Lies about THE CRUEL PRINCE

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024

Комментарии • 901

  • @WatchingWhileAsleep
    @WatchingWhileAsleep Год назад +13083

    Okay but a fantasy book with a mostly politcal main plot and a romance subplot is MY SHIT. it just hits different 😭 (and romance subplots are usually better than romance main plots imo because the characters have more development apart from each other but romance main plots are also fun sometimes)

    • @Kaeladoescrochet
      @Kaeladoescrochet Год назад +353

      Thank you someone who thinks the same way as me! Yes I much prefer a fantasy book with a romance subplot over a straight up romantic fantasy

    • @folded_pizza
      @folded_pizza Год назад +147

      Sameeee, I don't typically like JUST romance in a book, but I love when it's a subplot to a big intricate story. I might actually get this now.

    • @anupamjha7178
      @anupamjha7178 Год назад +6

      Fr

    • @somethingsomething6461
      @somethingsomething6461 Год назад +23

      Yesss can someone reccommend me books like that?

    • @Crossingpages
      @Crossingpages Год назад

      @@somethingsomething6461100% shatter me, it’s soooo good

  • @wa11ie
    @wa11ie Год назад +8742

    ok why do people not lead with the romance being a subplot? i don’t want to read romantasy, i want to read fantasy books with minor romance plots.

    • @rat_girlie
      @rat_girlie Год назад +151

      THIS.

    • @raksitharam6860
      @raksitharam6860 11 месяцев назад +117

      YES I WANT THAT SO MUCH

    • @caterlink99
      @caterlink99 11 месяцев назад +62

      Same
      I recommend mortal instruments series and mistborn series

    • @StarkeeperLen
      @StarkeeperLen 11 месяцев назад +12

      SAME EXACTLY

    • @noemblem
      @noemblem 11 месяцев назад +77

      This is the main reason I didn't buy the cruel prince since recently when I learned it wasn't about the romance!!! Like some of us who actually don't want the main plot to be romance exist!!!

  • @ismaelchambers4007
    @ismaelchambers4007 7 месяцев назад +410

    Unpopular opinion: Romantic subplot is ALWAYS so much better than as a main Plot. Romance as a main plot leaves only room for shallow character development.

    • @SakuraCrystalMoon
      @SakuraCrystalMoon 3 месяца назад +9

      FOR REAL! when i read romance books, it gets a little boring when there isn't much going on in the background. still love romance, just like romance subplots more!

    • @Arshi_Harshita
      @Arshi_Harshita Месяц назад +3

      Exactly It's Ironic How Characters falling for each other "in process" is more practical and yet is in a fantasy book.

    • @SakuraCrystalMoon
      @SakuraCrystalMoon Месяц назад +2

      update! i've read a couple of romance books recently, and i can confirm that romance books actually do have space for character development ;-; i've had a blast reading a couple but i can't see myself reading ONLY romance. will always be a fantasy girlie, but i still like romance nevertheless now!

    • @chelestax
      @chelestax Месяц назад

      @@SakuraCrystalMoonooh if you don’t mind, do you have recs for romance stories with good character development?

    • @SakuraCrystalMoon
      @SakuraCrystalMoon Месяц назад +1

      ​@@chelestax okay before i say anything, i definitely recommend you read the folk of the air (if you haven't) because it's still really good. i honestly can't give any good recs ;-; personally i love iron flame by rebecca yarros sm (it's wayyy better than fourth wing imo). Everything else I read might not be up your alley 😅 (percy jackson, wings of fire, one of us is lying, etc.)

  • @papercranes6016
    @papercranes6016 11 месяцев назад +2369

    This was ME I read for the enemies to lovers, but stayed for the political plot 💀
    edit: wow! since many of you agree, I recommend you guys to read the mirror visitor series (first book is a winter's promise).
    FML is nothing like Jude but she's smart (investigative wise, not emotionally) and she gets whisked away into the court's royal politics (similar to Jude), due to a political marriage strengthen their countries union. However she soon realised that it wasn't just for mere politics, but for "undisclosed purpose" and was just being used for her capabilities all along :0
    hope you guys go give it a read!

    • @scorpion9175-k3u
      @scorpion9175-k3u 10 месяцев назад +29

      This is totally me🤣🤣 it happens to me all the time while reading romantic fantasy books

    • @cmm5542
      @cmm5542 10 месяцев назад +22

      I came for 'trying to find books to recommend to my secondary school students', stayed for the best alternate version of Pride and Prejudice ever written (on some days, I think Holly Black could beat out Austen in a showdown!)

    • @amishasalvatore4234
      @amishasalvatore4234 8 месяцев назад +5

      Do you have any enemies to lovers recommendations I’m new to fantasy

    • @scorpion9175-k3u
      @scorpion9175-k3u 8 месяцев назад

      @@amishasalvatore4234 i would definitely recommend 'Cruel prince'

    • @uditabhattacharya2824
      @uditabhattacharya2824 8 месяцев назад +1

      Drop the recs

  • @ravensghost2008
    @ravensghost2008 Год назад +177

    Yes, but other subplots don’t have “By you, I am forever undone” or “judejudejudejudejudejudejudejude” in them

    • @cmm5542
      @cmm5542 10 месяцев назад +7

      Granted. (Waves hand in majestic dismissal like Cardan would 😁)

    • @ultimatebishoujo29
      @ultimatebishoujo29 5 месяцев назад

      Fr

    • @aubreycarter7624
      @aubreycarter7624 Месяц назад +3

      Lol, that is very true! I love Cardan's flowery speeches! The dialogue in the entire series is absolutely golden!

