Palestinian civilians were also involved in the October 7th atrocities. I heard of women who went to loot houses while their men were committing the atrocities, and of children who watched these men and laughed. There are no innocent civilians in Gaza. How can there be, when they were taught the Hamas creed from the cradle? I haven't got a grain of sympathy for any of them.
I agree 👍💯. Stop sending theses Hamas supporters and murders our taxpayers federal aid money .we have been things toe do with our federal aid money like helping actually refugees 😮
I agree. After Oct 7th any sympathy I had for Palestinians as humans is gone. They have ruined the little support they had because of their obvious hate and ambition to commit genocide on the Jews. They made their bed. Enough of their excuses and lies. Learn to live like civilized people or face the consequences.
Jihadis are snakes hiding in the grass, and "moderat" Mmuslims are the blades of grass. When the grass grows taller, the snakes larger, their bites more fatal,, ,, one must be responsible, and mow the lawn. Islame has no right to exist, nor do those defending that pedo-ideology.
They didn’t learn from the last, how many was it? Around 6 wars they started and lost for the past 76 years. They are radical and strive from hatred, nothing is going to change that unfortunately.
Hoping this is their "Wounded Knee Battle of 1890" moment. After 100 years of war, the Native American never attempted violent resistance against the US Gov't ever again!
I don’t have any hope for them, nor do I have any sympathy for their self built “suffering”. They started 6-7 wars and lost all of them only to commit October 7th. They won’t learn because Islam is a cult of hatred and death, they thrive off others suffering.
@@GilbertdeClare0704 It will need to be explained explicitly because the other side will only use it to recruit new "soldiers". Also it needs to be defunded. Something, whether it is an organisation, company or ideology will maintain and grow if it makes money.
But all Muslims do not stand up for each other. The Muslims of Gaza are Sunni Muslim. Most of the Muslims here in the West support them because they are also Sunni. What about the Uighurs in China who are being tortured and held in concentration camps. They are also Muslims but not Sunnis, so who cares. Not the other Muslims.
I'm a non jew from America/ and I watched the interview of Oct 7 hostage MIA SCHEM/ she said she kept in a family's home/ watch her interview/ even the children were cruel to her in this household
I watched that interview of Mia Shem and remember her saying there are no innocent civilians in Gaza. I don't understand why the mainstream media can't see this.
@@HaleyMary it's obvious that mainstream media pick a side and their news and opinions are bias to one side/in my opinion and (I'm a non Jewish American )who ever sides with gaza Palestinian hate the Jewish people as the Germans who followed Hitler.the oct 7th events were horrific and if one has a good heart and has daughters, sons ,beloved ones how can you side with gaza/Palestine like these college youth in those ridiculous encampments,and celebrities like that actress Susan sarandon who boldly say no women were raped & killed no babies killed on Oct 7th ,to see the viral videos of shani louk's lifeless broken body being taken into gaza with those monsters sitting on her corpse, then young boys spitting and beating her dead body showed me what those people are and that anyone in media can defend that nation,it's insanity. I'm disgusted when I see these jew hating protesters.
You guys are crazy - you think it's so "cruel" that a child didn't offer her candy??? Have you seen what the fuck the israeli "defence" forces have done to Palestinian children??? If you are SO simple minded as to think that children not sharing candy means that they are "evil" and "not innocent" whatsoever, I think it's time for you to get off your phone and go outside, luv.
I do know what you say is true. Except I recognise the spiritual war behind the conflict I would find the current madness in the Western world incomprehensible. May the Lord preserve Israel.
There is no such legal statehood or country named Palatine 😅. and there is no such ethic groups of people call palatineins 😆. There people are Arafat's Arabs mulsins who migrated from Jordan and Egypt and Sylvia during WWI and WWII to work in Jordan. They are merely squatters on the legal country of Israel 😅
Hamas are palestins and palestins are Hamas so if you want to survive, don’t keep hostages in your house when people support the Palestinians and say they’re poor. It’s not their fault. I disagree. They are all as bad as each other. Why don’t their neighbors help them because they know how bad these people are. 🇬🇧🇮🇱✌️
There’s a channel owner called Corey Gil-Shuster who interviews Pals. Listen to their own words and you quickly learn that the women and children are complicit in their hateful intentions.
listen to "Palestinian Christians: Why did many Christians leave Palestine?", listen to the fear in their voices, look at the the flickering eyes as they tell a lie to stay safe in a society with no freedom of speech, where christians are still dhimmi people under muslim rule.
