Citizenship Limbo for Dominican Haitians: Dominican Deadlock (Dispatch 2)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 июн 2015
- A 2013 ruling by the Dominican Republic's top court rendered hundreds of thousands of Dominican Haitians in the country effectively stateless by revoking their citizenship. After an outcry from the international community, the Dominican government passed a law allowing residents a pathway to naturalization. The deadline for those registering for naturalization at government bureaus around the country was Wednesday, June 17.
VICE News traveled to Batey Naranjo, a small rural village on the outskirts of Santo Domingo that is primarily populated by Haitians or Dominican Haitians, and spoke to residents about their confusion and concerns as to the ramifications of the naturalization deadline.
Watch “Deadline for Citizenship (Dispatch 1)" - bit.ly/1Na3Bmt
Watch VICE News’ Raw Coverage from the Dominican Republic - bit.ly/1IRDxLf
Dominican Republic Gives Haitians Until Midnight to Register or Face Deportation - bit.ly/1H1F4kz
In Photos: Anger Flares Over Tonight's Deportation Deadline in the Dominican Republic - bit.ly/1Bmo32k
Subscribe to VICE News here: bit.ly/Subscribe-to-VICE-News
Check out VICE News for more: vicenews.com
Follow VICE News here:
Facebook: / vicenews
Twitter: / vicenews
Tumblr: / vicenews
Instagram: / vicenews
More videos from the VICE network: www. vicevideos
-> Extreme Poverty
-> No work in village
-> Has 9 kids
Julius Johnson Noticed the same thing heh.. hypocrisy of these people.
Animurh Your impoverished agrarian ancestors had a shitload of kids too, because umm natural selection, so shut the fuck up.
Julius Johnson Its almost like people fuck
What a coincidence
The hypocrisy of these bitches, am I right
Animurh poverty = lack of access to contraceptives,
get off your high horse, you have no right to criticize a situation you can't even fathom
We need to make a documentary how the red cross stoled all the money from haiti to build houses during the earthquake
rap RD Keep the lies
Dmf Inc Haitians live in tents in Haiti. Is that a lie, too?
rap RD No we need to expose how racist you domincans really are.
rap RD
WTF? lol
*IDIOT*
rap RD
_"haitians are murderers"_ [SMH]
You're not a bigot...oh no, not you!
I'm Dominican born. As all of you are outsiders you only know what you have seen or heard never witnessed. The Dominican Republic is about as good as third world gets. Unreliable Electricity, No running water in 60% of the country, a quickly diminishing agriculture, rapidly climbing crime and poverty rate. The country is being choked to death because it has to share the burden of Haiti. During the Haitian Earthquake a few years back which country was 2nd behind the US in total aid? The Dominican Republic. This has nothing to do with race as Vice chooses to say it is. This has all to do with politics. The Haitian gov't has done nothing to stop its people from from flooding into DR ever since the 1940s. The DR simply cannot sustain an extra million illegals when it cant support its already 10million people. Don't always believe what you see or hear, its all propaganda. The DR is not the USA where millions of illegals reside in the country and realistically it does not effect everyday life, in DR 1 job to an illegal Haitian is literally one less job for a Dominican citizen there is no welfare in DR you cant just sit around collecting checks. You have to go out and find work. The country is doing what is has to do to protect its people, its heritage, and its ass. These so called Haitian Dominicans will be accepted with open arms into Haiti. Then they will crawl back into the country.
David Garden www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2015/06/04/the-red-cross-had-500-million-in-haitian-relief-money-and-it-built-just-6-houses/
David Garden This has EVERYTHING to do with race.
