Disappearance of Flight 370 | Mental Health & Personality
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 сен 2020
- This video answers the questions: Can I analyze the disappearance of Malaysia Flight 370 (MH370)? Did mental health factors play a role in the disappearance?
Support Dr. Grande on Patreon: / drgrande
American Psychiatric Association. (2013). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (5th ed.). Arlington, VA: Author.
www.usatoday.com/story/news/n...
www.nytimes.com/2016/06/19/fa...
www.independent.co.uk/news/wo...
www.theatlantic.com/magazine/...
www.travelandleisure.com/trav...
Would you like to listen to my content in podcast form? With my partners at Ars Longa Media, we released True Crime Psychology and Personality: Narcissism, Psychopathy and the Minds of Dangerous Criminals. Subscribe to it anywhere you listen to podcasts.
I'm looking forward to putting more of my content into audio and developing new, original podcasts on mental health topics. Visit us online, and feel free to reach out with your questions or ideas by going to arslonga.media.
Dr. Grande’s True Crime Psychology and Personality podcast: www.arslonga.media
Check out Dr. Grande’s merchandise at: teespring.com/stores/dr-grand...
When you’re so smart you can analyze the health and personality of a plane
Lmao
@@maxshabazz1543 Careful, he's only speculating about what COULD be going on with a plane like MH370.
Or helicopters. Budgie the Helicopter could be a good choice 😸
Michael Felix oh crap you’re right
“The most likely explanation is that *humans* caused the disappearance.” I agree, but I think the second most likely cause is a complete toss up between “aliens” and “dogs with antisocial personality disorder.”
I am a retired Captain
I have always felt the weakness of airline safety is the mental health of the pilots
That makes three disasters recently caused by pilot mental health
He probably asked the first officer to go back and get a coffee then locked him out of the cockpit
The problem is the F/O had no way of forcing entry to get back in
Answer: pilots should have a personal key to re-enter cockpit when locked out by other pilot
This is a sad story. A pilot can become a mass killer easily and instantly. Better mental health services should be available. The job is very stressful and there is a need.
I was a flight attendant for 5 years and in the 5 years I was there I have not still today met so many problematic, depressed, substance abusers people. The job is a ticking time bomb and the truth is the airlines don't want their crew to be depressed so they just hide it. They're not interested in the well-being of their staff because their well-being mean time off work and time is money and money is all they care about. Sad, very sad.
Hi, what if the individual does not voluntarily seek professional help?? Are there mandatory mental health check ups for those that are crew members?? What about all of the people that have contact, in any way shape or form, with the air craft?? Anyone can suffer from depression amongst other mental health issues that may cause them to lash out just like what is proposed to have happened in this instance?? Its freightning to know that this can happen to any flight at any time!!! What, if any, safe guards are in place to help prevent any and all instances of this magnitude??!! Thx for sharing with us.... Be safe everyone!!
The personal key to unlock the door seems like an interesting alternative.
A year after this a Lufthansa flight went down in March 2015. The pilot had become psychotic. He locked the co-pilot out of the cabin and slammed the plane into a mountain at high speed. I think about 158 people were killed. Pilots should be subjected to mental health checks yearly and extensive checks at that. It should be mandatory throughout the global airline industry.
@@dianneedwards4757 It wasn't Lufthansa - it was a Germanwings flight
“Alien lizard people are like the wedding crashes of conspiracy theories.” - Dr. Grande
Quote👏of👏the👏year👏
Dr. Grande, you won the Internet today!
alien lizard people need vacations too lol
A bit of humour goes a long way!
Dr Grande, have you discussed "Humour" yet? I laugh easily at myself and life in general. Still, coming from a Dutch family who went hungry during WW2, I find American "Cream Pie Food Fight" humour not funny.
How much of an individual's sense of humour is nature and how much is from the family influence?
Ash Mot maybe planet earth is their vacay spot 😂
Hysterical!! And with a straight face and compassionate tone of voice! Dr. G great!!!
I love how Dr Grande always comes to the most logically balanced conclusions solely based on the evidence at hand, particularly with difficult subjects 🇬🇧
As Dr. Grande said in the previous video we can’t just fill the unknown with random information.
Agree.
The world needs more figures like him. Logic is taking a beating these days.
You articulated this comment well
Tremendous video Dr Grande!
I completely agree with your conclusion. I remember my father and his fellow pilots talking about the disappearance of MH370. They're all non-commercial pilots so they were merely guessing but they all came to the same conclusion that the disappearance of the aircraft was likely human engineered.
They mentioned something along the lines that whoever was piloting the aircraft had to have a sophisticated knowledge of aircraft to turn off the transponder, fly on the border of neighbouring countries so as to evade ATC as long as possible, know the location of dead spots and fly at variable speeds and altitudes. The aircraft's flight path also wouldn't have been programmed into autopilot. It's incredibly tragic that the pilot would take the lives of the passengers and crew along with his own. Thanks for analyzing this case!
