Maybe it’s to do with the west praising navalny and Russians know him better by experience. Have you heard navalnys on race hate marches ? If you did then you would understand they reminded of what they face in ww2
Yeah sure. Then all Russians happily call all southerners 'churki', yes? A derogatory terms that means firewood. And it's only Navalni that reminds him of Hitler, not Putin's state?@@pauldean8638
As an expat who lived in Siberia for many years, and now lives in Georgia, I must say that I wish TV rain were significantly more watched and popular. I'm not talking about Russians themselves, I'm talking about westerners. But I also, wish that Russians had more access to this channel. My girlfriend who is Russian, and is not of the intelligencia, she's working class, once asked me what she should listen to and watch outside of Russia, I gave her the link to TV rain. She is now an avid watcher. She's not from one of the first five top cities of Russia, but the channel resonates with her, so this is not just the westerners, obviously, it is also reaching deep into the working class of Russia. Unfortunately it will take time, spreading in this way, organic that is, takes time. But it is happening... Keep up the good work
The way this analysis is presented, it looks like it is intended not for English-speaking Westerners but for Russians speaking English. English is mediocre; English pronunciation has issues; there is a lot of Runglish (poorly translated Russian idioms); there is a lot of underlying Russian folklore known only to the Russian audience. Until all the issues are ironed out, it is all in vain.
@@oneanywhere8561 no, it isn't in vain. Non-Russian speaking interested people who are keen for information as well as clues to the thinking that aren't only in Russian language, benefit immensely from these programs. RT or Al-Jazeera may broadcast in flawless English or other pertinent languages but their productions are mendacious, fertile with their abilities to seed further lies worldwide.
Excellent work by Anna Nemzer. She analyzes and highlights how the FSB uses both old KGB methods and adopts new approaches, including the use of modern technology, to achieve its goals. This is an excellent work not only by a journalist, but also by a person who is not indifferent to what is happening in Russia today. Thank you
And yet, 🖤putin has captured the US Congress Republicans. They do his bidding. The few stand-up Republicans fell last week. Mitch McConnell, Senate Minority Leader, was convinced to kneel at 🖤putin's feet by having his sister-in-law drowned in her Tesla in the pond on Mitch McConnell's Texas ranch 2 weeks ago. The oldest tree in the Republican forest was felled. All aid from the USA to Ukraine, Taiwan and other allies is unreachable now. I am in despair. Please, God, we need Your Divine Intervention 💔🥺
Incredible presentation, and highly informative. The impression I have gotten from what I have read is that the tentacles of the FSB are much too widespread and deep to be rooted out. At some point institutions such as this become self sustaining.
Most people like me who lived behind the iron curtain in Eastern Europe know that. But the Russian propaganda is still very powerful and causes a lot of problems in the democratic processes. I simply believe that dictatorships are not forever and dictators are mortal humans as well. TV rain, Meduza, Moscow times and the other Russian independent information channels have got a huge job in front of them. Kremlin’s got a tight grip on the information space in Russia and it’ll be almost impossible to fight it. But I don’t have any doubt that sooner or later the truth will come out.
Hello from Canada! Fantastic work, Anna. There is a lot of details in your presentation and I might have to watch it a couple of times but it is very interesting. By the way, you look stunningly beautiful.
Thank you so much for bravely speaking out. You and other dissident Russians give us in the West hope for a better future for Russia and ourselves without threats and aggression from the current administration.
Believe me a lot of people in Eastern Europe know it. But Russia has always been a master of the propaganda and deception. I only hope that Russian independent media succeeds to get the message out to the Russian population even with the Kremlin’s tight grip on the information space. It seems almost impossible but there is always hope.
I wish russian people will not lose the second chance to have free and democratic country now KGB have a state after the collapse of current regime then they will have a chance i also think not only soviet dictators but also russian dictator they never understand the value of russian peoples lives and their ecomic and political freedom
@@mariuschirita187 The one laughs best who laughs last. If anything changes in Russia, he might laugh for the rest of his life all the way to a federal penitentiary facility.
Il maccartismo della stampa occidentale ha sostituito il "Deus vult" delle crociate cristiane contro la Russia "cristiana ortodossa comunista"e contro gli infedeli musulmani Palestina.. è ridicolo...
