Just Play Nadu - The Objectively Correct Deck Choice For Modern RCQ Season (Pre-B&R Announcement)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 12 сен 2024
  • With no restrictions on timing or price, what would be your deck of choice for this Modern RCQ Season?
    It should be Bant Nadu! (Especially pre-B&R)
    Let's discuss Cedric Philip's thoughts on this and expand a little.
    #mtg #magicthegathering #meta #crazy #wow
    ______________________________________________
    Come Hang Out On Twitch: / thatmillguy
    Find Me On Twitter For More Updates: / millthat
    Follow me on Tiktok: / thatmillguy
    Mill Discord Invite Link: / discord

Комментарии • 53

  • @doc1739
    @doc1739 22 дня назад +43

    This seems like the absolute worst time to buy into any format except maybe pauper

    • @jiaan100
      @jiaan100 22 дня назад +1

      I don't see any reason it would get better. Other than wotc going out of business, that would help a lot.

    • @cedarbobedar7223
      @cedarbobedar7223 22 дня назад +5

      great time to buy into commander - the bloomburrow precons are sweet lol

    • @fusionxtras
      @fusionxtras 21 день назад +1

      Oathbreaker looks fun tbh
      Edit:im trying to get my friends to try it out on cockatrice so hopefully it is fun

    • @alexanderastrom1845
      @alexanderastrom1845 21 день назад

      @@doc1739 pauper is amazing right now with new metas every week due to counterplay

    • @cjams115
      @cjams115 21 день назад

      Never a bad time to start building your own cube

  • @behemoth9543
    @behemoth9543 22 дня назад +7

    Nadu is 1. on the banlist, The One Ring is likely 2., Grief somewhere after, while definetely very unfun probably still behind cards like Guide/Ocelot/Wrath of the Skies in terms of powerlevel.. No way Grief gets banned and Ring doesn't.

  • @BoltTheEmolga
    @BoltTheEmolga 22 дня назад +26

    I mean, The One Ring *has* to go before Grief does. Like there’s no way it’s Grief first.

    • @storeblaa
      @storeblaa 22 дня назад

      This

    • @AFailedTuringTest
      @AFailedTuringTest 22 дня назад +3

      Grief if definitely more important to ban

    • @storeblaa
      @storeblaa 22 дня назад +3

      @@AFailedTuringTest Because of feelsbads?

    • @tacotuesday458
      @tacotuesday458 18 дней назад +1

      Banning Grief will let combo decks to run rampant. Committing to scam decks aren’t strong enough right now with Boros/Mardu Energy that can still get by from top decking

  • @cerilious
    @cerilious 22 дня назад +20

    Banning furry was not a mistake IMO. Being able to destroy 4 creatures for free makes so many archetypes unplayable it was bad for diversity.

  • @nlj4523
    @nlj4523 22 дня назад +11

    Grief is not even a problem in modern right now. The problem cards are Nadu and The One Ring. Boros energy and Mardu energy are playing The One Ring now. The grief hate is truly subjective because objectively it is not the worse thing at the moment.

  • @TiredOfHumans
    @TiredOfHumans 22 дня назад +6

    Decks that play grief make up at most 9% of the meta. The top black decks mardu energy, and dimir murktide both dont run the card. Grief really is at an all time low in modern

  • @PressXtoDoubt
    @PressXtoDoubt 22 дня назад +10

    Can we just put a stipulation that Modern cards need to go through Standard??

    • @Heltonheta
      @Heltonheta 21 день назад +1

      Oh, the old times 😢

    • @PressXtoDoubt
      @PressXtoDoubt 21 день назад +1

      @@Heltonheta this would kill my Merfolk deck but I'm willing to make the sacrifice.

  • @scyphron4357
    @scyphron4357 22 дня назад +4

    Mono black necro has a terrible matchup against nadu. Its roughly 40% win rate

  • @justBlake11
    @justBlake11 22 дня назад +2

    Modern has too many problems for one banlist to fix.

  • @jasonkorf7700
    @jasonkorf7700 22 дня назад +4

    To win, Nadu. To have fun and play a deck that fits my play-style, then it's Affinity. However, Affinity is practically dead for competitive play in this current meta. So for those going up against Nadu, good luck.

  • @grzegorzszewczak7089
    @grzegorzszewczak7089 22 дня назад +1

    In Wrocław (Poland) RCQ took place last Saturday and Sunday.
    I didn't check the results from Sunday, but on Saturday the top 8 were:
    1xNadu, 2xFrogtide, 1x colorful Eldrazi (not sure how many colors) and 4x controls.
    One of the best players (top 8 on the Legacy European tour last year), he didn't even make the top 8 at this RCQ, even though played Nadu.

