Anvil 065: S&W model 29-2 Trigger stud replacement

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 дек 2024

Комментарии • 341

  • @marknovak8255
    @marknovak8255  3 года назад +79

    To clarify; I did NOT drill a alignment/dimension critical hole by hand. The drill was used to loosen a broken insert, revealing a precision hole previously drilled by the manufacturer. We were very careful not to disturb this.

  • @aussiebloke609
    @aussiebloke609 3 года назад +28

    "...did he shoot 5 shots, or six - _before it broke?"_ Got a good belly laugh out of that one, Mark. Outstanding! :-)

  • @wendyvic4046
    @wendyvic4046 2 месяца назад +2

    I know this is an older video, but I just wanted to say, great job, not just on the video, but the information and presentation too.

  • @lindanelson8400
    @lindanelson8400 3 года назад +11

    Nothing more beautiful than an old S&W revolver with the deep mirror blue and wood grips.

    • @cameronmccreary4758
      @cameronmccreary4758 3 года назад +1

      Mark said, he was going to rust blue the revolver when he was test-firing it in the rain. I do rust bluing and it typically doesn't come out to mirror finish however, the rust blue finish is more durable than the Smith & Wesson finish.

    • @marknovak8255
      @marknovak8255  3 года назад +1

      @@cameronmccreary4758 FAR more durable.....

  • @jamesw9930
    @jamesw9930 3 года назад +6

    We just got to watch Mark work on his own gun and he didn't half ass it like the rest of us would have. Oh, and you have to respect a man that is his own drill press

  • @kbjerke
    @kbjerke 3 года назад +5

    Important information that translates directly to my Model 28 Highway Patrolman. Thanks, Mark!!

  • @ghostgunsgeark.l.4439
    @ghostgunsgeark.l.4439 3 года назад +4

    " I know what you're thinking..... Did he fire five shots or was it six? Are you feeling lucky punk? Well are you!?" Great content Mark! Thank you sir.

  • @mikemalliski8380
    @mikemalliski8380 3 года назад +4

    I had a poor mans Model 29 back in the day. A S&W model 28, six inch in .357. Carried that on duty for six seven years, great shooter.

  • @blackhorsecavalry
    @blackhorsecavalry 3 года назад +4

    "It is what it is". The best time of the day. Mark is going to show us how to play with the big boys.

  • @chipsterb4946
    @chipsterb4946 2 года назад +6

    I bought a 99% Model 29 (no dash) not too long ago, so watching you drill through the frame was cringy as hell. Had to do it though! Your engineering change to use the threaded pin and leave those plate bushings intact made so much sense. Thanks

  • @keithdaniels5918
    @keithdaniels5918 3 года назад +6

    I had that happen to a M29 once about 1986/7…..sent it back to S&W to repair. Revolver had well over 5000 full power rounds through it and was really smooth from that wear. It came back stiff as a new gun and appeared to have been reblued.

  • @wlewisiii
    @wlewisiii 3 года назад +3

    My personal preference is the model 13 in 357. That said, the S&W K frame is my biggest bit of gunsmithing. This was a delight to watch. Thank you, sir.

  • @marktroxler6798
    @marktroxler6798 3 года назад +4

    Peening the stud by striking a hammer with another hammer was a brilliant hack; so much better control than using a punch and hammer. I'll try this on other projects the next time the need arises.

  • @kriztov265
    @kriztov265 3 года назад +3

    As always I love watching Mark carry out work that others are afraid of. The truth of comments around precision is that there is always a means to get it humanly correct which is a lot of time all that is needed. Mass produced pistols always have the mystique of terms like hand finished custom fit and bedded etc. But in reality there is always tolerances involved and a careful human can can achieve these with due care and attention with what are basic tools as mark so often does. If you dont dare you dont win !!

  • @jpkalishek4586
    @jpkalishek4586 3 года назад +6

    First Model 29 in .44 Mag I saw in person,not long after the movie came out when I was a kid, was owned by a Catholic Priest from Chicago.

    • @PatrickJDaley
      @PatrickJDaley 3 года назад +1

      Kinda funny, I had the opportunity to work on a 29-0 that was owned by a Baptist pastor. Pristine condition. Just needed a trigger job. Made him an offer.... he still owns it!

