I love the detail of the dad looking more and more scruffy and deranged every time we see him. This is about as far from a healthy outlet for his grief as it can get.
i am guilty of having the exact same fantasy of what i would do if someone did something that heinous to the people i love , i thought it would be such a satisfying feeling, but this movie is really confronting that fantasy and i don't think i would wish that to happen to anyone.
No fu¢king way could I want this on my rapist or the drunk driver that murdered my little brother; I thought about it I wanted to see the drunk driver actually fry and that was at the same time hurting my soul then I remembered °There but for the grace of God go I'° because I was/am sober and Big Mike was 14 year's sober and had just chaired a meeting at his home group; he said goodbye to his friends he got on his mother bike left the parking lot and got hit by a drunk driver I was 90 days sober and with time AA meetings and grief therapy and just fu¢king time I was able to meditate and pray until until I forget the man's name it wasn't about him anymore I just wanted peace and just remember Big Mike the anonymous sponsor that had almost a thousand people at his funeral; family, friends, and sponsee their families; I remember my lil bro every day and I'm still sober 15 yrs later; I had to find a way to forgive and pray for that man if I was going to maintain my sobriety and instead of hate forgiveness; so I could think of only one thing to pray for him and that was that he find AA or NA group in prison; I know I'm rambling but this is important to me I prayed death on that man and he died in the prison infirmary and to this day I feel guilty for that
@@justadudewholikestotalkSame, rapists don't deserve any sympathy, this would make them go through what their victims are going through mentally and as a rape survivor myself, I don't see why we should feel any remorse towards those monsters. You can kill somebody on accident, but you can't rape somebody on accident!
Only 12 minutes long but easily one of the most impactful movies I’ve ever watched That last line sent chills down my spine because I’d totally forgotten about that aspect of the punishment. 1000/10 would recommend to anyone that can stomach it
@@husky0098 “Except for the last week of the month. That’s when we go to the High Schools.” - for context, at the end, the guy is missing his nose, ears, lips, both arms and legs, his man hood, and a couple other things and he’s still being paraded around to atone for his crime. Absolutely gut wrenching
I think the moral issue comes from the fact that this was not a healing experience for the family, not even the father, and that the surgeons and nurses and other professionals involved seemed to take no pleasure in the amputations, and seemed to dread each surgery. The psychological impact creates more victims. In my opinion, Bingham deserved every second of his suffering for what he did to that little girl. However, taking this sort of revenge and enacting this punishment on another human being has a devastating impact on those in charge of carrying it out. Definitely a complicated and difficult situation to navigate. Great film.
@@sworthyboyI personally don’t think he deserves it. I would argue that he deserves death, but even in warfare where the goal is to kill you aren’t allowed to torture inhumanely. It’s just too far gone. And to show highschool kids a man slowly being amputated? Jesus Christ.
It also brings into light the matter of false accusations. Upon a wrongful conviction the physical loss would be permanent as well as the psychological trauma.
Truely phenomenal. So many things covered brilliantly. Pain turning to vengeance turning to possible regret at the end.. each daughter dropping away at their own realisation point. The audience having to realise a line in themselves to sympathise with Willie. Watching Willie's tragic downward plummet into darkness, helplessness, disfigurement & more. I could feel the dread & disappointment when the team would get the go ahead. I've not been so struck by a short film since 'X is for XXL' . Incredible job everyone involved 💙💚
Some of us don’t have to realise that line. We know there is right and wrong and the way you treat those that wronged you is far more telling of your moral character than how you treat those that haven’t wronged you or you even love.
@scesfizia That's the problem: People always think they already found that line. So they don't self-reflect or question themselves. People's lines get challenged through life. What you said sounded naive.
@nikkicassidy3429 Hi Sorry I took so long to reply. X is for XXL is a horror short from the film ABC's of Death (Warning - Very gruesome & disturbing for some people) where each letter is a short horror film by a different director or directors. X is for XXL is brutal & bloody but I personally love brilliant use of practical fx with little or even better, no cg. A woman is going home from work & people make fun of her weight at almost every turn. She gets home & spirals with bombardment of thin adverts on TV & in magazines.. those comments.. she binge eats. The brilliant insanity takes over, she goes into the bathroom & starts cutting into herself.. she gets the electric carving knife & carves her new figure. She steps out from the bathtub, poses, takes some some ragged breaths & collapses. It's incredible. My mum can't handle gore, so I skipped that bit, but I showed her & she agreed.. I wish more people knew about this. Hella visceral, but that message! Just wow.
To paraphrase Terry Pratchett: At an execution, there's something almost as terrible as the crime of the guilty. The smug satisfaction of the crowd. The pleasure of watching 'justice be done'.
The disturbing thing for me is that there really is no satisfaction in Willie's fate. His suffering doesn't bring the girl back, nor does it bring peace to her sisters. His advisor is clearly traumatized at the end by what he's done. And I think, for all those reasons, that's what makes this a truly great horror film. There's many of us who, when we hear about a horrible crime, wish nothing but the worst fate imaginable upon the perpetrator. But here, we actually get to see that fate be played out, and the sensation I feel is not a sense of justice, but just a deep, overwhelming feeling of disgust.
Looking at the comment section, I feel like this film needs an alternate ending where the guy is found to be innocent after the punishment. A lot of y'all seem to need a reminder that even if you think that stuff like this is an acceptable punishment, you can't always guarantee that the person receiving it is actually guilty.
Pretty sure if this was an actual punishment that people would receive for heinous crimes, they would make sure 100%. They were guilty. Sounds to me like you’re guilty of something.
