Easy to be-Islam: Chinese Soup (Bak-kut-teh) shows mistrust between Malaysians and Muslims?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 авг 2024
- When the National Heritage Department confirmed that the Chinese Soup called Bak-kut-teh as a heritage food of Malaysia, some Malay politicians and professors opposed the move under the reason that it is unislamic and that the Chinese soup is not 'old enough' to be known as 'heritage'. In this video I take this issue to task using simple Islamic values and the idea of a shared history of the Malay world in the many multi-faith Kingdoms of the past in Peninsular Malaysia.
![[KINI EXPLAINER] How rich are Dr M's sons? Wealth, controversies during ex-PM tenure](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/d7PP0Wzf6Ck/mqdefault.jpg)
I PAY HIGH RESPECT TO PROF. WITH HIS HIGH EDUCATED AND OPEN MINDED SET. 👍👍👍
You call him open minded. But you don’t say Cina people are close minded for wanting to preserve SJKC and not wanting their children to mingle with other races.
@atengku9660 You call Cina people close minded because they send their children to SJKC. But you don't ask why they don't send their children to SK in the first place.
@@atengku9660 What do you know about Cina and SJKC?
Chinese schools were established as preparation for children of Chinese immigrants to go back to China. But the Chinese pendatang decided to remain here and become citizen, why the need for sekolah Cina? Are the Chinese in this country are going back to China one day?
@@atengku9660 lagipun, pendatang itu semua buruk? Semua jahat? Gunalah otakmu yang dicipta oleh Allah! Gunalah akal untuk fikir dulu! Kan bulan suci ini Ramadan? Racist bising-bising lah pandai! Tawar kebencian dan perasaan dendam kepada yang lain darimu! Sengaja bodoh saja. Mana kebijaksanaan yang diajar dalam Qur'an? Di mana? Di mana saling fahami antara satu sama lain? Tiba -tiba bukan Muslim sudah? Baliklah belajar lagi SK kamu! Sistem gagal, tapi kau pun boleh gagal! Malaysia boleh lah! Lanun haram!
Well done, Prof. Tajuddin, we should have more Malaysian like you to speak out. ❤❤❤🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾
Nope, this Prof is explaining in the term of Islam which is wrong.
what is wrong? mind explaining it?@@kayellai5278
Why wrong? Where is the wrong part????@@kayellai5278
If everyone here agrees with Prof Tajuddin..he dare to speak out we should be brave to share in our own social media. I shared in FB. Hope you brave to do that too. 🙏
❤@@kayellai5278
Professor Tajuddin, you are indeed a National treasure. If there were more like you, we would be the envy of many nations .
Malaysia is really a food haven because of our many races!! That is the wonderful thing of living in this country!
There's a lot of Malays with Taliban mindset today that wants the country to be like Afghanistan. They go after food, clothing , entertainment , non muslim culture etc.
I wish to record my highest appreciation to Prof Tajuddin for his promotion of the bigger family concept for a sustainable and progressive Malaysia. If Muslims have such commitment and belief like him, Malaysia will go a long way. The saddening thing for Malaysia is that there are pseudo- Malaysians disrupting our wellness as a nation, let God arise, and bring hope to Malaysia whom we love.
Every moment of your thought sharing is highly appreciated and builts the mind to accept facts .. it's very encouraging to be of same mind to share good ideas.. kudos Prof
A well read Prof!
when u have cainis 95% supporting DAP to challenge malay statu quo, questioning Msia as a Malay Islamic country, for sure the malay will retaliate .......u despise jawi in sjkc , we fight back against bakkutteh....
My salute to you Prof Tajuddin! Your talk on the "Bak-kut-teh" issues is excellent. Hope your messages could reach every Malaysian. TQ! 👍👋🙏
Prof. Tajuddin is a true preacher of love, tolerance and understanding that goes beyond religious precepts. If we had more leaders like this Malaysia would be the best country in the world.