    • @bookgirlie15
      @bookgirlie15 Месяц назад +6

      or “kiss me. kiss me until i am sick of it.”

  • @raajidoshi
    @raajidoshi 11 месяцев назад +1297

    Romance isn't the main plot? You mean I've just been letting that book gather dust for nothing???

    • @ElineaTeine
      @ElineaTeine 7 месяцев назад +89

      Oh my gosh! Yes! I've refused to pick that book up for months now. But a story with romance being secondary to the plot? Yes, pleaaseeee!!!

    • @chanterelle483
      @chanterelle483 6 месяцев назад +14

      Exactly me 😂

    • @tochterchenfrost4784
      @tochterchenfrost4784 5 месяцев назад +13

      😂
      yea, i might actually give it a chance now!

    • @scarlett4346
      @scarlett4346 4 месяца назад +19

      OK my friend advertised it as a romance and i finaly sucked it up and read it and OMG ITS POLITICAL FANTASY I READ THE WHOLE SERIES IN AWEEK

    • @HutaoLover-zz1qh
      @HutaoLover-zz1qh 4 месяца назад +5

      What the fuck read it it’s so goof

  • @lephAANT312
    @lephAANT312 9 месяцев назад +781

    FINALLY. I never knew the name of my favourite fantasy genre until NOW. I CRAVE political fantasy. And. romantic. SUBPLOTS.

  • @mighty_polar_bear3786
    @mighty_polar_bear3786 Год назад +1440

    She gonna love the ending of the next one (low key was angry about the romance at first tbh. I like it in the later books tho). #2 and 3 hit different and I love them. May be my favorite series

    • @katehuhn4592
      @katehuhn4592 Год назад +23

      I have 20 pages left of first book and I am literally the girl from the TikTok like I thought there was going to be more romance then just straight politics, and now I don’t know if I should read the second one. Like is there more romance in the nexts books??

    • @mighty_polar_bear3786
      @mighty_polar_bear3786 Год назад +20

      @@katehuhn4592 it’s a fantasy court drama. There are some spicy scenes, sure, but it’s not the main plot exactly.

    • @Lizzye33
      @Lizzye33 Год назад +3

      Exactly!!! I have been trying to figure out how to explain my same feelings on that, and you did it so well!!!

    • @Lizzye33
      @Lizzye33 Год назад +18

      @@katehuhn4592 Fair question! I was in your shoes when I started the trilogy and was mad about the lack of romance going on because I needed that in my YA books. I also experienced the bully trope for the first time with this, and I am not really a fan, but it makes their story so much better in the next books! There is romance in the next book, and they get on more even ground in The Wicked King and lean more into a relationship we support. By the end of it you might not like him because something happens that makes you feel betrayed after the relationship buildup, (it's there, I promise you, and it's good,) but the third and final one, The Queen of Nothing is the greatest book I have read all year!!! It does finish all loopholes, and yes politics, but even more than that, they have a solid relationship that was better than what you could hope for them getting into the first book. It's so sweet you will be swooning and in love with this series! The first one is disappointing about their relationship, but it's mostly about Jude's journey, and as she finds herself and her purpose in the world of the fae, the world and its characters become more hers than she could have been without the journey. It's so wonderful, and I promise Cardan is someone you will like and support for Jude later. Please don't judge this series based on the first book like I almost did; each book is better than the last by more than 25%. If you have any questions, let me know! :)

    • @leaff123
      @leaff123 Год назад +4

      @@katehuhn4592yes read the next books. although the romance isn’t very prominent in the first book, you can see it a lot more in the next 2 books. just keep in mind that the main story isn’t about the romance so it doesn’t concentrate on it

  • @that.dam.moonlark
    @that.dam.moonlark 10 месяцев назад +178

    Ok but then there’s the “kiss me until I’m sick of it” and there will be squealing

  • @savy_kit
    @savy_kit Год назад +575

    Girl same, people convinced me to read it for cardan and jude and there was barely any romance 😭💀

    • @caterlink99
      @caterlink99 11 месяцев назад +49

      Other side characters are mentioned more than cardan is in the book like romance where??😭

    • @savy_kit
      @savy_kit 11 месяцев назад

      @@caterlink99 exactly 😭💀

    • @triaurorar3291
      @triaurorar3291 11 месяцев назад +43

      The first book sets things up, there is so much more romance in the second and third books. If you haven't read them, please do, they're amazing!

    • @savy_kit
      @savy_kit 10 месяцев назад +13

      @@triaurorar3291 I've only read the first and half of the second. Idk why but I just didn't like the second and couldn't force myself to finish it 😭 I'll prolly start it again tho

    • @scorpion9175-k3u
      @scorpion9175-k3u 10 месяцев назад +14

      Have some patience girls😌 read next two books first

  • @Ottolineification
    @Ottolineification 9 месяцев назад +83

    It’s a romance book, imo. It’s just that it has an actual plot. Not like a romantasy where there is only pining and shagging and no plot

    • @SakuraCrystalMoon
      @SakuraCrystalMoon 3 месяца назад +8

      yeah i was thinking about that because literally the first two books are named after him! everyone is saying the romance isnt there when there's literally so many moments?!?? the plot was literally well developed and interesting, and i would genuinely recommend to anyone regardless of the romance

  • @kiripedia
    @kiripedia Год назад +145

    I actually only read this book because I saw a video of someone mentioning this exact thing. Wasn’t interested in it from what I heard about it online before that, but then someone made a short of what it’s actually about and convinced me to read it. I ended up really liking it xD

    • @marlena.
      @marlena. 8 месяцев назад

      Did you read the entire series bc I just tapped off after starting the second book. I don't remember exactly why, but I do remember it was eighter the writing or the way the story was going.