@@shmh6002100% ? You underestimate how many loopholes can be taken advantage of in the system. As long as you have a suit ton of money and power you can influence anything. There are many wrongly convicted and accused of heinous crimes, with the real perpetrator Scot free just because of power. Evidence can be tampered and fabricated with the right amount of connection It's in every country
@@shmh6002 Up to 4% of people on death row in the USA are innocent. Multiple have been executed and later found to be innocent. Don't pretend for a second that "they would make sure 100% they were guilty." It's not possible.
My husband's grandmother was named Willie Bingham . I emailed Mr.Richards asking how he came up with the character's name and he was kind enough to answer me. I absolutely love this story. Don't drink and do drugs , or you'll end up like Willie Bingham. 😊
I heard just a piece of the plot about this from a short and made sure you got my view. Edit after watching: Great work from everyone. Acting, writing, scenery. All of it was amazing.
Good film. As a neurosurgeon this is odd because I know how twisted this is, if this were a real scenario, there wouldn't be enough enough surgeons for how families can be. Would I get it, I guess
This is so beautiful made message the cinematography how we’re seeing this threw a the surgeons point of you. How all the family expect the dad stop showing up. Willie face of remorse after the murder and punishment; to angry after the 1st surgery, to him just becoming more and more depressed of emotions and a shell of person literally and figuratively. It just so well done
It makes sense initially, but it can easily morph into revenge. Yes, he committed a horrible crime, or horrible crimes, but you might end up flipping the tables and becoming the perpetrator. Give one sentence and let it be; not incremental sentences that are meant to torment the person
Honestly for someone who SA’d and murdered a child, he seemed to be more upset about the punishment than his actual crime. Even at the beginning of the film he was defending his actions by blaming the drugs and alcohol, downplaying his moral responsibility. I would imagine someone who is truly sorry would not want this but would say they deserve this. Not a defense of this, but I think there’s a deeper conversation beyond “revenge bad, feel bad for Willie”.
Honestly I think that this argument would be more split if they showed what he did to the girl also we get to see how much pain he's in and how awful it is for him if we saw how he raped and murdered a child from the child's prospective I think a lot more people wouldn't feel bad for him
Na bíblia diz "se arrependa do que cometeu, e não do que você seria sem sua punição" tipo se arrependa por o que te fez ir para seu castigo e não apenas o fato de ser castigado
I don’t feel as bad for him as I feel for the kids being forced to watch his procedures or the kids he speaks to at the schools. They’re just traumatizing more kids by putting them in that situation, it’s more harm than good
The crime Willie committed is undoubtedly horrific and deserves severe punishment. However, I think that the punishment method used is way too severe even for him. Simply hearing about it before even watching the short film made me sick to my stomach, and watching it just made it worse. I don't justify his actions at all, but I think this torture method is too much... In my opinion It's also way too cruel to display that in front of kids, no matter how problematic they may be. But with all that said, this is a very well-made film that I would recommend but to people who can handle it better than me.
Esto no es justicia, esto es venganza. El problema es que a veces la justicia no hace bien su trabajo pero bajo ningún concepto se debería llegar a tales extremos tan atroces.
I sent this posting to a friend who viewed it and they became angry with me! I’m not sure why. It’s a fictional movie. They had extremely strong feelings about it and they never specifically articulated what those feelings were. They said I lacked poor judgment in presenting it to them. While they are entitled to their feelings, I think their vision and thinking are skewed. This is not a blood and gore horror movie with intensely bloody scenes. It’s a psychological presentation about revenge. It’s doing what a great movie does! It stimulates your emotions and thoughts. I totally related to all the characters. If someone hurt my husband, child or someone I deeply loved, I would have to confront many “not so nice” feelings within my soul. How far would I go when it’s a personal situation? Until it’s you, you never really know.
if you dont even know what upset them how can you say their thinking is skewed? it makes you sympathize with a child rapist and murderer, potentially a touchy subject to some???
They could just be touchy about violent themes? Or have been a victim of child abuse and therefore being triggered by being put in the predator's pov? Just... this is a very heavy film with heavy subjects, maybe next time just say "hey I saw this really cool thing but it's kinda dark and talks about this or that just so u know" so people don't blow up at u for sending them fucked up stuff lol
@@shootingblueyesThe subject is disturbing - yes that’s true. To stop talking to me is another thing. I also do not think they are victims of a child rapist. Actually one of them is a therapist. Therapists should be accustomed to dark, perverse events. What do people talk about in therapy? It can’t always be pretty things. I did not produce, write nor act in this short film. Perhaps I’m somewhat accustomed to dark subjects. I worked in emergency services for years.
There are maybe thousands of short horror movies out there, and most are clichés, full of cheap jumpscares, predictable and boring. NOT this one, this is outstanding from every point ov view. Many thanks to those who
This is so amazingly made and it makes people realize that someone that has done very very bad stuff like this doesnt deserve all pain and suffering. This is just something i wish for no one. It probably made people realize when the bad guy becomes the victim. Probs to you/whoever made this masterpiece if a short film
you only say that cuz he is made ti be the victim here. What if this video was from the point of view of the child getting raped ? Or literalmente the real victim ? You have simpaty for the wrong guy ,Emily.
@@sjshsnsjjs5531If you think feelings should dictate legal punishments, then I hope you never enter a courtroom or become a police officer. You have sympathy for the victim, but that doesn't mean they get to decide the legal punishment.
@@sjshsnsjjs5531 Right? People who feel sympathy towards rapists and pedos are so odd. I'm a rape survivor, my rapist took my basic human rights from me and destroyed me, so why should he get to keep his? When somebody chooses to rape a person or a child, they are giving away their own human rights with that, where I grew up in Serbia, if those monsters managed to survive prison, half of the country would be waiting for them on the outside and make them disappear, those people won't change after a couple of years and the people that take care of them are looking out for all of us!
and this is why we don't give the government the power to imprison people and enact horrible violence and torture, no matter who they are :) great film!
