As a muslim myself, i strongly agreed with prof tajudin point of view. I never feel always attack by other non muslims like other malay muslim feel. It is depend on your wordview or mindset. Which is developed by how much you read and understand things. The first commandment of Quran sent down by Allah is to read. Allah keep mentioned us to study, to learn, to ponder, to question things around us. Not just by listening to some popular ustaz and then stop learning islam at all. Allah want us to keep learning , be curious, and open your mind to his vast knowledge. When we stop learning, there will come prejudice, and negative perspectives.
Susahlah ustad2 itu cari makan Prof. When believers are taught the skills of research and critical thinking, it is considered a threat. HARAM. That quality is very contrary to their teachings. Those progressive believers, they labeled as thinking like Jews. The desired quality of followers, obey them. Those who understand other than their teachings are misguided and must be hated. It is this obedient group that enlivens their ceremony. If there are less attendees, less allowance.
Prof raise a very good point about reading. There is another issue arising from that, which is linguistic skills in other languages, especially English. Yes, most Malays understand basic English but those who are not comfortable reading English or other languages for deeper comprehension of subjects are solely reliant only on information and knowledge passed on to them in Malay. Who uses Malay in this planet? Indonesia and Malaysia. And the number of Malaysian Malays are actually quite small in comparison to all the other groups, races and nations in the world. They give excuse that Malays can get by knowing only Malay because many Japanese, Chinese are monolingual but they are developed nation. There are more than a billion Chinese and Japan has way more than a 100 million. That's a big pool of people to share knowledge with. Malays might be the majority in Malaysia but there are just slightly more than 15 million of them. If you disregard Indonesia, that is a very very small knowledge and information pool. If you just rely on getting and sharing knowledge from a pool of 15 million people you create a closed group of people just feeding off their own prejudices and magnifying it even more in a circle jerk of limited ideas.
yes ,but show an example that chinese boycot because of beef thrown at them . show a country where 300k people killed by chinese because of racial tension . any chinese scream and shout to ask for respect . dont utter something to show your total ignorance
I listen to Ustad and sometimes there was a logic answer and if there was non logic answer so i find my own way to find until full fit!! So far so 👍. I doesn't find perfect master in islam yet..we need to take our own effort and don't blame on other's
In one lifetime I'm sure you will find your living master to guide n show you the right pathway to know about God.I always wonder if those days people found their living master while they are alive to get the knowledge of God ,I'm very sure in this lifetime we will find a true living master to give knowledge of God to a living students to quench the thirst to be in peace with God.I really enjoyed listen to professor interview so much clarity.I Respect all the religions in Malaysia stay blessed and be in peace always guys😊😊
Agreed! The first verses that was revealed to Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him is “Read! In the name of your lord. “ It tells us that we have to read, and verify and adopt an open mind to gain knowledge and understanding. If we read to seek knowledge for Allah, our creator and not for our pride or worldly gains alone, god willing we will have that knowledge and wisdom to be a better person in this world and the hereafter.
Anyway I am a free thinker. I am at my eighty.I feel that I have no problems without believing this and that. I believe in me. When the time comes I go without thinking of this and that. I will just go without any disturbance of humans’ involvement. I will die just like other living things because I believe that I am not special at all. I am just a part of nature. I don’t like to be bounded by anything which is man made because I believe that no man is perfect.
We are the strongest. We are the chosen one. We are the luckiest human being to be born into this world. Millions of our brothers and sisters(sperms) did not make it. But why us ? Because god want us to experience the beauty of life as human beings. To see and appreciate his mighty creation of the universe. But not just to enjoy every seconds and beautiful moments in our live but to seek the truth about god himself, the one who created us and the universe. Its not how long you live, but how you live that matters. Every second counts...
@@abdulrahmansallehudin9351 Reply to brother abdulrahman Everything we see on earth is the chosen one ,we are only one of them. If we believe god is the creator then we can derive that everything that we can see is the creation of god n it is equally loved by the all mighty! So we are just one of the chosen ones! So all are special in the eyes of god.