Does it make sense to release Israeli's terrorist prisoners back to their country of origin as part of a/the hostage deal? The following is a list of Palestinian surnames that show the people's true national and historic origins: One of the most common Palestinian surnames is Al-Masri. In Arabic, Al-Masri literally means "the Egyptian." You'll also see Palestinians named Hourani, from Houran in southern Syria, - Tzurani, from Tyre in southern Lebanon, - Zrakawi, from Mazraka in Jordan, - Hijazi from the Hijaz province of the Arabian peninsula, - Mughrabi, from the Maghreb, - Elmisri, from Egypt, - Chalabi, Syrian, - Mugrabi, North Africa, - Habash, Ethiopia. Many other names point to the Palestinian's true hereditary and geographical origins.
When I found out that the palestinians voted hamas in, and later when they were in the streets cheering after the massacre of the Jewish people, I knew they were complicit with hamas. Why other people refuse to believe the truth, I don't know.
I don't see why the Palestinian's home nations and countries don't welcome and repatriate them. The following is a list of Palestinian surnames that show the people's true national and historic origins: One of the most common Palestinian surnames is Al-Masri. In Arabic, Al-Masri literally means "the Egyptian." You'll also see Palestinians named Hourani, from Houran in southern Syria, - Tzurani, from Tyre in southern Lebanon, - Zrakawi, from Mazraka in Jordan, - Hijazi from the Hijaz province of the Arabian peninsula, - Mughrabi, from the Maghreb, - Elmisri, from Egypt, - Chalabi, Syrian, - Mugrabi, North Africa, - Habash, Ethiopia. Many other names point to the Palestinian's true hereditary and geographical origins.
@@TURQUOISEEYES I understand that most Palestinians came to Israel during the first half of the 20th century for better living standards and perhaps as interlopers taking over and taking credit for the much-needed improvements that the Jews were making to the land. A certain number of them came during the 19th century as well, as did many Jews. A good number of travelers, reporters, government officials, and religious pilgrims, including Mark Twain and Herman Melville, traveled to the holy land during the 19th century. They all reported that Israel was desolate and nearly uninhabited. The statement, "A land without a people for a people without a land", is a true and accurate perspective.
I have a partial list of these travelers and reporters if people are interested: 1697, Thomas Shaw, English traveler - 18th century historian, French Count Constantine Francois Volney - 1816, James Silk Buckingham, English traveler - 1836, British nobleman Alexander William Crawford Lindsay - 1837, British Royal Commission - 1840, Lord Shaftsbury, Anthony Ashley Cooper 7th earl of Shaftesbury - 1852, English Clergyman Henry Burgess Whitaker Churton - 1853, Reverend Arthur G. H. Hollingsworth - 1857, British Council in Palestine - 1857, Herman Melville, author of 'Moby Dick' - 1860, Henry Baker Tristram - 1869, Mark Twain - 1888, Sir John William Dawson - 1888, English Clergyman Reverend Samuel Manning
@@TURQUOISEEYES I don´t think that is true (reganding African dna) (in general). Rather, the explanation that I have heard and that I think is likely, is that Muslim Arabs had slaves, and interbred with their slaves, and slaves often meant black slaves. And in Gaza / the WB, the descendants of slaves are there, and it is no secret. It is only facts that the doesn´t fit into the woke left´s favourite oppressor-oppressed narrative. I recommend for example "Afro-Palestinians" or "Slavery in Palestine", both articles are on wikipedia. So it is no secret, just not a convenient truth for the wokies to parrot out. Them being so highly sensitive individuals, poor things ... that is also why, in general, there is a visible difference between muslim and christian Arabs (and also jews), as both Christians and jews were dhimmi people, and had no slaves under muslim rile, and the African genetic hertitage is so strong. As genticist Ranajit Das put it: "Once you see it, you can´t un-see it." If you wonder who is "from Israel", there has been a lot of stuies showing that both Israeli jews and "palestinians" have what the researchers term "caananite" dna, and to morally declare which ones should live in Israel based on their dna, well, you can argue it, but that is a very dark road, ad even if someone is called "chalabi" or "tzurani", would that say that they have less "caananite" dna than cohen from Vienna, or Levi from Iraq? No, it wouldn´t. The ones that test with high amount of "caananite" dna are Iraqi jews, beduins of Israel/palestine/egypt, and even Saudi-Arabia, because that is the common ancestry. And a lot of turkish nationals would be high on jewish dna, as well. A lot of people go down that road, but in my opinion, it will not bring them anything good. It is also a Hamas/plo narrative, and from before we had access to dna testing, that is fairly recent. If you want them to go to Egypt because their family na is el masri, you are accepting the Hamas/plo narrative that the jews are settlers and foreign to the land of Israel, and that it somehow is about land, ancestry and justice. Well, it is not, as the Hamas charter makes it very clear that it is about the jews, and killing them (worldwide, not only in israel), and their etnisity has nothing to do with it, an neither does it matter when the jews came into Israel (their family). I have yet to see anyone make a good and coherent argument about right to live in Israel / Gaza / WB, and people´s genetics. Ultimately, it always comes off as some sort of racism, and pretty ugly, as well.
