@@chrismezza1940 to be a auteur you have to write direct produce edit cast photograph light costume design set design to name but a few none of these people are true auteurs just pretenders
@Bo No filmmaking isn’t a one person job, auteur theory usually is just about the director who gives a strong personal vision to the work. It’s a flawed idea, but eh it’s interesting. I guess truer auteurs would be people Soderbergh and Rodriguez.
i always love hearing him talk especially his dry humor. he always so passionate about filmaking without sounding phony and i'm glad he became more open as the years go by truly one of the greatest filmmaker of this era
@@MrChughad shut the fuck up. PTAs filmograhpy its so fucking good Hard Eight-Boogie Nights-Magnolia-Punck drunk love- There Will Be Blood- The Master- Inherent Vice- Phantom Thread PTA is on another level
@@leonardozumaeta4354 why is Nolan always targeted? A director makes movies with his vision and interest. You are in no position to judge anyone, especially Nolan. The kind of movies he bought to this world is memorable and beyond imagination. And as much as I like him, I like PTA. Both are masters of their craft, and let's stop judging a persons craft or calibre when you yourself aren't near any position as they are.
Saw it last week, for me Dunkirk still on top, but Phantom Thread is there on second position. PTA is getting to close to Kubrick in visual perfection terms. Stunning!
The best indeed. And del toro was so right when he confessed that he was jealousy that crimson peak should have been as phantom thread; bc del toro is not a master, he is good in visuals, set pieces and practical effects, only in technique; while pra is a master that fully understand about humanity and it's subtleties. Del toro will never be siting in the Olympus with PTA, kubrick, hitchcock, Lynch and others.
PTA is The Master, a classicist, Nolan is a genius who break the old walls in order to get where nobody could before. Both are my favourite in this era, different styles.
So glad Nolan finally got an Oscar nod. It was a travesty that the guy who gave us Memento, Insomnia, The Dark Knight Trilogy, The Prestige, Inception, and Interstellar before this never got a BD nod until this year. I don't care if he doesn't win, I'm just glad the Academy finally recognized him.
Tom Helms never for directing. That’s what the comment is about. Didn’t get a nod for any of the Dark Knight films, nor for Memento, Inception or Interstellar. I’d like to see Dunkirk taking home the Best Picture and Best Director prizes, but if the way the award shows have been any indicator, doesn’t look like this will happen. A surprise could be pulled and Dunkirk wins either Oscar or both of those Oscars, as well as other awards, in particularly in the technical categories, but I’m not sure. The Oscars can surprise everyone with their decisions. Just when you think you know which film will win the top prizes, they’ll surprise you. That said, I do think Gary Oldman will get his Academy Award finally. Long overdue for him indeed. This should be like Oldman’s fourth or fifth Oscar win by now.
It’s funny how people in this comment thread hate when the moderator ask the directors what they appreciated from other movies. I find it to be refreshing. Yes, there are hypocrites in this business, but I find no harm in sincerely commending your peers for their achievements.
@Aka I can reply to whatever I want to, thank you. And how exactly is it stupid when I just state my view? Me? Upset? Says the the guy who has to use the word stupid because I possibly offended his one of his favorite director. Who is looking stupid now?
Irony on how Nolan can summarize most of the film accurately show his dedication on film industry and thanks 🙏 to Del Toro for backing him regarding his vision on Dunkirk with minimal dialogue, like the end scene of the film.
Enrique Godinez the great thing is, the academy is still nominating him even as he gets weirder and out there. I think it will happen in the next 10 years.
Greta is so cute hahahaha I loved to know that Nolan and Del Toro are good friends, definitely didn't expect this. PTA is my favorite filmmaker and see him talking about anything else is soooo good. Good interview, i'd want that be more longer though.
There is no bigger achievement than making films that are all artistically, technically, financially and in magnificence successful. Nolan is the filmmaker of the century.
God some people on here are disgusting. Having seen and loved each of these films, these compliments were genuine and went to the core of the beauty of each individual film. Don’t see why this is bad, it’s great.
@@MrChughad lol lol lol. Maybe according to you. There are other filmmakers beside Christopher Nolan. You need to watch PTA movies 10, 100 times. Nolan is for the masses.
