Was I Wrong About Seiko 5? (5KX vs SKX)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 окт 2024

Комментарии • 112

  • @turnbasedtoddy7664
    @turnbasedtoddy7664 11 месяцев назад +46

    That’s not a 5KX that’s a dresskx. I love both watches, but it’s kind of a weird comparison. The actual 5KX would have been a better comparison.

    • @KnightOwl1881
      @KnightOwl1881 11 месяцев назад

      He says that several times…

  • @dns711
    @dns711 11 месяцев назад +5

    I am wearing a Seiko SKX aa I type this. I couldn't stand having to shake the watch to give it power, so I midded it with a Seiko NH35. While I had it apart, I installed a sapphire crystal.
    I have plenty of ISO rated dive watches. What I like about the 5KX watches is being able to wind them without unthreading the crown. Since they have 100 meter water resistance, I swim with them without worrying.

  • @marvean2519
    @marvean2519 11 месяцев назад +38

    I personnally don't like the 5kx dive style model. The dresskx on the other hand, pure beauty.

    • @mistadopeman
      @mistadopeman 11 месяцев назад +1

      They’re just big. I wish Seiko would ditch the see through case backs. It makes them thicker. At least give us a few affordable watches without it. They just wanna price people out of small stuff. It’s petty.

    • @H0kram
      @H0kram 11 месяцев назад +1

      ​@@mistadopemanFinally 😂
      I 100% agree. I would advise anybody to not believe the online hype and go check them out in boutiques.
      Every youtuber and their aunts advertise them as a huge deal, so classy etc. Nah. They're big, they're a bit weird, to each his own but there isn't anything that special about them.
      Oh and for that matter, the seller told me he wouldn't ever give me a discount on it because Seiko harrass them when they give discounts, so they just gave up. " Just as we gave up on checking their misaligned bezels " he added. Can't argue with that.
      I have no hate towards Seiko, quite the opposite, I keep looking for opportunities with that brand.

    • @nerychristian
      @nerychristian 11 месяцев назад +4

      Yeah, I hate that Seiko 5 logo. Looks hideous. I don't know why Seiko got rid of the SKX like. Same with the SARB line of watches. Those were the most popular watch models under $500

  • @thetattedpharmacist3215
    @thetattedpharmacist3215 11 месяцев назад +16

    You probably should’ve done the actual 5KX instead of this DressKX…. Would’ve been a more comparable review…

  • @waynesellers4078
    @waynesellers4078 11 месяцев назад +12

    As someone who didn't get into the hobby with an skx, I find it very difficult to pick a skx over the 5kx/dresskx. Obviously no one likes a price hike but purely on the specs I would pick the modern version every time.

    • @Jon-nz3dm
      @Jon-nz3dm 11 месяцев назад +2

      Surely the 200m water resistance is important even if it never gets wet, right?
      But seriously, it is a better watch overall I think. If the 5kx models didn't have that horrible font "automatic" then I would probably own multiples. It just looks so silly.

    • @Jon-nz3dm
      @Jon-nz3dm 11 месяцев назад +3

      @@stefanstankovic9006 I was joking, hence the "even if it never gets wet" and "but seriously". Yes, 100m is more than enough. The SKX only still talked about because of nostalgia and a first-love effect.

  • @drbobsnightmare2521
    @drbobsnightmare2521 11 месяцев назад +13

    Seiko would literally die if they put sapphire and a threaded crown on this watch.

  • @dank5015
    @dank5015 11 месяцев назад +17

    Congrats, you managed to find one that looks nothing like the SKX to compare it to.

    • @dblh84
      @dblh84 11 месяцев назад +1

      Yeah, that's pretty annoying - to say the least.

    • @thetimeteller
      @thetimeteller  11 месяцев назад

      ^🤣🤣🤣

    • @dank5015
      @dank5015 11 месяцев назад

      ​@@thetimetellerPlease compare it to a Seiko 5 sports. Since most of us don't wear these daily being able to stop the time while setting it is a big deal.

