This negligence will have to cost big in the future, as if now we are paying our past mistakes this judgement proved that hunting poor In India is not illegal practice
Sir your analysis on every topic is very simple and easy to understand with full depth in facts. If you will become IFS it will very good thing for our country.
I remember when the Kerala Chief minister told that they will not hand over the marines till the fisher men family get justice but the central govt and Sonia Gandis intervention made them to go back to their original country!
@Gaurang Tiwari wahi to bjp election se phle vaha koi riots nahi hua tha per jaha apne pair jamane ho vaha riots krvao or majboot ho jao results samne h riots ka fayda kise hua or kiske jane se hua y tumhe nahi dikhega bhakti jo krni h terrorist ki🤔🤐
This is the insight that you don't get from regular news. My condolences to the families of the fishermen, who will not see justice done. Usually pirates would try to board a ship and will have tools for that. Based on what information did the Italians choose to open fire? Is Kerala Somalia? Did they think that the people looked the same? What else will you see from atop an oil tanker? Who targets people without warning shots? India must lodge strong action against Italy. India must protest against the longitude marked as the eastern end of piracy alert. Plus, 44 kms is not a long distance away from India and we still cannot protect our people there? Surely, this can be a security concern in future.
*_Contagious Zone should be considered as our judicial territory as the threat to our fishers are on the verge bcoz , the Marines of foreign nations are given freedom to shoot down any suspect even if the frontier is not a pirate. Therefore amendment must be done in the maritime security law 👍_*
अमर उजाला हिंदी अखबार ने छोटे से कॉलम में ये खबर छापी थी। पर डिटेल्स में आपकी वीडियो से ही पता चला। PCA ने मोटर व्हीकल ट्रिब्यूनल की तरह पीडितों को कंपनसेशन देने का अवार्ड इटली के फेवर में दिया।
amazing video...ultimate content and analysis with conclusion. keep growing standards sir. in context of this case i fully agree with your solution for draft in unclos from india....otherwise this would be a threat to our maritime security , let alone rightful dominance over indian ocean.
Very few people know this but there was congruence between Italy and India that Italian marines were to be released in order for Italy to vote in favour of India for it's admission into MTCR.
India is a soft state.... India desperately needed bad boys on the top... Bad boys means hard, real patriot, ruthless... He can only see Bharat Bharat n Bharat... Sote jagte sirf or sirf mata Bharti hi ankhome honi cahiye..... O fisherman nahi the oo Bharat bashi the.... Lata Didi ka Gana yad hena dosto.. .......jay Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳😢😢😢
I think India did the right thing, because it shows that India respects Int'l conventions and agreements, although the dead fishermen will be served injustice but that's how diplomacy works.
Sir you Perfectly explained such complicated topic. Those Italian naval officers have shot our citizens deliberately. Anyone can differentiate between a Somalian and an Indian.
Main iska editorial padh raha tha lekin bohot hee uninteresting lag raha tha phir aapka vdo dekha.. Phir wapas jaake editorial padha tab interesting lga
P.s. this is my personal opinion. Many ( educated) Indians ( as I believe) have started developing hatred towards Italy for following reasons: 1) Italy is a part of china’s Belt and road initiative (BRI)| 2) this incident, which at some point undermines India‘s sovereignty over its exclusive economic zone ( EEZ)| 3) ( specifically related to non congress supporters) Sonia Gandhi is of Italian origin.
Mahipal Sir. IIm ki fees 36% badh gayi hai. Please ek video banaiye. Sarkaar tak baat pahunche. Aaj ki date me car loan 7.5% hai r education loan 11.5% Loan lene jao th 7.5 lakh se upar kuch girwi rakhna padta hai. matlab kisi gareeb me agar chahe jitni achi management qualities hon wo kabhi IIM jo ek govt run institution hai usme kabhi bhi jaa nai sakta kyon? kyonki uske paas koi property nai hai.
@@papajones9560 tahir Hussain aur Vikas dubey ko log Terrorist bula rhe h kyoki vo terror faila rhe the with petrol bomb and guns. Google pe jo Terrorist ki definition h uske hisab se to ye dono Terrorist h. Lekin Indian government ne dono Terrorist declare nhi kiya h. Agar kashmir me kisi ke paas guns aur bomb nikal jaye to use bhi direct Terrorist bol dete h. Likin jab neta logo ke pass illegal guns milta h to unhe Terrorist nhi bolte. Sala Terrorist kaun Gangsters kaun kuch samaj nhi aa rha.