  • @sambrown9475
    @sambrown9475 22 дня назад +2

    Grief has been living up to its name

  • @pikachuhoodie
    @pikachuhoodie 22 дня назад +1

    I genuinely want to have a real conversation with you on the health of the formats. I think most content creators are way off base on this ban announcement.

  • @djkatsuo
    @djkatsuo 22 дня назад +3

    I love to win but I don’t want an asterisk next to my name by playing with a broken card.

  • @cedarbobedar7223
    @cedarbobedar7223 22 дня назад +2

    I wonder how people would react to them reintroducing restricted cards and limiting cards people are sick of to 1 copy - could hit Bowmasters, One Ring (very flavor), Nadu, Sheoldred, Grief, and whatever else - would force people to use more tutors and make them less efficient plays and make some space in the meta without outright banning the top cards

  • @MistaMofr0
    @MistaMofr0 22 дня назад

    I played nadu at my last big tournament in town and honestly I know it's the best but I also now know that I hate playing it and that makes my win rate go down a lot. I'll stick to thopter sword for now to see how it goes

  • @tacotuesday458
    @tacotuesday458 18 дней назад

    My man has deep hatred for Grief

  • @pokclaymonmaster5286
    @pokclaymonmaster5286 22 дня назад

    I play mill confidently enough to say nadu isn’t an issue. With other decks focusing on the bird, they have less tech for mill at least where I’m at. I don’t have money to dump into it, even if I did I’d still stay with mill.

  • @DELTA-Gacha-Addict
    @DELTA-Gacha-Addict 22 дня назад

    They better not ban The One Ring at least. Because I got 2 copies and doing fine.

  • @tinfoilslacks3750
    @tinfoilslacks3750 21 день назад

    Reminder that Magic will continue to exist even if WotC stops existing. You can just make your own cards.

    • @Gweezy12
      @Gweezy12 21 день назад

      Hahaha make your own cards.

  • @jacktheooblord6648
    @jacktheooblord6648 20 дней назад

    Easy answer I will always play og jund. It may not be the best by a mile these days but consistency and pure fun the deck provides will always outclass this mess of the modern game.

  • @Sorran87
    @Sorran87 22 дня назад +4

    Be brave WOTC. Ban 10 cards

  • @TheGoodColonel
    @TheGoodColonel 22 дня назад

    RCQs are dead where I live until september. Thanks Wizards!

  • @xternalpunk
    @xternalpunk 22 дня назад

    Good thing my RCQ is after the ban

  • @falandfriends4760
    @falandfriends4760 22 дня назад +1

    I’m guessing they ban shuko and grief. Instead of Nadu and necro.
    Can’t sell the new cards if they are already banned.

    • @TiredOfHumans
      @TiredOfHumans 22 дня назад

      What percentage of the meta do you think grief decks take up?

  • @joshua_lee732
    @joshua_lee732 22 дня назад

    Even if Nadu is the correct choice I'll always err on the side of fun. I'll play UR Wizards

  • @evanbleu6362
    @evanbleu6362 21 день назад

    Nadu ? Nah, don't
    Ban'em, them and Grief

  • @danw.1250
    @danw.1250 22 дня назад

    FFS, Let Fury go. Play Phlage, it's a perfectly appropriate replacement.

  • @AntonioBaker-q4o
    @AntonioBaker-q4o 18 дней назад

    lol in 2 days nadu is banned and you walk back on this video bets in the replies

  • @syngen12
    @syngen12 22 дня назад

    One ring, nadu and grief need to be ban unban fury

    • @whiteerdydude
      @whiteerdydude 22 дня назад +1

      If you think a board wipe on a 3 power doublestriker that can be cast reliably for FREE is healthy and/or fine for the format, we need to ban more cards

    • @elijahlyons8164
      @elijahlyons8164 21 день назад

      Fury ruining all x/1s and x/2s forever in the format made me leave for legacy. Then fury got banned and I have no interest in returning.

  • @jiaan100
    @jiaan100 22 дня назад +1

    Just dont play any format that theyre ruining to sell packs. Premodern is cool.

  • @jbs6614
    @jbs6614 21 день назад

    just play Nadu and get the card banned 🤣

  • @michaelcollins4534
    @michaelcollins4534 22 дня назад

    Bird

  • @L8RSTORM
    @L8RSTORM 22 дня назад

    no thank