How so the train killed them not you? So If I saw someone drowning and do nothing you are murder? If you have no duty to protect those people then you shouldn’t do anything and leave to the professionals
I remember watching a short video from a lawyer, which basically said that you have no right to deprive other people of their lives. If you don't pull the lever, then it is the railway department's responsibility, but if you pull the lever, then it becomes your responsibility.
@@elenagacha-lk3kgYou don't need to die. Repent and turn away from your sins. Cultivate a relationship with God and believe that God raised him from the dead as a mediator and atonement for our sins. Colossians 3. 1. If ye then be risen with Christ, seek those things which are above where Christ sitteth on the right hand of God. 2. Set your affection on the things which are above and not on things which are on the earth. 3. For ye are dead and your life is hid with Christ in God. 4. When Christ, which is our life shall appear, so shall ye also appear with him in Glory. ******** Jesus is calling you today. Come to him, repent from your sins, bear his cross and live the victorious life ******** Romans 10:9-13 That if thou shalt confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus, and shalt believe in thine heart that God hath raised him from the dead, thou shalt be saved. For with the heart man believeth unto righteousness; and with the mouth confession is made unto salvation. For the scripture saith, Whosoever believeth on him shall not be ashamed. For there is no difference between the Jew and the Greek: for the same Lord over all is rich unto all that call upon him. For whosoever shall call upon the name of the Lord shall be saved. Hebrews 12:14 Follow peace with all men, and holiness, without which no man shall see the Lord: Matthew 5:3-12 Blessed are the poor in spirit: for theirs is the kingdom of heaven. Blessed are they that mourn: for they shall be comforted. Blessed are the meek: for they shall inherit the earth. Blessed are they which do hunger and thirst after righteousness: for they shall be filled. Blessed are the merciful: for they shall obtain mercy. Blessed are the pure in heart: for they shall see God. Blessed are the peacemakers: for they shall be called the children of God. Blessed are they which are persecuted for righteousness sake: for theirs is the kingdom of heaven. Blessed are ye, when men shall revile you, and persecute you, and shall say all manner of evil against you falsely, for my sake. Rejoice, and be exceeding glad: for great is your reward in heaven: for so persecuted they the prophets which were before you. FOR THOSE WHO ARE TIRED OF THEIR SINS AND ARE READY TO ACCEPT JESUS INTO THEIR LIFE, KINDLY SAY THIS PRAYER: Psalms 51. Have mercy upon me, O God, according to thy lovingkindness: according unto the multitude of thy tender mercies blot out my transgressions. Wash me throughly from mine iniquity, and cleanse me from my sin. For I acknowledge my transgressions: and my sin is ever before me. Against thee, thee only, have I sinned, and done this evil in thy sight: that thou mightest be justified when thou speakest, and be clear when thou judgest. Behold, I was shapen in iniquity; and in sin did my mother conceive me. Behold, thou desirest truth in the inward parts: and in the hidden part thou shalt make me to know wisdom. Purge me with hyssop, and I shall be clean: wash me, and I shall be whiter than snow. Make me to hear joy and gladness; that the bones which thou hast broken may rejoice. Hide thy face from my sins, and blot out all mine iniquities. Create in me a clean heart, O God; and renew a right spirit within me. Cast me not away from thy presence; and take not thy holy spirit from me. Restore unto me the joy of thy salvation; and uphold me with thy free spirit. Then will I teach transgressors thy ways; and sinners shall be converted unto thee. Deliver me from bloodguiltiness, O God, thou God of my salvation: and my tongue shall sing aloud of thy righteousness. O Lord, open thou my lips; and my mouth shall shew forth thy praise. For thou desirest not sacrifice; else would I give it: thou delightest not in burnt offering. The sacrifices of God are a broken spirit: a broken and a contrite heart, O God, thou wilt not despise. Do good in thy good pleasure unto Zion: build thou the walls of Jerusalem. Then shalt thou be pleased with the sacrifices of righteousness, with burnt offering and whole burnt offering: then shall they offer bullocks upon thine altar.
@@theweirdwolf1877 he made a fake train conductor station with videos of workers on the tracks. The videos were edited and ended right before the train hit so noone was harmed
I would not pull the lever. First of all, its not the guys fault he is alone. Second, I could be prosecuted with man slaughter. Third, the people on the track are together, so they would have some connection to each other. It would be cruel to make someone die alone just because of their unfortunate circumstances.
WE INDIANS ARE BROWN AND HAVE A RED DOT ON FOREHEAD. MOST OF US ARE POOR, UNEDUCATED, and UNHYGIENIC. Our air is polluted. We indians worship cows and they re our mother ❤️ sometimes we beg for wheat 🌾 and rice 🍚 because we too broke 😭 we try to STOP SCAMMING INNOCENT PEOPLE AND proud to be indian JAI HINDI ❤️ ❤️ ❤️
It is a tricky question because you don't choose the alone tied person but when you are the surgent you have to choose the person you will kill to save the other 5
Apparently, some people choose not to pull the lever because the train would go past the path it was originally on: which means you were literally uninvolved in the situation, because you did nothing.