We do by looking the other way. The usa operates black sites globally, torture far worse than this, worse than you can imagine on people who never got a trial. It's an open secret.
This hurt me to watch. Like it was so deep. Yes he deserved suffering for what he did. But there is a line for that and it was passed probably after his first surgery. After that I think it is just making him a vegetable for their satisfaction while he endured it and felt it. How inhumane it was and helpless I felt watching that actually impacted me
I thought I was a sadist but I actually cried. I don't know if I'd feel different if the one receiving it was the kinda criminal that never regret or even enjoy their crime. I almost begged at the end for him to be granted death penalty . . . Gawd I'm crying. I never thought I still have empathy and compassion in my heart.
If you think Willy deserved it, you missed the point and you are no better than him. No one wins in this situation. The victim is not brought back, the family has no catharsis and the medical team are deeply traumatized. It's just torture for torture's sake. Yes, what he did was awful. But this is not a proper punishment.
The thing is, it’s very hard to tell if this is a real story or if it is extremely amazingly accurate to a real life story. Amazing work everyone. May god bless everyone ❤
This film is commentary on the justice system yes what he did was horrible unforgivable act but he was sick he was drunk and needed help. Yes he should receive punishment but nothing like this. This is inhuman what if a person was wrongfully convicted like many in our system Jesus Christ y’all missed the message
people cant wrongly get convicted for this shit either and even if they do its very rare. + kids mostly don’t lie and there was most probs all sorts of evidence to the mrder and rpe so whats the problem☠️what they do is more sick and twisted bye
Being drunk makes you throw up and dance and pass out not rape and kill a little girl he was a very very very sick man who probably had those thoughts sober too he couldn't even properly apologize after tormenting and killing a little girl it was just excuses excuses excuses someone like this should never ever get to go back to normal society
@@user82299what if this punishment doesn't just extend to murderers, or rapists. What if it's petty theft next, drugs next. After all, if more people are punished in this way, then more profit.
As an amputee, this whole short film angered me. I understand that as far as we know William killed a child, but that doesn't give them the right to take his body. I have had to live without a limb, all my life. And it still hurt me. I have been mocked on the fact I have to wear a prosthetic. I live in paranoia that one day other parts of me will be gone. Nothing, and I mean nothing would make amputation as a punishment sit right with me. I hoped throughout the video they'd just put him out of his misery, but they just made him a husk of a man with no way for true reform.
This is a very interesting movie with a interesting concept i like it in a weird way. The only problem is the subtitles are in french for some reason and ive a hearing disorder so i couldnt understand all of it
I think the issues here are: the curgeries are a cold blood punishment for 1 act of hot blood. The murder only thought and decided 1 time, 1 moment... but the father had probably years to think and many times deciding. The doctors and nurses are not criminals and they dint feel the pain of the family, the daily absense of the person, the grief that never ends, so they really dont understand the point and clearly are judging the father. The criminal seems to feel kind of unjusticed to change parts of himself for a whole person who he'd cut off of this world. He is being "killed" little by little by the father and doctors, who are not killers like him, in exchange of his murder of a inocent child, priveted not only her body, but her very existence, her dreams, everything she was supposed to experience, the impact she would made in the world. He, on the other side, is a criminal, guilty, whose impact in the world was the worst possible, extremily damaged, and he'd probably taken life in prision, whivh means his life is now kind of over, useless and, dispite of loosing his body, his life and kind of comfort (or at least his main needings) are intact and mantained. I think, cold blood speaking, he had nothing to feel sorry for. Finally, the father, despite of his attemps to feel that justice had been made, could never feel satified, because any piece of bofies or any whole life taken off could give back the person he lost... it has literaly no point in the whole process. Well, it is indeed very compicated...
It seems to me that if the operations (donation) were to benefit sick people (kidney transplant, part of the liver, cornea, intestines, lung and, finally, heart), it would be righ
I think this definitely would work on deterring crime. I have NEVER taken drugs because of a newspaper article of a gir overdosed on the front page. I saw it when I was about 11. Job done. Brain stained.
Yo si estaría de acuerdo en que implementarán esto, pero com asesinos seriales, que hayan matado a varias personas, que sea comprobable, no digo que una vida no sea valiosa, pero es un castigo inhumano para gente inhumana.
Sí. En el vídeo se ve que el Sr Bingham hizo lo que hizo únicamente por intoxicación. No es para decir que este motivo lo disculpa, sino que si alguien está tan intoxicado como para hacer una barbaridad así, está también demasiado intoxicado para pensar en las consecuencias. Literalmente es incapaz de hacerlo.
THIS SCARED THE SHIT OUTTTA ME I HAVENT WATCHED IT YET THOUGH SINCE ITS TOO LATE AND I WOULD BE TOO SCARED TO WATDCH IT IN MUDDKE OF NIGHT BUT ILL WATCH IT LATER MATT RICHARDS! IT WILL MSOT LIKELY BE GOOD BUT SCARY (IN A GOOD WAY...) ILL WATCH THIS LATER AND GIVE MY HINEST OPPION LATER IN THE COMMJENT.S... SEE YOU SOON MATT RICHARDA!!