Nak baca apa lagi Prof? Sebelum masuk sekolah budak2 dah masuk Kafa. Lepaih tu 11 tahun dari Darjah 1 - Tingkatan 5 ada Pelajaran Agama Islam sbg subjek wajib. Tak cukup ke 12 tahun belajaq agama? Kalau nak salahkan orang kurang membaca tambahan bermakna subjek Agama Islam di sekolah tu tak relevan dan tak memberi sebarang manfaat. Humban saja lah subjek tu dr kurikulum pendidikan dan kita fokus kpd matematik dan sains. Sbb tak bawak manfaat. Belajar mengaji lepas sekolah mcm org dulu2 jer cukup. Atau tukaq content pelajaran subjek agama Islam di sekolah kpd yg relevant dan terbuka mcm Prof. Ok ke?
Such thinking is one of the root of corruption among the Malays. They all stop reading after their secondary school or at best after graduating. Read, read and read until ur 6 feet under the ground.
A fair point too, that's why religious study should NEVER be a compulsory subject in any education institution, well too bad our gomen not gonna do anything about it to improve as always.
Dan demi sesungguhnya! Kami telah mudahkan Al-Quran untuk menjadi peringatan dan pengajaran, maka adakah sesiapa yang mahu mengambil peringatan dan pelajaran (daripadanya)? AlQamar17
The more I think about it, the weirder It is to hear that comparing different translations and not expand on learning more is NOT a norm when studying religion. I see this even in conservative Christianity here in Malaysia. I've been following religious scholarship and academia on Christianity, and it is rather exciting to me to find Christian scholars essentially present their findings (whether in textual criticism or archeology) that might contradict or oppose certain tenets of what we understand colloquially as part of the Christian faith, and the scholars themselves accept it, YET still identify as Christians. To paraphrase what I heard from one scholar: "When we allow our faith to dictate our history, we really betray both." We have to be vulnerable in accepting new information. As Prof Tajuddin says, that's the only way we can grow.
Bahaya bila bukan ahlinye berbicara.....walaupun awal prof... tapi mengaji agama tu banyak cabang ilmunya..dan bila bukan ahlinye bercakap, seolah merendahkan ahli .... hati hati... musibahnya besar....
@@camelurine9667 Contoh apabila bila kita nak repair motor ...mcm mana nak cara nak repair ..ada buku panduan mesti kena ada master mengajar....baru tahu boleh belajar cara nak repair motor tu belajar sampai habis sampai pandai so dapat lah ilmu repair motor...ada master mengajar sampai menjadi repair motor yang bijak
It is common knowledge that majority of Malays can recite the Koran from memory but do not understand what they are reciting. This is because Malays when taught to recite the Koran, are not encouraged to ask questions. Theirs is not to ask but just follow. Outsyedthebox owner also has this opinion. In fact he has challenged the Muslim diehards from PAS to debate several issues regarding Islam but they have always refused to do so.
May god forgive you for your lack of understanding in Islam and your poor observation of how the quran is being taught to the muslims. Fyi the reading of the Quran can be taught at the very young age but understanding of the tafsir or translation of the entire Quran will take years. The prof is not a scholar of islamic studies and for him to challenge politicians from Pas is also wrong. Those Pas politicians are not qualified Islamic scholars. Prof should challenge the rightful islamic scholar like Nouman Ali Khan.
Academically, it is strange when the majority in a country should feels that way. Cognitive studies called it 'self-inferiority complex'. A true muslim would never felt enmity 👉and being, withal, of those who have attained to faith, and who enjoin upon one another patience in adversity, and enjoin upon one another compassion.[Al-Balad (The City) 90:17] [But] it may well be that God will bring about [mutual] affection between you [O believers] and some of those whom you [now] face as enemies: for, God is all-powerful - and God is much-forgiving, a dispenser of grace. [Al-Mumtahinah (The Examined One) 60:7]
The greatest trouble makers are the those who learn religions from written materials, together with the sendirian berhad punya knowledge and language capability, misconceptions and misinformation are considerated as perfect understanding of the teaching from the representatives of God from ancient time until today. Completely ignore the the most important part of the non writtenable of Universes knowledge. The most pittyful of all, these people assume nobody can better understand the religion matter other than the religious body.
Ada M yg jenis duduk bawah tempurung, tak bergaul dgn culture lain, agama lain, bangsa lain. Tin2 kosong ni lah yg paling lantang bersuara menegakkan agama dan bangsa kononnya. Tapi ilmu dan pengalaman, sesempit akal fikiran. Yg diam2 ubi berisi juga yg byk membantu jernihkan semula nama islam yg tercemar dgn tindakan tin2 kosong.