  • @bookswithike3256
    @bookswithike3256 11 месяцев назад +186

    This is the thing that finally convinced me to read The Cruel Prince after years of assuming it wouldn't be for me because of the way people talk about it. Thanks.

    • @scorpion9175-k3u
      @scorpion9175-k3u 10 месяцев назад +4

      Why👀? Because they only read the 1st book....and already judging 🙂....believe me...this patience would give you reward once you dive into the next 2 books....it is worth it

    • @bookswithike3256
      @bookswithike3256 10 месяцев назад +27

      @@scorpion9175-k3u Because despite liking The Darkest Part of the Forest, this came out during the Sarah J. Maas era, and the way people talked about it made it sound like it was part of the Sarah J. Maas style romance, i.e. insufferable characters, romanticised abusive relationships, romanticised gender roles, bland male characters who are somehow also terrible people even though they're not interesting - just overall nothing I want to read. But a political fantasy with a romance subplot I can do, and I already like Holly Black.

    • @cmm5542
      @cmm5542 10 месяцев назад +20

      ​@@bookswithike3256Yeah, I found Mass' relationships very unhealthy. Cardan and Jude I would consider a properly fantastical example of how to SOLVE an initially unhealthy relationship and grow a better one!

  • @studymate8469
    @studymate8469 Год назад +181

    Yeah I also didn't find much romance there just a lot of scheming and plotting 😅 But I'm still obsessed over Jude and cardan❤

  • @dearme4536
    @dearme4536 6 месяцев назад +30

    Ive finished the cruel prince three days ago. And guess what. I ordered the wicked king. It finally arrived.. THE BOOK IS LITERALLY INFRONT OF ME. LETS GOOOOOO

  • @ElisabethD3
    @ElisabethD3 11 месяцев назад +38

    That was my exact reaction to his book. However, I also love a good political fantasy, so this book hit every right note for me. I came for Jude and carden, but I stayed for the political interworkings of the fae.

    • @cmm5542
      @cmm5542 10 месяцев назад +2

      I came and stayed for both! Love a story with more than one plot thread!

    • @jasmintea8825
      @jasmintea8825 6 месяцев назад +1

      tbh i got confused about politics most of the time

  • @ahsoka_edits
    @ahsoka_edits 10 месяцев назад +41

    FINALLY SOMEONE SAYS IT, I THOUGHT IT WOULD BE AN ACOTAR KIND OF THING BUT NoOOOoOoOooo IT'S POLITICS!!!!

  • @DreamyTenshi
    @DreamyTenshi 6 месяцев назад +27

    I love when the romance is a subplot like yes please. They are always the best and they have the best couples!

  • @aelinAshrvyer
    @aelinAshrvyer Год назад +23

    As a booktok reader since 2020, Cardan and Jude are my absolutely all time favorite couple. I've read the folk of the air series more than 10 times and I Loved it everytime.

  • @burrito2981
    @burrito2981 10 месяцев назад +8

    Nuh cuz I would be mad opposite way around, if someone recommended me fantasy book and then ronace turned out to be main plot 🤡

  • @Rens27
    @Rens27 6 месяцев назад +12

    I saw The Wicked King on a display stand when I walked into the library a while back. The cover made stopped me in my tracks and immediately add it to my tbr (I had a bunch of reservations put out on other books across multiple series so couldn't read it immediately)

  • @elezeiaz
    @elezeiaz 9 месяцев назад +14

    I loved this book. And I love the addions of How the King of Elfhame learned to hate stories & the Stolen Heir

  • @sylve2474
    @sylve2474 11 месяцев назад +17

    Had me sold as soon as you said it was a young adult political fantasy(with a tertiary romance subplot),, sounds great

  • @KaiseaWings
    @KaiseaWings 11 месяцев назад +16

    I got psychic damage from 'young adult' until I remembered that 'Cruel Prince' and 'Captive Prince' are different books.

    • @priiifrg
      @priiifrg 2 месяца назад

      They are both excellent series though. The second book of CP is absolutely amazing.

    • @KaiseaWings
      @KaiseaWings 2 месяца назад

      @@priiifrg WHICH CP????
      I tried Captive Prince on a lark and ah, no, too much for me. Can see why people enjoy it though! Catharsis in darkness.

  • @chillitheconqueror3567
    @chillitheconqueror3567 Год назад +78

    Ok since I feel safe in a community of readers I shall rant here:
    I absolutely HATE Jude and Cardan's entire relationship. When I read this book Jude doesn't even talk about Cardan that much, she's more absorbed in her own shit which like totally go queen but she doesn't really show a SLIVER of "I like you" attitude, even when she sees Cardan surrounded by chicks she's like "ew what a slut 🙄" or something. I found the love story between her and Lock or Loke or however you spell his name (I read the book in my native language) WAY more compelling and interesting but then of course they HAD to ruin it and make him a complete asshole.
    What I'm saying is that we get a peek into Jude's thought process and she never even mentions liking him. She mentions that he's attractive but never really nothing other than that. But the moment she hears that Cardan likes her she just shifts her entire mood and proceeds to make out with him, which I felt was a huge jump that made no sense and came towards the END of the book so they had many chances throughout the book to get closer but every one of their interactions came out of a place of hate, at least for Jude.
    Not to mention Cardan has no redeeming qualities at all. And the book is all like "well he doesn't KILL" and omg that's like so hot that he doesn't kill as if it isn't EVEN LOWER THAN THE BARE MINIMUM. It's like when you congratulate a guy for not speaking over you and for not doing something when you tell them not to do it. CONGRATULATIONS, YOU HAVE ACHIEVED THE BARE MINIMUM.
    Meanwhile, Lok was a perfect arc, he was supportive and adorable, and didn't deny Jude the adventures she craves in her life. IF ONLY HE DIDN'T TURN OUT TO BE A RAGING SOCIOPATH WHO DATED HER BITCH SISTER THE ENTIRE TIME.
    And I'm not gonna type this and pretend like I know how to write a compelling enemies to lovers, but I AM gonna type this and pretend like I know how to NOT write an enemies to lovers.
    That being said, this isn't a "marked" situation, where anyone who likes the house of night series is automatically my mortal enemy, no. I have no issues with people who like this book series, to each their own. And the reason I typed all of this is because my friends don't listen to me when I rant about books I hate, so

