Would These Great Strategists Win the Game of Thrones?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 фев 2025

Комментарии •

  • @rougarabid
    @rougarabid  12 часов назад +5

    To be notified for debate streams on Discord click the link!
    Discord - discord.com/events/1190020956819824751/1337950258575048715

    • @Ethan03887
      @Ethan03887 10 часов назад +2

      Go watch/listen to the rainimator series and do a survival challenge or some kind of challenge with this ether the main series or the war of the ender kingdom’s either is alright with me 👌❓😎👍🤔
      By the way let me know which music out of the entire series is your favorite 2 of 3 of mine are ender wish and the brave 👌😎

  • @Psub950
    @Psub950 12 часов назад +33

    Another problem Palpatine has is that even if he is as smart as some people say, he is Canonically a massive adrenaline junkie that takes unnecessary risks all the time

    • @joaosturza
      @joaosturza 7 часов назад +5

      he specifically allowed the rebellion to continue because he was just so bored with winning so compleatly

  • @Hagaspaba
    @Hagaspaba 12 часов назад +46

    That one guy finally got his video

    • @Psub950
      @Psub950 12 часов назад +20

      I'm indeed very happy

    • @tinyguy1015
      @tinyguy1015 12 часов назад +1

      😂😂​@Psub950

  • @The_Squatch_97
    @The_Squatch_97 12 часов назад +22

    Game of Thrones is literally just European history where there just happens to be dragons and zombies

    • @isabelpage5950
      @isabelpage5950 12 часов назад +4

      Or Jewish history. The Second Book of Kings is just GOT but Jewish.

  • @Souplord1
    @Souplord1 12 часов назад +26

    Could modern politicians survive the ratification of the Constitution

  • @admin.slayerenryu
    @admin.slayerenryu 9 часов назад +5

    Another aspext to consider for Palpatine is the fact that he didn't planned the fall of the Republic and the Jedi from the beginning, he was essentially the one who enacted a plan that was decades to centuries in the making since Darth Bane of multiple Sith lords that conspired for years.

  • @rais6036
    @rais6036 5 часов назад +3

    You make very creative videos keep it up man

    • @rougarabid
      @rougarabid  3 часа назад +1

      As long as there are people who want to see them I’ll keep pumping them out 👍

  • @DAVIDMcDonald-uf2ep
    @DAVIDMcDonald-uf2ep 12 часов назад +18

    No Rouga, normal people do not produce biohazards for lunch. Very funny opening though, 10/10, getting a like

  • @stevelucky7579
    @stevelucky7579 8 часов назад +1

    Dude that 4 hour cut would be I think so cool to see!

  • @The_Squatch_97
    @The_Squatch_97 12 часов назад +13

    To make Palpatine and the Jedi seem even dumber: the Jedi built their temple on a massive pile of Sith artifacts. So imagine trying to parse out a sound while at a concert

  • @Gaia_Gaistar
    @Gaia_Gaistar 10 часов назад +3

    That opening description of slop surprise is so real, been there before buddy.

  • @JamesConner-j9i
    @JamesConner-j9i 10 часов назад +2

    Would LOVE to see helldivers thrown into the dead space universe I know there’s a video out about it already but not on the size and scale you do

  • @Hero-ul5dd
    @Hero-ul5dd 11 часов назад +2

    As always a Fantastic video

  • @IzukuTodoroki-t4l
    @IzukuTodoroki-t4l 11 часов назад +6

    Would these fictional assassins (Agent 47, Ezio, John Wick, Deadpool and I.M.P) be able to kill Batman in Arkham Origins

  • @joshuamoore9875
    @joshuamoore9875 11 часов назад +10

    I wonder how Lelouch (code geass) would do in this challenge.