Thanks for your input. It also adds to Dr. Grande's analysis.
Dr. Grande: " As a reminder I'm only speculating what could be happening in a situation like this"
Wendy's employee: " So are you gonna order or not?"
😂😂😂😂🙌
The alien lizards stole the beef
Sir, this is a Wendy's
🤣🤣🤣
LOL
Agree with your assessment. That the captain had done a "dry run" on his computer at home is pretty damning evidence. But what a chickenshit to take 200 strangers with him. Even if you are going to "justify" taking revenge, it makes somewhat more sense to justify taking revenge on someone who actually hurt you, not clueless strangers. He must have been very disturbed.
He wanted to shame his own government, and what better way than single handedly sabotaging a whole national airline. Mission accomplished.
@@BodyOpt naw, he was just a mass murderer who wanted to commit murder and then suicide. If it was about the government, he would of left a clue. Let’s not forget he killed so many innocent people ALL by his own doing.
There was another RUclips video which said he was suffering from depression for years and paranoia. It’s sad he would take the life his own first officer who was just starting life. And this innocent and terrified passengers who had to suffer such a horrible death. He was heartless
@@whitedragoness23
How many hours have you spent looking into this matter?
You honestly think someone would go to such drastic lengths just to kill themselves? My understanding is that he actually DID leave a note, initially it was leaked, and then the officials quickly covered that up. I assure you, he was not "just a mass murderer". It does not fit his character at all. His motive was not the death of innocents. It was death of his government, and it almost worked. He single handedly nearly destroyed the national airline.
@@BodyOpt you stated he left a suicide note, yes he’s a mass murderer because he killed people who were not willing to kill along side with him. He choose to be selfish and kill others! In order to get back at the government he had to kill innocents.
They had nothing to do with his political agenda. He CHOSE to kill them. He commit suicide because he intentionally let the plane run out of fuel or nose dive it or whatever he did. People even clapped for the uni bomber for killing many other innocent as an act against the government.
How does killing people deserve a applause? Why do they have to suffer? And they are just causalities while he’s a hero for murdering them?
Yeah, Todd, I feel confident that your assessment is accurate. It was suicide combined with mass murder, and more likely the captain, rather than the younger pilot, who had much more to live for. What cements it for certain is the flight simulator in the captain's home. Rather than an act of despair, for which you could simply jump off a building, this was an act of anger. Revenge against the airline, his employer, because think of what a mess it would leave for them in terms of legal and financial responsibility. Todd, I think you did a fantastic job of assembling the facts and arriving at what probably did happen. Very good. Thank you again!
Andreas Lubitz, who deliberately crashed Germanwings 9525 suffered from depression, too. I wonder if there is enough monitoring of pilots’ mental health...
YES EXACTLY!!!
Cosima Von Liebenau such a great question!!
Isabel Yes he was. Apparently he was suffering from depression because of some problem with his eye sight, which put his future as a pilot in doubt, and he ripped up his sick notes. What is strange is that the doctor didn’t notify the airline directly. If I were to fail an eye test with an optician, they would be obliged to notify the Driver and Vehicle licensing authority so my driving license can be cancelled. Either the same system doesn’t apply to flight crew, or the doctors stuffed up by not passing on the info, out of incompetence or some miss begotten idea of patient confidentiality. I don’t remember the case that well.
While he was in flight school, Lubitz took several months off due to a serious depressive episode with suicidal tendencies. The school knew about his mental health issues and still allowed him to become a pilot.
L. C. Jesus!
This is such a mystery. It obviously crashed but the Black Box would really help. Once again Dr. Grande picks a fantastic subject!
@@BaronSaturday66 There is a part of the flight path where the plane does a "turn towards" Malaysia. A theory is that this was a "religious homage nod/send off" by the pilot/s.
@@BaronSaturday66 I think a matyrdom would have been made more public. This one is a case of a creep who wanted revenge on others
@@BaronSaturday66 could be part or all of it but there have been other murder-suicide pilots like Germanwings as well. Divorce/stress/loneliness can make people completely lose their minds.
@@musicalneptunian Maybe, also, he could have been trying to fly back to a repair center in Malaysia. I am still not ruling out a possible plane fire and oxygen problem.
@@BaronSaturday66 Next to none, there would almost certainly have been ownership taken by the involved religious organization.
This is one of the creepiest cases ever to me..
I agree. It makes me relieved that I rarely fly anywhere...
I wholeheartedly agree. Just imagine the parents and friends of the passengers. Fuck.. hurts just thinking about it.
Totally.
Callously murdered victims...
