Indonesian Censorship and Government in a Nutshell 2
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
- 6 years later and here we are again.
3 August Update : As of writing this, they have slowly lifted most of the bans from major sites and even apologized to the public. I really hope that would be the end of this censorship saga and I hope I won't be making another sequel to this in the future. I hope.
Music:
Dragon Nest - Farm Theme
Bloodborne - Living Failures
Jaayms - Change
*3 August Update : As of writing this, they have slowly lifted most of the bans from major sites and even apologized to the public. I really hope that would be the end of this censorship saga and I hope I won't be making another sequel to this in the future. I hope.
Well from what I know about Indonesia government, who always make unexpected move to they people, I think this gonna get another sequel on future.
Yeah kominfo in nutshell
@@ariflewar789 true definition of "never let them know your next move".
Man am glad to be a pirate all over again.
@@sastradana9222 Some Kominfo representative said in the news that some sites like PayPal and Steam starting to notice the regulation, but it's probably a bs anyway. And the ban lifting right now is just temporary, till 5 of August iirc
Indonesia 2014 "why do we need faster internet"
Indonesia 2022 "why do we need internet"
Indonesia 2023 "what is internet"
Indonesia 2024 "unga bunga"
Back to Majapahit
Indonesia 2025 "what? "
@@samm13xyz No, but back to kutai
the fact that a dude with a degree in farming runs the communication and information ministry is just hysterical.
I think this is how it should be, to be honest
@@flanfre_skarlett why?
@WTFE Because a dude with a degree in farming would know damn well how to limit technology so that technology is under control and has no impact on the people. Technology was a mistake as much as the Industrial Revolution was.
@@flanfre_skarlett ok, then why block literally one of the main payment sites.
If they're "so smart" in handling technology they would at least know which ones to block and which ones not to. It just seems to me that you're making this conclusion from your biased and limited view of the world without digging in deeper of the facts.
@WTFE Well, why not. Payment sites are not good, to be honest. What's so biased in my opinion? Do you think my hate for technology is biased and based on no proven information or something?
The sequel everyone hope to never happen, but yet here we are
Damn that surprising me 😱
Let's hope in the near future there aren't more sequels...
@@GordonSnowMachine, never underestimate conservative boomers.
Look at Russia and Turkey.
true lol, didn't expect Rong Rong will make it so fast
I am suprised why Indonesia isn't ranked worse than Vietnam in terms of censorship by now
Don't worry, they didn't block their "illegal" casino sites because the yakuza bribed them. So you can play poker instead of playing phasmo.
But all poker money is on my paypal account.
@@namethathasntbeentakenyetm3682 LOL
@@namethathasntbeentakenyetm3682 bruh moment
@@namethathasntbeentakenyetm3682 mission failed successfully
I wonder if EA is blocked...
17 July 2023: HE GOT ARRESTED BECAUSE OF CORRUPTION LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO THATS WHAT YOU GET
-makes a rule nobody knew or care about
-barely or doesn't announce the new rule to anybody and does the bare minimum to warn companies about it
-bans one of the main payment methods, which pretty much ruins lives
-bans one of the main websites used to buy items outside of Indonesia
-bans multiple video game services
-refuses to elaborate
-leaves the internet to burn
I guarantee you, people will fucking RIOT for this and rightly so
they'll be sorry if it's another 1998 riot
GIGACHAD grindset
Violence breeds violence, but in the end it has to be this way.
Oh don't forget they encourage us to 'use/enjoy' our own product which is some our own game companies use steam for their platform and paypal as their payment. So now no one can enjoy anything. Not even our own product. Yaaay
"Just because you have unhappy childhood ,doesn't mean you must make our childhood unhappy too."
-Someone on internet
Crab Mentality is a plague that needs to be purged from this pisshole country
No shit im indonesian and fr they blocked steam sure but i can still accessing it by already having the software o my laptop
Idk whats the ruckus about hell i didn't even notice
That wont apply to the indonesian goverment, if you wanna be a fucking citizen of indonesia (if you are outside from indonesia) you basically need to change your nationality from example: French to Indonesian. You can only have 1 fucking nationality, so say goodbye to your dual-citizen dreams.
i feel like they’ve decided all adulthoods should be miserable too
This is what happens when you elect a goddamn farm tool businessman as ministry of information
This is what happens when you are in an Islamic country with Muslim politicians. Don't insult farm tools.
