I heard Ms Gomyo perform the Piazolla 4 seasons in LA a couple of years a go and absolutely loved her performance. It is great to hear her do this marathon of a concerto.
Hello, I think you got the tempos of movements wrong, some minor error happened :) 1st is moderato indeed 2nd isn't adagio, it's allegro / scherzo allegro (usually just scherzo written on the listing) 3rd i believe doesn't start with adagio but with andante so it would go I. Moderato 2. Scherzo allegro 3. Andante - allegro Absolutely brilliant performance, especially the scherzo :D Although I may think so just because it's my generally favorite part of the concerto... probably the most recognisable one too
You are right, something went absolutely wrong here and we are very sorry about that. We corrected the movements in the video descriptions. We hope you still enjoy the music!
@@WDRKlassik It doesn't matter in the slightest :D Video could be called "Shoskovich viola concertino 27" and it wouldn't matter at all :D Absolutely brilliant performance once again :D
fantastic performance - vital virtuos - but as well introverted...... at any rate always intense. bravoooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
Great performance. However as played is Op 99, not Op 77. The key difference between the two is who launches the Finale, soloist (77) or orchestra (99). Oistrakh suggested the change for the latter to give a breather for the soloist coming out from the Cadenza.
Yes, Shostakovich did make some changes for Oirstrakh before the concerto's world premiere. But for Shostakovich himself it was still his op. 77. The publisher at that time decided to give the work the opus number 99 for political reasons. The orchestra's score used for this recording is published by Sikorski and part of the New Shostakovich Complete Edition.
@@WDRKlassik How do we differentiate the original score where the soloist launches the finale, as some adhere to today, and the one edited for the orchestra to come in first as is played here?
@@WDRKlassik OK, quoting Laurel Fay of her book Shostakovich a Life, The Violin Concerto was initially assigned opus no. 99, corresponding chronologically to its date of first performance. It was subsequently reassigned opus no. 77, reflecting the actual date of composition. Opus 99 was assigned to the film music for The First Echelon. I guess there is no Violin Concerto Op 99 then.
Não consigo entender muito bem por que muitos musicistas e musicólogos que escrevem sobre eventos musicais não se preocupam com detalhes na titularidade de obras! Nesta apresentação, belíssima por sinal, nenhum violino está sendo consertado, e o que está ocorrendo, é a execução de uma partitura que, certamente está, ou deveria estar titulada como: Concerto Nº 1 para Violino e Orquestra! Me desculpem o mal jeito, mas sou um musicista detalhista, e entendo que tudo deve ser colocado corretamente, sem dúvidas.
When a virtuoso like Karen Gomyo plays a piece with her eyes closed I believe her heart and soul is totally absorbed with the beauty she is creating.
That's beautifully said! 🥰
This is pure magic, there's no other words for it.
I heard Ms Gomyo perform the Piazolla 4 seasons in LA a couple of years a go and absolutely loved her performance. It is great to hear her do this marathon of a concerto.
Beeindruckende Interpretation dieses Meisterwerks.
Danke!
At this very moment it sounds like a definitive performance. Truly phenomenal!
Thank you for your kind words!
It's a very impressive performance. I listened intently. thank you !!!
Thanks.
Nice to hear that you enjoyed it.
Браво! Браво! Браво!!
🤗
Toll gemacht. Orchester und Solistin sind ganz wunderbar. Und Macelaru ist ein Gluecksfall fuer das WDR Koeln. Danke !
Vielen Dank! 🥰
Freut uns, dass es Ihnen gefällt 😊
BRAVO!
Hello, I think you got the tempos of movements wrong, some minor error happened :)
1st is moderato indeed
2nd isn't adagio, it's allegro / scherzo allegro (usually just scherzo written on the listing)
3rd i believe doesn't start with adagio but with andante
so it would go
I. Moderato
2. Scherzo allegro
3. Andante - allegro
Absolutely brilliant performance, especially the scherzo :D Although I may think so just because it's my generally favorite part of the concerto... probably the most recognisable one too
You are right, something went absolutely wrong here and we are very sorry about that. We corrected the movements in the video descriptions. We hope you still enjoy the music!
@@WDRKlassik It doesn't matter in the slightest :D Video could be called "Shoskovich viola concertino 27" and it wouldn't matter at all :D Absolutely brilliant performance once again :D
Thank you for your understanding! :)
Powerful performance.
Thank you 🤗
fantastic performance - vital virtuos - but as well introverted...... at any rate always intense. bravoooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
Thank you so much for your kind words! 😍
Wonderful performance up there with the very best.
By the way, the tempo marking of the second movement is Allegro (not Adagio).
Very well played!
Great performance. However as played is Op 99, not Op 77. The key difference between the two is who launches the Finale, soloist (77) or orchestra (99). Oistrakh suggested the change for the latter to give a breather for the soloist coming out from the Cadenza.
Yes, Shostakovich did make some changes for Oirstrakh before the concerto's world premiere. But for Shostakovich himself it was still his op. 77. The publisher at that time decided to give the work the opus number 99 for political reasons. The orchestra's score used for this recording is published by Sikorski and part of the New Shostakovich Complete Edition.
@@WDRKlassik How do we differentiate the original score where the soloist launches the finale, as some adhere to today, and the one edited for the orchestra to come in first as is played here?
@@WDRKlassik OK, quoting Laurel Fay of her book Shostakovich a Life, The Violin Concerto was initially assigned opus no. 99, corresponding chronologically to its date of first performance. It was subsequently reassigned opus no. 77, reflecting the actual date of composition. Opus 99 was assigned to the film music for The First Echelon. I guess there is no Violin Concerto Op 99 then.
😃👍
Não consigo entender muito bem por que muitos musicistas e musicólogos que escrevem sobre eventos musicais não se preocupam com detalhes na titularidade de obras! Nesta apresentação, belíssima por sinal, nenhum violino está sendo consertado, e o que está ocorrendo, é a execução de uma partitura que, certamente está, ou deveria estar titulada como: Concerto Nº 1 para Violino e Orquestra! Me desculpem o mal jeito, mas sou um musicista detalhista, e entendo que tudo deve ser colocado corretamente, sem dúvidas.
The Japanese description says "カレン・ゴーミョー" or "カレン・ゴミョウ", but please write her Japanese name, "五明カレン".