Well said. Professor Tajuddin
He provides good analogy. Well done.👍
We need more learned people like professor in malaysia, shame on the poor politicians
I really salute you Prof,being an understading muslim🎉
Salam sejahtera Prof. I respect you very much. I am a Kadazan from Sabah. I stayed in Peninsula for 15 years long ago. I have so many good Malays, Chinese, and Indian friends there. God bless them. Keep up the good work Prof. You're the best!
This is one clear minded professor. Cheers prop.
Well said Professor Tajuddin. Salute to you.
Professor, I can state with all certainty the 17 minutes listening to you is truly well-spent. Thank you.
Prof please put in Malay subtitles so that those who are not fluent in English can understand too. Thank you for this beautiful video.
ruclips.net/video/7RxnHhStomA/видео.html - BM version
Only liberal-minded urban malays will listen to him
Others would label him as DAP malay
A good explanation, I hope the uneducated would understand
Its Not a matter of a person being highly educated or not,its their narrow minded who purposely play by those dirty bustards of the extrimist leaders 👿who are keen of divided the harmony amongst different races in this lovely land .😪
Nope, not straight forward and beating around the bush.
@@kayellai5278 Nope, his argument is actually well structured. If you listen closely, he has a proposition, premise, support, addresses the other side and concludes his thoughts. Spoken like a true professor.
This guy is so open minded, honest guy and excellent educator, heaven waits for you. GOD bless you sir
Professor Mohamed Tajuddin is a very knowledgeable person. Hopefully the malays emulate his philosophy and thinking and live as malaysians.
Well said. Prof, you're indeed an intellectual man
Otak PhD yang di sayangi.👍
Prof. You are so great.
Tq for bringing back to mind all that is lost due to politics.
Inilah Melayu Yang cerdik Kita mahu
Akan datang Akan ada Professor membolehkan makan babi, bila babi dibela dalami air-con, Diberi Mkn brg halal, discan tanpa parasites. Mana hukum Allah? Islam bukan setakat Ugama Rasmi, Ini Negara Islam. Bertolak ansur bukan bermakna Jadi penjilat. Jgn. Riak Dan takbur dgn gelaran.
melayu pak turut ini yang dibanggakan
If everyone here agrees with Prof Tajuddin..he dare to speak out we should be brave to share in our own social media. I shared in FB. Hope you brave to do that too. 🙏
melayu yang sanggup jadi barua pak turut cina baru lah dikatakan cerdik betul tak? melayu yang kata Malaysia negara melayu islam tak cerdik wakakaka....
@@sunbokyh7793brave enough to show your stupidity by parading this prof kangkong....
Well said prof and Malaysia needs citizen like you to help us Malaysian to move forward .
You are a beautiful soul Sir.
wow -wow -- malaysia need more ppl like prof tajuddin --may the great allah bless you n your family..
Tq Prof. Tajuddin, you have rightly and correctly said about the race, religion and cultural matters of Malaysia....our beloved country.
Well explained with your great understanding of malaysia. Salute to you
Well said. Prof who knows his heart, his religion, his God. When you know your true God and understand the teachings, you will carry it with you and not feel threatened just because of a dish, a word, a song, concerts etc etc. We cannot be living under a tempurung and not understand and accept the diversities of this world. In Malaysia, we all know it's full of sensitivities. Sometimes it is sad to see the contradictions.
What a great professor Tajuddin philosophies.
Excellent narratives, so knowledgeable definitely earned our respect. Our country need more genius like this prof Tajuddin to be our leaders. "My Hats Off You prof Tajuddin "
Well said Prof. Firstly Our history must be rewritten. You are truly a Malaysian.
Well said prof. If 90% of Muslim thinks like you, we will have world peace. Good work 👍, hope you can translate to other languages for others to understand your values.
Happy to have 30%😂😮😂!
Just One will do if that is PM10.but......
Actually most of the Muslims don't care about this, it is just like what Prof said, politician uses this as a topic. There's Halal bao as well. there's no need to make them think or anything, most of them don't care, they only know that food is food, as long as they are made halal, the name of the food doesn't matter.
@@AnotherCloudyday-nj6yr true.. But the common ppl pick it up from the politician then what say you like in this case.
This why saying the common ppl don't care is like sweeping it under the carpet.