You don't elect a minister.
President and the party coalition does
@@meferswift Mostly the party coalition. A president here in Indonesia basically means you have to babysit and make sure every political party is satisfied
Someone's got a massive hole in the back of their skull. I wonder who...
BRO WE DONT
This is borderline evil. So many people have paypal as a bank and your government just blocked your livelyhood on top of your fun. I pray things get better, hang in there!
Dont worry bro i think we just get used to it at this point, i mean we seen worse
@@notecat7785 getting used to something this terrible isn't good as well
@@notecat7785 don't get used to it, be mad at it. And do something that you can do. Even if it's just as small as letting other know that this is a problem.
Maaf pake basa enggres, lebih gampang buat ngungkapinnya.
@@suisui7481 yeah i know, i think i just very tired and disappointed
@@fwa8590 gpp, mungkin aku aja yang sudah capek, terlalu sering kecewa, terlalu sering di khianati, mudah mudahan kamu ngak.
Paypal being blocked is the worst (even while it's only temporarily), there's literally someone's hard-earned money and livelihood (freelancers, designers, digital artists, etc.) being restricted and they can't withdraw their money.
This is what our Ministry of Communication and Information choose to focus on instead while there're data breaches happening left and right on sensitive personal data in their healthcare system (your name, address, email, ID no (yes, freaking ID number) being leaked to public)
Let me guess conti hacks in those systems
Now, if only the hackers can ruin those guys' (in our government) personal data and livelihood instead
And this very same organization has the audacity for wanting Indonesia to become the center of South East Asian Digital.
Another day to be ashamed for being Indonesian . . .
dude, indog gov database literally open sources
@@LynSain those guys are fucking clowns, I'm voting for Singapore.
This policy is so unpopular that even the also unpopular Ministry of Finance, the one responsible for your taxes, joined netizen side and protest Kominfo policy for blocking Steam, stating that it would blocked them collecting taxes.
paypal is right there yet they focus on steam
Batam
Emigration in Indonesia is Alot of Bad behavior & problem
One Man = $ 100 to 200
Please help a weak person
One Man = $100 to 200
When this was first announced I was like. "No, you can't be serious. Forcing the world to waste their time signing up on something just to get their site opened on some third world country. Besides, the backlash would be massive, not to mention the economical issues this introduced."
And then my Steam couldn't open and I was like
"Oh wait, you're actually serious"
Thankfully aside from VPN, people have already been sharing ways to get around the block. Still, terrible completely unnecessary rule.
can you do transactions tho? i heard there's risk of getting ban or at least rejected if you do transactions with dns or vpn on
Well... so far I didn't get any sort of ban or warning. Then again, I also didn't change my country wallet when doing so. The VPN tunnel was also not that far from me (Singapore)
Don't take it from me though. I used it very sporadically that I don't even know whether or not I've done any transactions while using VPN
Maybe you don't even need VPN if you use GoodbyeDPI
Simple DNScrypt can bypass the ban for PC
Or Invizible pro for android
@@abednego_1254 do not do anything related to money with VPN, especially free one. Cloudflare DNS still works with paypal and doesn't carry risk of breach or getting account frozen
Like i can understand why they banned p0rn sites considering that they are an Islamic country ( all tho they allow gambling sites even it's literally forbidden in islam which it makes no sense) same with weird manga websites like I'm glad they banned them it's actually a good thing but banning Reddit, newgrounds, Steam, PayPal etc , like why would you do that that's a terrible idea like bro what is this are they turning into iran/china 2.0 or something like what is this?
You see, the president was losing an argument online so he wanted to ensure his opponent touched grass
President had nothing to do with this( directly at least).
Let's hope his son that play Dota 2 complained
@@meferswift
Oohh he definitely got the blames, since at the very least he could prevented it if he know what he's doing.
@@thatoneperson6969, nah, the minister's party is not even listening to the President anymore. I've heard rumours that they would seek a coalition with another party for 2024.
More effective than elon
At this point, I am convinced Brunei, Singapore, Malaysia and Indonesia, are just trying to see who is making their country the most unlivable. Such weird sibling rivalry we got.
Russia and Turkey: Don't forget us.
