Bad Romance (Lady Gaga vs Halestorm vs Rolling Quartz) REACTION & REVIEW! FIRST TIME HEARING!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 янв 2024
- Lady Gaga Fans.....Halestorm Fans.....Rolling Quartz Fans.....FEELIN' YOU!!! Tonight we're coming back to another Original Vs. Covers comparison. We have Lady Gaga Vs. Halestorm Vs. Rolling Quartz, as they all give me their take on the Lady Gaga song "Bad Romance". How's this one gonna go? Only one way to find out...
Come on in, enjoy the show...I'll see you inside.
Scoring System Guide
5 Stars - Amazing, Fantastic, Impressive, Perfect (if you believe in perfection).
4 Stars - Great, Very Good.
3 Stars - Pretty Good, O.k., Meh, Indifferent.
2 Stars - Pretty Bad, Bad, Really Bad
1 Star - Horrible, Awful, Terrible.
0 Stars - ??? (Hopefully we'll never have to find out)
Link to Original Video Here:
Lady Gaga - Bad Romance
• Lady Gaga - Bad Romanc...
Halestorm - Bad Romance (Lady Gaga cover)
• Halestorm - Bad Romanc...
Rolling Quartz - Bad Romance (Lady Gaga cover)
• Bad Romance (Lady Gaga...
My Patreon Page, where you can MAKE REQUESTS (As a Bronze Tier Member or higher) as well as view ALL the videos I try to post that RUclips is forced to block, can be found here: www.patreon.com/user?u=44053979
(Please note, you must be at least a Bronze Tier Member to be able to make fresh requests. All requests must be made on the Patreon page.)
My Twitter: / bassist4aw
My Instagram (I've just started learning how to use it): / davidheretic666
Our P.O. Box (yeah, we listened to you all and we got one):
P.O. Box #355
19360 Rinaldi St
Porter Ranch, CA. 91326
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. I have no intent on claiming this music for my own, I'm simply reacting to the video and giving my constructive criticism and feedback. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS 
Развлечения
the halestorm version is the best without question, if you want another flawless cover from them david, their cover of heart's "all I wanna do is make love to you" is truly phenomenal.
I made a mistake and typed the wrong song title in the first time around David, this is the correct one, apologies :)
I actually like the Rolling Quartz version the most. If I didn't know which was the original, I would have probably guessed that theirs was and that the other two took their overdone versions in 2 different directions. The Rolling Quartz version is the most straightforward and sounds the most real to me on first listen, while the other two both sound like something you'd get from big artists wanting to make it bigger and better. To me, the Halestorm version sounded the most lifeless. The instrumentation and performance sounded better than the Gaga overproduced digital sound, but it lacked the heart and conviction of Gaga's delivery. The original is good, very catchy and very well written, with great vocals from Gaga, and that chorus really hits. Yes, it's overproduced digital programming, but it's still fun to listen to. Unfortunately some of those lyrics do really make me cringe (la la, ga ga, baba yaga... etc)
Halestorm for the win!!!!!! I've seen them play it four times live now!!
🤘🤩🤘
David was getting loud in this one..
Fair assessment. Of course Halestorm are battle seasoned warriors. VERY early Rolling Quartz when they first got together (note: no brilliantly colored hair). Jayoung's vocal performance has improved ten fold. Compare her performance here to "Fearless".
Sad, sad state of affairs that the Lady Gaga spectle is so popular. It does not speak well of pop culture. Halestorm's version seems to have a lot of unnecessary compression. Definitely better than the original but could be better. I am not as excited about it as you are. The Rolling Quartz performance is one of the first things they did as a band. I have seen more recent performances that are better. I am a little biased because I am a huge RQ fan. I would rather listen to RQ's version than either of the other two. But, I am wearing an RQ t-shirt as I type this. Bias.
Yea but, the views on all of Halestorm and Rolling Quarts videos combined don't compare with one Lady Gaga video. It's the state of music these days.
Lizzie Hale always comes first, a unique rock star. I love her!
