Do you even realize that people that legally came into this country make up a large share those in the country illegally and I'm talking about those who are visa overstayers, the majority of whom are Canadians and Europeans. Of course you didn't know that.
@@wvvwwvwvv you paid your own defense companies to create new weapons and send the old ones you no longer use. A fraction of your yearly military spending. :')
@@jonathanponce857 I don’t think Trump will deport US citizens for what their parents did. There are enough undocumented immigrants to keep him busy for a while.
There is nothing wrong with being Pro Immigration and Anti Illegal Immigration. If the factories, construction, etc need more workers they can increase the legal immigration rate.
Neah. If there was enough pressure for that (by people firing for those Visa's) they likely would allow more temp labor. Lots of companies don't want to. Those kinds of Visa come with requirements for the employer (housing, pay rate, etc). And inherently give those workers a better leg to stand on. Illegal labor is cheap and employers generally aren't punished for it. So for them it's all upsides. That's without mentioning the fact that smaller businesses often don't know how to obtain those or can't afford the costs to staff that way (lawyers and such to help with it aren't cheap). And for factories it's often cheaper just to move them to Mexico or another cheaper country. Not that it's all bad. Economically Illegal immigrants tend to be good in direct ways (often paying taxes and never collecting benefits). And indirect such as food cost (American agriculture would be far less competitively priced compared to import if the workers cost more).
Yes it does technically, but when people will hear criminal they will think “violent, anti-social offenders” which the data shows they aren’t in high numbers.
Because it is arbitrary. US immigration is notoriously broken. It's far more complex and bureaucratic than it needs to be. If one is really a concerned, use a background check. Easy peasy. Border controls serve a purpose, but those controls need to be properly calibrated with the purpose. In the US, they are not. Not optimally at least
it's all bs, good man, the moment such an illegal immigrant does Trump a favour he gets to live in a nice villa, look at Melania and her family, they're just telling you what you like to hear, next they'll just make sure those dudes work the factories and undercut your wages, don't worry.
Why do people keep harping about migrants being criminals when all they wanted was a better life (as your ancestors did) while continuing to ignore the illegal acts their own elected president has commited. At this rate, DT's crimes probably amount to the entirity of crimes commited by "illegals"!!
It's not going to work ser what happened in 1954 Eisenhower did was horrible and 60 something years later do you thing is going to work?.AMERICA IS BROKEN NOW WITH OUT INDUSTRY AND NO WORKERS FROM WERE THE MINEY IS COMING FROM.? ?
It is supposed to take 10 years. I'm a legal immigrant, earned my US degree, earned my green card, and it takes 5 years after green card to qualify for citizenship. The idea is you earn and prove you deserv3 citizenship by having skills and obeying the law. Citizenship is worthless when people can just come illegally, only prove they break laws, and get it.
@@APerls it’s broken because it was intended that way! The majority of Americans don’t even know what legal immigration… All Europeans had to do was get a medical certificate of good health and drop the ethnic last name 😂
$7 billion in arrests. $66 billion in detention centers. $12.6 billion in legal proceedings. Security and safety of Americans, PRICELESS. For everything else, there's Mastercard.
@@longiusaescius2537 Unions are empowered when the organize all workers regardless of immigration status. Amnesty helps with organization. Billionaire capitalist want to deport during economic downturns and to create a pariah class keeping some workers with the illegal status to hold down wages of all workers.
Interpretation, by criminals it's referred to the country they came from. By illegal refers to US law. Big difference. A crime in the US is not necessarily a crime in a different country, but criminal records carry cross all borders.
Yet the FBI stats clearly show they commit crimes at least 5x more than normal (FBI says they are way under reported). My city is now the most violent in the US because of them.
@@night_hunter4752you can be Jesus Christ himself but if he cross the border illegally, you are breaking the law in the land in which you just entered. Therefore he is a criminal.
To say that people entering the country illegally are not committing any crimes is a paradox. We went into the finances of how much it cost to deport. Let's go into the finances on what it costs to keep them within the country.
They add to the economy, they fill jobs nobody wants like picking food in the farms. Or were there are shortages like construction, The USA was built by immigrants and still is to this day. For every dollar they get paid, what we get in returns is greater.
Ok we pay 196 billion for the ones already here a year of federal tax not including the amount we send in state taxes. And they bring in less than 25 billion in all 50 states and most are in welfare. So imagine we are going to spend more and tax more for them to the 15 million that comes in. We cannot afford them and unsustainable. Its cheaper to send them back. They say 88 billion a year to send them back.
This problem has been decades in the making and it will take decades to fix. There will be bumps along the way. The cost will be significant. But if your country doesn't have a secure border, you don't have a country.
the thing is it is. The people that are working do not get the benefits and they pay to work here including paying our taxes. If those people won't be working here anymore because they will be deported, who's going to do those jobs? ALL those taxes they pay which is over a billion... who is going to pay those now? I don't think people are seeing the bigger picture here on what is going to happen.
No trump will ensure a large part of the hardest workers that benefit the country flee elsewhere where they are welcomed, damn i think most countries in Europe would receive them with open arms compared to the people coming in right now.
@@Rubbe87 had a guy I work with come at me with "You all are illegals. every person in the US is an illegal immigrant if they are not native American." my answer was " nope, my family cam over as slaves of the English king."
This is the USA. When have resources and manpower ever been a problem? Even in that case, we'd have at least 50 million volunteers willing to assist the operation for free.
That would be the least of the issues. It's not like the authorities can send the undocumented immigrants a letter to please show up for deportation. Nope, they need to pick them up. Probably they need to search for them with methods that aren't legal under the US constitution, and they need to pester millions US citizens and deprive them of some of their rights under the constitution to have any success. And more likely, they don't have the manpower to do even a fraction of all of that. You'd basically need a force like the SS or STASI or some other form of secret police. Not gonna happen, even if it's just for cost reasons. But non-cooperation of most US citizens will go a long way as well.
He's got the highest court of the land on his side no matter what. The fact you think the courts would stop him shows how little you know about us politics atm
You are right, you see, you arent fleeing terror and violence for your family , your children. But how could you , half of America doesnt even know where half of the rest of the world is. I doubt if many could pick out South America on a global map.
Best way forward is cut all govt funding to migrant NGOs let them survive on donations forcing their executives accept a decrease to their massive salaries. To many of them don't actually do much other than aid migrants avoid the border guards, and take down names to send the bill to the local, state and federal govt to receive subsidies.
The problem is ngos only use immigrants because Americans refuse to do the jobs they do, or are you volunteering to work in the fields for even $50 an hour. Farmers lost crops to rot during trumps last presidency, because the Americans that believed they were just as good as immigrant workers lasted a day or two at most. But we will see, it is a dangerous experiment as if it fails so does America's food supply. You think prices are too high now wait. I am just glad i do not live there and can laugh at what you all voted for.
@@broski365 when lots of illegal immigrants also go for those jobs, the wages go down, thats why nobody wants to do it, the strawberry farm will have to offer honest wages to the us citizens or just go out of business...
The problem with this video is the It's basically arguing that money Is more important than sovereignty and national security. You can't say that the United States should endlessly throw money at some Ukraine to protect their sovereignty and national security and then turn around and say that it's somehow ridiculous for America to do the same in their own borders. Economically speaking for average people Would stand to benefit from removing these illegal immigrants because this Would reduce the labor pool and mean that companies can no longer benefit off of cheap labor which would mean they would have to raise wages in order to Get more workers. The people who would suffer from Losing illegal immigrant labor would be multinational corporations. I do think that there should be a conversation on the corruption of these Companies turning a blind eye to undocumented labor, personally I do think these companies should be punished for also breaking the law.
Just got fired from my job today I am a nail technician who started working for a nail salon late last month everything was going good they even agreed to have me on maternity leave for middle of feb. Because I’ll be having my baby first week of march. They knew I just graduated forms school even seen me work and got a few returning clients ,everything went good until I got my first paycheck I work in Arizona she didn’t give me a w2 nor 1099 payed me cash and payed me 45% commission for the services performed when I told her I thought legally you were supposed to pay me minimum wage because it was higher than my commission this week she says no I only pay 45% commission I thought oh ok she’s the business owner she must know more then me well I made it to my second paycheck now she’s hiring illegal Asians who are not even lisenced. So I went to school I’m pregnant and I was let go this morning because she was able to hire more experienced illegal technicians who are working for less than minimum wage! Now I have no Job 2 weeks before my kids 3rd bday and 6 weeks before christmas I wanna report them so bad but Karma will be in my side seems like it already is!
13:45 - “illegal immigrants are not organized as a group” They are collected through social media & written media in foreign countries, their travel & food is funded by money from groups, they are given instructions by groups, they are supported by legal organizations in the US… they most certainly are!
13:55 - “crime rates by illegal immigrants in the United States is actually very low” This is not true. Crime rates for legal immigrants in the United States is very low. In many sanctuary cities, crime is legal, where people are not prosecuted, therefore not arrested, and therefore the number is not available. When captured in sanctuary cities for atrocious crimes, they are not asked about their legal status, so as not to report to the federal government for deportation, so we don’t even know then.