Malayu Brothers: URRRAAAAA!!!!
Now to think about it's just ye just ye
Atleast singapore is a developed country 👌🤣
@@NIELL0_ they can't Chew gum, attempt it 100times and you'll have Yourself living inside in jail for a life
Singapore, Vietnam, and Timor Leste are doing great, Timor Leste will join ASEAN in 2023 and they will be one of the best places to live in by 2030
FYI Indo's Ministry of Finance is tilted against the Ministry of Communication's decision cuz a lot of these blocked services already signed tax contract in Indonesia and the abrupt blocking of services totally whited out the the gains from tax out of these services.
Talk about a stupid way to hurt their economy for no reason.
I know right? Its estimated this will lose the country billions. And the govt response? 'Just make your own websites, that are exclusive to indonesia' Yeah how are they supposed to do that when the govt banned most tools that would have let them? They will have to manually add the 0s and 1s. It could take the people up to 20 years at which point most would be living in poverty. But the govt thinks north korea is really cool
I mean seriously, they're literally refusing huge amounts of tax money and basically sending us back to the dark ages.
Indonesian person here
Actually they have good reason for banning them but yeah I think banning them wasn't nessesary and it just hurt more for their economy
Tell me about it
Our government always trying to hurt the economies for no reason
What pisses me off the most is that it's literally for no reason. If you're gonna block almost the entire internet at least make it a for a propaganda or something, but no. They just decide one day that they want to be a-holes and frick the country's entire IT and creative industry.
Its not the first time they do this you know? I mean there are like some people that got arrested for trying to defend their life from begal(similar as burglar or thief) they manage to defend themself but accidently killed the begal and instead of rewarding or ending the case they arrested the defender and put them in jail for so many years, so yeah.... that is not the worst situation indonesia gorverment have done.... yet
@@zenigamayasa8342 considering what we've done to chinese minority, this is tame.
addition: all our problem could traced back to Mr Suharto. Racism towards chinese, ethnic conflict because of transmigration, lack of development in borneo and papua, java-centric policy, rampant corruption, elites that still hold the democracy today, inflation, etc. he has 36 years in office yet does nothing.
Reddit still banned and i have to use VPN only to look at Memes 💀
@@zenigamayasa8342 i think in most countries its illegal to kill the burglar
@@agustinmelar5496 it is an "Accidental" killing AKA Self Defense Plea. But the court take it as Guilty plea
Well, well, well, Johnny G Plate, the minister of Ministry of Communication and Information Technology, the man who is responsible for all of this mess is now arrested for corruption charges. Well deserved, LMAO.
this is the truth and actually happen, rong-rong need to pin this comment
i am indonesian and yes i can confirm this is legit
Man i love the indonesian government ❤️. I couldn't draw because adobe is blocked, couldn't get art request because paypal is blocked, couldn't play my 200 steam library games.
Overall i hold the most useless skill in the industry right now 😀
Welp, you only hoped to become slave laborers on Saudis, China, or any country that needs cheap labor. I guess it would be better to start a boycott or something against this clown.
im an artist too and i could say FUCK KOMINFO
Creative economy they said.
4.0 industry they said
lol the audacity was too real
Get vpn
@@SaltedCaramrl using PayPal with VPN is quite risky though, your account might get blocked by doing that
Honestly this is gonna affect the govt so badly and cost the country billions in revenue if they keep this bs
Nah, the gov are doing fine since they only banned those site but NOT ONLINE GAMBLING Sites.
One of Kominfo high ranking literally said : " as long you registered into our database, you'll be fine" even though it's a gambling site.
@@monarchyyyy you know what's worse than that?
