Dalai's second brother, Jia Le Dunzhu wrote a confession that the biggest mistake in his life is to collaborate with the CIA.（The Noodle Maker of Kalimpong - The untold story of my struggle for Tibet)
Trump already said the mainstream media is FAKE NEWS. And Gaza proofs that. Just translate Tibet into Chinese, search on RUclips, see for yourself. U don't even need to understand what they are saying, just look around. U will understand hypocrisy of western media. In the era of social media, the fake news couldn't hide. And AI large language model can also help in translate and summarize a vedio or news around the globe.
During the construction of the Sichuan-Tibet Highway and the Qinghai-Tibet Highway by the Chinese government, more than 3,000 soldiers and civilians sacrificed their precious lives. The two highways are more than 4,360 kilometers long, starting from Chengdu in the east, Xining in the north, and Lhasa in the south. They are important passages connecting Tibet and the mainland. During the construction process, many road construction soldiers and staff sacrificed their lives in the face of difficulties such as high temperatures, hypoxia, complex geology, and material shortages. Especially on the Erlang Mountain section, an average of 7 soldiers sacrificed their lives per kilometer. The victims are all Han people, and the beneficiaries are Tibetan compatriots. When these wandering Tibetans try to split Tibet, you should first ask the Tibetans whether they agree. If you have watched the Tibet video, you should know the current urban environment in Tibet. Chinese farmers and herdsmen all own land and pastures. They do not need to pay any fees to the state. Instead, the state will provide various subsidies such as food, fertilizers, and machinery. They They enjoy more preferential policies and benefits than Han people.
The McMahon Line was first drafted in 1913, and the treaty to ratify them (Simla Accords) was never signed by the Republic Of China(ROC) who had just overthrown the Qing dynasty. There was no such thing as the McMahon Line in 1890, and China isn't disputing where the Line was drawn, she's disputing the validity of the Line in its entirety. The primary Indian claim is that the ROC did sign the Simla Accords because a British official called Olaf Caroe fabricated a narrative in 1938 where the ROC signed the Simla Accords (they didn't) and ceded parts of Tibet to the Raj. In 1963 a British diplomat compared a pre-1938 treaties compendium with the post-Caroe compendium and found that Caroe had changed the note on the ROC's not signing the Simla Accords into one where the ROC signed it and considers the Indo-Tibetan border finalised. Nehru picked up a copy of Caroe's fabricated compendium so he got the impression that his country was legally entitled to more than she actually was. Compounding this was the US' decision to add fuel to the flames by declaring the McMahon Line as the legitimate boundary in an attempt to contain the spread of communism, despite reservations from the US State Department and protests from the fiercely non-communist Chiang Kai-Shek, leader of the ROC. However, we all know Nehru irreversibly altered his country's relations with China in 1962, so by 1963, when the fabrication was discovered, it was already too late to stem the tide of Indian nationalism based on the false compendium entry. And that leaves us with the situation today, in the aftermath of a British attempt to de jure carve out a piece of Chinese territory which failed but had some success de facto, then a British fabrication of her failed attempt to carve out Chinese territory, then an Indian acceptance of the British fabrication alongside American endorsement, and a Chinese refusal to accept the fabrication as anything remotely legal. Some Indians recognise that they don't actually have a legal claim to South Tibet, so they've begun using a different claim in that the people living in South Tibet want to be part of India more than China; in essence, a claim based on the principle of self-determination. This is India's secondary claim. However, as history has shown time and time again (Catalonia, Confederate States, Taiwan, Corsica, Chechnya, Tibet, Naxalites), without the permission of the larger body, a smaller section of the population will not be allowed to separate from its original country regardless of what they want. A much more detailed account of the McMahon Line and its history is available here, written by Peter Lee who, contrary to impressions given by his surname, is not at all Chinese.
It's a hidden fact almost 80% of Tibetian in India have indian citizenship because its the most easiest way to get one through undertable channels. Tibetians refugees are among the most diluated communities supported by Western opportunist who want to see China downfall. I have visited China and Tibet thrice in 2024 and plan to go again next month to Lhasa one of best place I always love to visit. This tibetians refugees influx has been growing yearly and taking HHDL excuse still many tibetians cross over Himalayes every year. China has given them so much and who are still in Tibet don't like to call them Tibetians instead they love calling them chinese of Tibetian origin and if one see the present day Tibet, its just mind blowing. This tibetian hoax will remain till HHDL is alive thenafter this people who called them tibetian refugees will slowly devolve in India as Indians. Tibetians are the most unfriendly people ever seen outside of Tibet, if not one can try them weather in US, Europe or in Asia.
No one asked you to come into Tibet! If a robber dies while trying to rob a bank, is it the bank’s fault? Obviously not. So why should we feel grateful for the intruder who died on the way?
@tibetmusicvideos7593 Robbers Rob and take... The Han intruder gave Tibet billions dollars worth of infrastructure, hospital and schools !!!. Your childrens and great grand childrens will benefit greatly. At least they are born free and not born a serf.
Tibetan youths are realistic to leave. Looking at changes between India and China, already told you the future is not sweet and tough. India cannot even provide a proper living standard for their own Indian race, let alone Tibetans.
No, this not it they are following the Prophecy laid out but the Lotus Born Buddha that Tibetans will scatter like ants in wind and land in land people with red faces.
@@Madame702 Sorry, Madame, we are in different wavelength, you are living in mythical world while I am in a realistic world. Good luck to you and Goodness the Tibetan youths didn't think like you.
@@teogeorge2203 Don't be silly. You cannot escape your Karma. You want to be successful you seek out material things of this world. Then you need to make offering to the Buddhas of the three times and ten directions. Much wealth will come to you if that is what you seek. The Tibetans know how to make offering to the Nagas that bring rain and wealth if that what you seek. They have powerful wealth deities like Jambhala he married a Naga Princess who give him her "Wishfulling Jewel" that grants wishes, but you must have great generosity and compassion in this life and previous lives then and only then will it manifest your good Karma in form of Wealth if that that what you want.
@@teogeorge2203 Just remember Tony Robbins was born a very poor man. He gave food on thanksgiving, to needy families and keep doing so. Right now his organization feed over a million needy families every thanksgiving. His positive Kama has made him a rich man. You can do "Sur" offering to spirits suffering in this world and next. That too bring much joy and positive Karma as well.
@@Tzchoedak Not True. Nobody gets lock up for no reasons like every countries in the world. Besides Chinese Tibetan dressed many times better, enjoying life with 1st world amenities, more tastier foods, top rate medical care, etc. They also like dancing in city squares and parks. That is why Chinese Tibetan are a lot healthier and bigger size than the smaller built Tibetans in India.
The average income of Tibetans in China is 3 times the average income of Indians. 95% of Tibetans in China are cover by Medical insurance. 37% of Indians are cover by Medical insurance. There is a new sports stadium in Lhasa that can seat 22,000 spectators. 🦉
Tibetans face even more racism in Tibet than India. Majority of business in Tibet are owned by Han Chinese. They only employ and do business with other Han Chinese. So the majority of the wealth in Tibet is pooled within the Han Chinese population not the Tibetans.
after 70 years living under the Dala Lama’s teaching, hatred kept shimmering and nurtured. With that kind of bad karma formation, what future prospects can we expect? It’s the exact reason why we study Buddha’s teachings.
The McMahon Line was first drafted in 1913, and the treaty to ratify them (Simla Accords) was never signed by the Republic Of China(ROC) who had just overthrown the Qing dynasty. There was no such thing as the McMahon Line in 1890, and China isn't disputing where the Line was drawn, she's disputing the validity of the Line in its entirety. The primary Indian claim is that the ROC did sign the Simla Accords because a British official called Olaf Caroe fabricated a narrative in 1938 where the ROC signed the Simla Accords (they didn't) and ceded parts of Tibet to the Raj. In 1963 a British diplomat compared a pre-1938 treaties compendium with the post-Caroe compendium and found that Caroe had changed the note on the ROC's not signing the Simla Accords into one where the ROC signed it and considers the Indo-Tibetan border finalised. Nehru picked up a copy of Caroe's fabricated compendium so he got the impression that his country was legally entitled to more than she actually was. Compounding this was the US' decision to add fuel to the flames by declaring the McMahon Line as the legitimate boundary in an attempt to contain the spread of communism, despite reservations from the US State Department and protests from the fiercely non-communist Chiang Kai-Shek, leader of the ROC. However, we all know Nehru irreversibly altered his country's relations with China in 1962, so by 1963, when the fabrication was discovered, it was already too late to stem the tide of Indian nationalism based on the false compendium entry. And that leaves us with the situation today, in the aftermath of a British attempt to de jure carve out a piece of Chinese territory which failed but had some success de facto, then a British fabrication of her failed attempt to carve out Chinese territory, then an Indian acceptance of the British fabrication alongside American endorsement, and a Chinese refusal to accept the fabrication as anything remotely legal. Some Indians recognise that they don't actually have a legal claim to South Tibet, so they've begun using a different claim in that the people living in South Tibet want to be part of India more than China; in essence, a claim based on the principle of self-determination. This is India's secondary claim. However, as history has shown time and time again (Catalonia, Confederate States, Taiwan, Corsica, Chechnya, Tibet, Naxalites), without the permission of the larger body, a smaller section of the population will not be allowed to separate from its original country regardless of what they want. A much more detailed account of the McMahon Line and its history is available here, written by Peter Lee who, contrary to impressions given by his surname, is not at all Chinese.
Actually, the Dala Lama listened to the CIA and betrayed his country, those so called refugees are the outcome of that insurrection failure, and the Americans just abandoned those who are useless.
@@Wann-zo7rn2qn4i lol, How do you know? Explain in detail, Did you study Tibetan Buddhism? Don't be a pig, feeding on what master feed you, Most Chinese feed on what communist China(Govt)'s propaganda.
As an outsider and Nepalese national, probably it is not appropriate to suggest Tibetans or Bhotias. However, living close to Tibetan community in harmony in Kathmandu I would like them to reconcile and talk to Chinese Government to return to their homeland. I think Tibetans in Nepal are more reconciled with locals than in India. Reason, Nepalese and Tibetans have many commons. Do not go after democracy and freedom as such which is matter of fact an abstract thing and just a political tool. At the end of day what matters the most is your living and life. Tibet is now more prosperous and livable place in comparison to cities in India and Nepal and better than many EU and US cities. After all Tibet or Bhot is your mother land and you own it. Please reconcile. Use Buddhism - compassion and perseverance in practical life not just as preaching theory. Love from Nepal and best wishes.
Very sensible suggestion to these people whose parents have, in hindsight, made the wrong decision of running away for political reason to India and now finding themselves kind of lost and abandoned in their host country. Yet many of the 2nd and 3rd generation are still brainwashed into holding the dream of fighting for an independent Tibet, a dream that will likely disappoint themselves for the rest of their lives, either fighting from India or other 3rd country and turned into a floating lost tribe drifting with a lost cause to never ever return to Tibet again. That's the sad reality and there are millions and millions of other people around the world like them.
Yes when CCP is controlling everything over you it's good for them. What a good suggestion? A tour guide can't speak about the govt on record in Lhasa. Forget about other things. In wuhan virus time do you remember how CCP locked its people in shenzen ? You must be a CCP thug
Said again. No one wants them back, even the local Tibetan people. For local Tibetan people, they will dilute resources, like land, job opportunities, government subsidies, etc. For government, there will be a huge fiscal expenditure. Not to speak of that they have a different cultural background with local people now.
Many people talks about cia.but CIA has nothing to do with tibet before china enter in tibet.tibet ask for help at almost end of violence after millions life were taken..donations from aborts for schools and refugees are openly registered and free to cheak .So 95% tibetans refugees are well educated.n fighting with world.not only chiness ..world is already sold..
@@michaelgoh9768 Life in Tibet under China is far better than those in the richest state of India especially the infrastructure, security for women and livelihood.
Precisely, I have been both countries during my stint and that's what I have concluded. India needs another 50 years basing on current situation to be on par with China but by then, China will be further far ahead.
Life is better in Tibet, China. Its more developed, living standards are far higher, education and healthcare system is good, infrastructure is world class, economy is far better. Thats why more and more Tibetans are wanting to come back.
, your thinking is crazy. Let's assume that government give you every convenience And then said that you can't see, you can't think and can't hear, then whom will you choose? who has no freedom and is nothing
@@tenten9274don't follow western media. I go to Tibet frequently and to my knowledge freedom in Tibet is better than India where you have mob lynching, communal riots and cast and racial discrimination.
Dalai Lama - Tibet is a part of China, said he during an interview with SCMP. Statement confirmed by US Congressional-Executive Commission on China, Mar 15, 2005.
