'Separate South Country' Controversy - Dr. Jayaprakash Narayan on Regional Imbalance

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 окт 2024

Комментарии • 110

  • @kranthikn3
    @kranthikn3 8 месяцев назад +8

    I completely agree with all the views and good that you have taken time to speak about this topic separately!! But i felt it was more about crushing this argument and not about understanding why did even this argument come up. You said it might be there many people with this view but its wrong. Probably you should have discussed more about why even this argument came up and how we can stop this. Probably the delimitation should be done in a better way!!!! Equally based on both population and area. People in less populated areas have very bad representation in our country. For example forests, deserts and border areas etc.

  • @luckykumar3338
    @luckykumar3338 8 месяцев назад +3

    Thanks a lot for the video with English subtitles ❤❤🙏🙏

  • @mbbharath2659
    @mbbharath2659 8 месяцев назад +12

    దేశ రక్షణ రంగంలో త్రివిధ దళాల్లో దక్షిణాది వారిని ఆదరించడం కరువైఇంది '
    వివక్ష కనపడుతున్న ఏమి తెలియనట్లు నటించడం దక్షిణాది వారికే చెందుతుంది. 😶

    • @kah455
      @kah455 8 месяцев назад

      Yes, after 2026 , there will be more mp seats in North India, bjp don't need South states to get power , after that why should they care about when they are winning elections simply by their states uttarpradesh and Gujarat mps, they don't care that much about South, they only heat problems of people in which their people stayed

    • @BollywoodBagothalu
      @BollywoodBagothalu 8 месяцев назад +1

      Military environment is very performance oriented, it's just the numbers are low from us.

    • @4ever304
      @4ever304 8 месяцев назад

      @@kah455population is not the only criteria for delimitation in nation level. Demographic performance is taken into account in 15th finance commission.

  • @sachin4619
    @sachin4619 8 месяцев назад +4

    Only broadminded people can comprehend and understand his words

  • @Py23658
    @Py23658 8 месяцев назад +10

    ఒక స్టూడెంట్ ఐఐటీ లో చేరాలి అంటే మూడు సార్లు ఇస్తారు చాన్సు . తరువాత ఉండదు. Improve కాలేదు కనుక. అదే విధంగా వెనుకబడిన రాష్ట్రాలకి ఎన్నాల్లు ఇస్తారు. ఎక్కడి గొంగళి అక్కడే. పాలకుల్లో లోపాలు. జనాభా పెరుగుదల లో ఏమి చేస్తున్నారో.

    • @chirunjeevichiru8308
      @chirunjeevichiru8308 8 месяцев назад +1

      Same logic SC ST valki apply avuthundi Mari opukuntava, kodiga think chaii bro 65 years ga valki Ami chailadhu Congress government courption thapa UP before 2014 after 2020 chudu difference ardham avuthundi Mana up and bhiar people ki manam support chayali svardham ga think chaikudhu, manki regional parties development chasi kabati manki kastam thalidam lae north lo Congress gov Delhi Mumbai thappa Ami devlop chayla aa Gujrat kuda modi cm inaaka indhi, eppudu Congress ki north meedha patu povdam tho separate country kavali antunaru, nuvu evi Ani think chaikunda mindset marchukuntae mankae nastam

    • @chandu25abc20
      @chandu25abc20 8 месяцев назад

      @@chirunjeevichiru8308 problem not sharing kaadu baabu, pettanam maade, anubhavinchedi meme anetatlu vundi kaabate ee anti feelings. Asalu south Indian states ki yemi avasaram ee desamlo bhagamga vundataniki, vaaatikante chinna prantale and jaatule desallaga vunte Srilanka and Bhutanle vudhaharanalu and Europe lo ayithe prathi desam chinnade. Eee desamlo anni Hindi vaallakosame annatlu nadustundi kaabatte ee vyatirekataha. Indian govt anni bhashalani okelaaga chustunda? Janabha lekkana poyina prapamcham patamlo south Indian languages pradham 20 jaatullo vuntaru, and viri bhasha central govt premises lo vaadataaniki panikiraadu, railwasy ki vellu, airport ki vellu anta Hindi ledante english, idhi vivaksha kaada, ituvanti vaatinundi vachede ee aakrandana.