Media kept making it seem like a mystery at the time.
VERY obvious that the pilot did it. Not creepy, just sad and an unfortunately predictable response from a 3rd word authoritarian craphole government.
So sad for all those people and their families. Thank you for remembering this event.
Yeah not knowing gotta be the hardest thing
Like my best friend said: Humans are the scariest, because you never know what they're thinking.
I kinda disagree with your friends. Thanks to psychology we can explain human behaviors and predict them in advance. Nothing shocking me anymore.
❤
I grew up in northern and western Canada with lots of exposure to wild life and wild weather etc but the scariest thing when out in the woods was humans!
@@millville then you must not know about David Paulides and CanAm Missing 411. That is the scariest of all.
Trust no one.
As an Alien Lizard Person I can confirm that we had nothing to do with Flight 370
Yes.. 7th to 10th march is mating season we are all too busy.. Doing things!
@@raycarnis9540 Exactly!
😂😂😂
Typical ALP behaviour - deny, deny, deny.
@@finosuilleabhain7781 No.
I didn’t know one of Zaharie’s home computer simulations was a similar flight pattern and running out of fuel over the Indian Ocean. I certainly believe he did it now.
From what I remember of this case, the pattern was a DITCHING (landing over water) in the Indian Ocean! Thats a lot more precise than running out of fuel and indeed very suspicious!
How could you not have heard about that? Have you been hiding on a missing plane with all comms systems off, or something?
@@BodyOpt Could have been done after the fact to make him look guilty.
@@aphoenixrisingII By who? 1. the Malaysian government tried to deny all the time that it was him, a pilot from their national airline. They don't have a motive. 2. when too many people are required for a conspiracy, it cannot work.
It was definitely the captain, 100%. The only people really suggesting otherwise are nut jobs like that female French "journalist". If you read my post below, I've added some key missing details.
the route was taken from automatic metadata from the games engine so its more than likely that the points of interest that illustrated the route were from seperate instances of gaming i.e. the 'route' was created from a combination of other routes over different instances of use. in the official report by the government, they discounted the 'route' as evidence because it was innacurate
My heart breaks for all those passengers and crew and for their families.
Agree.
I remember watching the news and all the families gathering waiting for information it was so sad
I was thinking the same thing.
A distant cousin's husband was on that plane.
Most people I know who died in aircraft crashes were proven to have technical faults within the aircraft 😕
Especially now that I’m hearing the cause of death was suffocation and not a quick crash. That sounds terrible, freaking out so you need more air but there’s less and less with time. It’s terrible
This is one of those tragedies I always had hope would be solved, for the lost souls and for the sake of those poor poor families left behind 😢
There is a black box somewhere...
@@airadaimagery692 , but how long can the remain intact and functional?
Christine Hutchins that is a very good question... All that I know is that they are supposed to be designed to withstand a massive amount of percussion from impact, explosions etc. and to be completely waterproof. But I’m not sure what the tolerance to saltwater is...
@@airadaimagery692 I get the feeling the pilot didn’t want the plane to be discovered and the black box to be recovered as well. If it was then the truth would be put. He didn’t want to admit that he was going to murder his whole plane. Yet he wanted to take others down with him. Maybe he wanted to be remembered as some of those mysterious and lost flights
@@whitedragoness23 I wish that they would start searching for this plane again! This was 2 years ago that I commented on this video, and I forgot what I had said. Lol... But none the less, our technology has been getting better by the day. We have amazing scanning equipment, and mapping software now that could literally scan and map out the entire ocean floor! I guess no one wants to financially back up the project...
I would enjoy your analysis of the alien lizard people mental health. I believe you are correct about the Captain.
I think the Lizards get the most traction because the story has a more interesting plot .
Leona Rose You do have a point. 👍😄
It's one thing to take your own life, but to take hundreds of unwilling people with you is absolutely unforgivable. 😢
Imagine this being the flight that you missed....i hope in my lifetime it gets solved !
Me too
I've seen that film.
Like people missed the Titanic!
I always think of the passenger that posted a pic of MH17 on his social media, with a joking caption: "If it goes missing, this is what it looks like!" Then got shot out of the air by Russians/Ukrainians, depending on who you want to believe.
Charlie Sheen missed his plane that hit world trade center 1.
One piece of data that is particularly convincing for the “the pilot did it” side of things is that the flight path of the 777 took it directly over the pilot’s hometown - complete with a “wing wag” - a side-to-side movement of the aircraft’s wings indicating homage or respect to a place. I’m thoroughly convinced that the pilot is the culprit in this tragedy; whatever his motive, it is horrendous that so many innocent lives were lost, and that their families have been denied the closure of knowing exactly what happened to their loved ones.