I met some Tibetans in France who came from India,they can speak a little mandarin and are very nice people ,almost all of them said that they would earn some money to return to their home country for retirement,of course they would return to china
Return back to Tibet, enjoy, better working condition, good standard of living and free life. Lamas rule through religion. Every person has to bow their head and lie down,
Been to tibet as a tourist....wow brothers go back to your home land and settle things . Most of the tibetans and han people are living great life...their language culture is safe and secure. you are not going to get disappointed. You are always welcome to Bharath but dont buy westren propaganda and deprive ypurself of homeland. May avalokiteshwara bless all of you with his wisdom.
It is sad that these Tibetains left a better life in their home country to become refugees in a country with much lower stardard of living because of the propaganda and the deception.
@@Hogga91 indians had no dignity or self respect under british raj.. when i spoke with local tibetans they said their language culture and way of life is respected. they said they have better life than their parents and they are providing even more better life for their children. Its my small observation may be i am wrong
India won't let them to go back to China either, for political reasons. And, those in USA... will send money home to India. Those money is good for India too.
Who can remember Dalai Lama after his demise? Virtually few would want to regard him as a spiritual leader in modern China. There will not be a burial place in Tibet for his remains. Today, Tibetans and Chinese Hans live side by side harmoniously. Those who advocate Tibet independence will be crushed beyond recognition. Like it or not, it is China dictating the rule.
@tklim, in fact any form of separatism regardless tibetan or not, will be dealt with the greatest force. That rule applies to all ethnicity even for the Han majority in Taiwan 😊
hahhaha, In harmoniously? Are you joking? Chinese are oppressing Tibetans and undermining our culture, You Chinese have stolen our land, killed our people, and destroyed our language, we Tibetans are living in fear, We are living at gunpoint. If we have the choice we don't want dog, frog, and mouse eaters to live with us.
They're better to live in china,than in India because in racial discrimination and social discrimination is prevailing in India than in china because theirs looks and culture are somewhat similar 🎉
With the caste system still inherent in the Indian society whereby Indians discriminate among themselves, what is the chance that non Indians will not be discriminated.
they have been quietly going back to China for decades, but no one wants to talk abt it cause its too embarrassing for the CTA and the Dalai Lama the most followed Tibetan youtuber "Tibet Vista" was one of those exiled Tibetans who went back to china
No worries. China will make sure all those lands that belong to Xizang aka Tibet return back. This Is not the fault of India but it was Britain’s fault that took the land illegally from Xizang.
I mean when Indians themselves are leaving in millions each year, that too of those financially well off and upper class families, what more xan we have xpect from those unfortunate ones.
@@undefeatable17 According to the United Nations, India has one of the largest diasporas in the world, with over 18 million Indians living outside the country as of 2020. This is higher compared to the Chinese diaspora, which is estimated to be around 10 million. Not to mention these figures hv increased more for Indians. Each year, more than half a million are said to leave India & denounce their indian passport. Notably these are families who are financially well off , not middle class or lower class. Millionaires hv also left india in huge numbers and all these datas are highlighted in RUclips & internet by Indian whistle blowers and non govt agencies. Maybe it's time to change leadership. Modi led India has become a living hell for Indians. Next time come with facts plz otherwise go cry in the corner & watch upper middle class and rich Indians leaving india while you chew on cow dunk.
As someone born and brought up in Dharamsala, it’s impossible for us to see our area without Tibetans. They bring an enigma of fresh area and add a special charm to our land. We’ve always believed they are integral part of our society. We see them as locals and our own. For us someone from Punjab, Haryana, Delhi or any other part of India is an outsider but majority of people in Himachal would call Tibetans as their own people. We have deep rooted love and respect for Tibetan culture and people. HHDL is not only the spiritual and temporal leader of Tibet but he is also our Guru, our guiding light and our God. We wish Govt. of India starts giving Tibetans their due and equal representation now. We also want a free Tibet and see it as our own cause but, we wish that Tibetans should stay in India and have equal rights as long as Tibet doesn’t get freedom. Praying for the well being of our Tibetan friends, brothers and sisters. Long live the Indo Tibetan friendship. Bhod Gyalo Tashi Delek
What is the use of your praying? Lobby your Indian government to give them full citizenship so that they have the right to buy your land and build a good settlement and can put down roots.
Who will free Tibet from China? How many Tibetan people are living in India and other countries apart from China? Do you think these bunch of Tibetan people who are living outside China can bring independence of Tibet by living outside of China? Amongst these people how many of them are seeking for Tibet independence? Do you have any data? According to His Holiness Dalai Lama he has clarified umpteen times that "he does not seek any independence from China". So on what ground you're advocating for independence of Tibet from China? Moreover there are 98% of the Tibetan people living in China at the moment. There is no civil unrest going on against the Chinese govt by them. Therefore, taking all that into account, now you tell me who will free Tibet from China? Why you being a Punjabi is so interested in the independence of Tibet when the majority of Tibetans themselves are not interested in the first place. This exposes your envious nature towards China. If language, religion and culture are the criteria for demanding a separate independent nation then what is your take on the Khalistan freedom movement, Kashmir, Nagaland, Assam, Manipur, Mizoram, Meghalaya, Telugu Desam, Kannada desha, Tripura, Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra, Bengal, Sikkim etc?
@@kenkarko5432 as a student of the Buddha’s teachings, my wish is for a free Kashmir. As far as I know about Tibetan Autonomy region, they seemed happy there. Thanks for pointing that out.
The McMahon Line was first drafted in 1913, and the treaty to ratify them (Simla Accords) was never signed by the Republic Of China(ROC) who had just overthrown the Qing dynasty. There was no such thing as the McMahon Line in 1890, and China isn't disputing where the Line was drawn, she's disputing the validity of the Line in its entirety. The primary Indian claim is that the ROC did sign the Simla Accords because a British official called Olaf Caroe fabricated a narrative in 1938 where the ROC signed the Simla Accords (they didn't) and ceded parts of Tibet to the Raj. In 1963 a British diplomat compared a pre-1938 treaties compendium with the post-Caroe compendium and found that Caroe had changed the note on the ROC's not signing the Simla Accords into one where the ROC signed it and considers the Indo-Tibetan border finalised. Nehru picked up a copy of Caroe's fabricated compendium so he got the impression that his country was legally entitled to more than she actually was. Compounding this was the US' decision to add fuel to the flames by declaring the McMahon Line as the legitimate boundary in an attempt to contain the spread of communism, despite reservations from the US State Department and protests from the fiercely non-communist Chiang Kai-Shek, leader of the ROC. However, we all know Nehru irreversibly altered his country's relations with China in 1962, so by 1963, when the fabrication was discovered, it was already too late to stem the tide of Indian nationalism based on the false compendium entry. And that leaves us with the situation today, in the aftermath of a British attempt to de jure carve out a piece of Chinese territory which failed but had some success de facto, then a British fabrication of her failed attempt to carve out Chinese territory, then an Indian acceptance of the British fabrication alongside American endorsement, and a Chinese refusal to accept the fabrication as anything remotely legal. Some Indians recognise that they don't actually have a legal claim to South Tibet, so they've begun using a different claim in that the people living in South Tibet want to be part of India more than China; in essence, a claim based on the principle of self-determination. This is India's secondary claim. However, as history has shown time and time again (Catalonia, Confederate States, Taiwan, Corsica, Chechnya, Tibet, Naxalites), without the permission of the larger body, a smaller section of the population will not be allowed to separate from its original country regardless of what they want. A much more detailed account of the McMahon Line and its history is available here, written by Peter Lee who, contrary to impressions given by his surname, is not at all Chinese.
@dannyboy8850 अगर तिब्बती इन हालात में तिब्बत वापस चले गए तो भारतीय खुश नहीं रहेंगे! चीन तुरंत हमला कर देगा। तिब्बतियों की कृपा से भारत राजनीतिक दृष्टि से ज़्यादा सुरक्षित है। इसलिए भारत सरकार एक खेल खेल रही है। तिब्बत को आज़ाद नहीं होने देना है और न ही उसे वापस जाने देना है, यह उनके अपने फयदे के हित में है। 🤔🤔🤔
No one wants them back, even the local Tibetan people. For local Tibetan people, they will dilute resources, like land, job opportunities, government subsidies, etc. For government, there will be a huge fiscal expenditure. Not to speak of that they have a different cultural background with local people now.
@@konchoksoom1229 If all Tibetans in India go back, then the ownership of the so-called "Aruchal Pradesh" in India will be in question. Therefore, India will definitely impose restrictions on this.
@@faithfulshadow really ,I am watching from Tibet now ,Tibetan Chinese are real owner of China ,on the other hand Tibetan Indian have not even one inch of land in India .keep laughing .
Keeping aside the history..some people never see through the darkness of foul information..now Tibetans in china have so many benefits for being tibetans..they have priorities more than local chinese people..they are now entrepreneurs, they have businesses opportunities..so much better now.. Their lives are so much better. Afterall as a third country, I wish china and Tibet find the solution peacefully and do decisions as for mutual benefits.. The world needs peace and harmony.. Tibet is important Buddha land
We are just refugees, wat hope is left wen Indians are struggling in their own country.. We can't buy lands we can't get loans we can't get citizenship even if u are born here.Issues with the travel document which Govt provides us in the embassy n the airport evrytime. what choices are left for us other thn moving.. We love India, it's our second home n i am sure no one wants to leave where they were born n grown up but it's kinda hard to see a better future for our children n family here with so few opportunities. We wish n pray for the better future of india so tht no one hav to leave their family n their country.. Jai Hind🙏
@@proudgadwali144 born after 87 can't get citizen and, n the ciziten permission to those below starts onli few years back, the pension to the ex vikas army starts few yrs back n there's hugh differences in amount comparing indian army aswell.. We never complained n we are still thankful to India for letting us stay here as our own homland., the fact is it was harder before comparing today, still it's hard to build a better future for our families.. So abroad is the only option left for us. N u knw wat those who went as far as I knw they all miss India..
@@Tenz43 I don't know about the laws but they should give citizenship to our tibetan brothers the law should be changed , I know obviously everyone will look for their future and their lives , now I got to know why Tibetans are leaving india they are doing job as trash picker in America ,food vendor on streets ,dish washer in restaurant mainly in France it's cruel If it was in my hand I would have changed the law ,oh that's I have seen Tibetans only live in the areas specifically approved to them like dehradun ,bylakuppe etc
You can get citizenship there are precedents have to work on it . Plenty of opportunity in India one has to study work and compete ! This is india with a huge population !
Tibetans overseas send a lot of money back home, family members still living in India then use this money to build houses. In the two major tibetan settlements, Bylakuppe and Mundgod, you will see brand new houses everywhere. This is a major boon for the local Indian economy. The construction of these houses need a lot of workers which helps with the local employment of Indians, as well as supporting Indian businesses that supply the construction materials.
Lived and studied in India whole my life, but when I applied for the university , I was not eligible and had to apply as a foreigner and paid 5 x. Rampant discrimination and racism in big cities. Look at how North Eastern are treated in Mainland India. I migrated to the US, and from the very first day, people over here made me feel like I belonged here. That feeling I never got in India. I am now well settled and working in Govt. Sector.
India a developing nation ,struggling with the increasing population ,unemployment and poverty . I think India can always ‘help’😅 but cannot take the burden of all the refugees from neighbouring countries like Bangladeshis and Tibetans . I think it’s wrong to not be thankful to India after all these years
Meanwhile, Tibetans in China have increasingly more socio-economic opportunities, healthcare, housing, education, and industrial development throughout the region. Unfortunately the neglect of South Tibet is due to India's illegal occupation, and Tibetans trapped there, the price for being geopolitical pawns of US imperial designs
" On 27 September 1954, the Dalai Lama was selected as a Vice-chairman of the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress, a post he officially held until 1964. "
pls don't compare India to China. India will come to TOP when it comes for freedom. Every religion practice is allow here. n we all live together with harmony.
Don’t even compare India with China…. We might move abroad for better opportunities… as for China. We have to ESCAPE , putting our life on line… We hv FREEDOM of SPEECH and RELIGION here in India….. U r using VPN to comment here. Tat speak a LOUD 😂😂😂😂…
@@tenzinpassang5482 Yes, and each religion is "free" to kill the people of any religion they don't like. Look at what is happening in Manipur. These kind of religious unrest and riots and killings would have been stopped by the Chinese government months ago. If one day, the Tibetans are unfortunate enough to make the people of some other religion angry, and fighting breaks out, don't expect the government to come rescue you. The Tibetans in China all practised their own religion freely. We see so many travel videos of Tibet made by tourists. How is it not possible to compare with the miserable images in this video?