Dominicans are dark skinned and Black . This issue has NOTHING to do with race , of course Haitians suffer from racism, I've experienced racism in america but thats another subject.
cindy Queen Cindy as I don't know what you are, how smart you may be, or even Who the fuck you are I will not try to start a fight with you rather I will let you know why I and the Government of the Dominican Republic can careless if you think the Dominican Republic deporting illegal immigrants and the children of illegal immigrants has anything to do with race. The United Nations has already ruled that what is happening in my country is 100% legal and is not racial discrimination. You are an outsider looking in, not once have you given a single fuck about the rest of the world, let alone 3rd World Countries such as Haiti or the Dominican Republic. All you know is what you hear from Bias news sources such as Vice and you take their word as FACT. I will tell you we Dominicans do in fact think of the Haitians as lesser, but fuck; if you want to dig into that and look at that under a microscope lets make sure we aren't being hypocritical. Americans think of Mexicans as lesser, Mexicans think of any nation South of them as lesser, The English think of the Irish,Welsh, Scottish and Aussies as lesser. If you want to rub your nose in every little issue of the world how about you go to Africa and try to stop the Civil Wars that spring up every month and stay the fuck out of my countries business.
cindy Queen BURN! Shut up and Sit down. you know nothing.
Real facts:
In a census done in 2012, there were 524,632 legalized citizens recorded to be living in the Dominican Republic, 64% of which were Haitians. This represents around 5% of the Dominican population, and did not account for the amount of illegal immigrants residing in the country.
For a second let’s ignore the legal population, because they have not said a word throughout this ordeal due to the fact that their Dominican status is not being threatened by this process (although this fact should be considered by people worldwide because if they are so at ease, they are surely not being persecuted for murder).
Those immigrants who are in DR illegally have had access to the following privileges within the country, despite their status:
Education. Illegal immigrants have been allowed and encouraged to enroll in schools and universities.
Healthcare. Hospitals do not refuse medical attention to the constant inflow of Haitian mothers coming in to give birth, and leave the facility without paying a cent. Neither is it denied to anyone who shows up at a public hospital with an emergency.
Dominican hospitals are deficient, but they are equally deficient to Dominicans as they are to Haitians.
Work. Illegal immigrants are allowed to work without proper documentation. This is illegal by Dominican law, but the country has chosen to look the other way in order to mitigate the crisis of unemployed immigrants.
Access. Hospitals have pamphlets and posters in Creole as well as in Spanish, giving Haitians access to information.
Henry Erickson It's quite funny when the one lady in this video had what was it? 9 kids? Like fuck
***** My grandmother back in the day had a larger family but then they also ran a farm and everyone pitched in to help. What are these people doing to contribute with their dozen kids? Nothing apparently..
Animurh Here is how it works most likely the mother comes from rural Haiti where the custom is to have plenty of children. It usually takes a generation or two to break that custom among any immigrant no matter black, brown, light, or white. Most likely those 9 children will either have none or less than 3 children of their own unless she force to move back to rural Haiti. Its same way with Central American immigrants in the USA, the next generation fertility rates plument
You Dominicans are black too. It's sad that y'all hate yourselves too much to not accept Haitians as Dominicans. Love yourself and you will see that everything will change. Including the immigrant status of the Haitian immigrants who have a right to reside in the DR.
booboo thefool your so right Dominicans are descendants of Haitians but it’s just white people who fucked everything up
VICE used a Colombian woman who is from the Unitedstates to go to the Dominican Republic and concentrate on the Haitians who did the wrong move and waited until the last second for residency. Then she goes into a predominantly hatian area where a woman has 9 children...hatians aren't recognized as citizens at birth because of the ignorance of parents who don't go through the process of a paper work that is necessary.. The report was biast & paints Dominicans wrong
Haiti is what it is, a slave nation it will never rule itself and be prosper, theres no education, there are as primitive as it can be, every time there is a protest they destroy everithing, its unsafe to invest in a country where there no law, they are the responsibles for the disgraces , on the other side dominican republic shining with the biggest caribbean economy and most visited country on caribbean with the hieghest gdp...... the national emblem of DR says GOD, motherland, freedom haitian keep worshiping demons and voodoo shit and they dont get it that they are doomed
Haiti doesn’t even recognize these people as Dominican . By law in Haiti no matter what country your born in your Haitian .
Dominican Republic has the right to establish and enforce its immigration law. In this small island have to set the tone to establish order. This mushrooming Haitian population must be control and force Haitian government to handle the mess they have cause. They very irresponsible and disgraceful after have we have done running international campaign against Dominican Republic
I do not understand why they do not understand the math behind immigration. For example: the women who illegally immigrated in 80's. had zero money for herself and her 2 children at that time. She has since had 7 more children. No money for them either. I guess it is a waist of time to ask about the father(s). If you do not have any money to feed yourself why continue to have sex and create more children. This is why I have always had a difficult time sympathizing. Stupid is what stupid does so deal with the consequences of your actions.