Very high admiration for you--'Anna Nemzer',, for your humanity compassion,, your love for others and your tireless hours and days and years to expose the justice the Russian people need against Vladimir Putin,, You tell it straight with the facts and none of your own biases even though it would be tempting for you to easily take just one view of things and your speaking of English is impeccable,, I admire you---'God Bless You'--Amen.
"In Russia the government's power is absolute, but at the same time the government is extremely fearful of criticism, even of frank utterance. All men born in Russia . . . conspire tacitly to observe unanimous silence concerning what goes on. Nothing is ever said, yet everything is known. . . . In Russia, to converse is to conspire; to think is to revolt. Thought is not merely a crime, it is a misfortune." Custine. 1840s We have dedicated ourselves to a cause but without hope, in disgust and boredom. The day of action may be far off: the day of a conscience, of thought, of speech has already dawned." Alexander Herzen
Trump hasn't denied knowing organized crime figures. During a 2013 appearance on David Letterman's late night show, he admitted to having met mobsters "on occasion." "They happen to be very nice people," he said. "You just don't want to owe them money."
27:36 "In 1993 I came to the white house of the Russian Parliament and it was as if the entirety of the KGB headquarters moved in there... occupying offices of the government or the President's administration." 1993. Today 90%of admin are KGB almni" Chilling. Can the rat's nest ever be cleaned out?
That was a good broadcast. I liked that term institutional inertia. It seems that to be a successful dictator, you have to have an excellent secret police. The FSB, KGB, NKVD, etc, they all served the same purpose of protecting the authoritarian ruler of that time period. It looks like when Russians try something new and it doesn't go well, they fall back on what they are familiar with. The communist leaders of the USSR turned out to be just as authoritarian as the tsars before them. And Putin is just a continuation of this forceful, strongman leadership. This seems to be a recurring theme throughout Russia's history.
Russia has always been like this. A "peaceful, civilized, democratic Russia" has never existed, it has ALWAYS been invading its neighbours etc. This is why people say "It's Russia not necessarily Putin" because Putin has only been in power for 20 years and Russia was still like this long before him.
only idiots would throw their lives away to change what the Russian identity is, a free and independent world actor. trying the same thing over again and expect different results is insanity.
It is not just Putin, but Putin is the one who worked hard to make them like that. There is a clever indoctrination and brainwashing going on. A small minority with brains is fine and hate Putin with a passion, the rest are either ignorant or worse.
History will remember the murders of Navalny and Nemtsov as crimes against humanity, with those responsible being viewed the same as monstrous despotic conquerors such as Herod, Nero, and the like.
You ask for feedback: TV Rain does good work standing up against Russian Propaganda. I have followed you for months. A segment "total recall" must provide facts without whining, but tough. Short and precisely. Good luck in the youtube Universe! Time will show if there's a real possibility for a modern Russia.
Chances are those against lustration also were either operatives or agents :) When we opened archives, in agency were unimaginable individuals who worked for them in the past.
Using ironic humor to whitewash a security agency would be impossible in this english speaking country because all statements are always understood literally. But watching action adventure hero tv dramas is universal.
Navalny was a smart guy, a leader, to be respected. But he had a fatal flaw; he was not a coalition builder. The Russian opposition groups need to put thier differences aside, form a united front, do everything to remove the midget from power, then once he's gone, you sort the rest out later.
But the theme of this review is that it is not dependent on one person, that the infiltration of civil society, and replacement and elimination of it's institutions, and consequent total lack of any oversight or alternative, just means that whoever is at the top of the pile the organization will continue. Only a revolution can change things to the extent needed, in which case the outcome is uncertain.
@@tvrainnewsroom Finally, after you added subtitles, I was able to figure out that word at 13:25... "syncopal"... Folk, are you all there? This is a medical term! Hardly even 1% of the general population outside of the medical community knows this word. There are at least a few hundred, if not a few thousand, synonyms that can substitute this medical term. The poor choice of words is a sign of your ineptitude. Shame!
Pure Solovyov style fantasy. The West has never been remotely interested in Russia's resources. The irony of your comment is, Putin and his gang members got rich selling Russia's oil and gas to the West.
Your resources are in the West, together with gov officials families, even Putins daughter, lol. Or since the war can go check out Dubai, will see where your money ended up. That Western enemies fairy tale is exactly what Putin needs to keep you in check, lol.