Tibetans in India are not appreciated and India just takes advantage of them and HHDL. They would do best to leave and move on to having a wonderful life. India does not allow Tibetans any real rights whatsoever, despite pretending they do everything for them. The violence against them is rife and getting worse. The corruption within India affects the Tibetan diaspora terribly. Places like Dharamshala- McLeod have been taken over by outsiders. India does not allow Tibetans their rights to citizenship, despite claiming they're ENTITLED to it... or to vote or own property in India. India needs to stop pretending life is good for Tibetans in India. Talk about how Tibetans are even sometimes returning to Tibet. Tibetans want to live their lives in peace. The idea that people are afraid to take up citizenship in India is incorrect, as they are taking up citizenship in other countries where they have great opportunities and are welcomed. Why would Tibetans want to be citizens in a country that does not accept them nor value them, despite their incredible support of their adopted country India. TCV also gives education to non Tibetan children. India's policies are corrupt and abusive. Look at how many Indian nationals leave India!
chinese ccp troll extolling the virtues of ccp when PRC are running away from china to go to America,canada, australia,new zealand even malaysia ,singapore etc
Tibetans living in India are not immigrants or refugees. They can live in Tibetan lands such as Ladakh,Anunachal(southern Tibet), Sikkim, Dharamsala. Although these lands are ruled by India and have been Indianized
India government should release these mentioned lands back to the Tibetan refugees to form an independent country of Tibet because these lands were originally belonging to the Tibet.
They are doing good here in our place ,all are doing business, they are educated,rich and very disciplined people. Maybe for a better opportunity they are doing this . Many Indians are also doing the same.
At this rate of migration 70% of Tibetans in India, Nepal and Bhutan will be migrated to abroad. Tibetan communities in US and EU are getting much bigger & stronger than in india day by day.
Every state has different laws for the Tibetans in India. In Himachal Tibetans are facing lots of difficulties and challenges because local are so jealous we can not owned a taxi, list goes on… They forgot by the grace of His Holiness The 14 th Dalai Lama of Tibet, Dharmsala has became one of the international tourist spot.
I am afraid the Tibetan refugees may have followed the wrong leaders leading to wrong path. The current leadership lacks vision and ambition to bring happiness and human growth in this modern time. It could be better for all Tibetan refugees to return home and settle down and rebuild Tibet to greater prosperity and happiness to the people rather mired in stalemate without hope and future.
Not sure if this is covered in this video, but the biggest problem for young Tibetans is traveling abroad as a tibetan. Indian govt issues a travel document called Identity Certificate(not Indian passport). It takes around 6 months for this travel document to be issued, and it also takes greasing some palms in Indian bureaucracy. The document is valid for 10 yrs, the renewal also takes same time and effort. The foreign embassies don’t like issuing visa on this document Tibetans who eventually get a visa then must again go through Indian bureaucracy to get exit permit and a return to India permit. Overall, it makes travelling very unpleasant experience for Tibetans, and this also makes awkward conversation for Tibetans working in private sector as they can’t travel on short notice.
It is a sad story, a tragic story. India granted political asylum to the Dalai Lama but it is now evident, the process had only very limited aim: the aim to embarrass China. Had the Tibetans realised that, they would not have stayed on in India, which offered them no opportunity to flourish or prosper. If, on the other hand, when international sympathy was very high in favour of the Tibetans, they could have sought scholarships from universities in Europe and America and garnered tremendous benefits. Even now, instead of just seeking avenues open individually, His Holiness the Dalai Lama could obtain help for collective benefit. Everyone does not need to be a Lama; let them turn professionals, scientists. academicians; the sky is the limit.
The Dalai wants to keep them poor and ignorant. Easier to control them. He hasn't done anything good for them, not even fight for better living conditions and status from India. He expressed a wish to return to China himself but he doesn't do anything to try and reconcile with China at least to do something for the younger generation. What is going to happen to them when he dies?
@@PChan-yt4uf "The History" is actually quite different from what the media has spread. The insitution of the Dalai Lama" was established by the Celestial Emperor and had appointed two Ambans in Lhasa to assist the Dalai Lama in governance of the country. Likewise, the office of the Panchen Lama was also the gift of the Chinese Emperor, so that while the Dalai Lama looked after the Government of Tibet, the Panchen Lama was appointed as the spiritual head of the country. To afford him greater prominance, the Panchen Lama was ordained to be the spiritual mentor also of the Chinese Emperor. If we are to view the geo-political situation in Tibet in true perspective, this is the first lesson needed to be taught, worldwide. Rest can follow.
@@PChan-yt4uf It is my understanding that the massive changes between the Tibet he had left behind and the Tibet now stands as a prosperous land will itself deter him to want to return to Tibet. However, if some individual Tibetans are allowed to return to Tibet and see for themselves how an average Tibetan is enjoying the benefit of modernisation, it will help Tibet stabilise itself without any coersion. This is my personal opinion as I myself am living in exile in USA.
@@jimmy2263 Maybe you can help them to make peace and leave the past behind. At least the younger generation might have a chance to belong somewhere and make a better life.
The McMahon Line was first drafted in 1913, and the treaty to ratify them (Simla Accords) was never signed by the Republic Of China(ROC) who had just overthrown the Qing dynasty. There was no such thing as the McMahon Line in 1890, and China isn't disputing where the Line was drawn, she's disputing the validity of the Line in its entirety. The primary Indian claim is that the ROC did sign the Simla Accords because a British official called Olaf Caroe fabricated a narrative in 1938 where the ROC signed the Simla Accords (they didn't) and ceded parts of Tibet to the Raj. In 1963 a British diplomat compared a pre-1938 treaties compendium with the post-Caroe compendium and found that Caroe had changed the note on the ROC's not signing the Simla Accords into one where the ROC signed it and considers the Indo-Tibetan border finalised. Nehru picked up a copy of Caroe's fabricated compendium so he got the impression that his country was legally entitled to more than she actually was. Compounding this was the US' decision to add fuel to the flames by declaring the McMahon Line as the legitimate boundary in an attempt to contain the spread of communism, despite reservations from the US State Department and protests from the fiercely non-communist Chiang Kai-Shek, leader of the ROC. However, we all know Nehru irreversibly altered his country's relations with China in 1962, so by 1963, when the fabrication was discovered, it was already too late to stem the tide of Indian nationalism based on the false compendium entry. And that leaves us with the situation today, in the aftermath of a British attempt to de jure carve out a piece of Chinese territory which failed but had some success de facto, then a British fabrication of her failed attempt to carve out Chinese territory, then an Indian acceptance of the British fabrication alongside American endorsement, and a Chinese refusal to accept the fabrication as anything remotely legal. Some Indians recognise that they don't actually have a legal claim to South Tibet, so they've begun using a different claim in that the people living in South Tibet want to be part of India more than China; in essence, a claim based on the principle of self-determination. This is India's secondary claim. However, as history has shown time and time again (Catalonia, Confederate States, Taiwan, Corsica, Chechnya, Tibet, Naxalites), without the permission of the larger body, a smaller section of the population will not be allowed to separate from its original country regardless of what they want. A much more detailed account of the McMahon Line and its history is available here, written by Peter Lee who, contrary to impressions given by his surname, is not at all Chinese.
@@Rav01508 Six north eastern Indian states around Assam have been fighting for independence for decades. They don’t consider themselves Indians. When these states obtain their independence, South Tibet or Zang Nan will be returned to China.
It is right. You should quite The Himalayan Challenge as reference. But now things have change and China can’t be allowed to hv Tibet and the water & mineral resources with the expansionist approach. Atleast what’s left of it must be protected.
I have encountered a few so called “oversea Tibetan religious refugees”, none of them speak Tibetan, but the Tibetans from Tibet can all speak their local Tibetan dialogue and Mandarin Chinese. That makes me question a lot.
तिब्बतियों को एक जिले से दूसरे जिले में यात्रा करने की अनुमति नहीं है! यदि यात्रा करना आवश्यक है, तो एसी कार्यालय / तालुक कार्यालय से विशेष प्राधिकरण प्राप्त करना होगा। बिना पैसे दिए, वही कहानी दोहरायेगा कि कल आना/ साहब नहीं है ! विशेष प्राधिकरण प्राप्त करने के बाद दूसरे जिले में पहुँचने पर तिब्बती को एसपी ऑफिस में जाकर आर.सी. बुक पर मुहर लगवानी पड़ती है और वापस लौटने पर एसपी ऑफिस को सूचित कर आर.सी. बुक पर मुहर लगवानी पड़ती है और जब वापस अपने निवास स्थान पर पहुँचते हैं तो पुलिस स्टेशन जाकर रिपोर्ट दर्ज कर आर.सी. बुक पर मुहर लगवानी पड़ती है। कल्पना कीजिए कि भारत में तिब्बती कितने स्वतंत्र हैं ? 😢😮😢
Tibetan woman pop singer, Alan (Dawa Dolma), performing in front of a live audience. Alan is ethnic Tibetan, born in Kanding, Sichuan(China). The male singer, Tashi Dunzhu, is ethnic Tibetan , born in Kunming, Yunnan(China). ruclips.net/video/kXB7do1qknI/видео.html
On 27 September 1954, the Dalai Lama was selected as a Vice-chairman of the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress, a post he officially held until 1964.
Moral lesson: Beware of a 3 -lettered "intelligence" agency, for it not your friend. Ask those who had the misfortune to be made use of by it. It always lead to regret and remorse.
Even among Indians of primary color there are prejudice, discrimination root in Hindu religion. What to speak of secondary color of other minority populations different from Hindu religion who are unconsciously and silently being discriminated. Being born as human beings itself have to struggle hard for livelihood. This planet earth is the abode of suffering.
Tibetans in India better prospects returning to Tibet, China. Well developed with modern infrastructure development and well treated by the Chinese government. China allows the Tibetans to retain and promote their culture and freedom of practising Buddhism.
they wont tell you that most left Tibetans were actually went back to china nowadays you will have the opportunity to meet some Tibetans in china who speak english pretty well, and they grew up in India. India has lost over half of its Tibetan population, soon they are all gonna leave
A true Indian Brothers and Sisters will definitely understand the circumstances. ..and especially living a life as an refugee is hard though .....all the Struggles and Hustles our parents had from day 1 since they as an refugee came to this holy land ... from our childhood to adult , to school , colleges and universities and upbringing ....these were not easy at all...... ... ... ..but i am prity sure Indians will know what this is all about and why so many Tibetans youngsters flying abroad.... Please Remember always ... Our love , Gratitude to our mother land India will never be replaced. Our emotion , Respect and loyal to India will never be shattered ... Jai Bharat Mata ki 💐🙏 Jai Tibat 💐🙏
India could've granted citizenship i feel. Don't Tibetans have special identity status allows then certain privileges in India? I heard of it last time
“but i am prity sure Indians will know what this is all about and why so many Tibetans youngsters flying abroad” Because you are just refugees, not citizens of India. No one can help you, not even Indians. Indians can't even take care of their own children (35% of children are malnourished). If you are able, you should work overseas and become a citizen of another country.
R.C which is called refugees certificate that has been issued to all the Tibetans by the government of India doesn’t have any value. Airport check post office do not recognize RC at all. They throw it away by saying YHEA KAY HAI It is so sad.
Exile Government say u cant apply passport but tibetan parliamentarians use indian passport.but the truth is most Tibetan living india trying best to migrate to west. But india is very grateful for Tibetan living in india they give so many opportunities to tibetan .
If they can come to the US, they can have multiple citizenship and buy property. My state, West Virginia, has room for all Tibetans in the world, but not the infrastructure. If they could come and build businesses it would be great.
Meanwhile, Kuki Chin refugees from Myanmar are living in Manipur and rest of india as citizen of India with special protection *Schedule Tribe* Kuki refugees are more protected than indigenous peoples of Manipur. India itself is making grave mistakes and doing unfair treatment to its own indigenous people in Manipur.
To be honest, if I were a Tibetan, I'd never think even once to go back to Tibet, China. You people should be very proud for your great country. You won't get anything to be a part of where you are right now.
By the way, I doubt Dalai Lama's wisdom. He should be wise enough as the special one to guide his followers to lead a better life. I don't think he is special at all. Everyone has been fooled.
Tibetans are very good people, very good nature, I am very lucky to have a Tibetan wife Pema Lama. For Good People the World is home, for time being only. Having a citizenship does not mean the world is permanent for anyone. Good souls are free from any boundings, I think, They have higher call.
No matter wherever you move to, you next generation will be a citizen that country. You might be keep your tradition with your identity will change forever.
Yellow hats were outliers even in Tibet. It was Mongolia's Kahn invention of the Dalai Llama and his hordes who invaded the country gave absolute power to the Yellow hats who chose to enslave their people's. Bon
Tibetans in India and nepal are better financially than average locals. Many second generation have got citizenship and are holding positions in govt jobs because they have some how got ST status specially in uttarakhand.But as west gives them visas and green card easily in the name of refugees they always play victim card. I stay near Tibet border and china always welcomes Tibetans and the standard of living is better than average indians and nepali.most of the Tibetan s are high spending people, I don't know where they get money from may be the expatriates send.