_Let's be honest here, Charles. This is the real reason why, right here, Rolling Quartz. This is the reason why you want to do this._
Actually, no, David. :-) The reason was exactly what I said in the intro: Your first reaction to Halestorm's cover, where the video and audio were so bad that you didn't even give it a rating. In the comment section of that reaction of yours, I made this comment 4 months ago:
_The real unfortunate thing about this is that there was a much better fan cam of the exact same performance._
_The person who made this request was sadly unaware and ended up requesting a reaction using the worst of the 2 fan cams that were posted of this performance._
_Watching this has actually given me an idea for a future reaction request._
And this request is that idea. :-) I included the Rolling Quartz's cover because they just so happened to have done their own cover of it, and you have done several reactions on them already, so why not include them, ya know?
In any case, I'm glad that you picked up on what Rolling Quartz did. Yeah, I agree that what they did was interesting, which was not to do a straight cover of Halestorm's take but to add in their own interpretation of the Lady Gaga original. Since you made mention of the lead singer of Rolling Quartz several times in this video, and you reacted to them several times also, I figured you should know her name which is Ja Young. In terms of her singing ability, yeah she's great but as I said in the intro:
_It should be noted, that Rolling Quartz posted their cover 9 months before they made their official debut_
so Ja Young has improved even more since then.
I appreciate you giving your many thoughts on all these different versions of the song. I thought it would make for a really cool video, even if you say Lady Gaga's original didn't stand a chance. But, I gotta admit, hearing all your insights and only seeing ratings of 5 stars kinda makes me wish you were using your usual out of 10 scoring system. It doesn't quite capture what you're saying, you know? So, I'm keeping my fingers crossed that you'll go back to the out of 10 scoring, because it does make me wonder what each song here really would've gotten from you.
By the way, that 3 minute rant or so that you gave starting at around the 26 minute mark with the whole "unleash the potential that was locked inside of it" and stuff was probably one of your more entertaining rants that I've heard!
And that line that you said at 22 minutes:
_Your battleship got sunk all right by a torpedo named Halestorm!_
Ha! That sounds like it could be a slogan for Halestorm or something.
Anyway, it is funny that you refer to Lady Gaga's original as a "little league team" when "Bad Romance" is actually one of the top-selling singles in history. That's a pretty impressive little league! That part where you were mocking Lady Gaga's "Ra, ra, ah-ah-ah, Roma, roma-ma" lyrics made me chuckle a little, but I believe that it helped the song since it's one of the things that people remember about it. You zeroed in on those lines too, so it obviously has an impact. However, that's just a small part of the lyrics, and it's the overall lyrical content that motivated Halestorm to create their cover, like I explained in the intro. As a self-confessed non-lyrics guy, you still picked up on Gaga's lyrics when you said that you felt that Halestorm's version really brought out the emotion of the lyrics. They did a fantastic job with their cover, but the fact that the lyrics stuck with even you means that Lady Gaga's version definitely works, even if the genre is not your cup of tea.
Even though you slammed Lady Gaga's original, I would be remiss here if I didn't mention that your reaction to her performing "Moth To The Flame" with Metallica on stage was one of those rare moments on your channel where a performance actually made you tear up. It's clear that her music might not be your favorite, but there's no denying she's an incredible artist when it comes to singing, songwriting, and putting on a show. When she went full-on Metal, she absolutely killed it, and your emotional reaction to her performance was a testament to that!
All in all, I enjoyed the video, so thanks, David!
As far as Lady Gaga goes, she needs to ditch Pop music and focus on Rock and Metal. Seriously, after seeing her perform with Metallica, I was shaking my head going Why doesn't she do this instead of Pop??? She's so good as a rock front woman, she really is.
@@THEDavidHeretic because $$ unfortunately
@@THEDavidHeretic fun fact: before becoming "lady gaga", she was the frontwoman of a led zeppelin cover band lol. She's a rock & metal head at heart, but she chose synth pop in order to parody it initially... and that just kind of stuck as her main sound.
The idea of the original song is to use synthesizers. It's not a failure, it's a choice.
A choice that turned into a failure
I wanted to be a singer with a successful "failure" like this. Failure is being a hater of an internationally known artist. lol.
