I have been listening to this piece of music for 70 years now, and I believe this is the best version I have ever heard. The depth of expression especially from the strings was superb, and I could not fault anything at all. Sublimely majestic, moving, the pace exactly on point especially with the unhurried Nimrod, with its crescendos never failing to evoke emotion. Well done
I am in total agreement with your comments. I first heard the Enigma Variations when I was about 5 years old in 1946. My father was a church organist and musician who left me with a love of Elgar, Brahms and many other composers . I have watched this particular performance many times and it never fails to move me. a wonderful orchestra and superb performers. Even the filming is excellent and I can almost imagine I am actually sitting in that audience.
I totally agree - just wonderful. And consider also the significance of one of the most evocative pieces of English music being performed by a Polish Orchestra, in Warsaw, in the 21st century.
For me this is the sound of living to experience the sunrise after I have lost everything that made the sunrise worth living for. I had not thought of it as my soul crying before, but I think that must be what it is. That deep breath you take when you know that you must go on. (My name is also Alexandra ;} ).
@@Karloffrules I don't know what your loss is - whether it's the same as it is for many of us who thought that we were free - otherwise, whatever it is, take whatever heart you can and keep giving to anyone who depends on you. May God bless you.
Elgar must have loved Jaeger dearly. This is full of love, beauty, passion and all the lovely emotions you can think of. God rest Elgars wonderful soul.
WOW ! IMMACULATE AND INCOMPARABLE, IN EVERY WAY, WHICH INCLUDES THE SETTING ,CRISP RECORDING, BOTH AUDIBLE AND VISUAL, AND THE ECEPTIONAL APPEARANCE OF THE ORCHESTRA. SO -SO PROFFESSIONABLE.
God I love these people. Literally waited until no more sound was in the room, and then politely clapped at the end, no yelling or cheering, or jumping to their feet like rowdy victors in a football game. I don't think they know how civilized, wonderful and refreshing this behavior is to an American.
I agree that American audiences sometimes exhibit excessive histrionics for mediocre work, but I thought a little more enthusiasm for this excellent performance was warrented here!
personally i like when the audience really show how much they liked a performance. like you don't have to go crazy but i think it's kinda boring if people just clap politely at the end like a middle school orchestra concert because classical music can be exciting and more than just a boring pastime for old rich people and it shows that
@@tardx I,m thinking that the audiance was asked to hold their applause until the end of the entire performance as i have heard at a few performances. that is my take anyway. But what a great performance it was..
One of the most truly magical moments in any composition. I have the last bars of W.N and first bars of Nimrod tattooed on my forearm...the only color in the whole thing is that single held note that bridges the two.
I had to go back and have another listen, I was boiling the kettle and missed it hahah! Nimrod is my favourite classical piece by some margin and this just made it even better for me 🤩😍
This orchestra is astonishingly good at playing this most English of orchestral works. It is amazing how full blooded and nuanced their playing is. Absolutely fantastic.
I'm not a huge Elgar fan but that transition into Variation IX 'Nimrod' has to be one of the most heart breaking passages I have ever heard! It breaks my heart anew every time I hear it and especially played so superbly by this wonderful Orchestra who play it so respectfully and powerfully!
I've personally always loved Elgar, I've always found his compositions elegantly simple to listen to but heartbreakingly beautiful and evoking. This is, as you said so respectfully articulated ❤
I’m Japanese high school student, and I played this variations at the brass band competition. I played Nimrod and Finale. It is my most favorite masterpiece I’ve ever played.Thank you for the wonderful performance!
You tube... Smart tv... Sound bar surround... This performance... HEAVEN!!! Enormous congratulations to ALL, All musicians, strings, wood winds, brass, percussion and wonderful conductor. Recording and filming!!! Long life to 🇵🇱 and their music orchestras. THANK YOU!!!
So many brilliant soloists! The astonishing wind players! That clarinet! That cello solo - my God! - and viola! The timpanist! - a battalion! A joy and a delight to listen to - and to watch! - from start to finish.
Nothing like a real orchestra who's playing is as sweet as honey. My music teacher in the eighties introduced us to Sir Edward William Elgar and after he played this he told us he was English. I was so proud as I am of this exceptional Orchestra.
My biggest regret now that I've heard this is that I'll never be able to hear it for the first time again. Such a beautiful piece. I can't stop listening to it.
I am a Brit who has lived in the USA for50 years, I and my family are still very English and we come from Worcestershire where Sir Edward was also born, we have walked the same lanes and hills that he walked on and his music is VERY precious to us. Bravo for a wonderful performance, perhaps you have finally proved that English music can only be performed by an English orchestra is NOT ALWAYS TRUE.
I'm English. I love this piece of music. However I've not heard it played so well as in this performance. A short segment of life but long in quality and memory. Thank you Warsaw Philharmonic.
Co mam napisać? Wspaniałe wykonanie pełne emocji ... smutek, żal, radość...wiele uczuć i tak jakby podróż która jest dla każdego inna... przepiękne Panie Elgar i Panie Kaspszyk!
This performance is so moving. VIII and into Nimrod is sublime. Only discovered this the other day and can't stop listening to it. The best interpretation of this work I have ever heard. What an amazingly talented orchestra.