online loan sharks are not even blocked yet
@@monarchyyyy Yes, the gov hypocrisy at its finest
@@monarchyyyy yeah and they banned many sites that had registered anyway
@@blackbird7781 you know what's worse? they blocked the sites using tax money from people worth of milions of dollars
Man I remember the day when my co-workers talked about a new ban on games, I didn't believe them until I got home and saw it all behind censorship. The next day we all tried to figure out to what extent, man we were blown away
The best part is they blocked the website at saturday, so the people who want to enjoying their weekend by playing game completely ruined 😂
I mean, they could always go through the Pirate ways no way any governement would be able to block all of them without blocking Internet entirely, but true enough Piracy is far less popular than in the 2000
@@Freedmoon44 yeah, some Indonesian sarcasticly said the gov indirectly told us to play pirated game rather than the original. It is a good way as well, but for me the feels is really different when playing the original. I do play pirated game to test whether my laptop can actually play the game before buying it 🤣
@@rateupisalie ive always been a pirate and honestly steam and other game store banned arent bothering me
but the other websites
they are trying to kill us
@@3takoyakis well actually since my laptop is suck I don't really playing pc game that much and my job isn't related to using paypal and such at all, so the blocking sites from kominfo isn't really brothering me at all as well. But I just want to supports for those who got bothered by it since if we left it alone, the gov will always do as they wish and not listen to the citizen's opinion.
True ownership is gone, now all these companies are the ones who give you temporary control to your games. Only pirates seem to be the one who really own their games, ironically.
as a person residing in turkey, I feel your pain. we banned wikipedia once, paypal has been banned since 2016
Why ?
Well, at least Erdogan and Jokowi has become more similar each day.
@@comteraffayn8351 Restrictions on freedom of speech, press, assembly, TV content, and internet. All of that comes with censorship.
@@SwaggMessiah69 he's not asking you. Also, your reply doesn't make sense. Paypal was blocked because of a failure to comply with licensing rules. Only an idiot would think it's related to freedom of speech since Paypal is not used to speak your mind.
@@korosuke1788 Hm, if only there was something else in that comment that is an easy source of information. Its on the tip of my tongue starting with W but I just can't seem to remember.
Dunno why, but I was expected for the cops to arrest the guy for touching grass as well, just to top things off.
Indonesian government are just as smart as a Ferrari strategist during a Race Weekend
The Indonesian government is as smart as a rock
@@k3braon_meme bro that's just rude, you didn't have to insult a rock like that
@@batmanuk1810 yeah especially if the rock is solid and probably can hit you with rock bottom.
@@k3braon_meme don't insult Dwayne Johnson "The Rock" like that😡
@@dzaki8331 lmao😂
China: *Block most of the internet*
Kominfo for literally 0 reason: Hey, I could do that
Russia: Amateurs
Turkey: Kiddies
People : let me out from here... LET ME OUT LET ME OUT...!!!
**Mr.bean exam cheat meme template**
At least China offers alternatives.
This fucking utensil just got arrested for corruption LETS FUCKING GOOOOOOO!!!!
our Ministry of Communication and Information does not even have a tech-related degree, he is a economy degree and didnt even know how to use technology properly. I have no idea why a person that have no experience and knowledge about technology can have the position of a Ministry of all things.
most people under Kominfo are 35 year+ boomers that doesnt even know how to search in google without asking the intern, most of the time the worker there just throw their job to intern and didnt pay them at all while they go shopping to mall etc. (info is from an intern who have worked there).
they know how to handle business
they intent to monetize everything bcs of _rise from covid_ programme ig
"Karya anak bangsa" they said. At this point, those words and jargon are gonna have a bad connotation thanks to this ridiculous internet policy.
"Karya anak bangsa"
Proceed to ban the market to buy those products...
"karya anak bangsa" banned the most used website to make that and banned the online banking that almost all Indonesian people use and now online artist had the most useless skill in the Indonesian industry, good job.....this is why sometimes government need to be the younger generation to take over, because they know technology more
Politically destroyed nation, too many oligarchs and American NGOs to turn things around. Hopefully gen Z will be based as they reach the peak of their careers.
"Internet cepat buat apa?"
"What's the point of having fast internet?"
- Tifatul Sembiring, The Malevolent Idiot, 2014/01/30
"Internet buat apa?"
"What's the point of having the internet?"
- Johnny Gerard Plate, The Minister of Technology and Information With Agriculture Expertise Background, 2022/07/30
Harga akses internet aja kg turun2 udh beberapa tahun juga
Baru kemaren covid semua pake internet, kirain bkl berkembang internet
nyatanya kg, pd mo balik ke era 1900an gila
boomers
please tell me that the minister of IT's backround is a joke
@@liafitriapurnamawati2432 they hired a GARDENER to become the prime minister of TECHNOLOGY
They just blocked hypixel lol
Clown never stop being a clown 🤣
What? They did?