@@sharknado623 lol, I already watched all PTA movies, and I can explain all his movies to you, but there are bunch of details in Nolan movies, you cannot find a loophole, his movies are perfectly decorated with details.
@@MrChughad you don't have to explain anything to me, dude. I perfectly know what I watch and how I watch it, and you don't have to convince anyone of your tastes. Let people watch what they hell want and you do the same. You're no better than anyone just because you like something.
We are so lucky to have this panels nowadays, Because imagine back then when we could of have gotten, Orson Welles and John Huston talking with each other and Kurosawa chilling with Bergman. It would have been amazing to have seen this
Greta Gerwig produced an enhanced masterpiece in Little Women. The creative pacing, vibrant acting, and genuine emotional resonance in that film were off the chain in my humble opinion. Great group discussion.
Yeah, absolutely. Although, I didn't buy that thing with golden glow that was supposed to make past feel more perfect and present's blueish colouring is more bleak, and ending scene is kinda stable middle of two. That technique seemed kinda lame to me. Otherwise , very good movie, vibrant , exuberant characters like in a french new wave movie done right.
@@sha7303 bro her name is literally in the comment you’re replying too, can you really not read 💀 she’s there because she was nominated and people enjoyed her work so they voted for her. Simple as that.
so cool to see 5 of the most legendary directors working today completely nerding over each other's work... especially with Peele and Gerwig now having become firmly entrenched in that top tier, great to see the other 3 recognising their talent even back then just after their respective debuts
Guillermo seems like a silly, funny guy, but it's truly moving to hear him talk about his love for cinema, he has a way with words to convey what cinema does to you, and how it's something so special, he is excellent at explaining that feeling, that experience
Greta Gerwig is one talented lady- there’s something really fascinating and quirky about the screenplay of ladybird; the dialogues in the movie are simple, minimalistic and still so poetic.
Nighttray perhaps one day. Bladerunner 2049 was the most visually stunning movie I think I have ever seen. It could have easily been seated next to these other movies as a nominee for best picture. At least Deakins got nominated.
These five Best Director nominees represent such a wide gamut of film genres. Horror, coming-of-age, romantic period drama, war, fantasy. What a good year for movies 2017 was.
I've just rewatched this and the DGA panel (sadly with the exclusion of PTA) for the millionth time and I was so engrossed in it that I was startled when it ended. Probably the best year for a panel discussion ever. When you listen to them speak about each others films, you realize that all the critics, the awards and the whole hullabaloo that the media creates around films is really pointless. At the end of the day, I feel filmmakers are the ones who can really respect and acknowledge the collective love and passion for cinema. Such an inspiring pair of videos this one and the DGA panel together!
It is a potty they are better speech-persons than moviemakers. They read a lot of literature and study it, but it doesn't make them really good writers/directors.
This was great. I'm curious what else they could've answered if they had more time but its funny everyone took the time to gush about eachothers movies.
1.Jordan peele : Get Out 2.Greta Gerwing : Lady Bird 3.Paul Thomas Anderson : Phantom Thread 4.Christopher Nolan : Dunkirk 5.Guillermo del Toro : The Shape Of Water
Guillermo Del Toro - I’ve been noticing his name in the credits lately under Thanks (Special thanks, Producer wishes to thank, Director thanks, etc). Search on IMDb shows 96 productions that thanked him, including: Gravity, Birdman, The Revenant, Dune Part One, Ferrari, and Leave the World Behind. So besides seeming like a nice person and being quite busy as a filmmaker, he seems to be very helpful!
What's more impressive is that all these 5 also wrote their own screenplays. Always been all the more impressed by directors that write as well
Same here. There’s something really special about filmmakers who both write and direct their films. It just feels more personal
@@RShadow12 auteur theory!
@@chrismezza1940 to be a auteur you have to write direct produce edit cast photograph light costume design set design to name but a few none of these people are true auteurs just pretenders
@Bo No filmmaking isn’t a one person job, auteur theory usually is just about the director who gives a strong personal vision to the work. It’s a flawed idea, but eh it’s interesting. I guess truer auteurs would be people Soderbergh and Rodriguez.