Motive was mostly likely two fold - suicidal depression, and political, so it was a symbolic strike at his own government. The captain had attended a court hearing within days prior to the flight, and a politician he closely supported was incarcerated,
@Laura Collins Well put, Laura. I am in full agreement with your analysis. This case is not as mysterious as the media portrayed it.
The primary rule of aviation accident investigation is that absolutely nothing, no matter how unlikely to be causal, is ruled out without investigation. The flip side of this rule is that once every other possible cause has been ruled out, what you have left is almost certainly the cause. The captain did it.
This mystery has driven me insane more than any others. No matter how much I learn, or go over this case, I always am sure it was the Captain. Dr. Grande always has important tidbits that many other people omit when it comes to these cases.
I guess there were no notables on the passenger list, so one of the aviators were the most suspect. Interesting that someone would have taken down that many people and an entire $300m aircraft because his life was in shambles, but stranger things have happened in the world. Thanks for another thought-provoking take on yet another recent human tragedy, Dr. Grande!
I'm amazed suicidal pilots aren't a more common thing. Maybe I'm overestimating the evil in humans lol.
There's the German pilot who ran a plane full of people into a mountain. It does happen.
RemixedVoice kamikaze
He may have felt he no control over events in his life but he knew he had total control over that plane and all in it.
There was some guys on there with trademarks for some kind of new computer chips..
Noticed Doc didn't use the acronym OCEAN .....
may not have enough information... but he didn't use it last time either
I sea what you did there
Dr grande been replaced by one of those lizard people...
The plane needs diagnosing with OCEAN!
@@colonizerthehydrogen5282 he did that even without using the acronym OCEAN.
@@mayettaxtriger436 it was in the ocean...
Dr. Grande is a beast! Churning out content on the daily!
The White House should hire Dr Grande! The best holistic analyst on the planet, Hands Down!!!! , A great bipartisan rep for the good of America.
We admire your brilliant mind, Doc!!
With the current administration, Dr. Grande would be fired in a scaramuchi minute for being logical, rational, and not playing politics.
No, he's just speculating on what could be happening in a situation like this.
@@MsBettyRubble Your TDS is showing.
@@Trumblocity It's true, though.
@@MsBettyRubble Because catering to Muslims is more important than telling it as it is to them.
This makes complete sense to me and is the most logical explanation I’ve heard. It just feels right.
I agree, but tbh I'm yet to see a Dr Grande video where I didn't agree with everything he said, he's just so logical
same I agree
I'm a Malaysian, and the disappearance of this aircraft was such a confusing and heartbreaking experience for many people in Malaysia. Malaysia Airlines is actually one of my favourite international airlines, but the company suffered greatly from losing both MH370 and MH17 that it was very difficult for them to financially recover. And not to forget the reputation of the company was also ruined, I literally heard people that said they don't want to fly with Malaysia Airlines because it is very likely will disappear or get shot down, which is an understandable fear, I don't blame them, but definitely brought an impact to the company's name and made it difficult for them to bounce back. And the amount of conspiracy theories floating around for both MH370 and MH17 definitely did not helped the situation as well.
Extremely interesting. Thank you, Dr. Grande. You brought up a point that I have always wondered about and never been able to understand. I have never understood why a person who wants to commit suicide feels they have to take so many others with them. Your point about it possibly being that the person has no value on his or her own life, and as such no value on any other life was something I had never considered before.
I love the little chuckle that Dr. Grande does to himself before unleashing a good burn.
Dr. Grande is simply amazing. Thank you for explaining this mystery!
The best explanation I've heard too date
fran mellor exactly 👌🏼
As I read the title of the video, I thought to myself, "OoOooOo, Dr Grande, is good. He's going to tell us what the aircraft was thinking, before it dipped out".
This case is so creepy. I came in expecting a more whacky, mysterious idea, then ended up way more sad than I thought I’d be.
Was just about to go to bed🇬🇧 can’t resist it. Got to watch this first.💕
Lynn Williams Same 🇬🇧
Same 🇩🇪
Same here, hello from Italy
Haha same
@@mellano3 hope you and your family are healthy and sade from covid! I was so scared for my older cousins living in lombardy. Now I heard it's moved to the south so I'm now scared for my family still in our ancestral giola del colle. Thankfully none of my family died but quite a few got really sick during the first wave.
I really appreciate your content. I find it very interesting, as I suffer with ptsd and anxiety, I find your voice very calming 😌 thank you Dr.Grande
Amey Garcia-Aviles Drink a bottle of wine a day.
@@DaciaProject no thank you thats Terrible advice. Alcohol is a depressant, and will make matters worse and could end in addiction.