While following the program it suddenly stopped. was not accessible to fon or whatsup. When questioned my daughter admitted disconnecting the internet. Like to know Can a Muslim follow such programme.
nope, to give opinions about Quranic "tafsir" or "hadis" you need to have to master classical Arabic, its non negotiable, its a must, and you cannot skip it, it's the basic discipline and foundation of understanding the Islamic knowledge, without it you are just charlatan at best, no matter how many translations of the Quran you read, translation is translation, its never the same. and by saying enemy it doesn't mean it means literally, it mean that its enemy of Islam as an idea and way of life, they want to chage it, to make it irrelevant and absolete, to overthrow it, and its happening, doesn't mean that there's non Muslim are going after us to draw blood, no any sane muslim in their right mind are believing that.
@@abdulrahmansallehudin9351 I mean if he really wants to learn the discipline of Quranic tafsir, it's necessary, he need to master the classical Arabic.
That short narrow construct is what we call the discipline or the sciences of the methodology of understanding the text or the scripture. The Exegesis or the interpretation of the Dalil ie Quran and Hadith must be based on the works of the Righteous Predecessors of the first 300 years after the Prophet Peace be be Upon him. All else is prone to sacrileges, blasphemy and misguidance. Note that our religious councils except a few might have fallen into Heresy. Jahmi Heretics. Wahabism is the truth dude.
@@ChuanTehfyi ustaz only covers certain specialised topics, ulamak covers all topics regarding Islam. Not all ustaz qualifies to become ulamak. And only a few qualified ulamaks will be chosen as mufties.
Sewaktu zaman jahiliah saya melihat isteri monyet direjam oleh suami monyet, kerana ia melakukan persetubuhan haram. Saya juga, ikut merejam isteri monyet. Sahih al-Bukhari 3849
@@takiyaazrin7562 On a side note, this is why u just can't be dependent on direct translation. "Suami monyet" as a direct translation is just ridiculous. iLmu itu harus diambil pada ahlinya. Hadis tersebut ada pembahasannya but you have already stuck at "suami monyet". Can you comprehend why do u have misleading information?
The 3 Abrahamic religions were spread over different times. So it is clear that Judaism scriptures did not mention Christianity as an enemy because there were no Christians at the time, and likewise the Bible did not mention Islam as enemies. So, the so called term 'enemies of Islam' was termed during times of war between the tribes. It was not that the religions are enemies of each other. Hopefully all people understand that these are peaceful times with mulitiple race, religions and nations coexisting on earth. Do not get bought over by narrow minded teachings and cause one's life to be miserable unnecessarily.
@BluekBluh Theres are specific institutions that provides this service, heck even DBP, and they are comprised of Malays who are very highly versed in Arabic, especially having studied, lectured, or lived in Middle Eastern countries. Your comment reeks of negative stigma, stop being a coward hiding behind "out of curiosity" and be better.
Grandiosity, A false sense of entitlement, Projection are a few prominent characteristics of someone with 'Cluster-B Personality Disorders' ... Please look it up 🙏🏽
Tulah liberal.. kita dengar je.. jgn tepengaruh.. dengar boleh.. ada satu part tu dia cakap dia takde kawan.. aku nak gelak ada, menangis pun ada.. belajar tinggi sangat sampai pemikiran terlalu terbuka..takleh repair dah dia ni.. rebung kalau dah jadi buluh memang bangang
Satu kitab KALAM ALLAH sendiri takkan manusia tudak boleh fahamkan isinya msing2 . Kena guna khidmat penterjemah ulamak2 juga ke . Goggle pun blh terjemahkan dgn lebih kualiti penyeragaman tidak lama lgi . Sohih doif blh di selaraskan dgn bantuan teknologi . Ulamak2 agamawan dh tadak kerja tak lama lgi nmpaknya😅
I think you are his perfect audience target. We all go to school to learn (except those with highly qualified parents who can do home school) from teachers, but one must not stop at that, enquiry of knowledge , critical thinking are essential for self development n self discipline. A good teacher is one who wishes his students outdo him n gain better knowledge than him. There is no danger in learning more but the opposite is indeed more dangerous.
Zmn sedang berubah. Teknologi akn ambil alih tugas mendidik tidak lama lgi . Internet ,you tube twitter lebih pantas buat tugas2 ulamak agamawan semua agama tudak lama lgi . Generasi baru akn menjadi mahir dgn lebih advance 😅
Dah tahu ada yg tak kena bila prof berkata dia bukan hanya baca satu Quran saja. Memang bahaya dan boleh sesat. Sejak bila Islam ada lebih dari satu Quran utk rujukan?