VICE News traveled to Batey Naranjo, a small village near Santo Domingo primarily populated by Haitians or Dominican Haitians, and spoke with residents about their confusion and concerns as to the ramifications of the government’s naturalization deadline.
Watch “Deadline for Citizenship (Dispatch 1)" - bit.ly/1Na3Bmt
VICE News Keep the lies
they should all go the french guyana.. its close and they speak french..
congratulations now you know how dominicans feel.
They can't even speak creole those are Haitian that was born in dr so they speak Spanish and only know dr. Dominicans are racist with Haitian for history events i think It was 1821 when the Haitians own the whole island but dr always fought for independence.
dominicanozzylos Keep the lies
dominicanozzylos Even though this is not ok to deport many people who have been living there, that isn't quite true, the video showed at least 90% of haitians who spoke creole, you can tell by their accent. Sorry you are wrong.
Julie Gautreaux some was speaking spanish exatly like a dominican they deportin familys that been in dr since 1929 if you know spanish you'll see that the young guy they were interviewing was born in dr he said he never been to haiti .
as always, ONE side.
9 kids and the DR is supposed to take care of them
Claro, porque los niños son Dominicanos. Un día, Haití va a ser superior y excelente, y la República Dominicana lamentará la forma en que nos trataron.
@@jem5812 hahahahhahahhahaahhahhahaahhhahaaahhahaha haiti es la mierda mas grande del universo la unica vez que fueron ricos eran cuando eran esclavos de los franceses no seas ingenuo, por el otro lado somo el pais soñado de los haitianos , sueñan con tener un punta cana con 6 millones de visitantes al año , un PIB de 200 billones de dolares al año comparado con el de haiti de 6billones, no hay comparacion, rep dom crece 7% al año somos eñ pais que mas crece en la region 7 años concecutivos , vete a cenar galleticas de tierra....
@@albertomartinez109 idc
@@idontfukncareabout I'm a Haitian American so thankfully I will never need permission to stay in the racist Dominican Republic. You guys are killing Americans so now no one wants to go. You guys changed your constitutions so you could strip away citizenship from Dominican citizens who are of Haitian descent. Es una vergüenza
@@idontfukncareabout okay good because I don't want to be in a racist place where they kill Americans. Haiti is the reason you guys aren't slaves anymore lmaoo weak asses want to be white so bad
9 kIDS??? REALLY??
The Dominican republic has the right to pass law against illegal immigration
there's no such thing as Dominican Haitians
just my opinion, I take it you might possible be doninican.
and I have to disagree with you on your comment, I say yes there is Haitian-domicans, because if they are born in DC than that makes them domincans of Haitian decent and i don't see what the big fuss is about, it's basically the same thing all of it. you all share a island and you both are predominantly of African decent, get along people.
Si la caña no existe desde el 1998 y como dice la haitiana 'Tolentino' a ellos 'los compraban' (se le daba dinero al gobierno haitiano para traerlos hacer la labor de cortar la caña y estos debieran de haberse ido para su país al término).
Son tan descarados que dicen que los registran a nombre de otros... eso es una barbaridad.
Haitian and Dominican citizenship is obtained only through Jus sanguinis.
Though I disagree with the concept, it is the law of each country.
So I don't understand how this video doesn't explain that, and why the Dominican government is enforcing the law and requiring every foreigner to regularize themselves.
It's misinforming.
9 children!
It's a crime. That's what God gave her.Nobody hates the Latinos living off welfare in other country with their whole damn football team.
Downsizing cheap expendable labor. Cutting costs. It sounds harsh but thats what is going on.
I wonder if all the dominicans here who are in favor of deporting haitians to their own country would accept if Puerto Rico deported dominicans back to the Dominican Republic and created them the same social and humanitarian crisis they are reating for the poor haitians. Over 100k dominicans here in Puerto Rico either came illegally, or are sons and daughter of illegal inmigrants. Although coming poor, we have integrated them to our system, supplying them with jobs, health system, education system for their kids, helping them escape poverty in our island and send money back to their families in the Dominican Republic.