The numbers are also altered by the Democratic politicians advising their dem buddies as Governors or Mayors etc to dummy the numbers. I don't think it is even a crime to turn in falsified numbers for a federal census type info gathering. They can also play with the definitions of what they count or don't count like they do inflation. They count things favorable to their position and don't count things detrimental.
Can’t say for sure what should be done, but it seems fair to say the government messed up and let way too many people in and this needs to be corrected. The US are not the only ones with this issue either.
Many countries are facing this issue. Here in Ireland we have had an influx of Ukrainians and people from the middle east, only for the most part, we seem to be a lot more hospitable towards them which I hope doesn't change given the surge in nasty anti-immigration misinformation posts that are becoming ever more prolific on social media platforms like X. Migration is the price of war and corrupt governments. In Venesaula people's wages are not covering a fraction of the money required to feed a family so how can they stay? In war torn countries. where citizens see their family and friends butchered and children raped, how can they stay? Would we stay? After a few years of Trumps administration I can foresee a whole lot of people wanting to leave the USA given that Trump is modelling his administration on how North Korea run things. It's going to be a very unpleasant, corrupt government in place, and it wouldn't surprise me if USA people try to mass exodus there as well in the coming years. Maybe when they're fleeing for their lives or in search of wages that will feed them, they'll regret their vitriol towards otherwise innocent people who were really just trying to survive life and keep their family from harm.
Maybe not quite THAT high, but huge increases in prices for meat and dairy is absolutely coming. My hubby worked for one of the top meat companies in the US. The workforce was 95% immigrants. He now works in the egg industry where his company alone just found and fired over half his workers that he supervises because they were immigrants and the company made the mistake of outsourcing its hiring to a third party recruitment service that either didn't vet their fake papers hard enough or didn't require them to have legal docs in the first place. These companies don't pay enough to attract legal US citizens to work for them, and the trade off is we all get to enjoy cheaper beef, pork, chicken, eggs, and milk. But not anymore Oh and my hubby's company also supplies the egg products for companies like Hersheys, Burger King and Taco Bell breakfast menus. So look forward to paying even more for your candy and fast food soon (even worse than inflation and corporate greed price gouging).
If you cared about criminality for the sake of it, you wouldn't even entertain a single thing Trump has to say as he is a criminal and Musk was an illegal immigrant when he built his businesses. The point of contention is : What are these people DOING when they get here? People on your side of the issue tend to think these immigrants are ultra-violent gang members. Truth is : An OVERWHELMING of them want to keep their head down and work and end up contributing to America in ways that literally keep us running.
I found this video infuriating. The US has some of the most liberal laws towards illegal migrants in the world. If the US adopted the policies of nearly any other country in the world - the migrants would leave. That is: employment eligibility checks on employment and fining non compliant employers, eligibility checks for education, healthcare and most government services. In most countries, illegal migrants live in the margins in the US that is currently not the case
While I agree with the idea that AI can't do every job in the world, the types of jobs it can do are the middle level white collar jobs, so most American citizens will need a job or its going to lead to massive unrest, and understand that I'm using a polite word like unrest. Think LA Riots from the 90s but way worse. The people in politics know this and their solution is free up labor jobs at the bottom and hope that the labor market adjusts to pay low skilled jobs a living wage.
As soon as my cousins turned legal, they did a 180 and turned anti-immigration. You think they deserved or earned their citizenship? They're stuck in poverty, they beg us for money, they're on welfare and benefits they now qualify for. Do ppl even think about this shit 😂 my Trump supporter coworkers is a middle aged drop out stuck in a deadend job. Guess what, HES ON WELFARE TOO 😂 my friends mom isnt legal and shes working as a fucking nurse assistant i think studying too! You cant categorize a whole group, bc in that case, every undocumented immigrant ive met is working way harder and are raising their kids with an educational focused mentality. Meanwhile my fellow legal hispanics arent even making it past an Associates...
@@clayongunzelle9555 I don’t think it’s bias to point out practical difficulties. You must have been lied to by a politician before. You just got lied to again
Wouldn't it be cheaper to make everyone legal, no questions asked, and also keep the economy growing? A follow up video analysing that approach would be interesting
As a generally liberal Brit, I was quite surprised at how biased your analysis is of the deeper cultural concerns. Yes it doesn't always manifest as eloquent dialogue, yes Trump is brash and says extreme things to get attention, but people are so angry at being adandoned, ignored and demonised by the left, especially on "Democrat no-go" subjects like immigration, trans/DEI policies and the white middle class. Being surprised or shocked by how and why Trump is here is a failure on the part of the listener. Apart from that, love the videos generally!
""Democrat no-go" subjects like immigration" What a crock of unmitigated shiite. Have you read the previously proposed bi-partisan immigration bill, the one that was struck down by Trump? You sure as hell don't sound 'generally liberal', but nice try.
I mean I get why people feel abandoned, but to destroy the economy and people's lives, US citizen children's lives, just to stick it to the "woke elite" is dumb and destructive. Most illegal immigrants I do know own a business, have kids, and aren't engaging in anti social behavior, there are plenty that do, but most just keep to themselves and try to live day by day. Answer is, did they break the law? Yes. Does it justify destruction of the economy in a short period of time? No.
@sebastianflisback3296 Nah they're just stating facts and policies, if anything libs would find this video too pro-Trump, I mean if the guy's literal policies seem like shit, he's probably a shit president 🤷
11 million? The number 11 million has been used for decades. Just the ones caught average a million a year. Those that aren't caught are at least twice as many. So it's closer to 15-20 million now.
Have you bothered to ask the Native Americans on that point. Illegal immigrants flooded their land, took it, killed their nation with no repercussions. You bloody hypocrites.
Let's Trump voters taste the pill they asked for. Unfortunately the pill will be shared by all others: voters against Trump and nonvoters as well as those who couldn't vote being not citizens staying in the USA both legally and not. As always the bitterness will be spread unevenly.
WHAT ABOUT ALL THE AMERICANS THAT WILL HAVE NO JOBS IF HE STARTS LETTING EVERYONE GO IN THE GOVERNMENT? OH YEA! GET RID OF MILLIONS OF PEOPLE WITH GOOD PAY AND BENIFITS, This will screw all his voters, lol
The USA is a joke, it's politics is akin to watching comedy shows like Seinfeld or Friends. You have the power to vote for better leaders but you vote for clowns 😂 funny for us outsiders but bad for you. Have a nice 4 years or whatever long it's going to be 🎉
@@dassagichkeinem4454 Many Americans who needs the job for food. I run two shipyards, I can't say they are low payed job but it is hard laboring job. And if the job is low paying it means one thing.. easy jobs with no skill required. But most laboring jobs do better than Taxi Drivers. If you plan to work in McDonald frying fries, you will get the payment they deserve. But if you do hard labor you will get payed more. It is no not female job.
No. Most Americans won't pursue those jobs thanks to the abysmally low wages. Or those prices will go up dramatically. Its a bit like tariffs. You put those up, ths public food the bill and not the other country.
Fact check: Kurds are not illegal in Turkey, Kurds are citizens of Turkish state. They have equal rights and can become anything they want. Stop spreading misinformation. Kurds are a part of our country and we are like brothers and sisters.
Every candidate in recent political history made impossible promises. Spelling out the details of what would be required to accomplish what Trump said he would do is not anti candidate. It’s good reporting.
Thank you for appropriately and correctly referring to those that cross the U.S. border and claim asylum at anywhere other than a legal port of entry as "Illegal". The problem with deportation is that many - particularly convicted criminals - have been deported 2,3,4 more times and just cross back over.
As a beginner investor, it's essential for you to have a mentor to keep you accountable. Bridget Lee Wade is my trade analyst, she has guided me to identify key market trends, pinpointed strategic entry points, and provided risk assessment, ensuring my trades decisions align with market dynamics for optimal returns.
Debunk, by the guess and neighbors of the resort. Also later on by the Secret Service. Mara-Logo hire Cubans, Asians, Whites, Native American, Indians, Filipinos, Jamaicans, but very few Latins. You should visit.
I'm disgusted by all these comments here. We are all immigrants, just because you've been here longer doesn't make you an American. The true Americans were the natives who lived here. Of course the United States took over their land and gave them no options. I don't care whether its legal or illegal the way they got in. All of us are immigrants. The indifference towards immigrants is disgusting, even for Immigrants that came here legally, they are mistreated and racially discriminated. Mexico is a country plagued with corruption, narcotics, and economical struggles. If you members of your family had been kidnapped or killed by cartels, how would you feel? The United States isn't far off. There is so much crime that by the time you report it its already too late. I hope people start opening their eyes and realize all these politicians are terrible. Even when trump was president, nothing changed, crime, homelessness, and other problems still resided.