So his interpretation is that the enemy of Islam are free to make fun of Islam and the Muslims just sit back and relax..that is one professor I won't listen to
He said "I don't read only one Quran.." .. OMG! Since Muhammad pbuh died, there is only ONE Quran my friend and Allah has given commitment that the one and only Quran will be protected until the day of judgement.. To me, when you have more than one Quran as referral, it means you are referring to other than the Quran.. and no wonder lah ....
pls don't be so narrow minded. What the Prof try to transpire is... he might be weak in Arabic and he will try to read the translation it in many angles so that he can understand deeper. Without prejudice..
@@StanC0312 Agreed, thanks for making it clear. 🙏🏽 Prof did NOT say anything about MANY TYPES of Quran! 🫡 It's a well-known established fact that there is one Holy Quran 🙏🏽
So my concern became true, I'm not happy about what is happening to you now but this will be a valuable lesson for myself. You made a video about the Darkest Malaysia, virtue signaled and ridiculed your own Muslim brothers and sisters for defending their faith. Perhaps Allah is unmasking you for not defending his name. Despite it all, I pray Allah will be merciful and guide you through this trial.
As a muslim myself, i strongly agreed with prof tajudin point of view. I never feel always attack by other non muslims like other malay muslim feel. It is depend on your wordview or mindset. Which is developed by how much you read and understand things. The first commandment of Quran sent down by Allah is to read. Allah keep mentioned us to study, to learn, to ponder, to question things around us. Not just by listening to some popular ustaz and then stop learning islam at all. Allah want us to keep learning , be curious, and open your mind to his vast knowledge. When we stop learning, there will come prejudice, and negative perspectives.
This is not even controversial. It's the truth!
Yeah, a lot of malayphobe dont read. Thats why they always feel attacked and blame Malays for everything
Very controversial in terms of islamic context. He is not a scholar of Islamic studies. His views are very misleading.
Susahlah ustad2 itu cari makan Prof. When believers are taught the skills of research and critical thinking, it is considered a threat. HARAM. That quality is very contrary to their teachings. Those progressive believers, they labeled as thinking like Jews. The desired quality of followers, obey them. Those who understand other than their teachings are misguided and must be hated. It is this obedient group that enlivens their ceremony. If there are less attendees, less allowance.
Prof raise a very good point about reading. There is another issue arising from that, which is linguistic skills in other languages, especially English. Yes, most Malays understand basic English but those who are not comfortable reading English or other languages for deeper comprehension of subjects are solely reliant only on information and knowledge passed on to them in Malay. Who uses Malay in this planet? Indonesia and Malaysia. And the number of Malaysian Malays are actually quite small in comparison to all the other groups, races and nations in the world. They give excuse that Malays can get by knowing only Malay because many Japanese, Chinese are monolingual but they are developed nation. There are more than a billion Chinese and Japan has way more than a 100 million. That's a big pool of people to share knowledge with. Malays might be the majority in Malaysia but there are just slightly more than 15 million of them. If you disregard Indonesia, that is a very very small knowledge and information pool. If you just rely on getting and sharing knowledge from a pool of 15 million people you create a closed group of people just feeding off their own prejudices and magnifying it even more in a circle jerk of limited ideas.
Well said. Open minded and curitosity-driven knowledge are important to mankind.
Don't think what the prof said is controversial, is the current state of affairs!
Married women are forbidden unto you, except married women that you capture in war.
Quran 4:24
@@takiyaazrin7562 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taqiyya
very well said, actually same goes for chinese community too, we also got people like this
maybe u and your mom
yes ,but show an example that chinese boycot because of beef thrown at them . show a country where 300k people killed by chinese because of racial tension . any chinese scream and shout to ask for respect . dont utter something to show your total ignorance
That is why many countries send students abroad, to learn from others.
90% that LIKED this comment are Melayu. 😂
The less educated b40 community tend to fall victim to sesat religion.
Prof Controversial ❌ Akmal controversial (&sesat) ✅
I usually don't listen to hour-long podcast but that one was an exception. It's insightful from a Muslim I respected a lot
The true malaysian spirit is that of love not division😊
Some ustaz don't even teach properly... They are the one who makes people sesat, they can't blame the followers .