Oh, the beautiful melancholy of this masterpiece! It transports us, as it were, to a different world, another time, when gallantry and nobility were paramount and honesty and virtue were rewarded, even though hearts were breaking. I love it so.
That Nimrod is, simply put, exquisite. Emotional. Absolutely stunning. What a wood section. ! What a beautiful string ensemble cohesive sound! What a delicate interpretation by the conductor! Gosh, how come I haven't discovered that version earlier?! In love with it. Thank you for a beautiful moment of music.
For the 80th anniversary of D-Day. In remembrance of all whom have fallen and all who participated in the campaign and are no longer with us. Thank you for your service.
Stopped me in my tracks and Nimrod had me welling up with tears of joy. I had to play Nimrod over and over... Amazingly serene and rhythmic, had me open-mouthed and astounded. As far from Poland as i can be in the mountains of Tasmania, i was completely in that chamber and mesmerised. xxx thank you
I am moved to tears by the beauty of the Polish people. Just witnessing the portrayal of the emotionalism that is the foundation of this work, shows to me the depth and tradition of Poland's Arts community .........
I read the comments first. Unsure of a Polish orch playing such British music. All the people who said this is great were right as rain. This is stupendous! It could not be any better. Bravos all round. Loved the trombones and tuba. All are excellent. Thanks from Atlanta.
getting chills from Nimrod...so beautiful. Listening to this music gives me a better outlook on life. Thank the Lord for composers, musicians, and conductors...
Music knows no bounds. A Polish orchestra can play Elgar as if he wrote this music especially for them. Many thanks for publishing this remarkable performance!
I am Polish, a violinist, in mind, heart and soul, and yet there will always be another world to conquer in the life of music. To me, no classical music will ever be an orphan, but secretly, we have our favorites; this one consumes me, places an emotional burden of consummate joy upon me which cannot be described.
Bill, it is so nice to hear such warm and lovely comments. I believe that the Dalai Lama once said, 'Be kind whenever possible, it is always possible'. Music is such a unifying force. Love and best wishes from England.
I'm at a loss for words to describe the stunning beauty of this performance. The players are all so deep into making this the finest interpretation of the Enigma Variations. I've played this numerous times, and often I'll begin to play it as background music while I'm working, but then find myself viewing it instead, because the filming is so "in tune" with the amazing music and performances. Thank you, Warsaw Philharmonic, for not just the heavenly playing of this piece, but for making it available for everyone to enjoy. Just stunning. (I wish there was a recording of this performance!!)
This is the version I return to time and time again for both its musical and video quality. Today, while listening to/watching this performance one more time, I remembered the recent passing of the much beloved Queen Elizabeth II, and the music, especially the "Nimrod" variation, seemed to take on extra layers of meaning, and I was deeply touched, again. If you know someone who has not listened to (or watched) this performance, I highly recommend that you introduce this version to him/her.
Beautifully put into context. And on the 13th November it will be played as always at the Cenotaph ceremony where the UK honours all those killed in war from the UK and Commonwealth. And of course this will be the first one for over 70 years where Her Majesty will not be present except in our hearts. God bless her and God Save the King.
Wonderful. The greatest work by England's greatest composer played with the greatest feeling, verve and quality by this great Polish orchestra and conductor. WONDERFUL.
Probably one of the best performances I have listened to. As for the playing of Nimrod, the pace was majestic, not hurried with each crescendo being slowly built upon. The rise and fall of the notes gave me a tingling sensation.
The more of this elegant music we listen to, the more our world will reap PEACE as it should be. Just joy to the heart, mind and ear. Beautiful performance by all!!!
Remember the people who afforded this music were the ones wrecking havoc upon the world as well. So this isn’t really indicative of peaceful times. It may sound it but you need to get your history right.
A fine performance. To date I thought perhaps only the British could understand Elgar. But this is Polish soul and artistry. a truly wonderful interpretation of a fantastic piece of composition.
I've now listened to this RUclips recording a number of times and feel I must thank you once again. I attended the Proms in London throughout the sixties and early seventies hearing several versions of this (ie Boult!). But, as I come back to this Warsaw recording, time and time again I feel this is the BEST recording I have ever heard. Such finesse, balance, feeling and... soul. The conductor's name is not one I can pronounce :) but I will remember it! Accept once again my thanks for a truly wonderful interpretation of a great piece of British music.
I am an American and it took me a while to understand this work. But I agree that this is the performance is the one I most want to listen to. Music is indeed universal, after all, we all love Shakespeare. (And Monty Python).
Special congratulations to these three musicians ladies: Concertino, first viola and first oboe. Love them!!!! 😘 😘 😘 Enjoying a lot again the excellent performance.
I find myself watching this in its entirety over and over. I never knew the Warsaw Philharmonic was so good. I wish I could but Blu-Ray videos of their performances but I’m not seeing any. What a discovery for me.
@@leod-sigefast Vaughan Williams, Finzi, Parry, Bridge, Delius, Butterworth, Coates, Benjamin Britten etc. We have had a few. Elgar is my favourite though.
Vaughan Williams comes a very close second. But I've loved Elgar from childhood, andbthis isvthe best performamce of Enigma I've ever heard. And I'm Irish.