Que fuerte, me quede sin palabras, sintiendo mucho por los profecionales q tenían q hacer las cirugías, y proseso quedan traumatizados también, pero entro en controversia hay asecinos psicópatas q si merecen esto y pedofilos también, hay nose me quede en shock 😮😮😮
Crimes pesados deveriam ser punidos assim, com provas concretas contra a pessoa e se ela tivesse mais passagens no passado ou ter sido pega em flagrante n tem como errar
I don’t feel bad for him at all. I feel like the film wanted us to feel bad for him by showing his story but not the family of the girl he harmed. He did unspeakable things so he deserved his punishment. I believe if people had this as a punishment they would be less bold. People who use harm others with their private areas don’t need them, in my opinion.
I find it unethical, there are many other forms of punishment like life of prison or execution not only that if this were to become a thing millions of dollars from tax payers will be waisted on this stuff. In the end the father and daughters were more traumatized and this becomes a lose lose situation for anyone involved.
@@Malez548 The family would have never been so traumatized if he didn’t do the disgusting things he did to their family member. Also we don’t know what the family went through exactly or why the daughters stopped coming because the film barely showed their story. A life sentence does nothing but deep a monster alive & even with executions a lot of people don’t show remorse or fear. If they could experience the pain they caused they could die feeling the pain they inflicted.
Amazing short film, definitely a masterpiece imagined. I understand the feeling this was meant to provide, the reality we've all wished when watching true crimes and cases. My bizarre take however is within it's lack of justification.. Willie is the protagonist. All the viewer's knew was that he raped and killed this little girl.. simplified and undescribed.. this whole short was the consequence. Which is very twisted of course... the sympathy of the commenters here are understandable, or at least their self-realization that no human should go through with such torture no matter the wickedness they've done. But if the short dove deeper to what he did to the little girl (even the sligthest glimpse from the little girl's point of view...) before the events in the video... I feel like the comment section will be a lot more divided than its current state. I confess that I can't show pity to killers (extremely few exceptions), but especially not child killers. a five-minute section of the little girl's perspective of her experiences in Willie's hands, followed by his slow dismemberment as punishment. if Sympathy is a tangible $100 bill.. I'm pretty I'm giving at least $90 of that to the real victim.
Just NO! This is not fair i dont wish this on my worse enemy....amount of crime doesnt matter there are people who get wrongfully convicted as well.. this makes one no different than the criminal they are as sick as the criminal themselves just no
@@Alex-yb6yjI dont care. The removal of limbs is too horrid and cruel. I would not wish this upon my worst enemy, and no one, not the Devil, not a ruthless dictator, not someone as horrible as Willie should have this happen to them.
I love the detail of the dad looking more and more scruffy and deranged every time we see him. This is about as far from a healthy outlet for his grief as it can get.
i am guilty of having the exact same fantasy of what i would do if someone did something that heinous to the people i love , i thought it would be such a satisfying feeling, but this movie is really confronting that fantasy and i don't think i would wish that to happen to anyone.
No fu¢king way could I want this on my rapist or the drunk driver that murdered my little brother; I thought about it I wanted to see the drunk driver actually fry and that was at the same time hurting my soul then I remembered °There but for the grace of God go I'° because I was/am sober and Big Mike was 14 year's sober and had just chaired a meeting at his home group; he said goodbye to his friends he got on his mother bike left the parking lot and got hit by a drunk driver I was 90 days sober and with time AA meetings and grief therapy and just fu¢king time I was able to meditate and pray until until I forget the man's name it wasn't about him anymore I just wanted peace and just remember Big Mike the anonymous sponsor that had almost a thousand people at his funeral; family, friends, and sponsee their families; I remember my lil bro every day and I'm still sober 15 yrs later; I had to find a way to forgive and pray for that man if I was going to maintain my sobriety and instead of hate forgiveness; so I could think of only one thing to pray for him and that was that he find AA or NA group in prison; I know I'm rambling but this is important to me I prayed death on that man and he died in the prison infirmary and to this day I feel guilty for that
Looks like you found a moral compass.
This took it away? This just made me want this even more
@@justadudewholikestotalk Please never have children.
@@justadudewholikestotalkSame, rapists don't deserve any sympathy, this would make them go through what their victims are going through mentally and as a rape survivor myself, I don't see why we should feel any remorse towards those monsters. You can kill somebody on accident, but you can't rape somebody on accident!
Only 12 minutes long but easily one of the most impactful movies I’ve ever watched
That last line sent chills down my spine because I’d totally forgotten about that aspect of the punishment.
1000/10 would recommend to anyone that can stomach it
I can't stomach it but still am curious, what is the last line?
@@husky0098
“Except for the last week of the month. That’s when we go to the High Schools.”
- for context, at the end, the guy is missing his nose, ears, lips, both arms and legs, his man hood, and a couple other things and he’s still being paraded around to atone for his crime.
Absolutely gut wrenching
@@Nahnah111 ty
I think the moral issue comes from the fact that this was not a healing experience for the family, not even the father, and that the surgeons and nurses and other professionals involved seemed to take no pleasure in the amputations, and seemed to dread each surgery. The psychological impact creates more victims.
In my opinion, Bingham deserved every second of his suffering for what he did to that little girl.
However, taking this sort of revenge and enacting this punishment on another human being has a devastating impact on those in charge of carrying it out.
Definitely a complicated and difficult situation to navigate. Great film.
There's also if you can trust the system to never ever make a mistake and convict the wrong person
Also, although bingams case was justified. I am unsure that ither criminals deserve this.
@@sworthyboyI personally don’t think he deserves it. I would argue that he deserves death, but even in warfare where the goal is to kill you aren’t allowed to torture inhumanely. It’s just too far gone. And to show highschool kids a man slowly being amputated? Jesus Christ.
It also brings into light the matter of false accusations. Upon a wrongful conviction the physical loss would be permanent as well as the psychological trauma.
Truely phenomenal.
So many things covered brilliantly.
