False, he did to John Rocker’s girl in Blood vs Water 2. He treated her like a poor child, even though she was lazy and stole food. Same with Lindsey from Cagayan, who quit because her only alliance member got voted out. Then she threatens violence against Trish and ends up quitting before she did something “she would regret”. She quit because she had no chance of winning, just like Colton.
on nikaraguq they had nothing but the clothes on their back and it was raining all the time plus being extremely gold at nights kelly shinn had nothing but her swim suit for over 28 days (plus a shirt she got from a guy that was voted off) naonka was like kelly with nothing to eat and being in the rain in just a shirt and a swim suit for over 28 days it shouldnt surprise you :/
@@ThePercyJacksonDude Lord of the flies is a lie, the original was the opposite of the book. Search for The real Lord of the Flies: what happened when six boys were shipwrecked for 15 months
Cirie's move wasn't dumb. She explained that if she let Candice get voted out, she would have been the next one to go at that point because JT would have full control because he was working both sides anyways.
@@owensimon8450 Imagine commenting 5 years later and still using improper syntax. This is especially cringe worthy considering you're trying to Alpha someone over grammar. Perhaps you should attempt to realize there is a shelf life on grammar police, but being a douche is forever.
Nick is right. Cirie's move shouldnot be considered a dumb move. If anything it's an example of how difficult this game is. The tribe saw her as a threat just because she was able to persuade Amanda. Pretty difficult to see that coming.
cirie's move was not dumb at all in fact it was the smartest, don't u see how she was able to manage to handle the others when the others want candice out. Cirie understand that she is weak on physical challenge and of course she is the target. Cirie's got outwitted based on the fact that she is dangerous and JT don't like it.
She let people notice how dangerous she was thought, which was a mistake, she should have toned it down a bit. JT was smart to notice what a strategic threat she was and get rid of her before she could make damage at the merge.
I agree. If they go after Candice who's in the middle of the alliances first, then the next move is to go after Cirie next vote. It made no sense for her to get rid of her closest ally. I think though her reputation for masterminding Ozzy's blindside in Micronesia ultimately is what made JT very wary of her, and that's why he was so eager to vote her off his first chance.
Kadag S Agreed, the play she was making was right, there was nothing dumb about it all. It was a shame that her reputation was her downfall, not the move she was making.
Cirie's move does not deserve to be anywhere near this list. Cirie took control of the tribe and had everyone except JT on board with the play. JT just out played her and took a chance to get her out before she'd inevitably turn on him. Ultimately, yes it's easy to say it was the wrong move by Cirie considering the outcome, but when considering we're into season 30, there are hundreds of "dumber" survivor moves
My predictions for # 1 should the rest of this list ever be released: James gets voted out with two idols Erik gives up immunity Brandon gives up immunity The entire Manano tribe gives up immunity
I agree, but I think she was placed on the heroes tribe for 2 reasons: 1. She was a fan favourite 2. Her, candice and Amanda (although I thought they were all villains) had a lot of connections and past relationships from previous seasons (Panama, Cook Islands, Micronesia. Etc.) so I guess they just wanted to make it even towards the other players from both tribes
+Ryan B Yeah, which I thought it was so funny she was commenting about Sandra since she isn't that better. Heck, Candace is also kind of a villain with her mutiny. Danielle... I don't know why SHE is a villain. Not a hero either, she is kind of in the middle. But at least she was fun.
+BladeBlur Danielle used Terry to help her build fire and get Cirie out at 4, then won immunity at 3 and immediately got Terry out, which was seen as Villainous
I guess, but it still wasn't that big of a villain move to begin with. It was only touted as that to give her some excuse to be in that tribe. Once EI was done no one said "that Danielle was a villain", especially when you have Shane and Courtney around you :P
TCanFT how the hell is he a loser??? Being a villain isn’t even a bad thing. But people can have opinions... I didn’t even like Cirie in HvV actually. Does that make me a terrible person?
Michelle Louise I think you're partly right, part of him was upset, but... I dunno... he did say in the finale that he wasn't sure he could win against Tony, but couldn't break his word and would take him anyway... I think part of him knew he wouldn't wind, although part of him also regretted the decision later.