The UN and all Latin American countries should intervene to stop this humanitarian crisis by threatening sanctions and freezing oversea assets of those political leaders in the Dominican Republic who approve of the mass deportation of the Haitian communities.
lmaooooooo please deport them it would be hilarious
Guillermo Fuentes the dominicans that go to puerto rico are usually poor black dominicans and puerto ricans love dominicans and give them all citizenship
@@laydiaed Yeah because Puerto Ricans are amazing people
jay l true..most latinos need to be more like puerto ricans
Guillermo Fuentes
I agree with you.
These children never had the right to dominican citizenship just by being born there. It did not become "too late", they just never had that right under the law.
In Haiti constitution its says no matter where you are born you are Haitian
Hope they deport the Dominicans in the US too, and the ones who come illegally to Puerto Rico!
@Alana Weaver
Notice Mark M. can't respond to your statement, because you are 100% correct.
His prejudice shows his stupidity.
@@thekingofmoney2000
Trust me, they will cry like crazy and beg for mercy.
Then expect others to have compassion for them.
I have seen that myself from Dominicanos and Dominicanas living in Puerto Rico.
Russel Gino Williams ya only talk what is good to ya compare DR a poor to a rich one what an ipocrita mmg
Where is this Vice reporter from, Spain?
Please have better naming conventions for your continual dispatched pieces. It is extremely difficult to keep up. How have you not realized this?
We're so blessed in so many ways, this makes me wanna go over there & help educate those who don't have the "papers" to do so. It makes me sick
What about the children who were born with one Dominican parent and one Haitian do they still get deported
No.
No they are Dominican by law . But if u have 2 illegal Haitian parents u r not Dominican no matter if u were born on dr soil or not .
my ancestors were brought to pittsburgh to work in the steel mills. those mills are now gone. does that mean someone owes me a living?
They do not owe you a living but you received proper documentation a social and birth certificate to earn a living. Their problem is they do not have documentation to study or work.
I think it's ridiculous that the immigrants can't even register. And especially for those that are born in the DR.
Also I finally made to the under 301 club.
***** Illegal immigrants you mean, legal ones can get papers and do whatever they want.
Frostclaw20 He said immigrants, which are always illegal, there is no such thing as a legal immigrant, that's called a migrant.
Also, the point is that regardless of what they call them those people where born in the Dominican Republic and that should be reason enough for them to be citizens, and not migrants. You can't migrate to the country you where born in.
Jrockmonster You cannot be a foreign invader to the country you where born in.
Jrockmonster But that applies to 90% of the people alive today, if this where true then we are all invading each other's lands. But that, quite frankly, is a stupid and unproductive way of thinking that cannot lead to progress.
If you'd rather walk in reverse then I won't change your views, hopefully you'll fade off into the distance before you realize your mistake.
PS: Go back to the country your parents where born in! That's where you belong, invader! Immigrant!*
*I bet it feels horrible when the anger is directed at you.
Jrockmonster This is the case for Dominicans. The only people entitled to Dominican land or any land in the Americas son los Tainos/Native Americans. Who are basically extinct because nuestro queridos espanoles committed a genocide against them.
Ok, that was 3 years ago. What happen to Dominican/Haitian today?
What tf is wrong with hati cz people still live there
Dont worry Trump might bring the same lay here.And let's see how your people like if.After all American already adopted most of U.K.'s system
Thumbnail pic: Why is Don Cheadle pretending to need papers in the Dominican republic?
The big problem behind this controversy is that Dom rep is fed up of of haitians in particular because they don't respect the constitution of the Dominican Republic. They're very sturn born with idea of unifying the island, that's what happens when you don't respect other nations. They did also in Bahamas and others Caribbean countries. This is all bullshit about racism...