  • @StaticMusic
    @StaticMusic 3 года назад +4

    You're an absolute living legend. Love your style man, from the UK

    • @werre2
      @werre2 3 года назад

      Vote better! Now that you're out of the evil empire you can be anything.

  • @TBullCajunbreadmaker
    @TBullCajunbreadmaker 3 года назад +3

    I've got a nickel model with 7 1/2" barrel and it is a hoot to shoot. I love mine. S&W made something that will always be a demand for. It is the handgun to have if you like six shooters.

  • @jerrymartin5100
    @jerrymartin5100 3 года назад +3

    Model 29, such a classic, I own the 10-5/8" silhouette and the 6 inch models, hurts my soul to see it drilled, but you sir are an artist.

  • @jayostrem6214
    @jayostrem6214 3 года назад +3

    This part presses in. Getting it out per my armorer class was "send to factory." I've only seen one pop out on its own, and that was on a Centennial. That one was educating. It was knurled on the edges and pressed in.

  • @SouthpawPablo
    @SouthpawPablo 3 года назад +3

    god i would pay monthly to learn in person from you the things you know the abilities you have and above all the experience to utilize and all of that into such amazing work and craftsmanship almost nonexistent tody I WOULD LOVE every min of it all of the learning! KEEP IT UP!

  • @recoilrob324
    @recoilrob324 3 года назад +7

    I always wondered how those studs were installed. Were they milled as part of the frame? That would be very difficult, so your replacement makes total sense now that you've shown how it's done. Now we know! Thanks!

    • @stewcarew4943
      @stewcarew4943 3 года назад

      The studs are brazed in. They are pressed in and stick out of the other side,a small ring of brass is put on each one and then the frame goes through an oven to melt it. The frame and studs are killed flush.

  • @ewicander9045
    @ewicander9045 3 года назад +3

    I don't know how I missed this one but I'm sure happy to see it today.

  • @perezmig577
    @perezmig577 3 года назад +4

    "Sometimes you just gots to know!" is the best quote for this day, close down the internet everyone.

  • @endutubecensorship
    @endutubecensorship 3 года назад +4

    I love the re-uploads. Thanks Mark and team.

    • @SH-gr1bc
      @SH-gr1bc 3 года назад +1

      They might be re-uploads for you. But they are new to us new guys! :)

    • @marknovak8255
      @marknovak8255  3 года назад +2

      @@SH-gr1bc And glad to have ya

    • @SH-gr1bc
      @SH-gr1bc 3 года назад

      @@marknovak8255 we need more of your excellent work Mr Novak. It would be great to see a collaboration with you and Ian McCollum. Especially since I heard you mention, working on some of his guns.

  • @thescatologistcopromancer3936
    @thescatologistcopromancer3936 3 года назад +1

    Makes me think about the Model 28 Highway Patrolman I inherited. The thing hadn't been cleaned in decades to the point that the ratchet was full of gunk and one chamber wouldn't lock in place. A deep clean helped.

  • @hughroadie2291
    @hughroadie2291 3 года назад +1

    I absolutely love your “sailor-isms”! Nice job cleaning up that “cow wizzing on a flat rock”! First time I heard the “uncut version” was from an old Chief BT in WestPac in 1968. Ha!

  • @nnamrehck
    @nnamrehck 3 года назад +2

    Your skill as a gunsmith just amazes me!

  • @jimvandemoter6961
    @jimvandemoter6961 3 года назад +6

    Mark, I know you said this is your personal gun, but I can just hear someone screaming, "what do you mean it costs $XXX.XX??!! It's just one little pin!!" Considering what it took to make one little pin I could understand the price of one little pin.

    • @LuvBorderCollies
      @LuvBorderCollies 3 года назад +1

      Oh yea, lot of people judge value by size. How much for that diamond?? Its just a tiny rock.!

    • @CAMSLAYER13
      @CAMSLAYER13 3 года назад +1

      @@LuvBorderCollies diamonds are pretty fucking over priced

  • @rpvak
    @rpvak 2 года назад +2

    Nice work-very interesting process. Glad you emphasized the wait time between the damage occurrence and repair and why. Btw, nice socks!🤣

  • @99Racker
    @99Racker 3 года назад +2

    Even well engineered pistols wear on critical parts. I have some well used Smiths that I had not considered such an issue on. Your attention to detail is appreciated. Great job.