Pain turning to vengeance turning to possible regret at the end.. each daughter dropping away at their own realisation point.
The audience having to realise a line in themselves to sympathise with Willie.
Watching Willie's tragic downward plummet into darkness, helplessness, disfigurement & more.
I could feel the dread & disappointment when the team would get the go ahead.
I've not been so struck by a short film since 'X is for XXL' .
Incredible job everyone involved 💙💚
Thanks so much for the kind words! I appreciate you taking the time to comment and glad you enjoyed it.
What is X is for XXL about?
Some of us don’t have to realise that line. We know there is right and wrong and the way you treat those that wronged you is far more telling of your moral character than how you treat those that haven’t wronged you or you even love.
@scesfizia That's the problem: People always think they already found that line.
So they don't self-reflect or question themselves.
People's lines get challenged through life.
What you said sounded naive.
@nikkicassidy3429 Hi
Sorry I took so long to reply.
X is for XXL is a horror short from the film ABC's of Death (Warning - Very gruesome & disturbing for some people) where each letter is a short horror film by a different director or directors.
X is for XXL is brutal & bloody but I personally love brilliant use of practical fx with little or even better, no cg.
A woman is going home from work & people make fun of her weight at almost every turn.
She gets home & spirals with bombardment of thin adverts on TV & in magazines.. those comments.. she binge eats.
The brilliant insanity takes over, she goes into the bathroom & starts cutting into herself.. she gets the electric carving knife & carves her new figure.
She steps out from the bathtub, poses, takes some some ragged breaths & collapses.
It's incredible.
My mum can't handle gore, so I skipped that bit, but I showed her & she agreed.. I wish more people knew about this. Hella visceral, but that message! Just wow.
To paraphrase Terry Pratchett: At an execution, there's something almost as terrible as the crime of the guilty. The smug satisfaction of the crowd. The pleasure of watching 'justice be done'.
The disturbing thing for me is that there really is no satisfaction in Willie's fate. His suffering doesn't bring the girl back, nor does it bring peace to her sisters. His advisor is clearly traumatized at the end by what he's done. And I think, for all those reasons, that's what makes this a truly great horror film. There's many of us who, when we hear about a horrible crime, wish nothing but the worst fate imaginable upon the perpetrator. But here, we actually get to see that fate be played out, and the sensation I feel is not a sense of justice, but just a deep, overwhelming feeling of disgust.
Looking at the comment section, I feel like this film needs an alternate ending where the guy is found to be innocent after the punishment. A lot of y'all seem to need a reminder that even if you think that stuff like this is an acceptable punishment, you can't always guarantee that the person receiving it is actually guilty.
Pretty sure if this was an actual punishment that people would receive for heinous crimes, they would make sure 100%. They were guilty. Sounds to me like you’re guilty of something.
Se for alegar isso não vai poder prender ninguém, já que se pode condenar inocentes.
@@shmh6002100% ? You underestimate how many loopholes can be taken advantage of in the system. As long as you have a suit ton of money and power you can influence anything. There are many wrongly convicted and accused of heinous crimes, with the real perpetrator Scot free just because of power. Evidence can be tampered and fabricated with the right amount of connection
It's in every country
@@shmh6002 Up to 4% of people on death row in the USA are innocent. Multiple have been executed and later found to be innocent. Don't pretend for a second that "they would make sure 100% they were guilty." It's not possible.
That’s a really fair point
If we match the monsters we trapped, in the end, there will only be monsters left!
My husband's grandmother was named Willie Bingham . I emailed Mr.Richards asking how he came up with the character's name and he was kind enough to answer me. I absolutely love this story. Don't drink and do drugs , or you'll end up like Willie Bingham. 😊
It makes me think that if a system like this were to happen, many innocent people could suffer and endure the same pain as him.
E muitos criminosos deixariam de matar e estuprar por medo. Vale a pena
I heard just a piece of the plot about this from a short and made sure you got my view.
Edit after watching:
Great work from everyone. Acting, writing, scenery. All of it was amazing.
So sensitive! A masterpiece! Congratulations cast and crew! 👏👏👏
Good film.
As a neurosurgeon this is odd because I know how twisted this is, if this were a real scenario, there wouldn't be enough enough surgeons for how families can be.
Would I get it, I guess
I really hope if I ever stood there for the first time, I'd be able to say "Don’t proceed!" no matter how much pain they caused me.
This is so beautiful made message the cinematography how we’re seeing this threw a the surgeons point of you. How all the family expect the dad stop showing up. Willie face of remorse after the murder and punishment; to angry after the 1st surgery, to him just becoming more and more depressed of emotions and a shell of person literally and figuratively. It just so well done
Thanks so much for your kind words!
It makes sense initially, but it can easily morph into revenge. Yes, he committed a horrible crime, or horrible crimes, but you might end up flipping the tables and becoming the perpetrator. Give one sentence and let it be; not incremental sentences that are meant to torment the person
its frightening how quickly the victim can turn into the abuser...
what's wrong with revenge?
@Dododeath violence breeds more violence
Revenge doesn't right any wrongs. It doesn't erase the damage done by bad people, it's just more damage. @@Dododeath
@@dont_even_view2985 only in movies
Honestly for someone who SA’d and murdered a child, he seemed to be more upset about the punishment than his actual crime. Even at the beginning of the film he was defending his actions by blaming the drugs and alcohol, downplaying his moral responsibility. I would imagine someone who is truly sorry would not want this but would say they deserve this. Not a defense of this, but I think there’s a deeper conversation beyond “revenge bad, feel bad for Willie”.