MsMaggyW he just wanted to seem true to his values of his martial arts. But when the day is over no one is going to remember your values instead you'll be left or in his case, left without the $$, and a faint memory of what should have been.
Michelle Louise Exactly. Not a smart move. But at least he was smart enough to know it... I would have gone for the money though. It is just a game, and voting somebody out isn't dishonourable or anything...
Wow... glad I read the comments before starting this video. I would have been pissed it I had watched the whole thing and went to click on the next one, only to see this was the only video you made. It's been almost 7 years since you made this one, so I think its safe to say we won't be getting any more.
She couldn’t stand 4 hours of rain? When I am, it does sometimes rain for over 7 hours. And we love it. Rather I’d stay cold than really hot and sweaty
It wasn't a dumb move, because Tom targeted Cirie first and she reacted by trying to take him out. JT, Tom and Colby pussed out because they were literally terrified of Cirie.
Bruh. I’ve been on a survivor binge on yt for like the past 2 weeks. And of any video/video series, when I saw this one, I was more excited to watch than any other video. I was disappointed when there wasn’t a second part. So I looked at when this came out only to see that it was 9 years ago and I’ve never been more let down. Also. I can’t believe Phillip was on survivor over 9 years ago. I felt like that season was at most 5 years ago.
Rewatching that Final Tribal with Phillip just solidifies my disgust that Boston Rob won a season. It took him 4 attempts to win and look who he took to the end to finally guarentee that win.
Phillip still got a jury vote though funny enough! Also sometimes the jury pisses me off they are all bitter because they got blindsided. Also Ne Anca just pissed me off.
I think Cirie goes a little overboard with that. She doesn't realize that she is considered a strong player because of her strategic ability. So, once you get rid of the challenge beasts Cirie is the biggest threat to everyone.
Couldn't stand Phillip in any season. in ever played in. I hated him more than Russell Hantz. I almost rather watch Russell then watch Phillip. It was good riddance to bad rubbish
I know this video is about dumb moves, but there's a very smart (or at least heroic) move that I want to give a shout out to. Holly giving up a reward of a movie and movie snacks with actual flavor for just herself (and her team), for getting new supplies and bland rice to eat for the whole tribe. I remember her say how much she wanted just one hot dog, but made the selfless move. She should've won.
I don't blame or think is was dumb of Phillip Sheppard to respond to the jury the way he did. If someone is going to be nasty to you and obviously are not going to vote for you anyway, why not dig back at them? Good for him.
Tom and Cirie were threatened by each other due to their legacies. Which is understandable on both of their parts. They were eliminated within one round of each other, there's nothing dumb about it.
The maker of this video quit on this like nayanka did
Philip Thomas and purple kelly
naonka
Dumbest move # 1. Not finishing your list..
LOL
Media Buster true
inga tīrule this was uploaded 5-6 years ago lmao.
Media Buster 1000th like!
LMAO. I watched this one and was expecting the rest but no....
I love how jeff takes no crap from quitters
False, he did to John Rocker’s girl in Blood vs Water 2. He treated her like a poor child, even though she was lazy and stole food. Same with Lindsey from Cagayan, who quit because her only alliance member got voted out. Then she threatens violence against Trish and ends up quitting before she did something “she would regret”. She quit because she had no chance of winning, just like Colton.
Why did she quit on day 28 with a immunity idol!!! Are you kidding
Missed her cheese puffs.
Shane Brodeur Because of the constant rain.
Because she was a dumb crazy bitch. It was evident throughout the season.
@@lolomgmetobavi HAHAHAHA TRUE
on nikaraguq they had nothing but the clothes on their back and it was raining all the time plus being extremely gold at nights kelly shinn had nothing but her swim suit for over 28 days (plus a shirt she got from a guy that was voted off) naonka was like kelly with nothing to eat and being in the rain in just a shirt and a swim suit for over 28 days it shouldnt surprise you :/
#50 phillip and that girl (forget her name ) both literally said they were there because of Rob. Must have been one of the easiest wins ever .
They thought by them being loyal to Rob they were gonna get handed a million dollars
Natalie
Boston Rob trying so hard not to laugh during Philip's speech kills me everytime 😂😂
Taj was on fire in the beginning. Brendan really messed that whole thing up.