I've stumbled here late. In tears. Trying to come to terms with everything everyone else is trying to come to terms with. This is just sublime. Makes me miss full orchestra; makes me miss full brass. The pines of rome roar. Love it. To anyone else here and just absorbing this great performance: enjoy. Do well for those around you.
Yes, I miss playing in a symphony. There's something about being surrounded by the sound of the music all around me. It scoops me up and takes me to another place.
@@singingcyclops1 Absolutely it is different than listening. I often say "Oh I have played that before"! ... but I really think it is a different feeling being on the stage/grounds/dirt. :) This is not to take away from any performance: there are so many I could never achieve or be a part of or otherwise comment on. Just wish I could have been there :)
@@renzo6490 I also sang in choir in college. We used to do several great pieces with full symphony and a 73 voice choir. It would send chills down my spine sometimes.
Totally agree twelge15 - far too many conductors perform this at a faster pace and it ruines the whole build of the music. It has taken me ages to find someone who conductors at a similar pace to von Karajan - which is my very humble view is correct.
I thought long ago I had heard it at its proper adagio. But this is something else entirely...there is so much beauty and so much agony throughout Nimrod and I’ll be damned if I didn’t feel every single note like it was being torn out of me. I no longer have need for any other version of this.
Astonishing. Breathtakingly. Perfect. How many recordings of this have I in my collection and none... none... compare to this. Sweeping, majestic, haunting and poetic... Sir Edward would be proud and pleased. And, there were actually empty seats in the hall for this. How many of us would have like to have filled them. Bravo!
This is one orchestra I really would like to attend at a live performance . Probably my favourite out of many others. This performance of Elgar's Enigma Variations is certainly at top of my music tree.
What a magnificent rendition of this Enigma Variations written by Elgar! Who better to perform this than Warsaw Philharmonic Orchestra by one of my favourite Conductor the ever green Jacek Kaspszyk!. Every single string or wind instruments do a amazing job and that's exactly what makes Warsaw Philharmonic Orchestra outstanding. I have been to Krakow several times and not once have I missed a Classical concert when I am there! Thank you Poland for giving the world such remarkable musicians and music from Chopin to Ida Haendel and more! Your musical heritage is for all to see! It is rich with talents and glorious in performance! Now on the lighter side you have given a teenager of enormous talent to the tennis world by the name Swiatek! You as a nation should be proud you have given the world and me such Joy by your incredible musical journey to bring Peace, Tranquility and Serenity to millions the world over! Love and greetings from Denmark.
Nimrod does just that. Nimrod allows you to stand on the very precipice of all emotions that drive us to love.💘 . When the brass and drum begin, it takes you to a place we all seek but rarely ever find,. Home
Absolutely staggered by this live performance. Profoundly moving. The sheer beauty and depth were incredible. I remained stoically British stiff-upper-lipped until Nimrod and then the dam broke. From the bottom of my heart - thank you.
Phil Bates honestly the silence after Nimrod is blessed. The first time I heard Enigma, I was utterly unprepared for what Nimrod would do to my soul. I would have given anything for those 5 seconds of silence, but the audience was so overwhelmed that they couldn’t withhold applause. And I was ripped out of the most emotionally reflective moment of my entire life.
Poland, this symphony, and this conductor clearly understand the restrained depth of British emotion and nostalgia. Quite possibly the best rendition of Nimrod I've heard from the many 100's of attempts I've come across.
I now forget how many times I've listened to this magnificent performance. Having a wide selection of most of Beethoven's Mozart's Dvorak's Chopin and many other composers, for some reason I love Enigma Variations. Maybe it is because of this performance by the Warsaw Philharmonic. I now know the faces of so many performers... noble people. Dedicated to music. Now five years ago. Every time I hear it and see it I wonder how those people are managing. Is Jacek Kasprzyk still there? The others? I wish you all well.
The Warsaw Philharmonic Orchestra, Europe’s finest orchestra, delivers an unsurpassed performance of one of Elgar’s best-known works. There is also none better than maestro Jacek Kaspszyk.
Truly the best performance of this musical piece I have ever listened to! But how could we ever be disappointed by the Warsaw Philharmonic Orchestra and Jacek Kaspszyk? A big thank-you to Filharmonia Narodowa for the wonderful channel!
If Elgar hadn't written any more music than this work he would have been famous and respected by this alone. Wonderful performance from beginning to end. Bravo!!
In the Nimrod variation, the section between 18:47 and 18:53 is truly spectacularly done. It's amazing how much emotion can be packed into six seconds of music. I have never heard a better rendition (and i have heard a LOT)
The climax at 18:50 is as close to perfect as I am likely to ever hear. No other conductor comes close. (Only God's Philharmonic can do it better - maybe....)
The wonderful people of Warsaw are so fortunate to have this beautiful orchestra representing them. I am grateful too, even if I don't live in Warsaw. Thank you!!!
Yes, IMO the Warsaw Philharmonic is possibly the most underrated orchestra in Europe. At their best with the outstanding conducting of Jacek Kaspszyk (who I heard in London conducting an unforgettable "In the South" overture) they yield almost nothing to the more famous philharmonics of Vienna and Berlin.