    • @gonnfishy2987
      @gonnfishy2987 11 месяцев назад +4

      Have you read “The Lies of Locke Lamora” trilogy…. Its obsession and very immersive
      (Scott Lynch) … lots of generously developed characters

    • @chillitheconqueror3567
      @chillitheconqueror3567 11 месяцев назад +2

      @gonnfishy2987 ooh sounds awesome. I'll see if the bookstore has it, thanks for the recommendation!

    • @caterlink99
      @caterlink99 11 месяцев назад +13

      I agree with what you said about Locke.. Jude and Locke had way more of a connection than Jude and Cardan, like actually built a relationship between her and him but with Cardan he just somehow has an obsession with her?? She goes on and on about how she hates him but when he kisses her shes all of a sudden in love with him? What I really didn’t understand about the character Locke was how he was suppose to be obsessed drama and action but then he leaves Jude for her boring twin sister who ends killing him (what a waste of a character) like she was boring from the start , what was he even expecting?? not to mention how many times she back stabbed Jude , i rlly did not like her
      This series was hyped up a bit too much, it had a good plot but the characters and the romance was annoying to read 3.5/5 for me

    • @gonnfishy2987
      @gonnfishy2987 11 месяцев назад +3

      @@caterlink99 good analysis, this was a curious thing for me too. However, I enjoy reading books in this series/world and just adapted. (Not saying you should!)

    • @Nefferduat
      @Nefferduat 11 месяцев назад +5

      This is why I gave up reading ya fantasy. There are so many cool ideas in them, but every time I start a series it seems to devolve into "girl has to choose between two boys, one is chill and one is not but the author is told by their editor first pass that the romance with the not chill one feels weird and forced when the chill, supportive option is right there so instead of reworking the end game romance to be *good* just heel turns the chill one into an absolute lunatic so the not chill one feels good in comparison"
      Got exhausting after a while so I just stopped bothering.

  • @thearcadiancomplex9397
    @thearcadiancomplex9397 3 месяца назад +6

    Man the letters to jude were so gooood🎉

  • @Camrynwonderland
    @Camrynwonderland 6 месяцев назад +7

    Hey in my defense as a full time romance reader it was one of the best books and I'm waiting for my time to go to the bookstore to get the 2nd book

  • @devotedfolloweroftheunblin6633
    @devotedfolloweroftheunblin6633 11 месяцев назад +16

    I feel personal being called out here😂

  • @averageperson434
    @averageperson434 9 месяцев назад +9

    Ok I’ve read the whole trilogy and I loooved ittt! BUT I will not read something like that again because I will not be able to tear myself away from it

  • @UmbraDaiwrfol
    @UmbraDaiwrfol 9 месяцев назад +2

    Okay so I'm going to rant about my life right now, but the cruel prince saga was a Fcking breath of fresh air for me. Since I don't know how many years, every Fck time I want to red a YA fantasy novel book, it turned out to be a romance novel. And I hate them. Every time, the main plot is the romance, the real plot goes secondary. It's frustrating cause I really don't like romance and all the thing to it. I mean, I don't mind a biiit of it, but I don't want it to be the main plot!
    The cruel prince was a surprise really, I got it as a present, read it and I loooved it. It's still a '' basic enemy's to lover'' bit so well executed that it dob' t even feel like a cliché.
    If anybody have in mind a fantasy YA book without romance as the main plot, or even secondary plot, or even without romance, plllease spam me

  • @spiceupyourafterlife
    @spiceupyourafterlife 4 месяца назад +6

    I came for the enemies to lovers and stayed for the world building and political intrigue.

  • @BaobhanloreArt
    @BaobhanloreArt 9 месяцев назад +2

    Okay, I'll bite; this book is shit and has one of the most irredeemably toxic relationships I've come across. Wanna know why? Cardan uses magic to sexually assault Jude in the first act! They make her take her clothes off and do humiliating actions without her consent or power to stop.
    Also I could go into all the problems with conflicts being resolved way too easily, none of the plot beats having actual consequences, and how it uses a non-consentual brainwashing plot as it's supposedly woke great LGBT rep but I've complained about this series enough and don't have the energy or time to go into it right now.

  • @XxMCRroxnonstopxX
    @XxMCRroxnonstopxX 11 месяцев назад +10

    My copy of the thord book doesnt have the letters and I'm still mad.

    • @ultimatebishoujo29
      @ultimatebishoujo29 5 месяцев назад

      Really?

    • @XxMCRroxnonstopxX
      @XxMCRroxnonstopxX 5 месяцев назад

      @@ultimatebishoujo29 yep. It was confusing cause they kept going on about these letters that weren't in the book. I was so annoyed when I found out some editions had the letters. I bet it makes more sense with them too 😅

    • @Noveltea1113
      @Noveltea1113 2 месяца назад

      Look it up, you can find them posted for free!

  • @sophiesworldofwonder9100
    @sophiesworldofwonder9100 3 месяца назад +2

    Ok so, I was there for all the political crap, but Cardan and Jude? That guy bullied her and would've gladly killed her for sport. Not cute. Disgusting imo.