I admire those Russians who resist Putin and repression, but despair at the apathy and passivity of most Russians.
Maybe it’s to do with the west praising navalny and Russians know him better by experience. Have you heard navalnys on race hate marches ? If you did then you would understand they reminded of what they face in ww2
Yeah sure. Then all Russians happily call all southerners 'churki', yes? A derogatory terms that means firewood. And it's only Navalni that reminds him of Hitler, not Putin's state?@@pauldean8638
I am so grateful for this channel. Thank you all. We stand with y'all. Today and always. ❤
As an expat who lived in Siberia for many years, and now lives in Georgia, I must say that I wish TV rain were significantly more watched and popular. I'm not talking about Russians themselves, I'm talking about westerners. But I also, wish that Russians had more access to this channel. My girlfriend who is Russian, and is not of the intelligencia, she's working class, once asked me what she should listen to and watch outside of Russia, I gave her the link to TV rain. She is now an avid watcher. She's not from one of the first five top cities of Russia, but the channel resonates with her, so this is not just the westerners, obviously, it is also reaching deep into the working class of Russia. Unfortunately it will take time, spreading in this way, organic that is, takes time. But it is happening... Keep up the good work
Thank you so much!!
@@tvrainnewsroom 13:25 continued operation in a near "singapol" ??? state...
What is "singapol"? Or whatever word is meant?
The way this analysis is presented, it looks like it is intended not for English-speaking Westerners but for Russians speaking English. English is mediocre; English pronunciation has issues; there is a lot of Runglish (poorly translated Russian idioms); there is a lot of underlying Russian folklore known only to the Russian audience. Until all the issues are ironed out, it is all in vain.
@@oneanywhere8561Nonsense.
@@oneanywhere8561 no, it isn't in vain. Non-Russian speaking interested people who are keen for information as well as clues to the thinking that aren't only in Russian language, benefit immensely from these programs.
RT or Al-Jazeera may broadcast in flawless English or other pertinent languages but their productions are mendacious, fertile with their abilities to seed further lies worldwide.
Excellent work by Anna Nemzer. She analyzes and highlights how the FSB uses both old KGB methods and adopts new approaches, including the use of modern technology, to achieve its goals. This is an excellent work not only by a journalist, but also by a person who is not indifferent to what is happening in Russia today. Thank you
But what, exactly are their goals ? What do you want when you have everything - just more ?
@@ericwillis777 For them, it is never enough...
@@oneanywhere8561 I agree, what a mess !
@@ericwillis777 This is not a mess but a deliberately guided course of development that has reached its culmination.
@@oneanywhere8561 Болшои шутка, (hope that's spelled right, it's not worth looking up).
OMG, Anna, I am so happy to see you here, on the TV Rain English Channel! I always watch your shows in Russian as well! Please keep up a good work! 🙂
Putin killing Navalny show how stupid Putin is.
Budanov disagrees
@@steveagola9317How gives a fuck?
😂 😂 😂 I
It's funny to hear someone speak this way.
And yet, 🖤putin has captured the US Congress Republicans. They do his bidding. The few stand-up Republicans fell last week. Mitch McConnell, Senate Minority Leader, was convinced to kneel at 🖤putin's feet by having his sister-in-law drowned in her Tesla in the pond on Mitch McConnell's Texas ranch 2 weeks ago. The oldest tree in the Republican forest was felled. All aid from the USA to Ukraine, Taiwan and other allies is unreachable now. I am in despair. Please, God, we need Your Divine Intervention 💔🥺
Another great report.
Incredible presentation, and highly informative. The impression I have gotten from what I have read is that the tentacles of the FSB are much too widespread and deep to be rooted out. At some point institutions such as this become self sustaining.
I am so dissappointed to have to agree with you.
Very interesting as well as sad! Thank you! 🤔😔
Most people like me who lived behind the iron curtain in Eastern Europe know that. But the Russian propaganda is still very powerful and causes a lot of problems in the democratic processes. I simply believe that dictatorships are not forever and dictators are mortal humans as well. TV rain, Meduza, Moscow times and the other Russian independent information channels have got a huge job in front of them. Kremlin’s got a tight grip on the information space in Russia and it’ll be almost impossible to fight it. But I don’t have any doubt that sooner or later the truth will come out.