"...I d on't know why I'm talking about this...Oh I know why....Because every one is a moral idiot around here..." Shapiro just made my day )))))))))))))))))))))))))))
Continued prayers for the IDF the hostages and their families and for Jewish people across the world is Christians we stand with Israel bring them home🙏🌼🤝
8:12 correction it should be 'If Jews did what Christians/Muslims tell them to do...' Hindus/Buddhists/Sikhs are not telling Jews to lay down their arms.
I'm a Christian and absolutely do not believe they should "lay down their arms"... don't get true Christ followers conflate with "Christians" under Catholocism, or any of the other groups that make it hard to tell they aren't just regular atheist other than their beating to you to death with their high moral superiority. That's not what followers of Christ do.
Yea so if they are helping hamas and if they get killed the media will say that civilians were killed. A lot of theses civilians are also complicent in this too.
A lot of pro-Palestinian Israelis are against Hamas but believe the civilians are „innocent“. Granted, their views are more nuanced than us outsiders. Yet we hear about former hostages recounting how civilians SOLD them to Hamas. I just don’t follow that logic.
"Innocent" civilians. yeah right. Also Who was the journalist holding in his house? At first I heard it was Noa, but then later news broadcasts from Israel said it was the three men that were in the journalist's house and now this is back to saying that it was Noa. There is conflicting stories.
Read what the children are taught from birth. It is a wonder there are as many like Mosab who have transcended it. And I do believe more than we think.
Given your point, Ollie, the Torah DOES command us to leave one side open, to allow one's enemy a route for escape. Can you address the particular parameters of that halacha?
There are no european settlers in israel. THEY ARE JEWS ALL OF THEM IN THEIR OWN COUNTRY! SO READ SOME HISTORY AND TRY TO SEE WHO WAS THETE FIRST! NOT THE ARABS...THERE IS NO PROOF. BUT THERE IS PROOF FROM JEWS...
That's not true, they aren't all Hamas... some are Palestine Liberation Organization, Palestine Islamic Jihad, Palestine Liberation Front, Palestinian National Liberation Movement, Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigade, Popular Resistance Committees, Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine, Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine-General Command, Harakat al-Sabireen, and some are The Abu Nidal Organization. See? Totally innocent.
This is what Mosab Hassan Yousef (Son of Hamas) has been saying since October 7th! He said it on the Dr. Phil show interview. Gaza Palestinians are helping Hamas.
The large number of casualties was not in the area of the extraction of the hostages. We had thousands of infantry troops and tanks in the surrounding area acting as a diversion, it would have been impossible to have so many troops in an area of a few hundred square meters, the actual buildings the hostages were in were only 200 meters apart. The hamas figures of 274 dead and over 400 casualties is impossible in such a small area, we are talking about thousands of people spread over many dunam. We are also back to the old nonsense of evidence, over one million smartphones in gaza all with cameras, no pictures no evidence, just a few bodies on the floor of the hospital.
Well ita par for the course with the numbers.... I can't find it but I saw their numbers put to a graph and it's ridiculous..numbers go up by the same amount daily ...
The fault is the Quran. If u read it, u will find many places of intolerance for anyone that's not a believer of Islam. Jew, Christian, Atheist, Agnostic, Buddhist, etc...