Thats not how it works 💀4 people would get ko because of you Thats same logic as jumping out of car and say its not your fault because you wasnt in there when it happened
@@BlitzBrawler its not the same lol, for the first one, they were gonna get hit anyway, you just happened to be there, but the one guy wasn't, so he has nothing to do with the situation, why kill him
AS AN INDIAN I CAN CONFIRM THAT WHENEVER WE TOUCH THE POOL 🌊 OUR BROWN DEAD SKIN FLOATS ON DA WATER MAKING DA WATER BROWN 🖐🏾 SO SORRY GUYS BUT ARE WE LEARNING HOW TO GET USE TO HYGIENE IT TAKES TIME OK? ❤️🇮🇳🇮🇳❤️ please spread love💕
truly a "a villain would save you over the entire world meanwhile a hero would sacrifice you for the entire world over you"moment Edit: HOW IS THIS SO FAMOUS??!!? Edit2: Our next goal is 20K likes!
@@Kerttissome are, mostly ones you can live without like a kidney I think? Like those 2 same organs we have, you can live with only one, you can also remove something else but I forgor
Answering philosophical questions with some legal concepts helps a lot. So when you try to save 5 over 1 in a railway track, you can use the defence of necessity to escape any punishment. But in case of doctor killing one to save five is considered, he would be guilty of murder. This is with regards to principle set down in R vs. Dudley & Stephens where few persons stranded on a island killed and ate a boy for themselves to stay alive. The Court held they were guilty of murder and stated that even in life-threatening situations, one cannot take the life of another by saving their own. This principle is applicable to doctor's case where the doctor could have sacrificed his own organs to save the five, but chose to kill a person by saving his own. Thus he committed murder. But incase of the railway incident, the person is not guilty because he had no option but to make a choice, and chose 5 people over 1 by applying the utilitarian principle. He didn't choose his life over others and the principle in R vs. Dudley & Stephens does not apply.
This would still be murder, because the train track was in the direction of the five. Its was not an option. He decided to intervene willingly. He purposely made the train pass over someone who wouldn't be killed by it. He was not forced to make a choice as you are trying to state here, there was no "necessity". Its muder.
It doesn't justify it however it does reduce the guilt you might feel but in the end it's never easy knowing that someone had to die in order to save other.
@@sezuin_6577Actually no, you're legally culpable for the act that lead to death as soon as you touch the lever. You aren't rewarded for the ones you saved, that's separate.
Huh? The villain will put your loved one vs the world. Lol. He isn't saving anyone! So many don't even understand who the villain is and keep repeating the quote like robot.
Some people have who are more inclined to deontological ethics. Though the problem is flawed at providing indefinite answers given that it is too unusual for a scenario that can be applied to other scenarios, hence why most opt for the utilitarian choice.
@@tentaclesmod Fair enough but I guess he already was aware of death. And in this case it's not only you but also the driver, the train, the railways, the maniac that kidnapped him, the lever killing.
@@dragonplay2069 In any case the trolley problem is always meant to be metaphorical, it's something that has never happened in the story of humanity. And probably never will. Meanwhile the organs thing is exactly the kind of scenario that the trolley is a metaphor for. Of course, you could discuss the broader implications, for example, you kill a guy and use his organs to save 5 people (and probably improve the lives of a dozen more, since there are non-vital organs that can be donated too, like corneas) but besides killing a guy, you also completely destroy trust in hospitals because, did they kill a guy that came for a different, minor ailment?
Well we're comparing between one person who isn't free and is tied down and one who is completely free. The train is unstoppable. We are stoppable. That's why the doctor dilemma feels wrong and the train dilemma feels more morally justifiable.
You are not entirely correct tho. If the trolley is an unstoppable force, so is death that awaits 5 patients. You as a surgeon aren't really the one harming the 5 people tho, so that's probably why the trolley problem feels different 😅
That's the altered version of the trolley problem. Most people would choose to save the many at the expense of the few, so they make it more complicated by adding selfishness into it. It's a bit more of a 50/50 chance now, but I think most people would just let those 5 die.
The two situations are incomparable. In the train situation you weren’t the one that tied the people there, you’re simply an observer. Whereas in the surgeon situation, you yourself will be the direct reason for taking a perfectly healthy person’s life.
Well said. In the train situation the story in news articles will be that you saved 5 lives. In the surgeon situation, he will be arrested for taking one life. Very incomparable situations. Although in the current world, people will not make any decision on the train tracks to save the five people because they will be scared that they may be charged with murder of the other person.
@@RK99uh huh yeah sure "saved 5 people" so fuxk that other guy that would have lived if you weren't there ? You people try to come out as kind but then completely ignore the innocent person that died because of you lmfao
the point of this thought experiment is not to make the right choice, but rather to avoid getting into similar situations where difficult moral decisions need to be made
How to save both: if the train is still far away, pull the lever and run towards the one guy and try to untie him or atleast pull him away from the tracks I know that this is a methaphorical question but this way of sloving problems can work on different things too
@Didriksen.Bro that 1 guy need to have an heart transplant, if they share they organ how the heck is they gonna live if they change they hearts with dying hearts.