    • @chirunjeevichiru8308
      @chirunjeevichiru8308 8 месяцев назад

      @@chandu25abc20 Central lo unnapudu akuva MP seats unnapudu kastha garvam untadhi, Congress ilane petnam NTR Kalam lo chasinapudu NTR control lo patadu Congress ni tdp pati, antae Kani separate country kavali Ani demand chyladhu, chinna vishaniki separate country kavali andam thapu

    • @chandu25abc20
      @chandu25abc20 8 месяцев назад

      @@chirunjeevichiru8308 ikkada separate country yevaru adagaledu, jarige vivaksha ni prasnistunna. and idi seatla garvaniki sambandinchindi kaadu, maarchalsinadaanigurunchi and maarpu kosam presninchedi, innallu jarigipoyindi yevvaru pattinchukola, ippatikanna maarpu raavali, ee desamlo vunna anni bhashala vaallani samanamga chudali appude desam mida prema gouravam perugutayi.

    • @chirunjeevichiru8308
      @chirunjeevichiru8308 8 месяцев назад

      @@chandu25abc20 question chaii brother avriki problem ladhu ikadha Kani aa MP separate country adigadu dhani manam aslu support chaikudhu

  • @ramanamurthymurthy8797
    @ramanamurthymurthy8797 8 месяцев назад +1

    Respected Sir,
    U r the master of international affairs so kindly a upload a separate video on India and china conflict. Really we have a strength to flight with china ? Kindly upload videos on international affairs also
    Tq sir

  • @venkatreddy8829
    @venkatreddy8829 8 месяцев назад +2

    JP's voicew has to be broadcast widely even among so called intellectuals o India. Specially now Congress doing all tricks to come back to power

  • @DevrishiNarada2047
    @DevrishiNarada2047 8 месяцев назад +1

    People of india needs to recognise actions of breaking india forces through religion, media and paid influencers

  • @Bobby-ur6ci
    @Bobby-ur6ci 8 месяцев назад +3

    We need seperate country South India

    • @arjunvarmamaths1349
      @arjunvarmamaths1349 8 месяцев назад +1

      Even after listening this video , if u want separate country then God save u.

    • @mbbharath2659
      @mbbharath2659 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@arjunvarmamaths1349 keep it aside' but what formulations are taken to keep interests of South intact & Alive !

    • @reddisathya
      @reddisathya 8 месяцев назад

      Telangana people are not with you.

  • @sriramnarayanaswamy7777
    @sriramnarayanaswamy7777 8 месяцев назад

    I couldnt listen to the entire interview, but I hope he also mentioned that if there is a condition that the excess money shared with poorer states must be only spent on education and health and not on anything else, they will grow up to developed levels much faster than today where all the money is unaccounted for.

  • @kah455
    @kah455 8 месяцев назад +3

    If you are giving money to states like bihar to improve their facilities, but politicans there are just eating with that and not improving that state whether in terms of attracting companies to their state or building infrastructure,why should we need to put our money into that state especially when people themselves are not supporting development there

    • @kah455
      @kah455 8 месяцев назад

      The govt has been giving money equally to all states asper requirements according to you sir, then after 75 years , why those states are not developing like other states, their might be a lack of good governance their, we should warn them if you are not using the amount allocated by central properly , after three warnings that state should not receive money from the central,where they need to satisfy only with the amount that is generated by their state

    • @mbbharath2659
      @mbbharath2659 8 месяцев назад

      Moreover, if you see they are giving lectures to overshadow their mistakes such as Freight equailisation policy implemented during 2' decades ago and so on.. to make the loot look more ligitimate now a days 😅

    • @drlgkrishna
      @drlgkrishna 8 месяцев назад

      Our politicians are clean cows is it?

    • @karthika560
      @karthika560 8 месяцев назад

      @@kah455states are just administrative units setup for convenience.
      You can have same tax rate for ambani and a clerk. Also you pay income tax to CG and not to state govt.