  • @robertsanchez2358
    @robertsanchez2358 11 месяцев назад +18

    Put the DressKX on a Strapcode bracelet, and you can argue it's a perfect watch for someone who doesn't want to get too financially deep into the hobby-but who wants something that looks nice in the office, on a date, or hanging out. It also has Seiko quality, gets respect from other watch enthusiasts, and pretty much fits everyone.

  • @onewatchjustisntenough
    @onewatchjustisntenough 11 месяцев назад +12

    What happened to your channel. I feel like you have transitioned into something different. Honestly I don't enjoy your reviews as much as I used to. Whatever it is you're going through I hope the old you will be back

  • @justinebodlak1373
    @justinebodlak1373 11 месяцев назад +5

    This is a 'DressKX' so it is smaller but the 5KX is 42.5mm in diameter and 46mm lug to lug, so much more like the SKX. Not a useful comparison, I think. Nice looking watches.

  • @valengreymoon5623
    @valengreymoon5623 11 месяцев назад +14

    If Citizen could put the upgraded Miyota 8204 hand-wind / hack movement in their venerable NY0040, upping the game, I don't see why Seiko couldn't have just dropped the 4R-36 in the SKX, and kept it going, of course, at a slightly higher price. Just try to find a BNIB SKX J-model for under $500 now.

    • @Anirossa
      @Anirossa 10 месяцев назад

      Would hurt them in cannibalising their more expensive models, as people would see no reason in spending the extra money. Why they needed to make their entry level worse value, so they can heighten their prices. It works, so good business moves, though also anti consumer.

  • @melonmate4482
    @melonmate4482 11 месяцев назад +3

    I got the SRPE69 as my first automatic/mechanical watch two years ago and it brought me into watches so much. The all black dial was tacticool and stylish when I got it, not realizing I effectively chose to make this a daytime only watch by doing so. Honestly still love it despite what I know now since it did mark the start of a new journey for me.

  • @benfugerer5734
    @benfugerer5734 11 месяцев назад +1

    The 5KX was not supposed to be a replacement for the SKX. It is it's own thing. Comparing the two and being harsh on it is unfair in my opinion. The 5KX is in its own group of watches. The SKX is in its own group of watches.

  • @X85283
    @X85283 11 месяцев назад +2

    What was the actual MSRP on an SKX? $150 was a very good "street price" but the new ones can also be found for well below MSRP as well...
    Let's also keep in mind that $150 in 2015 is $200 today and $190 (a more common price according to articles from 2015) is $250.

  • @RussellAmpofo
    @RussellAmpofo 11 месяцев назад +2

    I’ve never though that this, or similar lines of Seiko, were the intended replacement for the SKX. I think the turtle is more like the modern-day version of the classic SKX. Seiko just need to come out and say it.
    By saying nothing, they are also paving the way to re-issue the SKX in the future.

  • @cartoonpete407
    @cartoonpete407 11 месяцев назад +2

    Long live the SKX007! I still hv my Made-In-Japan one and loving it!

  • @rangersmith4652
    @rangersmith4652 11 месяцев назад +2

    The watch I bought when I decided to buy my first automatic (after discovering my grandfather's Doxa and my father's Zodiac and being bitten by the bug) was a Seiko 5: specifically, an SNK805. 7S26 movement, of course. The price was $99. Besides an early 80s quartz dress watch, this remains my only Seiko. I've never had an SKX, and now that prices are silly, I suppose I never will. I do have a Citizen EcoDrive Promaster BN0150-28E, also a 200M ISO rated diver, and a better watch in every way than the much-loved SKX.

  • @roninpride
    @roninpride 11 месяцев назад +4

    You can always get an Orient.

  • @a_z.tazzzfan8497
    @a_z.tazzzfan8497 11 месяцев назад +2

    I tried to give the 5KX a chance.🤔 I bought the SRPE60. Aside from sizing the bracelet to my wrist; I never wore it.😶 Six months later, I sold it.😒

  • @zwerko
    @zwerko 11 месяцев назад +3

    I'd take an Orient Kamasu 2 over any sub-$1000 diver from Seiko (and I did), including the SKX.