Elgar is very precious: Has sentiment -- but he's not sentimental; Has Drama -- but he avoids the caustic, corrupting melodrama. His work is just goodness. And this orchestra offers a fine performance. Thank you.
A wonderful performance from start to finish. Nimrod was devastating in its beauty and climax, but everything else about the performance was top-notch as well. Masterfully done.
Unarguably the finest performance of Elgar's Enigma Variations I have ever heard. Moves me to tears every time I hear it. Very good that also it was permitted to finish without the audience immediately clapping the well deserved applause. Many thanks to all in the orchestra.
I notice that I commented on this two years ago . It’s still wonderful and I selected this recording above all others because I knew that the Polish people would understand Elgar . I live on the Malvern Hills , near to Elgar’s birthplace and many other places that inspired his music , and I am aware daily of this connection.
Jacek Kaspszyk is clearly an outstanding interpreter of Elgar. His conducting of “In the South” overture a few years back in London is the best I’ve ever heard and now one of the finest of the Enigma Variations. Please Mr. Kaspszyk give us performances with your outstanding orchestra of Elgar’s two remarkable symphonies!
I have two fine recordings of "In The South" and would have loved to have heard Maestro Kaspszyk's version referred to here. He clearly has the measure of Elgar!
![[DRAGON BALL LEGENDS REVEALS ＆ STUFF] LEGENDS FESTIVAL 2024 Special Edition Part 1](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mV5bGIswTtQ/mqdefault.jpg)
I have been listening to this piece of music for 70 years now, and I believe this is the best version I have ever heard. The depth of expression especially from the strings was superb, and I could not fault anything at all. Sublimely majestic, moving, the pace exactly on point especially with the unhurried Nimrod, with its crescendos never failing to evoke emotion. Well done
I am in total agreement with your comments. I first heard the Enigma Variations when I was about 5 years old in 1946. My father was a church organist and musician who left me with a love of Elgar, Brahms and many other composers . I have watched this particular performance many times and it never fails to move me. a wonderful orchestra and superb performers. Even the filming is excellent and I can almost imagine I am actually sitting in that audience.
Well said. I've only managed about fifty years but this version is so moving to my inexperienced ear.
Great orchestra, great conductor, great interpretation, could not agree more.
Yes
I totally agree - just wonderful. And consider also the significance of one of the most evocative pieces of English music being performed by a Polish Orchestra, in Warsaw, in the 21st century.
Thank you Polish people for playing our English music so wonderfully.
Not only great musicians but in the field of aviation, the 145 brave Polish pilots who distinguished themselves in the Battle of Britain during WWII!
My soul cried during "Nimrod" for reasons I cannot cannot, yet, comprehend or even know. It's breathtaking.
For me this is the sound of living to experience the sunrise after I have lost everything that made the sunrise worth living for. I had not thought of it as my soul crying before, but I think that must be what it is. That deep breath you take when you know that you must go on. (My name is also Alexandra ;} ).
How does a soul cry, I am curious
@@Karloffrules I don't know what your loss is - whether it's the same as it is for many of us who thought that we were free - otherwise, whatever it is, take whatever heart you can and keep giving to anyone who depends on you. May God bless you.
@@OurHereafterI suspect that unless you just know the answer to that question, your own has got a way yet to go.
@@OurHereafterwhen crying is not just dripping water from your eyes but the melting of your being
Elgar must have loved Jaeger dearly. This is full of love, beauty, passion and all the lovely emotions you can think of. God rest Elgars wonderful soul.
WOW ! IMMACULATE AND INCOMPARABLE, IN EVERY WAY, WHICH INCLUDES THE SETTING ,CRISP RECORDING, BOTH AUDIBLE AND VISUAL, AND THE ECEPTIONAL APPEARANCE OF THE ORCHESTRA. SO -SO PROFFESSIONABLE.
So beautifully played by the Warsaw Philharmonic Orchestra and with such feeling - better than a CD!😀
God I love these people. Literally waited until no more sound was in the room, and then politely clapped at the end, no yelling or cheering, or jumping to their feet like rowdy victors in a football game. I don't think they know how civilized, wonderful and refreshing this behavior is to an American.
I agree that American audiences sometimes exhibit excessive histrionics for mediocre work, but I thought a little more enthusiasm for this excellent performance was warrented here!
@@tardx Absolutely in agreement. Perhaps the best Enigma I've heard. Pity so many empty seats.
personally i like when the audience really show how much they liked a performance. like you don't have to go crazy but i think it's kinda boring if people just clap politely at the end like a middle school orchestra concert because classical music can be exciting and more than just a boring pastime for old rich people and it shows that
@@tardx I,m thinking that the audiance was asked to hold their applause until the end of the entire performance as i have heard at a few performances. that is my take anyway. But what a great performance it was..
Superb!Nimrod with it’s slower tempo is spine tingling.Love the lead viola.
The heart-stopping moment with the magical key change from “W.N.” to “Nimrod.”
One of the most truly magical moments in any composition. I have the last bars of W.N and first bars of Nimrod tattooed on my forearm...the only color in the whole thing is that single held note that bridges the two.