  • @M4t_P4tGT
    @M4t_P4tGT 6 месяцев назад +4

    Wait… it’s NOT actually a romance?
    I’m interested.
    Update: Read the book. HATED Cardan, but holy shit I need more Heather and Vivi those two have my whole heart 💖

    • @katgreer6113
      @katgreer6113 5 месяцев назад

      No it's not lol ppl just hype up the romance aspect.

    • @M4t_P4tGT
      @M4t_P4tGT 5 месяцев назад +1

      @@katgreer6113 Not surprised

  • @Mars-w5q
    @Mars-w5q 9 месяцев назад +2

    I enjoyed Cruel Prince, but I don’t like Cardan very much. I like the politics. Yet, I cannot enjoy romance that is simply a way for the characters to cope with the craziness around them.

  • @faeryeclair
    @faeryeclair Год назад +5

    im on the third book and im at the part where they.. uhm.. ahaha..!

  • @trulytryingtovibe
    @trulytryingtovibe 9 месяцев назад +2

    Ok but that’s what I WANT! I will happily take political fantasy action with a sprinkle of romance that hopefully is enemies to lovers. Would much rather have that then a romance that just happens to take place in a fantasy world.

  • @Mehisme-ul8se
    @Mehisme-ul8se 7 месяцев назад +4

    CRUEL PRINCE IS SO GOOD
    I MEAN THERES MORE ROMANCE AS YOU GOOO AHHHHHH

  • @gloss143
    @gloss143 9 месяцев назад +2

    I tried to read it but the way Jude was treated turned me off from Cardan completely and I had to stop reading

  • @aurahdz2468
    @aurahdz2468 Год назад +35

    The romance in those books is sooooooo worth it

  • @Yt-wc4jd
    @Yt-wc4jd 10 месяцев назад +4

    Totally but I still loved itb❤❤❤

  • @ellieeditss
    @ellieeditss 11 месяцев назад +6

    okay, quick question for anyone who has read The Cruel Prince, what is it’s age rating/spice level? because i’ve seen a lot about it online and it looks really good and i want to read it, but i’m not a big fan of books with too much spice

    • @britneyspears5727
      @britneyspears5727 10 месяцев назад +4

      I've read only the first two books, but there isn't anything very explicit in them. There's one (or 2?) slightly steamy scenes but it's more 'fade to black' and doesn't go into intense detail. Its like when you watch a movie and the people kiss and start to undress but then there's another scene, and you kind of know what happens and you see some of it but not everything.

    • @cmm5542
      @cmm5542 10 месяцев назад

      I'm literally a Victorian prude, and I was comfortable with the level of intimacy. There's a scene in the third book as well which is a bit more obvious (though still no graphic detail), but for REASONS I will not reveal here, I had 0 problems with it being included.
      And the lovely thing is that it will not impact either the plot or their romance at all if you skip both those scenes. I think Holly Black had to write them for those who DEMAND spice. The buildup of the relationship is much more central. And one of the things I loved best was having a strong female lead character who didn't ever feel the need to have sex to prove herself as an adult! (She just.. . . fights people instead 😉)

    • @selenathesparklycabbage
      @selenathesparklycabbage 9 месяцев назад +2

      There's practically nothing in the first 2 books- in the third, there's a scene but not too explicit at all- couple paragraphs you can gloss over and comfortably move on tbh. :)

    • @aubreycarter7624
      @aubreycarter7624 9 месяцев назад +1

      If I had to rate it on a scale of 0-5, five being the most descriptive, explicitly sexual, I would rate the Cruel Prince, Wicked King and Queen of nothing at about 0.5-1.
      In the first two books, there's a bit of kissing and steamy tension between Jude and Cardan, and a couple spots where sex between other characters is heavily implied, but not explicitly described.
      The third book has a sex scene between Cardan and Jude, but even then, it's pretty tame, not really graphic or descriptive.
      The whole series has mentions of nudity, but it's very matter of fact, and, again, not graphic.

  • @starsandbeyond8947
    @starsandbeyond8947 7 месяцев назад +2

    People who hate the series are the ones who just assumed it was some fae smut

  • @jaelyn-wk2oh
    @jaelyn-wk2oh 4 месяца назад +12

    Am I the only one who doesn't like Cardan with Jude? He was a jerk.

  • @thebisexualghost
    @thebisexualghost Месяц назад +1

    Only reason I would buy this book would be to find the page that just says, "Jude, Jude, Jude, Jude, Jude, Jude, Jude, Jude, Jude, Jude,"

  • @magpiex1289
    @magpiex1289 11 месяцев назад +10

    chapter 15 was our apology

  • @ash_its_cap
    @ash_its_cap 5 месяцев назад +1

    IM IN THE MIDDLE IF THIS BOOK AND I WAS WONDERING WHY IT WASNT LIKE ANYTHING I EXPECTED!!!! EVERYONE KEEOS SAYING ITS A ROMANCE BUT THATS BS 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

  • @drgnfsh9006
    @drgnfsh9006 9 месяцев назад +4

    Ok but holly black is one of my fav authors

  • @JadeNoms.urPencilfeul
    @JadeNoms.urPencilfeul 7 месяцев назад +1

    MY FAVORITE FANTASY POLITICAL ROMANCE IS RUSSIAN ROULETTE AND ITS ON WATTPAD
    Wanted to mention it here ( ^^)
    The revolutionarya are smart ah
    especially Ame

  • @giorgia.m
    @giorgia.m Год назад +20

    The romance subplot is the undercurrent of the whole story though I think, it’s just ever-present even when not the main focus, especially later. I loved the books!! 2 & 3 especially!!!