I was rooting for Taj, watched it all fall apart. #gutted
Imagine survivor but with no supervision. They would kill each other
I speak for most people when I say we wouldn’t kill each other
Yeah it's called hunger games
Lord of the Flies.
@@ThePercyJacksonDude Lord of the flies is a lie, the original was the opposite of the book.
Search for
The real Lord of the Flies: what happened when six boys were shipwrecked for 15 months
Alright weirdo
Cirie's move wasn't dumb. She explained that if she let Candice get voted out, she would have been the next one to go at that point because JT would have full control because he was working both sides anyways.
Phillips Rob speach lol
Zander Neilsen Phillip you are um weird
Imagine spelling speech wrong
@@owensimon8450 Imagine commenting 5 years later and still using improper syntax. This is especially cringe worthy considering you're trying to Alpha someone over grammar. Perhaps you should attempt to realize there is a shelf life on grammar police, but being a douche is forever.
Switters Hendo imagine being salty for no reason like get a life
Switters Hendo don’t let it bother you so much
For those of you who are bothered by this list not being finished, think of this as "5 of the dumbest moves in Survivor history"
Five best dumbest moves.
Your 6 year old comment just took this video out of my watch later… thank you 🙏 😂
“five of the okay-est moves in survivor history”
Bro I have stayed tuned for 3 years
same
Eva Noelle Maybe he died.
f i v e y e a r s
6 years
I’ve stayed tuned for 5 years
1:02 When Boston Rob realizes even Phillip wants him to win. :)
Nick is right. Cirie's move shouldnot be considered a dumb move. If anything it's an example of how difficult this game is. The tribe saw her as a threat just because she was able to persuade Amanda. Pretty difficult to see that coming.
Jake Jones
Nay calling Chase "her boy", and in the end votes for Fabio. THAT'S HILARIOUS
It's been three years, still no action for 46-1
Scott Moore you sure?
It’s been 6 years now, I doubt there ever going to finish it.
I've been waiting for 10 years still waiting
8 years
They just did 46-41 after 8 years
Solid list. It's a shame you never finished it.
cirie's move was not dumb at all in fact it was the smartest, don't u see how she was able to manage to handle the others when the others want candice out. Cirie understand that she is weak on physical challenge and of course she is the target. Cirie's got outwitted based on the fact that she is dangerous and JT don't like it.
She let people notice how dangerous she was thought, which was a mistake, she should have toned it down a bit. JT was smart to notice what a strategic threat she was and get rid of her before she could make damage at the merge.
I agree. If they go after Candice who's in the middle of the alliances first, then the next move is to go after Cirie next vote. It made no sense for her to get rid of her closest ally. I think though her reputation for masterminding Ozzy's blindside in Micronesia ultimately is what made JT very wary of her, and that's why he was so eager to vote her off his first chance.
Kadag S Agreed, the play she was making was right, there was nothing dumb about it all. It was a shame that her reputation was her downfall, not the move she was making.
Kadag S I like Cirie, but I actually didn’t like her in HvV tbh
@@MsMaggyW the only reason j.t found out out was because he was snooping behind them
"You.... are weird...." that makes me burst out laughing every time I hear it.
Its been 6 years but I’m still staying tuned!! Can’t wait until part 2! It’s taken 6 years it must be real good
I love how Jeff deals with quitters like Naonka
Cirie's move does not deserve to be anywhere near this list. Cirie took control of the tribe and had everyone except JT on board with the play. JT just out played her and took a chance to get her out before she'd inevitably turn on him. Ultimately, yes it's easy to say it was the wrong move by Cirie considering the outcome, but when considering we're into season 30, there are hundreds of "dumber" survivor moves
I've stayed tuned for seven years now.
Can we bring Phillip to every Final Tribal just to hear his responses to the jury questions? Love that guy!
My predictions for # 1 should the rest of this list ever be released:
James gets voted out with two idols
Erik gives up immunity
Brandon gives up immunity
The entire Manano tribe gives up immunity
Geez, Phillip makes me so mad here! I just don't understand why he thought that would make him look good to the jury...