  • @jeffstanley4593
    @jeffstanley4593 3 года назад +6

    I have a 29-2 and years ago I broke the hammer stud off while cleaning the gun. The gun is nickel plated and this was before 1984. I sent the gun back to S and W and they repaired and RE nickeled the gun, the whole gun as would be required to match the finish. NO charge.

    • @jeffstanley4593
      @jeffstanley4593 3 года назад +1

      @333badcat Chummy? Happy? You bet I was.

  • @michaelmichaelson8452
    @michaelmichaelson8452 3 года назад +1

    Mark your awesome, I know alot of Smith's today would have deadlines that gun for life but you brought it back from the dead.

  • @SteveandSusiesHomestead
    @SteveandSusiesHomestead 3 года назад

    It gets me every time you SEEM to take the easer way . But when I here you threw it makes perfect since . Thank you for including the thought process in your videos. Very important for a bull headed person like me.

  • @Whitpusmc
    @Whitpusmc 3 года назад +1

    I have this exact gun, I will be watching for this issue though it doesn’t get shot that much. Thanks for the trip down the rabbit hole!

  • @justfishing6067
    @justfishing6067 3 года назад +1

    This was a fun little adventure.
    Found your channel while cleaning the .500 version of that gun.
    I'm a huge fan of the half lug barrel, especially in my hell boy sized pew.
    Subscribed!

  • @CrazyPetez
    @CrazyPetez 3 года назад +1

    What a fascinating video about your gunsmithing knowedge and abilities repairing your Model 29. I love seeing how the actions in these older S&W revolvers. They give me insight into the action in my Model19-3.

  • @42pyroboy
    @42pyroboy 3 года назад +5

    To be perfectly clear and honest. The sounds of a storm DON'T detract from the video.

  • @MastGunWorks
    @MastGunWorks 3 года назад +1

    Love watching you work. I know there’s guys loosing their mind because you didn’t set that pistol up in a milling machine. But, I think it’s awesome that you did it the way you did with a hand drill and you were able to do it well.

  • @jamesstanlake4064
    @jamesstanlake4064 3 года назад +2

    You have the absolute talent of explaining the process and fix of repairing firearms. I greatly appreciate that. Well done!

  • @mpccenturion
    @mpccenturion 3 года назад +1

    A triple lock. Last time I heard about them - Elmer Kieth was shooting one and Ed Migiverne [sp?} Fast and Fancy Pistol shooting, back before WW 2. They are nice guns! PS - Mark - THANK YOU - Real Artists - GunSmiths should be doing this work. I still have a 44 Ruger - I bought when I was 20. Wish I bought the Super Comanche a friend offered for sale. Cheers Always!

    • @derekp2674
      @derekp2674 3 года назад

      Ed McGivern: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ed_McGivern

  • @LuvBorderCollies
    @LuvBorderCollies 3 года назад +1

    Very interesting. Got a Smith model 10 police trade-in a few years ago. Trigger/cylinder all worked but trigger felt odd. Sideplate off and problem was pretty obvious! Sent off to S&W and was wondering just how they fix those broken pins. I was impressed the revolver was still working, guess that speaks to the S&W design.

  • @SH-gr1bc
    @SH-gr1bc 3 года назад +1

    Shouldn't Re-timing a revolver, simply be a matter of replacing the worn out components? Was what I was going to ask. But then I pulled up a diagram of a S&W and holy cheese and crackers! There's a LOT of parts on this revolver! I thought the barrel was forged with the body of the revolver. But it makes sense to be able to replace the barrel. It made me appreciate your work on a whole new level.

    • @panzerabwerkanone
      @panzerabwerkanone 3 года назад +1

      A lot of these parts were still hand fitted by S&W factory.

  • @azkrouzreimertz9784
    @azkrouzreimertz9784 3 года назад

    I love how delicate you are even when using power tools

  • @donaldschumacher3683
    @donaldschumacher3683 3 года назад +3

    I have a Pre 29 that i hated to shoot until I figured out Coke bottle grips are not friends to my hands. Now with cheep Pachmayr grips it is a dream to shoot.

