Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
The Good And Bad Of Jujutsu Kaisen's Animation
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 июн 2023
- JJK slop JJK slop...
Follow my Instagram - / kannas_ricebowl
Follow my Twitter - / kannas_ricebowl
Check out my animation channel - / @tryingsakuga7339
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research.
#jujutsukaisen #mappa #animation
This channel deserves sooooo much more views
Fr
That is definitely true. Idk why this channel grows so slowly
i agree man
@@assarlannerborn9342yeah but now it's much faster than Before
this channel and -mankoman are S tier animation breakdown channels that deserve so many more views. Their knowledge on the medium is so valuable.
God of high school (july-sep 2020)
Jjk (oct 2020 to march 2021)
Jjk movie (december 2021)
Did the man ever sleep?
He attended the Yuichiro Hayashi school of time bending
@@ProbablyPretentious someone appreciates Hayashi 🤧. Man gets death threats and all but very few people know his worth.
I think the composition and backgrounds suffered greatly because of how detailed the character designs were in the action sequences.Even when I watched jjk for the first time it always had this “choppy” feel to it, and S2 looks like it won’t have that problem.
season 2 is way worse than season 1
@@Sonofdio2019Heck no you tripping
@@Sonofdio2019 could you elaborate more?
tripping@@Sonofdio2019
Really good video highlighting JJK Season 1 pros and cons. Hopefully this can open a lot of more people’s eyes on how much an improvement season 2 instead of saying how the art style is a downgrade for being simpler. I’m really looking forward to Gosso’s directing in action and non action scenes.
It is NOT an improvement.
@@hibiscus5086 what is not improved in season 2? also its really smart to make a decisive decision on a season with 2 episodes out
@@hibiscus5086 It Is NoT aN iMpRoVeMeNt.
@@Noctislolig K 💀 enjoy your new season that looks fan made
@@tater8960I prefer the s1 artstyle it's weird watching their goofy movement
Holy moly, dude, this is some phenomenal script writing. You manage to deliver the criticism, the praise, explanation and trivia without sounding too harsh, too praise-y AND without sounding monotone and boring. Keep it up mate, would love to hear more
I just binged watched 10 of your videos and man, you need more views like bro-
Yo, thanks a lot man🙌🙏
@@ProbablyPretentious collab when
Anytime lol
@@EzQuarthey you're here man. And yes his channel is Really great
@@EzQuartit would be exciting to see a collab of both you guys lol. That will be amazing
something I've always noticed for myself as i watched through JJK was that even though the action scenes were mostly amazing, the casual scenes were more or less dry with really limited character acting. even the baseball game in Ep 21 could have looked much more entertaining with the right approach, or 22 which i personally describe as having the driest character acting.
i do hope Park makes a return for an episode or two in the next season, but i have no doubt that Goshozono will pop off with his creativity.
Great video. This explains why I always thought something looked off about the backgrounds and curses. Regardless, the fight scenes are stunning, which is what matters most.
You summarized very well the failures in the episodes in which I felt that there was something strange, but i did not know how to explain very well.
It's good to know that you still consider that the first season was very good and you have high expectations about S2.
imo director of photography leveled up quite a bit
That's obvious lol
This is why i side-eye people saying the season 2 trailer looks worse lol. The season 2 trailer looks way better already.
Both look fantastic to me but season 2 just seems to improve upon everything
Those people are casuals. Those are the same People who think budget matters in anime
This is why season 2 is such a pleasant visual overhaul
To me, the composting isn't distracting because the choreography is so captivating it can distract from it. I also don't mind the textures on the curses, it gives them an otherworldly feel. That being said they were handled alot better in the movie. still a good and balanced video
Jjk season 1 cour 1 had amazing animation, but cour 2 it was just good composition, the reason for that was because the same animators were also working on god of highschool, I hope sunghoo park does an episode for season 2 😊
Cour two was most definitely stronger than cour one, also God of high school had finished airing before JJK started
@@ProbablyPretentious not really in my opinion, the choreography and fluidity and 3d color composition was way better in cour 1, again it's just my opinion
Bruh you tripping there were few fights in cour 1, cour 2 was full of them and each of them were stronger than the strongest fight in cour 1
How tho? Cour one featured episode 10, which was very mediocre, also episodes like 6 and 8 had very little going on in terms of animation, on the other hand, cour two had strong action sakuga in nearly every episode, also people like Tatsuya Yoshihara joined the team during cour two, also nakayama and goshozono could show off their directorial skills. Cour two was superior in nearly every way
Just Some Guy with a mustache As well.