WHOS FAULT IS IT THAT MEXICO 🇲🇽 DECIDED TO BECOME INDEPENDENT FROM SPAIN? THE SPANISH CULTURE WAS MUCH MORE CIVIL DESPITE THERE PREJUDICE NATURE... THE AZTECS, & MAYANS ALONG WITH ALL THE ORIGINAL TRIBES FROM MEXICO WERE RATHER UN CIVIL IN NATURE & BARBARIC... STUBBORN & REBELLIOUS AGAINST AUTHORITY... YOU SPEAK A LOT ABOUT CARTELS BUT DONT LOOK AT THE SOURCE OF THE PROBLEM... MEXICO 🇲🇽 CHOSE TO BE INDEPENDENT FROM SPAIN... THE SPANISH HAD ENOUGH WEALTH TO FUEL AN AWESOME SAFE ECONOMY FOR MEXICO 🇲🇽 YET MEXICO CHOSE INDEPENDENCE... AS A RESULT YOUR COUNTRY SUFFERS FROM CORRUPTION & POINTLESS CIVIL WARS AMERICA HAS BEEN VERY GENEROUS TO THE MEXICAN PEOPLE... THEYVE GIVEN OUT MILLIONS OF DOLLARS 💲 FOR SOCIAL SECURITY, FOOD STAMPS & BENEFITS MORE THAN OUR OWN MILITARY VETERANS WHAT MORE DO YOUR PEOPLE WANT??? IN PRISON THE MEXICAN MAFIA RUNS EVERYTHING IN THE STREETS??? MEXICAN GANGS DOMINATE IN CRIME & DRUG DEALING IS IT BAD THAT SOME PEOPLE WANT TO RAISE FAMILIES WITHOUT THE BULLSHIT THAT MEXICO BRINGS??? 🇲🇽
I live in a predominantly Mexican neighborhood and a lot of Mexicans feel unfairly treated. Some Mexicans have been in the US for decades, worked hard to earn their place here and didn’t get any help to get setup here. Meanwhile, Venezuelans for example have come to Chicago and been given free money, healthcare, places to stay, then those same Venezuelans turn around and have created some issues in city including within our neighborhood like stealing or starting up Venezuelan gangs. That alone has caused some people I know to vote Trump meanwhile I sat out the vote because while I agree with limiting immigration, I also believe men should stay out of the abortion argument as that isn’t up to us.
Trump literally had nothing to do with that issue. He is not a judge. And Democrats have had million chances to encode Roe in to law. They never do it because they want it to be an issue EVERY election. It's their best path to victory. So, in that case, you are suggesting men should stop voting for good.
Most poeple don't realize that 11 Miillion people equals 3.28% of the total US population. I doubt the US economy could take that big a hit, the loss ot tax revenue would be huge and many low paying jobs that "real" Americans do not want due to them being dirty, hot and nasty. Odds are many crops would be left to rot in the fields due to lack of workers to pick the produce, leading to shortages and increased prices. And this is just one example of potential economic impact of Trumps anti-immigratnat policies.
We'll be just fine? Watch. Besides, housing has gone up, there are housing shortages, groceries, et cetera due to the illegal invasions. Also, Trump is going to make our Veterans a priority. All the freebies have run out. Buh-bye!!!!
Most migrants don't want to do jobs that don't pay well to cover the cost of living. Only those allowed in as seasonal workers are even provided with places to sleep by the employer. A lot of automation is occurring in farming industry as younger migrants are finding it too hard or unwilling to do difficult labor apply to service industry. Its something that Canada is going through with places that wanted migrants in the Atlantic and Central provinces losing them to already over crowded major cities.
@@guardianoffire8814 I think you mistakenly put the word "migrants" instead of "Americans" in your statement the don't want to do jobs that don't pay well (enough) to cover the cost of living. While automation and mechanization is growing in the agricultural industies, much of the haversting of crops still needs to be done by hand due to various reasons Until the moron Musk's Tesla Bot can pick a ripe strawberry and leave an unripe one on the vine, human labour will be required. I'm a Canadian as well and know what is happening here in regards to migrant labour and how buggered up our system can be, especially toward legal and highly skilled immigrants. I knew a lady from China who was not only an Electrical Engineer, but she designed power grid systems, taught in Technical Universities and even wrote/contributed to text books on the subject. She was also fluent in English. So when both the BC and Federal Government when overseas looking for talent to help here, she applied and came her with her son. Upon arrival, the British Columbia Electrical Association (BCEA), the licencing body for Electrial Engineers refused to recognize her qualifications, telling her she would have go back to school and start at square one inorder to be ceritified. She had to take menial low paying jobs to support her and her young son. In the end she returned to China after saving up enough for air fare and left Canada, our loss if you ask me. Like it or not, both the US and Canada are dependent on migration, be it legal or illegal. There are jobs that natural born citizens are loath to do because they are seen to be beneath them or the rate of pay offered is too low. These are that jobs that migrants generally fill.
Most countries do not have birthright citizenship. There is nothing in the US Constitution that allows this. Birthright citizenship has been allowed by courts. A new law could overturn this.
Actually, it is in the Constitution. It’s the 14th Amendment! Any new law passed restricting birthright citizenship would be unconstitutional, and thus unenforceable. The only way to change it would be through a constitutional amendment.
@@lindadeeds5326 There is also an 1898 Supreme Court ruling (US v. Wong Kim Ark) that would be used. Once Trump issues an EO, which has force of law, someone will sue and the Supreme Court will follow precedent.
@@lindadeeds5326 the 14th amendment was to ensure all former slaves were clearly determined to be citizens. It was not for pregnant aliens to arrive and give birth to then claim their child was a citizen.
I don't think the price of Trump's deportations bothers him that much. The deportations would be Trump's glorious achievement when he leaves office while it would be his successor who fails miserably to solve, within a single electoral term, the massive problems created by he Trump deportations. Trump is really good at this, smash things to pieces, declare himself a winner and leave the cleanign up after him to somebody else.
It's the logistics challenges I don't see as feasible. I don't think people really understand the numbers we would be talking about here, or the fact that the US simply isn't going to toss them all to the other side of the border (and what that actually looks like, as many have never been to the South West or seen what the terrain and climate is like there). We have the rule of law in the US, and we simply aren't going to wave that away.
@@longiusaescius2537 Seriously...that's your answer? Yes, planes exist. Do you know how many flights it would take to fly 100's of thousands or millions to central and south America? Or what it would cost? Never mind...clearly not.
Look at the UK - the Brexit caused a mass leaving of east-European (legal) immigrants, leaving the Hospitality, Healthcare, Transportation, and Farming industries without workers. Even today, this gap of workers could not be filled. All the unemployed individuals, claiming that immigrants steal their jobs, are still unemployed and living from welfare. So think of the impact on the economy in the USA. Fun fact, all illegal immigrants from the USA that can drive a Truck, or work as a Carer or in Hospitality or repair Cars, are welcome to move to the UK. Just apply for the visa.😆
Not more willing, cheaper. You confuse the two. The cheap labor is why there being imported. Your being lied to. A man will work any job when faced with losing everything.
@@kinginyellow1490 Immigrants are not limited to cheap jobs. I'm working in IT and let me tell you "Europeans" are kind of a rarity. Often these jobs required technical skills that are difficult to find. That also the case in the medical domain, ranging from nurses to doctors. So beside your slightly racist assumption, the problem can be reduce to supply and demand. an example to put it simply : * All western country have an aging population. * Increasing number of seniors will require more doctors and nurses * There will not be enough students in med schools across these countries to satisfied the demand.
Illegal immigration is against the law and it seems the previous administration "forgot" about that. As a canadian citizen I cannot move into the US illegally and I would be prosecuted and deported if I tried to so This should be the same for everyone else not following the procedures in place in ANY country. Deporting everyone would be too big of a task but at least sealing the borders and enforce the laws from now on would be a good start.
You can say this just because you are a Canadian. When you become an Indian, who need to wait 15 years to get a Green Card, and who are under a constant threat of losing their job and having to leave, then I would listen to you
What do you mean when you say that Trump would be able to push through the constitutional amendment?? That would require 2/3 of the Senate, plus either 2/3 of the House or a convention. On top of that 3/4 of states would have to ratify it. How the fcuk is Trump gonna do all that?
Cash pay or fake social security numbers is how they used to do it. That meant that all of these people paid into the American systems without any benefits other than true emergency healthcare. It’s just not a good idea to remove most of them.
cash, fake ss number, or 1099 with a fake ss number with a 1099 the employeer can pay them as sub contractor then its up to them to report and pay their own taxes which guess what they never do why would they, if the irs checks into it the social security number leads no where. Meanwhile the American citizen working the same job pays around 30% of the check to taxes. The employees gets to write off the 1099 employee as cost to operation same as American citizen so the employer doesn't care they are both write offs as cost
It's amazing how even americans don't understand how being an illegal immigrant doesn't make you a criminal. It's not typified in criminal law, it doesn't carry a prison sentence. It's not a crime, it's not a felony. Do your damn research.
@@felipenachmanowicz9393 But yeah exact punishment aside it very much is a crime, we have ranges for sentencing, variations of different circumstances the works.
#1 national security for America will always be to secure her own borders. Only do the bare minimum to support NATO, & money saved can be repurposed for American border security.