Now the question arises if Tomorrow Armed Personnel of Indian Container Ship shoot down a Fishing Boat in Contiguous zone of Italy, will the same verdict be used ? Or there would be extra judicial processes for Europeans ? Did the marines Fire Warning shots Prior to Shooting them Down if not then it is a clear case Murder
It's feels our citizen not more safe in their own territory. In this situation any high level politician and business shot down govt will think about hard step. Anyone can give damage.
Sir can uou plz start a series that covers all the well known agreements that have been signed between member state of UN after its formation.? It will be very helpful
It's our slow process that a confirmed case of death was not proven in Indian Court Of Law. It's slow process of PCA that it took 5 years for judgement.
Sir regarding the moral harm is concerned, it is all about the discretion of the judges to grant damages over the moral trauma caused. If any offence is committed, law is said to protect against such offence as well to compensate the traumatic experience he had suffered. For example in a case of defamation, a party also claim a huge amount of money as a compensation because his moral image has been tarnished in the society.
I remember this news But they were sent back Italian Ambassador's guarantee to Vote not for christmas and when Italian government denied to sent them back, Indian court had to ordered to take Italian Ambassador into custody
Sir we all appreciate the hard work and time you all put in, Thank you for all efforts. Sir, Moral harm is calculated and awarded through punitive damages (they are on top of compensations), although its one of the most complicated legal calculations within legal institutions. And in legal terms, there is a big difference between "Damage" and "Damages" My analysis, Govt. didn't disclose it because of political oppositions opinions, the current ruling party will benefit by leveraging the impacts of the wrong happened during govt. of another party, I mean we all know the state govt. is against the central govt. this incident shall be used locally on the grounds.
No bro. Compensation can not bring life. What if some one said i will kill u and your family will get 1crore. Direct action should be taken, they are abusing us. 😏😢😢
@@bhumiputra7987 like when the GOI saved your compatriots in Afghanistan. There were about 30 people, most of them were Indians, but it seems like you have a short memory
This is an international issue Both india and Italy have done as much as govt can do Italy especially ( maybe because it became a poltical issue there) PCA Judgement is trying appease both party. I wonder how italy and Europe would respond if their citizens are shot near their maritime territory ?
But we all knew it was a mistake not intentionally killed. So its good that they compensate to the Fisher mans family and rest legal proceedings can happen in Italy. Whether they are punished in India or Italy it doesn't matter to the family as their loved ones won't come back 😥
I think there needs to be some flexible amendment in the clause. Indian govt. should clearly demarcate territorial waters and contiguous zone using technology. If there is no special purpose then don't cross territorial waters, if need arises, then there should be a app where every govt. needs to notify that our ship is going to contiguous water,(for this the ship has to take prior permission), even if any mishap occurs then Indian govt. should have the right to take action.
Download our app - play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.studyiq.android
Sir apki age kya hai
Plz make video on 2017 INTERNATIONAL COMPARISON PROGRAM (IC) it's very confusing ...😣🙏🙏
AND ALSO BOP 2019-20 PUBLISHED BY RBI
Sir Foregin Ambecie...par ak vidoe please
Topic...Sir Foregin Ambecie...par ak vidoe please
This negligence will have to cost big in the future, as if now we are paying our past mistakes this judgement proved that hunting poor In India is not illegal practice
Poor, who are them do you know.
Dear, I think you didn't get this word the word "poor" has different meaning i used it as a weak, strength wise
Don’t use victim card
Congress is responsible for that
Sir your analysis on every topic is very simple and easy to understand with full depth in facts.
If you will become IFS it will very good thing for our country.
Agar sir, IFS ban jaate toh itni precious knowledge hume kaun deta
@ IFS pe naukri karna aur kuch aur karna alag baat hai
I remember when the Kerala Chief minister told that they will not hand over the marines till the fisher men family get justice but the central govt and Sonia Gandis intervention made them to go back to their original country!
Because for gandis Indian life doesn't matter.
@@BlackPanther-ji1bg like gujarat athenic clinsing and lyinching after 2014 and criminals are free
@@jethamillionviews560 same with them as well.
