Shocking Podcast with Shabbar Zaidi, Asim Munir, Imran Khan and The DHA
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- Shocking Podcast with Shabbar Zaidi, Asim Munir, Imran Khan & The DHA @raftartv Podcast
Shabbar Zaidi provides valuable insights. As a respected economist and former Chairman of the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), Zaidi offers a nuanced look at Pakistan's complex issues including what if General Asim Munir visits Imran Khan in Adiala Jail, Pak-US relations, Donald Trump and what's next for Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI)
Please support us by subscribing to our channel, sharing our content, and engaging with us. Even if our work doesn't resonate with you, we'd appreciate your feedback. Raftar is not merely a content company that produces meticulously researched, high-quality videos about the economy, youth issues, gender roles, and sports. More than that, we represent a movement for social change. We cannot make a difference without your participation and support.
For more amazing content, SUBSCRIBE NOW!
RUclips
/ @raftartv
RUclips
/ @raftarnewsofficial
RUclips
/ @raftarsports
Website:
raftar.com/
![MISSING: SLIM SHADY [Expanded Mourner’s Edition Trailer]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xh8qgHrOO1g/mqdefault.jpg)
The best podcast from Shabbar zaidi on youtube so far ....
Hypocritical person
Mr Zaidi seems to be the only person in the media who has the guts to speak the truth...and Raftaar the only channel which has the accumen to ask the pertinent questions!!
God bless
Good ideas but this guy is too crude to be successful as a leader. Need someone else that has strong ideas but has diplomacy also.
@@ahaanmisra4892 ye bnda acha ha but sad k JB Bolna chate tha tb NAHI bola
@@lapampa4296 wish there was a leader who could use this energy and accumen for the good of the country!! Not every good resource needs to be a good leader dude 🙂
@@lapampa4296 Zaid hamid has 'strong ideas'
What a man shabbar sb is... He is truly a gem and dabang economist.... Shabbar is ghabbar
Hypocritical person
I thank from bottom of my heart to raftar channel for taking Mr Zaidi's words on Imam Hussain A.S message. May Pakistani nation understand the core of his words
زیدی صاحب کی شخصیت کمال ھے۔۔۔معاشرے کے تلخ حقائق شائستہ طریقے سے ظاہر کرتے ھیں۔
Hypocritical person
Its fruitful to listen Shabbar Zaidi. Thanks for inviting such knowledgeable person.
bakwas.... yeah itna laiq hai tu jahangir khan tareen ko corrupt bol dayy bus
ye agr itna qabil tha to fbr k chaimen hhote hue kiu kuch na kr ska?? ise hta kr hi tareen ko laya gya tha n??
Kyuki jo Army kahe gi sirf Vohi hota haiv Pakistan mei...Imran khan nei jaise hi Army ki baat maan ne se mana kiya toh utha ke daal diya jail me.....DEMOCRACY sirf kitaabo mein hai Pakistan mei..@@vantagehistory1813
@@bittertruth2210 oh bhai rhne de tu...................... nawaz ata he to kam pr kam krta he jbkh imran k hath pao pkre the??
such ye he imran khan ne panjab se domicile khtm kia jise aj maryam ne restore kia he.............just lahore safe city me 90% jobs balochistan or kp walo ko di jo panjab province ki jobs thi....................phir socho agr pti wapis ayi to kia halat kregi ............................... i dont hate kp or balochistan mgr jb un k sobo me panjabio ko qatal kr dia jata he,,,\
ap log panjab ki jan choro................... panjabio ko apne mulk k bare me serious ho kr sochna chahie
Hypocritical person
Thank you, Raftar, for bringing Shabbar Zaidi back. His intellectual discussions are always insightful and thought-provoking. Shabbar Zaidi's ability to simplify complex economic concepts and provide fresh perspectives is truly invaluable. Keep up the great work, and thank you for featuring such esteemed guests.😀
Glad you liked it! Please share as much as possible.
@@raftartvInvite Mr Basit the former ambesdor in India & expose him by your hard question , He is a big liar
Shabbar Zaidi is a Rock Star of You Tube !! Love his humorous and witty podcasts.
His humour reflects the reality
Probably the only honest man left in Pakistan….he will unfortunately not live long….
He is an idiot when it comes to history and international relations
"Ye nalaaiqon ka tola hai" . Golden words as always from Shabbar Zaidi. IK is victorious . Allah will reward him, insha Allah.
IK kdr se aa gya hai? IK khud trump uncle k sar peh hai youthiyo open ur eyes now. . . Come out from the darkness of cult and papulism
Zaidi sir, a true gentleman...respect from India 🇮🇳 👏
Ghanta, gentleman! Listen to his opinions on Hindus and you'll change your view.