😂
Idk why your voice is calming
I swear to god, I am glad that I don't know much about animation because all the bads that the PP mentions, I felt none of them😂
It's not about how much you know animation, cause the "bads" that were mentioned are mostly to make the video feel pro and con balanced (since this is a overall video instead of a pro OR con focused video). JJK is a masterfully animated show, so it is natural to feel that there are more positives than negatives. But no matter how you look at it, whats most important is that if you enjoy watching it then it is a W for everyone
@@RayZL90 facts
Are you planning to make a video about what shows to look out for in the next season in terms of production?
I am planning a video like that, although not in terms of production, but rather in terms of everything (which includes the production as well)
Do you think the new season will have the same level of choreography as the first season? I dont know what the new directors has previously worked on, but i know the animation is going to be good, what about the choreography tho 🤔
It will have a different approach yes, Park had a very raw, rough style, don't expect that, the closest example I can think of is chainsaw man episode 8 (also directed by Goshozono) where the combat was still very physical but different. Also, a lot of high profile animators will work on this show, so they'll most likely modify the storyboards as such, there might be some similarities
I see, maybe not park's choreography then, but the creative shots and camera angles should make up for it :p (if those from csm ep 8 were from goshozono)
Don't expect too much from the trailer i think problem will be solved but i can't say for sure fight scene in Vinland saga season 2 was not well animated compare to wit studio.
Hell's paradise looks less detailed animation and too bright for a horror series.
They are definitely picking up too many series.
Jujutsu Kaiden is considered a good anime because it has a well-written and engaging story that explores themes of power, corruption, and the consequences of one's actions. The animation is also of high quality, and the characters are well-developed and likable. Additionally, the show has a good balance of action, drama, and humor. Overall, it is a well-rounded and compelling series that has received critical acclaim from both audiences and critics.
When u have a stack KA team but newbie (or debuting) DoP and art director with a decent schedule the result is jjk S1
So far s2 is looking really good but it will depend on how much they can do with the terrible schedule since they don't have the beast sunghoo park to carry
There is no confirmation of (terrible schedule). We can't be sure about The schedule
@@user-og6pb6dd5p if we only consider the fights they have to animate this season in 8-9 months it's terrible
And so far ig they r currently done with 11-12eps so they still have 12eps of constant fights to animate
@@userK894how do you Know the schedule? It is confirmed? No. The trailer aside from great action and compositing, even had complex storyboards and Character acting. When they obviously need to priorities shibuya arc. You think it's possible for them to do this here? Also JJK is The main IP for mappa. They make sure they aren't gonna fuck this up. Bro 8-9 months is like AOT part 1 schedule with 2 cours💀. This Quality is not possible.
@@user-og6pb6dd5p yeh we don't have any confirmation about the schedule it's all guesses based on how they completed CSM
They can with this team they can give a strong season or movie like jjk0 with a bad to decent schedule but the problem is it's 2 cour with no breaks so it's a shame that with this team they could have achieved a mob psycho like prod if CSM doesn't exist between the movie and s2 but it's manabu we r talking about so both projects will never have sequel without prod problems
Speaking of complex storyboards it will be a miracle if gosso can maintain this throughout the season (it will be a grand debut for him unlike a cinema guy *joke* )
@@userK894 mob psycho 100 production is not possible. First TOHO won't give them that much time and it's 2 cours as you said. Also dosen't mean that CSM can effect JJK a lot. They may just mostly Share big animators than The whole staff (Credits). But i doubt that with this Quality it's a pretty bad or maybe even a bad schedule
the way you break down and summarized every single cuts and mention all the details almost everyone missed shows your hard work very well... why don't you talk about one piece?
He didn't Watched one piece
Jjk s2 is bouta be insane, as an anime only I’m very excited
I wish if you would make a video on Castlevania. Spencer Wan, Sam Deats, Tam Lu, Carrie Lu, Jazz Valkyrie and many more talented animators work.
Amazing content ❤
Overall I'm excited to see what s2 has to offer
I think EP9, 12, 13, 17, 19 and 24 were some of the most memorable and best eps in the entire season, visually as well as narratively.
Overall, season 1 was nearly perfect imo but yes, the art direction was really flawed. Even I noticed the issues the first time I watched it
Didn’t have to call me out like that in the last part of the video damn
:(
Why don't u try breakdown for one piece recent episodes(like 1061&2) I would enjoy to know about how u feel about that animation
bro, do you know MankoMan? i find you very similar to him (in a good way). btw loved your videos on jjk s2. 😄✌
Yes he knows, same with manko
I saw him in mankos comments
@@Mefrius yes
Can you please talk about the animation for, that one fan-made dragon ball animation, Legends a dragon ball tale I think it was called.
I'd love to hear your thoughts on the animation and composition, and overall visuals.
It would also be really interesting because western animation is so different from anime, so it would be cool to see what he thinks.