I had to go back and have another listen, I was boiling the kettle and missed it hahah!
Nimrod is my favourite classical piece by some margin and this just made it even better for me 🤩😍
You should take a look at Mr. Leonard Bernstein's Nimrod - his too was very slow! :-)
This orchestra is astonishingly good at playing this most English of orchestral works. It is amazing how full blooded and nuanced their playing is. Absolutely fantastic.
This wonderful performance tells us that Elgar's music is not just of England, but much fuller, much broader. He is a composer of the world.
I think the Poles have cracked the Enigma code
:)
I'm not a huge Elgar fan but that transition into Variation IX 'Nimrod' has to be one of the most heart breaking passages I have ever heard! It breaks my heart anew every time I hear it and especially played so superbly by this wonderful Orchestra who play it so respectfully and powerfully!
Not a huge fan of Elgar ? have you heard his Cello concerto ?
I've personally always loved Elgar, I've always found his compositions elegantly simple to listen to but heartbreakingly beautiful and evoking. This is, as you said so respectfully articulated ❤
Hope you are converted.
You sound like a huge fan of Elgar 😍
I’m Japanese high school student, and I played this variations at the brass band competition. I played Nimrod and Finale. It is my most favorite masterpiece I’ve ever played.Thank you for the wonderful performance!
You tube... Smart tv... Sound bar surround... This performance... HEAVEN!!!
Enormous congratulations to ALL, All musicians, strings, wood winds, brass, percussion and wonderful conductor. Recording and filming!!! Long life to 🇵🇱 and their music orchestras.
THANK YOU!!!
So many brilliant soloists!
The astonishing wind players! That clarinet!
That cello solo - my God! - and viola!
The timpanist! - a battalion!
A joy and a delight to listen to - and to watch! - from start to finish.
I have watched this program many times and the thrill never stops.
Nothing like a real orchestra who's playing is as sweet as honey.
My music teacher in the eighties introduced us to Sir Edward William Elgar and after he played this he told us he was English.
I was so proud as I am of this exceptional Orchestra.
... and if the finale of Nimrod doesn't bring you to tears, you have no soul!!!
One of the best Enigma at all. Bravo, Maestro Kaspszyk!
Probably the best performed Enigma, EVER.
Amazing sound performance and conducting. The conductor received an Elgar award. So outstanding, I listen to it over and over r
excellent magical ❤
My biggest regret now that I've heard this is that I'll never be able to hear it for the first time again. Such a beautiful piece. I can't stop listening to it.
I fully understand you.
I am a Brit who has lived in the USA for50 years, I and my family are still very English and we come from Worcestershire where Sir Edward was also born, we have walked the same lanes and hills that he walked on and his music is VERY precious to us.
Bravo for a wonderful performance, perhaps you have finally proved that English music can only be performed by an English orchestra is NOT ALWAYS TRUE.
My family also comes Worcestershire, which town or village precisely did Elgar live near? My family comes from Kempsey
The finest "Nimrod" - ever! Thank you.
I'm English.
I love this piece of music.
However I've not heard it played so well as in this performance. A short segment of life but long in quality and memory.
Thank you Warsaw Philharmonic.
Me too, it's gives me goosebumps any time i listen to this song
The finale is absolutly wonderful.
My favorite part.
Thank you, beloved and brilliant Polish musicians.
Nimrod was played at my grandmother's funeral, absolutely beautiful piece and reminds me of her.
Co mam napisać? Wspaniałe wykonanie pełne emocji ... smutek, żal, radość...wiele uczuć i tak jakby podróż która jest dla każdego inna... przepiękne Panie Elgar i Panie Kaspszyk!
Everyone talks about the nimrod but I think the first variation does deserve its fair recognition and applause
and the eighth
This performance is so moving. VIII and into Nimrod is sublime. Only discovered this the other day and can't stop listening to it. The best interpretation of this work I have ever heard. What an amazingly talented orchestra.
Masterfully done, English composer, Polish orchestra and a grateful Turk who enjoys Elgar. I’d like to visit Warsaw just to hear this from this team.
I, too, have thought about flying to Warsaw just to hear this orchestra :)😀
Oh, the beautiful melancholy of this masterpiece! It transports us, as it were, to a different world, another time, when gallantry and nobility were paramount and honesty and virtue were rewarded, even though hearts were breaking. I love it so.
I close my eyes and let this music lift my spirits. This piece, and its exquisite performance, is a perfect reminder of the power of music.
That Nimrod is, simply put, exquisite. Emotional. Absolutely stunning.
What a wood section.
! What a beautiful string ensemble cohesive sound! What a delicate interpretation by the conductor! Gosh, how come I haven't discovered that version earlier?! In love with it. Thank you for a beautiful moment of music.
Honestly, the best performance of Enigma Variations I`ve ever heard. A sublime orchestra conducted by an excellent musician
For the 80th anniversary of D-Day. In remembrance of all whom have fallen and all who participated in the campaign and are no longer with us. Thank you for your service.
Stopped me in my tracks and Nimrod had me welling up with tears of joy. I had to play Nimrod over and over... Amazingly serene and rhythmic, had me open-mouthed and astounded. As far from Poland as i can be in the mountains of Tasmania, i was completely in that chamber and mesmerised. xxx thank you
I am moved to tears by the beauty of the Polish people. Just witnessing the portrayal of the emotionalism that is the foundation of this work, shows to me the depth and tradition of Poland's Arts community .........