NGOs spent far less that the estimates given in this video to send the illegal migrants here. The idea that something is expensive is no reason to ignore the law.
Only 11 million? If you believe that I have a bridge to sell you. Closer to 60 million from all the damage I have seen. There about that amount in LA alone.
@@donsolo4845 I have heard numbers all the way up to 80 million. Lets see, 10000 a day in one border city (El Paso, actual number) for 10 years, that over 36 million.
@@RS-ls7mm60% of them are repeat offenders, meaning 600 of each 1000 are coming in after being deported one or more times already. The double counting alone drops it to 14.6 million based on that 36 million figure
agreed .they're deleting comments I've replied to the guy beneath this comment four times to answer the question have I had a politician lie to me his name was Joe Biden
@@jontalbot1 if Trump does half the things he said were set hell if he just gets rid of the income tax everyone will be happy .but you people can't say anything but orange man bad. also have been lied to his name was Biden .
@@jontalbot1 I don't know how many times I have to post this because apparently keeps getting deleted if Trump does half the things he said were set hell if he just gets rid of the income tax everyone will be happy .but you people can't say anything but orange man bad. also have been lied to his name was Biden .
What about registration of all illegals here without criminal record before 2017 and allowing them to get work permit and pay into the system. They can renew like daca and if they mess it up make it an automatic deportation.
Imagine squatting in someone's house for DECADES, and then screaming that you have a human right to have them house, feed, and clothe you, and that to remove you would be racist. This is America, and it is a miracle you even broke in to this country without people defending themselves against you.
The US wouldn't have to spend this kind of money if they had a secure border to begin with.
Do you even realize that people that legally came into this country make up a large share those in the country illegally and I'm talking about those who are visa overstayers, the majority of whom are Canadians and Europeans. Of course you didn't know that.
@@gloriathomas3245 how do you know what other people think , please teach us
@@lughaidhmoutia3589 I happen to be an immigrant myself
SMALL PRICE TO PAY!! 🤣🤣
We sent more to Ukraine than "the cost of deportation". 🤣
@@wvvwwvwvv you paid your own defense companies to create new weapons and send the old ones you no longer use. A fraction of your yearly military spending. :')
“Of course families will be deported together.”
I mean… he’s got a point
It made me laugh very loud 😂😂😂😂😂
The idea of deporting U.S. citizens for what their parents did is fucking wild.
@@jonathanponce857 I don’t think Trump will deport US citizens for what their parents did. There are enough undocumented immigrants to keep him busy for a while.
@@jonathanponce857 anchor babies aren't citizens.
@@jonathanponce857 they aren't citizens
There is nothing wrong with being Pro Immigration and Anti Illegal Immigration. If the factories, construction, etc need more workers they can increase the legal immigration rate.
Yeah just make a temp visa
I say use the military. We are being invaded illegally. What part of “national defense” do you not understand?
You're being invaded by millions of desperate refugees. @@gloriamadaffari5404
@@gloriamadaffari5404
We aren't being invaded. As the video goes over. An invasion is military action, this isn't.
Neah. If there was enough pressure for that (by people firing for those Visa's) they likely would allow more temp labor.
Lots of companies don't want to. Those kinds of Visa come with requirements for the employer (housing, pay rate, etc). And inherently give those workers a better leg to stand on. Illegal labor is cheap and employers generally aren't punished for it. So for them it's all upsides.
That's without mentioning the fact that smaller businesses often don't know how to obtain those or can't afford the costs to staff that way (lawyers and such to help with it aren't cheap).
And for factories it's often cheaper just to move them to Mexico or another cheaper country.
Not that it's all bad. Economically Illegal immigrants tend to be good in direct ways (often paying taxes and never collecting benefits). And indirect such as food cost (American agriculture would be far less competitively priced compared to import if the workers cost more).
Why do people keep saying that entering a country illegally, and there by breaking that countries law, does not make them a criminal?
Yes it does technically, but when people will hear criminal they will think “violent, anti-social offenders” which the data shows they aren’t in high numbers.
Because it is arbitrary. US immigration is notoriously broken. It's far more complex and bureaucratic than it needs to be. If one is really a concerned, use a background check. Easy peasy. Border controls serve a purpose, but those controls need to be properly calibrated with the purpose. In the US, they are not. Not optimally at least
it's all bs, good man, the moment such an illegal immigrant does Trump a favour he gets to live in a nice villa, look at Melania and her family, they're just telling you what you like to hear, next they'll just make sure those dudes work the factories and undercut your wages, don't worry.
Why do people keep harping about migrants being criminals when all they wanted was a better life (as your ancestors did) while continuing to ignore the illegal acts their own elected president has commited. At this rate, DT's crimes probably amount to the entirity of crimes commited by "illegals"!!
@@MrGman789 False, over 600.000 illegal immigrants in the US have committed other crimes than crossing the border
The costs are high but the costs of doing nothing are even higher.
can you back up your comment? just out of curiosity
It's a pointless exercise because they'll just come back. Therefore, actually doing this will always cost more than doing nothing.
It's not going to work ser what happened in 1954 Eisenhower did was horrible and 60 something years later do you thing is going to work?.AMERICA IS BROKEN NOW WITH OUT INDUSTRY AND NO WORKERS FROM WERE THE MINEY IS COMING FROM.?
?
If Trump closes the wall they can’t come back
@@OilHutJones So do nothing? most of them would prolly leave permanently, so no.
imagine migrating legally, jumping all the hoops doing things nicely, so others make you look bad and hinder your hard work, no thanks
How do they make you look bad? The current immigration system is broken, it can take up to 10 years
Who's Ya DIDDY ❓
A lot of them were originally illegal but just married into citizenship lol
It is supposed to take 10 years. I'm a legal immigrant, earned my US degree, earned my green card, and it takes 5 years after green card to qualify for citizenship. The idea is you earn and prove you deserv3 citizenship by having skills and obeying the law. Citizenship is worthless when people can just come illegally, only prove they break laws, and get it.
@@APerls it’s broken because it was intended that way! The majority of Americans don’t even know what legal immigration… All Europeans had to do was get a medical certificate of good health and drop the ethnic last name 😂
$7 billion in arrests. $66 billion in detention centers. $12.6 billion in legal proceedings. Security and safety of Americans, PRICELESS. For everything else, there's Mastercard.
Let the billionaires pay for it then.
@kimobrien. Why would they want to raise wages and empower unions?
@@longiusaescius2537 Unions are empowered when the organize all workers regardless of immigration status. Amnesty helps with organization. Billionaire capitalist want to deport during economic downturns and to create a pariah class keeping some workers with the illegal status to hold down wages of all workers.
Mass shooters and guys who tried to assassinate trump are all US citizens
thats how they make you swallow the costs, first it starts out cheap, then scope creep sets in then you have a fiscal-political boondoggle.
Sue the NGOs that have brought them in, and use their facilities, just in the other direction..
Sue them for whst.
thats actually a good idea
“Most illegal immigrants are not criminals” look at the words you just said and realize the problem.
Absolutamente
Interpretation, by criminals it's referred to the country they came from. By illegal refers to US law.
Big difference. A crime in the US is not necessarily a crime in a different country, but criminal records carry cross all borders.
Yet the FBI stats clearly show they commit crimes at least 5x more than normal (FBI says they are way under reported). My city is now the most violent in the US because of them.
Entering the country illegally alone is a crime
@@night_hunter4752you can be Jesus Christ himself but if he cross the border illegally, you are breaking the law in the land in which you just entered. Therefore he is a criminal.
Use the front door to come into the US the law is the law
Hell yeah! or you will exit the US cold
@@dawuid1491 if they did that it would trigger a civil war
Okay but the US doesn't give a fck if you break the law. Just look at your convicted felon Trump.
@@ILovePancakes24not really because that’s what’s about to happen b
YES!
The amount of misinformation in this video is disturbing...😢
Why ?
To say that people entering the country illegally are not committing any crimes is a paradox.
We went into the finances of how much it cost to deport. Let's go into the finances on what it costs to keep them within the country.
They add to the economy, they fill jobs nobody wants like picking food in the farms. Or were there are shortages like construction, The USA was built by immigrants and still is to this day.
For every dollar they get paid, what we get in returns is greater.
@benjacondell2751 no one is saying to get rid of migrants.
Those jobs are still available to those who come in legally and are vetted.
@benjacondell2751 you could argue that illegal immigrants are just stealing jobs away from more qualified would be legal immigrants
Ok we pay 196 billion for the ones already here a year of federal tax not including the amount we send in state taxes. And they bring in less than 25 billion in all 50 states and most are in welfare. So imagine we are going to spend more and tax more for them to the 15 million that comes in. We cannot afford them and unsustainable. Its cheaper to send them back. They say 88 billion a year to send them back.
@@racheljustrachel2732 Welfare payments haven't been raised in years.
This problem has been decades in the making and it will take decades to fix. There will be bumps along the way. The cost will be significant. But if your country doesn't have a secure border, you don't have a country.