Del Toro is like a cute Polar Bear
Nolan is so articulate and precise with his words, it's pretty amazing. he summed up every film so quickly yet so accurately...
i always love hearing him talk especially his dry humor. he always so passionate about filmaking without sounding phony and i'm glad he became more open as the years go by truly one of the greatest filmmaker of this era
Mujtaba Ibrahim LOL he is the most eloquent one I can see
Del Toro and Nolan are both really great communicators
Nolan took English Literature during college, so that’s why he is speaking so eloquently. Also why his film’s dialogues are so beautiful
@@serspeny1237 It's funny that for a literature major he loves spectacle first and foremost. But reading his scripts is a delight
Chris Nolan and PTA with each other is a dream come true
Cinema Max only needed Tarantino and this would have been The Avengers of the best contemporary filmmaker
Chris Cantos Nolan isnt even near the same league as Tarantino, and Tarantino isnt even near the same league as PTA
@@leonardozumaeta4354 lol, they are all Noobs in front of Nolan,
Where are you from bro? Are you from earth
@@leonardozumaeta4354 it doesn't make you cooler or trendy
They are simply great.
Pta is so respected by everyone! Such a genius and a great script writer
LUKE SCHROTER Nolan hasnt made anything of the same calibre as Boogie Nights, and thats not even PTA’s best film
@@leonardozumaeta4354 i agreed, even his first movie hard eight is a masterpiece
@@leonardozumaeta4354 there never be movies like, Inception, Interstellar, Dark Knight' Memento, Prestige... Nolan is on another level
@@MrChughad shut the fuck up. PTAs filmograhpy its so fucking good
Hard Eight-Boogie Nights-Magnolia-Punck drunk love- There Will Be Blood- The Master- Inherent Vice- Phantom Thread
PTA is on another level
@@leonardozumaeta4354 why is Nolan always targeted? A director makes movies with his vision and interest. You are in no position to judge anyone, especially Nolan. The kind of movies he bought to this world is memorable and beyond imagination. And as much as I like him, I like PTA. Both are masters of their craft, and let's stop judging a persons craft or calibre when you yourself aren't near any position as they are.
PTA is the man
He is getting too close to Kubrick in visual perfection terms.
@@gameplaystation96 i think Dennis Villeneuve will surpass PTA in terms of visual asthetics
Ohh, ok, I thought she is woman
@@notimeforyoutubelol read main comment
@@notimeforyoutubelol I think you are the joke.
You did not get what I said.
this shouldve been so much longer
Exactly
ruclips.net/video/FNAFHMyXBNA/видео.html
Anil Gajbhare you are THE human being
@@anilgajbhare9674 Unfortunately, that interview is missing one PTA.
It’s so telling that Greta chose moments from each of the films rather than talking themes, or generalities. It rlly speaks to her style of filmmaking
Shallow.
Shes such a fan of movies and so earnest I love her.
I think PTA had the best film.
Saw it last week, for me Dunkirk still on top, but Phantom Thread is there on second position. PTA is getting to close to Kubrick in visual perfection terms. Stunning!
he usually does but not this time.
Lady bird is so damn pitched perfect, id go with that. But Phantom Thread might be the best of the year.
Nolan does...
The best indeed. And del toro was so right when he confessed that he was jealousy that crimson peak should have been as phantom thread; bc del toro is not a master, he is good in visuals, set pieces and practical effects, only in technique; while pra is a master that fully understand about humanity and it's subtleties. Del toro will never be siting in the Olympus with PTA, kubrick, hitchcock, Lynch and others.
I never seen NOlan smile so much, Guillermo Del Toro really brings out the best out of people, that's what great directors and artists do.
The master is sitting in the middle.
Yep, he’s the man!
Guillermo is not in the middle
The two others on his left hand side are not bad at all too
PTA is clearly the master in that line-up. The other guys are pretty good too, but sorry, PT is the boss.
PTA is The Master, a classicist, Nolan is a genius who break the old walls in order to get where nobody could before. Both are my favourite in this era, different styles.
So glad Nolan finally got an Oscar nod. It was a travesty that the guy who gave us Memento, Insomnia, The Dark Knight Trilogy, The Prestige, Inception, and Interstellar before this never got a BD nod until this year. I don't care if he doesn't win, I'm just glad the Academy finally recognized him.
