Got all 3 right almost right away (want to thank Tyler Clippard's brief stint with the White Sox for helping me with the last one) and got all 3 with the Winner's Circle although Musial took me a lot longer than I thought. Fun fact: Cal Ripken Jr. just barely made the cutoff for the last question, since he played 3001 games as an Oriole and in his career Stan Musial finished his career with 1,815 hits at home and 1,815 hits on the road. - He is also 4th all time in hits, only behind Pete Rose, Ty Cobb, and Hank Aaron. - Musial also would have likely been apart of the 500 Home Run Club if he didn't miss a season due to military service - Musial is 11th all time in WAR and 8th all time in Position Player WAR. Only 2 guys ahead of him (Walter Johnson and Honus Wagner) played their whole careers with one team - Stan Musial was born on November 21st in the town of Donora, Pennsylvania. Amazingly, he is not the only left handed Hall Of Fame outfielder to be born on November 21st in Donora, Pennsylvania. That other player's name is Ken Griffey Jr.
Max Mannis notably absent from this one... we might need to see him and Sales Lucas have a big showdown episode, possibly Jeopardy-style? With live commentary from Jimmy & Jake???
I would love episodes during the season with players who know the game like the back of their hand and others who aren't that knowledgeable on past players
The first one was easy, the second one gave me flashbacks to the “Fernando Rodney experience” as a mariners fan. The last one stumped me because I was picturing Tyler Clippard but guessed Drew Storen.😂
I love this series. Two ideas for the future. Guys who were free agents in a random year. (For example 2005.) or guys who won an award in a random year.
I looked at the back end of the career for 'Medium' and totally did not think that was who it ended up being. Guess I had no idea he bounced around that much after Seattle. If I'd just focused on the first part of his career, I probably would've gotten it.
Very mad I missed the hard player because I've been on his b-r page before... could only come up with half a dozen guesses for the bonus round before giving up and I only felt really good about one of them. Turns out I got all 3!! I love this series, one of the few instant clicks in my sub box
Haven’t started yet but I like this, I usually get all of them but if I can’t get it from what teams they were on what year I just figure it out. This sounds like a challenge
@@brennan883 Stan is a legend, much before my time but I started shouting his name... to many trips to his baseball reference page, Carl I know of but never looked up his stats wasnt aware he spent his whole career in boston or that he had 3,000 hits?
I got the first player because he is a all time legend. I got the second player because I remember his time on Seattle. I got the third guy because I use him on mlb the show a lot.
Got Bartolo in literally 3 seconds. Saw Mets in the middle and then looked to the top saw Cleveland in the 90s and knew right away. Edit: If i ever paid attention to the silhouettes I would’ve gotten it before I even saw the stat sheet
@@gadbammit4736 considering 1. You dont know the league 10 years in the future 2. What the average salary will be 3. You can eat the contract, its not a given at all, plenty of players have retired before their contract was up or been released or traded. Also, its not a 10+ year deal.
@@Glizzitron5000 I know, Albert Pujols and Miguel Cabrera are pretty good proof, other than pujols age 42 season he didnt have a "good one" after 2016? Stan Musials beat season after turning 36 came when he was 36.... and he hit around 15 home runs and 20 doubles from there on out which is league average production? You must be confusing Barry Bonds, Rodger Clemens, Rafael Palemero who were eating a balanced breakfast, with the average human body?
man my baseball knowledge is only from mlb the show11 while its so easy to guess rodney and clippard , im confuse with colon bcs hes not a player in the show 11 lol im thinking is it aj burnett or someone from yankee 2011 pitcher 🤦♂
I eventually got all three for the trivia round, but it took an embarrassing # of guesses. Yount and Brett at least *close,* but it was pretty shocking how far off the likes of Yadi, Larkin, Chipper, Schmidt, Banks, etc. were. (Obvious) conclusion: 3,000 is a sh!tload of games.
Got all 3 right almost right away (want to thank Tyler Clippard's brief stint with the White Sox for helping me with the last one) and got all 3 with the Winner's Circle although Musial took me a lot longer than I thought.
Fun fact: Cal Ripken Jr. just barely made the cutoff for the last question, since he played 3001 games as an Oriole and in his career
Stan Musial finished his career with 1,815 hits at home and 1,815 hits on the road.
- He is also 4th all time in hits, only behind Pete Rose, Ty Cobb, and Hank Aaron.