Honestly I think that this argument would be more split if they showed what he did to the girl also we get to see how much pain he's in and how awful it is for him if we saw how he raped and murdered a child from the child's prospective I think a lot more people wouldn't feel bad for him
but he only feel even more wronged as it just turned into revenge
Na bíblia diz "se arrependa do que cometeu, e não do que você seria sem sua punição" tipo se arrependa por o que te fez ir para seu castigo e não apenas o fato de ser castigado
@@rubyfox6997what he did to the girl? The idea s revolting and disgusting as is. It doesn't need to be shown to know how vile it is
I don’t feel as bad for him as I feel for the kids being forced to watch his procedures or the kids he speaks to at the schools. They’re just traumatizing more kids by putting them in that situation, it’s more harm than good
This made me feel sick deep inside
The crime Willie committed is undoubtedly horrific and deserves severe punishment. However, I think that the punishment method used is way too severe even for him. Simply hearing about it before even watching the short film made me sick to my stomach, and watching it just made it worse. I don't justify his actions at all, but I think this torture method is too much...
In my opinion It's also way too cruel to display that in front of kids, no matter how problematic they may be.
But with all that said, this is a very well-made film that I would recommend but to people who can handle it better than me.
Esto no es justicia, esto es venganza. El problema es que a veces la justicia no hace bien su trabajo pero bajo ningún concepto se debería llegar a tales extremos tan atroces.
Literally shut up🤗
É fácil criticar quando não temos uma filha envolvida
I sent this posting to a friend who viewed it and they became angry with me! I’m not sure why. It’s a fictional movie. They had extremely strong feelings about it and they never specifically articulated what those feelings were. They said I lacked poor judgment in presenting it to them. While they are entitled to their feelings, I think their vision and thinking are skewed. This is not a blood and gore horror movie with intensely bloody scenes. It’s a psychological presentation about revenge. It’s doing what a great movie does! It stimulates your emotions and thoughts.
I totally related to all the characters. If someone hurt my husband, child or someone I deeply loved, I would have to confront many “not so nice” feelings within my soul. How far would I go when it’s a personal situation? Until it’s you, you never really know.
if you dont even know what upset them how can you say their thinking is skewed?
it makes you sympathize with a child rapist and murderer, potentially a touchy subject to some???
It's horrifically disturbing, are you joking? Very upsetting subject matter.
Yap yap yap
They could just be touchy about violent themes? Or have been a victim of child abuse and therefore being triggered by being put in the predator's pov? Just... this is a very heavy film with heavy subjects, maybe next time just say "hey I saw this really cool thing but it's kinda dark and talks about this or that just so u know" so people don't blow up at u for sending them fucked up stuff lol
@@shootingblueyesThe subject is disturbing - yes that’s true. To stop talking to me is another thing. I also do not think they are victims of a child rapist. Actually one of them is a therapist. Therapists should be accustomed to dark, perverse events. What do people talk about in therapy? It can’t always be pretty things. I did not produce, write nor act in this short film. Perhaps I’m somewhat accustomed to dark subjects. I worked in emergency services for years.
There are maybe thousands of short horror movies out there, and most are clichés, full of cheap jumpscares, predictable and boring. NOT this one, this is outstanding from every point ov view. Many thanks to those who
This is so amazingly made and it makes people realize that someone that has done very very bad stuff like this doesnt deserve all pain and suffering. This is just something i wish for no one. It probably made people realize when the bad guy becomes the victim. Probs to you/whoever made this masterpiece if a short film
you only say that cuz he is made ti be the victim here. What if this video was from the point of view of the child getting raped ? Or literalmente the real victim ? You have simpaty for the wrong guy ,Emily.
@@sjshsnsjjs5531you can have sympathy for more than one person
@@sjshsnsjjs5531If you think feelings should dictate legal punishments, then I hope you never enter a courtroom or become a police officer.
You have sympathy for the victim, but that doesn't mean they get to decide the legal punishment.
@@sjshsnsjjs5531 Right? People who feel sympathy towards rapists and pedos are so odd. I'm a rape survivor, my rapist took my basic human rights from me and destroyed me, so why should he get to keep his? When somebody chooses to rape a person or a child, they are giving away their own human rights with that, where I grew up in Serbia, if those monsters managed to survive prison, half of the country would be waiting for them on the outside and make them disappear, those people won't change after a couple of years and the people that take care of them are looking out for all of us!
@@sjshsnsjjs5531true, cause there’s similar content in American Mary and we’re on her side
and this is why we don't give the government the power to imprison people and enact horrible violence and torture, no matter who they are :) great film!
We do by looking the other way. The usa operates black sites globally, torture far worse than this, worse than you can imagine on people who never got a trial. It's an open secret.
This hurt me to watch. Like it was so deep.
Yes he deserved suffering for what he did. But there is a line for that and it was passed probably after his first surgery. After that I think it is just making him a vegetable for their satisfaction while he endured it and felt it. How inhumane it was and helpless I felt watching that actually impacted me
I thought I was a sadist but I actually cried. I don't know if I'd feel different if the one receiving it was the kinda criminal that never regret or even enjoy their crime. I almost begged at the end for him to be granted death penalty . . . Gawd I'm crying. I never thought I still have empathy and compassion in my heart.
If you think Willy deserved it, you missed the point and you are no better than him. No one wins in this situation. The victim is not brought back, the family has no catharsis and the medical team are deeply traumatized. It's just torture for torture's sake. Yes, what he did was awful. But this is not a proper punishment.
E qual seria a punição adequada para a monstruosidade que ele cometeu?
"An eye for an eye leaves the whole world blind."
~Mahatma Gandhi
Wasn't that the guy with a child for a wife? Who refused to let her have life saving surgery then when ill himself choes to be operated on?