@@lhobang Yeah, search it lmao
Sadly. It's not confirmed temporary. Could be permanent as long as said services refuse to sign in with the new system (PSA System) made by the Kominfo. Which needs you to do tedious procedure and money, AND on top of that, signing it means that said service must allow gov to have access to their customer data (only for Indonesian customer data at least), but that it self means Breaching the Privacy Policy of most if not all the services out there.
Indonesia is trying to become the next "you know where" whilst keep badmouthing them.
Irony at its finest
What do you mean? Indonesians supports Russia and Turkey and often chides Jokowi for not being as strong and tough towards foreign internet breaches as Putin and Erdogan did to their country's internet.
Vox Populi Vox Dei
@@krasnamerah1926 but the action they took seemingly leans to the other.....
@@Madao_Aniki, well yeah. Just easy-to-beat internet blocks unassailable by boomers, not on the levels of EU's Firewall or NSA's Spyware Ring yet for now.
THIS! Yeah i know there is a possibility that this mess can be resolved in a good way (just temporary block, negotiation succeed) but there is a chance that it can be worse too (permanent block, they refused to sign in to PSE). I can’t imagine the effect to people who use these apps for living if it come to worst, migrating to other country will be better choice at that point.
It feels like Indonesian government like to gamble things lol
@@potatomain1239 no man, if they registered, that means they have to give gov FULL ACCESS to their customer data AT ALL TIMES and not needing any court order or something like that. This means they can use the data to OPRESS any opposition, or anyone who criticize the gov
My man comeback to life just to roast the government, i mean to touch grass
Top 10 most annoying thing to see:
1. 10 seconds unskipable ads
2. Furry
10. Internet positif 🗿
"There are many things that this world would be happier without. Take for example, death, war, Kominfo."
-A random friend
Did she bang a certain power?
Damn straight
In Reddit
Saw this on the r/Indonesia
Lmao, makima
@@TheReader09 This is def that reddit post
Woke up to a new day just to learn that almost every good stuff got blocked, yet all of the bad stuff like slots sites are not blocked like wtf
That's because Big Casino would assassinate everyone in the government if their sites got blocked
Nah, i opened PH and it's still got blocked. Wtf are you talking about.
@@krasnamerah1926 well that's the good stuff, the bad stuffs are online casinos & those are still up
@@kusada3035 that's a good point there
Double standards
Double standards
Just what in the bloody hell were the people of KOMINFO thinking?
In case people are wondering, all of the blocked sites are accessible now with the exception of epic games. They open temporary 5 days access to paypal on day 1 but paypal has follow the regulation and its now permanently accessible. But what a pain in the ass. Ministry of technology said they support esport and then proceed to block steam and other gaming services, people were mad.
And remember, ladies and non-ladies: there's no such thing as "this could _never_ happen where I live". It can happen _anywhere,_ at _any time._ Freedoms are nice, until your government decides they're getting in the way of its plans.
Not in germany, your companys probaly hold more controll then our goverment,
And the goverment banning things wild mean its getting something done, witch is impossibil
Probably Italy in 2023 because of the new government
Be like the Americans, keep your rifles by your side.
@@seansamlee6490 And unlike the Americans, actually fucking use them instead of wandering around LARP’ing with them for all eternity. (Yes I’m American)
@@seansamlee6490 after the latest school shootings?
Beware
I can hear thousands of commission freelancers just screaming in agony, despair, and seethe in early morning.
So that's why yesterday morning feels dreadful.
+ they done that, exactly, on the fucking Saturday, which is a fucking weekend and day where mostly of us is having a day off.
that shit really make me rage.
As an Indonesian, this hurts to watch, EVEN IF IM ONLY A KID, THIS IS OUTRAGEOUS.
It's not just indonesia. Governments across the world including the United States are full of scumbags who would LOVE to do this, and far more but just can't yet. Never trust a politican or government with anything more than the barest minimums of power.
censorship: safe and fun for the whole family!
what's that? your whole family's income is processed through PayPal?
_censorship: safe and fun for most whole families!_
What's that? You have something that makes shopping in person difficult and now Amazon is down?
Safe and fun for some families!
@piYoup what's that? You can't access your favorite comics, manga, or games because internet positive?