I would pull the lever to 1 person and the that person will lay down under the train to the lowest part in between the train track and the train and that person will survive and the 5 people
Yeah but then dilema also shifts. Will you save 5 people on the tracks and doom the 5 that need an organ transplant that the 1 guy on the train could provide, or would you do the opposite
@@thenitpickchannel9993your question isn’t shifting tho, if you save the 5 people then the one would die- giving the 5 people their organs (in this situation supposedly- in real life most or all the organs would not be able to be saved)
The thing is, if you pull the leather that means you’re responsible for a murder but if you don’t pull the lever and just walk away, technically you cannot be charged with anything since you were not involved in the deaths
It's more unsettling when the people look like actual people who are struggling and probably begging for their life.
more better
Ban gya cool
It is, isn't it. The truth hurts
AS AN INDIAN, SORRY FOR OUR EXPIRED CURRY SCENTED BO 😭 WE ARE WORKING HARD TO SHOWER EVERYDAY AND USE DEODORANT ❤️❤️❤
W pfp
Until yesterday, Zack answered unwanted questions. Now he wants answers👀💀
💀💀💀
Yeap 💀😱
true
Subscribe
To me
If I pull the lever that makes me a murderer, if I don't.
That makes me a witness
But then you're guilty that means you are the murder
How so the train killed them not you?
So If I saw someone drowning and do nothing you are murder? If you have no duty to protect those people then you shouldn’t do anything and leave to the professionals
its better pretending you seen nothing than getting involved on something you don't wanna be in
@@Can0nically7 wonder if you keep the same energy when you need help from a stranger
I agree with you 😎😎
Imagine surviving being tied to a train track, just for your organs to be harvested
😂
A: Do nothing
B: Pull the lever
C: Defy physics
C
@@nevetesmestere657 NPC ahh comment
What that not a option lol
C
C
I remember watching a short video from a lawyer, which basically said that you have no right to deprive other people of their lives. If you don't pull the lever, then it is the railway department's responsibility, but if you pull the lever, then it becomes your responsibility.
Is it law by mike
Jailed if you do, traumatised if you don’t 😭
@@divyamohan_ it’s a canon event. I’m not gonna sacrifice anyone to save 5 people.
@@redfatseal2407that’s still 4 lives on your hands
AS AN INDIAN, SORRY FOR OUR EXPIRED CURRY SCENTED BO 😭 WE ARE WORKING HARD TO SHOWER EVERYDAY AND USE DEODORANT ❤️❤️❤
You know it's crazy when Zack starts questioning us 💀
FR💀
To everyone in this chat, Jesus is calling you today. Come to him, repent from your sins, bear his cross and live the victorious life;
A fatherless and motherless UTTP and bot will spam this comment I can already predict it
@@JesusPlsSaveMelook I am a Jesus sopporter but how else tehn dying can I go to him look I don’t want to die
@@elenagacha-lk3kgYou don't need to die. Repent and turn away from your sins. Cultivate a relationship with God and believe that God raised him from the dead as a mediator and atonement for our sins.
Colossians 3.
1. If ye then be risen with Christ, seek those things which are above where Christ sitteth on the right hand of God.
2. Set your affection on the things which are above and not on things which are on the earth.
3. For ye are dead and your life is hid with Christ in God.
4. When Christ, which is our life shall appear, so shall ye also appear with him in Glory.
********
Jesus is calling you today. Come to him, repent from your sins, bear his cross and live the victorious life
********
Romans 10:9-13
That if thou shalt confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus, and shalt believe in thine heart that God hath raised him from the dead, thou shalt be saved.
For with the heart man believeth unto righteousness; and with the mouth confession is made unto salvation.
For the scripture saith, Whosoever believeth on him shall not be ashamed.
For there is no difference between the Jew and the Greek: for the same Lord over all is rich unto all that call upon him.
For whosoever shall call upon the name of the Lord shall be saved.
Hebrews 12:14
Follow peace with all men, and holiness, without which no man shall see the Lord:
Matthew 5:3-12 Blessed are the poor in spirit: for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.
Blessed are they that mourn: for they shall be comforted.
Blessed are the meek: for they shall inherit the earth.
Blessed are they which do hunger and thirst after righteousness: for they shall be filled.
Blessed are the merciful: for they shall obtain mercy.
Blessed are the pure in heart: for they shall see God.
Blessed are the peacemakers: for they shall be called the children of God.
Blessed are they which are persecuted for righteousness sake: for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.
Blessed are ye, when men shall revile you, and persecute you, and shall say all manner of evil against you falsely, for my sake.
Rejoice, and be exceeding glad: for great is your reward in heaven: for so persecuted they the prophets which were before you.
FOR THOSE WHO ARE TIRED OF THEIR SINS AND ARE READY TO ACCEPT JESUS INTO THEIR LIFE, KINDLY SAY THIS PRAYER:
Psalms 51.
Have mercy upon me, O God, according to thy lovingkindness: according unto the multitude of thy tender mercies blot out my transgressions.
Wash me throughly from mine iniquity, and cleanse me from my sin.
For I acknowledge my transgressions: and my sin is ever before me.
Against thee, thee only, have I sinned, and done this evil in thy sight: that thou mightest be justified when thou speakest, and be clear when thou judgest.