You do just one with a lot of illegal immigrants doing jobs Americans don’t want and paying taxes
the thing is it is. The people that are working do not get the benefits and they pay to work here including paying our taxes. If those people won't be working here anymore because they will be deported, who's going to do those jobs? ALL those taxes they pay which is over a billion... who is going to pay those now? I don't think people are seeing the bigger picture here on what is going to happen.
No trump will ensure a large part of the hardest workers that benefit the country flee elsewhere where they are welcomed, damn i think most countries in Europe would receive them with open arms compared to the people coming in right now.
Continuing to stay in a country that clearly doesn’t want you there is the real insanity….
Damn i didn't know coming in illegally wasn't illegal
Many people seem to lack common sense these days, or we wouldn't be discussing "whether illegal immigrants are legal or not!"
When you dye your hair an unnatural color and scream at strangers for emotional reasons, anything is legal.
When they cross they ask for asylum which makes them legal until their court dates.
@@Teriyakichick The left media has been at this for decades. They hope that if they keep telling us 2+2=3 that we will come to believe it.
@@blueberry-ri7eb it's a BS loophole.
You don’t know difference between legal and illegal immigration ??
Not the left
@@Rubbe87 had a guy I work with come at me with "You all are illegals. every person in the US is an illegal immigrant if they are not native American." my answer was " nope, my family cam over as slaves of the English king."
One benefits people, the other doesn’t
And not all legal immigrants want illegal ones to enter. One of the Dem mistakes was assuming so.
minimum wage vs slave labor
This is the USA. When have resources and manpower ever been a problem? Even in that case, we'd have at least 50 million volunteers willing to assist the operation for free.
Why? They’re planning on 20 years?
Theres more here than they think. They sneak in and aren't caught. I live in AZ by the border and I know.
Of course you do.
That would be the least of the issues. It's not like the authorities can send the undocumented immigrants a letter to please show up for deportation. Nope, they need to pick them up. Probably they need to search for them with methods that aren't legal under the US constitution, and they need to pester millions US citizens and deprive them of some of their rights under the constitution to have any success. And more likely, they don't have the manpower to do even a fraction of all of that. You'd basically need a force like the SS or STASI or some other form of secret police. Not gonna happen, even if it's just for cost reasons. But non-cooperation of most US citizens will go a long way as well.
They've floated the same 11 million number for a decade. It's more like 40 - 60 million.
@@_.-AAA-._65 million is the total latin american population in the u.s., it’s not 65 million
I don't care.
He's got the highest court of the land on his side no matter what. The fact you think the courts would stop him shows how little you know about us politics atm
We have finally been unBiden by what has been
Bye-den 2024! Trump 2024!
Lol.
Let's Go BRANDON 🇨🇳
@Sect10n31 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Biden gave us a soft landing after Trumps distaster.
I dont understand how people dont think people illegally crossing borders is a massive issue 😂
The bosses want them to be illegal because it is easier to exploit them that way.
What is the issue?
You are right, you see, you arent fleeing terror and violence for your family , your children. But how could you , half of America doesnt even know where half of the rest of the world is. I doubt if many could pick out South America on a global map.
Where the only nation in the world with citizens who are ok with immigration. Its crazy.
@@Sjb2077 How is that the problem of Americans? Why don't immigrants fix their own countries?
Best way forward is cut all govt funding to migrant NGOs let them survive on donations forcing their executives accept a decrease to their massive salaries. To many of them don't actually do much other than aid migrants avoid the border guards, and take down names to send the bill to the local, state and federal govt to receive subsidies.
Suck it, California is one the biggest economies in the US and they alone with other blue states can fund those.
The problem is ngos only use immigrants because Americans refuse to do the jobs they do, or are you volunteering to work in the fields for even $50 an hour. Farmers lost crops to rot during trumps last presidency, because the Americans that believed they were just as good as immigrant workers lasted a day or two at most.
But we will see, it is a dangerous experiment as if it fails so does America's food supply. You think prices are too high now wait. I am just glad i do not live there and can laugh at what you all voted for.
If this goes through, people can finally stop complaining they cant find a job.
Most people aren't willing to move, perform a job that they don't like, or work for a price that is too low for them
We're going to see increased inflation since there will be a shortage of workers.
Conservatives ain't going to work in the farm picking strawberries
@@broski365 when lots of illegal immigrants also go for those jobs, the wages go down, thats why nobody wants to do it, the strawberry farm will have to offer honest wages to the us citizens or just go out of business...
@@davianoinglesias5030 don't worry those 2 millions fed are gonna pick strawberries for you
The problem with this video is the It's basically arguing that money Is more important than sovereignty and national security. You can't say that the United States should endlessly throw money at some Ukraine to protect their sovereignty and national security and then turn around and say that it's somehow ridiculous for America to do the same in their own borders. Economically speaking for average people Would stand to benefit from removing these illegal immigrants because this Would reduce the labor pool and mean that companies can no longer benefit off of cheap labor which would mean they would have to raise wages in order to Get more workers. The people who would suffer from Losing illegal immigrant labor would be multinational corporations. I do think that there should be a conversation on the corruption of these Companies turning a blind eye to undocumented labor, personally I do think these companies should be punished for also breaking the law.
well said
I'm not sure those corporations would be will to raise their payments that much.
Solid Point
And when the companies go broke? Many isolationists have learnt that lesson.
Just got fired from my job today I am a nail technician who started working for a nail salon late last month everything was going good they even agreed to have me on maternity leave for middle of feb. Because I’ll be having my baby first week of march. They knew I just graduated forms school even seen me work and got a few returning clients ,everything went good until I got my first paycheck I work in Arizona she didn’t give me a w2 nor 1099 payed me cash and payed me 45% commission for the services performed when I told her I thought legally you were supposed to pay me minimum wage because it was higher than my commission this week she says no I only pay 45% commission I thought oh ok she’s the business owner she must know more then me well I made it to my second paycheck now she’s hiring illegal Asians who are not even lisenced. So I went to school I’m pregnant and I was let go this morning because she was able to hire more experienced illegal technicians who are working for less than minimum wage! Now I have no Job 2 weeks before my kids 3rd bday and 6 weeks before christmas I wanna report them so bad but Karma will be in my side seems like it already is!
13:45 - “illegal immigrants are not organized as a group”
They are collected through social media & written media in foreign countries, their travel & food is funded by money from groups, they are given instructions by groups, they are supported by legal organizations in the US… they most certainly are!
95% of them appear to be men of military age, but they keep yammering on endlessly about "family separation."
They will self-deport if you have high fines and prison time for the people hiring them.
Harsh punishment doesn't work
@@complexaltruist So you think meaningless punishment is the way to go? I think we have already tried that.
@@complexaltruistOh yes it does.
@@lylez00 oh no it don't!
@@RayCamacho-m2e The bosses control the government they have no intention of depriving themselves of cheap labor.
13:55 - “crime rates by illegal immigrants in the United States is actually very low”
This is not true.
Crime rates for legal immigrants in the United States is very low.
In many sanctuary cities, crime is legal, where people are not prosecuted, therefore not arrested, and therefore the number is not available.
When captured in sanctuary cities for atrocious crimes, they are not asked about their legal status, so as not to report to the federal government for deportation, so we don’t even know then.
What cities are you referring to?
The numbers are also altered by the Democratic politicians advising their dem buddies as Governors or Mayors etc to dummy the numbers. I don't think it is even a crime to turn in falsified numbers for a federal census type info gathering. They can also play with the definitions of what they count or don't count like they do inflation. They count things favorable to their position and don't count things detrimental.
For now
Trump is dead serious!
The man literally made an entirely new branch of the military to tackle those aliens:
SPACE FORCE
Can’t say for sure what should be done, but it seems fair to say the government messed up and let way too many people in and this needs to be corrected. The US are not the only ones with this issue either.
Many countries are facing this issue. Here in Ireland we have had an influx of Ukrainians and people from the middle east, only for the most part, we seem to be a lot more hospitable towards them which I hope doesn't change given the surge in nasty anti-immigration misinformation posts that are becoming ever more prolific on social media platforms like X. Migration is the price of war and corrupt governments. In Venesaula people's wages are not covering a fraction of the money required to feed a family so how can they stay? In war torn countries. where citizens see their family and friends butchered and children raped, how can they stay? Would we stay? After a few years of Trumps administration I can foresee a whole lot of people wanting to leave the USA given that Trump is modelling his administration on how North Korea run things. It's going to be a very unpleasant, corrupt government in place, and it wouldn't surprise me if USA people try to mass exodus there as well in the coming years. Maybe when they're fleeing for their lives or in search of wages that will feed them, they'll regret their vitriol towards otherwise innocent people who were really just trying to survive life and keep their family from harm.
@amandafielding4451
when the US starts , the rest of the west will follow
Nah. No chaos. Dont have documentation? Goodbye.
That's not how asylum works
@complexaltruist "asylum"
U want to find them simple! Just put a order on door dash or UberEats and watch them flock your front doors 😂😂
Or the local swap meet, street food vendors and of course 🤣 the classic, Home Depot.