@@mayank9638 kabhi to mazhab se Bahar ajao ab hum Nikal rahey to tm log is me phans Rahe ho ? Humse aur hamare Haal se hi seekh lo kuch
@@user-sn3ew8zy6r tu apne kaam se kaam rakh na bhai.....humei na sikha kya bolna hai aor kaise sochna hai
Hinduo ki ,.....................................🦵🦶👠🥿👞👢🥾🩴👟👣
@@yogesh41048 tu bhi Apne channel dekh Yahan Kya ghanta Lene Aya hai ? Wo dekh ja ke apna jingoism media ... KUCH BHEEE lol
I got addicted to watching Zaidi saheb's videos. When I don't find any new video, i get panicky.
Me too. And I'm from India. Love the way he talks and I get to learn a bit of Urdu 😅
@@rna1879 09⁰⁰⁰0p0pppp000⁰
شکریہ رفتار حقائق بتانے کےلیے
It is always a treat to watch Zaidi saheb. I have watched all his available videos.
Excellent podcast Allah Shabbar Zaidi Sahab ko sehat wali zindagi ata karay or unky ilm, qabliat, farasat, such goi, jurrat mandi or unki zahanat ko hamesha qaim o daim rakhy
Shabbar zaidi saab Thousands percent right
@raftartv, i will pay to watch the UNCUT version
😂
Few years ago we interviewed Shabbar Zaidi. Later we sat and watched unedited video, he requested to delete his interview which we did. He exposed lots of people and felt that the mafia will use his interview against him.
It's amazing بہت عرصے بعد کوئی پُر مغز پوڈکاسٹ بنا ہے
According to the FBR, the income tax collected from just one of Karachi's ten commercial hubs, the Saddar area, surpasses the tax revenue from entire cities like Lahore, Faisalabad, Sialkot, Wazirabad, and Gujranwala. Yet, Karachi sees not a single rupee of its hard-earned tax revenue in return. No sovereign guarantees for this unfortunate city. Meanwhile, according to WAPDA reports, Lahore alone steals 4 billion units of electricity annually, amounting to around 200 billion rupees in theft, significantly contributing to the circular debt. Despite this, Lahore enjoys heavily subsidized motorways the metros, the Orange Train, and now even a tram. How delightfully fair!
lurdu speaking are best in lies.................
panjab is 65% gdp of pakistan and you think that fsd lahore etc pay less than karachi??
63% taxes of karachi comes from port..............taxes of port paid by panjab....
panjab pay his 95% electric bill..............and lurdu speaking lunluhajir lying and lying do you know 4billion unit??
karachi is responsibility of sindh govt..........................................mgr muhajir knjri ki nsl ne panjabio ka lora chusna hi chusna he......................................................tm bundhajir panjabio k L pr charho.......................................tax sara panjabi memon bihari de or apni ammi ko gela tm kro???
No such report from FBR actually exists. Also do remember that there is a difference in tax collection and tax generation. The taxes of both imports and exports are collected mainly in Karachi. Similarly most headquarters of companies are situated in Karachi and taxes for the whole revenue from Pakistan is collected via Karachi.
Who spends on city of mohazirs..😂
@@kawan5851Smh. The staggering amount of ignorance that still exists baffles me. I wish you had even a shred of knowledge about economic matters that would warrant me enlightening you comprehensively.
Great answer by shabbar zaidi, he is telling the truth, and he is showing the way for pakistan
Shabbar sahab real gabbar awaam ki tarjumani krty hain ap Sir Allah pak apko hamesha salamat rakhen ameen
yar bohat Intezzar Karaya jaldi jaldi Bulaya kro Shabbar Uncle ko Great Podcast❤ Good Work Raftaar 👍
بہت انتظار کروایا آپ نے۔
بہت شکریہ ایک نیا پوڈ کاسٹ لانے کیلئے
he is absolutely right - all PTI in parliament , senate, youtube Vloggers who are making money on IK name etc are all against Imran Khan
Very intellectual man👍
Bravo !!!
Keep speaking & spreading the truth.
After sir Abdul Qadeer Khan, Shabbar zaidi sahab is now more respectful in Pakistan
Shabbar bro you are a well intentioned person
Excellent Questions by Anchor
It seems that Mr. Zaidi has nothing left. Very disappointing situation.
He was in FBR for so long and we can not ignore those who failed Pakistan ---- and he is one of them.
No disasters don't just happen, it took years (and those years while Mr. Zaidi was in FBR).