- Musial also would have likely been apart of the 500 Home Run Club if he didn't miss a season due to military service
- Musial is 11th all time in WAR and 8th all time in Position Player WAR. Only 2 guys ahead of him (Walter Johnson and Honus Wagner) played their whole careers with one team
- Stan Musial was born on November 21st in the town of Donora, Pennsylvania. Amazingly, he is not the only left handed Hall Of Fame outfielder to be born on November 21st in Donora, Pennsylvania. That other player's name is Ken Griffey Jr.
oddly specific
That last fact is freaky
I just somehow know Tyler clippard’s baseball reference page because I use him in the grid when I can. I’m now just oddly familiar with it
Is it bad that I got the easy one by the silhouette? 😂
haha same
saw this comment before the easy round and i didn’t know what you meant, now i do 😂
Haha same. I didn't even look at the stat sheet. I'd recognize that big sexy silhouette anywhere.
didn't even get easy or medium by stats but got hard by silhouette lol
@Thunderbolt2396 Same! I saw this comment thought no way. Then saw the silhouette
I wish this was posted everyday, I love this. Somebody gotta make this a app
“Clip and Save” was huge on those Nationals teams. Clip holds a special place in any Nats fans heart
I got Tyler clippard way too fast I started questioning myself
Mets legend was how I knew it was him
Same.
I am so bad at Ref Guess, but I love watching this every week! One day I'll make it to the winners circle. :D
One of my favorite series on YT. Thankful for you guys
Max Mannis notably absent from this one... we might need to see him and Sales Lucas have a big showdown episode, possibly Jeopardy-style? With live commentary from Jimmy & Jake???
I would love episodes during the season with players who know the game like the back of their hand and others who aren't that knowledgeable on past players
Petition to make REFGuess a 2/week show
The first one was easy, the second one gave me flashbacks to the “Fernando Rodney experience” as a mariners fan. The last one stumped me because I was picturing Tyler Clippard but guessed Drew Storen.😂
Thought for sure Biggio was gonna be an answer to that trivia question. Apparently he was just less than a season shy at 2,850 games played.
I love this series. Two ideas for the future. Guys who were free agents in a random year. (For example 2005.) or guys who won an award in a random year.
I got the last one because of the Andrew Vargha video lol
Who?
Keep these up!! They make me feel so smart 😂
Sales Lucas is making all the Lucas' out there proud. I'm not one of them, but I still appreciate his hot hand right now.
Ain't nothing wrong with one man appreciating another man's "hot hand," now is there?
I looked at the back end of the career for 'Medium' and totally did not think that was who it ended up being. Guess I had no idea he bounced around that much after Seattle. If I'd just focused on the first part of his career, I probably would've gotten it.
Very mad I missed the hard player because I've been on his b-r page before... could only come up with half a dozen guesses for the bonus round before giving up and I only felt really good about one of them. Turns out I got all 3!! I love this series, one of the few instant clicks in my sub box
Got me with #2, I was convinced it was Joaquin Benoit until someone said Fernando Rodney
Big Sexy is so iconic I could tell it was him from the silhouette alone
I somehow missed Fernando Rodney but got Tyler Clippard in 10 seconds
Haven’t started yet but I like this, I usually get all of them but if I can’t get it from what teams they were on what year I just figure it out. This sounds like a challenge
Biggest takeaway was that Clippard was crazy underrated, that's a hell of a career
Could watch these for hours
I could and I am!
"This is bart colon" gringo pronunciation got me lmao
thank you jack hughes for bringing the word heater back to the world
3/3 again. Came as close as I ever have to winning the Winner Circle with 2/3
Who did you miss Carl or Stan?
I missed Carl
@@gadbammit4736 Stan :/
@@gadbammit4736 he's who i missed too
@@brennan883 Stan is a legend, much before my time but I started shouting his name... to many trips to his baseball reference page, Carl I know of but never looked up his stats wasnt aware he spent his whole career in boston or that he had 3,000 hits?
Bartolo was a little too easy considering i knew immediately from the silhouette lmao dude got a big head 😂😂
Wow glad i wasnt the only one who thought Fransisco Rodney at first
I got Cal and Carl, but can't believe I couldn't think of Stan the Man.
Was expecting to see Octavio Dotel and Latroy Hawkins here.
I was waiting on Edwin Jackson
Damn I gotta pay more attention to relievers, this was brutal
Got all 3! I was going to say a good closing question would be to name all position players who played for at least 10 teams. Can't be many
Damn. Shoulda known the last 3 in the bonus round. Thought Robin Yount was one of them. Got Cal but not Carl or Stan.
I think I got Bartolo in less than 3 seconds for how much I’ve looked at his page
Woah woah woah woah….. like Chaminade in Saint Louis? Can’t miss that C anywhere
“This guy had 17 girlfriends in 2017?!” 🤣
fun vids. thanks for these!
I guessed Chipper instead of Yastrzemski dammit 😅, another great episode as usual.
Brooks Robinson? Damn!!! Nice one again
You guys should try a Guess the Pitcher by their batting stats.
Went 2/3 in the first round and went 1/3 in the winners circle! Good one this week! See yall next week!