I agree 🎶 no volume creeping!!! Lol
Seems kind of odd the captain even had a desk top flight simulator. Now retired, but when I was flying the last thing I would want to do is fly a desk top simulator on my time off. I'm not alone, I can't think of anybody that I worked with that owned the MS Flight Simulator. Maybe some did, I don't have any official data. I don't even know if it means anything. To me it is just one more odd piece of a puzzle.
I was thinking and wondering myself, questioning why?? Maybe living for the build up and final crescendo? I do find it quite strange also.
Interesting. I am not a pilot (nor do I play one on TV lol) so I would not have this insight! Thank you!
I have zero flight experience- but could it be possible that this wasn’t suicide and that they quickly gained altitude to try to put out a fire?
@@Msteenytinytina The "fire in the electronics bay knocking out wires in a very specific order and making the pilot's behavior look exactly like a suicide mission" theory has several holes. One: Occam's razor says that the simplest explanation for something is the most likely to be correct. If it looks and quacks like a pilot suicide, it's probably a pilot suicide. Two: The satcom equipment TURNED BACK ON after it left Malaysian radar coverage. A fire doesn't reconnect wires. Three: The multiple and numerous pieces of evidence that the pilot was in fact depressed and/ or suffering from personal problems. Four: THE FLIGHT SIMULATOR! People say "where's the suicide note?" Like, dude, IT'S RIGHT IN FRONT OF YOU!
@@Msteenytinytina no way. 100% suicide mission dude.
I agree with your theory, Dr. Grande. Perhaps the officer believed that by killing others, he could get on life for not treating him fairly. Great job being consistent with your uploading schedule, by the way, I don't know how you manage to do it.
Typing mistake: I meant to say "revenge" between "others" and "he."
Mateo's 2020 Politics You can edit your first post.
@@Caperhere the comment won't be hearted by Dr. Grande then, there wouldn't be any point.
He manages to keep his schedule because a bunch of strangers support him on. Patreon so he has nothing else to do.
@@TheMateoFischerShow Just wanted to tell you about the three little dots. If you click on it, there is an option to edit what you've written so you can correct it. Hope that helps. 🙂
Your logical, calm analyses are so refreshing. One of my favorite YT channels🙌
This is a very scary and sad case. I can't imagine how the family and friends of those missing people feel. And why are transponders allowed to be shut off? I never understood that part. Maybe if there's more than one, and they're trying to save power for certain systems at certain moments during the flight, but to be able to completely turn off (any or all) so that no one can keep track of and/or find it...that's just fucking off to me. Thank you for your input on this one, Dr. Grande. Much appreciated.
If the captain committed this atrocity (and I'm only speculating here), he was likely suicidal and wanted his death to be a ''major event,'' but not necessarily for revenge. A similar scenario would be someone who wants to commit ''suicide by cop,'' and plans to take out as many officers as possible before he dies, not because he hates cops, but to make sure his death would be headline news. It does make sense, in a sick sort of way, although the value of notoriety to a dead person is highly debatable. Thanks, Dr. Grande; good analysis as always.
Thank you Dr. Grande for the excellent research you put into these stories. The fact that the captain had a simulator in his home and actually practiced the exact path including running out of fuel convinces me that that's what actually happened to the plane.
My understanding when reflecting on which of the aviators was responsible, is that the First Officer was to be married in a weeks time. I sincerely doubt that HE was the cause of the plane crashing into the ocean. Also, and this information came from a documentary like program on Australian TV, was that the captain "waggled" his wings over Tiawon or the island of his birth if Tiawon is incorrect. This action represents a "goodbye" to that place. The conclusion drawn by one of the Australian Pilot Trainers who had extensive experience in the area of "possible possibilities", (Yes, I know it's a strange way to put it) which did exclude the Lizard People from involvement in this particular situation, believed that the Captain was alive right up till the end and allowed the plane to descend slowly and glide until it finally stopped in an area within 100 kilometers from the area which all prior searches concluded. He stated that the prior searches DID NOT take into consideration that the Captain would have worked out mathematically just how many kilometers he could get out of the plane which was full of jet fuel at take off, but how far he could glide and how far above the ocean he could do this and where latitudally and longtitudally he would sink. I wish I could recall this man's name and I now recall that it was in fact an episode of Australian 60 Minutes, so look it up if you're interested. The Australian expert felt that the pilot DID NOT want the plane found and was at the controls and alive when it sunk. I'm aware of the pieces of the aircraft found in various island beaches, but these did not negate his theory. I can't believe it's been 6 years since this happened and I still see in my head as a distinct memory the Australian mother and son sitting near the front of the plane taking a selfie before take off. They had no idea that they would be dead within the hour! None of them did. RIP you poor souls!