$70 bacon. None of the legal immigrants are interested in butchering pigs.
70dollar bacon your in fantasy land 😂😂😂
Are you?
Maybe not quite THAT high, but huge increases in prices for meat and dairy is absolutely coming. My hubby worked for one of the top meat companies in the US. The workforce was 95% immigrants. He now works in the egg industry where his company alone just found and fired over half his workers that he supervises because they were immigrants and the company made the mistake of outsourcing its hiring to a third party recruitment service that either didn't vet their fake papers hard enough or didn't require them to have legal docs in the first place. These companies don't pay enough to attract legal US citizens to work for them, and the trade off is we all get to enjoy cheaper beef, pork, chicken, eggs, and milk. But not anymore Oh and my hubby's company also supplies the egg products for companies like Hersheys, Burger King and Taco Bell breakfast menus. So look forward to paying even more for your candy and fast food soon (even worse than inflation and corporate greed price gouging).
Don't forget chickens.😢
Watch out cats,dogs,and pets
'the vast majority of *illegal* imigrants are not criminals' Read that sentence a couple of times until it clicks VisualPolitik team.
If you cared about criminality for the sake of it, you wouldn't even entertain a single thing Trump has to say as he is a criminal and Musk was an illegal immigrant when he built his businesses.
The point of contention is : What are these people DOING when they get here?
People on your side of the issue tend to think these immigrants are ultra-violent gang members.
Truth is : An OVERWHELMING of them want to keep their head down and work and end up contributing to America in ways that literally keep us running.
Not in the sense they hurt someone or robbed a store.
Wow......how many do you know?
And how do you monitor their activities....at all times?
Trumps a criminal too , he broke the law..
@@johnbazan8674So then, a special pleading logical fallacy?
11 million? Try between 15-20 million.
11 million that we know of but yes the actual number would be around there
More like 40.
I think he was confused woth the 11 million that have come in During the current admin - plus 1.5 million got-aways.
Evidence?
@@complexaltruist It's the 11 million already here plus the most likely fraudulent amnesty applications.
I found this video infuriating. The US has some of the most liberal laws towards illegal migrants in the world. If the US adopted the policies of nearly any other country in the world - the migrants would leave. That is: employment eligibility checks on employment and fining non compliant employers, eligibility checks for education, healthcare and most government services. In most countries, illegal migrants live in the margins in the US that is currently not the case
What is exactly infuriating you?
I didn't have any problems with these people. Did any of them do any harm to you?
With automation and AI, the United States will not need cheap labor.
AI can’t do every single job in the world. Lol
While I agree with the idea that AI can't do every job in the world, the types of jobs it can do are the middle level white collar jobs, so most American citizens will need a job or its going to lead to massive unrest, and understand that I'm using a polite word like unrest. Think LA Riots from the 90s but way worse. The people in politics know this and their solution is free up labor jobs at the bottom and hope that the labor market adjusts to pay low skilled jobs a living wage.
@@alephnot000 Exactly! Well said.
As soon as my cousins turned legal, they did a 180 and turned anti-immigration. You think they deserved or earned their citizenship? They're stuck in poverty, they beg us for money, they're on welfare and benefits they now qualify for. Do ppl even think about this shit 😂 my Trump supporter coworkers is a middle aged drop out stuck in a deadend job. Guess what, HES ON WELFARE TOO 😂 my friends mom isnt legal and shes working as a fucking nurse assistant i think studying too! You cant categorize a whole group, bc in that case, every undocumented immigrant ive met is working way harder and are raising their kids with an educational focused mentality. Meanwhile my fellow legal hispanics arent even making it past an Associates...
Is Mexico still going to pay for his wall?
NO!!
Technically, you should have said that additional crimes are low among illegal immigrants as crossing the border illegally is in fact a crime.
I'm excited and scared at the same time ,for the future. What do we not know.
I love that the US elected a president that agrees with politicians from 1798 and boasts about it.
Hello. I've liked this channel for some time. Please do not think viewers cannot see or hear bias. Thanks.
I have a love hate relationship with channels like these because the information is valuable but the bias is annoying.
@@clayongunzelle9555 I don’t think it’s bias to point out practical difficulties. You must have been lied to by a politician before. You just got lied to again
Wouldn't it be cheaper to make everyone legal, no questions asked, and also keep the economy growing? A follow up video analysing that approach would be interesting
Drugs is a big problem in this world.
Is they?
As a generally liberal Brit, I was quite surprised at how biased your analysis is of the deeper cultural concerns. Yes it doesn't always manifest as eloquent dialogue, yes Trump is brash and says extreme things to get attention, but people are so angry at being adandoned, ignored and demonised by the left, especially on "Democrat no-go" subjects like immigration, trans/DEI policies and the white middle class.
Being surprised or shocked by how and why Trump is here is a failure on the part of the listener.
Apart from that, love the videos generally!
""Democrat no-go" subjects like immigration"
What a crock of unmitigated shiite. Have you read the previously proposed bi-partisan immigration bill, the one that was struck down by Trump?
You sure as hell don't sound 'generally liberal', but nice try.
I mean I get why people feel abandoned, but to destroy the economy and people's lives, US citizen children's lives, just to stick it to the "woke elite" is dumb and destructive. Most illegal immigrants I do know own a business, have kids, and aren't engaging in anti social behavior, there are plenty that do, but most just keep to themselves and try to live day by day. Answer is, did they break the law? Yes. Does it justify destruction of the economy in a short period of time? No.
Agreed, they are ridiculously biased against trump which makes one question their other videos
@sebastianflisback3296 Nah they're just stating facts and policies, if anything libs would find this video too pro-Trump, I mean if the guy's literal policies seem like shit, he's probably a shit president 🤷
Unbiased perspectives don't exist
11 million? The number 11 million has been used for decades. Just the ones caught average a million a year. Those that aren't caught are at least twice as many. So it's closer to 15-20 million now.
Have you bothered to ask the Native Americans on that point. Illegal immigrants flooded their land, took it, killed their nation with no repercussions. You bloody hypocrites.
Good thing i'm a Legal Immigrant
As a Trump voter youre the kind of immigrant I want in this country
@GoblinRatz I have Canadian citizenship, though
@@Durahan82 Sad very sad. We accept you as a refugee
@@GoblinRatz Nah , i'll apply for a green card first , and work as a trucker , since i'm already doing CAN/US runs on a Flatbed.
@@Durahan82you from South Asia regions ❓
Let's Trump voters taste the pill they asked for. Unfortunately the pill will be shared by all others: voters against Trump and nonvoters as well as those who couldn't vote being not citizens staying in the USA both legally and not. As always the bitterness will be spread unevenly.
That's what we the Americans want depotation.
WHAT ABOUT ALL THE AMERICANS THAT WILL HAVE NO JOBS IF HE STARTS LETTING EVERYONE GO IN THE GOVERNMENT? OH YEA! GET RID OF MILLIONS OF PEOPLE WITH GOOD PAY AND BENIFITS, This will screw all his voters, lol
I've wanted to see most government employees I've had contact with loose their jobs for over 50 years. No tear will be shed, no help given.
2015 was his second campaign. He ran in 2000 as an independent.
Were not going to break up familys, They'll all go down together.
What they say and what they do are too different things.
Hahahahah!
@vickygehring7513 they came together they leave together
It’s crazy how trump brings out people like y’all to the light and then literally does nothing of what he promises. 😂😂
2Million Illegals own there own homes while so many Americans can’t even afford there own homes :(
? No they don't.
The USA is a joke, it's politics is akin to watching comedy shows like Seinfeld or Friends. You have the power to vote for better leaders but you vote for clowns 😂 funny for us outsiders but bad for you. Have a nice 4 years or whatever long it's going to be 🎉
and the UK and Germany are arresting people for making Mean Tweets you're so much better because you're not in America every country has its problems
Because every time they like someone they call for them to be president, regardless of experience qualifications or character
Ivanka 2028 🇺🇸😁
Illegal means illegal. 🤣
Your president elect is illegal
oh but when Trump commits crimes, then it is go and NOT illegal. Crime is crime no matter where it comes from. Such a double standard!
At some point It was illegal to help fugitive slaves, so what? Laws are sometimes very harmful and not just
Hers a clue, the narrator kept calling them undocumented immigrants. Thats the lefts buzz word for Illegal. Should tell you all you need to know.
One of the reason why we Americans voted for him.!
Who will do all the low paid work?
@@dassagichkeinem4454 Many Americans who needs the job for food. I run two shipyards, I can't say they are low payed job but it is hard laboring job. And if the job is low paying it means one thing.. easy jobs with no skill required. But most laboring jobs do better than Taxi Drivers. If you plan to work in McDonald frying fries, you will get the payment they deserve. But if you do hard labor you will get payed more. It is no not female job.
Heck ya Trump! Clean sweep the streets.
The immigration measures that lowered entry came during an election year. Imagine that.
Let him do his job. TY. It’s overdue
Sounds like a massive self-inflicted wound in the making
Not really chairo
So we'll pick our own vegetables and put up our own roofs?