I read the comments first. Unsure of a Polish orch playing such British music. All the people who said this is great were right as rain. This is stupendous! It could not be any better. Bravos all round. Loved the trombones and tuba. All are excellent. Thanks from Atlanta.
Le chef d'orchestre est passionnant à regarder. Il respire et vit intensément la musique avec ses musiciens.
L'âme slave à 300 %
Edward Elgar has to be one of if not my favorite composers of all time. This beautiful performance made his work shine just as he would have intended.
getting chills from Nimrod...so beautiful. Listening to this music gives me a better outlook on life. Thank the Lord for composers, musicians, and conductors...
Grandiosa orchestra, musica divina, direttore Super ❤😊
😍
Not only is this performance the very best, but the recording is absolutely fabulous!!
The amount of passion in this music. And knowing that he wrote this to each one of his closest friends. Amazing
Music knows no bounds. A Polish orchestra can play Elgar as if he wrote this music especially for them. Many thanks for publishing this remarkable performance!
I am Polish, a violinist, in mind, heart and soul, and yet there will always be another world to conquer in the life of music. To me, no classical music will ever be an orphan, but secretly, we have our favorites; this one consumes me, places an emotional burden of consummate joy upon me which cannot be described.
Thank you a well deserved tribute.
My appreciation for Elgar has and will always remain this way.
Bill, it is so nice to hear such warm and lovely comments. I believe that the Dalai Lama once said, 'Be kind whenever possible, it is always possible'. Music is such a unifying force. Love and best wishes from England.
Yes. A life of creative genius is our goal.
Beautiful cello, viola and clarinet solo sections.
I'm at a loss for words to describe the stunning beauty of this performance. The players are all so deep into making this the finest interpretation of the Enigma Variations. I've played this numerous times, and often I'll begin to play it as background music while I'm working, but then find myself viewing it instead, because the filming is so "in tune" with the amazing music and performances. Thank you, Warsaw Philharmonic, for not just the heavenly playing of this piece, but for making it available for everyone to enjoy. Just stunning. (I wish there was a recording of this performance!!)
This is the version I return to time and time again for both its musical and video quality. Today, while listening to/watching this performance one more time, I remembered the recent passing of the much beloved Queen Elizabeth II, and the music, especially the "Nimrod" variation, seemed to take on extra layers of meaning, and I was deeply touched, again. If you know someone who has not listened to (or watched) this performance, I highly recommend that you introduce this version to him/her.
Beautifully put into context. And on the 13th November it will be played as always at the Cenotaph ceremony where the UK honours all those killed in war from the UK and Commonwealth. And of course this will be the first one for over 70 years where Her Majesty will not be present except in our hearts.
God bless her and God Save the King.
Excellent performance , the best i have ever heard, Elgar would be proud , Bravo Bravo maestro Kaspszyk...
Wonderful. The greatest work by England's greatest composer played with the greatest feeling, verve and quality by this great Polish orchestra and conductor. WONDERFUL.
Probably one of the best performances I have listened to. As for the playing of Nimrod, the pace was majestic, not hurried with each crescendo being slowly built upon. The rise and fall of the notes gave me a tingling sensation.
Have you ever watched the film Dunkirk?
I hope you see this. Agreed.
@@julijangrajfoner1730which one nimrod?
The more of this elegant music we listen to, the more our world will reap PEACE
as it should be.
Just joy to the heart, mind and ear.
Beautiful performance by all!!!
Remember the people who afforded this music were the ones wrecking havoc upon the world as well. So this isn’t really indicative of peaceful times. It may sound it but you need to get your history right.
This is simply an amazing performance of Elgar... one of the very best. In terms of expression and tempo it cannot be bettered.
A fine performance. To date I thought perhaps only the British could understand Elgar. But this is Polish soul and artistry. a truly wonderful interpretation of a fantastic piece of composition.
I've now listened to this RUclips recording a number of times and feel I must thank you once again. I attended the Proms in London throughout the sixties and early seventies hearing several versions of this (ie Boult!). But, as I come back to this Warsaw recording, time and time again I feel this is the BEST recording I have ever heard. Such finesse, balance, feeling and... soul. The conductor's name is not one I can pronounce :) but I will remember it! Accept once again my thanks for a truly wonderful interpretation of a great piece of British music.
I lived in Poland for seven years and came to love the country. The Polish soul is a very old one. I saw evidence of it many, many times.
I am an American and it took me a while to understand this work. But I agree that this is the performance is the one I most want to listen to. Music is indeed universal, after all, we all love Shakespeare. (And Monty Python).
Variation XII (Andante) "B.G.N." is very touching. The cello solo is softly coming to us from heaven.
Special congratulations to these three musicians ladies: Concertino, first viola and first oboe. Love them!!!! 😘 😘 😘
Enjoying a lot again the excellent performance.
I find myself watching this in its entirety over and over. I never knew the Warsaw Philharmonic was so good. I wish I could but Blu-Ray videos of their performances but I’m not seeing any. What a discovery for me.