Behold, I was shapen in iniquity; and in sin did my mother conceive me.
Behold, thou desirest truth in the inward parts: and in the hidden part thou shalt make me to know wisdom.
Purge me with hyssop, and I shall be clean: wash me, and I shall be whiter than snow.
Make me to hear joy and gladness; that the bones which thou hast broken may rejoice.
Hide thy face from my sins, and blot out all mine iniquities.
Create in me a clean heart, O God; and renew a right spirit within me.
Cast me not away from thy presence; and take not thy holy spirit from me.
Restore unto me the joy of thy salvation; and uphold me with thy free spirit.
Then will I teach transgressors thy ways; and sinners shall be converted unto thee.
Deliver me from bloodguiltiness, O God, thou God of my salvation: and my tongue shall sing aloud of thy righteousness.
O Lord, open thou my lips; and my mouth shall shew forth thy praise.
For thou desirest not sacrifice; else would I give it: thou delightest not in burnt offering.
The sacrifices of God are a broken spirit: a broken and a contrite heart, O God, thou wilt not despise.
Do good in thy good pleasure unto Zion: build thou the walls of Jerusalem.
Then shalt thou be pleased with the sacrifices of righteousness, with burnt offering and whole burnt offering: then shall they offer bullocks upon thine altar.
Killing 5 just to fix 5 people who are already dying is dumb. The trolley problem gets more difficult if that one person is a loved one/relative.
"huh? wha- THAT'S NOT AN OPTION" 💀
@KevYesandZackNo*takes your lungs and stomach*
@JolasBobas-jn3ui ok shut up bot
The bots again
PLS I NEED SOME TIME TO GIVE PROTECTION TO UTTP😭
Tutututututu huh? wha- that's not an option?!?
Actually Zack, Vsauce did an experiment and found that most people end up hesitating for too long. Very few end up actually doing this in reality
How the hell did he do that experiment 😳😳
Commenting because I need answers for this
@@theweirdwolf1877 @bruhmoment6789 vsauce trolley problem RUclips. Amazing video
I watched that video!
@@theweirdwolf1877 he made a fake train conductor station with videos of workers on the tracks. The videos were edited and ended right before the train hit so noone was harmed
Collab with Zack: 😊
Collab with Zack:💀
Does anyone want to play Gacha life with me
A reply bot has been detected on this comment, please ignore it and report it. Don't interact with the bot it feeds off your attention! 50665
@MatPatQuitLOL 0 subs ofc
Holy the Bots have taken over you
Anti bot here
but is saving 1 life justifying sacrificing 5 ?
Zack in physics: 🙂
Zack in biology: ☠️
Zack in philosophy: 🧐🤔
Your so original 🤯
*Philosophy
Overused and not funny
@@TheSmileyGeneral Ion know abt that
@@fabiancortez6062you're*
I would investigate whoever tf tied those 6 people to the railway, that's the real culprit.
Yea but you're missing the point.
@@daleputnam8300/r whoosh
@@space.banana_ais that pfp gay
@@Vangel-jt6io ye
I would not pull the lever.
First of all, its not the guys fault he is alone.
Second, I could be prosecuted with man slaughter.
Third, the people on the track are together, so they would have some connection to each other. It would be cruel to make someone die alone just because of their unfortunate circumstances.
Bro got kidnapped for an organ transplant💀😭🙏
Chainor
AS AN INDIAN, SORRY FOR OUR EXPIRED CURRY SCENTED BO 😭 WE ARE WORKING HARD TO SHOWER EVERYDAY AND USE DEODORANT ❤️❤️❤
WE INDIANS ARE BROWN AND HAVE A RED DOT ON FOREHEAD. MOST OF US ARE POOR, UNEDUCATED, and UNHYGIENIC. Our air is polluted. We indians worship cows and they re our mother ❤️ sometimes we beg for wheat 🌾 and rice 🍚 because we too broke 😭 we try to STOP SCAMMING INNOCENT PEOPLE AND proud to be indian JAI HINDI ❤️ ❤️ ❤️
@@zebra2662wtff
That does happen lol
It is a tricky question because you don't choose the alone tied person but when you are the surgent you have to choose the person you will kill to save the other 5
Guy: Let's goo I'm untied
Surgeon: Yeah now come with me
😂
😂😂😂
AS AN INDIAN, SORRY FOR OUR EXPIRED CURRY SCENTED BO 😭 WE ARE WORKING HARD TO SHOWER EVERYDAY AND USE DEODORANT ❤️❤️❤❤❤
So glad someone talked about it.
😂😂
Apparently, some people choose not to pull the lever because the train would go past the path it was originally on: which means you were literally uninvolved in the situation, because you did nothing.
Yeah that's what I also thought
People will still blame you for doing nothing
@@paldennorbu8808 who care. Its people habit to bark 🐶
Exactly
Those five people look high asf 😂😂
Like Wraith said “I’d rather not sleep thinking about the one life I took instead of the ones I couldn’t save”
That quote in spiderman 2 went hard
But you could have saved them . .
@@DEADBEATONLY real
@@UnBeAtabLe9735 that’s the thing, you never know if you could in the end. So do the choice you will regret the least
@-RadioGlitch- yuri is such a cold character. The spiderman 1 dlc really changed her.