No. Most Americans won't pursue those jobs thanks to the abysmally low wages.
Or those prices will go up dramatically. Its a bit like tariffs. You put those up, ths public food the bill and not the other country.
It's called a victory garden during WWII
Yes
@needbettername8583 listen again to the comment above
@@needbettername8583 Wages for actual work will have to go up then if we want those jobs done.
Fact check: Kurds are not illegal in Turkey, Kurds are citizens of Turkish state. They have equal rights and can become anything they want. Stop spreading misinformation. Kurds are a part of our country and we are like brothers and sisters.
Lol you wish.
I can’t wait! MAGA!
Trump derangement syndrome is strong with this guy.
Every candidate in recent political history made impossible promises. Spelling out the details of what would be required to accomplish what Trump said he would do is not anti candidate. It’s good reporting.
Thank you for appropriately and correctly referring to those that cross the U.S. border and claim asylum at anywhere other than a legal port of entry as "Illegal". The problem with deportation is that many - particularly convicted criminals - have been deported 2,3,4 more times and just cross back over.
@michaellewandowski9094 Hello Hasbara
The retirement crisis is getting worse and the economy is so messed up to start investing right away.
As a beginner investor, it's essential for you to have a mentor to keep you accountable. Bridget Lee Wade is my trade analyst, she has guided me to identify key market trends, pinpointed strategic entry points, and provided risk assessment, ensuring my trades decisions align with market dynamics for optimal returns.
This is correct, Bridget's strategy has normalized winning trades for me also and it’s a huge milestone for me looking back to how it all started
Bridget has an exceptional ability to capitalize on opportunities created by economic changes. Her skills are top-notch.
Yes, I agree with you. Her platform is wonderful and her strategies are exceptional
Please educate me. I've come across this name before Now I am interested. How can I reach her?
Trump used illegal immigrants at Mara-logo for years.
Debunk, by the guess and neighbors of the resort. Also later on by the Secret Service. Mara-Logo hire Cubans, Asians, Whites, Native American, Indians, Filipinos, Jamaicans, but very few Latins. You should visit.
First that's fake, second even if he did it doesn't take away that fact that illegal immigration is bad.
lying folks lies thinking others are idiots. thats why Trump won.
And "mara" means "gang". Mara salvatrucha. Coincidence?
They probably were the ones who built it while working under an American bosses
I'm disgusted by all these comments here. We are all immigrants, just because you've been here longer doesn't make you an American. The true Americans were the natives who lived here. Of course the United States took over their land and gave them no options. I don't care whether its legal or illegal the way they got in. All of us are immigrants. The indifference towards immigrants is disgusting, even for Immigrants that came here legally, they are mistreated and racially discriminated.
Mexico is a country plagued with corruption, narcotics, and economical struggles. If you members of your family had been kidnapped or killed by cartels, how would you feel? The United States isn't far off. There is so much crime that by the time you report it its already too late. I hope people start opening their eyes and realize all these politicians are terrible. Even when trump was president, nothing changed, crime, homelessness, and other problems still resided.
WHOS FAULT IS IT THAT MEXICO 🇲🇽 DECIDED TO BECOME INDEPENDENT FROM SPAIN?
THE SPANISH CULTURE WAS MUCH MORE CIVIL DESPITE THERE PREJUDICE NATURE...
THE AZTECS, & MAYANS ALONG WITH ALL THE ORIGINAL TRIBES FROM MEXICO WERE RATHER UN CIVIL IN NATURE & BARBARIC... STUBBORN & REBELLIOUS AGAINST AUTHORITY...
YOU SPEAK A LOT ABOUT CARTELS BUT DONT LOOK AT THE SOURCE OF THE PROBLEM...
MEXICO 🇲🇽 CHOSE TO BE INDEPENDENT FROM SPAIN... THE SPANISH HAD ENOUGH WEALTH TO FUEL AN AWESOME SAFE ECONOMY FOR MEXICO 🇲🇽 YET MEXICO CHOSE INDEPENDENCE... AS A RESULT YOUR COUNTRY SUFFERS FROM CORRUPTION & POINTLESS CIVIL WARS
AMERICA HAS BEEN VERY GENEROUS TO THE MEXICAN PEOPLE...
THEYVE GIVEN OUT MILLIONS OF DOLLARS 💲 FOR SOCIAL SECURITY, FOOD STAMPS & BENEFITS MORE THAN OUR OWN MILITARY VETERANS WHAT MORE DO YOUR PEOPLE WANT???
IN PRISON THE MEXICAN MAFIA RUNS EVERYTHING
IN THE STREETS??? MEXICAN GANGS DOMINATE IN CRIME & DRUG DEALING
IS IT BAD THAT SOME PEOPLE WANT TO RAISE FAMILIES WITHOUT THE BULLSHIT THAT MEXICO BRINGS??? 🇲🇽
Big difference between immigrant and Illegal immigrant. If you don't see the difference, it is a waste of time discussing this with you.
OK mr/ms citizen of the world, some people like living in a nation and not a special economic zone
I live in a predominantly Mexican neighborhood and a lot of Mexicans feel unfairly treated.
Some Mexicans have been in the US for decades, worked hard to earn their place here and didn’t get any help to get setup here.
Meanwhile, Venezuelans for example have come to Chicago and been given free money, healthcare, places to stay, then those same Venezuelans turn around and have created some issues in city including within our neighborhood like stealing or starting up Venezuelan gangs.
That alone has caused some people I know to vote Trump meanwhile I sat out the vote because while I agree with limiting immigration, I also believe men should stay out of the abortion argument as that isn’t up to us.
Trump literally had nothing to do with that issue. He is not a judge. And Democrats have had million chances to encode Roe in to law. They never do it because they want it to be an issue EVERY election. It's their best path to victory. So, in that case, you are suggesting men should stop voting for good.
cool story bro. I bet that sounded good in your head lmao
@@AmorFati-n6q 😂😂 get out of your echo chamber bro.
Well everyone is getting deported now
@@michellestr8998it wasn't an issue until Trump corrupted the supremacy court with judges that lied through their teeth at their appointments.
Watched a family climb over Trumps wall, they scaled it without needing a ladder.
They walked into U.S. they can walk home.
Most poeple don't realize that 11 Miillion people equals 3.28% of the total US population. I doubt the US economy could take that big a hit, the loss ot tax revenue would be huge and many low paying jobs that "real" Americans do not want due to them being dirty, hot and nasty. Odds are many crops would be left to rot in the fields due to lack of workers to pick the produce, leading to shortages and increased prices. And this is just one example of potential economic impact of Trumps anti-immigratnat policies.
We'll be just fine? Watch. Besides, housing has gone up, there are housing shortages, groceries, et cetera due to the illegal invasions. Also, Trump is going to make our Veterans a priority. All the freebies have run out. Buh-bye!!!!
Most migrants don't want to do jobs that don't pay well to cover the cost of living. Only those allowed in as seasonal workers are even provided with places to sleep by the employer. A lot of automation is occurring in farming industry as younger migrants are finding it too hard or unwilling to do difficult labor apply to service industry. Its something that Canada is going through with places that wanted migrants in the Atlantic and Central provinces losing them to already over crowded major cities.
Mass deportations will reduce housing costs, education costs, medical costs, judicial costs and give citizens a better chance at getting jobs.
@@gumpyoldbugger6944 nothing you've said is factual
@@guardianoffire8814 I think you mistakenly put the word "migrants" instead of "Americans" in your statement the don't want to do jobs that don't pay well (enough) to cover the cost of living.
While automation and mechanization is growing in the agricultural industies, much of the haversting of crops still needs to be done by hand due to various reasons Until the moron Musk's Tesla Bot can pick a ripe strawberry and leave an unripe one on the vine, human labour will be required.
I'm a Canadian as well and know what is happening here in regards to migrant labour and how buggered up our system can be, especially toward legal and highly skilled immigrants.
I knew a lady from China who was not only an Electrical Engineer, but she designed power grid systems, taught in Technical Universities and even wrote/contributed to text books on the subject. She was also fluent in English.
So when both the BC and Federal Government when overseas looking for talent to help here, she applied and came her with her son.
Upon arrival, the British Columbia Electrical Association (BCEA), the licencing body for Electrial Engineers refused to recognize her qualifications, telling her she would have go back to school and start at square one inorder to be ceritified.
She had to take menial low paying jobs to support her and her young son. In the end she returned to China after saving up enough for air fare and left Canada, our loss if you ask me.
Like it or not, both the US and Canada are dependent on migration, be it legal or illegal.
There are jobs that natural born citizens are loath to do because they are seen to be beneath them or the rate of pay offered is too low. These are that jobs that migrants generally fill.
Most countries do not have birthright citizenship. There is nothing in the US Constitution that allows this. Birthright citizenship has been allowed by courts. A new law could overturn this.
Actually, it is in the Constitution. It’s the 14th Amendment! Any new law passed restricting birthright citizenship would be unconstitutional, and thus unenforceable. The only way to change it would be through a constitutional amendment.