The thing is, it’s very hard to tell if this is a real story or if it is extremely amazingly accurate to a real life story. Amazing work everyone. May god bless everyone ❤
At least he was under anesthesia. His victim wasn’t.
Concordo
This film is commentary on the justice system yes what he did was horrible unforgivable act but he was sick he was drunk and needed help. Yes he should receive punishment but nothing like this. This is inhuman what if a person was wrongfully convicted like many in our system Jesus Christ y’all missed the message
people cant wrongly get convicted for this shit either and even if they do its very rare. + kids mostly don’t lie and there was most probs all sorts of evidence to the mrder and rpe so whats the problem☠️what they do is more sick and twisted bye
Being drunk makes you throw up and dance and pass out not rape and kill a little girl he was a very very very sick man who probably had those thoughts sober too he couldn't even properly apologize after tormenting and killing a little girl it was just excuses excuses excuses someone like this should never ever get to go back to normal society
@@user82299what if this punishment doesn't just extend to murderers, or rapists. What if it's petty theft next, drugs next. After all, if more people are punished in this way, then more profit.
I wish they could donate is parts to people that need it
"La venganza nunca es buena, mata el alma y la envenena." - El filósofo de Güemes
Pensei que o seu Madruga tinha inventado essa.
Bruh traumatizing kids 😭
Teach em not to rape and murder anyone
@@ChrisMcmahon-h8xYou really think it would have that effect? An exceedingly common reason for these type of crimes is childhood trauma
Alright, I'll send this to my friends so they can feel as miserable as I did when I watched this
I don’t know if I have ever been impacted more psychologically than I was for this 13:00. Really, really good job.
I fell bad for every person I did this to in Rimworld
Ir nas escolas e falar sobre o assunto foi pessado demais
As an amputee, this whole short film angered me. I understand that as far as we know William killed a child, but that doesn't give them the right to take his body. I have had to live without a limb, all my life. And it still hurt me. I have been mocked on the fact I have to wear a prosthetic. I live in paranoia that one day other parts of me will be gone. Nothing, and I mean nothing would make amputation as a punishment sit right with me. I hoped throughout the video they'd just put him out of his misery, but they just made him a husk of a man with no way for true reform.
Saw it in Fantosfreak, my favorite one!
This is a very interesting movie with a interesting concept i like it in a weird way. The only problem is the subtitles are in french for some reason and ive a hearing disorder so i couldnt understand all of it
You can select the subtitles. You can chose English subtitles.
Man that is scarry like a horror film
I think the issues here are: the curgeries are a cold blood punishment for 1 act of hot blood. The murder only thought and decided 1 time, 1 moment... but the father had probably years to think and many times deciding. The doctors and nurses are not criminals and they dint feel the pain of the family, the daily absense of the person, the grief that never ends, so they really dont understand the point and clearly are judging the father. The criminal seems to feel kind of unjusticed to change parts of himself for a whole person who he'd cut off of this world. He is being "killed" little by little by the father and doctors, who are not killers like him, in exchange of his murder of a inocent child, priveted not only her body, but her very existence, her dreams, everything she was supposed to experience, the impact she would made in the world. He, on the other side, is a criminal, guilty, whose impact in the world was the worst possible, extremily damaged, and he'd probably taken life in prision, whivh means his life is now kind of over, useless and, dispite of loosing his body, his life and kind of comfort (or at least his main needings) are intact and mantained. I think, cold blood speaking, he had nothing to feel sorry for. Finally, the father, despite of his attemps to feel that justice had been made, could never feel satified, because any piece of bofies or any whole life taken off could give back the person he lost... it has literaly no point in the whole process. Well, it is indeed very compicated...
It’s crazy how this video has less than 10% of the views that the one on Omeletto has. I understand that it says it’s used with permission
It seems to me that if the operations (donation) were to benefit sick people (kidney transplant, part of the liver, cornea, intestines, lung and, finally, heart), it would be righ
This is really good.
God bless the hipocratic oath that prevents this
Why didn’t he try to commit suicide before the first amputation? Did they make sure he couldn't?
Alguém sabe o nome do filme
I think this definitely would work on deterring crime. I have NEVER taken drugs because of a newspaper article of a gir overdosed on the front page. I saw it when I was about 11. Job done. Brain stained.
Nice
Bro got the korblox bundle☠️
Yo si estaría de acuerdo en que implementarán esto, pero com asesinos seriales, que hayan matado a varias personas, que sea comprobable, no digo que una vida no sea valiosa, pero es un castigo inhumano para gente inhumana.
“Gente inhumana” acabas de cometer una contradicción amigo. Y además esto tampoco es aceptable para los animales, que eso también es ilegal
Wow, a child rapist and murderer though, hope he wasn't innocent
he admits to what he did in the film
Also at the beginning the guy said that he mutilated the little girl afterwards @@dragonspeaks5973
Madness
The hamurabi aprovet this
Soooo dark. Holy mackerel.
La maldad humana no tiene límites
they cut off little mr Bingham 😮 that was to much . he even cant be a wanker 😵💫😵💫
Se a punição fosse essa, será que alguém cometeria crimes como esse????
Sí. En el vídeo se ve que el Sr Bingham hizo lo que hizo únicamente por intoxicación. No es para decir que este motivo lo disculpa, sino que si alguien está tan intoxicado como para hacer una barbaridad así, está también demasiado intoxicado para pensar en las consecuencias. Literalmente es incapaz de hacerlo.
한국어 자막이 있었으면....
Hoping to get the Korean subs from cineherb :)
Onde tem esse filme
Australia
When fighting monsters...
자막좀.....ㅠㅠ
This is a metaphor for life sentence, right?