You actually saved 10 lives. 5 from train and 5 in the hospital.
Credit goes to the guy who was involuntarily tied down.
I think people tend to forget that it counts as murder if they pull the lever
But it counts as negligence if you dont
@@SuchDarkness would you rather be charged in court for negligence or murder?
@@rowlanddavid1576murder rather be inprison knowing i saved 5 people
@@SuchDarknesstf they gon charge you with last time I checked you ain't in the train
this is the problem with the american government
Plot twist:
All the 5 need the same organ transplant
😂😂😂
Real
Shitty ass plot twist
He said everyone needs a different organ
Fr
Step 1 - Pull the lever
Step 2 - Run to the guy
Step 3 - Take him out of the track
Ok Flash
@@Bruno-ry3pg just run, the time you have to think you can use to run.
@@Teguemy Yeah... that is what I was thinking and that is what I would do.😊
But make sure to run faster than the train💀
@@Bruno-ry3pg You can pull the lever before the train can get to the turn
Dawg why am I out here questioning my morality 😭
the single guy only has his arms tied. he just needs to lay down, cross his legs, stand up and walk away
Issa moral quandary
He's tied down to the sides of the track
Does that work if you need an organ transplant? Asking for a friend
AS AN INDIAN, SORRY FOR OUR EXPIRED CURRY SCENTED BO 😭 WE ARE WORKING HARD TO SHOWER EVERYDAY AND USE DEODORANT ❤️❤️❤
@@zebra2662WOAH WHAT
Zack started playing with our emotional intelligence.
it's not emotional intelligence, it's just a trick question that have correct answer(s).
But 5 people with that logic can save 25 people
Ooohhh love this comment mind blown
Yes
500iq moves
10 people
But there’s the possibility it’s not, he said that the one has healthy organs, as if the others didn’t.
Sadmar’s answer:
Change the lever 0.01 seconds before it arrives, this would not harm people (forget about the train pilot)
Do nothing = 0 kills
Pull the lever = 1 kill
1 Kill = 5 Saved
@@sewitscherhd5493let fate decide = 0 kills, 0 saved
@@sewitscherhd5493Touch lever = Law suit
Thats not how it works 💀4 people would get ko because of you
Thats same logic as jumping out of car and say its not your fault because you wasnt in there when it happened
@@BlitzBrawler its not the same lol, for the first one, they were gonna get hit anyway, you just happened to be there, but the one guy wasn't, so he has nothing to do with the situation, why kill him
Zack went from coming up with the most random questions to giving us riddles.💀💀
AS AN INDIAN, SORRY FOR OUR EXPIRED CURRY SCENTED BO 😭 WE ARE WORKING HARD TO SHOWER EVERYDAY AND USE DEODORANT ❤️❤️❤❤❤
@@zebra2662nah ur good
@@zebra2662??
Shut up@@zebra2662
@@zebra2662wtf😭😭
Bro was backstabbed, dissected, and donated 💀
Flip the lever so thw trajn goes between the 2 tracks, then u saved 6 lives
Person: "I LIVE!!"
Surgeon: *"nuh uh"*
Bfb profiley
Osc fan detected. Sub given.
AS AN INDIAN I CAN CONFIRM THAT WHENEVER WE TOUCH THE POOL 🌊 OUR BROWN DEAD SKIN FLOATS ON DA WATER MAKING DA WATER BROWN 🖐🏾 SO SORRY GUYS BUT ARE WE LEARNING HOW TO GET USE TO HYGIENE IT TAKES TIME OK? ❤️🇮🇳🇮🇳❤️ please spread love💕
truly a "a villain would save you over the entire world meanwhile a hero would sacrifice you for the entire world over you"moment
Edit: HOW IS THIS SO FAMOUS??!!?
Edit2: Our next goal is 20K likes!
don’t mind this guy he’s a scammer just move along
Would you like to play Gacha life with me
😅
Kiritsugu moment
@JolasBobas-jn3ui Bro's spamming so hard that he forgot the spam
Dang Zack went from torturing his characters to straight up murdering them 😭
Leave no witness.
We must be glad we aren’t the characters
1
True 😢
No Zack didn't do it someone else did it
I would probably choose to break the laws of physics 👍
That surgeon example was actually so much better than the usual “if there was a really, really fat guy; would you push him in front of the train”
😂😂The fat guy would take the blow from the train
its such a stupid example, organs arent gathered from people who are alive lmfao
@@Kerttissome are, mostly ones you can live without like a kidney I think? Like those 2 same organs we have, you can live with only one, you can also remove something else but I forgor
@@Sam-kz5sxLiterally just kidney and bone marrow. Everything showed here like the liver or the heart are only donated from already dead people
@@mal5620 And liver. Just a part of the liver is enough for transplantation. Then it grows back.
all fun and games until that one person is you
True
be the one pulling the lever or the power to control the one pulling the lever
I would’ve really matter if I were that one person
Nah I'd win
If u save 5 people we can donate oragans to 25 people
Was this information necessary ?
*NO*
Is he considering us psychopaths ?