Safe and fun for a few whole families
Just some additional notes : apparently online gambling sites are not blocked since some people have them registered
Yeah. It is just as expected of our Kominfo Ministry
" it ain't a crime if its official, baby" - Kominfo, probably
@@rinothename5563 "we aren't gonna ban you if you -bribe- registered to us" - Kominfo.
As an Indonesian i confirm this is true
Money == Power in Indonesian. You can evem get away with war crimes with enough money. Some "celebrities" here is formerly criminals graduated to public figures lol
Absolutely Indonesia! 😂
Blocking PayPal out of nowhere without enough of a warning is insane. Like, all the other stuff sucks a lot too but that's literally the place people store their money, wtf?
RUclips/google not blocked eh lol D:
Gonna rub the grass if that happens.
Yeah the kominfo minister got doxxed at its only been a day
Public official can't be doxxed.
Their info are already public.
Oh yeah forgot but some people have already been there its just a matter of time until someone vandalise it
I mean, when google, wiki, paypal and many harmless website is in the list, you know it bounds to be bad.
this is why MALAYSIA SUPERIOR 🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾
As an Indonesian myself, i can feel a huge emotional damage.
Don't worry, most of us Indonesians people felt the same emotional damage.
Heck, Tara Arts streamed solitaire while criticizing the ministry for hours because his co-op GTA plan got ruined due to the Steam block.
@@dindapriska Yeah, I heard many PC game streamers are decided to delay their routine upload & live stream schedules and some of them are now playing some mobile games as a content alternative
VPN go BRR
Me too, Had been crying that I can't play GTA, But hey, I still can play TF2 and CSGO! and also CS Warzone.
EMOOOOTIONOH DEEEEMIGE
I jokingly said to my friend that rongrong will upload a second one, and holy shit was i right
You're goddamn right
2022: became 1984
Random internet people try to be funny:
Apollo with prophet gift: lol
The pure nonsense of censorship in my country will never cease to bizarrely amaze me....
Everytime. Darn. Time. The minister does or said something it's always a massive L, I can't believe how a person without IT background can get into a power and started to ban all of the necessary part of internet.
#BlokirKominfo
>necessary part of internet
lmfao
Why do you allow these criminals to rule over you. You have individual rights that are granted to you by God and not by your country.
@@sastradana9222 no, seriously. they ban ALL if not MOST necessary parts of internet
if its just game store, piracy is easy to do
they gonna ban wikipedia, scientific journal sites, a web making tool, and a game making tool
on top of that, paypal and google too
with **ZERO** backup plans
no news before the execution begins, ppl life pretty much ruined and soon all of us would
which is really sad bcs in covid and years before it, government is being nice to millenials and digital sector workers
@@3takoyakis >wikipedia
lmao
>scientific journal sites
such as?
FYI to all foreigners out there, our government just audited top 100 populer website. They will continue to audit top 200 populer website and they will target to execute it next week. In other words, there will be more website and platforms got banned in the future. Hope you guys can see this message and please we need international awareness to this as we, indonesian has already lose hope and despair.
You reach down to touch the grass when a red light floods your eyes.
Grass
Website blocked by Indonesin gov
As a russian living in 2022, the paypal thing is horribly relatable
You had Roskomnadzor to watch out for after all...
fuck putin, pass it on
I don't know what's stupider, getting sanctioned by an international coalition due to an _actual war_ or voluntarily shooting your economical crotch just because.
@@RDSyafriyar yea, this dude is extremely annoying. Blocked all foreign social networks and news resources. Now either vpn / tor, or telegram. But we also have blockages from the corporations themselves. Only in truth, I think that putin somehow doesn’t care about my blocked paypal and I can’t buy almost all AAA games on Steam.
Now Kazakhstan is unironically has more freedoms than Russia.
I did not expect a sequel. This is gold.
We already have time paradox for this
gold for you because it's funny
my indo ass over here suffering
Meanwhile Indonesia's fucking burning over here, undertandable that you laughed but this shit sucks
Gold?
This is pure suffering for us.
@@thedreamleader Tor bro
Also for some reason sometimes cloudflare's DNS managed to work at times when I was over there.
Oh wait I forgot there was a part 1 on this topic. All I remembered was the music of that video
Little does this man know, the grass is censored too!
The funny part is. THEY LEGALIZED GAMBLING
No wonder they are boomers
Did they really??? Now that's the shock of the decade
yeah, we should ban gacha and loot boxes in games!!!1
Imagine reject technology.