    • @cmm5542
      @cmm5542 10 месяцев назад

      Same here!

  • @aliyahritson8583
    @aliyahritson8583 Год назад +2

    Ok but this actually make me want to read it more i heard stuff wich makes me think its very much romance centered like say a court of thorns and roses but om going to read the cruel price now lol
    Politics!

    • @cmm5542
      @cmm5542 10 месяцев назад

      I think it's because Cardan is INTRODUCED in the early chapters as an obvious hate-to-love interest, and I think lots of people take that at face value and spend the rest of the series expecting romance of which there is approximately 20 pages total throughout the trilogy.
      Remember folks - Holy Black is a FAE AUTHOR. She's trying to trick us!

  • @spoilertruther
    @spoilertruther 10 месяцев назад +3

    I just bought The Cruel Prince!! Im gonna resd the series after i read tgcf

  • @jasmintea8825
    @jasmintea8825 6 месяцев назад +2

    tbh my favorite part about the book is Jude and her psychology

    • @livethroughtthiswithme
      @livethroughtthiswithme 6 месяцев назад +2

      Same!!! I LOVE being able to analyse characters so jude was like my favourite part of the story ^^
      I also really love that her a taryn basically have the same trauma but respond differently to it. I feel like that was also one of my favourite parts since idk, i feel like people don't often recognise that there is not only 1 "correct" way to deal with it if that makes sense??? Lol

  • @m.m.7552
    @m.m.7552 6 месяцев назад +3

    Me rereading the cruel prince right now (well, the queen of nothing by now) and realizing I've tricked myself into misremembering what this book was about and how much of it was actually about the romance. Yeah, i feel this.

  • @icarusxedits
    @icarusxedits Год назад +2

    It’s not mainly romance? Reliefed, I might reconsider giving it a shot

  • @katie_842
    @katie_842 7 месяцев назад +5

    JUDE AND CARDAN ARE SO CUTE THO

  • @moonlit_rain.6784
    @moonlit_rain.6784 5 месяцев назад +1

    Unpopular opinion here: I actually kinda hated the romance subplot...

  • @AzaleaM
    @AzaleaM 9 месяцев назад +3

    I love the Cruel Prince books. Don’t get me wrong, Carden started out as an asshole, but to see Jude grow to love him just as much as he did, made me so happy. I started on the Queen of Nothing by mistake, but that book made the whole series make so much sense to me.

  • @justwonder1404
    @justwonder1404 8 месяцев назад +2

    It took me so long to get to this one precisely cause I thought it was mainly romance😅 I only gave it a chance because I wanted me some folklore-ish fairies, so glad I did. Holly Black and her publishers were smart to market it as romance, but it almost missed me.

  • @tamiressoares9303
    @tamiressoares9303 Год назад +4

    Omg 😳 make another video with her reaction on the end of the second book PLEASE ❤

  • @zzzzoz22
    @zzzzoz22 8 месяцев назад +1

    I tried reading the cruel prince, but I just don't understand political plots. They're so confusing to me. Fantasy is also really confusing to me too. Just not my favorite, I prefer dystopian/sci fi

  • @Lilwitchyreads
    @Lilwitchyreads Год назад +5

    I’m on book 3 right now! Loving it

  • @cris_ad
    @cris_ad 9 месяцев назад +1

    Perhaps unpopular opinion? But I didn't really like this very much. There is nothing wrong with it, I am just 37 and find no joy in young adult tropes. Decided to give it a chance since a lot of people seemed to like it.. and... meh? Someone getting bullied in magic high school is not something I find interesting to read. Not for me, glad it exists for others to enjoy.

  • @The_Freddy_Krueger
    @The_Freddy_Krueger Год назад +7

    RahMance book?

  • @tuttifrutti4221
    @tuttifrutti4221 9 месяцев назад +2

    I literally bought this book because the covers were pretty💀😭
    But iam so glad i did because it was amazing. I read the first book in under a week.

  • @Lilly_aphmaus_fan
    @Lilly_aphmaus_fan 4 месяца назад +3

    Are you sure that the wicked king is good bc i bought it and oh boy i got confused
    Maybe bc i didn't see the cruel prince and i can't buy it bc I'm too broke 😅

    • @wrentheelf2656
      @wrentheelf2656 4 месяца назад +1

      Yeah you can't really read the second book of the trilogy without reading the first. There's so much information about the world and the characters in the first one you're bound to be lost if you start later

  • @tearsofthekingdom9062
    @tearsofthekingdom9062 7 месяцев назад +1

    Ok just saying An Ember in the Ashes by Sabaa Tahir and a curse so dark and lonely (I don’t remember who wrote it) are a great books. They are romance fantasy books.

  • @aubreycarter7624
    @aubreycarter7624 9 месяцев назад +3

    Lol, everyone is obsessed with Jude and Cardan because they are the best enemies-to-lovers power couple!
    And The Folk of the Air series is one of the few, rare series that I reread on a fairly regular basis. I love the dialouge!

    • @cmm5542
      @cmm5542 9 месяцев назад +2

      Absolutely!
      (And as someone who studies medieval history, it's a LOT more realistic than fantasy! There were real royal couples like this - looking at you, Eleanor of Aquitaine!)

  • @harrypotterfan1665
    @harrypotterfan1665 11 месяцев назад +1

    “I did” What are you talking about I never intentionally lied to you but I’m not denying it WHAT DID I DO

  • @duhforg
    @duhforg 11 месяцев назад +3

    I don't think I read them with the right attitude. I kinda thought Cardan was a bit of a clown for laughing at her at that one point.