Hello from Canada! Fantastic work, Anna. There is a lot of details in your presentation and I might have to watch it a couple of times but it is very interesting. By the way, you look stunningly beautiful.
Excellent, educational and freighting.
This explains everything
Thank you so much for bravely speaking out. You and other dissident Russians give us in the West hope for a better future for Russia and ourselves without threats and aggression from the current administration.
Wow, quite scaring. Thank you for releasing this video, a lot of people must know
Believe me a lot of people in Eastern Europe know it. But Russia has always been a master of the propaganda and deception. I only hope that Russian independent media succeeds to get the message out to the Russian population even with the Kremlin’s tight grip on the information space. It seems almost impossible but there is always hope.
Sending support from Portugal 🇵🇹❤🌎
Extremely well presented, Thank you, all people of the west should see this!!
I wish russian people will not lose the second chance to have free and democratic country now KGB have a state after the collapse of current regime then they will have a chance i also think not only soviet dictators but also russian dictator they never understand the value of russian peoples lives and their ecomic and political freedom
you must be feeling the pain of an economy without Russian resources. lets be honest about it.
The dystopia described by Orwell exists in Russia. Big brother is watching.
Edward Snowden laughs at this. good efforts though
@@mariuschirita187 The one laughs best who laughs last. If anything changes in Russia, he might laugh for the rest of his life all the way to a federal penitentiary facility.
Il maccartismo della stampa occidentale ha sostituito il "Deus vult" delle crociate cristiane contro la Russia "cristiana ortodossa comunista"e contro gli infedeli musulmani Palestina.. è ridicolo...
interesting, thanks
Thanks to you, Gzha. Nemzer and your research and production teams. Molotsy!
Very high admiration for you--'Anna Nemzer',, for your humanity compassion,, your love for others and your tireless hours and days and years to expose the justice the Russian people need against Vladimir Putin,, You tell it straight with the facts and none of your own biases even though it would be tempting for you to easily take just one view of things and your speaking of English is impeccable,, I admire you---'God Bless You'--Amen.
Thank you for reminding everybody so well of what we have in front of us. 👏
Very glad to see and hear Anna!
Your programme is just what the Russian people need. Calling and keeping Putin to account is the way forward.
"In Russia the government's power is absolute, but at the same time the government is extremely fearful of criticism, even of frank utterance. All men born in Russia . . . conspire tacitly to observe unanimous silence concerning what goes on. Nothing is ever said, yet everything is known. . . . In Russia, to converse is to conspire; to think is to revolt. Thought is not merely a crime, it is a misfortune." Custine. 1840s
We have dedicated ourselves to a cause but without hope, in disgust and boredom.
The day of action may be far off: the day of a conscience, of thought, of speech has already dawned." Alexander Herzen
Most of them live like that till today
thank you, Anna, for keep doing your important job
Trump hasn't denied knowing organized crime figures. During a 2013 appearance on David Letterman's late night show, he admitted to having met mobsters "on occasion."
"They happen to be very nice people," he said. "You just don't want to owe them money."
KGB has never lost control over Russia.
Excellent work, thank you.
Great to speak out. Regards UK
Thank you for your work. ❤
Thank you for a very interesting series of the history of the cruel Russia.
A very good Video, thank you very much.
Thank you.
i agree with the title and its exciting to understand how
27:36 "In 1993 I came to the white house of the Russian Parliament and it was as if the entirety of the KGB headquarters moved in there... occupying offices of the government or the President's administration."
1993.
Today 90%of admin are KGB almni"
Chilling. Can the rat's nest ever be cleaned out?
The dissemblance of Eltsin's reforms paved the way for KGB to come back with a vengeance.
That was a good broadcast. I liked that term institutional inertia. It seems that to be a successful dictator, you have to have an excellent secret police. The FSB, KGB, NKVD, etc, they all served the same purpose of protecting the authoritarian ruler of that time period. It looks like when Russians try something new and it doesn't go well, they fall back on what they are familiar with. The communist leaders of the USSR turned out to be just as authoritarian as the tsars before them. And Putin is just a continuation of this forceful, strongman leadership. This seems to be a recurring theme throughout Russia's history.
i think i love Anna ...a little bit x
Russia has always been like this. A "peaceful, civilized, democratic Russia" has never existed, it has ALWAYS been invading its neighbours etc. This is why people say "It's Russia not necessarily Putin" because Putin has only been in power for 20 years and Russia was still like this long before him.
only idiots would throw their lives away to change what the Russian identity is, a free and independent world actor. trying the same thing over again and expect different results is insanity.