EVIL IN THE WORLD ...THEY WILL PAY FOR IT! MY PEOPLE HOLD ON AND KEEP PRAYING AND FIGHT FIGHT FIGHT FOR YOUR RIGHTS BECAUSE YOU ARE WORTHY !!
this goes both ways. quite sad. its bad for DR to have used them and then kick em out when their done but it is their country. on the other hand i think its quite ridiculous that these people leave Haiti with nothing and expect to go to another country, have kids there and say "hey my kids are dominican so i should be able to stay"? just ignorance
I have something to say about citizenship in general in most places of the world. The man and the community in the beginning although of Haitian descent, spoke like Dominicans and clearly identify as such. These people should have the right to citizenship if they truly identify as Dominicans. On the other hand, if an individual identifies more as a Haitian, his/her citizenship is Haitian and they should have a right to residency. Residency and Citizenship are not the same thing, and as a Dominican, I think it strips us of cultural identity to grant citizenship to people who identify as Haitian. The solution is to grant residency, the problem is that many individuals don't have legal documentation, so they can't apply for legal residency.
Yo me pregunto, por qué si eres tan pobre tienes nueve hijos, osea qué pasa con el mundo?
I'm wonder, why if this woman is to poor she has nine children, i mean wtf?
Tried to ask this question before but no one answered, if you are entered DR illegally i agree that's a crime and you should deal with the consequences, but why does the law have to go back to 1930. in essence if someones great grandmother came illegally to DR had children, those children have children who by all intensive purposes are Dominican by birth, culture, language food how do kick that person out and tell them they are not Dominican. That is a question which needs an answer. someone please give me a non biased non emotional logical response.
Nico moreno it's called JUS SANGUINIS and most country use that medium to give their citezenship, if one of your parent is citizen or at least resident you can get the nationality, haitians laws are even harsher for you to be considered haitian one of you parent must be haitian citizen(born and raised), is the law is not meant to be emotional but rather more rational in the sense of protecting the country and their interest.
also those people were given the citizenship after a large process of regulating our inmigrants because of international pressure, the ones that have trouble are those didn't signed to the process or lacked documents because the haitian government has been very indolent with their people.
www.nicepeoplenetworking.com/2015/sugar-cane-cutters-protest-at-embassy-of-haiti/
Haitians born from 1930 are already dominican lol? what are you talking about
We need to respect the laws of each country I believe other nations should help the Haitian people restore there country the IN should get involved
do not worry, come to America, you do not need documents, just cross the Mexican border and when you get here will give drivers licenses with documents, free housing, free education, free food stamps and free medical all on the American working class. Came all American borders are all open for you, ask Obama!
Murmad Man your hatred will never destroy our beautiful people from Puerto Rico D.R. and Haiti
Great example of what those people do: uncontrollably have children and pay no taxes and we have to take care of them in our hospitals providing our public resources to people who hate us and discredit us internationally.
Dominican Republic is a poor country that can not be done by Haiti.
The Haitian constitution says that every son of Haiti is Haiti where Nasca Nasca.
European countries such as France are those who have to take care of haiti.
In the Dominican Republic there are more than 3 million Haitians. Haitian women consume all hospital budgets.
Haitian women have 5 children on average.
The DR constitution states you need DR blood line to be a citizen. Only 2 other ways are by marriage and involvement
What dominican is racist? No somos racistas? Ignorantes.
Why aren't they planting sugar canes anymore?
Yo creo que vieron que ellos han contribuido al caos. Se le han dado todas las facilidades y no tomaron la oportunidad. En la cara se le ve a la reportera que no puede creer lo que escucha
This journalist should go to Bahamas where Haitians are deported, Should go too Cuban when they get there by boat, they are deported too. Should talk to USA that provide year and halve to sty in USA then they have to go back. In DR there are 3,000,000 millions being here for 6 years without paper. Haitian government don't even provide them with document. Many this people being dump without documentation, coming from jail, mental institution and expect another poor country to take care of then. Haitian government are irresponsible dumping all this people in DR.
Haitians are very good people, they are very good doctors,lawyers and neurosurgeons, in fact our former Governor General of Canada, the Honorable Michaëlle Jean PC CC CMM COM CD FRCPSC is a Canadian stateswoman and former journalist who is the third and current Secretary-General of the Organisation internationale de la Francophonie. Her appointments point to the contributions Haitians have made to North America and to the west, Haitians work has been recognized in Canada and in England, Haitians make Canada proud and have a strong place in the Canadian political landscape and are ardent law makers and legislators from Montreal to Ottawa to France. It saddens me and members of my organization that Haitians and Jamaicans face racism and economic marginalization and even violence while seeking refuge and to find a better life. I would like to tell the government of Dominica that the world is watching.