    • @karthika560
      @karthika560 8 месяцев назад

      @@kah455lol. In Bihar an avg candidate spends 1/25 of the money spent in southern states(barring kerala).

  • @akavaramvenkatreddy1745
    @akavaramvenkatreddy1745 8 месяцев назад +1

    రాష్ట్రలపై యూనియన్ పెత్తనం గురించిన చర్చ జరగాలి .రాష్ట్రాల అదాయలనుంచి యూనియన్ వాటా తగ్గించాలి.మత పరమైన ప్రేమ ఎక్కువైనందుననే ఈరోజు కాంగ్రేస్ దాని ఫలాలు ఆనుభవిస్తున్నది.యూనియన్ పాలకులు ఎవరైన ప్రజలను భారతీయులుగాచూడాలి.రాగ ద్వేశాలుచూపకుండ పాలించాలి.అదికారం శాశ్వతమైనది కాదు.దేశం శాశ్వతమైనది అదికారంఈరోజు ఒకరిచేతిలోఉంటే రేపు మరోకరిది.ప్రభుత్వాలు ప్రజలతీర్పునుగౌరవించాలి.కాలం బలమైంది ఓడలు బండ్లు,బండ్లు ఓడలవుతాయి ఇది మనంఆనుకోవడంకాదు ఇది చరిత్ర చెపుతున్నసత్యం.ప్రజల మనోభావాలు గాయపడినపుడు ఇలాంటి బావాలు వ్యక్తమవుతాయి.జైఇండియా,జైహిందుస్తాన్.❤
    27:22

  • @chandu25abc20
    @chandu25abc20 8 месяцев назад

    Every state whether big or small should have equal number of seats in parliament and that will solve the problem.

  • @Vij367
    @Vij367 8 месяцев назад

    If we are benefitting from a common market, why is our GDP nominal per capita 143rd out of 195 economies sir?

    • @arjunvarmamaths1349
      @arjunvarmamaths1349 8 месяцев назад

      Because no country destroy them self like India does.
      South North Divide, caste divide, religious divide language divide,
      Even Cinema divide😂

  • @ratnamalasrinuvasrao8959
    @ratnamalasrinuvasrao8959 8 месяцев назад

    I realised
    Change my idealogy
    Now I agree with you

  • @SwechaVaadi
    @SwechaVaadi 8 месяцев назад +1

    The logical conclusion of common market argument is a world government. If we have only one government in charge of the entire world, then there are no borders anywhere, and the whole population gets the benefits JP is mentioning. So does he support world govt then? I want to do a video response to this but it will definitely get banned.

  • @murthyprakhya8623
    @murthyprakhya8623 8 месяцев назад +3

    in a combined family one brother earns for the whole family and another brother only spends. it is feature in Indian combined families.

    • @shyammadireddy6909
      @shyammadireddy6909 8 месяцев назад +1

      that's why they separated her family after marriage

    • @drlgkrishna
      @drlgkrishna 8 месяцев назад

      Then if wife earns less will you separate from wife also?

    • @kah455
      @kah455 8 месяцев назад

      @@drlgkrishna wife is his own , where as in family after getting married all are getting separated

  • @rav8149
    @rav8149 8 месяцев назад

    We have the basic responsibility of supporting JP garu and promoting his ideals.

  • @Vij367
    @Vij367 8 месяцев назад +2

    "Know your facts first, then distort them as you please." - Mark Twain. JP sir is collecting facts but distorting them to support the BJP rather than our constitutional values which the BJP is infamous for downplaying. Congress is corrupt but embraced modernization. BJP is neither modern nor ending corruption is what is really worrying.

    • @arjunvarmamaths1349
      @arjunvarmamaths1349 8 месяцев назад +1

      😂😂😂
      Prove with facts dude.
      Don't just make a statement and satisfy your thoughts without retrospection.

    • @BollywoodBagothalu
      @BollywoodBagothalu 8 месяцев назад +1

      Just don't spit words, provide some evidence, i would say Bjp is far far ahead in modernization and dealing with corruption, just see the numbers for yourself.