Reality is Tibetans in Tibet China is better off culturally, politically, economically than anywhere else. The few Tibetans in India are mere guests India & marginalized in all aspects.
Although we have some difficulties due to our refugees status in India but it’s also fact that we the Tibetan people were,are and will always be grateful to india .long live Indo Tibetan friendship.
These exiles appear leaner than their brethren in China, who look much more well fed. Chinese Tibetans are now doing well, benefitting from massive investment and subsidies by Beijing, domestic tourism and domestic demand for ethnic Tibetan herbs and produce.
I believe that Tibetian should be satisfied to get Indian citizenzip and can go wherever they want such as get the best education, doing business, and own properties. Forget about getting independence for Tibet, it won't happen unless they have to win battles against the Chinese. I believe the young generations should focus on to have a better life and still keep their language and culture or going back to Tibet and get dual citizenzip and live happily forever. Everybody deserve better life and enjoy happiness and to be treated fairly.
I really like to stay with them, found so much peace whenever I used to be around the tibetan monasteries, I liked the calmness of the people too,infact I admired those, I used to miss that environment after I had left my irish Catholic run school and found peace only around the churches and monasteries near himalayas. I hope they do not loose their purity, simplicity and calm mind, even for the sake of livelihood, living or prosperity, those things arre very precious , particularly nowadays, do not loose those qualities/characteristics for anything else. I dont think france would be proper place for them, I think any quieter, less multicultural, mountainous environment would be ideal for them. I can understand why they do not feel comfortable in India. India or at least major parts of it has changed drastically, I dont see any letdown to that, besides people of india are ethnically,genetically different from tibetans and believe me I am sure now that most indians supported tibetans to gain control over the region or to prevent china from gaining control, but there might have been few without such ideas,in any case i never thought India was best option for them, maybe only the hill regions , ladakh was ok but even those places are under increasing strain from mainland indians and i had anticipated that long back.
I hope china will someday understand this longing for peace and loneliness inherent among himalayan people and give Tibetans much more freedom to build their traditional region in their own manner, not in the way coastal china is developed. I dont think same type of thinking, activity is good for all kinds of people
I think Tibetans should try to assimilate into Indian society. It will be hard to maintain a distinct identity from the majority. Assimilation does not mean you cannot speak your own language and practise your own traditions. If they want a,better life, you need to be able to communicate and mingle with the majority.
We all feel sorry for the thousands of innocent Tibetans who blindly followed and fled Tibet on false promises but now decades later find themselves and their offspring in a state of cultural and economic limbo facing discrimination racism statelessness jobless and at best 2nd class citizens perhaps worse than those in Manipur Is it possible in the future for these people to be accepted back to their homeland?
Because their parents still hold Tibetan citizenship. For non-Indians, just being born in India does not make one an Indian citizen The parents have a choice to give their children their own citizenship or else apply for Indian citizenship
Though life is little difficult and different tn Indian. But as Tibetan….. India is best country in world… wr u will feel home….. people might leave for better opportunities and for betterment of their family…. Work in abroad hard to support the family here in India. But ask which country is best to them???? It’s always India in their heart…. India is our home…. It wont change…. How can you betray delicious foods😂
They live in India as refugees while Tibetan in China have all human rights to live as Chinese citizen. I saw them in Lez and ladak and China Tibetan Autonomous. Tibetans in India are just the play chesses of CIA and Western regime.
No less loyal to both govt , we want to live like fully independent n full freedom with full democracy n power to enjoy all liberties like own countries and real citizen of any country where we born n off course livelihood
You were living your life as a slaveowner in tibet once, so you are not welcomed back according the ordinary Tibetans who finally get rid of your caste system and have wealth and dignity to live their peacefully.
If India does not give citizenship to those ethnic Tibetans born in India after 1987, they will become a community of stateless people in India. Stateless people are the most vulnerable people in the world, with the least opportunity. Their cause? It has been long lost. Looking ahead, the world will be very turbulent. The world is facing the impact of the Information Age, global warming, radical change to the world order. Each one of these can turn the world upside down by itself and the world has to deal with all of them at the same time. How many people in the world are going to pay attention to the Tibetan cause? These people are wise to leave India and settle in the West. Get a citizenship while you can. You do not want to be a stateless person anywhere.
I' m very Thankful for India for giving us place to stay and we called it Home. I'm born n brought up in South India. i loved my birth place. I came to US for my better future n for my family. As most of the Indian to do that too. Also i heard those Tibetans who got Indian Citizenship can't buy land like Indian. I think there are restriction on Tibetan Indian citizenships its not same like others Indians. Personally i never applied for it. I hope Indian gov allow the same rules to the Tibetans who want to become Indian citizenship. These way it will open more doors to the young Tibetans. Jai Hind and Jai Tibet.
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
Dalai's second brother, Jia Le Dunzhu wrote a confession that the biggest mistake in his life is to collaborate with the CIA.（The Noodle Maker of Kalimpong - The untold story of my struggle for Tibet)
Hahaha cia? What an idiot. He's lucky he's alive to tell the story
Trump already said the mainstream media is FAKE NEWS. And Gaza proofs that.
Just translate Tibet into Chinese, search on RUclips, see for yourself.
U don't even need to understand what they are saying, just look around. U will understand hypocrisy of western media.
In the era of social media, the fake news couldn't hide. And AI large language model can also help in translate and summarize a vedio or news around the globe.
You mean Gyalo Thondup....
First write his name properly. Gyallo Dhondup.
During the construction of the Sichuan-Tibet Highway and the Qinghai-Tibet Highway by the Chinese government, more than 3,000 soldiers and civilians sacrificed their precious lives. The two highways are more than 4,360 kilometers long, starting from Chengdu in the east, Xining in the north, and Lhasa in the south. They are important passages connecting Tibet and the mainland. During the construction process, many road construction soldiers and staff sacrificed their lives in the face of difficulties such as high temperatures, hypoxia, complex geology, and material shortages. Especially on the Erlang Mountain section, an average of 7 soldiers sacrificed their lives per kilometer. The victims are all Han people, and the beneficiaries are Tibetan compatriots. When these wandering Tibetans try to split Tibet, you should first ask the Tibetans whether they agree. If you have watched the Tibet video, you should know the current urban environment in Tibet. Chinese farmers and herdsmen all own land and pastures. They do not need to pay any fees to the state. Instead, the state will provide various subsidies such as food, fertilizers, and machinery. They They enjoy more preferential policies and benefits than Han people.
The McMahon Line was first drafted in 1913, and the treaty to ratify them (Simla Accords) was never signed by the Republic Of China(ROC) who had just overthrown the Qing dynasty. There was no such thing as the McMahon Line in 1890, and China isn't disputing where the Line was drawn, she's disputing the validity of the Line in its entirety. The primary Indian claim is that the ROC did sign the Simla Accords because a British official called Olaf Caroe fabricated a narrative in 1938 where the ROC signed the Simla Accords (they didn't) and ceded parts of Tibet to the Raj.
In 1963 a British diplomat compared a pre-1938 treaties compendium with the post-Caroe compendium and found that Caroe had changed the note on the ROC's not signing the Simla Accords into one where the ROC signed it and considers the Indo-Tibetan border finalised. Nehru picked up a copy of Caroe's fabricated compendium so he got the impression that his country was legally entitled to more than she actually was. Compounding this was the US' decision to add fuel to the flames by declaring the McMahon Line as the legitimate boundary in an attempt to contain the spread of communism, despite reservations from the US State Department and protests from the fiercely non-communist Chiang Kai-Shek, leader of the ROC.
However, we all know Nehru irreversibly altered his country's relations with China in 1962, so by 1963, when the fabrication was discovered, it was already too late to stem the tide of Indian nationalism based on the false compendium entry. And that leaves us with the situation today, in the aftermath of a British attempt to de jure carve out a piece of Chinese territory which failed but had some success de facto, then a British fabrication of her failed attempt to carve out Chinese territory, then an Indian acceptance of the British fabrication alongside American endorsement, and a Chinese refusal to accept the fabrication as anything remotely legal.
Some Indians recognise that they don't actually have a legal claim to South Tibet, so they've begun using a different claim in that the people living in South Tibet want to be part of India more than China; in essence, a claim based on the principle of self-determination. This is India's secondary claim. However, as history has shown time and time again (Catalonia, Confederate States, Taiwan, Corsica, Chechnya, Tibet, Naxalites), without the permission of the larger body, a smaller section of the population will not be allowed to separate from its original country regardless of what they want.
A much more detailed account of the McMahon Line and its history is available here, written by Peter Lee who, contrary to impressions given by his surname, is not at all Chinese.
It's a hidden fact almost 80% of Tibetian in India have indian citizenship because its the most easiest way to get one through undertable channels. Tibetians refugees are among the most diluated communities supported by Western opportunist who want to see China downfall. I have visited China and Tibet thrice in 2024 and plan to go again next month to Lhasa one of best place I always love to visit. This tibetians refugees influx has been growing yearly and taking HHDL excuse still many tibetians cross over Himalayes every year. China has given them so much and who are still in Tibet don't like to call them Tibetians instead they love calling them chinese of Tibetian origin and if one see the present day Tibet, its just mind blowing. This tibetian hoax will remain till HHDL is alive thenafter this people who called them tibetian refugees will slowly devolve in India as Indians. Tibetians are the most unfriendly people ever seen outside of Tibet, if not one can try them weather in US, Europe or in Asia.
No one asked you to come into Tibet! If a robber dies while trying to rob a bank, is it the bank’s fault? Obviously not. So why should we feel grateful for the intruder who died on the way?
He is Half Indian and Half Cowboy ( pretending to be an American)! 😂
@tibetmusicvideos7593
Robbers Rob and take...
The Han intruder gave Tibet billions dollars worth of infrastructure, hospital and schools !!!.
Your childrens and great grand childrens will benefit greatly. At least they are born free and not born a serf.
Tibetan youths are realistic to leave. Looking at changes between India and China, already told you the future is not sweet and tough. India cannot even provide a proper living standard for their own Indian race, let alone Tibetans.
No, this not it they are following the Prophecy laid out but the Lotus Born Buddha that Tibetans will scatter like ants in wind and land in land people with red faces.
@@Madame702 Sorry, Madame, we are in different wavelength, you are living in mythical world while I am in a realistic world. Good luck to you and Goodness the Tibetan youths didn't think like you.
@@teogeorge2203 Don't be silly. You cannot escape your Karma. You want to be successful you seek out material things of this world. Then you need to make offering to the Buddhas of the three times and ten directions. Much wealth will come to you if that is what you seek. The Tibetans know how to make offering to the Nagas that bring rain and wealth if that what you seek. They have powerful wealth deities like Jambhala he married a Naga Princess who give him her "Wishfulling Jewel" that grants wishes, but you must have great generosity and compassion in this life and previous lives then and only then will it manifest your good Karma in form of Wealth if that that what you want.
@@teogeorge2203 Just remember Tony Robbins was born a very poor man. He gave food on thanksgiving, to needy families and keep doing so. Right now his organization feed over a million needy families every thanksgiving. His positive Kama has made him a rich man. You can do "Sur" offering to spirits suffering in this world and next. That too bring much joy and positive Karma as well.
@@Madame702 You believe then you should be doing, not ask others to do. Believe in your calling.
Tibetans in India looks skinnier and smaller than those in China. Maybe food in India isn't as varied and palatable with those in China.
nope....
Not true.. Nevertheless we Tibetans would rather be free than get fed in prison..
China can never be varied and palatable in terms of food. Not even in dreams in comparison to India. CCP thug
@@Tzchoedak Not True. Nobody gets lock up for no reasons like every countries in the world. Besides Chinese Tibetan dressed many times better, enjoying life with 1st world amenities, more tastier foods, top rate medical care, etc. They also like dancing in city squares and parks. That is why Chinese Tibetan are a lot healthier and bigger size than the smaller built Tibetans in India.
@@jacku8304
Looks is not a big deal. Freedom is what matters the most.
The average income of Tibetans in China is 3 times the average income of Indians.
95% of Tibetans in China are cover by Medical insurance.
37% of Indians are cover by Medical insurance.
There is a new sports stadium in Lhasa that can seat 22,000 spectators.
🦉
These people should go back to their own place in China. Xinjiang has developed a lot in recent times.
Are you saying Tibetan is better off in china than India?
Tibetans face even more racism in Tibet than India. Majority of business in Tibet are owned by Han Chinese. They only employ and do business with other Han Chinese. So the majority of the wealth in Tibet is pooled within the Han Chinese population not the Tibetans.