Pretty much all countries in the Americas have birthright citizenship, none outside do.
@@lindadeeds5326 There is also an 1898 Supreme Court ruling (US v. Wong Kim Ark) that would be used. Once Trump issues an EO, which has force of law, someone will sue and the Supreme Court will follow precedent.
@@lindadeeds5326 the 14th amendment was to ensure all former slaves were clearly determined to be citizens. It was not for pregnant aliens to arrive and give birth to then claim their child was a citizen.
@Eddies_Bra-att-ha-grejer that may be true for the 2 American continents but this is not true for the whole world.
I don't think the price of Trump's deportations bothers him that much. The deportations would be Trump's glorious achievement when he leaves office while it would be his successor who fails miserably to solve, within a single electoral term, the massive problems created by he Trump deportations. Trump is really good at this, smash things to pieces, declare himself a winner and leave the cleanign up after him to somebody else.
Ok Odin Yahtzee
It's the logistics challenges I don't see as feasible. I don't think people really understand the numbers we would be talking about here, or the fact that the US simply isn't going to toss them all to the other side of the border (and what that actually looks like, as many have never been to the South West or seen what the terrain and climate is like there). We have the rule of law in the US, and we simply aren't going to wave that away.
Planes exist
@@longiusaescius2537 Seriously...that's your answer? Yes, planes exist. Do you know how many flights it would take to fly 100's of thousands or millions to central and south America? Or what it would cost? Never mind...clearly not.
Send the bill to Biden and Harris for their mess
😂
Look at the UK - the Brexit caused a mass leaving of east-European (legal) immigrants, leaving the Hospitality, Healthcare, Transportation, and Farming industries without workers. Even today, this gap of workers could not be filled. All the unemployed individuals, claiming that immigrants steal their jobs, are still unemployed and living from welfare. So think of the impact on the economy in the USA. Fun fact, all illegal immigrants from the USA that can drive a Truck, or work as a Carer or in Hospitality or repair Cars, are welcome to move to the UK. Just apply for the visa.😆
Many of these people would leave if they weren’t being supported at taxpayer expense in cities like Chicago and NYC.
Trump, the man and the legend
Our Great Orange Hope ❤
@@Baddy187 a man of great conviction!
Epstein legend
@larryc1616 Not on the list
Similar to what happen with Brexit, EU migrants from eastern europe were cheaper and more willing to do laborious jobs than UK citizens.
and Brexit worked out brilliantly, right.. *sigh*
@threedprint5562 Leave the ECHR
Not more willing, cheaper. You confuse the two. The cheap labor is why there being imported. Your being lied to. A man will work any job when faced with losing everything.
@@kinginyellow1490 Immigrants are not limited to cheap jobs.
I'm working in IT and let me tell you "Europeans" are kind of a rarity. Often these jobs required technical skills that are difficult to find. That also the case in the medical domain, ranging from nurses to doctors.
So beside your slightly racist assumption, the problem can be reduce to supply and demand.
an example to put it simply :
* All western country have an aging population.
* Increasing number of seniors will require more doctors and nurses
* There will not be enough students in med schools across these countries to satisfied the demand.
Illegal immigration is against the law and it seems the previous administration "forgot" about that. As a canadian citizen I cannot move into the US illegally and I would be prosecuted and deported if I tried to so This should be the same for everyone else not following the procedures in place in ANY country. Deporting everyone would be too big of a task but at least sealing the borders and enforce the laws from now on would be a good start.
You can say this just because you are a Canadian. When you become an Indian, who need to wait 15 years to get a Green Card, and who are under a constant threat of losing their job and having to leave, then I would listen to you
What do you mean when you say that Trump would be able to push through the constitutional amendment?? That would require 2/3 of the Senate, plus either 2/3 of the House or a convention. On top of that 3/4 of states would have to ratify it. How the fcuk is Trump gonna do all that?
The same way he got elected. We the people are behind Trump
How can they be on payrolls when they are here illegally
they work for cash
1099
Cash pay or fake social security numbers is how they used to do it. That meant that all of these people paid into the American systems without any benefits other than true emergency healthcare. It’s just not a good idea to remove most of them.
Those laws are barely enforced. Homan will fix that.
cash, fake ss number, or 1099 with a fake ss number with a 1099 the employeer can pay them as sub contractor then its up to them to report and pay their own taxes which guess what they never do why would they, if the irs checks into it the social security number leads no where. Meanwhile the American citizen working the same job pays around 30% of the check to taxes. The employees gets to write off the 1099 employee as cost to operation same as American citizen so the employer doesn't care they are both write offs as cost
You think it's a joke just ask the governor of Texas
The way the script is framed is sooooooo partisan and slanted from reality. Used to like this channel.
It's amazing how even americans don't understand how being an illegal immigrant doesn't make you a criminal.
It's not typified in criminal law, it doesn't carry a prison sentence. It's not a crime, it's not a felony. Do your damn research.
50 to 250 dollar fine and up to 6 months prison sentence, it actually is in the books, its just not enforced properly.
Yes it is silly. Its in the name illegal immigrant.
@@seamusfinnegan1164 Where? It's not a federal crime.
@felipenachmanowicz9393 ≤- po|ack Copenhagen resident
@@felipenachmanowicz9393 But yeah exact punishment aside it very much is a crime, we have ranges for sentencing, variations of different circumstances the works.
Thats more people then my entire country.
Build that Wall!
Why, didn't trump build it in his first term with payment by Mexico 😁😁
I've seen videos where people climb over that wall.
@@honeyhoney1529 But But Trump told me he would usher paradise once the wall was finished 🤣🤣
They just go around the wall and rush the boarder by the bridges.
@kimobrien. "Preparen, Apunten, Fuego!"
You can't put a price on the safety of your citizens
Easier said than done.
@johnbazan8674 the alternative is to keep them here, which will cost more money
Then get rid of guns .
@@michaelrowsell1160 true
surely criminals will respect law and order
@@michaelrowsell1160 getting rid of guns puts every man, woman, and child under threat from the government.
Never trust the government
#1 national security for America will always be to secure her own borders. Only do the bare minimum to support NATO, & money saved can be repurposed for American border security.
NGOs spent far less that the estimates given in this video to send the illegal migrants here. The idea that something is expensive is no reason to ignore the law.
It's a lie from TLDR and even then still cheaper than keeping them here
Only 11 million? If you believe that I have a bridge to sell you. Closer to 60 million from all the damage I have seen. There about that amount in LA alone.
It’s closer to 20 million from what I’ve read.
@@donsolo4845 I have heard numbers all the way up to 80 million. Lets see, 10000 a day in one border city (El Paso, actual number) for 10 years, that over 36 million.
@ that’s wild!!!!
@@RS-ls7mm60% of them are repeat offenders, meaning 600 of each 1000 are coming in after being deported one or more times already. The double counting alone drops it to 14.6 million based on that 36 million figure
There's no evidence to support that
Honestly I just figured Trump was going to deport as many as possible but the ones he can't will be imprisoned and used as slave labor.
nope. NEXT!
Disinformation and defamation!
I don't believe that's the case. And even so, I would not care 😂
You guys are just evil @@Baddy187
I love the smug poo-pooing tone of this video. It's so 2020. "You may have won, but you're not going to get your way."
agreed .they're deleting comments I've replied to the guy beneath this comment four times to answer the question have I had a politician lie to me his name was Joe Biden
Just pointing out the practicalities. You never been lied to by a politician before? It’s about to happen again
@@jontalbot1 if Trump does half the things he said were set hell if he just gets rid of the income tax everyone will be happy .but you people can't say anything but orange man bad. also have been lied to his name was Biden .
@@jontalbot1 I don't know how many times I have to post this because apparently keeps getting deleted if Trump does half the things he said were set hell if he just gets rid of the income tax everyone will be happy .but you people can't say anything but orange man bad. also have been lied to his name was Biden .
@@dennisbowes3972 Boy are you in for a disappointment. Remember all those great things he did last time? Me neither. Roll on the mid terms!
They broke the law so it is something right.
Trump is a criminal so we have a criminal back in office, But you don't have a single brain cell to be able to comprehend it
3:41 no its not beyond our capabilities.. we can have hundreds thousands of troops deployed in a couple days..
What about registration of all illegals here without criminal record before 2017 and allowing them to get work permit and pay into the system. They can renew like daca and if they mess it up make it an automatic deportation.
Imagine squatting in someone's house for DECADES, and then screaming that you have a human right to have them house, feed, and clothe you, and that to remove you would be racist. This is America, and it is a miracle you even broke in to this country without people defending themselves against you.
Exactly this is America 😂
Try going illegal to Mexico, jail!
Mexican immigration just waves people in and usually doesn't even bother looking at passports or stamping them.
it be funny if trumps wife got deported under this act . and trump could be jailed for harboring one
She came in on an Einstein visa. I’m doubtful you did.
she's legal
It'd be funny if you knew the First Lady came to the US LEGALLY. Delete your comment. You're embarrassing.
@@krasnayakarinahe said he would even deport legal immigrants