I just realized, Detailed character design very useful for limited-animation scene, for example, I like Vinland Saga and JoJo (Especially part 5), they using detailed character design and it will give more emotional and tension even it in limited-animation, but at the same time there's cons for detailed character design, it's bad for action sequence, For example, JJK S1 problem, it looks really inconsistent because animator hard to add detail in action sequence.
At the same time, Simple character design are better for action sequence, it really help animator to make it more consistent. but Simple character design make less emotional for limited-animation scene, that's is why I really appreciate when character designer make a simple character design with strong expression. I like improvement that they make on character design in season 2 (and Compositing side ofc)
Hey will you make a video about the animation of one piece? Love your content BTW
Bleach TYBW needs its animation like these fights have been so lackluster so far and a few second good cut can't save it
I see so many people praising tybw and im so confused cuz what tf are you watching it barely has any good animation, especially in cour 2
Hey sir can you please make a video on death note's animation
Personally i think season 2 will look infinitely better. Ok this is off topic but i would like to see a video on fire forces effects animation, i really think its some of the best effects even today, with names like nozomu abe it wasn't exactly a suprise.
I wont lie, I always DID think those parts of the Nanami vs Mahito/Yuji and Todo vs Hanami looked pretty rough, I just never thought about them much because the moments of mediocre/bad animation in Jujutsu Kaisen are always overshadowed by the good/spectacular moments of animation. It's an adaptation that's so well done that people don't even notice highly conspicuous blemishes like these.
Do you plan to make aot content before the finale airs?
I believe JJK 0 movie was improved
Definitely yes
i truly love you man
I have a question: if I read the manga, would you still recommend the anime? It looks pretty good, but there’s only so much time in the day. Like is it better than the manga, because that’s what I hear from most people?
You must, the staff are very talented and very creative
the manga is ugly like there is no point to read the manga instead of watching the anime, the anime is a literal upgrade of the manga lol
@@simplyrohith2163 okay, I’ll at least check out the new season, then maybe come back to season 1.
@@saqenocturne9769 I’m already caught up, so that doesn’t really matter.
@@thomasffrench3639 ? my point was the anime is way better than the manga, and i actually recommend you watching season 1 instead of skipping it, now do whatever you want
jjk season one cgi wasnt that bad tbh, its just super stylized, like they tried to make it fit TOO hard lol
It did looked pretty bad
I had no clue how much lower the animation quality in JJK was until after watching CSM and coming back to it. I still love JJK and don't think it's bad for having less quality. After all, one of my favorite anime ever is Yu Yu Hakusho and that anime is nothing compared to today.
Even if there are underwhelming elements, it was still an entertaining experience and nothing was too off to take me out of the moment imo. I appreciate quality animation but I don't absolutely need it as long as the low moments of quality ruin consistency. The original Tokyo Mew Mew comes to mind; overall a lot was done very well for its time, but there was almost no consistent artstyle to stay on model to and that took away from a lot of potential quality.
Even if JJK has their moments, the artstyle is consistent and I'm incredibly grateful for that.
More JJK! Season 2 is gonna be the best
0:43 Where can I find these animators list in jjk ss1.
Anime news network
Could you do this same vid but for chainsawman please
hes already done countless vids on csm. he said before that if he were to make a video on the cons it would only be like 40 seconds long. a video on pros and cons would basically be the same type of vids he already made on the individual episodes but 40 seconds of criticism. there really isnt much to criticize
How do you know what staff is working on a season or show or a particular seven like it's so accurate 😭🛐
Sakugabooru, Anime news Network.
and MAL
Can you make a video on chotha bheem ? Best anime of your country.
this video is so good. I really like it
Thank you for this content I’ve been feeling crazy trying to explain how unimpressive sunghoo park as a director and his animation is horrible.
Seaon one had a lot of fluid action animation and"sakuga" Secnes, tho i feel like a lot of s2 will be carried by kanada style animation wand direction, what do you feel? Can season 2 overtaken seaspn 1??
Because season 2 has improved in terms of CD and the color grading and the compositing, and do i even have to mention gosso as the director, i mean we've seen a lot of uniquely directed shots in trailwr already, tho sometimes gooso ambition also takes a wacky turn
Not Really. They will use all types of Animation. You can't say it by a short trailer
will you do a black clover movie trailers animation?
You should analyze the animation of Joran the princess of blood and snow
what do you think changed between this and Jujutsu Kaisen 0
The only thing is much better compositing and art direction
01:40 wdym this looks perfectly fine to me
compositing is not good. the colors are terrible and arent appealing to look at. 3d lava spurting out the ground looks very poorly made
Can you make a breakdown of jjk 0 movie as well? The move seems like a better version of season two since it looks a lot more "clean". Is it due to better compositing or something else?
Not Really. First you shouldn't compare a movie to a TV series. Season 2 probably and season 1 had better sakuga Scenes than The movie itself but The compositing and art direction was a huge improvment compared to The first season. But i do think The compositing and art direction will be even better in season 2. Same with The action if at least it has an average schedule
The movie was a better version of season 1.the compositing improved quite a lot the backgrounds were better too.