Yes man he is right,
I am indian, this place is big sh-it@@michaelsomething7674
@@lobsangchodon3031so true what you said. Tibetans in Tibet has no fundamental rights like freedom of religion, freedom of religion ..
after 70 years living under the Dala Lama’s teaching, hatred kept shimmering and nurtured. With that kind of bad karma formation, what future prospects can we expect? It’s the exact reason why we study Buddha’s teachings.
Tibetan Buddhism is different from what Buddha taught.
The McMahon Line was first drafted in 1913, and the treaty to ratify them (Simla Accords) was never signed by the Republic Of China(ROC) who had just overthrown the Qing dynasty. There was no such thing as the McMahon Line in 1890, and China isn't disputing where the Line was drawn, she's disputing the validity of the Line in its entirety. The primary Indian claim is that the ROC did sign the Simla Accords because a British official called Olaf Caroe fabricated a narrative in 1938 where the ROC signed the Simla Accords (they didn't) and ceded parts of Tibet to the Raj.
In 1963 a British diplomat compared a pre-1938 treaties compendium with the post-Caroe compendium and found that Caroe had changed the note on the ROC's not signing the Simla Accords into one where the ROC signed it and considers the Indo-Tibetan border finalised. Nehru picked up a copy of Caroe's fabricated compendium so he got the impression that his country was legally entitled to more than she actually was. Compounding this was the US' decision to add fuel to the flames by declaring the McMahon Line as the legitimate boundary in an attempt to contain the spread of communism, despite reservations from the US State Department and protests from the fiercely non-communist Chiang Kai-Shek, leader of the ROC.
However, we all know Nehru irreversibly altered his country's relations with China in 1962, so by 1963, when the fabrication was discovered, it was already too late to stem the tide of Indian nationalism based on the false compendium entry. And that leaves us with the situation today, in the aftermath of a British attempt to de jure carve out a piece of Chinese territory which failed but had some success de facto, then a British fabrication of her failed attempt to carve out Chinese territory, then an Indian acceptance of the British fabrication alongside American endorsement, and a Chinese refusal to accept the fabrication as anything remotely legal.
Some Indians recognise that they don't actually have a legal claim to South Tibet, so they've begun using a different claim in that the people living in South Tibet want to be part of India more than China; in essence, a claim based on the principle of self-determination. This is India's secondary claim. However, as history has shown time and time again (Catalonia, Confederate States, Taiwan, Corsica, Chechnya, Tibet, Naxalites), without the permission of the larger body, a smaller section of the population will not be allowed to separate from its original country regardless of what they want.
A much more detailed account of the McMahon Line and its history is available here, written by Peter Lee who, contrary to impressions given by his surname, is not at all Chinese.
Actually, the Dala Lama listened to the CIA and betrayed his country, those so called refugees are the outcome of that insurrection failure, and the Americans just abandoned those who are useless.
@@Wann-zo7rn2qn4i lol, How do you know? Explain in detail, Did you study Tibetan Buddhism? Don't be a pig, feeding on what master feed you, Most Chinese feed on what communist China(Govt)'s propaganda.
As an outsider and Nepalese national, probably it is not appropriate to suggest Tibetans or Bhotias. However, living close to Tibetan community in harmony in Kathmandu I would like them to reconcile and talk to Chinese Government to return to their homeland. I think Tibetans in Nepal are more reconciled with locals than in India. Reason, Nepalese and Tibetans have many commons. Do not go after democracy and freedom as such which is matter of fact an abstract thing and just a political tool. At the end of day what matters the most is your living and life. Tibet is now more prosperous and livable place in comparison to cities in India and Nepal and better than many EU and US cities. After all Tibet or Bhot is your mother land and you own it. Please reconcile. Use Buddhism - compassion and perseverance in practical life not just as preaching theory. Love from Nepal and best wishes.
Very sensible suggestion to these people whose parents have, in hindsight, made the wrong decision of running away for political reason to India and now finding themselves kind of lost and abandoned in their host country. Yet many of the 2nd and 3rd generation are still brainwashed into holding the dream of fighting for an independent Tibet, a dream that will likely disappoint themselves for the rest of their lives, either fighting from India or other 3rd country and turned into a floating lost tribe drifting with a lost cause to never ever return to Tibet again. That's the sad reality and there are millions and millions of other people around the world like them.
Yes when CCP is controlling everything over you it's good for them. What a good suggestion? A tour guide can't speak about the govt on record in Lhasa. Forget about other things. In wuhan virus time do you remember how CCP locked its people in shenzen ?
You must be a CCP thug
Said again.
No one wants them back, even the local Tibetan people. For local Tibetan people, they will dilute resources, like land, job opportunities, government subsidies, etc. For government, there will be a huge fiscal expenditure.
Not to speak of that they have a different cultural background with local people now.
Well said
A good suggestion
Thats what happen u play with CIA.
Many people talks about cia.but CIA has nothing to do with tibet before china enter in tibet.tibet ask for help at almost end of violence after millions life were taken..donations from aborts for schools and refugees are openly registered and free to cheak .So 95% tibetans refugees are well educated.n fighting with world.not only chiness ..world is already sold..
Exactly. Western journalists tell half truth, hide the cause of the Tibetan riots.
these traitors deserve their karma - for working with CIA
Free Tibet
Better than worshiping Confucius and Marx.
@@Nga_Bhodpa_yeen ruclips.net/video/5vYDQDFVz-c/видео.html
@@Nga_Bhodpa_yeenTibet is free seventy years before. It is you who need to be freed.
@@rivertonhigh-v4tDo ppl worship plato? You think philosopher are gods?
Talk about uneducated
Chins has developed Tibet so much for the Tibetans
Yes, China put tons of money to develop Tibet.
@@michaelgoh9768 Life in Tibet under China is far better than those in the richest state of India especially the infrastructure, security for women and livelihood.
Precisely, I have been both countries during my stint and that's what I have concluded. India needs another 50 years basing on current situation to be on par with China but by then, China will be further far ahead.
Life is better in Tibet, China. Its more developed, living standards are far higher, education and healthcare system is good, infrastructure is world class, economy is far better. Thats why more and more Tibetans are wanting to come back.
, your thinking is crazy.
Let's assume that government give you every convenience
And then said that you can't see, you can't think and can't hear, then whom will you choose?
who has no freedom and is nothing
@@tenten9274
Have you watched " Travel with AK" he visiting Tibet, its opposite what you said
@@tenten9274don't follow western media. I go to Tibet frequently and to my knowledge freedom in Tibet is better than India where you have mob lynching, communal riots and cast and racial discrimination.
@@tenten9274You eat live work in comfort
Not malnourished and dirty
Leave then? None stopping u
Dalai Lama - Tibet is a part of China, said he during an interview with SCMP. Statement confirmed by US Congressional-Executive Commission on China, Mar 15, 2005.
He did say Tibet is part of China, but he wants to be the king of Tibet.
shut up bot
Tibet has been a part of China for the past 60 years since Mao. That's common knowledge.
Even Indians leaving India and moving to Canada
😅only sick people, I mean Sikh people
And Canadians are moving out of Canada.. What a world we lived in! Toronto feels like India nowadays, Indians everywhere 🤣
And these Indians openly "let go" in Canadian beaches...Nice!
@@kolviczd6885 😂😂😂
Also open-defecation everywhere?
I met some Tibetans in France who came from India,they can speak a little mandarin and are very nice people ,almost all of them said that they would earn some money to return to their home country for retirement,of course they would return to china
@@白白-d5x taiwan formosa 1959 Great Leap Forward square Winnie the pooh
Taiwan is also China bro
@@Giles20 China is west Taiwan
@@DavidWayne-w7n A cutthroat rebel province after losing popular support.
@@DavidWayne-w7n Taiwan is just a province in your own constitution also
Return back to Tibet, enjoy, better working condition, good standard of living and free life.
Lamas rule through religion. Every person has to bow their head and lie down,
You can leave whenever you want, come whenever you want, how could such a good thing happen?
想走就走，想来就来，哪有这种好事？
The Dali Lamas is a pedophile.
@@Squirtle-xm6bi 藏人其实一直在回流，国家还是默认的
Been to tibet as a tourist....wow brothers go back to your home land and settle things .
Most of the tibetans and han people are living great life...their language culture is safe and secure.
you are not going to get disappointed.
You are always welcome to Bharath but dont buy westren propaganda and deprive ypurself of homeland.
May avalokiteshwara bless all of you with his wisdom.
It is sad that these Tibetains left a better life in their home country to become refugees in a country with much lower stardard of living because of the propaganda and the deception.
In that case why you guys didn’t stayed under British rule as britishers also developed your nation
@@Hogga91 indians had no dignity or self respect under british raj..
when i spoke with local tibetans they said their language culture and way of life is respected. they said they have better life than their parents and they are providing even more better life for their children.
Its my small observation may be i am wrong
India won't let them to go back to China either, for political reasons. And, those in USA... will send money home to India. Those money is good for India too.
Your sincere concern is appreciated.
Thanks friend.
when you are only being used as an pawn, what can you hope for?
They are leaving India because they can see that the Chinese Tibetan are doing very well and there are lots of Americans propaganda money.
if they are true Buddhist, they should know it is karma and accept it. These are the descendant of serf master or had closed tied with serfdom
@@fannyalbi9040 yes, you are absolutely correct but a lot of Westerners & diaspora still propagate these narrative Free Tibet narrative.
Who can remember Dalai Lama after his demise? Virtually few would want to regard him as a spiritual leader in modern China. There will not be a burial place in Tibet for his remains. Today, Tibetans and Chinese Hans live side by side harmoniously. Those who advocate Tibet independence will be crushed beyond recognition. Like it or not, it is China dictating the rule.
@tklim, in fact any form of separatism regardless tibetan or not, will be dealt with the greatest force. That rule applies to all ethnicity even for the Han majority in Taiwan 😊
hahhaha, In harmoniously? Are you joking? Chinese are oppressing Tibetans and undermining our culture, You Chinese have stolen our land, killed our people, and destroyed our language, we Tibetans are living in fear, We are living at gunpoint. If we have the choice we don't want dog, frog, and mouse eaters to live with us.
@@youngyungdung783 Please post videos of Tibetans being oppressed, don't edit these fake texts
They're better to live in china,than in India because in racial discrimination and social discrimination is prevailing in India than in china because theirs looks and culture are somewhat similar 🎉
With the caste system still inherent in the Indian society whereby Indians discriminate among themselves, what is the chance that non Indians will not be discriminated.
他们在印度都没有合法身份，各种限制，哪像中国的藏族，享受少数民族政策，每年给西藏几百亿元的财政补贴。
they have been quietly going back to China for decades, but no one wants to talk abt it cause its too embarrassing for the CTA and the Dalai Lama
the most followed Tibetan youtuber "Tibet Vista" was one of those exiled Tibetans who went back to china
But china gets the blames for their predicaments. And no, china should never accept people who are hostile.
我在另一个藏族博主评论区才知道。印度藏人没有公民身份，印度禁止办理🚫他们来中国的手续。但是很多印度藏人都想回到中国。全在问那个藏族博主怎么弄到合法文件的。
India should rerurn occupied Tibet land, south Tibet, back to Tibetan, not taking advantage of the Tibetan people.
Should let all those Tibetan in India have south Tibet as their home land like the best soluction.
No worries. China will make sure all those lands that belong to Xizang aka Tibet return back. This Is not the fault of India but it was Britain’s fault that took the land illegally from Xizang.
yes
fat hope. Nothing is possible with India. Corrupt Indian chief every where.
😂occupied by your mouth only😂
Ask china for help Tibetan won't regret by going with china
China doesn't need more headache..........
I mean when Indians themselves are leaving in millions each year, that too of those financially well off and upper class families, what more xan we have xpect from those unfortunate ones.
Chinese are leaving china more than Indian leave India. Son
@@undefeatable17 According to the United Nations, India has one of the largest diasporas in the world, with over 18 million Indians living outside the country as of 2020. This is higher compared to the Chinese diaspora, which is estimated to be around 10 million. Not to mention these figures hv increased more for Indians. Each year, more than half a million are said to leave India & denounce their indian passport. Notably these are families who are financially well off , not middle class or lower class. Millionaires hv also left india in huge numbers and all these datas are highlighted in RUclips & internet by Indian whistle blowers and non govt agencies. Maybe it's time to change leadership. Modi led India has become a living hell for Indians. Next time come with facts plz otherwise go cry in the corner & watch upper middle class and rich Indians leaving india while you chew on cow dunk.