It's always there just waiting for it to ignite.
If everyone here agrees with Prof Tajuddin..he dare to speak out we should be brave to share in our own social media. I shared in FB. Hope you brave to do that too. 🙏
Only very intellectual persons like prof.. with such a wide knowledge and perspective besides Islamic knowledge can save our beloved country, Malaysia. Hats off and we salute you, Prof for being a true Malaysian with a big heart for a better Malaysia for all and the future generations.
Great explanation and elaboration from a learned scholar !!!
I don't know what to say except to give you one like. Hats off to you
Deep heartfelt THANK YOU to you professor for your views on this storm in a tea cup "issue" which we never really had. I truly hope that all Malaysians will strive to educate themselves about the evils of a lot of our politicians who abuse religion and divide us.
A very wise professor we ever know with so much Compassanate mind.
Hello Prof Tajuddin, again the Muslim in this country is not truly Islamic when they (Muslim) prohibit the heritage food of Bak Kut Teh from being recognised as heritage in Malaysia. As Islam is a beautiful religion, it allows the non Muslim to practise freedom to eat their heritage food. So, I don't see the Bak Kut Teh being recognised as Heritage food pose any problem because the Bak Kut Teh dish is just a name " Meat Bone Soup". The meat can be pork, lamb, beef, fish, seafood, chicken & the soup is made from herbs. So, the Muslims need not be sensitive to prohibit the Bah Kut Teh being recognised as Heritage Food.
Hello Prof Tajuddin , you are truly Asian and MALAYSIAN. Respect to you PROF. Good health to you. Always .
There is no compulsion in Islam !
相由心造,
We even have vegetarian BKT...for crying out loud!!
All this just wasting time, energy & chances to be better. Respect to Prof.
thank you prof🙏❤👍
Well said in a righteousness way in regards to individual religious precepts and regardless of race! We welcome, follow and respect to such act of ‘perpaduan’ in harmony. Thanks Prof 👏👏👏
Orang negara lain dah nak ke planet Marikh, orang Malaysia masih lagi di takuk perkauman.
Bukan orang Malaysia lah. Orang Melayu dan islam masih tunggang buraqh dan cari pokok gadhgad untuk ditebang. Masih meneropong bulan untuk cari rekahan tempat bulan terbelah walaupun dah terbukti bulan sama sekali tidak boleh dibelah.
Pemikiran sempit
Sebab minda feudal dan semangat ketuanan Melayu sangat kuat di kalangan orang Melayu. Sedih.
kerana nak dapat publicity murah atau free.......
Baca buku Golden Khersonese oleh Paul Wheatley, kerajaan di awal kurun masihi adalah kerajaan India Selatan dan ada komuniti berkulit putih cerah, tak ada komuniti berkulit coklat lah.
Melayu juga pendatang ke Malaya.
Prof ur explanation is great. Tqvm for sharing
Well said Prof !! You need politician like you. 👏👏👏👍🏼
I personally respect your understanding on every issues with regards to race, religion, and cultures of multiracial citizens in this country. I really hope that there are more professors and learned peoples like you. Thank you professor, hope your clarification will reach every citizen of this country. I think you should be one of the advisors to the government of the day👍👍👍❤
Simple BKT dish became a national issue😢 This opens a can of worms! You have done a good job in clearifying and educating those blinded by evil politicians who fool the ppl for self gain! Great respect to you sir!😅
These politicians have to create a controversy so that they can get their names into the limelight. Otherwise, they are irrelevant.
Our parliament has spent all time in racism and religion obsession. No one capable of even talking economic, technology and nation survivor.
Brilliant... Thanks and respect to prof Tajuddin!👍👍👍🙏
Well said Prof👏👏👏
Because of narrow mindedness Malaysia looses out in social economic development and goes back into the dark ages where more fear and suspicion exists. Finally we really have many "misses". I have heartaches to see my beloved Malaysia going back in the time tunnel.😢😢😢
Do you know that the learned Professor whom many non malays adore listed in his personal profile as a malay first then a Malaysian second.? He received many benefits as a bumi and a scholarship to study in US . I am not implying anything. Up to viewers to judge.