It's because the movie doesn't use light diffusion filter (aka the tool that makes most modern Anime look like crap if compared to the pre 2010 ones)
@@lorenzorizzi864 1999-2006 anime look way worse than modern anime. What are you talking about?
@@thomasffrench3639 don't tell me that you are one of those people that watch older Anime in a subpar video quality... You wouldn't be the first sadly
Vinland saga
Finally, a video about JJK. I can die now
Day 2 of asking to review FGO Camelot 2 Movies
The animation lacks fluidity which is a job for in-between for better fps
Not always, yea poor in between can make a scene feel choppy, but also poor key frames, and poor timings dictated by the key animator can lead to a choppy final product.
@@ProbablyPretentious yeah, due to that some sequences or actions are hard to follow it feels like you are using a laggy PC.
bhai india mei kaha sey ho?
I hate the new animation of season 2!! Season 1 was great!
I don't hate it but I think season 1 animation style suits Jujutsu Kaisen better.
S2 was way better.
For example
S2 Ep9 has god tier character movement
S2 Ep13 has god tier compositing and choreography
S2 Ep1-5 are god tier in every single way
You are just a dumbass
JJK season 1 had that 90s animation style. Very detailed 2D, but a little dirty looking.
There's not a thing called 90s style tho. It depends on the source Material and who the Character Designer is And other things as well
@@user-og6pb6dd5p There's a clear difference between 90s anime and the anime today. That difference is what I'm talking about.
@@fukun5773 and that is probably cell Animation that you're Talking about. Now it is Digital coloring and compositing. But there's not a certain style
@@user-og6pb6dd5p I would say that you are both right. More shows back in the 90s had art that was more detailed than we have now. Nowadays most art seems more standardized to fit the general anime aesthetic, but for each genre. Battle Shonen tend to have more simple if more human characters like Naruto and Black Clover which was influenced by Dragon Ball. School and Isekai anime tend to take the Shojo eye aesthetic where all the girls have big eyes, the not hot boys have big eyes, and hot dudes have thin eyes, and some girls also have thin eyes. Yu Yu Hakusho and Hunter x Hunter also take from those designs and combine it with shonen. And more adult action shows take the general look of the shojo shows, make the eyes more reasonable and all of the dudes have more thin eyes. This is such a gross generalization, and I’m probably wrong on a lot of it, but it is what I’ve noticed.
But you are right that the source material does determine the art style, and each artist has their own quirks and strengths.
Disagree
No, you are absolutely wrong. Season one was perfect. This is the way should all anime look like. Focus on well detailed characters and action and the crappy insignificant background give extra focus to the important parts. It seems you do not understand what is truly important in a motion picture.
Bruh. The bad compositing and art direction can let down the Quality of sakuga (episode 8 being the main victim). But if those are good, it can let the Animation shine. The other Elements are as important as The Animation is. Also those extra detail on the fabric definitely made the Animation stiffer (when they obviously need to animate them in a TV schedule). The new Designs (not The flashback arc) looks much better and it's not Really different. Just those ugly extra details that season 1 made them stood out in a bad way is gone. It looks pleasing and they can move and express much more. There's no way you said season 1 was perfect. Although tanaka's episode in season 2 as always will have a lot of details on faces, hair and etc..
Then why watch adaptations when you can read the source material? Because 9/10 times, it’s way better written. It’s because visuals are important to the story so should be treated as important.
if what was mentioned in this video isnt what's important in animation, ur basically invalidating the reason why demon slayer and ufotable shows as a whole stand out as the best visually appealing shows. it's because they arent like u and consider good art direction and compositing and combine it with their good animation to put it a step ahead of other good studios who usually ONLY have good animation
Still better than s2
Nahhhh
Not even
S1 was meh
I tell the same thing to everyone who praise jjk but people straight up neglects it.
I wonder why this show have bad animation were Hunter x Hunter a weakly animated show has amazing fight scene and art style too.
After watching gon vs hisoka yuji and todo vs hanami animation was too cheap and sakuga of running sequence and point of impact was ugly.
I am also disappointed with mappa not bringing chainsaw man quality to jujutsu kaisen season 2.
What the hell are you talking about? The problem with JJK is art direction and compositing, not the animation itself. The Gon vs Hisoka really is well animated, but overall, JJK tops HxH in that aspect, it has more consistently good animated fights while HxH still has mostly still fights.
And JJK S2 literally looks better than S1 already lmao
Did you compare it
Just go and watch it
Have you seen yuji's run in hanami fight scene over the tree trunk .
Running animation was in an odd position compared to the background there is so many scene in The fight that are badly animated
Or has this guy said thats the style they chose to animate