Dr Grande, I would like to contribute my view. I would merge the indifference theory with the revenge theory. I would find it more convincing that the captain is depressed (indifference) and projected it towards others in planning for the crash (revenge). However as to why he chose this way to die I think I can offer something: he had lost everything and the only dignity left for him was his position as an aircraft pilot. In Malaysia this is a substantial prestige, perhaps (just my guess) in his mind he wanted to die with this last bit of dignity left to him. Lastly I pray for the grieving families still out there that they can find closure from this tragedy. 🙏🙏🙏 Please take care.
Agree.✌️
Listening to this a year later than everyone else, but it makes sense. Thinking this pilot/captain was an egomaniac, with a grandiose sense of self-importance, craving admiration but who saw what he perceived as insults from lack of appreciation (especially from younger women) could have driven him to do this. Seems pretty extreme, wonder if he had time to think in a right mind would he take it all back. But then again, it could be mechanical, the lithium battery theory comes to mind. What about that cell call to the co-pilot?
Great analysis as always! Only thing I wish was stressed more was that the government response was so abysmally poor and slow. While I think it is clear that whoever did this was hoping to go undetected as long as possible, thus making the turn right between ATC towers, I wonder how realistic of an expectation it was that the plane would actually get that far completely undetected. To the point that despite the plane disappearing on the radar they didn't notice and then didn't start searching for so long and in the completely wrong place. I dont know that the pilot would have reasonably thought it would become this big of a mystery. That could be why he didn't leave much behind. He may have expected at the very least substantial fuselage would have been found pretty quickly.
The revenge against society theory makes sense. However I think it might also have been the case that he wanted to die but also cover up his suicide to avoid embarrassment or judgment. By dying in a mysterious way he could imagine that his family might think it was an accident or a hijacker or something else other than suicide.
I need doctor Grande to examine Aaliyahs untimely plane tragedy so we can understand
...and drugs.
tina w. Yup
Poppy Fields no
Dr. G. Did the plane go down in your OCEAN? You rock. Keep them coming.
➡️Case Suggestion: The behavior & disappearance of Lars Mittank in Bulgaria
That one is SO WEIRD!!!
K K Yes, absolutely! Idk if he Disappeared because of a brain injury, mental illness, or drugs. Either way it’s so sad
@@Hjortasmr A
The last images of him running through the airport 😢
Yes!!!
K K It’s haunting☹️ do you have a theory?
The Turpin parents/case would be an interesting case to do next! I
Yes, I'd like to see this please
Thank you for the upload, doc! Analyzing the mental and psychological background of this case is interesting because one wouldn’t initially think of those being a factor to explore. This is going to be a great video!
With the revenge angle, could he have also been trying to bring shame and a loss of reputation to his estranged wife? I don't know about Malaysia's culture specifically, but my understanding is that some Asian countries have an honour-shame culture. I wonder if, in their culture, the estranged wife he left behind could expect to shoulder some blame and other social consequences for her estranged husband's actions.
Interesting point
Great point, never thought of that before. But then wouldn't he have left a note saying that he did it in order to make sure she shouldered some of the blame?
If someone is mentally ill it makes perfect sense to use this distorted type of thinking. It's very cruel to punish innocent people.
He wanted to bring shame to the new prime minster who he hated. Politics poisoned his brain
@@mattgrele6318 Then killing everyone else makes a lot more sense.
Good analysis, the best piece I've seen is Australian 60 Minutes where it was theorized that the captain flew over his hometown and gave it a nod.
Can you also do an analysis on the Germanwings Flight 9525 crash in March 2015? (Thanks)
60 Minutes Australia has devoted air time to analyzing the disappearance of Flight 370. (Can be viewed on RUclips). Commentary given was that the captain, once taking control of the craft, did a banking maneuver by Penang ,Malaysia, where he was from, as if he was taking one last look of his home area. I’m sadden that he felt this was his only choice he felt he had to deal with whatever was paining him.
I think your theory about what happened is quite plausible.👍🏼
Dr. Grande, today is Labor Day and I want to give you a special thank you for all the tremendous work that you do. You are probably one of the hardest working man I know. I hope you have an enjoyable and restful day.
Happy Labor Day Dr. Grande! ❤️☀️🍃🌼
Dr. Grande might say; "Labor Day? Uhh...., who on earth invented that? I'm working each day". 😁😁
pocoeagle2 - i think you may be right Ben:)😁😁
An analysis on the type of person to end their life in this manner would be interesting. It is not the first time something like this has happened. I can understand depression and suicidal thoughts, but what personality type decides they have the right to end so many innocent lives in the process of taking their own life. It is also not a spontaneous action of a person who snapped in the moment, but something that was planned in advance.
so mysterious. At least those plane pieces washed up.
Nan, yes very mysterious. I hope so much I'm still around when and if they find the remains.