  • @Paladin1873
    @Paladin1873 3 года назад

    That was a slick repair job. I don't think I would have attempted it, but I do like your solution.

  • @stephenmorris8187
    @stephenmorris8187 3 года назад +2

    Always good content! Thanks for your time and the vid.

  • @cayminlast
    @cayminlast 3 года назад

    Excellent ! I so much enjoy watching and learning from a person with experience, skill and passion

  • @ResilientFreedom
    @ResilientFreedom 3 года назад +1

    Mark is a true artist.

  • @bryanfaulkenburg462
    @bryanfaulkenburg462 3 года назад +1

    Very cool repair. Way outside my very novice capabilities , but awsome content to watch .

  • @Khanclansith
    @Khanclansith 3 года назад

    Heart warming to see a classic brought back to life!

  • @PatRMG
    @PatRMG 3 года назад +4

    Oh yeah! A revolver is right in my "wheel'house!

    • @pbp6741
      @pbp6741 3 года назад +1

      Chuckle

    • @PatRMG
      @PatRMG 3 года назад +2

      @@pbp6741 Thank you thank you, I'll be here all day!

  • @pystykorva7114
    @pystykorva7114 3 года назад +3

    I've probably watched too much of Mark's work since i was thinking he might end up threading the stud in before he said he will ;)

  • @chrishewitt4220
    @chrishewitt4220 3 года назад

    Now that's a beautiful piece of art... such a lovely revolver.

  • @cameronmccreary4758
    @cameronmccreary4758 3 года назад +2

    Excellent repair work! Before I would have started the repair though, I would have asked myself one question; "do I feel lucky?"

  • @mertonsilliker3686
    @mertonsilliker3686 3 года назад +1

    Nice save. Scary when plan comes together.

  • @morgangallowglass8668
    @morgangallowglass8668 3 года назад +1

    Confirmed for sorcerer. Amazing work, Sir!

  • @frankhinkle5772
    @frankhinkle5772 3 года назад

    Sometimes... you just gotsda know.
    Thanks for that and for this video. The inside of a S&W revolver is a thing of beauty!

  • @texpatriot8462
    @texpatriot8462 3 года назад +7

    Never apologize for using the American measure system (the Brits abandoned it - it ours now).

    • @joewalker2152
      @joewalker2152 3 года назад +2

      We never abandoned it, we just use both.... the best of both really.......
      goo.gl/maps/8faRCqf31PEVAnS29

    • @CrazyPetez
      @CrazyPetez 3 года назад

      We call them Freedom Units.

    • @travissmith2211
      @travissmith2211 3 года назад +1

      Remember, the metric system is for those who suck at math.

    • @panzerabwerkanone
      @panzerabwerkanone 3 года назад +1

      Amurican units were good enough to send men to the Moon! ( just don't mix Murican and metric or you will lose your Mars probe)

    • @allangibson2408
      @allangibson2408 3 года назад +2

      @@panzerabwerkanone The Saturn V and Apollo spacecraft was all metric...
      It was designed by German engineers. The Space Shuttle used inch measurements...
      The British and American inches were different until 1959 when they both agreed to use a metric definition of an inch of 25.4mm (yes the current inch is a metric derivative unit and in the American case has been since 1897). That is also why the American Survey Foot is a different length to a regular foot.
      The British Legal inch was slightly shorter than the American inch. The Enfield inch was slightly longer than both (Hence 0.303 when 0.300 was ordered).

  • @keithmccormack6248
    @keithmccormack6248 3 года назад +6

    If you’re gonna shoot, shoot-don’t talk.
    -Tuco

  • @hoghunter6872
    @hoghunter6872 Год назад +4

    You should make a book with all your sketches from over the years. I think that would be great read

  • @joecallahan3379
    @joecallahan3379 3 года назад

    Good stuff, like to watch a guy work that knows his craft

  • @anthonyglickman6245
    @anthonyglickman6245 3 года назад +1

    Just a matter of hand fittin - excellent work and lesson! Thank you sir!

  • @SaposJoint
    @SaposJoint 3 года назад +1

    What a joy. Thank you, Mark.