    • @crocoboi7936
      @crocoboi7936 3 часа назад

      Stuff like this is perfect for him especially either his geass

  • @djashovel
    @djashovel 11 часов назад +3

    I think the best crossover series i've seen for star wars
    Is warhammer vs star wars series made by( a fan with too much time)
    He is a great writer and I highly recommend the series

  • @diegocardenas6494
    @diegocardenas6494 11 часов назад +6

    This gives me an idea of powerscaling characters from bad shows or good shows with a bad season or sometbing like that and essentially make a battle royal of idiots and incompetent people

    • @diegocardenas6494
      @diegocardenas6494 11 часов назад +2

      Either that or have a vs challenge of spoof characters vs the original characters that the spoof characters are based on

  • @kevind3974
    @kevind3974 11 часов назад +3

    Also for toranaga this is his third major game of thrones. And he technically won all three (oda won the first, hideoshi the second but toriaga was both of there left hand man)
    Game of thrones is just a tusday for him.

  • @EnderBaldwin
    @EnderBaldwin 8 часов назад +4

    Fun fact the good parts of the plan weren't even Palpatine it was other sith who were plotting this for millenia.

  • @JustPanda2305
    @JustPanda2305 7 часов назад +2

    Wait but, what about Thrawn? Ain't he an absolute genius in Star Wars?

    • @rougarabid
      @rougarabid  3 часа назад

      Depends on the version but his genius is based around space warfare not political maneuvering.

  • @darkreflection9087
    @darkreflection9087 11 часов назад +5

    Would these Open World Survivors
    (TOTK) Link
    (Minecraft) Characters
    (Horizon) Aloy
    (Don’t Starve) Characters
    (Fallout 76) Vault Dweller
    Survive Ark Survival Evolved
    Who else should be on this list
    Edit
    (Subnautica) Robin Ayou

  • @jamesmcdonald1108
    @jamesmcdonald1108 10 часов назад +1

    I think you're underselling Azula a bit, she's shown the ability to play nice and keep a mask up- but I do agree she's going to have to make a massive effort to overcome her weakness in her thinking- but I also think she's smart enough to recognize her new inability, though it's a matter of if she can adapt before she's wiped out.

  • @maxicam5980
    @maxicam5980 Минуту назад

    20:45 Eren is going to be looking for those crops a long time since as House Greyjoy's words state "we do not sow"

  • @thibaultl1956
    @thibaultl1956 6 часов назад

    The leftovers story is super relatable.

  • @jackolantern147
    @jackolantern147 10 часов назад

    We all would love to see a 4 hour cut of ROTS. They have an extended fight of Kenobi vs Grievous's Magnaguards which I have heard to be the best choreographed fight in the entire series so far. Kicking staffs where a lightsaber can't block, barrel rolling, even the Magnaguards jumping him all at once instead of one at a time.
    Also, Sheevs planning and preparation skills made it to where he wins just by the Clone Wars kicking off. Hell, he has an order 66 equivalent for the droids called order 99 just in case the clones aren't a viable options for whatever reason. He just didn't use it because the point of the war was to get the Jedi used to fighting easy to beat droids then skilled clones of a great jedi hunter take them by suprise. He even had the galaxy cheer when their protectors were branded traitors and hunted. You think it's only a coincidence that he chose a former Jedi to lead the Sepratists formed solely of genocidal monsters or aliens, then made an empire solely of human supremacy? There are other points I could make, but this is starting to get long, bottom line ,he sure as hell should be higher than freaking Eren Yeager at the very least. Second perhaps only to Yoshi.

  • @thehermitman822
    @thehermitman822 8 часов назад

    Clever ad for Shogun and I'm here for it.

  • @admin.slayerenryu
    @admin.slayerenryu 9 часов назад +1

    4:42 The only times that hasn't happened were in Troy and the Percy Jackson fanfic that was the first movie.

    • @rougarabid
      @rougarabid  9 часов назад +2

      And national treasure

  • @sabbathjackal
    @sabbathjackal 4 часа назад

    Its actually kind of amazing the level of independent social cooperation. That turned GOT from cutural phenomenon into "ive never fucking heard of it" in like 2hrs.