I'm really glad you covered this. Great analysis as always.
your videos always leave me rewatching them! they offer such an amazing insight into what could have really happened when there isn’t a clear answer. you really helped me understand the elisa lam case especially, that one always creeped me out but now i know more about what behaviors are expected in certain mental illnesses
It would be interesing if you talk about the german flight that crashed due to the pilot being suicidal back in 2015.. Germanwings Flight 9525 according to wikipedia
"It may have been that he removed his own oxygen mask at some point so that he would die before the crash occurred."
I agree with the gist of the video. But people who are committing suicide in such a manner wouldn't chicken out during the last couple of minutes. They would go out with a bang. There was a similar case in Europe a while back. A German pilot crashed a plane into a mountain. He knowingly steered the entire plane into the mountain. People like that do not chicken out and remove oxygen masks, imo.
The German pilot crashed the plane in France.
@@DT-bp2om Agreed.
Like how Jim Jones had hundreds of his followers die by poison, but shot himself.
The idea that 'people like that never chicken out' is over simplification and just opinion based on emotion rather than facts.
Some do take the easier way out for themselves, others don't.
The FACTS are that we have no way of knowing how whoever the last person alive was died because the body was never found.
This is by far the best analysis of this case I have ever heard. Thank you Dr. Grande!
Oh wow, I LOVE that you tackled this topic!! After so much speculation and “what if” scenarios were floated in the media, your analysis is both knowledgeable and logical. Mental health analysis is what has always been lacking in this mystery. THANK YOU!
An exploration of trigger warnings would be of interest to many of us, as a well known Internet phenomenon. Are they really helpful to PTSD sufferers or are they an unnecessary idiosyncrasy of the well-meaning, but misinformed?
@@spiritmatter1553 Maybe they meant scary for the dog?
Personally speaking, I appreciate trigger warnings in that they allow me to make an informed decision about whether to proceed with reading someone's post or watching someone's video. You know: "viewer discretion is advised"? Sometimes one is just not in the right frame of mind to hear about violence (or whatever is linked to their trauma or sets off their anxiety). I suppose I see it as an extension of common courtesy -- despite courtesy becoming less and less common.
I appreciate knowing if any Animal abuse is in a story because it's very hard for me to cope with. I'd rather not read the story if any Animals are hurt. Abuse Survival left me very touchy.
I can’t even begin to think about the kind of person that could do this. Even in ones darkest moments, WHY would you want to kill other people who are happily going about their lives? It makes absolutely no sense to me.
Uhhhhh I think he gave you 2 pretty good reasons.
Doesn't have to make sense, guy was messed up and didn't care.
Maybe he was bitter because others were happily going about their lives, while he wasn't
Could be he’s upset that people do seem to be happily going about their lives or it could be that he sees no point in his life or in existence at all. You can never know what people are thinking in their darkest moments
Your humour and delivery makes me smile every time. I look forward to seeing your posts
thanks for always putting some humored theories in your videos, Dr. G
Excellent video! I clicked on this notification so fast I almost tripped and fell 😂 This case has always made me so uncomfortable and even afraid about our world and society in general. I always put myself in the passengers’ positions and it was probably a good thing that they most likely did not really have any time to figure out what was going on (that their deaths were literally going to happen in a mere few seconds). 😢
I’ve always been a tad scared of flying, and so I especially remember when this tragedy happened; it certainly didn’t help my fears any (it made them worse in fact). I tend to overthink things without looking at them more logically or seek a more rational and reasonable explanation (I am a terrible “scientist” when I try, so it’s such a relief to have people like Dr. G to bring those of us back to reality so to speak, and to help us be more grounded when assessing things like this).
So a huge thanks to you, Dr. Grande, for always helping me to stop, breathe, and take a moment to really think as rationally and as logically as I can (instead of just freaking out right away before I’ve even really studied the facts). Thank you, Dr. G, for being that voice of reason we sometimes all need in life! Being reasonable shouldn’t be this difficult for me, but with some things it just is. Dr. Grande’s video topics always make me look inward at myself too, which I find very beneficial and helpful. ☺️
Final note: I also agree that the Captain was responsible for what happened; one of the reasons I think this is because I have read/heard several articles/other media that the younger First Officer was planning to propose to his gf very, very soon (which obviously doesn’t fit with the whole suicide theory for him).
Fascinating, Dr. GRande and thank you
Dr Grande, another top episode! My absolute favourite thing to watch. Keep up the good work doc. 👌
Another spot-on stellar analysis, Dr. Grande! Thank you.
Not mentioned is the supposition that whoever was flying the plane wanted to create an unsolvable mystery, and would have done just that, except for the hourly satellite electronic handshakes, which gave us at least the likely end area. These handshakes were then relatively unknown even to professional pilots, but not any longer.