@@TenShinChoejin read report of henley and partners report 2024 . Not CCP Propaganda 😂😂🤣🤣
@@TenShinChoejin 1. China 15200 millionaires left in Henly and Partners 2024 report
2. United Kingdom with 9500
3. India with 4300
@@undefeatable17 so white countries report is more reliable, seems like you haven't learn from your ancestors 😂😂
As someone born and brought up in Dharamsala, it’s impossible for us to see our area without Tibetans. They bring an enigma of fresh area and add a special charm to our land. We’ve always believed they are integral part of our society. We see them as locals and our own. For us someone from Punjab, Haryana, Delhi or any other part of India is an outsider but majority of people in Himachal would call Tibetans as their own people. We have deep rooted love and respect for Tibetan culture and people. HHDL is not only the spiritual and temporal leader of Tibet but he is also our Guru, our guiding light and our God. We wish Govt. of India starts giving Tibetans their due and equal representation now. We also want a free Tibet and see it as our own cause but, we wish that Tibetans should stay in India and have equal rights as long as Tibet doesn’t get freedom. Praying for the well being of our Tibetan friends, brothers and sisters. Long live the Indo Tibetan friendship.
Bhod Gyalo
Tashi Delek
@@rijulshergill i too wish for a free Kashmir/
What is the use of your praying?
Lobby your Indian government to give them full citizenship so that they have the right to buy your land and build a good settlement and can put down roots.
Have you watch " Travel With AK" he visiting Tibet, it's opposite what you said
Who will free Tibet from China? How many Tibetan people are living in India and other countries apart from China?
Do you think these bunch of Tibetan people who are living outside China can bring independence of Tibet by living outside of China?
Amongst these people how many of them are seeking for Tibet independence? Do you have any data? According to His Holiness Dalai Lama he has clarified umpteen times that "he does not seek any independence from China". So on what ground you're advocating for independence of Tibet from China?
Moreover there are 98% of the Tibetan people living in China at the moment. There is no civil unrest going on against the Chinese govt by them.
Therefore, taking all that into account, now you tell me who will free Tibet from China? Why you being a Punjabi is so interested in the independence of Tibet when the majority of Tibetans themselves are not interested in the first place.
This exposes your envious nature towards China.
If language, religion and culture are the criteria for demanding a separate independent nation then what is your take on the Khalistan freedom movement, Kashmir, Nagaland, Assam, Manipur, Mizoram, Meghalaya, Telugu Desam, Kannada desha, Tripura, Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra, Bengal, Sikkim etc?
@@kenkarko5432 as a student of the Buddha’s teachings, my wish is for a free Kashmir. As far as I know about Tibetan Autonomy region, they seemed happy there. Thanks for pointing that out.
Actually India occupy some of the best Tibetan land in terms of agriculture value, wonder why they have never seek for independent from India ?
@@johnso2399 yes, and may be both have same DNA.because most of the refugees are descendants of padmasamvhawa,he was an Aryan
It was suppressed by the Indian government. The Tibetan there loses its independence.
The McMahon Line was first drafted in 1913, and the treaty to ratify them (Simla Accords) was never signed by the Republic Of China(ROC) who had just overthrown the Qing dynasty. There was no such thing as the McMahon Line in 1890, and China isn't disputing where the Line was drawn, she's disputing the validity of the Line in its entirety. The primary Indian claim is that the ROC did sign the Simla Accords because a British official called Olaf Caroe fabricated a narrative in 1938 where the ROC signed the Simla Accords (they didn't) and ceded parts of Tibet to the Raj.
In 1963 a British diplomat compared a pre-1938 treaties compendium with the post-Caroe compendium and found that Caroe had changed the note on the ROC's not signing the Simla Accords into one where the ROC signed it and considers the Indo-Tibetan border finalised. Nehru picked up a copy of Caroe's fabricated compendium so he got the impression that his country was legally entitled to more than she actually was. Compounding this was the US' decision to add fuel to the flames by declaring the McMahon Line as the legitimate boundary in an attempt to contain the spread of communism, despite reservations from the US State Department and protests from the fiercely non-communist Chiang Kai-Shek, leader of the ROC.
However, we all know Nehru irreversibly altered his country's relations with China in 1962, so by 1963, when the fabrication was discovered, it was already too late to stem the tide of Indian nationalism based on the false compendium entry. And that leaves us with the situation today, in the aftermath of a British attempt to de jure carve out a piece of Chinese territory which failed but had some success de facto, then a British fabrication of her failed attempt to carve out Chinese territory, then an Indian acceptance of the British fabrication alongside American endorsement, and a Chinese refusal to accept the fabrication as anything remotely legal.
Some Indians recognise that they don't actually have a legal claim to South Tibet, so they've begun using a different claim in that the people living in South Tibet want to be part of India more than China; in essence, a claim based on the principle of self-determination. This is India's secondary claim. However, as history has shown time and time again (Catalonia, Confederate States, Taiwan, Corsica, Chechnya, Tibet, Naxalites), without the permission of the larger body, a smaller section of the population will not be allowed to separate from its original country regardless of what they want.
A much more detailed account of the McMahon Line and its history is available here, written by Peter Lee who, contrary to impressions given by his surname, is not at all Chinese.
@@Rav01508 Very detailed statement. But I don’t think that the Chinese can ever get the land back because the Indian have swallowed it for too long.
Keep dreaming pal
Go back to Tibet and live happily ever after! 😊😊😊
@dannyboy8850 अगर तिब्बती इन हालात में तिब्बत वापस चले गए तो भारतीय खुश नहीं रहेंगे! चीन तुरंत हमला कर देगा। तिब्बतियों की कृपा से भारत राजनीतिक दृष्टि से ज़्यादा सुरक्षित है। इसलिए भारत सरकार एक खेल खेल रही है। तिब्बत को आज़ाद नहीं होने देना है और न ही उसे वापस जाने देना है, यह उनके अपने फयदे के हित में है। 🤔🤔🤔
No one wants them back, even the local Tibetan people. For local Tibetan people, they will dilute resources, like land, job opportunities, government subsidies, etc. For government, there will be a huge fiscal expenditure.
Not to speak of that they have a different cultural background with local people now.
another chinese
@@konchoksoom1229 If all Tibetans in India go back, then the ownership of the so-called "Aruchal Pradesh" in India will be in question. Therefore, India will definitely impose restrictions on this.
Tibetans in China has special rights for being a minority.
Joke of the day……
@@faithfulshadow really ,I am watching from Tibet now ,Tibetan Chinese are real owner of China ,on the other hand Tibetan Indian have not even one inch of land in India .keep laughing .
@@georgewong1837 动态网自由门 天安門 天安门 法輪功 李洪志 Free Tibet 六四天安門事件 The Tiananmen Square protests of 1989 天安門大屠殺 The Tiananmen Square Massacre 反右派鬥爭 The Anti-Rightist Struggle 大躍進政策 The Great Leap Forward 文化大革命 The Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution 人權 Human Rights 民運 Democratization 自由 Freedom 獨立 Independence 多黨制 Multi-party system 台灣 臺灣 Taiwan Formosa 中華民國 Republic of China 西藏 土伯特 唐古特 Tibet 達賴喇嘛 Dalai Lama 法輪功 Falun Dafa 新疆維吾爾自治區 The Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region 諾貝爾和平獎 Nobel Peace Prize 劉暁波 Liu Xiaobo 民主 言論 思想 反共 反革命 抗議 運動 騷亂 暴亂 騷擾 擾亂 抗暴 平反 維權 示威游行 李洪志 法輪大法 大法弟子 強制斷種 強制堕胎 民族淨化 人體實驗 肅清 胡耀邦 趙紫陽 魏京生 王丹 還政於民 和平演變 激流中國 北京之春 大紀元時報 九評論共産黨 獨裁 專制 壓制 統一 監視 鎮壓 迫害 侵略 掠奪 破壞 拷問 屠殺 活摘器官 誘拐 買賣人口 遊進 走私 毒品 賣淫 春畫 賭博 六合彩 天安門 天安门 法輪功 李洪志 Winnie the Pooh 劉曉波动态网自由门
@@malorybertie8046 动态网自由门 天安門 天安门 法輪功 李洪志 Free Tibet 六四天安門事件 The Tiananmen Square protests of 1989 天安門大屠殺 The Tiananmen Square Massacre 反右派鬥爭 The Anti-Rightist Struggle 大躍進政策 The Great Leap Forward 文化大革命 The Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution 人權 Human Rights 民運 Democratization 自由 Freedom 獨立 Independence 多黨制 Multi-party system 台灣 臺灣 Taiwan Formosa 中華民國 Republic of China 西藏 土伯特 唐古特 Tibet 達賴喇嘛 Dalai Lama 法輪功 Falun Dafa 新疆維吾爾自治區 The Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region 諾貝爾和平獎 Nobel Peace Prize 劉暁波 Liu Xiaobo 民主 言論 思想 反共 反革命 抗議 運動 騷亂 暴亂 騷擾 擾亂 抗暴 平反 維權 示威游行 李洪志 法輪大法 大法弟子 強制斷種 強制堕胎 民族淨化 人體實驗 肅清 胡耀邦 趙紫陽 魏京生 王丹 還政於民 和平演變 激流中國 北京之春 大紀元時報 九評論共産黨 獨裁 專制 壓制 統一 監視 鎮壓 迫害 侵略 掠奪 破壞 拷問 屠殺 活摘器官 誘拐 買賣人口 遊進 走私 毒品 賣淫 春畫 賭博 六合彩 天安門 天安门 法輪功 李洪志 Winnie the Pooh 劉曉波动态网自由门
Keeping aside the history..some people never see through the darkness of foul information..now Tibetans in china have so many benefits for being tibetans..they have priorities more than local chinese people..they are now entrepreneurs, they have businesses opportunities..so much better now..
Their lives are so much better.
Afterall as a third country, I wish china and Tibet find the solution peacefully and do decisions as for mutual benefits..
The world needs peace and harmony..
Tibet is important Buddha land
Thanks!
We are just refugees, wat hope is left wen Indians are struggling in their own country.. We can't buy lands we can't get loans we can't get citizenship even if u are born here.Issues with the travel document which Govt provides us in the embassy n the airport evrytime. what choices are left for us other thn moving.. We love India, it's our second home n i am sure no one wants to leave where they were born n grown up but it's kinda hard to see a better future for our children n family here with so few opportunities. We wish n pray for the better future of india so tht no one hav to leave their family n their country.. Jai Hind🙏
Why?? You can't get citizenship ??? Can you explain??
@@proudgadwali144 born after 87 can't get citizen and, n the ciziten permission to those below starts onli few years back, the pension to the ex vikas army starts few yrs back n there's hugh differences in amount comparing indian army aswell.. We never complained n we are still thankful to India for letting us stay here as our own homland., the fact is it was harder before comparing today, still it's hard to build a better future for our families.. So abroad is the only option left for us. N u knw wat those who went as far as I knw they all miss India..
It's totally understandable. Tibetans are hardworking and generous, they deserve better livelihood. Support from Ladags
@@Tenz43 I don't know about the laws but they should give citizenship to our tibetan brothers the law should be changed , I know obviously everyone will look for their future and their lives , now I got to know why Tibetans are leaving india they are doing job as trash picker in America ,food vendor on streets ,dish washer in restaurant mainly in France it's cruel
If it was in my hand I would have changed the law ,oh that's I have seen Tibetans only live in the areas specifically approved to them like dehradun ,bylakuppe etc
You can get citizenship there are precedents have to work on it . Plenty of opportunity in India one has to study work and compete ! This is india with a huge population !
Tibetans overseas send a lot of money back home, family members still living in India then use this money to build houses. In the two major tibetan settlements, Bylakuppe and Mundgod, you will see brand new houses everywhere. This is a major boon for the local Indian economy. The construction of these houses need a lot of workers which helps with the local employment of Indians, as well as supporting Indian businesses that supply the construction materials.
Lived and studied in India whole my life, but when I applied for the university , I was not eligible and had to apply as a foreigner and paid 5 x. Rampant discrimination and racism in big cities. Look at how North Eastern are treated in Mainland India. I migrated to the US, and from the very first day, people over here made me feel like I belonged here. That feeling I never got in India. I am now well settled and working in Govt. Sector.
India a developing nation ,struggling with the increasing population ,unemployment and poverty . I think India can always ‘help’😅 but cannot take the burden of all the refugees from neighbouring countries like Bangladeshis and Tibetans . I think it’s wrong to not be thankful to India after all these years
Meanwhile, Tibetans in China have increasingly more socio-economic opportunities, healthcare, housing, education, and industrial development throughout the region.
Unfortunately the neglect of South Tibet is due to India's illegal occupation, and Tibetans trapped there, the price for being geopolitical pawns of US imperial designs
" On 27 September 1954, the Dalai Lama was selected as a Vice-chairman of the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress, a post he officially held until 1964. "
Sad
Iam a Naga from Nagaland and I agree with you 100%
Free Arunalcal Pradesh and. SIKKIM
Southern Tibet or Zhang Nan.