  • @johnarcher6150
    @johnarcher6150 5 часов назад

    Oh hey. That one dude is happy now.

  • @JamesConner-j9i
    @JamesConner-j9i 10 часов назад

    Absolutely love to hate these videos dude keep it up I don’t always agree with ur stuff but it’s clear you put a lot of effort in keep it up because you always have banger video ideas

  • @admin.slayerenryu
    @admin.slayerenryu 4 часа назад

    The biggest issue for Eren could be Euron Greyjoy as he's essentially a lovecraftian kinda antagonist in the books, but even then that's not a guarantee.

  • @joshuamoore9875
    @joshuamoore9875 11 часов назад +2

    Which medieval/fantasy series would survive game of thrones:
    -conan the barbarian
    -lord of the rings
    - Witcher
    - robin hood
    - final fantasy

  • @juliusbossman7280
    @juliusbossman7280 10 часов назад

    Would these cops survive GTA V?
    -Frank Drebin
    -Robocop
    -Axel Foley
    -Columbo

  • @evanjrclarke1079
    @evanjrclarke1079 9 часов назад

    31:00 Ieyasu- er, Toronaga for the win baby!

  • @Psub950
    @Psub950 12 часов назад +7

    Would These Characters Survive Game of Thrones?
    -Aragorn (Lord of the Rings)
    -Apollyon (For Honor)
    -Askeladd (Vinland Saga)
    -Ambessa Medarda (Arcane)

    • @lukalovric2463
      @lukalovric2463 6 часов назад +1

      Apollyan would love the Mountain and Victarion, They are perfect wolfs.

    • @Psub950
      @Psub950 6 часов назад +1

      ​@@lukalovric2463I think she would like Arya as well

  • @thehermitman822
    @thehermitman822 9 часов назад

    Ole Bobby B. enjoys the perks of being King he just hates the duties.

  • @old_timey_prospector
    @old_timey_prospector 12 часов назад +1

    Doom soup? I used to make that. Can't have it anymore though, soups just go right through me.

  • @missyummy1040
    @missyummy1040 3 часа назад

    i think Overlord and Eminence in Shadow should be next, it feels fitting in the challenge

  • @65firered
    @65firered 8 часов назад +2

    Eren: "You leave me alone, I leave you alone."
    Westeros: "Deal."

  • @lastminuterecodings9752
    @lastminuterecodings9752 12 часов назад +3

    I think Erwin would've been a more intresting character to put instead of Eren

  • @kxs22
    @kxs22 10 часов назад +1

    Spoiler alert, sean beans character in national treasure lives at the end

    • @rougarabid
      @rougarabid  10 часов назад +1

      Nah he dies to excessive prison rape.

  • @loganjustlogan8367
    @loganjustlogan8367 5 часов назад

    Video 4 of asking you to do something with the resistance franchise. This time my suggestion is: would Rapture (BioShock) survive an invasion from the chimera. Or just a few alien invaders and include them in there.

  • @RomanHistoryFan476AD
    @RomanHistoryFan476AD 8 часов назад

    Another mark to show how bad Palpatine's plans are: This man had the whole main rebel fleet in his grasp stuck between Death Star 2 and a overwhelming Imperial fleet. Now instead of being smart and just using the Imperial fleet to hammer the rebels till they're destroyed, he instead rather tell the fleet to just stay there and let the death star 2 do all the work wasting time and allowing the heroes time to blow the shield generator and Luke to begin getting into Vader's head.
    The rebels charged the Imperial fleet to use it as a shield against the death star.

  • @dakotalange2858
    @dakotalange2858 10 часов назад +2

    Book Varys would be a match or beat him show Varys is a joke

  • @agentumbra2374
    @agentumbra2374 10 часов назад

    If i could make a suggestion for a future video: could character's who fight monsters survive Platime Co from Poppy Playtime.
    So character's like Buffy the vampire slayer, Sam & Dean Winchester and John Constantine vs Poppy Playtime

  • @DaeshaniSanchez
    @DaeshaniSanchez 10 часов назад +1

    I think lelouch (code geass) would have been a more interesting choice over eren or johan from monster

  • @isabelpage5950
    @isabelpage5950 12 часов назад +2

    Palpatine honestly doesn't need a master plan. Bro just moggs the entire GOT universe so badly he'd basically be a god.