@Gaurang Tiwari vo sare log qatal ho gae but jisne gujrat mujaffrpur lyinching kri vo sb gov me h free h
@Gaurang Tiwari wahi to bjp election se phle vaha koi riots nahi hua tha per jaha apne pair jamane ho vaha riots krvao or majboot ho jao results samne h riots ka fayda kise hua or kiske jane se hua y tumhe nahi dikhega bhakti jo krni h terrorist ki🤔🤐
Finally complete analysis... The Hindu me ED padhe smjh me km aaya bt sir aapne pura clear kr deya... Thank u sir...
If someone inocent lost his life because of your misunderstanding then it's a crime.
The world must learn the value of Indian citizenship
Satyamev jayate 🙏
Haa yaar🙏🏻
govt withdrew the case
I hope those families will get a good amount of money
But still money can't bring those lives back
4 and 4 crore each fisherman will get
They killed 2 crimals not peacemakers
My favourite sir on this channel is mahipal sir.... excellent way of teaching sir...thank you from the bottom of my heart...
This is the insight that you don't get from regular news. My condolences to the families of the fishermen, who will not see justice done.
Usually pirates would try to board a ship and will have tools for that. Based on what information did the Italians choose to open fire? Is Kerala Somalia? Did they think that the people looked the same? What else will you see from atop an oil tanker? Who targets people without warning shots?
India must lodge strong action against Italy. India must protest against the longitude marked as the eastern end of piracy alert. Plus, 44 kms is not a long distance away from India and we still cannot protect our people there? Surely, this can be a security concern in future.
15:11 Very true sir. Since India will be member of UNSC in 2021... India should surely raise the point.
We have to increase our indian navy size so we can make sure for the protection of our fisherman and territory.
Video phir se dekho chutiye
Increasing navy size is not easy brother it takes a lot of time and a lot of money
But yes increasing the power of Navy is the need of the hour
Kya kuch v ..logic kya hai
Iske upar b ek mukadma chlaya jaaye katai chutiya aadmi h
@@bhanureddy2087 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Its always good to have Sir's personal views on the topic for more understanding and to know what should be the correct stand.
Yes Indian government should strongly consider this justification and surely proposed a amendment in UNCLOS thank you sir ♥️♥️
सर मेवात में हो रहे हिंदू पर आत्य चार पर वीडियो बनाए
किया यहां सही है plsss pless ???
Yes sir please make we want to see the truth
Ji ha
Kaha kuch ho rha waha toh baichaara hai itna.
~~Rubbish chacha
Shi kha
Ha sir please make a video
*_Contagious Zone should be considered as our judicial territory as the threat to our fishers are on the verge bcoz , the Marines of foreign nations are given freedom to shoot down any suspect even if the frontier is not a pirate.
Therefore amendment must be done in the maritime security law
👍_*
अमर उजाला हिंदी अखबार ने छोटे से कॉलम में ये खबर छापी थी। पर डिटेल्स में आपकी वीडियो से ही पता चला। PCA ने मोटर व्हीकल ट्रिब्यूनल की तरह पीडितों को कंपनसेशन देने का अवार्ड इटली के फेवर में दिया।
One short video of Mahipal Singh Rathore on any topic and you have enough information to talk about it in any interview.
I can't thank you enough.
Yes government should take a serious step towards the issue..
How complicated the case was !
But, you explained very well.
Thanks a lot.
And may god give you bless for your hard work.
Sir, If you don't mind but I support PCA and specially appreciate Italy because of their effort to save their people.
No one asking why government remain silent for month's & don't inform to the nation anything.
Finally all doubts r cleared about Enrica Lexie case... Thank you soo much sir!!
If such an incident does happen again in the future, the government of India will have to think about it.
Thanks sir for every video of study iq
We love u
Best teacher of virtual world
amazing video...ultimate content and analysis with conclusion. keep growing standards sir.
in context of this case i fully agree with your solution for draft in unclos from india....otherwise this would be a threat to our maritime security , let alone rightful dominance over indian ocean.
Very few people know this but there was congruence between Italy and India that Italian marines were to be released in order for Italy to vote in favour of India for it's admission into MTCR.
It looks like internal understanding between Italy and India to get rid out of this tension.. 🙂🙂
India is a soft state.... India desperately needed bad boys on the top... Bad boys means hard, real patriot, ruthless... He can only see Bharat Bharat n Bharat... Sote jagte sirf or sirf mata Bharti hi ankhome honi cahiye..... O fisherman nahi the oo Bharat bashi the....
Lata Didi ka Gana yad hena dosto.. .......jay Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳😢😢😢
Great value addition by you.
Your work is highly appreciated.