Your Nimrod rendition is so beautiful. Tears in my eyes.
I applaude you all, standing ovation from the UK 👏👏👏 simply outstanding 👏👏👏
The deepest truest Nimrod I have ever heard 👏 Congratulations 👏
A great performance - we Brits are always grateful when Elgar et al are performed abroad, especially this well.
Pretty much because we had no great composers besides him! Notwithstanding Purcell.
@@leod-sigefastVaughan-William's Fantasia on a Theme is - in my opinion - the most moving classical piece ever written.
@@leod-sigefast Vaughan Williams, Finzi, Parry, Bridge, Delius, Butterworth, Coates, Benjamin Britten etc. We have had a few. Elgar is my favourite though.
Vaughan Williams comes a very close second. But I've loved Elgar from childhood, andbthis isvthe best performamce of Enigma I've ever heard. And I'm Irish.
Leode Siefast
Purcell, William Byrd, Vaughan-Willams, Britten, Tippett, Robert Simpson, Maw, Whettam.
I've stumbled here late. In tears. Trying to come to terms with everything everyone else is trying to come to terms with. This is just sublime. Makes me miss full orchestra; makes me miss full brass. The pines of rome roar. Love it. To anyone else here and just absorbing this great performance: enjoy. Do well for those around you.
Yes, I miss playing in a symphony. There's something about being surrounded by the sound of the music all around me. It scoops me up and takes me to another place.
@@singingcyclops1 Absolutely it is different than listening. I often say "Oh I have played that before"! ... but I really think it is a different feeling being on the stage/grounds/dirt. :) This is not to take away from any performance: there are so many I could never achieve or be a part of or otherwise comment on. Just wish I could have been there :)
@@renzo6490 I also sang in choir in college. We used to do several great pieces with full symphony and a 73 voice choir. It would send chills down my spine sometimes.
the transition between VIII and IX is something truly divine.
Best recording of this I've seen. And, at the proper, slow tempo for "Nimrod".
adagio - a piece of music that is played or performed slowly and gracefully
Totally agree twelge15 - far too many conductors perform this at a faster pace and it ruines the whole build of the music. It has taken me ages to find someone who conductors at a similar pace to von Karajan - which is my very humble view is correct.
I thought long ago I had heard it at its proper adagio. But this is something else entirely...there is so much beauty and so much agony throughout Nimrod and I’ll be damned if I didn’t feel every single note like it was being torn out of me. I no longer have need for any other version of this.
Thank you twelge15 for your comment. To my ears this is the best Nimrod I have heard.
18:45 is just spine-tingling
Astonishing. Breathtakingly. Perfect. How many recordings of this have I in my collection and none... none... compare to this. Sweeping, majestic, haunting and poetic... Sir Edward would be proud and pleased. And, there were actually empty seats in the hall for this. How many of us would have like to have filled them. Bravo!
Yes! I wish I could have been there!! The word "perfect" is often used loosely, but you are spot on. This performance is perfect.
One of the most underrated orchestras in the world
This is one orchestra I really would like to attend at a live performance . Probably my favourite out of many others. This performance of Elgar's Enigma Variations is certainly at top of my music tree.
What a magnificent rendition of this Enigma Variations written by Elgar! Who better to perform this than Warsaw Philharmonic Orchestra by one of my favourite Conductor the ever green Jacek Kaspszyk!. Every single string or wind instruments do a amazing job and that's exactly what makes Warsaw Philharmonic Orchestra outstanding. I have been to Krakow several times and not once have I missed a Classical concert when I am there!
Thank you Poland for giving the world such remarkable musicians and music from Chopin to Ida Haendel and more! Your musical heritage is for all to see! It is rich with talents and glorious in performance!
Now on the lighter side you have given a teenager of enormous talent to the tennis world by the name Swiatek! You as a nation should be proud you have given the world and me such Joy by your incredible musical journey to bring Peace, Tranquility and Serenity to millions the world over! Love and greetings from Denmark.
i play cello and i participate in a orchestra and we play enigma and when i listen this i was crying because it's very beautiful!!!
Och... jestem tu znowu i słucham chyba 10ty raz...jest drugą w nocy a ja nie chcę iść spać.... jestem podekscytowany...
Ta muzyka sprawia że chce się żyć, wszystko ma smak i sens... dziękuję 😊
EXEPCIONAL musicality and sound of this orchestra.
The best performance I ever heard from this Enigma Variations, congragulations.v
Exquisite performance. Nimrod had me in tears.
As it should!
Nimrod does just that. Nimrod allows you to stand on the very precipice of all emotions that drive us to love.💘 . When the brass and drum begin, it takes you to a place we all seek but rarely ever find,. Home
Indeed.
@@lindar1043 Beautifully and perfectly expressed.
it always does. I miss my father who educated me with this masterpice.
That 9th variation always brings me to tears. One of the most beautiful pieces of music ever written.
Bellissima musica. Orchestra stupenda. Grazie 💚. Questo è il lato più bello della tecnologia 😊
Agreed!
Absolutely staggered by this live performance. Profoundly moving. The sheer beauty and depth were incredible. I remained stoically British stiff-upper-lipped until Nimrod and then the dam broke. From the bottom of my heart - thank you.