You don't have to, our government already did it.
"what you don't want to join our PSE so that we can stalk on people's privacy!? damn then I'll just block it. GO KARYA ANAK BANGSA!!! (without being payed + still getting taxed + not helping them + reject the "karya bangsa" doesn't do anything about it)
haha, karya bangsa apanya, toh kg ada yg dukung jg
terutama sektor IT dan kesenian non tradisional
petani disuruh meningkatkan pangan, tanahnya masih kena pajak
apparently its just a DNS block, meaning its not that hard to bypass. Still really fucking evil to do that tho.
its not even evil because their claims arent supported by anything. i'd much prefer the term idiotic
it IS evil
no mentions whatsoever and bam! all blocked on saturday after islamic new year
@@helper_bot Hanlon's razor: Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity
Not at all, some of our ISPs/Mobile Operators (like Telkomsel and maybe Tri from Hutchison) are using DPI for blocking these sites.
Me: Mom, can we get China?
Mom: We have China at home
China at home:
Kominfo : "Hey with these globalization thingy going around, we fully supports the creative industry of our future generations"
Also Kominfo : hehe Blokir go brrrr
also that same kominfo: Don't block gambling website
Awokekekwk
@@muarekh4118 Because THEY'RE the one who played that thing LOLZ
this gonna put TV overlords on top again!
@@mirizid9667 "aS LoNg aS yOu rEgiStEr tO oUr dAtaBaSe iTs fiNe"
Menkominfo really brought the phrase "touch grass" into whole new level
"Why are people leaving our country more?"
I don't even use Paypal and I would be horrified if it got shut down without notice, I know how many people used it. Man, I hope people are doing okay.
I'm an artist that earns my money there... Can't use VPN for Paypal. For those saying just use another payment service, sure but do you think my target client base care enough? Most of them use Paypal and Paypal only. I'm nowhere near established enough to warrant people to go above and beyond to use my services.
@@nna_ If there was any uniform move away from PayPal (something that needs to happen, considering how much scum they actually are), customers would have to make their choice; And most would want stuff, as that is the main purpose of their PayPal.
it is not without notice tho
@@nna_ Offer paypal or alternatives. If the alternatives are better the people will move if given the chance.
TBH even without government interference paypal itself is known for shutting peoples accounts down and taking the money without explaining. I wouldn't use paypal anyways.
I thought the grass would flash red and be blocked xD
Unfortunately, grass has been blocked by the Indonesian government.
Pemblokiran tersebut merupakan bukti bahwa kerja mereka nyata
Nyata banget,nyata buat sekali nya kerja cuma nyusahin doang
Kominfo nggak asbun
biar 'keliatan kerja' lebih tepatnya, soalnya slama ini cm tidur
Nyata .. Tapi bikin repot orang ... Padahal ada data2 kita disitu ... Udah terlalu keterlaluan blokirnya ....
Nyata tololnya
As someone from Russia, I can relate
Most Indonesians supported Russia too, so i think it fits tho.
The West ist blocking Manny sites thought and not your own government.
They do block sites but the majority is blocked by the west
@@krasnamerah1926 we only supporting it's citizens, both Russian and Indonesian government can rot in hell for all I cares.
Putin's decision and impact after invade Ukraine alone can compete entire idiocracy of Kominfo
@@afdalridwan3813, i mean, gasoline, coal, and CPO prices are on hike because of Putin's actions.
Now Kominfo is responsible for data leak recently.
a certified "KOMINFO ANJENG" moment
censoring indonesian cyber space since 2008
@@pnnytx woooo
Legacy of Tifatul
Hello android game.... You win... 😘😘
Indonesia becoming china 2.0 fr
Nah
Certainly Turkey 2.0, if a Turkish commenter here to be believed. Or Russia 2.0 according to the three Russians here.
Fitting since most Indonesians loves Russia and Turkey and wanted the government to emulate them.
I knew it, ever since this happened I kept thinking "this is the type of tragedy rongrong would animate"
>be a telecommunication and information minister
>creating new controversial regulation
>regulation executed
>public outrage
>repeat
Funny thing is, the minister ain't even an IT Graduate, but an Agriculture Graduate.