@@chrislee528 Good food for thoughts.
Narrow minded ,R u talking about that one community who have its own school vernacular and still demand and disturb bumi right ,ur community logic be like::
When UMNO talk about malay ,ohhh racist malay
When DAP or MCA talk about chinese community ,,,ohhh we not racist,we malaysian malaysia
My brain not braining with this community
Thanks for offering such an straight-up incisive view loaded with illumining examples, Prof. I would be more appreciative if this clip was made in Bahasa, so that more Malays not so conversant with English are able to get such historical nourishment as I am.
Professor you are the Best to break the ice of some under educated minded who were up to University Level to really understand other Races Speciality of their individual invented famous dishes for their tables...Bak Kut Teh @ General all Types of Meats or now any Buddhist who are full life time Vegetarian named it Vegetarian Bak Kut Teh...See???....
Tqvm for your Open Minded and Spoken Out To Bring Justice and Fairness for all races in Malaysia regardless of any religions to savour the Tasty Herbal Teh for Muslims and Non Muslims to choose from Non or Halal Kut Herbal Teh...
In fact it's also bring some good medical TCM value in the Herbal Ingredients too for our body in general well beings...
Well said Prof Tajuddin! We hold u in high esteem as you are very knowledgeable, fair and kind. May Allah bless you for coming out to voice your take on what is the truth!!
My utmost respect and appreciation to you Prof, for your effort, dedication and hard work in bridging the divide. May God Bless you...
Prof. You are the 'srila consciousness' for malay community. Keep it up. God is behind you.
V well said. Prof Tajuudin.Salute n respect Sir.
Cool. If possible, appreciate it if Prof could do more videos in English so that friends from abroad can have a better understanding about the real Malaysia. Thanks for this wonderful video.
Excellent speech Prof.Tajuddin. I suggest the Government will form a NGO headed by Prof.tajuddin to check on politicians or entities abusing Islam for personal and political purposes! This will make Malaysia a better place...less chaos and misunderstandings.🙏🏻
Hi prof. Love from Sabah👌❤️
Prof. Bakuteh berasal Dari pelabuhan Klang. Kenapa Pelabuhan?. Orang Hokkien kerja angkut barang barang berat pelabuhan guna badan sendiri. Gaji sikit. Kerja panas hujan. Tiada mesin angkut barang. Semua pakai tenaga badan. Bandan Tua sakit badan Dan kaki. Bagaimana Bakuteh dijumpai ? Perdagangan herba juga berlaku di pelabuhan Klang. Pekerja pelabuhan juga angkut herba Yang berat. Ada herba kayu Dan daun terjatuh ke lantai perlabuhan. Jadi perkerja pun kutip saki Baki herba Yang terjatuh masa pulang kerja. Merdeka pun Campur semua jenis saki Baki herba Yang terjatuh ke lantai perlabuhan. Megapa Tulang rusuk? Ini adalah kerana perkerja angkut barang tak Ada duit Beli daging. Daging Mahal bagi Mereka pada masa ITU. sebab ini Beli Tulang murah. Jadi herba pelbagai Jenis dimasak dengan Tulang. Lepas Makan perkerja pelabuhan Klang Ada tenaga angkut barang . Kami sendi tidak sakit. Lebih bertenaga Cari duit berapa Sen sehari. Ini kisah Susah orang hokkien Malaysia di perlabuhan Klang . Ada media Singapore buat documentary Bakuteh. Singapore Cuba claim Bakuteh dari Singapore. Tetapi. Herba memang dari Singapore.. tapi Cara resepi campuran bukan dari Singapore. Resipi ITU di atas herba herba Yang terjatuh atas lantai perlabuhan Klang. Perkerja pelabuhan tiada duit Beli herba. Jadi kutip saki Baki herba Dan Campur sendiri. Sebenar ialah sup Tulang herba.
Well explained.
Sup tulang kambing Versus Sup bak kut teh(non halal food).