    • @Vij367
      @Vij367 8 месяцев назад

      @@BollywoodBagothalu I said Congress is corrupt and I don't have double standards like the Monkey baat. I have several cases where the BJP is not acting against corruption. Quote me which government hospitals, which government offices are free from corruption after the BJP came to power? Ajit Pawar is accused of 70,000 crores scam by the PM himself and the same Monkey baat made him finance minister and deputy CM of Maharashtra to suit his needs. Why is this monkey baat afraid of the press and has an attendance of 0.01% attendance in the parliament when he chooses to speak and not to listen nor respond without side tracking the question bringing Nehru or Indira name? He is the only person in the world to ask people to bang utensils during corona - is this not backwardness or lunaticism? Also the only person to declare a holiday for a religious building consecration - is it backwardness or politics using God too? Prostrate wherever possible - including the new parliament! Theories of Darwinism and genetics question the myths of creation, and of varnas and jatis, so remove those theories from school textbooks! In what way is the electoral bond information irrelevant for the voters to know through RTI? How many BJP leaders were raided by the ED and CBI so far? Do we need a Ramayan, a Bible, or a Quran to know what is right, who is a liar, who is an opportunistic, who banks on the development initiatives of others, and who sits silently when ethnic violence is happening and people are dying?

  • @kasi805
    @kasi805 8 месяцев назад

    I agree with you sir❤
    Every citizen of india including all states if they have only market then why should the central government is not giving equal amount of money to all the states.
    Basically South Indian states are controlled their population according to certain rules and regulations.But why can't north indian control their population.
    Why there is un equal budget distribution, central railway funds, hospitals,water storage bodies...

    • @the69prophet47
      @the69prophet47 8 месяцев назад +1

      If you really agreed with JP, you won’t ask this question.

    • @kasi805
      @kasi805 8 месяцев назад

      It is not enough that explanation by JP sir when it comes to ground reality and check the problems of every Indian citizen is the words by the constitution is not desirable.

  • @nationfirst9527
    @nationfirst9527 8 месяцев назад

    100 percent correct , inclusive ga alochiste , a prantam kalasi undadu our country proud barath mataki jai

  • @raoadvocate2406
    @raoadvocate2406 8 месяцев назад

    నార్త్ ఈస్ట్ రాష్ట్రాలు ఫ్రీ మనీ ప్రతి కుటుంబానికి పంచుతున్న 75 ఏళ్లగా వాళ్లు మేము ఇండియన్స్ అని గుండె మీద చెయ్యి వేసుకుని చెపుతారా. మనం మిజోరం లో ఎంటర్ అవ్వాలంటే ఎయిర్పోర్ట్ లో పాస్ ఎందుకు తీసుకోవాలి వాళ్లు మాత్రం ఇండియా లో ఎక్కడైనా తిరగవచ్చు. ఈ విషయాలు మనలో ఎందరికి తెలుసు

  • @tarak888
    @tarak888 8 месяцев назад +1

    Limit lekundaaa... Population penchuthuntee, remaining states endhuku loss avvalii

  • @rajeshwargaddam7336
    @rajeshwargaddam7336 8 месяцев назад

    Mr jayaprakash Narayan , why there is no uniformity development in the country.
    Govt fail to implement the programs effectively taking into consideration the resources available. Diverse GDP of states itself is indicative of the partial attitude of the political parties.
    Feel sad at the backwardness of UP Bihar and other states.
    Gujarat is well developed and BJP still continues to favour that state.

  • @gopi6366
    @gopi6366 8 месяцев назад

    Sir, Pl see d allocation of Industries/ big projects to Gujarat like gift city, bullet train, google, chip manufacturing unit,latest boing co name a few, lot lot com/ ind to north especially to Gujarat. What about other states like AP ? If d discrimination goes on ., what will happen. Somebody should address these

    • @arjunvarmamaths1349
      @arjunvarmamaths1349 8 месяцев назад

      Dude paln of gift city is under way from last 20+ yrs. It is the idea when modi was cm.
      It take 2 , 3 decades to build a gift city. If u chose other place then it will become like AP capital total waste.
      Bullet train is for maharashtra Gujarat. But the plan is going to extend to karnataka or telengana .
      If not karnataka and tamilnadu.
      Coming to other projects like semiconductor, Gujarat state is giving more than 25% investment as subsidy if other sates give then they shift. Eg Foxconn in tamilnadu, somany auto mobiles man in tamilnadu. Just search how many huge companies came into tamilnadu in last 10yrs.