  • @martinpankov2736
    @martinpankov2736 11 месяцев назад +2

    You won't have a misaligned bezel if there is no bezel ! 😂😂😂

  • @ewxlt
    @ewxlt 11 месяцев назад +2

    I have an SRP 777, which I love, very similar to the SKX. Bought the same street style watch because it was all black and thought it would be similar. Returned it immediately. just didn’t feel close in quality or performance.

  • @ChrisM752
    @ChrisM752 11 месяцев назад

    I purchased a used SKX007, the warranty card is stamped from The Time Teller in 2017. Had the 009 for years as well, great watches and value before the increase in used prices.

  • @warrenrhinerson6373
    @warrenrhinerson6373 11 месяцев назад

    The 5KX was my first automatic watch. Unfortunately it was destroyed during an eviction. Planning on getting a replacement

  • @inlandwatchreviews5745
    @inlandwatchreviews5745 11 месяцев назад +2

    in 2005 I paid $125 for my skx173 , big money in those days.

  • @unclekrconzh85
    @unclekrconzh85 11 месяцев назад

    Got mine in November of 2021. The Seiko 5 SRPD55. I wear it almost every day. I can’t swim, so the 100m WR is perfect for me, just for handwashing. But the prices are rediculous nowdays. I got mine for 278€, which was around 299$. Recently saw one in a local watch shop for 340€, which is 363,8$. That’s too much.

  • @christianaviles2199
    @christianaviles2199 11 месяцев назад +5

    The 5KX is a great beginners watch. But it's a consumer watch vs the SKX which is an actual tool watch. I get the controversy in that they "look" like the same watch. They both serve their respective purposes well enough.
    I guess maybe Seiko knew that they couldn't keep the SKX in the affordable range? And since so many saw it as entry level watch...they decided that was more important vs the true "Driver's" capabilities. Easier to sell entry level watch than a ISO Certified Diver.
    Hopefully one day Seiko gives us the SKX re- release with a sapphire upgrade and the obvious movement upgrade...maybe even 6R?

    • @Dirtywesterner
      @Dirtywesterner 11 месяцев назад

      Seiko’s disregard for the preferences of their customer base is legendary lol

    • @dblh84
      @dblh84 11 месяцев назад

      That seems like the logical thing to do (that would absolutely be great); sadly, SEIKO has a rich history of defying logic and alignment.

  • @mannyfernandez1713
    @mannyfernandez1713 11 месяцев назад +2

    You should give the gmt a try

  • @kyledriscollmusic
    @kyledriscollmusic 11 месяцев назад

    the background music was very inspiring

  • @daletaylorjr.4786
    @daletaylorjr.4786 11 месяцев назад +1

    I have the SKX 007 and 009. I find myself not wearing them as often for its intended purpose because they are discontinued.

    • @winstonlanda7731
      @winstonlanda7731 11 месяцев назад +5

      I wear my SKX007 daily because fuck it. But also I know that, with the except of the dial, parts for the SKX are plentiful. Beat it to hell. It can take it. 5 years of daily SKX use can attest to that.

  • @fndrr42
    @fndrr42 11 месяцев назад

    I agree - if they just put a threaded crown on it I would probably have 4 of them.

  • @barrettwbenton
    @barrettwbenton 11 месяцев назад

    Okay: I truly get how some folks hacked a hairball when the SKX disappeared and the "5KX" showed up sometime later, but I think more than a bit of the hostility is a tad misplaced: other than the desire for street-cred, the lack of ISO certification is a non-issue for all but a fraction of the people buying the things, a fact that likely wasn't lost on Seiko: said certification isn't particularly cheap to achieve, so the decision was made to swap that for something with broader appeal, like...a movement that hacks and hand-winds. (Yes, people moaned about the lack of this in the SKX...short memories, maybe?) Meanwhile, anyone truly in need of a watch with all the proper diver's bonafides can snag a Prospex Turtle for well under $400...and if that still seems a tad steep: whats the going rate for a clean, used SKX right now?