This is one of the major problems in our country 🤦🏽♂️ + It's not an easy problem to resolve 😓
I listen to Ustad and sometimes there was a logic answer and if there was non logic answer so i find my own way to find until full fit!! So far so 👍. I doesn't find perfect master in islam yet..we need to take our own effort and don't blame on other's
In one lifetime I'm sure you will find your living master to guide n show you the right pathway to know about God.I always wonder if those days people found their living master while they are alive to get the knowledge of God ,I'm very sure in this lifetime we will find a true living master to give knowledge of God to a living students to quench the thirst to be in peace with God.I really enjoyed listen to professor interview so much clarity.I Respect all the religions in Malaysia stay blessed and be in peace always guys😊😊
@@puvanespeace3552If you want to seek the truth, please ask God for His guidance.
I totally agree with Prof…
Dont just agree without undertanding the context of what he is saying.
@@abdulrahmansallehudin9351 Nope, you're everywhere in this comment section and you're the one who doesn't understand.
That's the result of the Malaysian Education system...akin to rote learning, not much critical thinking.
Agreed! The first verses that was revealed to Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him is “Read! In the name of your lord. “
It tells us that we have to read, and verify and adopt an open mind to gain knowledge and understanding.
If we read to seek knowledge for Allah, our creator and not for our pride or worldly gains alone, god willing we will have that knowledge and wisdom to be a better person in this world and the hereafter.
Very astute observation and understanding of the dilemma.
Well said Prof.👍🎉
Anyway I am a free thinker.
I am at my eighty.I feel that I have no problems without believing this and that.
I believe in me.
When the time comes I go without thinking of this and that.
I will just go without any disturbance of humans’ involvement.
I will die just like other living things because I believe that I am not special at all. I am just a part of nature.
I don’t like to be bounded by anything which is man made because I believe that no man is perfect.
We are the strongest. We are the chosen one. We are the luckiest human being to be born into this world. Millions of our brothers and sisters(sperms) did not make it. But why us ? Because god want us to experience the beauty of life as human beings. To see and appreciate his mighty creation of the universe. But not just to enjoy every seconds and beautiful moments in our live but to seek the truth about god himself, the one who created us and the universe. Its not how long you live, but how you live that matters. Every second counts...
@@abdulrahmansallehudin9351
Reply to brother abdulrahman
Everything we see on earth is the chosen one ,we are only one of them.
If we believe god is the creator then we can derive that everything that we can see is the creation of god n it is equally loved by the all mighty!
So we are just one of the chosen ones!
So all are special in the eyes of god.
Agree.
I like how you sing Bukit Mah ❤
Am 83 years old. Wants to know whether we are forbidden to see live video of groups singing hymns for Israel.
Nak baca apa lagi Prof? Sebelum masuk sekolah budak2 dah masuk Kafa. Lepaih tu 11 tahun dari Darjah 1 - Tingkatan 5 ada Pelajaran Agama Islam sbg subjek wajib. Tak cukup ke 12 tahun belajaq agama? Kalau nak salahkan orang kurang membaca tambahan bermakna subjek Agama Islam di sekolah tu tak relevan dan tak memberi sebarang manfaat. Humban saja lah subjek tu dr kurikulum pendidikan dan kita fokus kpd matematik dan sains. Sbb tak bawak manfaat. Belajar mengaji lepas sekolah mcm org dulu2 jer cukup. Atau tukaq content pelajaran subjek agama Islam di sekolah kpd yg relevant dan terbuka mcm Prof. Ok ke?
Such thinking is one of the root of corruption among the Malays. They all stop reading after their secondary school or at best after graduating. Read, read and read until ur 6 feet under the ground.
A fair point too, that's why religious study should NEVER be a compulsory subject in any education institution, well too bad our gomen not gonna do anything about it to improve as always.
Dan demi sesungguhnya! Kami telah mudahkan Al-Quran untuk menjadi peringatan dan pengajaran, maka adakah sesiapa yang mahu mengambil peringatan dan pelajaran (daripadanya)?
AlQamar17
Kami tidak menurunkan Al-Quran kepadamu (wahai Muhammad) supaya engkau menanggung kesusahan.
(Taha 20:2) |
Painful truth..