*YES*
PLS GIVE ME TIME
These bots are saying drake stuff💀💀
The bot is so fast. Bro sit there all day just waiting for zack to post vids😂
@@SamStickmanbro just work and the get subs urself
Bruh is filosophy dog wth do u mean psyctopaths💀💀💀
They can just ran away because the rope is not tied in their feet😂
That doc snatched him like it was a bag of money hidden away that he found💀💀
Huh No Comments?
@UTTPGOD-c9dbro’s looking down the barrel of the ban hammer gun
A reply bot has been detected on this comment, report it and ignore it. Don’t reply to the bot as the bot feeds on your attention! 666
Technically everyone is a bag of money waiting to be "harvested".
OH NO NOT THE MEME
Answering philosophical questions with some legal concepts helps a lot. So when you try to save 5 over 1 in a railway track, you can use the defence of necessity to escape any punishment. But in case of doctor killing one to save five is considered, he would be guilty of murder. This is with regards to principle set down in R vs. Dudley & Stephens where few persons stranded on a island killed and ate a boy for themselves to stay alive. The Court held they were guilty of murder and stated that even in life-threatening situations, one cannot take the life of another by saving their own.
This principle is applicable to doctor's case where the doctor could have sacrificed his own organs to save the five, but chose to kill a person by saving his own. Thus he committed murder.
But incase of the railway incident, the person is not guilty because he had no option but to make a choice, and chose 5 people over 1 by applying the utilitarian principle. He didn't choose his life over others and the principle in R vs. Dudley & Stephens does not apply.
Oh wow
Bro are you a lawyer?
Btw thanks for the logical reasoning and explaining
@@WitheredCookie Not yet bro, but I'm still a law student ✌️✌️
@@prathamkumar2k4 Good luck with that!
This would still be murder, because the train track was in the direction of the five. Its was not an option. He decided to intervene willingly. He purposely made the train pass over someone who wouldn't be killed by it. He was not forced to make a choice as you are trying to state here, there was no "necessity". Its muder.
It doesn't justify it however it does reduce the guilt you might feel but in the end it's never easy knowing that someone had to die in order to save other.
You'd feel guilt either way, for instance if you don't intervene to save more people
@@anhsu4854 nah
@@rohanking12ableyes you do. If you don't, yiu should check that out, because thats not normal.
It doesn't justify it, but in this case you're an innocent bystander who stepped up and saved 5 lives.
@@sezuin_6577Actually no, you're legally culpable for the act that lead to death as soon as you touch the lever. You aren't rewarded for the ones you saved, that's separate.
The better option is breaking physics
bro came up from traumatizing kids, telling random questions, torturing his test subjects to asking questions 💀
AS AN INDIAN, SORRY FOR OUR EXPIRED CURRY SCENTED BO 😭 WE ARE WORKING HARD TO SHOWER EVERYDAY AND USE DEODORANT ❤️❤️❤💕
AS AN INDIAN, SORRY FOR OUR EXPIRED CURRY SCENTED BO 😭 WE ARE WORKING HARD TO SHOWER EVERYDAY AND USE DEODORANT ❤️❤️❤
Fr Tho😭😭💀💀
(Also you can ignore the bots lol)
wow there is no bots guys it's safe!
@@Qoothy idc fr
Everyone is gangsta until that person is you😅😅
Then how will u pull the lever
What he mean is you are the tied up person and another guy the one that pull the lever,now of course you will beg for life @@mayanksinha7029
Why is everyone gangsta 🤔
Tf you think the one who is deciding the lever pull gonna do? Hop on the track and do a spiderman😭
@@jayrenhills52 it's just a joke kid don't be serious
Zack was definitely high during this
Fr
High zack still questioning our realities
The science joint hits too hard😔
This question would be much harder to decide upon if you added that the 1 person is a family member/best friend
Paired organs: 🙂
Unpaired organs :👁👄👁
well, I have a solution to that... try to put some sort of code such as 0000 or 1234, it usually works for pairing...
Would you like to play gacha life with me?
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
it's like heroes saving the world in cost of their love one's life while the villain will sacrifice the world to their love one
Huh? The villain will put your loved one vs the world. Lol.
He isn't saving anyone! So many don't even understand who the villain is and keep repeating the quote like robot.
@Didriksen. one of them needed lungs and another needed a heart you cant survive without a heart or lungs
@@Vor567tezyou didn't understand the comment.
What if i don't know any of them?
u got it switched up. The villian is the one who sacrifices the loved one and the hero is the one that sacrifices the world
It's actually wild, I bet most of the people never even considered about that one life.
Some people have who are more inclined to deontological ethics. Though the problem is flawed at providing indefinite answers given that it is too unusual for a scenario that can be applied to other scenarios, hence why most opt for the utilitarian choice.
I'll probably choose the one guy.
@@BubbleyiesRileynah im gonna chose 6 of them
@@Totallynotnormalguy that's one way too, but those 5 are kinda annoying looking so I'm going to save that one.
Just fly with the trial😎😎
Step one... dont pull the lever.
Step two... bring the one man and join him with the other 5...
Step three... watch.