Hamas themselves said the hostages were held by civilians. They implied that they would not have been rescued if Hamas had been holding them. Of course, civilians holding hostages, or storing weapons, are considered militants under the laws of warfare.
This whole area there, seams to be an insane asylum with all those 'good' people taking care of violently stolen people. I,well, remember that when they heard the horrific news they rejoiced in the streets. On the other hand, I do not expect ethos and faith in moral rules outside that asylum. I hope to be disproved. I only believe in the mind and heart of the people of Israel. Thank you!
The only difference between Hamas and a Gazan civilian is that the civilian has not yet acted on their beliefs. They dress the same, and eventually act the same.
![DDG & G Herbo - Nosey [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/I9Ra0Zc2NlQ/mqdefault.jpg)
According to Abbas Palestinian President said all Palestinian people are Hamas last October
They know it and they say it themselves; only the antisemitic left claims otherwise.
Palestinian civilians were also involved in the October 7th atrocities. I heard of women who went to loot houses while their men were committing the atrocities, and of children who watched these men and laughed. There are no innocent civilians in Gaza. How can there be, when they were taught the Hamas creed from the cradle? I haven't got a grain of sympathy for any of them.
I agree 👍💯. Stop sending theses Hamas supporters and murders our taxpayers federal aid money .we have been things toe do with our federal aid money like helping actually refugees 😮
I knew civilians participated in the massacre of Oct 7. I didn't hear about women were looting and children were there watching .
@@susnasongbird1277 That's what someone from Nir Oz who was there said he saw. I read about it shortly after October 7th.
I agree. After Oct 7th any sympathy I had for Palestinians as humans is gone. They have ruined the little support they had because of their obvious hate and ambition to commit genocide on the Jews. They made their bed. Enough of their excuses and lies. Learn to live like civilized people or face the consequences.
Jihadis are snakes hiding in the grass, and "moderat" Mmuslims are the blades of grass.
When the grass grows taller, the snakes larger, their bites more fatal,,
,, one must be responsible, and mow the lawn. Islame has no right to exist, nor do those defending that pedo-ideology.
'There's no difference between palestinians and hamas.' - Mosab Hassan Yousef , son of hamas
This makes Al Jazeera complicit in the attack on Israel.
Thought I was the only one seeing stuff.
@@onlythetruth883 they use freedom of speech and western democracy in which they don't believe but use it to destroy us from the inside
Its all coming out slowly
Qatar as well
@@Calatriste54 Qatar With their money infiltrating our institutions and use our democracy and freedom of speech to destroy us from within
Mosab Hassan Yousef summed it all up with genius simplicity "It is a culture that is based on honor and shame and not right or wrong"
Mosab is an amazing person, and this quote is brilliant, thx for that.
And they are shamed constantly as results of their stupid decisions and actions.
@@jamesjameson4303But the international media cover up these facts and promotes anti- semitism !!!!!
Those that do all that are just as complicit.!
Facts not feelings
As soon as they become casualties they also become civilians. Hamas has no combat casualties. And that is the UN position!
UN is Hamas
It was a civilian who kidnapped Noa on his bike. It could very well be that photographer or his father.
Every Gazan man in that video looks like a civilian, as do the ones seen kidnapping the Bibas family.
let them learn from this experience and this war, country of hate doesn’t go well long term
They didn’t learn from the last, how many was it? Around 6 wars they started and lost for the past 76 years. They are radical and strive from hatred, nothing is going to change that unfortunately.
Hoping this is their "Wounded Knee Battle of 1890" moment. After 100 years of war, the Native American never attempted violent resistance against the US Gov't ever again!
@@lornestein7248 Yes, undoubtedly Gazans will learn their lesson and leave the Indigenous people of Israel alone
I don’t have any hope for them, nor do I have any sympathy for their self built “suffering”. They started 6-7 wars and lost all of them only to commit October 7th. They won’t learn because Islam is a cult of hatred and death, they thrive off others suffering.
@@GilbertdeClare0704 It will need to be explained explicitly because the other side will only use it to recruit new "soldiers".
Also it needs to be defunded. Something, whether it is an organisation, company or ideology will maintain and grow if it makes money.
!! Right on Ben Shapiro !!
Excellent program !!!
