñ percebeu ñ, meu caro amigo, que ela, nos minutos finais do vídeo, usou playback!!!!😁😁😁😁😁
For me this is the Best version of the song, the Best singer of nightwish is Annette
Yes yes lov3 annette nightwish were never the same
Ik heb haar bij een concert gehoord, geef mij Floor Jansen maar.
You do know tho that this performance is playback right? Annette is not a bad singer but she even struggled to sing her own songs live
@@lilith7867 this is lip synced?
@@ToTheWolves yea obviously
Would Tuomas have really agreed to a lip synced playback only version in a live performance?
They even did it with Tarja once or twice so yes
Full Playback
what happen with that people ?????????????????
TEMON....PERO NADIE VA A SUPERAR A TARJA TURUNEN.....HERMOSA VOZ LA DE ANETTE....
no se trata de superar, todas tienen su encanto y son excelentes
Cada una tiene una voz diferente. Y eso hace de que la banda tenga las mejores vocalistas.
La superó hace rato desde el día que la votaron y entro Anette con su tremenda voz 😎
ese sonido no es en vivo!!!
no me diga!!
it's playback right?
The only time that Annette sang like, acted like, and dressed like a rockstar! Too bad you didn't stay the course! You had the talent!
Agreed. This is by far he best she ever looked.
playback... :S
No way
Because she's not good enough singer for TV
Not at the ending.
Bang knapa vokalisnya buka flor
Anette vokalis kedua nightwish. Lpas anette kluar bru floor jansen masuk group ni
playback
Nightwish don't need to do that, I don't know why they didn't play live, it seems like a fraud for an artist to do that
Yes, German Award Show. Tarja ( Nemo ) at Viva Interactiv is also Playback.
Playback?
It's funny to see how Nw became much more recognized thanks to Anette.
Anette no es mala cantante, y si, de supone que los 2 discos con ella han sido los más vendidos. Las 3 cantantes tienen lo suyo
Lip syncing
This isn't the actual live performance, someone took the video of thr performance but the audio is from the album, the quality is too sharp yo be a live performance
Nigtwis nu suna mai bine fara tarija turunen
This is a lip sync?
Tarja is the best vocal, but Annette is my favorite.
Sem a Tarja a banda perdeu sua identidade 😪😪
Teucu
Essa é minha opinião
Aceita o 🤘que dói menos😤🖕
Ainda isso?
Worst crowd ever.
Жаль что под фанеру поют и играют
Ojalá hubiera cantado en vivo por que esto claramente es playback 😑
Volvé Tarja Turunen, que esta piba, hace pasitos de pop, en una banda gotica...😡 "
Pues ni hace "pasito de pop" y la banda no es "gótica" 😝🤣
Jajajajajajajajaja jajajajajajajajaja qhdp
Le voy a comprar un colchón para que siga soñando 🤭😂😂
This seems lip synched
Playback!
Позорище
Terrible crowd
Oh this is with the worst singer :(
Lol
Do you people know if this is LIVE? Cause it sounds too perfect to the point I think this is Playback