The corrupt Punjab army has truly shown its true colors once again, Dumping these PPP scumbags onto Karachiites purely to reap illicit gains. In a recent move, DHA has ordered 5000 acres of land in Hawks Bay, with Murad Ali Shah directing the revenue board to allocate it. The last clean seashores we enjoyed will now be plagued, transforming into yet another Phase 8-style open sewage drain system. Bravo!
Shabbar Sahab, you have previously discussed Karachi's economic genocide case at the UN in your talks with Ali Zaidi and at the Art Council. I must ask, what are we waiting for? We are long overdue in filing this case at the UN. It has been 50 years since this economic genocide began with that brutal nationalization by a ruthless wadayra, and we have yet to recover. We possess ample irrefutable evidence of persecution. Under the threat of military guns, Karachi is self-sacrificing to sustain an entire nation of parasites and thieves, subsidizing the debauchery in Islamabad, the profligacy in Lahore, and the insatiable greed of the Punjab army. Even the meager funds from the NFC are handed over to the dacoits of interior Sindh. Karachi deserves a dedicated annual allocation of at least 2000 billion from its own tax revenues and should be fully empowered. After all, it is the people of Karachi who truly know how to turn the economy around.
people or bunhajir or bagore of india.................................jb bhag kr pakistan aye the to national investment trust bna kr in bhuke nango ko ghr bna kr diye or kam k lie paisa dia tha panjab ne...........................................................................................karachi is part of sindh ................mgr nmk hram begert lurdu speaking jhut pr jhut pr jhut...........................is k ilava kuch nhi bolega.......................aj bhi karachi ka 70% tax panjabi pathan memon bihari dete he.....................mgr bundhajiro ka rona hi nhi khtm hota..............................randia k parasite pta nhi kis manhos waqt me pak sindh dharti me agye.................................
people or bunhajir or bagore of india.................................jb bhag kr pakistan aye the to national investment trust bna kr in bhuke nango ko ghr bna kr diye or kam k lie paisa dia tha panjab ne...........................................................................................karachi is part of sindh ................mgr nmk hram begert lurdu speaking jhut pr jhut pr jhut...........................is k ilava kuch nhi bolega.......................aj bhi karachi ka 70% tax panjabi pathan memon bihari dete he.....................mgr bundhajiro ka rona hi nhi khtm hota..............................randia k parasite pta nhi kis manhos waqt me pak sindh dharti me agye...................
Karachis should not be part of Sindh… even after being removed as capital, Karachi had to be part of federal territory. Karachi has been hijacked by Sindh vaderas and since they don’t have any stakes in Karachi, so is the current infrastructure, law and order, education and opportunities for locals is worse than most under developed countries
@@Ali47_tech but muhajir want to fight with panjabi and its history fight with panjabi is fatal
@@vantagehistory1813 I don’t think there is any fight between mohajir and punjabi… it’s the establishment which make such rules and laws to discriminate mohajir
What a masterpiece it was thanks raftar for uploading such a brilliant podcast and It's a humble request to please do more podcasts with Sir Shabar Zahidi
THE. REALLY. BIG. MESSAGE. AND. GOOD. MESSAGE. SHABBAR. ZAIDI.
Shabbar zaidi is a great person.
His examples are worth listening to.
Yaar raftaar podcast dekhne ka sirf is liye maza aata hai kiyu k host nalla nahi betha hota... Intellectual conversation hoti hai👍
Excellent ANSWER by SYED
Amazing! One of the few people in Pakistan who speak the truth fearlessly. May Allah keep Shabbar sahab safe and protected. Aameen. 🙏 🤲
The smartphone analogy was too good. 👌
Sir ! Salute to you I am really impressed I used to listen you try to understand you and You are really near to my heart. God bless you because "koi to sach bolta hay " I must say you are socrate of our time.
Thanks for Raftar .. may long live
Highly appreciated for arranging this podcast with Mr Shabber Zaidi...❤❤❤❤❤
Ye Dukan wala example was simply brilliant and also the way dukan can be revived. Felt like a Gujarati business mindset.
Shabbar Zaidi SB is no doubt the field marshal general of the economy of Pakistan!
Good information ❤❤❤❤❤❤
شبر زیدی جیسے سول سوسائٹی کے لوگوں کو آگئے آکر عوام کو شعور و آگاہی دینے کی ضرورت ہے
Yahan nai milay ga....doosray jahan mein milay ga...wat a sarcastic dialogue....hats off....Zaidi
Always love listening to him and it feels like I m listening to my old self
Shabbar Zaidi both acha insan ha
Hemesha sach bolta ha
Engineer hafiz naeem ur rahman sahib very brave great & honest with his honest team. Aashura k ehtaram mein us ny apna Islamabad ka dharna 26 July tak postponed kiya hy.