Yeah, to me interestellar is nearly the best movie ever made and the fact that didn't win any oscar is nonsense
Kevin Twin I love interstellar. It should’ve won
Tom Helms never for directing. That’s what the comment is about. Didn’t get a nod for any of the Dark Knight films, nor for Memento, Inception or Interstellar. I’d like to see Dunkirk taking home the Best Picture and Best Director prizes, but if the way the award shows have been any indicator, doesn’t look like this will happen. A surprise could be pulled and Dunkirk wins either Oscar or both of those Oscars, as well as other awards, in particularly in the technical categories, but I’m not sure. The Oscars can surprise everyone with their decisions. Just when you think you know which film will win the top prizes, they’ll surprise you. That said, I do think Gary Oldman will get his Academy Award finally. Long overdue for him indeed. This should be like Oldman’s fourth or fifth Oscar win by now.
You forgot Paul Thomas Anderson , who's movies are thousands of Years ahead Nolan.
Percy M. V. R. It is not necessary to compare PTA with Nolan their movies are very different from each other.
I loved learning that Nolan & Del Toro are good friends. Great group of talent here.
It’s funny how people in this comment thread hate when the moderator ask the directors what they appreciated from other movies. I find it to be refreshing. Yes, there are hypocrites in this business, but I find no harm in sincerely commending your peers for their achievements.
Yeah I liked that. Wish Nolan said something about Get Out though. The only movie he skipped
John uh Jacobs He did talk about watching Get Out.
John uh Jacobs He's talks about the film at 15:50
In 15 years we'll look back at this video in disbelief that 5 GOATs are sat next to each other
i fuckin love Nolan
Yes.
Everyone does
@@kaiftintoiwala6414 not me. Nothing against him, I enjoyed some of his movies but I find him overrated.
@Aka I can reply to whatever I want to, thank you. And how exactly is it stupid when I just state my view? Me? Upset? Says the the guy who has to use the word stupid because I possibly offended his one of his favorite director. Who is looking stupid now?
@Aka 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Guillermo is a killer, working the crowd big-time. I'm in stitches here!!! I love this guy!
I really liked this, five distinctly different filmmakers just talking passionately about each other's films. This needed to be at least an hour long.
Christopher Nolan is the definition of class.
Nolan summed up all the movies pretty well.
Irony on how Nolan can summarize most of the film accurately show his dedication on film industry and thanks 🙏 to Del Toro for backing him regarding his vision on Dunkirk with minimal dialogue, like the end scene of the film.
I found myself shouting "YES" every time PTA spoke or someone spoke highly of Phantom Thread. The level of respect I have for that man is unmatched.
Amen. Right there with me. When PT speaks, I listen to.
same. when jordan was describing the new years eve scene i kept sayin 'yhes' in alma's breathy voice
He's the best
It's the look of "You cannot shame me because I am in love".
I wish we could see movies the way you do Greta.
PTA the Best
Nolan>
@@saketadarsh7606 in your dreams. they both are different directors, but PTA movies are hard to direct compare to Nolan movies
@@prashanthadepu3013 whatever PTA is but Nolan is genius, no one in this video is near the level of him
AZ I people can have opinions
@@sketta. so what is your opinion
Guillermo is more than likely going to win but PTA is long overdue for that best director Oscar.
Enrique Godinez the great thing is, the academy is still nominating him even as he gets weirder and out there. I think it will happen in the next 10 years.
Chris Cantos I don’t think Paul will ever win, he will be Kubrick with having a great filmography
@@CannibalWHORE22 I'm actually okay with that. I think even he is at peace with being a well-respected auteur
@@chrisjfox8715 Exactly! His filmography is more worth it’s weight in gold then some award.
Nolan’s efficiency is unparalleled!
Pure focus.
After watching dunkirk my faith in Nolan is doubled up
PTA feels like a wise master, enjoying, digesting, preaching. I love that they all respect him so much.
Greta is so cute hahahaha
I loved to know that Nolan and Del Toro are good friends, definitely didn't expect this. PTA is my favorite filmmaker and see him talking about anything else is soooo good. Good interview, i'd want that be more longer though.
Guillermo del Toro is such a fan of Greta Gerwig and I'm loving it!