    • @rougarabid
      @rougarabid  9 часов назад +1

      Didn’t watch the video.

  • @qevansable
    @qevansable 3 часа назад

    I would put Oz Cobb ( the penguin t.v show) and Ender from (Ender's game) Vito and Michael Corleone, and Askeladd (Vinland) in this conversation.

  • @johnarcher6150
    @johnarcher6150 5 часов назад

    Also. Just reminding people that Jar Jar Binks was the Sith Lord all along.

  • @redmaxxs
    @redmaxxs 3 часа назад

    20:38 It's interesting debate with Aaron from attack on Titan. I would say the older version of himself would be a good strategist but a younger version of himself without any influence would be an ok strategist. The older version of himself I can see is getting kind of far, the younger version of himself will not make it even past season 1.

  • @djashovel
    @djashovel 12 часов назад +3

    Sauron Should have been also on this list

  • @killking-wr8mp
    @killking-wr8mp 11 часов назад +2

    I believe Anakin was conflicted after attacking Padma, giving him a mental nerf. combine that with his already established hubris is likely why Obi wan won.

  • @rmartinson19
    @rmartinson19 Час назад

    Your critiques of Palpatine ands Star Wars are largely based on major misunderstandings about the lore, and assumptions that the characters knew things that they didn't. The Jedi had no clue that Dooku was involved in the creation of the clones. They learned from Jango Fett that he was hired to be the progenitor of the Clone Army by a man named "Tyrannus", and from the Kaminoans that the Army was ordered by a Jedi Master named Sifo-Dyas, who was renowned as the best seer among the Jedi Order, and who had often spoken of visions of a coming war for years before he mysteriously died (pretty much immediately after cutting this deal to make the clones).
    They never learned that Dooku's Sith title was "Darth Tyrannus", because he never used that name unless he was talking to Palpatine in private. They already had a reasonably solid explanation for why the Army existed (i.e. "that guy who was the absolute best at seeing the future foresaw the war and had them made, but died before he could tell the rest of us about it"), and before they could dig into the mystery of who this "Tyrannus" figure was, the war had started and the Senate (at Palpatine's behest) had voted to conscript the Jedi as officers in its new army. The Jedi were already concerned at the kinds of psychopaths that were becoming prominent in the new military (like Wilhuff Tarkin, the guy who would one day blow up Alderaan purely to make a statement) and worried both for how immorally the war would be conducted without their direct involvement, as well as how little regard many high-ranking officers had for the clones as living beings. So in order to act as a regulator on the Republic's war machine, they opted to not fight against the Senate's decision, and the demands of the war put their efforts at investigating "Tyrannus" onto the back burner until it was far too late.
    Second, Palpatine did, in fact, fool everyone. The Jedi didn't trust him toward the END of the war, because they thought he might have been manipulated by the Sith, and they were concerned at a politician amassing too much power. They never suspected that he was the Sith Lord behind everything that had happened until he chose to reveal himself to Anakin. He fooled the Jedi, he fooled the Senate (which overwhelmingly supported him), and he fooled the general population of the Republic, who saw him as a heroic figure.
    Thirdly, Padme was never a Separatist. You are misremembering and misunderstanding what was going on in those deleted scenes. In those scenes, what she and her friends like Bail Organa and Mon Mothma were actually doing was laying the groundwork for what would become the Rebel Alliance. They were setting up a contingency plan to start a violent pro-democracy revolution in the event that Palpatine refused to relinquish his emergency powers at the end of the war, and set himself up as a dictator. She was never a "double agent" for the Separatists, it was entirely a plan to save the Republic after the Separatists were already defeated. And the whole thing about Anakin's fears was mostly tied to insecurity about Padme both committing treason and possibly cheating on him with Obi-wan (which was strongly hinted at in those deleted scenes - not that she did it, but that Anakin was afraid that she might have). That is the fear that would be seemingly confirmed by her showing up with Obi-wan at the end, which would drive him into such a rage that he would attack her directly.
    Honestly, I gave up here. Pretty much every point you made aftre that in the Palpatine section was simply wrong. You were remembering things incorrectly, or making assumptions that weren't actually true. If I wanted to refute them all, this post would be triple the length, and I'm tired of typing this out. Basically, do your homework and maybe re-watch some things before doing a lore-heavy video again, because you simply do not know what you're talking about.