We may have lost ,but thats what laws says,
Winning a moral battle is not as important as to act like an responsible nation
I think India did the right thing, because it shows that India respects Int'l conventions and agreements, although the dead fishermen will be served injustice but that's how diplomacy works.
India should hire lawyer like Harish Salve as India hire for Kubhusan Jhadhav.......
Super explanation!!! 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Sir you Perfectly explained such complicated topic.
Those Italian naval officers have shot our citizens deliberately.
Anyone can differentiate between a Somalian and an Indian.
sir the judgment was by 3:2.
Italy blocked the entry of India in the MTCR in the year 2015 for the same case. Later when the marines were sent back, Italy supported India’s entry.
This is big lesson for our country, slap and risk also.
We can increase the boundaries of that zone for future securities
Main iska editorial padh raha tha lekin bohot hee uninteresting lag raha tha phir aapka vdo dekha.. Phir wapas jaake editorial padha tab interesting lga
Sir u r teach us very beautiful ty so much🌈🌈🌹🌹
Totally agree with you mahipal ji
P.s. this is my personal opinion. Many ( educated) Indians ( as I believe) have started developing hatred towards Italy for following reasons: 1) Italy is a part of china’s Belt and road initiative (BRI)| 2) this incident, which at some point undermines India‘s sovereignty over its exclusive economic zone ( EEZ)| 3) ( specifically related to non congress supporters) Sonia Gandhi is of Italian origin.
Sir, you are so much good at this and imparting knowledge so effectively and with pure neutrality.
Sir first a fall thankyou...I was waiting for this lecture since this topic came in news that India lost case against Italian marine case....
Thanx sir vry simple way me smjha diya apne
lecture was full of enegy ...thanks a lot sir
Fabulous...lectur
Ocean of knowledge- Mahipal Singh Rathore...
Mahipal Sir. IIm ki fees 36% badh gayi hai. Please ek video banaiye. Sarkaar tak baat pahunche. Aaj ki date me car loan 7.5% hai r education loan 11.5%
Loan lene jao th 7.5 lakh se upar kuch girwi rakhna padta hai. matlab kisi gareeb me agar chahe jitni achi management qualities hon wo kabhi IIM jo ek govt run institution hai usme kabhi bhi jaa nai sakta kyon? kyonki uske paas koi property nai hai.
Study IQ team should join politics.. we need leaders like u sir!
@@hm6715 i feel u
Sir ek video
Criminal
Gangsters
Terrorist
Ke difference pe video banao.
Log paglo ki tarah lad rhe h social media pe
mujh se poocho
@@papajones9560 tahir Hussain aur Vikas dubey ko log Terrorist bula rhe h kyoki vo terror faila rhe the with petrol bomb and guns.
Google pe jo Terrorist ki definition h uske hisab se to ye dono Terrorist h.
Lekin Indian government ne dono Terrorist declare nhi kiya h.
Agar kashmir me kisi ke paas guns aur bomb nikal jaye to use bhi direct Terrorist bol dete h.
Likin jab neta logo ke pass illegal guns milta h to unhe Terrorist nhi bolte.
Sala Terrorist kaun Gangsters kaun kuch samaj nhi aa rha.
Now the question arises if Tomorrow Armed Personnel of Indian Container Ship shoot down a Fishing Boat in Contiguous zone of Italy, will the same verdict be used ? Or there would be extra judicial processes for Europeans ? Did the marines Fire Warning shots Prior to Shooting them Down if not then it is a clear case Murder
Thanks a lot sir apne is topic pe video bnayi me bhut confuse thi is news me exactly kya h mtlb apne easily smza diya thanks again💯✔
Today sonia Gandhi will be the happiest person in the world
Why ?
@@yashwantchoudhari2080 😅😅😂
Antonia maino
@@yashwantchoudhari2080 love your innocence bro. Her nephew got fucking justice
You can get jailed for this comment (for defamation)
It's feels our citizen not more safe in their own territory.
In this situation any high level politician and business shot down govt will think about hard step.
Anyone can give damage.
this was totally new for me....thank you sir
Sir can uou plz start a series that covers all the well known agreements that have been signed between member state of UN after its formation.? It will be very helpful
11:50 Sir Indian and Jamaican judge ruled in favour of India. So we lost 3-2
I was waiting for this video.
@Slipknot when PCA gave its latest judgment.
Are you reading the Hindu newspaper??