Brave and honest lands you in jail.
In a 2012 ARY News interview, the then-Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani admitted that Shahbaz Sharif, while arrogantly showcasing the nearly completed Metrobus project, brazenly manipulated the diversion of the CPEC project to Lahore before its final publication, SEC China can confirm this...Seeing the imminent CPEC project, which included the Karachi Brown line train project that would have given Karachi a clear edge over Lahore's Metrobus, he shamelessly made his move to sabotage it.
bundhajir is crying .......cpec start by nawaz.............lurdu speaking are indian bagore.......................shukar kro tm logo ko pakistan me jgah di wrna tm panahgero ko wapis bhejne ka dil krta he.....................................dunia ki gatiya tareen nsl lurdu speaking lunluhajir.........................................
bundhajir is crying .......cpec start by nawaz..gillani have nothing to do with it...........lurdu speaking are in.dian bagore.......................shukar kro tm logo ko pakistan me jgah di wrna tm panahgero ko wapis bhejne ka dil krta he.....................................dunia ki gatiya tareen nsl lurdu speaking lunluhajir..................
My request to Zaidi Saheb is that please discuss the history beginning after the death of Jinnah Sab.
Why Ayub Khan was promoted against the wishes of Jinnah Saheb and first commander in chief of Pakistan.
Why Liaqat Ali Khan did not follow Jinnah Saheb’s instructions.
Who started quota for hiring ( name and date ).
Firing of 360 senior officers of Federal government by Ayub Khan.
Liaqat ali like Bhutto were Pro Left means Pro USSR like Nehru as liaqat was old style politician and knew Congress very well. He like Nehru wanted to Decolonis pakistan in true sense from western imperialists.
Both were removed ...by west. Liaqat also wanted good relations with india that's why he signed Nehru liaqat pact
Interesting questions but debating them is generally useless. Won't solve any issues Pakistan faces right now.
Raftar team
I love you from depth of my heart
Very informative
Solid content
And we love you too bro!
Best part Hazrat Trump ane wale han 😂😂😂😂
شبر صاحب کی ساری باتیں اپنی جگہ صرف یہ بتادیں کہ اگر عمران خان کی حکومت واپس آ جاتی ہے تو وہ مہنگائی اور یہ جو قرض ہے اور اسکو کیسے ختم کرے گی ان مسائل کا حل کیا ہے
@@farrukhsiraj6453 is ka Hal sewaye awam k kesi k pas ni ha ye sare politition aj b stablishment ki pocket ma ha bas awam ko Bewakoof bana rakha ha anti stablishment k beyanye ko Le kar
Absolutely right... about jamat islami
Very Knowledgeable and Informative podcast. Really loved it and as always honourable Mr. Zaidi Shb has enlightened us all with his wisdom and true insight. Big fan sir! May god bless you and protect you. Thank you Raftar for this and hope that there will be more like this to come in future.
Very knowledgeable
Shabbar zaidi you rocks. At least koi to social media pr sach bol raha h. Inki jurat ko salam.
یے ملک امیروں کیلئے بنایا گیا ہے، غریبوں کیلئے تو اس میں کچھ نئی رکھا ہے۰❤
Shabbar Zaidi daheb is just about the only person who is talking sense. God bless him.
The best advice here is ban the vehicles above 1200 CC. It can significantly reduce petroleum consumption. The other advices are also great but, he failed to mention the unnecessary expenses of the government on luxuries, energy, the main problem is that governmeny spend a lot on protocols and privellages
Good point. The government and leadership has to lead the way and show people that it is time to cut back. But I see nobody stepping up....
@@lapampa4296 Yeah unfortunately nobody is serious in solving the country's problems. Everyone is protecting their own interests. Nawaz Shahbaz Zardari all finished but they are still active in making way for their children. Army is worried about their stakes too. They are in every in industry, they are not ready to leave anything behind.
Imran khan being an honest leader can not do anything. And People's power mean shit in this country nobody comes out for their rights. Khan depended a lot on people and they stand with him in elections. But to what gain?
There is no way pakistan can come out of this crisis without a bloody revolution. There is no solution in the current system. Shabbat, Ali zaidi, Ammar, Muzammil and a lot of other economists talk about countless solutions. But these solutions will never be implemented in current scenario.