As an aviation lover I was really interested to hear your take on this. I am impressed at your research into the world of aviation and feel that you gave a good analysis of what could have been the cause of this tragic story. I agree, that it seems likely that the disaster was due to human interference of piloting such an aircraft. I am not fully aware of when the transponder was turned off but would assume the aircraft was at cruise level and consequently on autopilot. So, I would also assume that the captain took the plane off autopilot in order to take control of flying. Tbh, I cannot imagine the captain coming up with a good enough reason to persuade his FO to leave the cockpit. Again, this could only happen at cruise level as there are many procedures that need to be completed before such time. It's definitely a conundrum of sorts, with many questions remaining unanswered.
1. Why were the Malaysian Aviation Authorities so slow to react and respond?
2. When did the aircraft disappear from radar?
3. When did ATC report something was wrong?
4. When did the aircraft veer off it's flight plan and were ATC immediately concerned?
I realise you probably can't answer the questions, I was merely thinking out loud.
Anyway, great video as per, Doc. Watching those numbers going up and clapping loudly for you. Stay safe!
Dr. Grande is quickly becoming my favorite channel on RUclips!
This tragedy is def one of the sadder ones..so glad you explored this one too👍🏼👏🏼
Holy smokes! I requested this one just days ago. Now that’s what I call service! Thanks, Dr. Grande.
Dr. Grande, thank you so much for your analysis. This case has always been mysterious to me. At least you gave me a very probable explanation.
Thorough and convincing analysis of an incredible case. I did not know about this case. Thank you very much.
Thanks Dr. Grande. You have give the most plausible explanation. I am picking up on your humor.
Hey Dr. Grande, this topic makes me wonder if you could do a video about The Bermuda Triangle - why do so many people believe in this phenomenon, and what do you think is the personality model of people who believe in the paranormal?
👍👍👍 Yes please! Of course there are always those Lizard People...
Annemarie Reis - like Jim Morrison? 😉
@@dotdashdotdash
People are strange
@@myrlewulf6256 ...excellent!
Dr Grande, as per usual, is the man. Such a bad ass.
Wow incredible 👏 analysis Dr. Grande. Appreciate your comments and interesting topics - great channel too ♥️🙏
Good job, good topic. Love your sense of humor
This analysis made me really scared to fly planes now because you never know what kind of mood/psychological disorder the captain might have. My heart goes out to those poor souls and their families.
It pains me for the loved ones left behind.
Another excellent video and I guess it's entirely possible that you investigate another psychological abnormality, that of addiction to the You Tube Channel of Dr. Todd Grande! I'm hooked and feel zombie like mesmerized by your explanations, assumptions, possibilities and probabilities. Well done Dr. G.
De Grande, your analysis makes so much sense. It’s such a tragic loss. If this is true it’s terrible to think someone sees suicide as their only option. But to take innocent people with you is unconscionable
I just discovered Doctor Grande three days ago when revisiting the Jonbenet Ramsey case, which I got to going on a tangent from other unsolved cases, namely MH370. I watched several more of his videos as I love his style. I wondered if he had covered MH370. Then today after watching the Skylar Neese video as it was recommended in my main feed (I have looked into this case also) I went back to Doctor Grande's page to scroll through the video list. Then I see this!!! Crazy timing! Thank you Doctor for your insight and sense of humor sprinkled in. Watching now...
i love the little jokesies dr grande drops while still remaining respectful 🤲
You pick the best topics in here for it 💙
Thank you for any cogent analysis of this strange event - best one heard to date.
I suspect he did leave a note but his family hid it.
You are correct or close. I understand that in the earliest stages, a report WAS released, that he left a suicide note, but shortly after that report, the government said it was a mistake and false information. I gather the government are extremely corrupt, and probably more motivated to avoid shame than discover and declare the truth. So the suicide note, if there was one, may have been jointly covered up by family and government to avoid shame.
Not just the shame. A heck of a lot of money in compensation if the captain can be proven guilty of downing the flight. So i wonder how many politicians have a financial interest in Malaysian airlines?
@@BodyOpt Very interesting if he did leave a suicide note and it was covered up.
That would make complete.
A Malaysian subscriber here. 👏
Excellent analysis. The best so far 👍🏻
Hi Dr. Grande! Thank you again, you give us such insight.
Dr. Grande,
it would be awesome to see you analyze Gemma Barker.
And I wish you were my father.
He looks a little like one of my brothers. Wonder if they would trade families.
You’re not alone.
Todd, Do a video about HH Holmes or Jack The Ripper
H.H.Holmes!! Jack the Ripper is overrated.
Awesome analysis, thanks for sharing your knowledge and the thorough analysis.
Such a great analysis, as usual. Thank you for making sense in such a senseless case. While extremely rare, unfortunately, it still happens - as was the case from 2015, Germanwings Flight 9525 :(