Every muslim on Earth is complicite as they do not stand up against the jihad
Agreed
But all Muslims do not stand up for each other. The Muslims of Gaza are Sunni Muslim. Most of the Muslims here in the West support them because they are also Sunni. What about the Uighurs in China who are being tortured and held in concentration camps. They are also Muslims but not Sunnis, so who cares. Not the other Muslims.
I'm a non jew from America/ and I watched the interview of Oct 7 hostage MIA SCHEM/ she said she kept in a family's home/ watch her interview/ even the children were cruel to her in this household
Yes; the kid taunted her by pretending to offer her candy, then snatching it away. Disgusting behaviour, no doubt learned from his parents.
I watched that interview of Mia Shem and remember her saying there are no innocent civilians in Gaza. I don't understand why the mainstream media can't see this.
@@HaleyMary it's obvious that mainstream media pick a side and their news and opinions are bias to one side/in my opinion and (I'm a non Jewish American )who ever sides with gaza Palestinian hate the Jewish people as the Germans who followed Hitler.the oct 7th events were horrific and if one has a good heart and has daughters, sons ,beloved ones how can you side with gaza/Palestine like these college youth in those ridiculous encampments,and celebrities like that actress Susan sarandon who boldly say no women were raped & killed no babies killed on Oct 7th ,to see the viral videos of shani louk's lifeless broken body being taken into gaza with those monsters sitting on her corpse, then young boys spitting and beating her dead body showed me what those people are and that anyone in media can defend that nation,it's insanity. I'm disgusted when I see these jew hating protesters.
You guys are crazy - you think it's so "cruel" that a child didn't offer her candy??? Have you seen what the fuck the israeli "defence" forces have done to Palestinian children??? If you are SO simple minded as to think that children not sharing candy means that they are "evil" and "not innocent" whatsoever, I think it's time for you to get off your phone and go outside, luv.
I always love Ben Shapiro's takes. Especially on this.
of course civilians voted for HAMAS ....
I do know what you say is true. Except I recognise the spiritual war behind the conflict I would find the current madness in the Western world incomprehensible. May the Lord preserve Israel.
Europe has fallen bro 😮💨
@@davie8906 They have surrendered.
There is no such legal statehood or country named Palatine 😅. and there is no such ethic groups of people call palatineins 😆. There people are Arafat's Arabs mulsins who migrated from Jordan and Egypt and Sylvia during WWI and WWII to work in Jordan. They are merely squatters on the legal country of Israel 😅
Leave the smiles out...looks as a joke but is the truth
Palestinia, capital city Narnia. They have a soccerball squad & national anthem...it's quite catchy. 😂
The irony that "Palestine" was named by the Romans, after a Hebrew word meaning "invaders". So I guess they got the right name.
There are no innocent gazans
Gaza civilians ..
Directly or indirectly supporting HAMAS ..
Hypocrite
very sinister ...
I knew that when I was 14 years old. People who doubt that are totally ignorant or totally on their side of eval!
Hamas are palestins and palestins are Hamas so if you want to survive, don’t keep hostages in your house when people support the Palestinians and say they’re poor. It’s not their fault. I disagree. They are all as bad as each other. Why don’t their neighbors help them because they know how bad these people are. 🇬🇧🇮🇱✌️
There’s a channel owner called Corey Gil-Shuster who interviews Pals. Listen to their own words and you quickly learn that the women and children are complicit in their hateful intentions.
listen to "Palestinian Christians: Why did many Christians leave Palestine?", listen to the fear in their voices, look at the the flickering eyes as they tell a lie to stay safe in a society with no freedom of speech, where christians are still dhimmi people under muslim rule.
yes, its very eye-opening.
A doctor treating any patient is off-limits. A doctor helping a terrorist get away, or harboring ammunitions... that doctor is not off-limits.
No such ENTITY as innocent in that region. Just like no such ENTITY as palestine or palestinian...🎯
Not Noa, it was the 3 male hostages who were held with a "journalist" and his doctor father
If a journalist and a Doctor are this rotten, think what the average person is like.
Moral trash. Yup. What gets us is that most of the world is on the side of that moral trash.
Hamastinians don't wear Uniforms
Well said.
❤
Even Al Jazeera disowned this guy.
I mean, how dare you celebrate hostages being saved ! My sympathy for Palestinians is fkn ZERO
Does it make sense to release Israeli's terrorist prisoners back to their country of origin as part of a/the hostage deal?