Bro’s starting his jigsaw arc
Fr this guy its really scary
“I missed the part where that’s my problem”🚶🏾♂️
In the 2nd case the person wasn't aware of giving his organs. In the first case, he is already in danger.
i feel very bad for the second man in both cases
Literally he wasn't in a danger if you didn't interact and pulled the liver
Actually, he wasn't, at that's the point. He will be fine unless you pull the lever.
@@tentaclesmod Fair enough but I guess he already was aware of death. And in this case it's not only you but also the driver, the train, the railways, the maniac that kidnapped him, the lever killing.
@@dragonplay2069 In any case the trolley problem is always meant to be metaphorical, it's something that has never happened in the story of humanity. And probably never will. Meanwhile the organs thing is exactly the kind of scenario that the trolley is a metaphor for. Of course, you could discuss the broader implications, for example, you kill a guy and use his organs to save 5 people (and probably improve the lives of a dozen more, since there are non-vital organs that can be donated too, like corneas) but besides killing a guy, you also completely destroy trust in hospitals because, did they kill a guy that came for a different, minor ailment?
Does saving 1 life justify taking 5 lives😂😂
"What is the cause of your death?"
"I volunteered zack's short!"
Haha underrated comment 😂
real
how do you ask someone how they died
@@bethjensen7549no no, its when they go to heaven/hell
Bros making me rethink my life at 1:00am💀
Real
The way the surgeon just kidnapped him 💀
Edit: HOW DID I GET 1K LIKES IN 1 DAY?!?!
Option 3: drift
its the same way zach kidnaps his victims
"woohoo-" a few frames later shows him dead 💀
1
@@ZiggyKeffel ?
The biggest problem is that if you intervene you are to blame for the situation.
*denys the physics and flys the train to mars*
“Wh- tha- THATS NOT AN OPTION
Ya
Poor guy
He went from "yay i survived" to "how the heck did did the doc take me"😂
Well we're comparing between one person who isn't free and is tied down and one who is completely free. The train is unstoppable. We are stoppable. That's why the doctor dilemma feels wrong and the train dilemma feels more morally justifiable.
Would you like to play Gacha life with me
Poor guy💀
Imagine having a reply section filled with bots💀
ANYWAY WHO ASKED + MY CONTENT IS WAY BETTER
(Joke cuz it’s not)
@@kevnLreemsjbro whay
You are not entirely correct tho. If the trolley is an unstoppable force, so is death that awaits 5 patients. You as a surgeon aren't really the one harming the 5 people tho, so that's probably why the trolley problem feels different 😅
Sad to see only 3 human replies, RUclips really needs to do something about these bots
The trolley who choose the lifetime human😔
Bro the surgeon looks like he kidnapped the one tied down (Edit: Wait this is the first time with so many likes on my comment no way!)
Wait... *(Brain Processing Sounds)* Huh???
no shit
He did
😂😂😂
Ruined it with the edit
damn, we're asked to be a psychopath now? that's really traumatizing, Zack 💀
Negus
A reply bot has been detected on this comment, please ignore it and report it. Don't interact with the bot it feeds off your attention! 63898
Would you like to play Gacha life with me
BRO THESE BOTS
If you save 5 people thats 25 patients
If you ask yourself, "I'm healthy, would I give up my life to save 5 complete strangers?". I think you will have your answer.
Not quite right. Yourself would make a self serving decision, obviously.
This question makes it more objective as you're not involved
Counterpoint: That's a pretty cool way to go out, wouldn't really mind.
@@tegathemenace That’s just not true though, no perfectly healthy person is about give up their life to save 5 other people.
I would not or do that to any other person and I don’t think the two situations are thesame
It depends, i qould give up my life, but some ofher people wouldn't
The only difference from the two scenarios is that the one guy is healthy while the other 5 are already dying
Plot twist: The person at the right IS the surgeon
They be fricked
So what that mean?
@@abdulhamiddauda2204 that the surgeon would be dead and no one would be saved
ruclips.net/video/kBdfcR-8hEY/видео.htmlsi=aYFj-3jjEnxbrBPF
Camera man just watching and filming like “yea that’s a real pickle”
💀😭
If its 5 blacks yeah u know the answer
@@VGODPracist
The way the surgeon snatched the person 😭
💀💀💀 I just realised there was a little fading "ahh..."
Most people: pulling the lever
Me: pulling the lever and once the locomotive passes pull it again to derail the train
It also gets worse if the five persons are strangers and the one person is your family member.
it actually gets easier
@@jazzxgrayoh ye thats tru
Five people 😊 that's my choose I ain't changing it
depending on the person i might save 5 lives
That's the altered version of the trolley problem. Most people would choose to save the many at the expense of the few, so they make it more complicated by adding selfishness into it. It's a bit more of a 50/50 chance now, but I think most people would just let those 5 die.
it depends if you can do something about it other than pulling the lever
I've realized that over 6 months of watching Zack, his content has slowly and scarily gotten more sadistic. And im all here for it.
I gonna reply before the bot does.
@@anandareisya2396 i don't think the bots will appear
@@anandareisya2396like you
im calling the auttp
ok
Bro its so easy. Just become a SPIDER MAN
Internet isn't ready to see Zack asking instead of answering
The two situations are incomparable. In the train situation you weren’t the one that tied the people there, you’re simply an observer. Whereas in the surgeon situation, you yourself will be the direct reason for taking a perfectly healthy person’s life.