There is no such place name as Arunachal
it seems Tibatan in China are MUCH more free than Tibetan in India，at least they can go anywhere they want in China lands
@@叶铎销 u need to dig little deeper to find the answer brother..
pls don't compare India to China. India will come to TOP when it comes for freedom. Every religion practice is allow here. n we all live together with harmony.
Tibetans in Tibet cannot go to next town without Chinese permission! Don’t lie
Don’t even compare India with China…. We might move abroad for better opportunities… as for China. We have to ESCAPE , putting our life on line…
We hv FREEDOM of SPEECH and RELIGION here in India…..
U r using VPN to comment here. Tat speak a LOUD 😂😂😂😂…
@@tenzinpassang5482 Yes, and each religion is "free" to kill the people of any religion they don't like. Look at what is happening in Manipur. These kind of religious unrest and riots and killings would have been stopped by the Chinese government months ago.
If one day, the Tibetans are unfortunate enough to make the people of some other religion angry, and fighting breaks out, don't expect the government to come rescue you.
The Tibetans in China all practised their own religion freely. We see so many travel videos of Tibet made by tourists. How is it not possible to compare with the miserable images in this video?
Most are not 'refugees'. They were born in India to the owners of serfs and their supporters who fled to India.
@@NCM-xy8ow 动态网自由门 天安門 天安门 法輪功 李洪志 Free Tibet 六四天安門事件 The Tiananmen Square protests of 1989 天安門大屠殺 The Tiananmen Square Massacre 反右派鬥爭 The Anti-Rightist Struggle 大躍進政策 The Great Leap Forward 文化大革命 The Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution 人權 Human Rights 民運 Democratization 自由 Freedom 獨立 Independence 多黨制 Multi-party system 台灣 臺灣 Taiwan Formosa 中華民國 Republic of China 西藏 土伯特 唐古特 Tibet 達賴喇嘛 Dalai Lama 法輪功 Falun Dafa 新疆維吾爾自治區 The Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region 諾貝爾和平獎 Nobel Peace Prize 劉暁波 Liu Xiaobo 民主 言論 思想 反共 反革命 抗議 運動 騷亂 暴亂 騷擾 擾亂 抗暴 平反 維權 示威游行 李洪志 法輪大法 大法弟子 強制斷種 強制堕胎 民族淨化 人體實驗 肅清 胡耀邦 趙紫陽 魏京生 王丹 還政於民 和平演變 激流中國 北京之春 大紀元時報 九評論共産黨 獨裁 專制 壓制 統一 監視 鎮壓 迫害 侵略 掠奪 破壞 拷問 屠殺 活摘器官 誘拐 買賣人口 遊進 走私 毒品 賣淫 春畫 賭博 六合彩 天安門 天安门 法輪功 李洪志 Winnie the Pooh 劉曉波动态网自由门
Tibetans in India are not appreciated and India just takes advantage of them and HHDL. They would do best to leave and move on to having a wonderful life. India does not allow Tibetans any real rights whatsoever, despite pretending they do everything for them. The violence against them is rife and getting worse. The corruption within India affects the Tibetan diaspora terribly. Places like Dharamshala- McLeod have been taken over by outsiders. India does not allow Tibetans their rights to citizenship, despite claiming they're ENTITLED to it... or to vote or own property in India. India needs to stop pretending life is good for Tibetans in India.
Talk about how Tibetans are even sometimes returning to Tibet. Tibetans want to live their lives in peace. The idea that people are afraid to take up citizenship in India is incorrect, as they are taking up citizenship in other countries where they have great opportunities and are welcomed.
Why would Tibetans want to be citizens in a country that does not accept them nor value them, despite their incredible support of their adopted country India. TCV also gives education to non Tibetan children.
India's policies are corrupt and abusive. Look at how many Indian nationals leave India!
chinese ccp troll extolling the virtues of ccp when PRC are running away from
china to go to America,canada, australia,new zealand even malaysia ,singapore etc
Tibetans living in India are not immigrants or refugees. They can live in Tibetan lands such as Ladakh,Anunachal(southern Tibet), Sikkim, Dharamsala. Although these lands are ruled by India and have been Indianized
India government should release these mentioned lands back to the Tibetan refugees to form an independent country of Tibet because these lands were originally belonging to the Tibet.
Occupied Nan-Zang
Then what’s the difference. One is rule by China and the other by India.
They are doing good here in our place ,all are doing business, they are educated,rich and very disciplined people. Maybe for a better opportunity they are doing this . Many Indians are also doing the same.
They should move to Arunachal Pradesh. They will feel at home. It is part of Tibet.
Ladakh is part of tibet arunachal is not .
中国也不会欢迎他们，就让他们慢慢印度化以后变成彻彻底底的印度人吧😂😂😂@@user-ausabc2024
At this rate of migration 70% of Tibetans in India, Nepal and Bhutan will be migrated to abroad. Tibetan communities in US and EU are getting much bigger & stronger than in india day by day.
Every state has different laws for the Tibetans in India. In
Himachal Tibetans are facing lots of difficulties and challenges because local are so jealous we can not owned a taxi, list goes on…
They forgot by the grace of His Holiness The 14 th Dalai Lama of Tibet, Dharmsala has became one of the international tourist spot.
Miya Bangladeshi gets free pass but
Our dearest Tibetian brothers dont get indian citizenship.
Indian government should give them
Special relief .
I am afraid the Tibetan refugees may have followed the wrong leaders leading to wrong path. The current leadership lacks vision and ambition to bring happiness and human growth in this modern time. It could be better for all Tibetan refugees to return home and settle down and rebuild Tibet to greater prosperity and happiness to the people rather mired in stalemate without hope and future.
Not sure if this is covered in this video, but the biggest problem for young Tibetans is traveling abroad as a tibetan.
Indian govt issues a travel document called Identity Certificate(not Indian passport).
It takes around 6 months for this travel document to be issued, and it also takes greasing some palms in Indian bureaucracy.
The document is valid for 10 yrs, the renewal also takes same time and effort.
The foreign embassies don’t like issuing visa on this document
Tibetans who eventually get a visa then must again go through Indian bureaucracy to get exit permit and a return to India permit.
Overall, it makes travelling very unpleasant experience for Tibetans, and this also makes awkward conversation for Tibetans working in private sector as they can’t travel on short notice.
Why donot they go back to their own Homeland and serve their Tibet and fight in your own area in Tibet,
Go to anywhere no problem.
They have two loyalty unbelievea le .
France beware
Another difficulty is the language barrier.
It is a sad story, a tragic story. India granted political asylum to the Dalai Lama but it is now evident, the process had only very limited aim: the aim to embarrass China. Had the Tibetans realised that, they would not have stayed on in India, which offered them no opportunity to flourish or prosper. If, on the other hand, when international sympathy was very high in favour of the Tibetans, they could have sought scholarships from universities in Europe and America and garnered tremendous benefits. Even now, instead of just seeking avenues open individually, His Holiness the Dalai Lama could obtain help for collective benefit. Everyone does not need to be a Lama; let them turn professionals, scientists. academicians; the sky is the limit.
The Dalai wants to keep them poor and ignorant. Easier to control them. He hasn't done anything good for them, not even fight for better living conditions and status from India.
He expressed a wish to return to China himself but he doesn't do anything to try and reconcile with China at least to do something for the younger generation. What is going to happen to them when he dies?
@@PChan-yt4uf "The History" is actually quite different from what the media has spread. The insitution of the Dalai Lama" was established by the Celestial Emperor and had appointed two Ambans in Lhasa to assist the Dalai Lama in governance of the country. Likewise, the office of the Panchen Lama was also the gift of the Chinese Emperor, so that while the Dalai Lama looked after the Government of Tibet, the Panchen Lama was appointed as the spiritual head of the country. To afford him greater prominance, the Panchen Lama was ordained to be the spiritual mentor also of the Chinese Emperor. If we are to view the geo-political situation in Tibet in true perspective, this is the first lesson needed to be taught, worldwide. Rest can follow.
@@jimmy2263 Yes. That's why I said the Dalai hasn't done anything worthy for his people.
@@PChan-yt4uf It is my understanding that the massive changes between the Tibet he had left behind and the Tibet now stands as a prosperous land will itself deter him to want to return to Tibet. However, if some individual Tibetans are allowed to return to Tibet and see for themselves how an average Tibetan is enjoying the benefit of modernisation, it will help Tibet stabilise itself without any coersion. This is my personal opinion as I myself am living in exile in USA.
@@jimmy2263 Maybe you can help them to make peace and leave the past behind. At least the younger generation might have a chance to belong somewhere and make a better life.
The McMahon Line was first drafted in 1913, and the treaty to ratify them (Simla Accords) was never signed by the Republic Of China(ROC) who had just overthrown the Qing dynasty. There was no such thing as the McMahon Line in 1890, and China isn't disputing where the Line was drawn, she's disputing the validity of the Line in its entirety. The primary Indian claim is that the ROC did sign the Simla Accords because a British official called Olaf Caroe fabricated a narrative in 1938 where the ROC signed the Simla Accords (they didn't) and ceded parts of Tibet to the Raj.
In 1963 a British diplomat compared a pre-1938 treaties compendium with the post-Caroe compendium and found that Caroe had changed the note on the ROC's not signing the Simla Accords into one where the ROC signed it and considers the Indo-Tibetan border finalised. Nehru picked up a copy of Caroe's fabricated compendium so he got the impression that his country was legally entitled to more than she actually was. Compounding this was the US' decision to add fuel to the flames by declaring the McMahon Line as the legitimate boundary in an attempt to contain the spread of communism, despite reservations from the US State Department and protests from the fiercely non-communist Chiang Kai-Shek, leader of the ROC.
However, we all know Nehru irreversibly altered his country's relations with China in 1962, so by 1963, when the fabrication was discovered, it was already too late to stem the tide of Indian nationalism based on the false compendium entry. And that leaves us with the situation today, in the aftermath of a British attempt to de jure carve out a piece of Chinese territory which failed but had some success de facto, then a British fabrication of her failed attempt to carve out Chinese territory, then an Indian acceptance of the British fabrication alongside American endorsement, and a Chinese refusal to accept the fabrication as anything remotely legal.
Some Indians recognise that they don't actually have a legal claim to South Tibet, so they've begun using a different claim in that the people living in South Tibet want to be part of India more than China; in essence, a claim based on the principle of self-determination. This is India's secondary claim. However, as history has shown time and time again (Catalonia, Confederate States, Taiwan, Corsica, Chechnya, Tibet, Naxalites), without the permission of the larger body, a smaller section of the population will not be allowed to separate from its original country regardless of what they want.
A much more detailed account of the McMahon Line and its history is available here, written by Peter Lee who, contrary to impressions given by his surname, is not at all Chinese.
@@Rav01508 Six north eastern Indian states around Assam have been fighting for independence for decades. They don’t consider themselves Indians. When these states obtain their independence, South Tibet or Zang Nan will be returned to China.
Very informative. Thank you.
It is right. You should quite The Himalayan Challenge as reference. But now things have change and China can’t be allowed to hv Tibet and the water & mineral resources with the expansionist approach. Atleast what’s left of it must be protected.
another chinese spreading propaganda for CCP
I have encountered a few so called “oversea Tibetan religious refugees”, none of them speak Tibetan, but the Tibetans from Tibet can all speak their local Tibetan dialogue and Mandarin Chinese.
That makes me question a lot.
Indians are leaving india in droves, why not Tibetans?
.......no status= no passport
तिब्बतियों को एक जिले से दूसरे जिले में यात्रा करने की अनुमति नहीं है! यदि यात्रा करना आवश्यक है, तो एसी कार्यालय / तालुक कार्यालय से विशेष प्राधिकरण प्राप्त करना होगा। बिना पैसे दिए, वही कहानी दोहरायेगा कि कल आना/ साहब नहीं है ! विशेष प्राधिकरण प्राप्त करने के बाद दूसरे जिले में पहुँचने पर तिब्बती को एसपी ऑफिस में जाकर आर.सी. बुक पर मुहर लगवानी पड़ती है और वापस लौटने पर एसपी ऑफिस को सूचित कर आर.सी. बुक पर मुहर लगवानी पड़ती है और जब वापस अपने निवास स्थान पर पहुँचते हैं तो पुलिस स्टेशन जाकर रिपोर्ट दर्ज कर आर.सी. बुक पर मुहर लगवानी पड़ती है। कल्पना कीजिए कि भारत में तिब्बती कितने स्वतंत्र हैं ? 😢😮😢
इतना बढ़ा चढ़ा कर पेश मत करो।
Tibetan woman pop singer, Alan (Dawa Dolma), performing in front of a live audience.