@@mariuschirita187yes, free from moral constraints and independent of any restraint by their population.
It is not just Putin, but Putin is the one who worked hard to make them like that. There is a clever indoctrination and brainwashing going on. A small minority with brains is fine and hate Putin with a passion, the rest are either ignorant or worse.
History will remember the murders of Navalny and Nemtsov as crimes against humanity, with those responsible being viewed the same as monstrous despotic conquerors such as Herod, Nero, and the like.
You ask for feedback: TV Rain does good work standing up against Russian Propaganda. I have followed you for months. A segment "total recall" must provide facts without whining, but tough. Short and precisely. Good luck in the youtube Universe! Time will show if there's a real possibility for a modern Russia.
Thank you!
You should do more videos
He obviously smoked a cigarette and fell out a window. So natural .
Chances are those against lustration also were either operatives or agents :) When we opened archives, in agency were unimaginable individuals who worked for them in the past.
👍
Using ironic humor to whitewash a security agency would be impossible in this english speaking country because all statements are always understood literally. But watching action adventure hero tv dramas is universal.
Putin is so grateful that he sent Trump a jar of hummus for Christmas:
it's made of Russian chick pea.
The Okhrana - Tsarist secret police. How much does this organisation show a Russian prediliction for this type of political oppression?
Read “The Fourth Man” by Robert Bear (former CIA operator). He covers many things in this podcast. It’s hair raising
Massive dubious entities throughout russian history 😢
Add subtitles in English
done!
He turned him into a martyr.
هل كان لعمر سليمان ابن من امرأة انجليزيه فى منتصف الخمسينات من القرن الماضى؟؟
I’m learning English somehow 👀👀
Navalny was a smart guy, a leader, to be respected. But he had a fatal flaw; he was not a coalition builder. The Russian opposition groups need to put thier differences aside, form a united front, do everything to remove the midget from power, then once he's gone, you sort the rest out later.
struggling with the reality of an economy without access to Russian energy? its palpable in your comment...
But the theme of this review is that it is not dependent on one person, that the infiltration of civil society, and replacement and elimination of it's institutions, and consequent total lack of any oversight or alternative, just means that whoever is at the top of the pile the organization will continue. Only a revolution can change things to the extent needed, in which case the outcome is uncertain.
WHEN YOU SLING MUD, YOU GET DIRTY.
THEY REMIND ME EXACTLY OF THE CIA😂.I LIVE IN FLORIDA I KNOW OF THEM WELL
Fool, of the Cheka you clearly know nothing.
Hey Putin. Money and power it's a funny thing.
🇷🇺Russian flying shovel is deadly 😅😅
Add text in ENGLISH!!!
done!
@@tvrainnewsroom Finally, after you added subtitles, I was able to figure out that word at 13:25... "syncopal"... Folk, are you all there? This is a medical term! Hardly even 1% of the general population outside of the medical community knows this word. There are at least a few hundred, if not a few thousand, synonyms that can substitute this medical term. The poor choice of words is a sign of your ineptitude. Shame!
🇺🇦🇷🇺👑️👉👁️
с возвращением самые могущественные доброжелатели КГБ из безбожной Индии и обеих стран
How kgb kept west greedy paw off it resources .
Pure Solovyov style fantasy. The West has never been remotely interested in Russia's resources. The irony of your comment is, Putin and his gang members got rich selling Russia's oil and gas to the West.
how greedy kgb kept all Russian citizens money.
@@mojomaxy at least still in 🇷🇺
@@mojomaxy ...surly the citizens keep some of the money. Russians just dont have that western over consumption behaviour.
Your resources are in the West, together with gov officials families, even Putins daughter, lol. Or since the war can go check out Dubai, will see where your money ended up. That Western enemies fairy tale is exactly what Putin needs to keep you in check, lol.
Traitor
The murder of a Nazis.
Long live Putin
... in the Hague dungeon.
This woman is so brave,
Thank you.