Masaalahnya Prof....kita tiada larangan bnyk mana pon mereka nak minum tp daging yg digunakan
.ketidakpastian babi, ayam , kambing/ sembelih tak? Lagipon kita cuma tak setuju diangkat sbg makanan wariasan. Bnyk lg makanan lain spt nasi lemak , roti canai, rendang pon kita tak angkat jadikan makanan warisan cuma iktiraf sbg makanan Malaysia...
🤨 org Malaysia yg cipta resepi bak kut teh ni memang tak patut Singapore nak claim, banyak cantik sangat diorang ni😤
@@sapiyahkassim5176sambal takde nasi lemak takde sambal dari asal indon fikir
Prof, as usual you are so on point. It is just a dish and it is the way how it is prepared.
I wish there are more enlightened Muslims like Prof. Tajuddin, in this country. Someone, who is able to explain issues in a clear and rational manner.
Nope, this Prof is explaining in term of Islam. Food has nothing to do with religion.
So well presented, Professor. You are the greatest!
Well said Prof. High respect to you. 😊
Well said, Prof! Islam is progressive, dynamic and beautiful. True preacher of Islam will embrace peace, tolerance, forgiveness and not harness hatred, separation, misunderstanding.
However, some religious preacher and politicians had found religion as weapon to advance their political selfish interest.
As prof had said clearly, as a proud Muslim, why not we embrace something bigger than ourselves from a wider perspective.
The practice of religion (ajaran sesat) had shaped the Muslim into something very undemocratic, narrow, persimistic and low self esteem. They had been misled and threatened by the politicians and hence afraid to embrace advancement and differences.
Negarawan is a one who lead to build nation with the interest of future generation and hence leave a legacy.
Politicians cast fear factor among Malay for the sake of their short term interest and to enrich themselves.
Very well put my dear professor! Kudos to your common sense and understanding!
Its hard to change the mindset of some people on this issue prof..I can't understand.
Very well explained. With someone like you being a Muslim and bumiputra saying this, Malaysia have a glimmer of hope. I left Malaysia more than 25 years ago to give my children a better future because of the injustice dished out to non bumiputras even though our fore father's sacrificed in the nation building of this country call Malaysia.
My opinion as a pendatangs. Thank you Prof.
Terima kasih Prof.
Well explained.
thank you professor for an excellent presentation! Mutuality, inclusivity, respect, compassionate, understanding bring peace to the world, benefiting humanity in the ages to come!
Halal/ haram Pau, mi, dim sum bergantung kpd ingredients nya. Begitu juga BKT, haram / halal juga bergantung kpd ingredients nya. Semudah ABC
Thanks Prof for your truth in your views which is nothing other than a dish’s name, whether it’s halal or not.
I fully agree with your remarks on the UMNO youth chief who actually is bankrupt of constructive and rational ideas towards nation building rather than becoming a ´ Batu API ´ with divisive narratives.
Honestly, who is actually the prince of the land ´ is not proven yet todate but regardless we achieve independence from the British with all 3 main races ( Malay, Chinese & Indians ) together.
In fact the first delegation led by TAR to Britain was unsuccessful in its request for independence simply due to the fact that the delegation was represented by the Malay & Chinese but not the Indians. It was only after the 3 main races was represented in TAR’s subsequent delegation that we got the approval for Independence.
Thus, history of how our independence was achieved was maliciously interpreted by certain Malay leaders who wanted to remain in power.
Thank you Sir. Very matured and sharp statements. Loved it. Not just because of the food but the open minded thought process which make our Malaysia larger than we think.
I’ve travelled around the world and each time coming back to my motherland just the descending note enough to feel I’m home.
“KEPADA WARGANEGARA MALAYSIA, SELAMAT PULANG KE TANAH AIR”
Regards,
Proud Malaysian
Vishnu VIDOLA
Well said Prof.Tajuddin. salute you for your fair say!
Brilliant explanation and hope there will be more intellectuals like you especially among out politicians to lead this country especially with the way the country is regressing so much these days
Prof Tajuddin, u r truly gentleman. Wish more Muslim in Malaysia think like u.