"Well one person doesn't deserve it so... we can cut him off"😂😂
BRAAAHHH, my stomach hurts 😂😂
i’ve stayed tuned for 7 years
I still don't understand why Cirie belongs in the Hero tribe. She stands out so much as a villain.
I agree, but I think she was placed on the heroes tribe for 2 reasons:
1. She was a fan favourite
2. Her, candice and Amanda (although I thought they were all villains) had a lot of connections and past relationships from previous seasons (Panama, Cook Islands, Micronesia. Etc.) so I guess they just wanted to make it even towards the other players from both tribes
+Ryan B Yeah, which I thought it was so funny she was commenting about Sandra since she isn't that better. Heck, Candace is also kind of a villain with her mutiny. Danielle... I don't know why SHE is a villain. Not a hero either, she is kind of in the middle. But at least she was fun.
+BladeBlur Danielle used Terry to help her build fire and get Cirie out at 4, then won immunity at 3 and immediately got Terry out, which was seen as Villainous
I guess, but it still wasn't that big of a villain move to begin with. It was only touted as that to give her some excuse to be in that tribe. Once EI was done no one said "that Danielle was a villain", especially when you have Shane and Courtney around you :P
TCanFT how the hell is he a loser??? Being a villain isn’t even a bad thing. But people can have opinions... I didn’t even like Cirie in HvV actually. Does that make me a terrible person?
Naonka: I’m not a quitter!
Me: But you literally just said you quit!
you could chuck woo in there now for bringing tony to the end
Is it dumb if he knew he wouldn't win and didn't mind? Hmm.
MsMaggyW im about 134% certain he minded that he didnt win a million dollars. He may have said he didnt but no one thinks that way really
Michelle Louise I think you're partly right, part of him was upset, but... I dunno... he did say in the finale that he wasn't sure he could win against Tony, but couldn't break his word and would take him anyway... I think part of him knew he wouldn't wind, although part of him also regretted the decision later.
MsMaggyW he just wanted to seem true to his values of his martial arts. But when the day is over no one is going to remember your values instead you'll be left or in his case, left without the $$, and a faint memory of what should have been.
Michelle Louise Exactly. Not a smart move. But at least he was smart enough to know it... I would have gone for the money though. It is just a game, and voting somebody out isn't dishonourable or anything...
This is why idols suck. Cirie should've won the whole thing.
Cirie always should win the game.
Been staying tuned for over 6 years, idk if something went on in their life but I hope they finish the list...
I finish on my account come check it out
I love Boston rob. Boston rob. I heart Boston rob. #1 Boston rob fan. Love Boston rob. rob. Robby #number1mastermind= Boston rob. luv him- Phillip
Tessie Almost as good as Rob. C.
Promising 50 and haven't finished all 50 since Jan. 2013 be called a dumb move
GR3Y5H3ART we still waiting in the future
Yes as it is now 2019
Wow... glad I read the comments before starting this video. I would have been pissed it I had watched the whole thing and went to click on the next one, only to see this was the only video you made. It's been almost 7 years since you made this one, so I think its safe to say we won't be getting any more.
i’ve been staying tuned for 9 years bruh
10 now
how long will i be staying tuned it’s been 5 years im starting to think there is no part two
To be honest more honest philip is one of my favs
LOVE Phillip!
Also.. When this video came out I was 10!! Wow! You are a great editor.. But please finish this. I would love to see more!
Phillip managed to still get one vote 😂
lol lets goo!!!
Such an awesome video, wish there was the rest
It's been 7 years and im still waiting for part 2
"THE HELL WITH YOU" 😂😂
damn i forgot just how harsh everybody got with philip haha
coz he's a dumbass
After 6 years. Im still stayed tuned.
Legend says to this day, that he is still in the making of part 2
Still waiting for the rest of this list
She couldn’t stand 4 hours of rain? When I am, it does sometimes rain for over 7 hours. And we love it. Rather I’d stay cold than really hot and sweaty
4 years and I am still waiting for part 2
Matching this makes me wish Taj had a 2nd season.
6 and a half years have gone by, we need closure
Dude PLEASE finish this series it's the best
cirie's move is not dumb, it is not dumb for her to go against tom.. people around her were dumb..