@@dr.cherrydonutman7193 he should play farmville instead 💀
>get +Rp.1 trillion profit
@@pnnytx he took the "touch grass" meme way too seriously
might aswell just have a civil war or revolution.
Im indonesian and im really feel that this time,they really are went overboard,welp then again from 6 years ago "this country is just a comedy",i hope this problem will be solve quickly...
they did it without warning too
straightly after islamic new year
the worst part is that they did the ban during weekend, which mean they literally ban steam paypal etc during their peak day.
When all the blocked sites where shown i thought he'd just shrug it off and use a VPN
After this, Rong Rong got BLOCKED BY INDONESIAN GOV.
rip rongrong
i would miss that monkey or whatever that is
i hope this channel renamed to bona the pink elephant with long trunks
There's a massive online outrage, I don't think this will last that long
Thats if they actually listen
Hahahaha you think the govt cares about the people?
@@blackbird7781 Sike, they busy enjoying life from people taxes
@Minh Đức Nguyễn next thing we learn is that After the Internet they attempt to close all acces between the Pacific and the Indian ocean without stupidly high taxes, the kind of stuff that pisses of litteraly everyone if Suez alone bothered everone
@@Freedmoon44 oh, as if indonesian gov ACTUALLY do it
they are in huge debt that they are forced to not monetize access between pacific and indian ocean (aka australia to asia and vice versa)
indonesia would be huge if they tried to monetize it like singapore (fuel refilling, ship repairment)
the legend is back
Holy moly, today every single local content creator suddenly rose from the grave
Hell, even Rong Rong appeared as well
Eh, orang Indonesia kah kamu?
They underestimate the power of the gamers, and they better unblock everything sooner or else their parliament houses will be visited by just about everyone.
Yeah. Indonesian people when mad is crazy 😂 Kominfo shouldn't make them angry the people who silent & peacefully live at home & play the game all day.
its not even gamers, Indonesian people when angry can cause problems
@@hilmamufidah7286 I remember that inciden when SBY raise fuel prices riot bruh they are no joke.
Aha, so that's what's happening in upside-down Poland.
Imagine even thinking of touching grass in our beautifully polluted nation. Dream on
those companies are all needed to build our country!
The gambling apps are still there tho 💀
0:09 “Welcome to White Space, You have been living in here as long as you can remember”
Only in indonesia where the governemnt doesn’t banned online gambling but banning legal platform👍👍
Coba tanyakan pada rumput yang bergoyang, barang kali disana ada jawabnya "mengapa?"
By Ebiet G. Ade
the moment i heard the bloodborne music i was hooked
Now my fellow Indonesian! We have to start a new revolution as soon as possible (you know, the one similar to 1998 right before reformation).
No use. Last time it happened on 2020, the students involved got red-tagged as bunch of communists and got arrested.
this time, burn the boomers
Oh,you mean this?
id.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kerusuhan_Mei_1998
Time to get rid of those old timer bitc
@@RoXTs. yes
The worst part is gambling sites, which is considered HARAM, are not blocked by the government
And to make it worse, they even approved their registration.
have to make some money on the side if you know what i mean
I mean this is what I consider a positive, anything haram allowed to go through is probably or even always outright good.
bro finally touching grass
The sequel that everybody in Indonesia didn't want to happen.
Yet it happens
Not "everybody" becuse there is definitely some dumbasses in Indonesia who genuinely thought that this is a good idea...
my indonesian friend literally just bought gmod so we could play together yesterday bruh
QUICKLY, THE VPN SITES AREN’T BLOCKED, GET A SUBSCRIPTION TO ACCESS ALL THE WEBSITES AGAIN!
Kominfo: if you want your site/app to get acces in our country, you have register it first
Site/App Owner: Free right?
Kominfo: ......
situs jurnal jg, wkwkwk kg ada skripsi krn kg ada bahan
When government bans its citizens from accessing their own wallets
this is why digital money is problematic. One ban and your wallet is gone
@@3takoyakis not like putting your physical Money in a wallet is safe to. Indonesia is one of those countries where you should definetly not pull out your wallet in public
Just what in the world has to happen in the life of a stickman to make them touch grass..
“Having fun? Absolute haram”
i must say, although china is felt very strict, at least they are competent
indonesia ministry one day wake up and saying "i must block internet"