The following is a list of Palestinian surnames that show the people's true national and historic origins:
One of the most common Palestinian surnames is Al-Masri. In Arabic, Al-Masri literally means "the Egyptian." You'll also see Palestinians named Hourani, from Houran in southern Syria, - Tzurani, from Tyre in southern Lebanon, - Zrakawi, from Mazraka in Jordan, - Hijazi from the Hijaz province of the Arabian peninsula, - Mughrabi, from the Maghreb, - Elmisri, from Egypt, - Chalabi, Syrian, - Mugrabi, North Africa, - Habash, Ethiopia. Many other names point to the Palestinian's true hereditary and geographical origins.
When I found out that the palestinians voted hamas in, and later when they were in the streets cheering after the massacre of the Jewish people, I knew they were complicit with hamas. Why other people refuse to believe the truth, I don't know.
I don't see why the Palestinian's home nations and countries don't welcome and repatriate them.
The following is a list of Palestinian surnames that show the people's true national and historic origins:
One of the most common Palestinian surnames is Al-Masri. In Arabic, Al-Masri literally means "the Egyptian." You'll also see Palestinians named Hourani, from Houran in southern Syria, - Tzurani, from Tyre in southern Lebanon, - Zrakawi, from Mazraka in Jordan, - Hijazi from the Hijaz province of the Arabian peninsula, - Mughrabi, from the Maghreb, - Elmisri, from Egypt, - Chalabi, Syrian, - Mugrabi, North Africa, - Habash, Ethiopia. Many other names point to the Palestinian's true hereditary and geographical origins.
Exactly! A LOT of thrm have African DNA too. Because thry are from Egypt. It is OBVIOUS They are not from Israeli land.
@@TURQUOISEEYES I understand that most Palestinians came to Israel during the first half of the 20th century for better living standards and perhaps as interlopers taking over and taking credit for the much-needed improvements that the Jews were making to the land.
A certain number of them came during the 19th century as well, as did many Jews.
A good number of travelers, reporters, government officials, and religious pilgrims, including Mark Twain and Herman Melville, traveled to the holy land during the 19th century. They all reported that Israel was desolate and nearly uninhabited.
The statement, "A land without a people for a people without a land", is a true and accurate perspective.
I have a partial list of these travelers and reporters if people are interested:
1697, Thomas Shaw, English traveler - 18th century historian, French Count Constantine Francois Volney - 1816, James Silk Buckingham, English traveler - 1836, British nobleman Alexander William Crawford Lindsay - 1837, British Royal Commission - 1840, Lord Shaftsbury, Anthony Ashley Cooper 7th earl of Shaftesbury - 1852, English Clergyman Henry Burgess Whitaker Churton - 1853, Reverend Arthur G. H. Hollingsworth - 1857, British Council in Palestine - 1857, Herman Melville, author of 'Moby Dick' - 1860, Henry Baker Tristram - 1869, Mark Twain - 1888, Sir John William Dawson - 1888, English Clergyman Reverend Samuel Manning
@@TURQUOISEEYES I don´t think that is true (reganding African dna) (in general). Rather, the explanation that I have heard and that I think is likely, is that Muslim Arabs had slaves, and interbred with their slaves, and slaves often meant black slaves. And in Gaza / the WB, the descendants of slaves are there, and it is no secret. It is only facts that the doesn´t fit into the woke left´s favourite oppressor-oppressed narrative.
I recommend for example "Afro-Palestinians" or "Slavery in Palestine", both articles are on wikipedia. So it is no secret, just not a convenient truth for the wokies to parrot out. Them being so highly sensitive individuals, poor things ... that is also why, in general, there is a visible difference between muslim and christian Arabs (and also jews), as both Christians and jews were dhimmi people, and had no slaves under muslim rile, and the African genetic hertitage is so strong. As genticist Ranajit Das put it: "Once you see it, you can´t un-see it."
If you wonder who is "from Israel", there has been a lot of stuies showing that both Israeli jews and "palestinians" have what the researchers term "caananite" dna, and to morally declare which ones should live in Israel based on their dna, well, you can argue it, but that is a very dark road, ad even if someone is called "chalabi" or "tzurani", would that say that they have less "caananite" dna than cohen from Vienna, or Levi from Iraq? No, it wouldn´t.