  • @kodiakc6227
    @kodiakc6227 11 месяцев назад +1

    Instead of either of these, i settled for an Orient Ray 2. Must say Im quite happy 😊

  • @mistadopeman
    @mistadopeman 11 месяцев назад +1

    Funny thing is, even if you put a watch in a winder, it will still need to be adjusted every couple weeks. I adjust my watches quite often. Maybe that’s just me. And if you don’t have hacking, if you know what you’re doing, you can finagle the second hand to get it where ya want.

  • @beberforumer9715
    @beberforumer9715 11 месяцев назад

    i love my sea urchin. there is also a lot of chinese skx homage out there with nh35, saphire and cermaic bezel for affordable price. who needs the 5kx?

  • @topg2820
    @topg2820 11 месяцев назад

    5KX is good for new watch collectors, but for us old bois the SKX still got that soul which the former doesn't seem to quite have even though it's refined in every way

  • @peterkalos6271
    @peterkalos6271 11 месяцев назад

    I’d give up 100M of water resistance for the upgraded 4R movement which is better thay 7S26. More people prefer an upgraded movement over 100M of water resistances. And as far the price there are many factors…partly inflation, and the other part was seikos we’re being sold but gray market vendors buying from Japan.

  • @msmith9698
    @msmith9698 11 месяцев назад

    I love my SRPG27 except the bracelet is awful. Big downgrade from my SKX. Are all 5KX bracelets this bad?

  • @winstonlanda7731
    @winstonlanda7731 11 месяцев назад

    Ayo Jory, let's get you my Citizen Ana-Digi Temp on your wrist for the lols.
    Seriously though I'm about to pull the trigger on hmthe Seiko 7548-7000, that's the quartz SKX. It's about $330 altogether but maaaaan I really think that's the move right now. What do you think?

  • @SmurfPerfect
    @SmurfPerfect 11 месяцев назад

    Always have to remind myself that you didn’t invent time. Thankfully, your very humble outro clarified that.

  • @plantemichel
    @plantemichel 11 месяцев назад

    Nice video Jory 😃

  • @t0rnt0pieces
    @t0rnt0pieces 11 месяцев назад +1

    Are there any other watches that have crown guards with a push-pull crown? Seems kind of silly.

  • @martintanz9098
    @martintanz9098 11 месяцев назад

    We all know of some guy who bought a Rolex for $300 in 1968, or whatever. Those days are over. Fortunately, plenty of Seiko divers that compete with the skx available new or used for $200 to $400.
    Tge 5kx is a great value at $150 to $200.

  • @sukyvirk2289
    @sukyvirk2289 11 месяцев назад

    Never understood why Seiko put the lume on the second hand on the "wrong" side... Please make it make sense !

  • @67NewEngland
    @67NewEngland 11 месяцев назад

    -$315 for that dress-KX is just ok in light of the fact I got a micro brand field watch in titanium case, NH38 movement, 100m water resist, sapphire crystal, signed rubber strap, screw down signed crown for same price. Seiko could have easily put a sapphire crystal on the new 5 KX series without a big price increase. They just chose not to because it will conflict with their elevating price scale towards Prospex .

  • @harkonen1000000
    @harkonen1000000 11 месяцев назад

    SKX is quintessential '90s grunge technology.

  • @Mat-sz9hs
    @Mat-sz9hs 2 месяца назад

    The rotor in my dresskx is a bit loud, is it normal? I checked and is not loose

  • @caerphoto
    @caerphoto 11 месяцев назад

    The 'street style' thing has nothing to do with the bezel; it's entirely about the colourway. In fact that specific DressKX is the *only* one in the 'street style' collection without a bezel.

  • @JS-ev4xc
    @JS-ev4xc 11 месяцев назад

    Indeed, it was like doomsday when SKX was discontinued. What is Seiko thinking? Even Casio knows you cannot stop producing legendary models, that is why F-91W and Square G-Shock are still going strong.

  • @mantissebastian1122
    @mantissebastian1122 11 месяцев назад

    The lack of the screw down crown really bothers me. Sure it’s rated to 100+ meters but I do not trust that overtime. Seems like a really lame way to cut corners. I do dive and spearfish and swim and surf with my watches regularly.