The more I think about it, the weirder It is to hear that comparing different translations and not expand on learning more is NOT a norm when studying religion. I see this even in conservative Christianity here in Malaysia. I've been following religious scholarship and academia on Christianity, and it is rather exciting to me to find Christian scholars essentially present their findings (whether in textual criticism or archeology) that might contradict or oppose certain tenets of what we understand colloquially as part of the Christian faith, and the scholars themselves accept it, YET still identify as Christians.
To paraphrase what I heard from one scholar: "When we allow our faith to dictate our history, we really betray both." We have to be vulnerable in accepting new information. As Prof Tajuddin says, that's the only way we can grow.
Lack of thinking ability, mentality was ruined by one person.
Imagine there's no countries
It isn't hard to do
Nothing to kill or die for
And no religion, too
Imagine all the people
Livin' life in peace.
If he is a PM candidate, i will vote for him
Be very careful what you wish for.
UMNO n PAS pemain kaum n penunggang agama terbaik
Wait for interesting comment from the warriors.
Ini la ulamak cakap, cakap benda dia xtau. Tengok google je pastu bagi pandangan sana sini sesatkan orang. Astaga
Bahaya bila bukan ahlinye berbicara.....walaupun awal prof... tapi mengaji agama tu banyak cabang ilmunya..dan bila bukan ahlinye bercakap, seolah merendahkan ahli .... hati hati... musibahnya besar....
Just by going through the comments section here... One can clearly relate to what Prof. was explaining in regards to the topic 😓
Prof just ups my respect for a true Muslim.
Tak tahu refer lah scholar islam berpengetahuan luas...nak bertanya dan memahami mendapat jawapan yang benar....
Dunia tenet berkembang baik. Banyak membantu . Semua ujung jari je.
@@camelurine9667
Contoh apabila bila kita nak repair motor ...mcm mana nak cara nak repair ..ada buku panduan mesti kena ada master mengajar....baru tahu boleh belajar cara nak repair motor tu belajar sampai habis sampai pandai so dapat lah ilmu repair motor...ada master mengajar sampai menjadi repair motor yang bijak
If you follow the absolute truth you don't have to fear what others say as absolute truth will always remain the absolute truth whatever people say .
It is common knowledge that majority of Malays can recite the Koran from memory but do not understand what they are reciting. This is because Malays when taught to recite the Koran, are not encouraged to ask questions. Theirs is not to ask but just follow. Outsyedthebox owner also has this opinion. In fact he has challenged the Muslim diehards from PAS to debate several issues regarding Islam but they have always refused to do so.
They do understand and are encouraged to ask question. Its interesting to see these islamophobe say things they no clue about.
May god forgive you for your lack of understanding in Islam and your poor observation of how the quran is being taught to the muslims. Fyi the reading of the Quran can be taught at the very young age but understanding of the tafsir or translation of the entire Quran will take years. The prof is not a scholar of islamic studies and for him to challenge politicians from Pas is also wrong. Those Pas politicians are not qualified Islamic scholars. Prof should challenge the rightful islamic scholar like Nouman Ali Khan.
dont bother with us the malay muslims .u take care of ur own people
Academically, it is strange when the majority in a country should feels that way. Cognitive studies called it 'self-inferiority complex'. A true muslim would never felt enmity 👉and being, withal, of those who have attained to faith, and who enjoin upon one another patience in adversity, and enjoin upon one another compassion.[Al-Balad (The City) 90:17] [But] it may well be that God will bring about [mutual] affection between you [O believers] and some of those whom you [now] face as enemies: for, God is all-powerful - and God is much-forgiving, a dispenser of grace. [Al-Mumtahinah (The Examined One) 60:7]
Non Melayu Muslims 2nd class rakyat is being attended by Ketuanan Melayu all the time
Dangerous if it's not your field...
You sesat when you go around the stone, bow to the stone, throw stones and kiss the representation of the broken pieces of a stone.
The greatest trouble makers are the those who learn religions from written materials, together with the sendirian berhad punya knowledge and language capability, misconceptions and misinformation are considerated as perfect understanding of the teaching from the representatives of God from ancient time until today. Completely ignore the the most important part of the non writtenable of Universes knowledge. The most pittyful of all, these people assume nobody can better understand the religion matter other than the religious body.
BEST❤SPEAKERS
Ada M yg jenis duduk bawah tempurung, tak bergaul dgn culture lain, agama lain, bangsa lain. Tin2 kosong ni lah yg paling lantang bersuara menegakkan agama dan bangsa kononnya. Tapi ilmu dan pengalaman, sesempit akal fikiran. Yg diam2 ubi berisi juga yg byk membantu jernihkan semula nama islam yg tercemar dgn tindakan tin2 kosong.