The ones that test with high amount of "caananite" dna are Iraqi jews, beduins of Israel/palestine/egypt, and even Saudi-Arabia, because that is the common ancestry. And a lot of turkish nationals would be high on jewish dna, as well. A lot of people go down that road, but in my opinion, it will not bring them anything good. It is also a Hamas/plo narrative, and from before we had access to dna testing, that is fairly recent. If you want them to go to Egypt because their family na is el masri, you are accepting the Hamas/plo narrative that the jews are settlers and foreign to the land of Israel, and that it somehow is about land, ancestry and justice. Well, it is not, as the Hamas charter makes it very clear that it is about the jews, and killing them (worldwide, not only in israel), and their etnisity has nothing to do with it, an neither does it matter when the jews came into Israel (their family).
I have yet to see anyone make a good and coherent argument about right to live in Israel / Gaza / WB, and people´s genetics. Ultimately, it always comes off as some sort of racism, and pretty ugly, as well.
@@liteenergy4843 that doesn´t make an argument for "ga back home" based on their family name,tho. (And I´m pro-Israel, also)
Well said. Shalom Israel 🇮🇱 ❤️
“People are…moral trash.” Sadly, Ben Shapiro is not wrong about many on social media (or stamping about on the streets) these days.
"...I d on't know why I'm talking about this...Oh I know why....Because every one is a moral idiot around here..."
Shapiro just made my day )))))))))))))))))))))))))))
AND THIS IS THE REASON FOR NO TWO-STATE SOLUTION- YOU CAN NOT TRUST THESE PEOPLE.
I
h a t e
Al Jazeera!
All Gaza has is Sí Villains !
There are no innocent civilians.
Continued prayers for the IDF the hostages and their families and for Jewish people across the world is Christians we stand with Israel bring them home🙏🌼🤝
When lies are your only claim to fame. Here comes dreadful fall days.
No surprises there .
It IS that journalist on the motorcycle on October 7 , is it not ?
8:12 correction it should be 'If Jews did what Christians/Muslims tell them to do...' Hindus/Buddhists/Sikhs are not telling Jews to lay down their arms.
I'm a Christian and absolutely do not believe they should "lay down their arms"... don't get true Christ followers conflate with "Christians" under Catholocism, or any of the other groups that make it hard to tell they aren't just regular atheist other than their beating to you to death with their high moral superiority. That's not what followers of Christ do.
Yea so if they are helping hamas and if they get killed the media will say that civilians were killed. A lot of theses civilians are also complicent in this too.
Soon Qatar will have a lawsuit on their lap
Can you please cover the palestine conference in michigan, it has symbols of the whole of Israel as they are supposedly calling for peace.
"Gaza" Arabs of some kind.
For once i agree with Ben. Most of them are in on it, not all. I stand with Israel
💯
Terropassengers...😂
No innocent civilians n gaza😢
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
GOD Bless Israel and the IDF. ✝✡.
You did right
A lot of pro-Palestinian Israelis are against Hamas but believe the civilians are „innocent“. Granted, their views are more nuanced than us outsiders. Yet we hear about former hostages recounting how civilians SOLD them to Hamas. I just don’t follow that logic.
Hamas is game playing. Today they said they did not know how many hostages were alive.
please let this be known by the few decent people still on this earth...
Ben - tell us about Irgun!
Eliminate the word " complicit " Gaza ( civilians) are and were part and parcel of Hamas.
We're Germans mearly complicit during WW2.
All gazan civilians are complacent -
"Innocent" civilians. yeah right.
Also Who was the journalist holding in his house? At first I heard it was Noa, but then later news broadcasts from Israel said it was the three men that were in the journalist's house and now this is back to saying that it was Noa. There is conflicting stories.
I heard it was Noa also.
Only small babies are innocent there
They’re complicit
There is no line between hamans and palestinkans whatsoever
They are one and the same
Zeker en dat hebben ze met zijn dood moet betalen
Only a few bad apples huh
Allah Yahwe menghukum palestina ☝🏿
Read what the children are taught from birth. It is a wonder there are as many like Mosab who have transcended it. And I do believe more than we think.
Ben talking isnt evidence.. you just said words you didnt provide evidence
Moral sense is needed, you say? Sorry but you're wasting your breath because adherents to the ROP don't even know what that means.