Good speak, Sir. Total Respect. Peace
true words by you tapek
First time i know there are good common sense malay like prof. Tajuddin. Salute to you sir. God bless you and family..🙏🙏 you are man of knowledge 👍🏾👍🏾
Well said sir!! It comforting to note that we still have very knowledgeble and moderate minded academician in our country.
Thank you professor for this much needed episode.
On Bak Kut Teh, I was introduced to seafood version some time back. At the same time, I’m also a fan of vegetarian version of Bak Kut Teh.
Thank you once again, for sharing the history of pre Malaysia.
Thank you very much for this clear and precise explanation.You are the greatest of all
Thank you Prof, for simply being logical and rational. You have my high respect.
One of the best explanation and solution given by a Malay intellectual on nation building and how Malaysia is made of and the many contributions by various foreign regimes or cultural influences. I personally and sincerely salute Professor Tajuddin.
Thank you to Prof for the short sejarah recap. This is exactly what happens when sejarah subject taught in our schools have been altered so much due to political reasons
Thank you Sir for your enlighten knowledge and the wisdom to analyse the difference of who to consume what ? As other ethnic people have no problem with Muslims consuming beef other ethnic groups should be allowed to consume what ever they prefer. Thank you sir. Thank you indeed. Thank you for putting History in the correct prospective.
Bravo Prof! Knowledge, facts and common sense always triumphs over emotionally driven rhetoric which our politicians are famous for.
Well said & respectable Professor Tajuddin. You are very knowledgeable and thank you for your fair & open minded sharing.
I am a Buddhist vegetarian, i used to take vegetarian bak ku teh without any meat😂
Chinese being a pork eater, bakkuteh even it mean meat naturally cook with pork. Just like muslim, when you said dagging (meat) you use beef.
Just like chakoitiao, konloumee, hokiancha all use pork. But many malay did sell with no pork.
wrong...............
Salute Sir. These are words of wisdom without twisting the facts or riding on the religion for political gain.
Thank you Professor for making this video. God bless.
Singapore generates US500 million from Taylor Swift concert and Malaysian majority are worried about naming Bak Kut Teh as heritage for the chinese minority.
We are getting poorer and poorer.
God damn it
BKT is not heritage to chinese only, for all races. That is true malaysian.
Allons-y. Malaysia wake up!
A very very rare knowledgeable person like prof Tajuddin
Very wise, thoughtful & understanding Prof. Tajuddin! Keep it up the good works!
Thank You Prof Tajuddin for educating us ! 👍
"Nation building is about being in a larger family, respecting other cultures" THIS is what we all should keep in heart as Malaysians. Thank you Prof!
A very wise and well educated man. I wish everyone is open minded thinks and reason like you. ❤
Thank you Prof Tajuddin for making time for us Malaysian to have better understanding of the mentioned politicized topics affecting the trust and unity of the Rakyat. Your knowledge and professionalism given to the Rakyat reduces the racial annoyance on the 3 RRR used to upset the nationalism of the Malaysians. Please continue to share your time and effort to educate those ignorance who is not blissful but the roots of evil destroying trust and unity among the generations to come.
Prof Tajuddin, you are a very rare Malay breed of a very high caliber. It is a privilege to listen to what you have to say on all the various issues afflicting Malaysians.
Well said Prof... In Singapore our food centres has Halal Ayam BukKuaTeh. We have many Chinese Muslim.
Prof, I have read many of your articles. And I am really proud that we have such a Malaysian in your distinguished self. How I wish that our MPs are like your humble self! Wishful thinking?
TOP ❤ FOR PROFESSOR. WE ❤ YOUR WIDENED AND REASONABLE MIND.
WE ❤ YOU AND ABANG JOH WHO PERMITTED THE SINGING OF "THE SILENT NIGHT".
THANK YOU PROF, WE ❤ YOU FOR YOUR UNSELFISH SHARING. ❤❤❤❤❤❤.
We ordinary people do not care much about certain food being listed as heritage or warisan or whatnot. Don't know what the fuss is about 🤦🏻♂️
Greetings from Singapore. Your video is very refreshing . . . In the end, if people want to live together - they will live together regardless of the differences. If they don't want to - everything is an issue...