Wow, for such a straight-forward effect (pun intended), this makes for a really enchanting clip. Even just the way Bobby's facial expressions are reversed at the end-- it creates a whole new story. Thanks for sharing!
The best part because the people spin it really doesn’t look like it’s going forward or backwards either way no matter which way you run it. It looks interesting.
To explain for those confused by this: the actual scene was done with the actors moving backwards and the footage was then run in the opposite direction in the film. This created a weird effect where the characters were moving normally but in a slightly off kilter way that generated unease. Also a possible connection to how the speech and motion in the evil Black Lodge was done backwards then played the other way in that famous dream-speech manner.
i never knew how badly i needed to see this... and i still don't quite understand all of what is going on in this scene. This is one that SHOULD be taught in film school. I've NO CLUE what the lesson would be.. but still.. it should be taught.
I think it's just part of David Lynch's artistry when it comes to making a totally mundane scene feel very dream-like or surreal. There's nothing inherently special about Bobby walking backwards, here. But the fact that he does it with such grace and the way nobody around him seems to mind or care, really sets this strangeness in motion. He's a weirdo that nobody acknowledges, not until after Laura's death, then he becomes prime suspect #1, alongside Leo and James.
Damn, i didn't thought about it at all, like it's normal Bobby behaviour. Nice detail. P.S Rewatching it makes scene even better, ngl, with all that goofiness from crowd. Perfect.
Stranger Things has the Upside Down. Twin Peaks has the Black Lodge where everything is both backwards and forwards. An allegory for the antimatter mirror universe where antiparticles spin in reverse, and which is based on e-l-e-c-t-r-i-c-i-t-y (rather than magnetism).
@@wyskass861 I'm sure I learned that at some point but forgot, or I just never put it together in that way. The natural world is crazy. Energy in general is astounding.
I saw this thing once that suggested that lies could be distiguished in reverse speach. Something to do with the human thought process and how we go about constructing a lie, apparently its undone in the reverse. The CIA apparently regarded this as a fact for years and have reversed recordings of people to sometimes find what theyre looking for. Something beautiful about a lie being unmade! Sorry ramdom tangent.
Reviving an ancient, long-dead comment to say that the same human pattern-seeking behaviour that leads to the effect known as "paradolia" - ie; seeing faces in things that aren't faces, like sand or gravel or clouds, tree bark, shadows, etc. Is also capable of doing the same thing to speech/noise. It's why people sometimes report hearing voices in allegedly haunted buildings, hear voices on the wind in forests, etc. The human brain is desperate to construct the stimuli it interacts with on a daily basis as something important and critical to it's survival. So when we hear reversed human speech, our brain jumps to interpret it in a way that makes sense to us. Hence, we come up with these crazy theories that we can somehow hear subliminal messaging in reversed speech. But the reality of it is, our mind is just trying to make sense of what clearly sounds like human speech, but definitely doesn't make sense.
@@brigadier-tc8565The first time Coop talks about Bob and Mike to Harry after his dream Harry even asks "Mike and Bobby?" and Coop says "No, different Mike and different Bob"
![Twin Peaks - What Year Is This [Final Scene]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/R36ww3q7nqE/mqdefault.jpg)
![Twin Peaks - What Year Is This [Final Scene]](/img/tr.png)
Bobby has such swagger even if he's in reversed
The swaggiest!
This is how the Lodge entities see our world.
I want to be a lodge resident.
That gum he likes is going to come back in style.
he seems like a gum chewer
Bobby reversed time so much, he changed Donna in the process.
HAHAHAHA!
Fire MOONWALK WITH ME
Just another normal day in that little town
Nothing weird over here!
Wow, for such a straight-forward effect (pun intended), this makes for a really enchanting clip. Even just the way Bobby's facial expressions are reversed at the end-- it creates a whole new story. Thanks for sharing!
Thanks for watching! I agree, it's so simple, but unique and weird and fun.
The best part because the people spin it really doesn’t look like it’s going forward or backwards either way no matter which way you run it. It looks interesting.
It's some fun visual art.
That smile-drop at the end, perfect
I know, right? That might be my favorite part.
Reminds me of Kanye
@@spejampar It was a great (dare I say Lynchian?) way to end the clip! 😊
@@calanor4130 I'll take all the credit! ;)
He looks like he's about to break out a musical number
I so wish that would've been true.
Me with Walk Fire: Peaks Twin
This somewhat makes sense
Fire backwalk with me.
Man every little detail, intentional or not, is just amazing. You can't beat the world of lynch and twin peaks
you got that right! It's fun to watch each person.
He was so real for this
He's the best
To explain for those confused by this: the actual scene was done with the actors moving backwards and the footage was then run in the opposite direction in the film. This created a weird effect where the characters were moving normally but in a slightly off kilter way that generated unease. Also a possible connection to how the speech and motion in the evil Black Lodge was done backwards then played the other way in that famous dream-speech manner.
and its somehow one of the most of putting parts of the show ( this is not negative its praise, very few artist can make you feel this way)
Let's rock
That last second gets intense lol
Yeah it does! What's gonna happen next?!