  • @MrBacchus18
    @MrBacchus18 11 месяцев назад

    Any excuse to talk about the Skx is fine with me. It was easy to buy them for $150 but msrp was around $499 if I remember right.

  • @orangeyellow-me1pz
    @orangeyellow-me1pz 11 месяцев назад

    I have a Seiko 5 sports. I only got it because it looked cool to me and was the Chun Li edition. I liked it because of that and paid the damned premium for it. I don't care for a name brand most of the time which is why I prefer to get the Aliexpress homages. They have the look but you get far more for your money. The SKX looks great but my addiesdive gives me sapphire and has everything else for $60. Seiko needs to give us sapphire and a screw-down crown if they're going to ask for over $200. I'd get it over the homage if it had these. I tried the Orient Mako II route and regretted it because the crystal broke easily. My Invictas are far tougher. The kicker is that my pro diver and Technomarine cost me only $60 as well.

  • @trevormekelburg3773
    @trevormekelburg3773 11 месяцев назад +3

    Next video will be how the Alpinist is the worst watch ever.

  • @dukes70
    @dukes70 11 месяцев назад

    Bad comparison, should have chosen the 5KX dive. I personally do not like the 5KX but if they get new people into the watch hobby/enthusiast that’s a good thing!

  • @antyvirusuk8056
    @antyvirusuk8056 11 месяцев назад

    I mean, if you want an SKX today, buy a kamasu.
    I think the 5kx would be LESS, of an issue if they just called it a sports watch instead of a "dive style" watch. Also, way too much cash money

  • @dblh84
    @dblh84 11 месяцев назад

    Jory removing that shmutz from his desk for $200 tells me all I need to know.

  • @gotsouced4943
    @gotsouced4943 11 месяцев назад

    I have not seen a real review of the san martin SN0120 military chronograph. I bought for 120$ but right now 100. It's my favorite watch right now. For the price the lume and build are better then others.

  • @jussipseppala
    @jussipseppala 11 месяцев назад

    Like many already stated, that is a weird comparison. There are all the SRPD models that are almost like the SKX. 22mm lugs and other dimensions. That dresskx is just nothing like the SKX.

    • @thetimeteller
      @thetimeteller  11 месяцев назад

      I have access to what I have access to, my man. Hopefully I can get another one in the office soon!

  • @matthewbessey681
    @matthewbessey681 11 месяцев назад

    Nice Segway there ! 😂 ⌚️🔧

  • @BradReiter
    @BradReiter 11 месяцев назад

    Are those hands gold tone or is that the lighting?

  • @edwardsjohnpaul
    @edwardsjohnpaul 11 месяцев назад

    Am I the only one thinking the Casio SGW-100 at the start... is the best watch in this video?

  • @X85283
    @X85283 11 месяцев назад +1

    Lol what even makes the 7S26 a "great movement"?
    Nothing. It isn't anywhere near the best in its price range in any area at all lol.

  • @fubaralakbar6800
    @fubaralakbar6800 11 месяцев назад

    Casio did the same thing to the Duro.

  • @rtime4269
    @rtime4269 11 месяцев назад +2

    Wearing my skx013 right now. Still a hard pass on the new seiko 5 range.I would honestly rather pick up used SARB035 or 065 since I missed out on those.

    • @JeeGee114
      @JeeGee114 11 месяцев назад +1

      Pick up the 35. You won't be disappointed.

  • @matthewpasqua4804
    @matthewpasqua4804 5 месяцев назад

    Omg even the spring bars look weak!!! 😢

  • @vanveenmatt
    @vanveenmatt 11 месяцев назад +1

    A non hackable movement is a deal-breaker in my opinion. I like to be able to set my watches precisely to the second. I'd give up 100 m of water resistance to have a hackable movement. I don't know why they got rid of the screw down crown though. They certainly could have kept that.

  • @butnugit
    @butnugit 11 месяцев назад

    I like your channel, your humor, and your strong opinions (even if I don't agree with them all), but HOW IN THE FUCK do YOU not know that this is a DressKX, and not a 5KX?