  • @krishnamurtyuppala4909
    @krishnamurtyuppala4909 8 месяцев назад

    👌👌

  • @dv9239
    @dv9239 8 месяцев назад +1

    Speak against delimitation

    • @rajeshreddy4491
      @rajeshreddy4491 8 месяцев назад

      delimitation is a constitutional oblugations duffer

    • @dv9239
      @dv9239 8 месяцев назад

      @@rajeshreddy4491 arey evadra duffer faltu gadi laga comments lo kotladanike egeskunta ochinav

  • @madinavinodh6142
    @madinavinodh6142 3 месяца назад

    North Indians should know (1200-1500), Mughals(1500-1700), Marata Chatrapatis (1700-1800). These are ruled North India ( Muslims-500 years, Hindus-100 years). If we know about Muslim ruling then only North India United always. South India ( 1300-1550)(Vijayanagara Hindu Empire) and 1550-1750 ( Muslims ruled South India). So in 1750 Bengalis, Andhra and tamils are accepted British due to Muslim domination in India sub continent. Like that India went to British South India(1750-1950), North India(1800-1950), Punjab and Kashmir (1850-1950) ruled by British. So simply British United North India and South India. Now South Indian should divide from India between (2025-2030) because of North India BJP domination in National politics like Congress emergency (1975). South India 5 states should make one country and South India divide 20 states for better administration. If South India becomes country it will be 9th largest country by area and population(25 crores). In all ways South India becomes 9th country out of 200 countries in the world. Already tamils fought for South India country in (1940-1945) under great legend E.V.Ramasamy Nayakar or (Telugu-Naidu). I am a Telugu ( Kalingaandhra region) person from Srikakulam District.

  • @humanityfirst4538
    @humanityfirst4538 8 месяцев назад +2

    Jaya prakash narayana sir your views on politics are outdated

  • @somireddykothi.
    @somireddykothi. 8 месяцев назад

    గ్రామీణ ప్రాంతాల్లో కూలిపని వారికి 200 లభిస్తుంది. వాళ్లను పరోక్షంగా దోచుకుంటున్నారు. పట్టణాలు, రాజ్యమంతా.

    • @reddisathya
      @reddisathya 8 месяцев назад

      In which place you will get labour for 200?

  • @haranathg532
    @haranathg532 8 месяцев назад +3

    South and NE , Neglected by BJP government.
    * BJP government cut " allocation of budget" is cut, because Karnataka govt is ruled by Congress.

    • @mbbharath2659
      @mbbharath2659 8 месяцев назад

      That too There is no much financial effort needed for North East improvement ' they have done better. But the problem is with fair allocation & equal distribution to Southern states.

    • @karthika560
      @karthika560 8 месяцев назад

      @@mbbharath2659 is 1:1 fair allocation? Country cannot work like that. Rich states have to subsidize poor states otherwise they will migrate and change demographics.

    • @arjunvarmamaths1349
      @arjunvarmamaths1349 8 месяцев назад

      Dude just check how much roads and railways, airports , electricity xonnection, water connecting, bridges done in NE.
      No other gov did this much for NE. Just Google some data.
      Without facts don't blame.

    • @mbbharath2659
      @mbbharath2659 8 месяцев назад

      @@karthika560 Already it's happening now.. and what are you justifying here'; Remember! the anguish is to maintain and regulate that all improper.