Looks like Los Angeles
Whoever made this video would do their homework and learn that no matter where in the world they are born the children of Haitian citizens are Haitian citizens and of you have a baby in Haiti the baby is not Haitian, because Haiti constitution says so. Look it up. They are not in limbo, they are Haitian citizens. It’s nobody’s fault that Haitian government is incapable of providing they’re nationals with documents.
To anyone who hates puertoricans you can not judge everyone is not the same we are millions in number and multipling all over the state's and throughout the world we are all in the same boat maybe not exactly the same what we need to do is stop the hate and rac ism and find ways to improve our lives and help others
Y esta mmg que va a pais de Nosotro hace entrevital mmg
Ella le tira a lo mango bajito esa mmg y Ella no save de donde viene el problema .....
Me encanta el acento.
Shame on you Vice, for this one sided garbage.
don cheadle?
this girl needs to go home is not your business we respect hatian conatitution respect ours
Haiti has the most racist history in the western hemisphere and that's why its population is so homogenous. After the so-called liberation of Saint Domingue (so-called because they paid France a huge amount to be "free"), Haiti executed the most complete ethnic cleansing on its turf after carrying out a genocidal execution of everybody who didn't look like them.
In 1804 the whole island was NOT under haitian control. Haiti freed ONLY roughly one third of the island (present day Haiti, a name stolen from the indigenous). But the other roughly two-third of the island, Santo Domingo, was at the time still under French control. Santo Domingo became a colony of Spain again when Spain seized it from France via The Battle of Palo Hincado in 1808. From 1808 to 1821, it was known as The España Boba. In late 1821, without any haitian involvement, a dominican named Jose Nuñez de Caceres started a revolt that overthrew the spanish reign. This period is commonly known as the Ephemeral Independence because it lasted only three months. In 1822, Boyer unified the two countries for the next 22 years via a pacific invasion. The main goal of this unification was to help Haiti pay for it's paid "independence" from France. During this time span, the dominican state was heavily taxed and haitian racist laws caused the dominican population to be cut in half.
In 1838, Juan Pablo Duarte started the movement that overthrew the haitian ocupation for good in 1844. But Haiti didn't give up. Haiti invaded the Dominican Republic for the next 12 years under the leadership of emperors like Faustin Soulouque. It it important to also mention the massacres that murderers like Dessalines and Christophe carried on innocent dominican men, women and children (haitian "historians" have unsuccesfully tried to mask these massacres as attacks aimed at french and spanish colonizers, but it's not the case). One of the most infamous massacre is The Beheading of Moca, in which haitian troops beheaded dominican children. Also notable was the burning of cities like Santiago and Moca in El Cibao. Dominican liberator of Cuba Maximo Gomez fought against haitian invaders early in his military career to protect The Dominican Republic.
Toussaint Louvertune (who originally joined Spain to fight France in the island) didn't abolish slavery for long because Napoleon Bonaparte restored it shortly after. Slavery wasn't abolished in Santo Dominigo (present day The Dominican Republic) all the way until 1822. The Dominican Republic has not practiced slavery since.
Haiti still practices slavery in 2017.
Haitians massacred us in 1804 and then in 1822-42 , their hatred against Dominicans have been registered for centuries.
They should get they paperwork in order law is the law
Yo that looks like Africa
I'm not criticizing u don't come to somebody's land to give them more problem u come to better yourself.children are gift from God,how could one keep having the desire to have sex while you swimming in hardship and difficulties.for me it is plain selfishness.poor children who has to suffer.now as a law maker something got to be done.but these children deserves basic needs.these people are not to blame.now we facing a crisis human rights.think we are mothers and fathers.God bless.
Mejor lo digo en español. Este reportaje es muy poco profesional, empezando con las expresiones de la reportera quien tiene un desconocimiento total sobre el tema.
El drama haitiano como podemos ver con esa mujer que tiene NUEVE hijos y es tan irresponsable que no los ha registrado en el Libro de Extranjería.