While following the program it suddenly stopped. was not accessible to fon or whatsup. When questioned my daughter admitted disconnecting the internet. Like to know Can a Muslim follow such programme.
DIA Ada discipline DLM Cara befikir tu. Bukan bole ikut Nafs.
Yes
nope, to give opinions about Quranic "tafsir" or "hadis" you need to have to master classical Arabic, its non negotiable, its a must, and you cannot skip it, it's the basic discipline and foundation of understanding the Islamic knowledge, without it you are just charlatan at best, no matter how many translations of the Quran you read, translation is translation, its never the same. and by saying enemy it doesn't mean it means literally, it mean that its enemy of Islam as an idea and way of life, they want to chage it, to make it irrelevant and absolete, to overthrow it, and its happening, doesn't mean that there's non Muslim are going after us to draw blood, no any sane muslim in their right mind are believing that.
Correction : You need to refer from the qualified Islamic Scholar of the Quran, not a " master classical Arabic".
@@abdulrahmansallehudin9351 I mean if he really wants to learn the discipline of Quranic tafsir, it's necessary, he need to master the classical Arabic.
Its just being honest & open, something more ppl should be unafraid of
Its good to be honest and open, but not to the extend of giving misleading statement especially when you are not the rightful scholar of Islam.
Talking about narrow when you can't even extract from the raw source...aahh isn't it ironic?
Married women are forbidden unto you, except married women that you capture in war.
Quran 4:24
That short narrow construct is what we call the discipline or the sciences of the methodology of understanding the text or the scripture. The Exegesis or the interpretation of the Dalil ie Quran and Hadith must be based on the works of the Righteous Predecessors of the first 300 years after the Prophet Peace be be Upon him. All else is prone to sacrileges, blasphemy and misguidance. Note that our religious councils except a few might have fallen into Heresy. Jahmi Heretics. Wahabism is the truth dude.
Married women are forbidden unto you, except married women that you capture in war.
Quran 4:24
Beza yg sekolah dgn yg x de sekolah
prof dont read one quran? correction, he dont read one tafsir.. but it really dangerous to learn tafsir without ustaz or ulama..
What makes you think that all ustaz or ulama are qualifies,
@@ChuanTehfyi ustaz only covers certain specialised topics, ulamak covers all topics regarding Islam. Not all ustaz qualifies to become ulamak. And only a few qualified ulamaks will be chosen as mufties.
Ok la kau rasa kau pandai boleh belajat ilmu ugama tanpa guru..mentang2 la professor katakan ..takut2 shaitan masuk jadi guru kau .
Sewaktu zaman jahiliah saya melihat isteri monyet direjam oleh suami monyet, kerana ia melakukan persetubuhan haram. Saya juga, ikut merejam isteri monyet.
Sahih al-Bukhari 3849
@@takiyaazrin7562 On a side note, this is why u just can't be dependent on direct translation. "Suami monyet" as a direct translation is just ridiculous. iLmu itu harus diambil pada ahlinya. Hadis tersebut ada pembahasannya but you have already stuck at "suami monyet". Can you comprehend why do u have misleading information?
Dah kene rasuk dah..
Sesat is everywhere ! Why the believers don't call out such sesat stuff mostly extremist views ?
The 3 Abrahamic religions were spread over different times. So it is clear that Judaism scriptures did not mention Christianity as an enemy because there were no Christians at the time, and likewise the Bible did not mention Islam as enemies. So, the so called term 'enemies of Islam' was termed during times of war between the tribes. It was not that the religions are enemies of each other. Hopefully all people understand that these are peaceful times with mulitiple race, religions and nations coexisting on earth. Do not get bought over by narrow minded teachings and cause one's life to be miserable unnecessarily.
If god says only one religion is true. Does that means god created enemies with others?
God does not create humans as enemies but all humans must seek the truth about the one and only rightful religion of god.
God does not create a religion. Us humans are the ones segregating ourselves for political gain
Please rephrase the title and remove the the word "CONTROVERSIAL'" bcos its very misleading.
@BluekBluh Theres are specific institutions that provides this service, heck even DBP, and they are comprised of Malays who are very highly versed in Arabic, especially having studied, lectured, or lived in Middle Eastern countries. Your comment reeks of negative stigma, stop being a coward hiding behind "out of curiosity" and be better.