Duh. Gazians are hamas.
Given your point, Ollie, the Torah DOES command us to leave one side open, to allow one's enemy a route for escape. Can you address the particular parameters of that halacha?
They have 2 sides open, Jordan and Egypt.
And Hamas is Amelech? So you ARE interested in genocide then? Just please say it straight out.
B.s is another liar
If the Europeans settler return to Europe this war will completely end
There are no European settlers in israel
If the middle Easterns Left the Western countries with their religious death cult and return to their countries, The war would have never started 😮
Nope! During the ha locaust they WERE in Europe and it still happened. It's a problem with the human condition...
There are no european settlers in israel. THEY ARE JEWS ALL OF THEM IN THEIR OWN COUNTRY! SO READ SOME HISTORY AND TRY TO SEE WHO WAS THETE FIRST! NOT THE ARABS...THERE IS NO PROOF. BUT THERE IS PROOF FROM JEWS...
Jewish majority in Israel came or were expelled from Arab countries and not from Europe, this disproves your claims
Egypt is complicit too
TRUE
There is no such thing as "innocent civilian" in Palestine. Palestine IS hamas.
Yes true Amen 🙏
Well that's not true. Its true of the majority but not all. May I remind you of the likes of Mosab Hassan Yousef and Hamza Howidy.
@@jhunt5578Maybe 10 out of millions unfortunately
FACT!
That's not true, they aren't all Hamas... some are Palestine Liberation Organization, Palestine Islamic Jihad, Palestine Liberation Front, Palestinian National Liberation Movement, Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigade, Popular Resistance Committees, Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine, Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine-General Command, Harakat al-Sabireen, and some are The Abu Nidal Organization. See? Totally innocent.
Ollie. Thank you for staying strong and showing the world what's right ❤🇮🇱
I'm afraid that the UN is also complicit with Hamas/Hezbollah/Huthi/ISIS or else sympathizing with them strongly.
This is what Mosab Hassan Yousef (Son of Hamas) has been saying since October 7th! He said it on the Dr. Phil show interview. Gaza Palestinians are helping Hamas.
The large number of casualties was not in the area of the extraction of the hostages.
We had thousands of infantry troops and tanks in the surrounding area acting as a diversion, it would have been impossible to have so many troops in an area of a few hundred square meters, the actual buildings the hostages were in were only 200 meters apart.
The hamas figures of 274 dead and over 400 casualties is impossible in such a small area, we are talking about thousands of people spread over many dunam.
We are also back to the old nonsense of evidence, over one million smartphones in gaza all with cameras, no pictures no evidence, just a few bodies on the floor of the hospital.
Well ita par for the course with the numbers.... I can't find it but I saw their numbers put to a graph and it's ridiculous..numbers go up by the same amount daily ...
🇮🇱✡️🇮🇱
Exactley, put!!!!!!!
Pure evil 🤮
The fault is the Quran.
If u read it, u will find many places of intolerance for anyone that's not a believer of Islam.
Jew, Christian, Atheist, Agnostic, Buddhist, etc...
No one in arab countries protesting against HamaSS... Wonder why!
It is all to easy to see average nice western living Gaza and West bank civilians and overlook the dark religious extremism hidden in their hearts.
"Tis clear as Summer Sun.." WS
Nailed it, Ben
Palestinians said they are older than Israel, unless you're a mummy, I don't think 🤔 so...
Hamas themselves said the hostages were held by civilians. They implied that they would not have been rescued if Hamas had been holding them. Of course, civilians holding hostages, or storing weapons, are considered militants under the laws of warfare.
This whole area there, seams to be an insane asylum with all those 'good' people taking care of violently stolen people. I,well, remember that when they heard the horrific news they rejoiced in the streets. On the other hand, I do not expect ethos and faith in moral rules outside that asylum. I hope to be disproved. I only believe in the mind and heart of the people of Israel. Thank you!
❤🙏🇮🇱🙏🇮🇱🙏🇮🇱🙏🇺🇸🙏✝️🙏🕊
I´ve been saying that there´s not such a thing as innocent civilian maybe except the ones that haven´t been indoctrinated yet. So really young childs.
The only difference between Hamas and a Gazan civilian is that the civilian has not yet acted on their beliefs. They dress the same, and eventually act the same.
Aiding and abetting is a criminal act of war!