Es una pena que organizaciones que quieren ganarse un nombre lo hagan de una manera tan burda y haciendo lo que han hecho todas las ONG's: vivir de la pobreza haitiana. Le debiera de dar vergüenza de subir such a piece of crap.
most of dominican republic is black with or without haitian immigrants
stack hefner
stack hefner it isn't
stack hefner there is more mixed then it's white then it's black so mixed is the majority
that crazy but it true
stack hefner that's funny cz that's a big lieeee
that part that we are not racist do not understand are black most also, we do fasil anyone who says we are racist and do not help haiti want inlegales Haitians in their country to tell us that the Dominican government regale air travel to every country that wants inlegales and want to help Haitians and thus help Haitians to live in a better place because DR is not rich and can not help while the legal Haitians to stay and peace for all
End the Domician parade in New York city it bring to much pain to Americans
Dominicans are black too but we're not hatians
No, you are not black...don't try it.
EL Donjuan it's Haitian you stupid idiot
Hell no dominicans are no black
@@themmmfamily7130 we got black Dominicans too that just aren’t Haitians
They always live in the poor parts of the DR
They all gotta go.
GUUUUAAOOO POR QUE QUIERE SACAR LOS HAITIANOS NI MODO ESA GENTE SON EJEMPLO SEGUN LA SEÑORA
PERO QUE FALACIAAA LE VENDE AL MUNDOOO .
Don't worry, come to America, you don't need documents, just cross the Mexican border and get fee medical, food stamps,housing and free eduction. Come all American borders are open for everyone
why are there no longer sugar cane plantations there? did they chase out the 'slavemasters'?
test7er I´m guessing the demand and price for sugar declined a lot. In Cuba for example they now produce far less sugar than 30 years ago.
The demand stopped, there just a few still running. Big countries are getting sugar cheaper from other countries.
test7er The effects of Globalization that vice news promotes. Sugar Cane can be produced cheaper in third world countries where there aren't labor laws and Vice News can't report on and so those jobs are moved to those countries with even worse labor conditions than the D.R.
So sad that the D.R. government can't afford to, Provide education to Illegal Haitians, Provide Health Care to illegal Haitians, Provide safe housing to illegal Haitians, Provide well paying easy slack work for the Haitians. Etc. Vice News informed me that it's all the Dominicans fault whenever a Haitian is poor or hungry.
test7er Search in the internet "Corn Syrup Lobby". You will find the answer for this question there.
Keep the lies
DR has a first rate immigration system the world should follow............
7-9 kids... way to go Mom, you're the problem.
👎👎👎👎👎👎
I am Dominican. I am very ashamed of this happening to the Haitian.
I think if the D. R. is doing this to the Haitian; the USA needs to pass the same law to apply only to dominicans born in the USA. Also they should make illegals for dominicans living in the USA to send money to the D. R.
An Eye for Eye.
Another Haitian trying to pass for Dominican. Be proud to be Haitian and stop trying to pass for people that rejected you have some pride.
Lol watching Dominicans argue with each other because of their skin color is funny
@@themmmfamily7130 Who says is teh skin colour ? do you think we are like the US? don't come with our mindset thinkking everything is about colour you are just so annoying.
60% of dominican hospitals are been used to haitians, ilegal haitians got the right to education and so more benefits you are clearly not a dominican because you don't know a thing
“ I am Dominican “ y did u feel the need to add tht ? U could’ve just stated ur opinion and kept it moving .
What difference does it make? Deep down they're both black and poor They need to merge and become one state, work together to get out of poverty
So stupid smh
The boys that are speaking Spanish are not Haitian at all. No real Haitians would claim them. Look at how the dr treat they people since the 1930s all because of color
Is it crack ? Is that what u smoke ? If you’re Haitian then you would know by law no matter where u are/were born u are Haitian .
@@rosaliafernandezzz7139 so there’s no dark skin full dominicans in dr ? Answer that. Dumba55
All Haitians want to be Dominicans
@@themmmfamily7130 yes but these particular dark skin people are Haitian, no matter if you like it or not
@@bow6379 never . Y’all stand for nothing..