No podría. Está bien que uno quiera justicia, pero eso ya te convierte en el malo
Eu.. Eu senti dó pelo cara 🤓
THIS SCARED THE SHIT OUTTTA ME I HAVENT WATCHED IT YET THOUGH SINCE ITS TOO LATE AND I WOULD BE TOO SCARED TO WATDCH IT IN MUDDKE OF NIGHT BUT ILL WATCH IT LATER MATT RICHARDS! IT WILL MSOT LIKELY BE GOOD BUT SCARY (IN A GOOD WAY...) ILL WATCH THIS LATER AND GIVE MY HINEST OPPION LATER IN THE COMMJENT.S... SEE YOU SOON MATT RICHARDA!!
never gave your opinion 😔
@@GamePro_35 two years ago 😢
@@bruhsoundeffect1408Three years ago now...
3 years 💔 wheres your opinion 😔
Where’s your opinion, please we need it.. ❤😢
Si ven que wil no muestra ningun arrepentimiento? Solo culpa a las drogas por sus accion
It's kind of crazy to think that, if this father is a Christian, he knows he's going to hell...
I saw this on omeleto:)
He wont do that again
He can’t… it’s no longer possible for him..fortunately but it’s still horrible
r/technicallythetruth
Some of the comments... you would think this is a real thing. It's....a.... movie. Getting Tom Six vibes too....
anyone else was 50/50 on the whole thing until its revealed he raped her? that was where i lost all sympathy for him
Reservable punishment for sure 👌🏼
Que fuerte, me quede sin palabras, sintiendo mucho por los profecionales q tenían q hacer las cirugías, y proseso quedan traumatizados también, pero entro en controversia hay asecinos psicópatas q si merecen esto y pedofilos también, hay nose me quede en shock 😮😮😮
si, es muy dificil no?
Let’s do this.
Jesus Christ, such a bad take.
Eu achei pouco
Q fuerte tenaz
They shouldve removed his willy then give him 2 life sentences in prison
Não tenho um pingo de pena. Se isso existisse os criminosos pensariam duas vezes antes de cometer crimes bárbaros.
I’m concerned about the girls having their father take them to see this nonsense
I dont understand what this film is trying to do,am i supposed to feel sympathy for willie?
If karma is a real thing the suffering willy created vs the suffering the family created is much much more
Crimes pesados deveriam ser punidos assim, com provas concretas contra a pessoa e se ela tivesse mais passagens no passado ou ter sido pega em flagrante n tem como errar
I don’t feel bad for him at all. I feel like the film wanted us to feel bad for him by showing his story but not the family of the girl he harmed. He did unspeakable things so he deserved his punishment. I believe if people had this as a punishment they would be less bold. People who use harm others with their private areas don’t need them, in my opinion.
I'd suggest you see a psychologist then because you seem like a sociopath
@KidWivAutism that doesn't constitute sociopathy nor psychopathy
I find it unethical, there are many other forms of punishment like life of prison or execution not only that if this were to become a thing millions of dollars from tax payers will be waisted on this stuff. In the end the father and daughters were more traumatized and this becomes a lose lose situation for anyone involved.
Google false conviction rate
@@Malez548 The family would have never been so traumatized if he didn’t do the disgusting things he did to their family member. Also we don’t know what the family went through exactly or why the daughters stopped coming because the film barely showed their story. A life sentence does nothing but deep a monster alive & even with executions a lot of people don’t show remorse or fear. If they could experience the pain they caused they could die feeling the pain they inflicted.
É cruel, mas aprendeu.
Jesus would not approve that and I am always on his side.
God often did sacrifices if you be alive in the bible
@@thedifferenceincolour7341he never sacrifice someone by slowly torturing them. Jesus wouldn’t approve
@@thedifferenceincolour7341Never scarificed people.
Great idea! When will this be implemented?
What?!!! 😨😨
Never. And thank God for that.
Probably in the next patch
А что он сделал
Still no pity
the justice system defo needs this
Brave
司法豈可偷懶，把量刑的責任丟給家屬。
It would cost too much money for the surgeries and to care for the inmate. Especially if they took a lung or his kidneys.
Amazing short film, definitely a masterpiece imagined.
I understand the feeling this was meant to provide, the reality we've all wished when watching true crimes and cases. My bizarre take however is within it's lack of justification.. Willie is the protagonist. All the viewer's knew was that he raped and killed this little girl.. simplified and undescribed.. this whole short was the consequence. Which is very twisted of course... the sympathy of the commenters here are understandable, or at least their self-realization that no human should go through with such torture no matter the wickedness they've done.
But if the short dove deeper to what he did to the little girl (even the sligthest glimpse from the little girl's point of view...) before the events in the video... I feel like the comment section will be a lot more divided than its current state.
I confess that I can't show pity to killers (extremely few exceptions), but especially not child killers.
a five-minute section of the little girl's perspective of her experiences in Willie's hands, followed by his slow dismemberment as punishment. if Sympathy is a tangible $100 bill.. I'm pretty I'm giving at least $90 of that to the real victim.
Agora mostra a parte da vitima
É cruel o lado que ela sofreu também. Uma criancinha vulnerável.
I would still never want this to happen to anyone.
@@rarescevei8268 me too
Willie got off easy
Just NO! This is not fair i dont wish this on my worse enemy....amount of crime doesnt matter there are people who get wrongfully convicted as well.. this makes one no different than the criminal they are as sick as the criminal themselves just no
Not as cruel because at least he was under anesthesia 🤷♀️
He admitted it in the film
@@Alex-yb6yjI dont care. The removal of limbs is too horrid and cruel. I would not wish this upon my worst enemy, and no one, not the Devil, not a ruthless dictator, not someone as horrible as Willie should have this happen to them.