Lochanside | Whats in a Tune

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 янв 2025

Комментарии • 11

  • @kohrsthomas
    @kohrsthomas Год назад

    Thank you very much

  • @johnminer8672
    @johnminer8672 Год назад

    This and Killworth Hills are my two favorite marches.

    • @piperg6179
      @piperg6179 8 месяцев назад

      In this category, The Highland Brigade at Magersfontein is the runaway class act.

  • @ianduncan7189
    @ianduncan7189 Год назад

    Lochanside is probably one of the best / greatest tunes ever written for the GHB.....it really has everything....(ok no taurlauths!).....as tunes go...it is a tune of "confidence"...as i call it....who can't lift their playing marching down the road...playing Lochanside...it puts a smile on everybody's faces as you march past.........(it is a tune i really love to play.....especially in massed bands!)
    my other favorite tune is ........"Caberfeidh"........now there's a tune......a "serious" tune......a tune with "intent"......play Caberfeidh....and the path opens up for you.....even God stands aside!

  • @igorGriffiths
    @igorGriffiths Год назад

    Love this tune, makes a great uplift finale to the Green Hills and Battles O'er. Just played it and paused after the second part, ok a good tune so far but as you say the 3rd part seals the deal and acts like a reprise to close the tune.

    • @piperg6179
      @piperg6179 Год назад +1

      I’ll grant you that Lochanside is melodic and even uplifting but it can’t compensate for that slogging predictable tune Green Hills. Even a hydraulic jack wouldn’t lift Green Hills.

    • @ianduncan7189
      @ianduncan7189 Год назад

      for green hills.....you need to really point it to give it lift....also to up the tempo a bit.....many 3/4s suffer from being crucial@@piperg6179

    • @MrBagpipes
      @MrBagpipes 8 месяцев назад

      ​@@piperg6179I think the problem with Green Hills is pipers just play it so much we become immune to it. It's actually a decent tune with a good story behind it and recognised by many non-players. It comes in handy at the end of a long march/parade when we're getting tired and we need something we can play almost without thinking.

    • @piperg6179
      @piperg6179 8 месяцев назад

      @@MrBagpipes You may be right, but i still hate the tune. Hundreds have died of boredom while listening to it. When I get to be world dictator any piper who even tries it will be sent to a dungeon and we will allow Green H to be played only on primitive instruments such as the piano and fiddle.

  • @jamiepage1066
    @jamiepage1066 Год назад

    Adore this tune. Here is a favourite recording of it: ruclips.net/video/WIAvC5bMc6k/видео.html

  • @piperg6179
    @piperg6179 4 месяца назад

    Unimpressed! As far as i am concerned, in this class of tunes, The Highland Brigade at Magersfontein is far better, far more lyrical and far more interesting.
    A previous comment says that Lochanside is a good follow on to Green Hills of Tyrol. Actually, any tune is a good follow on to Green H. Even five minutes of low G is better than that dreary, predictable slog.