  • @dragonknight1560
    @dragonknight1560 6 часов назад

    ... Where's Lelouch Lamperouge? If there's someone who will claim the throne to end the idiotic fighting... it's the guy who kills evil by using evil. Even without Geass, bro is a strategist through and through.

  • @YTSearchRapBattlesKinGLeoVs
    @YTSearchRapBattlesKinGLeoVs 2 часа назад

    Would these Dream Walkers survive Elm St. Max from Sharkboy and LavaGirl and whiever else has dream powers lmao

  • @alexboggs6416
    @alexboggs6416 12 часов назад +1

    Who wins the game Justice League edition. No powers allowed. Batman is on the Small council as spy master, Wonder Woman is Dynaris, Jon Snow is replaced with Martian Manhunter, The iron Islands is Aquaman's, Cyborg claims the North, Stormsend is GreenLanterns, The Vail is Superman's, and Flash owns the area The flower people owned.

    • @alexboggs6416
      @alexboggs6416 12 часов назад +1

      Also Green Arrow is the Lanisters

  • @justx6397
    @justx6397 9 часов назад

    I it was a good idea fr

  • @jexilthevulpix2476
    @jexilthevulpix2476 10 часов назад

    Please do lelouce, when you do this list next time.

  • @ghelmet2701
    @ghelmet2701 11 часов назад +2

    Not gonna lie, Game of Thrones has the most terrible Seige battles.

    • @rougarabid
      @rougarabid  3 часа назад

      Terrible battles period as far as strategy goes.

  • @DarthWombat
    @DarthWombat 8 часов назад

    Styles make fights. Dooku's form was better against Obi's form, not as good against Anakin's.

  • @grantyboi454
    @grantyboi454 8 часов назад

    How would Edelgard from Fire Emblem do in Game of Thrones

  • @dwayneasher6765
    @dwayneasher6765 3 часа назад

    If this video becomes successful can you put in light the main character from death note and the main character from code gasses and the bad guy for Mobile suit Gundam SEED destiny

  • @darkreflection9087
    @darkreflection9087 11 часов назад +2

    Would these Villains
    (Sonic) Dr Eggman
    (Megaman) Dr Wily
    (Mario) Bowser
    (Ratchet & Clank) Dr Nefarious
    (Crash Bandicoot) Doctor Neo Cortex
    (Jak and Daxter) Gol Acheron
    (The Owl House) Emperor Belos
    (The Dragon Prince) Viren
    (The Dragon Prince) Finnegrin
    (Minecraft Dungeons) Arch Illager
    (Minecraft Dungeons) Nameless One
    (Max Steel Reboot) Elementors
    (Danny Phantom) Vlad Plasmius
    (Danny Phantom) Pariah Dark
    (Ben 10) Vilgax
    (Sonic) Lyric
    (Sonic) Deadly Six
    (Sonic) Doctor Starline
    (Soulcalibur) Nightmare
    (Kirby) Fecto Elfilis
    (Mario) Cursa The Destroyer
    (Hollow Knight) Radiance
    (Sonic) Scourge
    (Sonic) Ixis Naugus
    (TOTK) Ganondorf
    (Sonic) Commander Brutus
    (Cult of the Lamb) The Old Faith
    (PVZ) Dr Zomboss
    Survive Skylanders or Conquer Skylands
    What other villains should be added to this list
    Edit
    (Donkey Kong) King K Rool
    (Warcraft) Lich King
    (Avatar) Ozai