    • @cmm5542
      @cmm5542 10 месяцев назад +2

      You're supposed to think that initially. Holly Black likes to trick us like her own fae. And she wanted us to have to read the third book to find out his motives there - though the fact that he hesitated a beat before joining in the laughter gave me a strong suspicion he was trying to protect Jude from something. Like the faerie fruit scene in the first book where Cardan tells Jude to kiss his foot; sounds awful out of context, but in fact Nicasia was about to initiate and orgy with a non-consensual Jude, and Cardan was outnumbered, so he played along and shifted the focus back on to Jude's inferior status as his subject to prevent the others from sexually assaulting her.

    • @duhforg
      @duhforg 10 месяцев назад

      @cmm5542 that's fair. I think I might've been so distracted by the political aspect of the books that I never really got attached to Cardan at all. I did read them all, and of course I'm glad he's still kicking, but he's no Rhysand, Rowan, Xaden, etc. imo. I think their ages, or age group, got in the way for me. Everyone saw them as kids, they were kids. Reading them as a twenty something year old, yeah these characters aren't relationshipable. There were just boundaries like that for me. I'd read them again with a new perspective, if you think I should.

    • @duhforg
      @duhforg 10 месяцев назад

      @cmm5542 I don't think Cardan was a bad character, he was complicated and we were supposed to have a different perspective by the end. He just wasn't ever like... 😍🥵🥰

    • @Faye-el1bz
      @Faye-el1bz 9 месяцев назад

      Interesting

  • @Dia_mant_and_cat
    @Dia_mant_and_cat 11 месяцев назад +2

    She'll be back at the end of book 2

  • @zahraghaderi43
    @zahraghaderi43 Год назад +32

    Exactly. I also thought this's gonna be a enemies to lovers romance book but I could barely find a chapter about romance in it. And I am not satisfied with jude and carden yet😭
    So please tell me the next books contain more romantic parts to give me the courage to start them.

    • @biancamoore413
      @biancamoore413 Год назад

      Just keep going just keep going Just get through the first and the second and the third. Oh my goodness the third the last one. Oh my goodness oh my goodness the third that’s all I have to say is the third 3❤. 3❤. 3❤. 3😍. 3🥰. 3😘. 3🤭. 3🤗. 3🫠. 3🫶🏽. 3👏. 3👍🏽. 3🔥. 3🎇. 3🎆. 3💕. 3💞. 3💓. 3💗. 3💖. 3💘. 3💝. 3💟.

    • @megsdeps2405
      @megsdeps2405 11 месяцев назад +8

      I would say the third one would have more romance than the 2nd one

    • @scorpion9175-k3u
      @scorpion9175-k3u 10 месяцев назад +6

      M writing this comment again ," have some patience girl, read next two books first 😌"

    • @cmm5542
      @cmm5542 10 месяцев назад +3

      There is more romance to come.
      Also, to anyone struggling with the power dynamic between Jude and Cardan initially I will always say: 'Have you read Pride and Prejidice? Because this is the Exact. Same. Trope!' (Honestly, I think Cardan redeems himself better than Darcy. It's just Darcy SAYS more in apology in P&P.)

    • @aubreycarter7624
      @aubreycarter7624 9 месяцев назад +6

      There is more of Cardan and Jude's relationship in books 2 and 3. The third book does have a sex scene, but it's pretty short and not terribly descriptive. Although the dialogue between them is 🤌chef's kiss.

  • @hannahcasey6411
    @hannahcasey6411 5 месяцев назад +2

    What happened to your nose?!

  • @StarkeeperLen
    @StarkeeperLen 11 месяцев назад +11

    YOU DONT KNOW HOW MUCH THIS MAKES ME ACTUALLY LOOK FORWARD TO READING THIS BOOK
    I bought it when I was in a bookstore last summer but I've not had time to read 😔
    Knowing that the romance is just some subplot makes it sound a lot more appealing already

    • @cmm5542
      @cmm5542 10 месяцев назад

      I thought from Cardan's introduction in the early chapters that the romance would be all there was (insert eye roll), then a few chapters further in I was like 'Wait, what else is going on here? YOU MEAN THERE IS MORE TO JUDE'S STORY THAN HER FALLING IN LOVE WITH SOMEONE SHE SHOULDN'T? Bring it on!' 😅
      (Note: by 'someone she shouldn't' I mean 'a romance that looks like it SHOULD be a toxic failure, but keeps you on edge wondering if these two tenacious characters are ACTUALLY going to defy the odds and social expectations to pull it off!

  • @MyCorner_YT
    @MyCorner_YT 9 месяцев назад +1

    OH MY GOD I LOVE THAT BOOK :D!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @Sj_zxxchh
    @Sj_zxxchh 4 месяца назад +3

    #jarden is amazing

  • @kpoppy9635
    @kpoppy9635 7 месяцев назад +1

    Im glad romance isnt the main plot. Im much more interested in the politics, the world and the MC being a spy.
    I wish the author of Iron Flame would take notes because the romance between the two main characters is literally wrecking the story.

  • @youtube2snoopy820
    @youtube2snoopy820 Год назад +16

    Why the band-aid on the nose?

  • @guessWHOOO111
    @guessWHOOO111 7 месяцев назад +1

    I still love it cuz romance as the main plot gets boring for me i prefer some ✨court drama✨ and betrayals and politics mixed in (and yes i read the whole series i loved it)

  • @jfd013
    @jfd013 Год назад +3

    FINALLY someone realizes it! it’s worth the hype but NOT for the category it’s in 😮‍💨😮‍💨
    still love the book though ❤

    • @cmm5542
      @cmm5542 10 месяцев назад +1

      Yes indeed!