There is no bigger achievement than making films that are all artistically, technically, financially and in magnificence successful.
Nolan is the filmmaker of the century.
👏👍
Damn... I'm feeling very emotional for some reason.
ME TOO!
Paul Thomas Anderson is amazing
God some people on here are disgusting. Having seen and loved each of these films, these compliments were genuine and went to the core of the beauty of each individual film. Don’t see why this is bad, it’s great.
IN NOLAN WE TRUST!
Shut Up You Shameless Old Dummy!
@@kushsrivastava418 stfu Kush
Man someone should just sit with Nolan and listen to him review a film, then transcribe it. The guys is so we'll spoken.
Anyone who has Dark Knight and interstellar in their CV is pretty amazing!
Anyone who has There will be blood and The master is pretty amazing.
@@sharknado623 lol, don't compare any movie with "Interstellar" and "Inception". You need to watch theses films 10 times
@@MrChughad lol lol lol. Maybe according to you. There are other filmmakers beside Christopher Nolan. You need to watch PTA movies 10, 100 times. Nolan is for the masses.
@@sharknado623 lol, I already watched all PTA movies, and I can explain all his movies to you, but there are bunch of details in Nolan movies, you cannot find a loophole, his movies are perfectly decorated with details.
@@MrChughad you don't have to explain anything to me, dude. I perfectly know what I watch and how I watch it, and you don't have to convince anyone of your tastes. Let people watch what they hell want and you do the same. You're no better than anyone just because you like something.
Nolan is the man.
We are so lucky to have this panels nowadays, Because imagine back then when we could of have gotten, Orson Welles and John Huston talking with each other and Kurosawa chilling with Bergman. It would have been amazing to have seen this
What about Hitchcock Kubrick and and Kurosawa
Greta Gerwig produced an enhanced masterpiece in Little Women. The creative pacing, vibrant acting, and genuine emotional resonance in that film were off the chain in my humble opinion. Great group discussion.
Yeah, absolutely. Although, I didn't buy that thing with golden glow that was supposed to make past feel more perfect and present's blueish colouring is more bleak, and ending scene is kinda stable middle of two. That technique seemed kinda lame to me. Otherwise , very good movie, vibrant , exuberant characters like in a french new wave movie done right.
Wtf is Greta whatshername doing amongst them? And stop misusing the word masterpiece.
@@sha7303 This comment is a masterpiece. XD
I hate the damn word now.
@@sha7303 bro her name is literally in the comment you’re replying too, can you really not read 💀 she’s there because she was nominated and people enjoyed her work so they voted for her. Simple as that.
@@Ella-gb7no Lmao Barbie director sitting amongst PTA, Nolan & Guillermo. Talk about being out of place lmaooo
the one sitting in the middle is shining
A monster, Batman, a hippie, a bird, and milk ❤️
Del Toro is soo cute.. Really like his aura 😂😁 Nolan and him look good together..
Referring to Christopher Nolan as “Chris” on a panel of directors has to be one of the most surreal experiences
It’s just his name, you dork.
Denis Villeneuve and Martin McDonagh are missing:(
All their movies were great and lasted they weren’t just nominated and then forgotten
Sally Hawkins 🧡💛🧡
Nolan is so humble but he knows he’s the shit
of-fucking-course
He is real shit, never saw any movie like Inception, Interstellar, Dark Knight
Too much detail in his film
After 10 yrs i see my self sitting among that GANG
Goat 🐐
so cool to see 5 of the most legendary directors working today completely nerding over each other's work... especially with Peele and Gerwig now having become firmly entrenched in that top tier, great to see the other 3 recognising their talent even back then just after their respective debuts
agree
Guillermo seems like a silly, funny guy, but it's truly moving to hear him talk about his love for cinema, he has a way with words to convey what cinema does to you, and how it's something so special, he is excellent at explaining that feeling, that experience
Del Toro's closing statements is pure poetry.
Greta Gerwig is one talented lady- there’s something really fascinating and quirky about the screenplay of ladybird; the dialogues in the movie are simple, minimalistic and still so poetic.
Greta and Nolan, the Barbenheimer happened years ago
Paul is not wrong in his reaction to finding out Jordan Peele watched Phantom Thread on a screener...so whack.
Why is it wack?