  • @frankdn109
    @frankdn109 10 месяцев назад +3

    An absolutely riveting video :-) I figured you'd harden the stud, but no? And did you bush the oversized hole in the side plate?
    I had the hammer pivot stud snap on my J-frame. S&W fixed it free, on a gun that went out of warranty back when I still had hair!

  • @outspokengenius
    @outspokengenius 3 года назад +2

    How does one break a trigger stud on a S&W 29? It's not like it's a Rossi or a Rohm! Then again I bought a NOS 29-1 in 2005ish and after 500 rounds of Federal American Eagle it was out of time. I ended up trading it and some cash to a gunsmith for a new 629, never had a problem with that gun but after a few years I decided I'd rather have a 29 as I prefer blued guns. So I found a 29-5 4" for a good deal and bought it. I've had it since 2015 and put probably 2000 of my 240gr cast bullets over 18.0 grains of 2400 through it with no issues. I don't know if S&W made a 29-5 4" from the factory or if someone did this but I sure like it with light to medium loads.

    • @SlavicCelery
      @SlavicCelery 3 года назад +1

      Probably a flaw in the part. Something small that took a whole lot of rounds before fracturing. Either that, or someone dropped the revolver at some point in time. GunBlue(something something something) talks about working as a armorer for police forces back in the day. Stuff like that usually came around as a result of dropped guns.

  • @GHOST0766
    @GHOST0766 3 года назад

    Another great and informative video... and now to sit and wait until the next one

  • @cheif10thumbs
    @cheif10thumbs 3 года назад +1

    I used to do warranty repairs for S&W back when there was money in it. I would have counseled returning it to the factory for this repair. I'm sure Mark knows the "You Touch It, You Own It Rule." Particularly the liability factor on this doomed weapon. Nuff said.

    • @derekp2674
      @derekp2674 3 года назад

      I think Mark said he was only deviating from the "return to S&W" procedure because he owned the firearm in question. I guess this one must have seen a lot of use to wear out the trigger pivot that way. I had a Model 14 as my "most serious" centrefire match revolver from about 1980 until 1997 and must have put several thousands of rounds through it over those years.

  • @Robin6512
    @Robin6512 3 года назад +1

    Excactly the same model I have.
    Good revolvers.

  • @joelfildes5544
    @joelfildes5544 3 года назад

    I gottstaknow ! Brilliant,I’ve ordered my Umarex 6.5 inch BB version,coz that’s all they’ll let us have in the Uk ! Still though,I can’t wait ! Cheers from Blighty

  • @robotbuster1487
    @robotbuster1487 3 года назад +2

    What audio problem? The John Philip Sousa marches sounded superb

  • @lidlett9883
    @lidlett9883 3 года назад +1

    Well done Mark as always

  • @RatelLaw
    @RatelLaw 3 года назад

    Always informative, always interesting. Thank you .

  • @dbmail545
    @dbmail545 3 года назад +1

    As many S&W as I have owned, I never knew that the cylinder retaining boss was a separate piece that included the trigger pivot pin.

  • @stephenknutson1343
    @stephenknutson1343 3 года назад

    Magic stuff I have always wondered about, good work!

  • @dennisbartoskewitz7847
    @dennisbartoskewitz7847 3 года назад

    Once again, very informative and excellent video. Thanks Mark !

  • @raymondhorvatin1050
    @raymondhorvatin1050 3 года назад +1

    Innovative repair thanks for sharing

  • @WestCoastChicano
    @WestCoastChicano 3 года назад

    My favorite gun in the whole world is my beautiful Model 29 Dirty Harry style. Excellent video as usual. 🔫 🇺🇸

  • @russellskalla6658
    @russellskalla6658 3 года назад

    Shoulda gone with a Ruger Redhawk. Just poking fun. Fantastic job my friend.

  • @Sven-_Trials
    @Sven-_Trials 3 года назад

    Ballsy hand drilling and tapping, to keep all in square and relation to the other studs. You are the big boy!

    • @CCW1911
      @CCW1911 3 года назад +2

      That was the only time I've watched Mark work that I had pause, I'm not that confident in hand drilling and tapping and would've done the drilling and tapping in my mill, but it worked for him so all good.

  • @travissmith2211
    @travissmith2211 3 года назад +2

    I admire the humility you show when stating that you just recently felt up to the task of such an endeavor. Also, was that Sousa on the reassembly time lapse?