  • @ram47863
    @ram47863 8 месяцев назад +1

    I read it too
    But cardan just a red flag
    But also jude is a bit, I don't know
    They deserve each other

  • @Alivia_775
    @Alivia_775 11 месяцев назад +2

    This is so me. I honestly like romance subplots, but this one was barely there and people made it seem like it was this HUGE romance book. I read the first one, hated it, still bought the second one bc everyone said it was good (and ofc I listened) and I dnfed it.

  • @forajaysingh
    @forajaysingh 5 месяцев назад +1

    guys i hv a doubt , is this the book which the prince is getting abused by his brother or smthg like that ...........

  • @marichat_obsession
    @marichat_obsession 7 месяцев назад +1

    11 year old me reading it all Holly blacks books

  • @Right_LeadEquestrian
    @Right_LeadEquestrian 11 месяцев назад +1

    K but fantasy books with a romance subplot r way superior to fantasy romances

  • @ThyLocalBard
    @ThyLocalBard 9 месяцев назад +2

    I read the cruel prince trilogy backwards and it was still really interesting lol

    • @cmm5542
      @cmm5542 9 месяцев назад +2

      This is so funny because I have a similar story! You see, I was checking through the YA to find books to recommend to my students - I don't usually read fantasy - so I just read the beginning of The Cruel Prince. It was compelling so I turned to the end to see if it would be worth reading through (I tend to not care about knowing the ending; I'm more interested in how the characters get there but HATE getting let down by tragic or inconclusive endings). As soon as I read that ast line 'It's what you wanted, isn't it? What you sacrificed everything for. Take it. It's all yours' - I turned back to the beginning and started reading as fast as I could! 😅

    • @ThyLocalBard
      @ThyLocalBard 9 месяцев назад

      @@cmm5542 oh man 😅 I agree about the endings, sometimes having spoilers can make it way more fascinating, especially when you can pick up on all the little hints that *could* mean something but you don't know what exactly, or how they get from here to the end

  • @vidisha9312
    @vidisha9312 7 месяцев назад +1

    EXACT LYYYYYY
    LIKE THE ROMANCE SUB PLOT JUSR BECOMES SO MUCH MORE BETTER AND AUTHENTIC WHEN ITS NOT THE MAIN THING AND ITS MORE POLITICALLY CENTERED CAUSE THAT MAKES THE ROMANCE WORTH IT

  • @jankachowski
    @jankachowski 10 месяцев назад +1

    It's really not that good. The books. Especially the last one.

  • @DepressedSunshine
    @DepressedSunshine 6 месяцев назад +1

    WAIT I THOUGHT THIS WAS A DARK ROMANCE ENEMIES-TO-LOVERS BOOK WITH A TERTIARY HIGH COURT POLITICAL SUBPLOT! CLEARLY theres been some unspoken mistakes

    • @katgreer6113
      @katgreer6113 5 месяцев назад

      NOPE not even close hahaha 😂

  • @animeator
    @animeator 9 месяцев назад +1

    Hihi. Tithe by the same author, for anyone wanting to know where all that started.

  • @vrtualover
    @vrtualover 6 месяцев назад +1

    started reading the series for the romance. stayed for the political drama because sweet jesus do they have some issues

  • @MeepLeDoodle
    @MeepLeDoodle 6 месяцев назад +1

    I want to read these books so bad XD I've only read The Darkest Part of the Forest by her and I loved it.

  • @EowynVala
    @EowynVala 2 месяца назад +1

    Okay. But the bandaid... Explain

  • @inaskulsumhabib649
    @inaskulsumhabib649 9 месяцев назад +1

    Funny i came across this ryt when i am reading the cruel prince i was confused with how little romance is hinted between them and i really dislike cardan and now i cant wait to see theyre gonna fix that

  • @Raccoon-hv8wd
    @Raccoon-hv8wd 5 месяцев назад +1

    What happened to your nows
    ( Sorry, I meant Nose)

  • @grahamcrack
    @grahamcrack 10 месяцев назад +1

    I love TFOTA series sooooo much!!! I prefer romance as a subplot in fantasy, because way too many romantasy completely fail in creating a balance between smut and serious plots. They will bring up how horny and in love a character is while they’re in a meeting discussion genocide, or 2 seconds after abolishing slavery the couple will have sex, like it just ruins the grim atmosphere and I just can’t take the topics on hand seriously since the main character themselves aren’t🥲
    SPOILER THRONE OF GLASS:
    Like when Aelin and Rowan(it was Rowan right??) goes on an ice cream date out in a city where she’s wanted by the king??? like how am I supposed to believe the king is a real threat to you, you’re in danger and you have to hide when you’re strolling down the streets snacking on some rainbow sprinkles??? Get out of here

    • @cmm5542
      @cmm5542 10 месяцев назад

      COMPLETELY agree! I simply do not have the level of suspension of disbelief to accept that someone running for their life has time to think about sex!
      (Not sure if you've read the Wicked King yet, so I won't give it away, but there's one scene where Cardan is injured and Jude is exhausted, but they're alone together and any other author would have had them have sex even though they're clearly not physically up for it, which I HATE; but Holly Black DOESN'T do that to them, and I love her for it!)

  • @simeonwood3613
    @simeonwood3613 9 месяцев назад +1

    If you like fun stories, read the belgariad.

  • @abigailkaterbergcolibaba
    @abigailkaterbergcolibaba 8 месяцев назад +1

    Dude i have no idea why i picked up book 2 but im so glad i did cause the series gets so much better

  • @manuquini05.855
    @manuquini05.855 8 месяцев назад +2

    Yes, I don't understand why so much people say that The cruel prince is a book of "romance"... Don't see the book or what?