Grandiosity, A false sense of entitlement, Projection are a few prominent characteristics of someone with 'Cluster-B Personality Disorders' ...
Please look it up 🙏🏽
@@rabinraj15 lmao is this comment for yourself? 😂 bro rly thought he did something.
😅😅✌️
Don't be a nuisance to yourself.
Bahaya bila Bukan ahli berhujah.....bukan ahli pula yg bertanya.....tinggalkan lah bila bukan ahli berbicara di luar bidang nye......
Tulah liberal.. kita dengar je.. jgn tepengaruh.. dengar boleh.. ada satu part tu dia cakap dia takde kawan.. aku nak gelak ada, menangis pun ada.. belajar tinggi sangat sampai pemikiran terlalu terbuka..takleh repair dah dia ni.. rebung kalau dah jadi buluh memang bangang
Satu kitab KALAM ALLAH sendiri takkan manusia tudak boleh fahamkan isinya msing2 . Kena guna khidmat penterjemah ulamak2 juga ke . Goggle pun blh terjemahkan dgn lebih kualiti penyeragaman tidak lama lgi . Sohih doif blh di selaraskan dgn bantuan teknologi . Ulamak2 agamawan dh tadak kerja tak lama lgi nmpaknya😅
I think you are his perfect audience target. We all go to school to learn (except those with highly qualified parents who can do home school) from teachers, but one must not stop at that, enquiry of knowledge , critical thinking are essential for self development n self discipline. A good teacher is one who wishes his students outdo him n gain better knowledge than him. There is no danger in learning more but the opposite is indeed more dangerous.
Sangat setuju.
Yang ahli pulak boleh pulak berhujah pasal politik , ekonomi dan kerajaan..ahli tak ahli semua pun sama
when two clowns riding each other 😂
Dia ni siapa..ye???
Professor Melayu yg berakal.
Dia seorang yg bukan pakar dlm kefahaman Islam tetapi cuba memberi pandangan mengenai islam dari sudut dan akal beliau sendiri.
Its not a controversial statement. Its a dumb statement.
Married women are forbidden unto you, except married women that you capture in war.
Quran 4:24
I own and read more books than this Professor Kangkung
Bahaya arkitek ni...kalau mcmni siapa2 blh jd ustaz n ulama...baca ja...bahaya blh sesat ni...
Zmn sedang berubah. Teknologi akn ambil alih tugas mendidik tidak lama lgi . Internet ,you tube twitter lebih pantas buat tugas2 ulamak agamawan semua agama tudak lama lgi . Generasi baru akn menjadi mahir dgn lebih advance 😅
Dah tahu ada yg tak kena bila prof berkata dia bukan hanya baca satu Quran saja. Memang bahaya dan boleh sesat. Sejak bila Islam ada lebih dari satu Quran utk rujukan?
So his interpretation is that the enemy of Islam are free to make fun of Islam and the Muslims just sit back and relax..that is one professor I won't listen to
Agreed. Many of his views are very misleading. Trying to explain about Islam when he is not even a scholar of Islam.
Blindly follow some politician who wants to gain
He said "I don't read only one Quran.." .. OMG! Since Muhammad pbuh died, there is only ONE Quran my friend and Allah has given commitment that the one and only Quran will be protected until the day of judgement.. To me, when you have more than one Quran as referral, it means you are referring to other than the Quran.. and no wonder lah ....
pls don't be so narrow minded. What the Prof try to transpire is... he might be weak in Arabic and he will try to read the translation it in many angles so that he can understand deeper. Without prejudice..
There are so many lah bro. Google it.
@@StanC0312 Agreed, thanks for making it clear. 🙏🏽
Prof did NOT say anything about MANY TYPES of Quran! 🫡
It's a well-known established fact that there is one Holy Quran 🙏🏽
he means translation dum dum, very obvious you did not read Quran, just like the prof said LMAO!
You dono. He knows better ! 😅
So my concern became true, I'm not happy about what is happening to you now but this will be a valuable lesson for myself. You made a video about the Darkest Malaysia, virtue signaled and ridiculed your own Muslim brothers and sisters for defending their faith. Perhaps Allah is unmasking you for not defending his name. Despite it all, I pray Allah will be merciful and guide you through this trial.