  • @laurentgagne892
    @laurentgagne892 11 месяцев назад

    how can you read a blacked out watch?????

  • @terratenientesalgo2511
    @terratenientesalgo2511 11 месяцев назад

    (haven't seen the video yet) i just want to say that i wish i was financially capable during the spec monster era, now all the watches i want are discontinued and severely jacked up in price and now all i get is the equivalent of a Chinese knock off.

    • @terratenientesalgo2511
      @terratenientesalgo2511 11 месяцев назад

      my current job demands to be time precise and is not very good pay yet quite physical and i can end up in all kind of scenarios and weather, so i ended up buying chinese spec monster homage of watches that are no longer affordable for the role i need them for.

  • @gotsouced4943
    @gotsouced4943 11 месяцев назад

    200.00 is what it should sell for especially with the lumes not very good

  • @LuisMiguelToscano
    @LuisMiguelToscano 11 месяцев назад

    I can’t concentrate on what you’re saying because of the background music. It’s super distracting.

  • @EricMiller
    @EricMiller 11 месяцев назад

    BUDDY, YOUR LINK DOES NOT WORK

    • @thetimeteller
      @thetimeteller  11 месяцев назад

      It was already sold!!

    • @dblh84
      @dblh84 11 месяцев назад

      ​@@thetimeteller Shocking.🙄

  • @csongormartonszutorisz-szu3999
    @csongormartonszutorisz-szu3999 11 месяцев назад +2

    Apples oranges

  • @deanspeer1
    @deanspeer1 11 месяцев назад

    It's a good gateway watch.

  • @robertschriek1353
    @robertschriek1353 11 месяцев назад

    softlex ... I just don't want that on a watch. on my personal skx it has not proven durable.

  • @antyvirusuk8056
    @antyvirusuk8056 11 месяцев назад

    ... Did you get this 5KX just for the 69 ref number?

  • @matthewhunter5999
    @matthewhunter5999 11 месяцев назад +1

    Oh my, what is that weird background music.

    • @dblh84
      @dblh84 11 месяцев назад

      Horrible - not sure what compelled him to torture us with creepy nursery music, here.

  • @KRW628
    @KRW628 11 месяцев назад

    The SKX wasn't my first "real"watch, it was my last (two years ago). I'm wearing it now. I like the 007 so much, I'm buying another one tomorrow. (I'll wear it on the rubber for a while). The 5KX is for newbies who don't know what they're missing.

  • @dblh84
    @dblh84 11 месяцев назад

    I'm in complete agreement with you, Jory. It’s maddening beyond words that SEIKO discontinued our beloved SKXs and I'll always hate all things 5KX for the exact same reasons you've covered ad infinitum. It’s always good seeing your remarkably clean SKX, btw.

  • @TheSleepLes
    @TheSleepLes 11 месяцев назад

    $40 Timex with a Seiko name on it.

  • @ivanmirones9220
    @ivanmirones9220 11 месяцев назад

    Sell it and get the SRPD 79k1

  • @scarredhandsreviews
    @scarredhandsreviews 11 месяцев назад +3

    No.. you never wrong.

  • @TheRealAlPhil
    @TheRealAlPhil 11 месяцев назад

    Nice

  • @garyd599
    @garyd599 11 месяцев назад

    One is a dive watch. The other isn't. Period.

  • @dblh84
    @dblh84 11 месяцев назад

    SEIKO turned the SKX into a beta.

  • @jorge32421
    @jorge32421 11 месяцев назад

    i got rid of my 5kx

  • @newgunguy4176
    @newgunguy4176 11 месяцев назад +4

    SKX007 is a real watch. 5KX is a toy. End of fucking story. You weren't harsh. Seiko is selling us less for more money.

  • @АзатЕникеев-й1б
    @АзатЕникеев-й1б 11 месяцев назад

    Nein!

  • @drdesign6886
    @drdesign6886 11 месяцев назад

    Weird

  • @miked2662
    @miked2662 11 месяцев назад

    Nice