This whole performance is absolutely sublime, and Nimrod is one of the very best I have ever heard. Thank you for this.
But how can the audience response be so muted? Crazy.
Phil Bates honestly the silence after Nimrod is blessed. The first time I heard Enigma, I was utterly unprepared for what Nimrod would do to my soul. I would have given anything for those 5 seconds of silence, but the audience was so overwhelmed that they couldn’t withhold applause. And I was ripped out of the most emotionally reflective moment of my entire life.
'Edge of the seat' stuff.
@@philbates7975 You don't have to clap hard at all. Audience making any noise is just a childish act to be honest.
A little like your comment.
The finest collection of musicians united to achieve a cohesive expression of their collective talents I've experienced in a very long time.
Ein wunderbares Orchester und ein toller Dirigent.
Poland, this symphony, and this conductor clearly understand the restrained depth of British emotion and nostalgia. Quite possibly the best rendition of Nimrod I've heard from the many 100's of attempts I've come across.
Agree. Beautifully done. Bravo!
Moved me to tears.
@@foxtrotnow yep...me too
Agreed. Although I'd say more specifically English than British.
No doubt Warsaw has the best philharmonic orchestra, all of your interpretations are masterpiece. Thank you for sharing these with us.
I now forget how many times I've listened to this magnificent performance. Having a wide selection of most of Beethoven's Mozart's Dvorak's Chopin and many other composers, for some reason I love Enigma Variations. Maybe it is because of this performance by the Warsaw Philharmonic. I now know the faces of so many performers... noble people. Dedicated to music. Now five years ago. Every time I hear it and see it I wonder how those people are managing. Is Jacek Kasprzyk still there? The others? I wish you all well.
Of all the versions I have heard, this is easily the finest. It's simply superb.
Благодарю! Я влюбилась в эту музыку! Исполнение шикарное, невозможно оторваться!
The best version I ever heard, congrats Warsaw Philharmonic Orchestra, Jacek Kaspszyk
simply the best i have ever heard. my dad introduced me to Elgar, Nimrod always brings a tear to my eye. i miss you dad
The Warsaw Philharmonic Orchestra, Europe’s finest orchestra, delivers an unsurpassed performance of one of Elgar’s best-known works. There is also none better than maestro Jacek Kaspszyk.
Wonderful, wonderful, wonderful. It hurts so beautifully. Thank you.
Probably one of the best performed of Enigma, ever.
Truly the best performance of this musical piece I have ever listened to!
But how could we ever be disappointed by the Warsaw Philharmonic Orchestra and Jacek Kaspszyk?
A big thank-you to
Filharmonia Narodowa for the wonderful channel!
A truly exceptional and sublime performance of Elgar’s masterpiece.
If Elgar hadn't written any more music than this work he would have been famous and respected by this alone. Wonderful performance from beginning to end. Bravo!!
In the Nimrod variation, the section between 18:47 and 18:53 is truly spectacularly done. It's amazing how much emotion can be packed into six seconds of music. I have never heard a better rendition (and i have heard a LOT)
The climax at 18:50 is as close to perfect as I am likely to ever hear. No other conductor comes close. (Only God's Philharmonic can do it better - maybe....)
The wonderful people of Warsaw are so fortunate to have this beautiful orchestra representing them. I am grateful too, even if I don't live in Warsaw. Thank you!!!
Yes, IMO the Warsaw Philharmonic is possibly the most underrated orchestra in Europe. At their best with the outstanding conducting of Jacek Kaspszyk (who I heard in London conducting an unforgettable "In the South" overture) they yield almost nothing to the more famous philharmonics of Vienna and Berlin.
@@paullewis2413 I heard them in the UK a few years ago - fabulous orchestra and on terrific form here - the cello in Variation 12 is sublime.
Wspaniały. Szkoda, że tam nie byłem.
Magnificent. I wish I could have been present.
Elgar is very precious: Has sentiment -- but he's not sentimental; Has Drama -- but he avoids the caustic, corrupting melodrama. His work is just goodness. And this orchestra offers a fine performance. Thank you.
A wonderful performance from start to finish. Nimrod was devastating in its beauty and climax, but everything else about the performance was top-notch as well. Masterfully done.
Unarguably the finest performance of Elgar's Enigma Variations I have ever heard. Moves me to tears every time I hear it. Very good that also it was permitted to finish without the audience immediately clapping the well deserved applause. Many thanks to all in the orchestra.
I notice that I commented on this two years ago . It’s still wonderful and I selected this recording above all others because I knew that the Polish people would understand Elgar . I live on the Malvern Hills , near to Elgar’s birthplace and many other places that inspired his music , and I am aware daily of this connection.
Jacek Kaspszyk is clearly an outstanding interpreter of Elgar. His conducting of “In the South” overture a few years back in London is the best I’ve ever heard and now one of the finest of the Enigma Variations. Please Mr. Kaspszyk give us performances with your outstanding orchestra of Elgar’s two remarkable symphonies!
I have two fine recordings of "In The South" and would have loved to have heard Maestro Kaspszyk's
version referred to here. He clearly has the measure of Elgar!