Alan is ethnic Tibetan, born in Kanding, Sichuan(China).
The male singer, Tashi Dunzhu, is ethnic Tibetan , born in Kunming, Yunnan(China).
ruclips.net/video/kXB7do1qknI/видео.html
On 27 September 1954, the Dalai Lama was selected as a Vice-chairman of the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress, a post he officially held until 1964.
Special treatment only for those with suspicious background. Cannot be too careful. Everyone wants to maintain the peace.
我一直以为在印度的藏人可以在印度任何地方旅行,没有想到这么麻烦;
以现在的身份回西藏很难,有能力还是去其它国家发展吧!以第三国的身份回西藏;
在印度这个国100年后你们还是无法改变什么,说好了你们是难民,说不好听的你们是印度与中国谈判的人质,所以努力吧!至少让孩子离开印度;
Moral lesson: Beware of a 3 -lettered "intelligence" agency, for it not your friend. Ask those who had the misfortune to be made use of by it. It always lead to regret and remorse.
Even among Indians of primary color there are prejudice, discrimination root in Hindu religion. What to speak of secondary color of other minority populations different from Hindu religion who are unconsciously and silently being discriminated. Being born as human beings itself have to struggle hard for livelihood. This planet earth is the abode of suffering.
Show me where in Hinduism it says to discriminate against others? If you have problems with Hindus, then you are free to leave India.
Tibetans in India better prospects returning to Tibet, China. Well developed with modern infrastructure development and well treated by the Chinese government. China allows the Tibetans to retain and promote their culture and freedom of practising Buddhism.
South Tibet is their home land. They should stay.
Homeland controlled by India where they are mistreated
To all the Tibetans in India. Please stay there and don’t go back to Tibet. You are living in Dalai Lama’s 香格里拉。
At the beginning of the video, those children who play games speak Mandarin in China.😂😂😂
Tibetan are welcome to come back to their homeland
完全不欢迎，他们回来，就会是新疆未来动乱的根源。
@@shuailou9189 仍然留在印度的百分百都是原农奴的后代，他们在印度出生长大，已经生活了两三代了，通晓印度的各地方言，心里面的祖国是出生并长大的印度，实际上成了和中国藏族完全不一样的另一个民族了，让他们搬回到青藏高原生活已经不可能了，重返青藏高原生活对他们来说只不过是叶公好龙。
Tibet had advanced so much and it is a pity that these refugees in India can never go home.
Dollar Lama is very powerful. He can choose his next rebirth in China and becomes Emperor.
they wont tell you that most left Tibetans were actually went back to china
nowadays you will have the opportunity to meet some Tibetans in china who speak english pretty well, and they grew up in India.
India has lost over half of its Tibetan population, soon they are all gonna leave
A true Indian Brothers and Sisters will definitely understand the circumstances. ..and especially living a life as an refugee is hard though .....all the Struggles and Hustles our parents had from day 1 since they as an refugee came to this holy land ... from our childhood to adult , to school , colleges and universities and upbringing ....these were not easy at all...... ... ... ..but i am prity sure Indians will know what this is all about and why so many Tibetans youngsters flying abroad....
Please Remember always ...
Our love , Gratitude to our mother land India will never be replaced. Our emotion , Respect and loyal to India will never be shattered ...
Jai Bharat Mata ki 💐🙏
Jai Tibat 💐🙏
India could've granted citizenship i feel. Don't Tibetans have special identity status allows then certain privileges in India? I heard of it last time
“but i am prity sure Indians will know what this is all about and why so many Tibetans youngsters flying abroad” Because you are just refugees, not citizens of India. No one can help you, not even Indians. Indians can't even take care of their own children (35% of children are malnourished). If you are able, you should work overseas and become a citizen of another country.
We have our own Tibetans. You belong to India now
R.C which is called refugees certificate that has been issued to all the Tibetans by the government of India doesn’t have any value.
Airport check post office do not recognize RC at all. They throw it away by saying YHEA KAY HAI
It is so sad.
This old monk become A west propaganda....
Exile Government say u cant apply passport but tibetan parliamentarians use indian passport.but the truth is most Tibetan living india trying best to migrate to west. But india is very grateful for Tibetan living in india they give so many opportunities to tibetan .
If they can come to the US, they can have multiple citizenship and buy property. My state, West Virginia, has room for all Tibetans in the world, but not the infrastructure. If they could come and build businesses it would be great.
Hope they won't become victims of hate crimes done by white extremests there.
Meanwhile, Kuki Chin refugees from Myanmar are living in Manipur and rest of india as citizen of India with special protection *Schedule Tribe* Kuki refugees are more protected than indigenous peoples of Manipur. India itself is making grave mistakes and doing unfair treatment to its own indigenous people in Manipur.
To be honest, if I were a Tibetan, I'd never think even once to go back to Tibet, China. You people should be very proud for your great country. You won't get anything to be a part of where you are right now.
By the way, I doubt Dalai Lama's wisdom. He should be wise enough as the special one to guide his followers to lead a better life. I don't think he is special at all. Everyone has been fooled.
GDP per capita of Tibet in 2023 is USD9,315. India's is USD2,239. 4 times higher.
Tibetans are very good people, very good nature, I am very lucky to have a Tibetan wife Pema Lama. For Good People the World is home, for time being only. Having a citizenship does not mean the world is permanent for anyone. Good souls are free from any boundings, I think, They have higher call.
Young Men, please choose between Ideology vs Reality !
Achieve your Dream while still living on this Earth.
No matter wherever you move to, you next generation will be a citizen that country. You might be keep your tradition with your identity will change forever.
Yellow hats were outliers even in Tibet. It was Mongolia's Kahn invention of the Dalai Llama and his hordes who invaded the country gave absolute power to the Yellow hats who chose to enslave their people's. Bon
As i am Indian🇮🇳, i want to find better jobs in Foreign countries
That's normal human nature.
Tibetans in India and nepal are better financially than average locals. Many second generation have got citizenship and are holding positions in govt jobs because they have some how got ST status specially in uttarakhand.But as west gives them visas and green card easily in the name of refugees they always play victim card. I stay near Tibet border and china always welcomes Tibetans and the standard of living is better than average indians and nepali.most of the Tibetan s are high spending people, I don't know where they get money from may be the expatriates send.
因为西藏只有300万人藏族人，西藏之外有13亿中国人，去西藏旅游都能带来不错的收入，西藏人可以自己开民宿开参观种植水果种植药养牦牛卖给藏地以外的中国地区这是多么大的市场😂😂😂😂
Even Noth east India do not have That Options as we do not Know HINDI.
Reality is Tibetans in Tibet China is better off culturally, politically, economically than anywhere else. The few Tibetans in India are mere guests India & marginalized in all aspects.
Although we have some difficulties due to our refugees status in India but it’s also fact that we the Tibetan people were,are and will always be grateful to india .long live Indo Tibetan friendship.
you must be descendent of one of those former landowners who enslaved other Tibetans.
@@shineluvslambiel all I can say is I really wish you a happy,healthy and peaceful life.may god
(whoever you believe in )bless your heart.🙏🙏🙏
👍. Then you should live in your beloved country, India for the rest of your life.
所以为什么要离开印度？
I think Chinese Tibetans will be the first to object after all the harm these people have done to them
These exiles appear leaner than their brethren in China, who look much more well fed. Chinese Tibetans are now doing well, benefitting from massive investment and subsidies by Beijing, domestic tourism and domestic demand for ethnic Tibetan herbs and produce.
I believe that Tibetian should be satisfied to get Indian citizenzip and can go wherever they want such as get the best education, doing business, and own properties. Forget about getting independence for Tibet, it won't happen unless they have to win battles against the Chinese. I believe the young generations should focus on to have a better life and still keep their language and culture or going back to Tibet and get dual citizenzip and live happily forever. Everybody deserve better life and enjoy happiness and to be treated fairly.
I really like to stay with them, found so much peace whenever I used to be around the tibetan monasteries, I liked the calmness of the people too,infact I admired those, I used to miss that environment after I had left my irish Catholic run school and found peace only around the churches and monasteries near himalayas.
I hope they do not loose their purity, simplicity and calm mind, even for the sake of livelihood, living or prosperity, those things arre very precious , particularly nowadays, do not loose those qualities/characteristics for anything else.
I dont think france would be proper place for them, I think any quieter, less multicultural, mountainous environment would be ideal for them.
I can understand why they do not feel comfortable in India. India or at least major parts of it has changed drastically, I dont see any letdown to that, besides people of india are ethnically,genetically different from tibetans and believe me I am sure now that most indians supported tibetans to gain control over the region or to prevent china from gaining control, but there might have been few without such ideas,in any case i never thought India was best option for them, maybe only the hill regions , ladakh was ok but even those places are under increasing strain from mainland indians and i had anticipated that long back.
I hope china will someday understand this longing for peace and loneliness inherent among himalayan people and give Tibetans much more freedom to build their traditional region in their own manner, not in the way coastal china is developed. I dont think same type of thinking, activity is good for all kinds of people
India have more Bangladeshi and Rohingyas to Tibetan
I think Tibetans should try to assimilate into Indian society. It will be hard to maintain a distinct identity from the majority. Assimilation does not mean you cannot speak your own language and practise your own traditions. If they want a,better life, you need to be able to communicate and mingle with the majority.
那他们回西藏放弃独立可以过比在印度更好的生活
We all feel sorry for the thousands of innocent Tibetans who blindly followed and fled Tibet on false promises but now decades later find themselves and their offspring in a state of cultural and economic limbo facing discrimination racism statelessness jobless and at best 2nd class citizens perhaps worse than those in Manipur
Is it possible in the future for these people to be accepted back to their homeland?
Many Indians themselves have problems looking for jobs and future, so why would Tibetan refugees be treated different?
Why did India decide to deny Tibetans, who are born in India, their citizenship?
What is the reason behind this law?
Because their parents still hold Tibetan citizenship.
For non-Indians, just being born in India does not make one an Indian citizen
The parents have a choice to give their children their own citizenship or else apply for Indian citizenship
Being man handle is not an experience any youth would want by lama himself.
Though life is little difficult and different tn Indian.
But as Tibetan…..
India is best country in world… wr u will feel home…..
people might leave for better opportunities and for betterment of their family…. Work in abroad hard to support the family here in India.
But ask which country is best to them???? It’s always India in their heart….
India is our home…. It wont change…. How can you betray delicious foods😂
India sucks
。。。。。。。。你是藏族吗？连自己的文字都不会写了吗？
not only delicious ,but also clean .
They live in India as refugees while Tibetan in China have all human rights to live as Chinese citizen. I saw them in Lez and ladak and China Tibetan Autonomous.
Tibetans in India are just the play chesses of CIA and Western regime.
No less loyal to both govt , we want to live like fully independent n full freedom with full democracy n power to enjoy all liberties like own countries and real citizen of any country where we born n off course livelihood
You were living your life as a slaveowner in tibet once, so you are not welcomed back according the ordinary Tibetans who finally get rid of your caste system and have wealth and dignity to live their peacefully.
If India does not give citizenship to those ethnic Tibetans born in India after 1987, they will become a community of stateless people in India. Stateless people are the most vulnerable people in the world, with the least opportunity. Their cause? It has been long lost.
Looking ahead, the world will be very turbulent. The world is facing the impact of the Information Age, global warming, radical change to the world order. Each one of these can turn the world upside down by itself and the world has to deal with all of them at the same time. How many people in the world are going to pay attention to the Tibetan cause?
These people are wise to leave India and settle in the West. Get a citizenship while you can. You do not want to be a stateless person anywhere.
Even Indians are leaving India and moving abroad,why would Tibetan refugees stay there
I' m very Thankful for India for giving us place to stay and we called it Home. I'm born n brought up in South India. i loved my birth place. I came to US for my better future n for my family. As most of the Indian to do that too. Also i heard those Tibetans who got Indian Citizenship can't buy land like Indian. I think there are restriction on Tibetan Indian citizenships its not same like others Indians. Personally i never applied for it. I hope Indian gov allow the same rules to the Tibetans who want to become Indian citizenship. These way it will open more doors to the young Tibetans. Jai Hind and Jai Tibet.
Anyone that chooses India over their motherland deserves to never be reunited with the same grounds that birthed and buried their ancestors.
once you are out from your den, all strings get cut. you become migratory person.
Hello!
INDIANS are migrating to the West too!
Why could not they claim Indian citizenship?
Not only tibetans thar are leaving india so i suggest you to go deeper you will find even those indisns are planning to get out of india going abroad
Better go back to Tibet don't go to western county you be homeless
I already said the indian government just used tou you guys
Mainly Tibetan go abroad coz they also have family and a life to live n family to feed..
They paid for their previous choices.