    • @DAVIDMcDonald-uf2ep
      @DAVIDMcDonald-uf2ep 11 часов назад +1

      @@darkreflection9087 it’s Dr Zomboss

    • @darkreflection9087
      @darkreflection9087 11 часов назад +1

      @@DAVIDMcDonald-uf2epi actually noticed that I thought I typed it correctly but it think autocorrect changed it without me noticing

  • @RandomName2449
    @RandomName2449 10 часов назад

    What is about Thomas Shelby?

  • @ThegrandKrild
    @ThegrandKrild 12 часов назад +3

    The cut parts are not canon
    Palpatine got into power with plagueis money and raw political skills
    Mace windu is the third strongest jedi in history while the 3 Masters are suposed to be part of the top 10
    Palpatine used sith magic to blind the jedi AND fough both wars from both sides with nobody knowing about dooku because sipho diaz is the one who got the clone army and the kamino didn't want to talk eiter
    The empire lasted 20 years and is stated in both timelines how the death star was a scare tactic from (against another galaxy in legends, but also was planed by plagueis and palpatine just keep the plan going)
    The order 66 killed literally 98%/99% of all jedi
    Only like 100 survived and the inquisitors killed almost all of them (and surviving jedi like ahsoka, kenobi or yoda are powerfull enough to survive)
    With weaker jedi surviving by just being very far or getting their masters killed to escape
    (In episode 6 there was 4 jedi alive in a galaxy with quintillions from the original 10.000 or more from the republic)
    All other arguments are just ignorance or fac fic
    Idk where the dune rage bait come from but that is just bias and there's nothing like the clone wars or the jedi (and the voice is not the force because the name is similar AND the force mental power is just a secondary power compared with the living universe granting power, or spice being important because all drugs are called spice and were never important to the plot outside of worldbuilding, also the sand planet has like 20 minutes of screen time in 3 films)
    Also eren gets washed (he can't he can't even show fake emotions)

  • @mcgclock
    @mcgclock 7 часов назад

    I feel like you're giving Eren too much credit. Since when was he a great strategist? The only ever smart thing he ever did was infiltrate Marley (not even sure that was his idea, someone else might've brought it up) and infiltration and spying is not even something unique in Game of Thrones. Who's to say the Iron Islands won't send spies of their own to Paradis Island?
    A big reason why Eren even has his crazy plan to destroy the world is because he can see the future and the past, he can see what happens and what to do. He wouldn't have any of those powers so he wouldn't have any reason to destroy the world and make himself a villain. He'd probably just be a normal soldier, since that's what he was at the beginning. Also, he wouldn't be the leader of Paradis Island and neither would anyone pay him any mind. A major reason why anyone even listens to him is because he had titan powers and intel that helped Paradis. Even he was shocked by some of the things he learned.
    At best, he'd become a high ranking soldier of Paradis but would probably die very quickly because being a soldier won't win you the game of thrones. He shouldn't even be that high.

  • @pattou2175
    @pattou2175 7 часов назад

    You put Eren Yeager above azula and the sith Lord I usually don't call bullshit too much on your stuff but I'm sorry that is completely dumb. Eren Yeager is not even a smart character in his own universe And the only thing he has going for him is he could turn into a Titan

    • @rougarabid
      @rougarabid  7 часов назад +1

      Eren plans out all the events of the series from his father stealing the Titan, controlling power, to the Yeagers rising up, to the rumbling being released, to saving paradis. He was able to fool, literally the entire world into believing that he was some horrible monster also so that he could die as a martyr to save his people. He outsmarted literally everyone. The scouts, his brother, the Yeagerists, everyone.

  • @MikaAli-h9j
    @MikaAli-h9j 3 часа назад

    The intro is awful

    • @rougarabid
      @rougarabid  3 часа назад

      Can’t please everyone.