I enjoyed that more than I thought I would.
It's good stuff, right? :)
@@spejampar You betcha. Damn good stuff.
Best pharcyde song by far
Haha!
This was oddly visually pleasing to me.
It's perfectly normal to be pleased by this! Nothing odd about that! ;)
this is absolutely the very best part of this entire film
I can’t tell if that means you love this scene a WHOLE LOT or you just LIKE the rest of the film. 😝
i never knew how badly i needed to see this... and i still don't quite understand all of what is going on in this scene. This is one that SHOULD be taught in film school. I've NO CLUE what the lesson would be.. but still.. it should be taught.
A whole class on this one scene! I love it. If Lynch taught it, it would be about 1 minute long "We shot the scene. That's it."
I think it's just part of David Lynch's artistry when it comes to making a totally mundane scene feel very dream-like or surreal. There's nothing inherently special about Bobby walking backwards, here. But the fact that he does it with such grace and the way nobody around him seems to mind or care, really sets this strangeness in motion. He's a weirdo that nobody acknowledges, not until after Laura's death, then he becomes prime suspect #1, alongside Leo and James.
*We live in a twilight world*
Damn, i didn't thought about it at all, like it's normal Bobby behaviour. Nice detail. P.S Rewatching it makes scene even better, ngl, with all that goofiness from crowd. Perfect.
Yeah, I love the start (end) of the scene when they're moving weird.
Garmonbozia
"I AM THE ARM."
Hend hai sound loik this woowoowoowoowoowoo
Meanwhile...
Sometimes his legs walk backwards.
So THIS is Tenet?
Pretty much, yeah.
Stranger Things has the Upside Down. Twin Peaks has the Black Lodge where everything is both backwards and forwards. An allegory for the antimatter mirror universe where antiparticles spin in reverse, and which is based on e-l-e-c-t-r-i-c-i-t-y (rather than magnetism).
I don't know what to say but I love the connection!
electricity and magnetism are the same phenomenon expressed through both orthogonal fields simultaneously.. One doesn't exist without the other.
@@wyskass861 I'm sure I learned that at some point but forgot, or I just never put it together in that way. The natural world is crazy. Energy in general is astounding.
@@spejampar True indeed
Electricity and magnetism are flip sides of the same coin.
0:11 to 0:14 Does anyone else hear this? " in the free world forced to choose" There are other messages, too. There's a science about reverse speech.
Thanks for pointing that out! I love backwards sounds and talking and stuff.
I saw this thing once that suggested that lies could be distiguished in reverse speach. Something to do with the human thought process and how we go about constructing a lie, apparently its undone in the reverse.
The CIA apparently regarded this as a fact for years and have reversed recordings of people to sometimes find what theyre looking for.
Something beautiful about a lie being unmade!
Sorry ramdom tangent.
I heard, “In a free world for tacos.” But I’m hungry.
Reviving an ancient, long-dead comment to say that the same human pattern-seeking behaviour that leads to the effect known as "paradolia" - ie; seeing faces in things that aren't faces, like sand or gravel or clouds, tree bark, shadows, etc. Is also capable of doing the same thing to speech/noise. It's why people sometimes report hearing voices in allegedly haunted buildings, hear voices on the wind in forests, etc.
The human brain is desperate to construct the stimuli it interacts with on a daily basis as something important and critical to it's survival. So when we hear reversed human speech, our brain jumps to interpret it in a way that makes sense to us. Hence, we come up with these crazy theories that we can somehow hear subliminal messaging in reversed speech. But the reality of it is, our mind is just trying to make sense of what clearly sounds like human speech, but definitely doesn't make sense.
I hear it too!!
Ah, the other Bob and Mike. Certain they were going to do more with that if it hadn't been cancelled.
What do you speculate that was going to be about?
How the hell is this the first time I realised there was two Bobs and Mikes?!?!?!?!
@@brigadier-tc8565The first time Coop talks about Bob and Mike to Harry after his dream Harry even asks "Mike and Bobby?" and Coop says "No, different Mike and different Bob"
@@Ren.4744 I'm a total moron, aren't I?
@@brigadier-tc8565 No.
so it was a dream...
But was it?
What year is this 2 by 4?
We live INSIDE a DREAM.
Awesome sauce, Bobby, err Spencer.
You can call me Bobby. It's fine. I like backwards stuff. :)
Reminds me of Jim Carrey in the ballerina dress
I think I can see that! I love it.
That was cool but creepy
It's in that perfect zone.
Haey zlleh ho!
!mooB
@@spejampar8008
Title of this song please!!
"A Real Indication"
Uhhhh...what?
I think it's pretty clear. ;)