@@kalanhitchens8782
Constructive critique...all should be live versions
You should of reacted to a live version of lady gagas bad romance, she basically has a band backing her every time she preforms.
A few years ago Lord of the Lost also covered this song. And it is included in the covers album that they released a few days ago.
You compared Lady Gaga's studio version vs live covers and you said it's all digital, well u should react to Lady Gaga live and compare it with other covers. ps lady gaga live killed it.
no, he did not. Halestorm was not Live. Pay attention. I believe you when you say Lady Gaga killed it Live - NOW.
She's a great singer and an unique artist - I hold Lady Gaga in high regards in the meantime. Gaga showed what she could do when she performed with Metallica or at the Oscars. But David was also right when he said that the Original was artificial and Lifeless. < I would really like to hear a re-imagined version by Gaga :-)
I would say the Haelstorm version has over the top compression, that just kills any dynamics and leaves it flat. Gaga's production was made for pop, not pop/metal. We all know she is exceptional live, so I'm trying to stick to the production value. Rolling Quartz was bottom of the pile for me... singing off pitch quite a bit@@ThielKlenner
For me the winner is Halestorm as well.
Just for another rendition of the song - Floor with ReVamp ruclips.net/video/3mXAKyqMhqw/видео.html
Oh, i forgot to suggest it on the reflecting god reaction, it would be interesting to see a comparison between "kinderfeld" from antichrist superstar and the demo version - "smells like children". Kinderfeld is industrial but with a doom flair, while smells like children is very different structurally - despite having the same bass hook.
I personally prefer smells like children, but kinderfeld is produced better for obvious reasons. "Smells like children (studio version)" is the version on youtube with the best quality.
Try reacting to Wicked Ways by Halestorm. The official music video and then the live performance
I'm kind of indifferent to the song, even the covers, but I do like the changes from Halestorm. In particular, they went to the half-time feel in the second part of the chorus, and then made it double-time for the last one. There's also a sneaky change in the beat just before the breakdown, where the snare switches to the 1 and 3.
The biggest highlight, though, was all the DH metaphors. 😆
Hey, reaction the rolling stones and lady gaga - sweet sounds of heaven
I don't like lady Gaga out of the covers I would choose both of them
Halestorm for sure. I like the original, but I love Lzzy's version. Prefer their version of Heathens too, lol.
Have you heard about the new Japanese band "East of Eden"?
We don't need to wait for you to tell us the order David :) .......
I definitely agree Halestorm for the win. As a keyboard player myself I cannot stand program digital shit. I prefer to actually play as you would hear it live. I prefer to play actual parts instead of a bunch of digital sequenced sampled crap.
@23:20 The Man, The Myth, The Legend
Watch her live or with Tony Bennett.
On target all the way.
I used to love Lady Gaga's version, and I still do enjoy it. But I've been ruined for purely digital music - same thing makes Taylor Swift's more recent music feel lifeless for me too. And a number of other artists. I just can't get behind a track with no instruments!
(T Swift actually just released some acoustic versions of her midnights songs - and I don't understand why the original choice was made. at all. they are worlds better)
Jeff Beck covered this. One of most interesting cover by him but great outcome
Listening to David riff on the KISS concept album and I’m like “Oh God… He doesn’t know Lulu exists because he stopped listening to Metallica after Reload.”
Hopefully, no one makes him listen to that.
Gaga has said that she writes her songs on piano - regardless of if pianos are involved in the song at all - because, as she puts it "a good song is a good song no matter what instruments you use"
If we're doing gaga, i would suggest "bloody mary". It has a nice haunted house feel to it.
Halestorm live version is even better. Give it a listen
i laughed hard watching david die inside
Flatlined on the Lady Gaga track.I wonder what it Sounds like ,with out the auto tune?
Lady Gaga has an incredible voice. Without autotune. She sang duets with Tony Bennett and did 2 albums with him.
Oooh .. I think your being a bit harsh on Gaga, she is awesome, but you must remember, the two bands who made the covers, must have thought the original was a banger to begin with 👊💥
And you have to give credit to those that created the original song. The others were just coping it not creating it.