Phillip is weird but he does make the game more interesting. At 2:25 when he said “yes i am gonna comment, I’m doing it now”. 😂
Why on earth is Phillip promoting his opponents?
I’ve never seen a list unfinished like this lmao
I'm disappointed that the list ends here.
This was a great first part.
I would’ve loved to see Tom and Cirie work together… the best strategists on the Heroes tribe, and so fun to watch.
I wish Cirie and Tom would've allied together. They would've dominated together.
TheMarshmallowBear
Even if Obama and Putin will allied together they will not dominate russel
Russell started this season off well, but later on, all he was was an anchor, chained to Parvati's ankles. He was so shit post-merge.
6 years later, and we will never know the rest of this list
It wasn't a dumb move, because Tom targeted Cirie first and she reacted by trying to take him out. JT, Tom and Colby pussed out because they were literally terrified of Cirie.
Ive been waiting for 7 years 😭
Bruh. I’ve been on a survivor binge on yt for like the past 2 weeks. And of any video/video series, when I saw this one, I was more excited to watch than any other video. I was disappointed when there wasn’t a second part. So I looked at when this came out only to see that it was 9 years ago and I’ve never been more let down.
Also. I can’t believe Phillip was on survivor over 9 years ago. I felt like that season was at most 5 years ago.
I stay tuned for six years now!
Phil kinda looks like Murr from impractical jokers
8 years and waiting
I stayed tune for 6 years
NaOnka leaving is still ridiculous
Watching this reminds me of how much I love Taj... what an amazing player!
When it's been six years and you don't know numbers 45-1
I just found out about this list, and I'm already triggered it wasn't finished
Rewatching that Final Tribal with Phillip just solidifies my disgust that Boston Rob won a season. It took him 4 attempts to win and look who he took to the end to finally guarentee that win.
"To hell with you"
"To hell with you"
*"To hell with you"*
Phillip still got a jury vote though funny enough! Also sometimes the jury pisses me off they are all bitter because they got blindsided. Also Ne Anca just pissed me off.
I personally think Cirie's move wasn't dumb. It is a strategic move. Get rid off the strongest player in the game is the smartest move.
I think Cirie goes a little overboard with that. She doesn't realize that she is considered a strong player because of her strategic ability. So, once you get rid of the challenge beasts Cirie is the biggest threat to everyone.
Been waiting six years🥵🤷♀️
say what you will about redemption island being a horrible season..that jury was MEAN
It’s now been 7 years where’s the rest of this list
This is excellent! I look forward too part 2.
My strategy: If you are a bad liar, don't try to lie. Just choose not to share information.
Couldn't stand Phillip in any season. in ever played in. I hated him more than Russell Hantz. I almost rather watch Russell then watch Phillip. It was good riddance to bad rubbish
I know this video is about dumb moves, but there's a very smart (or at least heroic) move that I want to give a shout out to. Holly giving up a reward of a movie and movie snacks with actual flavor for just herself (and her team), for getting new supplies and bland rice to eat for the whole tribe. I remember her say how much she wanted just one hot dog, but made the selfless move. She should've won.
been waiting 7 years.....any day now
I don't blame or think is was dumb of Phillip Sheppard to respond to the jury the way he did. If someone is going to be nasty to you and obviously are not going to vote for you anyway, why not dig back at them? Good for him.
Jeff is just loving this
I’ve waited 6 years now...
The philip thing could almost of been number 1 lol
R u still preparing your list
6 years later and still no update...
6 years still waiting for part 2
Tom was Ten Steps Ahead of cirie holy shit brilliant outplay!
Tom and Cirie were threatened by each other due to their legacies. Which is understandable on both of their parts. They were eliminated within one round of each other, there's nothing dumb about it.
I loved Stephanie and Rupert
When I saw Hero’s Vs Villans I was like “oh plot twist JT is gonna be at 46 to surprise everyone!”
I agree, I hate when people quit, but Survivor is not easy. I think people need to realize what their getting into. It is a hard 39 days.
I enjoyed watching Philip lol
homeboy left us hanging for 7 years now
oh greatness, where is the infamous survivor Micronesia immunity necklace
Yeah yeah NaOnka was selfish for not giving up her place for the good of the tribe but I wouldn't pass a unique Survivor experience either.