@@pranavpatil6377 yes bro. 4th july k the hindu editorial me ye news tha.
🇮🇳🙏Namaste Sir jii🙏🇮🇳
Our nation too can use this case if anything will happened.
Thanks sir for this video. Hum ANI ka screenshot bhejne wale the ki aap video bna dijiye.😅
Thank you for the explanation sir
It's our slow process that a confirmed case of death was not proven in Indian Court Of Law. It's slow process of PCA that it took 5 years for judgement.
DNNAYVAAD SIR APKA 👍 👍 👍
And TNX TEAM STUDY IQ 👍 👍 👍
What a preposterous decision was that to send them back to Italy 🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
Very useful information.
I think it was a very intelligent judgement of it was not influenced by EU
That was just a mistake, we should understand this. Why would a cargo ship fire on a fish boat?
You are right sir un me reforms ki jaroorat hai
2013,Christmas and congress
Thank you sir , I was waiting for this video and as expected pura crystal clear kar diya matter.
Thank you🙏😇
Very very detailed analysis 👍👍
Sir regarding the moral harm is concerned, it is all about the discretion of the judges to grant damages over the moral trauma caused. If any offence is committed, law is said to protect against such offence as well to compensate the traumatic experience he had suffered. For example in a case of defamation, a party also claim a huge amount of money as a compensation because his moral image has been tarnished in the society.
I was waiting for this news... Well explain sir Thanku so much
Judgement is Fair yet Unfortunate One
in my opinion,marines were not at fault.
I remember this news
But they were sent back Italian Ambassador's guarantee to Vote not for christmas and when Italian government denied to sent them back, Indian court had to ordered to take Italian Ambassador into custody
Sir Maine "The Hindu" m pdha ki judgement "2-3" favour m aaya h
They shouldn't have booked him under the law of high sea instead regular IPC 302 which would have given India, the jurisdiction over these officers.
Court judgment has to accepte by indian government, as we have democratic country & we respect the law
Justice should be quick otherwise it is a unjustic to all acquitteds, victims, and societies
Very important case
@Rathoremahipal sir
Your analytics thinking cover every single concept makes us very informative sir
Huge Applaud for You sir
Sir we all appreciate the hard work and time you all put in, Thank you for all efforts. Sir, Moral harm is calculated and awarded through punitive damages (they are on top of compensations), although its one of the most complicated legal calculations within legal institutions. And in legal terms, there is a big difference between "Damage" and "Damages"
My analysis, Govt. didn't disclose it because of political oppositions opinions, the current ruling party will benefit by leveraging the impacts of the wrong happened during govt. of another party, I mean we all know the state govt. is against the central govt. this incident shall be used locally on the grounds.
Ok. I did not know about that (moral harm). Good to learn!
Thanks for such useful information
Compensation of 1,00,00,000 (1 crore rupees ) is given to family of both fisherman
No bro. Compensation can not bring life. What if some one said i will kill u and your family will get 1crore. Direct action should be taken, they are abusing us. 😏😢😢
@@bhumiputra7987 like when the GOI saved your compatriots in Afghanistan. There were about 30 people, most of them were Indians, but it seems like you have a short memory
This is an international issue
Both india and Italy have done as much as govt can do
Italy especially ( maybe because it became a poltical issue there)
PCA Judgement is trying appease both party.
I wonder how italy and Europe would respond if their citizens are shot near their maritime territory ?
Victim country should have jurisdiction for accused
Compensation for human life....??? ...HOW ..??????
Mai apke sath hoon!
Of this case hay happened with USA or Russia or China,
What would they have done?
But we all knew it was a mistake not intentionally killed. So its good that they compensate to the Fisher mans family and rest legal proceedings can happen in Italy. Whether they are punished in India or Italy it doesn't matter to the family as their loved ones won't come back 😥
25 km ke bahar machli pakadne mat jana, international water mey do not do fishing, there is shark
I think there needs to be some flexible amendment in the clause. Indian govt. should clearly demarcate territorial waters and contiguous zone using technology. If there is no special purpose then don't cross territorial waters, if need arises, then there should be a app where every govt. needs to notify that our ship is going to contiguous water,(for this the ship has to take prior permission), even if any mishap occurs then Indian govt. should have the right to take action.
सब अंतोनियो जी का कमाल है
Great video..big fan of u sir🇮🇳..keep up the good work
हेग होता है सर् जी हॉग नही🙏बाकी आप तो गुरु जी हो