Can we make the room of the security guard smaller? Qayamat asakti hai but this cannot happen :(
I totally agree with your opinion
SHABBER ZAIDI SHOULD BE TAKEN BY ESTABLISHMENT AS THEIR ADVISOR. ZAIDI IS GENIUS AND THIS COUNTRY DESPERATELY NEED PEOPLE LIKE ZAIDI. 🙏🇨🇦
Very good analogy of security guard 💂♀️ and Nokia phone ☎️ shop salesman 😂😂😂
Zaidi shahab is great person
You are correct but all in vain
Thanx to Raftar for invited to MR Shabbar Zaidi
Loved the conversation
The solution is in fact Islam and the way that works is by individual action, not what others are doing and saying. Qaul and fa'l .
You are brainwashed. I hope you get to come out of the well and get to understand the world.
شہیدوں کی سرزمین چکوال 💝💝
After listening to this podcast, my worries started increasing about the bijli prices and the bills payment
I like the blunt comments of Shabbar zaidi which is based on reality ❤
He is a brave person , not a sycophant.
I can listen shabbar zaidi all day long, how can one person know soo much, please keep bringing him regularly. Respect from India 🇮🇳
Good👍
Exactly he is absolutely right about budget no one says right about budget
Totally agree most of PTI MPAs are coward
Shabbar 👍👍👍
For these Pakistanios the "extension" of Donald Trump also holds so much value.
Everyone is speaking about the problem but not telling solution
Knowledge se bharpoor program. Wonderful
Pakistan wo mulakh hai jo apne logo ka balla nhi sochta hope for the best
Pakistan wo mulakh hai jo sirf Punjabi ka balla sochta hai
@fj7948 superiority complex se grassit punjabi in both sides of border shameful all human are equal i hope the day will come out soon
On interst he's absolutely right
One of the best person. ❤ salute 🫡
Shabir saab is 100% right....
Shabbar Zaidi is King💗👍
the whole podcast is based on 100% reality.
Allah Bless Pakistan 😔😪
Mr. Jinnah in his speech to the Bengalis of East Pakistan proclaimed that the national language of Pakistan will be Urdu and Urdu only. The speech was in English ???
His decision wasn’t wrong . Urdu was the lingua Franca being used by Bengalis Punjabis Pashtuns Sindhis Etc to interact with eachother . Even Bengalis knew it and that’s why they wanted Bengali to be give equal status . They never demanded that Urdu be removed altogether because they too know the importance of Urdu and limitations of Bengali in this regards. People mistake Bengali language movement as Bangladeshi independence movement which it never was. Bangladesh became independent due to economic disparities and subsequent genocide in Bangladesh when mujeeb was refused power . It was never Urdu esp when bangla was declared as the state language along with Urdu
@@msr7373 urdu was never ever lingua franca between bangali panjabi sindhi or pushtun...................british made urdu n hindi from hindustani then in panjab ch wadera have to go heramandi to learn urdu and in kp it was teach by gora even in aligarh urdu teachers was gora
@msr7373 You are missing my point. I was referring to the hypocrisy that Shabbar Zaidi mentioned about FIR being in Urdu, while the order was given in English.
You see, Pakistan, from its inception till today has been a series of hypocrisies.
You are my leader I m with you ❤
Let move
Shabbar has the talent to engage people till the end of the video
Shabbar a straight forward and honest man
For the first time I have such guts in person belonging to Pakistan.
Have you seen complete video.
Pakistan need complete overhaul from grassroot to top.
Need complete system reform in social executive judicial and political and educational reforms.
Took minimum 20 years means jo child aaj born hoga usko ek responsible citizen hone mai take 20 years.
And need to take actions today and the present system has to compromise in that whether they are politician or bureaucrats or military or all people representative or religious person they have to come forward for noble cause.
Agree. Need to throw out the current leadership and build a new one
Faisal Bhai shabbar zaidi is right, Allah will think about it, this is the main reason of downfall of Pakistan because you people before starting any thing leave everything on allah yaar raham karo us pay maat usko hamesha tang karo. Bachay paida khud karo fir bolo allah ki dain . love you God bless you with good health and prosperity.
Totally agree
Yeh unkle bhi Apne time k Kafi mashoor shaksyat hain... Enki chalakiya bhi humne dekhi hain
I would request you to again invite Dr Kaiser Bengali on the show and ask questions on the current economic turmoil
Hal Sirf jamateislami ❤️
Shabbar Ziadi kia baat hai, zabardast
Raftar is one a great raftar to become best podcast channel.
This guy is the undisputed king of dark comedy
Inshallah rafter will be reach top Pakistani subscribers Chanel