Is screener a cellphone ?
@@carmellebandibasits a dvd handed out to people in the business before the public.
@@paulelroy6650 so it's illegal?
@@nabil731 no they get them from the studios. its not a pirate copy haha
Only one missing is Denis Villenueve.
Nighttray perhaps one day. Bladerunner 2049 was the most visually stunning movie I think I have ever seen. It could have easily been seated next to these other movies as a nominee for best picture. At least Deakins got nominated.
I think you must to see more cinema. It's digital, and is aberrant.
Ah, and it's full of green screen. Please don't fuck up! Some respect for the REAL masters.
You may want to throw in Michael Haneke, because he's the boss of all these bosses.
TyGLynx_ blade runner full of green screen?
These five Best Director nominees represent such a wide gamut of film genres. Horror, coming-of-age, romantic period drama, war, fantasy. What a good year for movies 2017 was.
Yeah, one of the best groups of Best Director's in recent memory.
2017 really was an insane year for directors kicking ass with their movies.
The way Greta talks 😘
Bravonanda Moirangthem SOO HOT!! Holy shit!
2018: Nolan vs Gerwig Round 1
2023: Nolan vs Gerwig Round 2
I've just rewatched this and the DGA panel (sadly with the exclusion of PTA) for the millionth time and I was so engrossed in it that I was startled when it ended. Probably the best year for a panel discussion ever. When you listen to them speak about each others films, you realize that all the critics, the awards and the whole hullabaloo that the media creates around films is really pointless. At the end of the day, I feel filmmakers are the ones who can really respect and acknowledge the collective love and passion for cinema. Such an inspiring pair of videos this one and the DGA panel together!
Genius Guillermo
Greta’s compliments were absolutely wonderful
I think Nolan deserves the award as best director.
Greatest talents altogether!
What a precious bunch!
Man i thank Guillermo for highlighting Dunkirk and its ending. Masterpiece!
Man, this might just be my fav RUclips vid of all time
One of the best interviews
They should have David Fincher, Quinten Tarrentino, Michael Mann, Christopher Nolan, Sam Mendes
Can there be a video review series by Nolan and Del Toro? The way both describe films is utterly beautiful and both would contrast each other.
It is a potty they are better speech-persons than moviemakers. They read a lot of literature and study it, but it doesn't make them really good writers/directors.
Greta is fangirling the entire time 😂
I respect all of them and their art, and make no mistake about it, their films are art.
Nolan And PTA, the Meetup we deserve.
“Muffin” - Guillermo del toro
Love everything
This feels more like a group of friends talking, than just some filmmakers your acquainted with.
About time they released these
I think this is a very strong year. And it's diverse.
This was great. I'm curious what else they could've answered if they had more time but its funny everyone took the time to gush about eachothers movies.
1.Jordan peele : Get Out
2.Greta Gerwing : Lady Bird
3.Paul Thomas Anderson : Phantom Thread
4.Christopher Nolan : Dunkirk
5.Guillermo del Toro : The Shape Of Water
"The four men and Greta Gerwig" 😀😀
That's a great group of people up there and not just for their films.
Wooow. Icons in film-making.
Greta Gerwig is magic
Yes!
elbakng She's a puppy 🙂🙂👌
Every single one of them is MASTER of their own respected GENERA....
So those who is comparing..
I said chilll...
There's more swearing then I thought there'd be. But thats why I love it.
Guillermo is hilarious!
besides being a cinematic genius...
12:31 Hahaha love Guillermo. They genuinely love each others works.
yeaa
stage full of brilliance
I could see only two
WHAT a panel
Pta y Nolan los más grandes
Del Torro is hilarious
Thank❤ you
Guillermo Del Toro - I’ve been noticing his name in the credits lately under Thanks (Special thanks, Producer wishes to thank, Director thanks, etc). Search on IMDb shows 96 productions that thanked him, including: Gravity, Birdman, The Revenant, Dune Part One, Ferrari, and Leave the World Behind. So besides seeming like a nice person and being quite busy as a filmmaker, he seems to be very helpful!
greta seems like she feels emotions very deeply makes her really endearing
PTA is the best. No question.
This should have been the round table.
the way PTA says saoirse is sendingg me
Del Toro is just hilarious LOL