Waiting on one of these to stump me. Need a super hard round
They were all extremely easy for me! Got so lucky that I knew Rodney’s ref like the back of my hand!
Should do Oliver Perez in one of these videos lol he had a wild career.
Colon 1:18
This stats thing is super easy for me I use to read the back of cards pooping 😂😂😂
With all the times they've name-dropped Andrew Miller, JM will have to include him at some point 🤣
It’s time for me to host a spin-off called Stump Lucas
Of the three ten-team players, not a one of them had an inning for the Cardinals. And probably other teams, I wasn't paying attention to them.
I would've got the 2nd one wrong if that guy hadn't said anything about the arrow. My initial guess was Joaquin Benoit.
The Easy one was given away by his silhouette lol
Knew the first guy just by the outline 🤣
as soon as i saw the title i was waiting to see Bartolo
Got Clippard but somehow missed Rodney
Bartolo is the first one I’ve gotten in the whole series 😂
All I had to do was look at Bart's silhuthette lol
Jolly looks tired in this😂
All 3 of these guys played for the Twins!
I got the first player because he is a all time legend.
I got the second player because I remember his time on Seattle.
I got the third guy because I use him on mlb the show a lot.
Got Bartolo in literally 3 seconds. Saw Mets in the middle and then looked to the top saw Cleveland in the 90s and knew right away.
Edit: If i ever paid attention to the silhouettes I would’ve gotten it before I even saw the stat sheet
TWENTY SEVEN FOR TWENTY SEVEN GET ME ON THIS SHOWW
The silhouette was a dead giveaway
Either jollys trying to troll or he doesnt know what albatross means
No.... any 10+ 300 million at age 30 will be an albatross contract, it's almost a given
@@gadbammit4736 considering 1. You dont know the league 10 years in the future 2. What the average salary will be 3. You can eat the contract, its not a given at all, plenty of players have retired before their contract was up or been released or traded. Also, its not a 10+ year deal.
@@Glizzitron5000 no, I just know how the average human body breaks down? I heard Clemens cans still throw 86
@@gadbammit4736 clemens was 1. Effective into his early 40s and 2. Pushing 60 years old. And 3. These peoples bodies arent average
@@Glizzitron5000 I know, Albert Pujols and Miguel Cabrera are pretty good proof, other than pujols age 42 season he didnt have a "good one" after 2016? Stan Musials beat season after turning 36 came when he was 36.... and he hit around 15 home runs and 20 doubles from there on out which is league average production?
You must be confusing Barry Bonds, Rodger Clemens, Rafael Palemero who were eating a balanced breakfast, with the average human body?
Ref guess is fun... can't believe only one dude guessed Stan The Man? Wow wtf yal got Tyler clippard but didn't guess Stan?
missing jake this episode
I crushed this one and the bonus round. Can't believe it because I suck at these
Lucas dominating
Wow I actually managed to get all 3 for the first time lol
I heard the premise and thought, “they got to have Big Sexy in this”
641 era+ in 2012 for the medium guy lmao
3 Twins legends right here
I feel odd that I got Tyler clippard faster than the other two lol
You should.
Would of loved to see Jesse Chavez 😩
Why can't that lady compete by herself???
Tyler Clippard lead the 2011 Nats in WAR!
Orrecchiette for the pasta baby
got t-clip but not the others lol
man my baseball knowledge is only from mlb the show11 while its so easy to guess rodney and clippard , im confuse with colon bcs hes not a player in the show 11 lol im thinking is it aj burnett or someone from yankee 2011 pitcher 🤦♂
I eventually got all three for the trivia round, but it took an embarrassing # of guesses. Yount and Brett at least *close,* but it was pretty shocking how far off the likes of Yadi, Larkin, Chipper, Schmidt, Banks, etc. were.
(Obvious) conclusion: 3,000 is a sh!tload of games.
at least your guesses all played for one team
Wait what about chipper jones n Tony Gwynn? Gotta be close
If one isn't Octavio Dotel or Edwin Jackson, is it really a complete list?
Dotel is like on my all-time 21st century underrated team. His career K/9 is naaaaasty.
This is fun. Can you grow up and do it for hockey?
As a Twins fan these were all very easy
Oh, bart colon
Lucas! Lucas! Lucas!
Got all 3 :)
Got first two from silhouette
i don’t think i’ve missed one yet in all the episodes
How long does it take for people to get these in real time? These were VERY EASY
Is rob s related to Jake? They’re twins right?
d'Aversa getting Ripken last is craaaaaazy.
Rodney 3:05
gotta be tyler clippard
fuck yeah
Btw honus wagner never changed teams the team just moved so doesn’t really count
Handsome rob?
Shame to do this without Max Mannis #WeWantMax
Another easy ref guess. Maybe im just smart
3 Twins. Easy.
Bartolo Colon played on 11 teams not 10
Guys who have visited the JM HQ