Well said. In the train situation the story in news articles will be that you saved 5 lives. In the surgeon situation, he will be arrested for taking one life. Very incomparable situations. Although in the current world, people will not make any decision on the train tracks to save the five people because they will be scared that they may be charged with murder of the other person.
@@RK99uh huh yeah sure "saved 5 people" so fuxk that other guy that would have lived if you weren't there ? You people try to come out as kind but then completely ignore the innocent person that died because of you lmfao
Yeah like this one dude is just a sacrifice it's disgusting how people think@@ΣπυροςΣτεφανιδης-δ3θ
@@ΣπυροςΣτεφανιδης-δ3θ bro u deserves to rule the world with such common sense
@@ΣπυροςΣτεφανιδης-δ3θ calm down, no need to get worked up for no reason
the way the surgeon pulled the guy help 😭😭😭
He only helped him, to save his 5 patients 💀
500 likes and one replie lemme fix that
he snatched him😭
ruclips.net/video/kBdfcR-8hEY/видео.htmlsi=aYFj-3jjEnxbrBPF
yoink
the point of this thought experiment is not to make the right choice, but rather to avoid getting into similar situations where difficult moral decisions need to be made
Bro is starting his villian arc 💀💀
"How did you die?"
"Zack took away my orgians to save five ppl for a video"
Lol
Starts like a mrbeast video, ends like a psychological conflict
Nevermind this reply.
Nevermind this reply.
Nevermind this reply.
Nevermind this reply.
How to save both: if the train is still far away, pull the lever and run towards the one guy and try to untie him or atleast pull him away from the tracks
I know that this is a methaphorical question but this way of sloving problems can work on different things too
Now, if Zack started doing these things in real life we're all doomed 💀💀💀
😅
@Didriksen.what if 1 needs a heart
@Didriksen. That would be like
Fixing a problem by introducing a new problem.
*pulls the lever halfway so it goes to the middle instead* “wha- NO YOU CANT DO THAT!”
That’s not possible pal hope this helps
@@Unclebumba-Lki89o🛩🛩🛩🛫👤🛬damn that flew past you pretty quick
@@Unclebumba-Lki89o it is it will just derail the train
@Didriksen.Bro that 1 guy need to have an heart transplant, if they share they organ how the heck is they gonna live if they change they hearts with dying hearts.
It's not possible to pull the lever in the middle but if you manage to do it the train just gonna crash killing both of them.
Plot twist: the 5 people in the hospital were all hit by a train and injured, and the healthy person is the other guy
😂😂
Wait I think u just solved it😮😮😂😂
@@FireWaLL_MiKEYIk fr
😂😂😂
Just simply untie the 1 person and then pull the lever 💀
Train starts flying up “THATS NOT A OPTION”
Stolen comment
*dying*I WAS THINK ABOUT THAT
*freebird starts playing*
me too@@darkfire3086
@@TheNumber1OnePieceFan bro you commented new fear unlocked on a vid you can't talk.
Zack is asking questions which we can't answer💀
@KaiYFGA-g4vstop yapping
who ordered a yappicuno
Report him also his account was only created an hour ago
😂😂
A reply bot has been detected on this comment, report it and ignore it. Don’t reply to the bot as the bot feeds on your attention! 666
Everyone: pulls the lever to save 5 people for one
Me: balances lever in the middle for train to go off track
With that logic you will kill all the people in the train as it leads to a major train accident if it goes off the track.
😂😂😂😂
Everyone on the train : ☠️☠️☠️
@@stvrfishthe train would most likely stop due to lack of friction, or tip over I really don’t know 😭
I would pull the lever to 1 person and the that person will lay down under the train to the lowest part in between the train track and the train and that person will survive and the 5 people
Id call my buddy phil he always knows what to do
I’d run straight to the other direction to avoid the possible drama and lawsuits heading my way
It is all confusing and mysteries until you realise that the other person dies anyway, whether by donating organs, or by the train 😂
RUclips
Yeah but then dilema also shifts. Will you save 5 people on the tracks and doom the 5 that need an organ transplant that the 1 guy on the train could provide, or would you do the opposite
Youre right😂
@@thenitpickchannel9993your question isn’t shifting tho, if you save the 5 people then the one would die- giving the 5 people their organs (in this situation supposedly- in real life most or all the organs would not be able to be saved)
Those dying patients were gonna get their organs but someone had to pull a lever
The thing is, if you pull the leather that means you’re responsible for a murder but if you don’t pull the lever and just walk away, technically you cannot be charged with anything since you were not involved in the deaths
The way the surgeon snatched the guy on the railroad 😂
Damn Got A Bot Just Like Crowding In Here.
Bruh these bots 😩
Free relastate ahh surgeon 😭
RUclips really needs a moderation overhaul.
Lil bro will a human sacrifice. A hero
Nah the way the surgeon grabbed him like he was about to do a tight bear hug like mark henry the wwe wrestler 💀
It really depends who they are. Some humans are worth more than others.