  • @timothyruggles7396
    @timothyruggles7396 3 года назад +1

    Thank god for the saviour of the breed

  • @eduk4387
    @eduk4387 3 года назад +3

    I'm here for the great music.

  • @foxmoth5477
    @foxmoth5477 3 года назад +9

    please show the rust bluing of the frame - the small area you now have to rust blue to match the rest of the gun - you have never shown a small area rust blued to match the rest of the guns bluing that is still ok - that process, many of us have a pistol or gun that needs a touch up in an area with rust bluing...

    • @CAMSLAYER13
      @CAMSLAYER13 3 года назад

      Pretty sure you just do the whole thing

  • @onpsxmember
    @onpsxmember 3 года назад

    I hope you do a little follow up when you do the rust bluing, even when you only show the end result.

  • @cheapolegunguy
    @cheapolegunguy 3 года назад +1

    Always a pleasure, thanks :)

  • @phileas007
    @phileas007 3 года назад +4

    Ok, here's a question:
    When cold, both the SA & DA are silky smooth.
    When warm (2-3 full cylinders at the range), the SA is still fine but the DA snags and brings me no pleasure.
    Any clue what the cause could be???

    • @marknovak8255
      @marknovak8255  3 года назад +8

      DA and SA use two different sears, two different feels. First, make sure the ejector rod is tight, this can cause problems. Heating up implies drying out. Run lots of oil in front of the hammer then cycle dry a bunch. Run it WET for a few cylinders, then blow out with compressed air.

    • @phileas007
      @phileas007 3 года назад +2

      @@marknovak8255 Thanks so much for taking the time to answer.

  • @banzaibailey5891
    @banzaibailey5891 3 года назад +2

    Repost but I still happily watched it. Hey, could you repost your work on the trench gun refurbishment, the one where you added a reproduction bayonet mount? I built up my own "SIT DOWN GUN" tribute from an old Western Field (Mossberg 500). I was pleased with the way it came out and tried to re-watch your video to compare and can't find it. Please ignore if it's posted and I just couldn't find it. Love your work, thanks.

  • @bbqsauce8854
    @bbqsauce8854 3 года назад +1

    We love you Novak

  • @gabrielathero
    @gabrielathero 3 года назад +2

    14:49 watching your video during a thunderstorm was a little bit confusing, having one thunderstorm outside the house, and one in your video XD

  • @olskool3967
    @olskool3967 3 года назад

    you must have recorded that last Wednesday. here in SC it was raining cats and dogs that day! i am about 30 miles from you. good video,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

  • @michaelbytner9346
    @michaelbytner9346 Год назад +2

    Dear mister Novak
    I got today a beautiful S&W 29-2, in mint condition with the serial N1295.. (I concealed the last two digits).
    Can you tell me please what for build year is this one?
    My guess is something around 1973, but I don't have exactly information.
    Thank you sir in advance and wish you all the best!

  • @a.h.9663
    @a.h.9663 3 года назад

    Awesome as always Mark

  • @Crustymarine
    @Crustymarine 3 года назад +3

    I enjoyed this video.

  • @williammills7778
    @williammills7778 3 года назад +1

    Another awsome post thanks for sharing...now we know too😁

  • @oftenwrong.
    @oftenwrong. 3 года назад

    Wished you would have shown the rust bluing portion. It is what it is.
    Best regards from Idaho

  • @kutamsterdam
    @kutamsterdam 3 года назад

    Outstanding ... now we know ... thanks ... again Mark.

  • @fursu69
    @fursu69 3 года назад +2

    What happend with the hole in the plate was the old pin so worn that it wobled or did he fit a new socket?

  • @bobdunn4179
    @bobdunn4179 3 года назад +1

    Marching band! Victory is in the air!

  • @FelisSilvestrisBE
    @FelisSilvestrisBE 3 года назад +2

    Is this a re-upload? I seem to remember something like this on your channel, fixing studs in a revolver frame. Weird.
    Also: Please don't apologise for the audio. You don't control the forces of nature and personally I find it rather soothing. Rain, thunder, sounds excellent weather for tinkering with guns in a 'shed' ;)

  • @christurley391
    @christurley391 3 года назад +1

    Thanks for the video.