  • @GamerOne_me
    @GamerOne_me 8 месяцев назад +4

    This old man going crazy
    There only state tax and central tax
    Comparing that with districts illogical 😂 there is no district tax
    And since 30 years south tax spending in north
    Still they didn't develop
    Till how many years this loot will continue the main thing is UP bihar not utilising the money properly
    Next CM candidate of Bihar when bridge worth 1500cr collapsed 2 times
    He saying dishti tagilindi that's why it is collapsed
    We are sending our tax to those states who has leaders like this
    Why UP Bihar not controlling population
    Still 3.1 fertility rate why
    And north want to have more MP seats so they can monopoly on indian politics
    That's why new indian parliament have 835 seats instead of 544
    More population more MPs
    Imagine one state UP have 185 MPs in parliament in 835
    Is that good for democracy

    • @mbbharath2659
      @mbbharath2659 8 месяцев назад +2

      Yes మాటల్లో.. చాదస్తం కనపడుతుంది'

    • @garage-vx8gx
      @garage-vx8gx 8 месяцев назад

      anni districts vallantha state ki tax kadatharu state government ki okate tax radhu kadha, district condition batti money spend chestadhi , same for central applies some may poor ,don't think intelligent just rethink about it and talk

    • @lohithkumar2860
      @lohithkumar2860 8 месяцев назад

      Counter to your argument when job opportunities increased in UP around 600,000 workers in Tamilnadu are required to replace them. Can it happen with a tweet or press statement, no. What if industry faces crisis and they shutdown. Do you blam e UP govt for increasing local jobs. We are strong until we are united.

    • @lohithkumar2860
      @lohithkumar2860 8 месяцев назад

      And we could discuss go point by point on number of MPs and other issues. When there is such injustice why Rahul gandhi and Mallikarjun Kharge not raising in parliament and in south Indian states. Because they know it is bogus issue and not correct idea to bring in this country in the interests of country’s development.

    • @GamerOne_me
      @GamerOne_me 8 месяцев назад

      @@lohithkumar2860 🤣🤣 don't ask illogical questions dude
      By predicting the future like a horoscope expert
      Talk about current situation, why would any sector will go down and crisis may occur
      first tell me that
      And which industry you are talking about

  • @somireddykothi.
    @somireddykothi. 8 месяцев назад

    భారత దేశం ఏర్పడిన సమయంలో జనాభా 35 కోట్లు. నేడు 142 కోట్లు. ఇంత జనాభా కు 2 దేశాలు అవసరమే. భారత రాజ్యాంగం ఏమీ బ్రహ్మ పదార్ధము కాదు .కాలానికి అనుగుణంగా నూతన రాజ్యము ఏర్పాటు చేయవచ్చు. రాజ్యమే లేని సమాజం కోసం కృషి చేసిన తప్పు లేదు. రాజ్యమే నేడు ఒక కీడు. 3 ప్రభుత్వం లు కలసి ప్రతి కుటుంబం పైన 2,40,000 పన్ను భారం మోపు తున్నారు.

  • @HeartistMurali
    @HeartistMurali 8 месяцев назад

    JP = BJP .

  • @Crk-f9b
    @Crk-f9b 8 месяцев назад +2

    North India is ripping South India. Show me a single PM other than PV, few months Deva Gouda…yes, time for South India PM to the number of NORTH…

    • @karthika560
      @karthika560 8 месяцев назад +1

      PM is from western india not north. Go back and learn geography

    • @arjunvarmamaths1349
      @arjunvarmamaths1349 8 месяцев назад

      What a sick mentality.
      Do u think only person from south benefit south??
      Then how is south so developed compared to North when no prominent PM form south.
      Pls stop this bullshit thoughts.
      We all indians. Who ever develop and stand for the country we should support them.

    • @mbbharath2659
      @mbbharath2659 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@karthika560 when n while we people treat anything above Hyderabad is North ⬆️ your comment is just hold nowhere up ! 🤷

    • @Crk-f9b
      @Crk-f9b 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@karthika560 listen Gujju is north., learn India first, did u ever go to gujju place., ?!

    • @reddisathya
      @reddisathya 8 месяцев назад +1

      We don't mind who is PM if he is not corrupt like congress.

  • @srikanthreddy6991
    @srikanthreddy6991 8 месяцев назад

    Sir how to reach you or your team. Please send your contact mail