Are Isaac Heeney's Brownlow Medal hopes OVER after off the ball high hit? - Footy Furnace
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 24 июл 2024
- The Footy Furnace panel weighs in on Brownlow contender Isaac Heeney's controversial incident and the Saints' comeback win over the flag favourites.
Watch Footy Classified LIVE every Monday and Wednesday at 8PM (AEST) nationally on 9Now 👉 nine.social/IMZ
Watch Footy Furnace LIVE every Sunday at 8PM (AEST) nationally on 9Now 👉 nine.social/IMX
Subscribe here 👉bit.ly/2mS8v5S
AFL News 👉 wwos.nine.com.au/afl
See Nine’s turbo charged coverage of Australian Rules football with the signing of some big new names, the launch of exciting new programs and the return of familiar favourites.
Our beefed-up footy slate will see previews, reviews and analysis of the AFL with fan favourites like Footy Classified, Sunday Footy Show and more.
Facebook: FootyonNine/
Twitter: FootyonNine
Instagram: footyonnine
TikTok: tiktok.com/@footyonnine
#9WWOS #AFL #FootyOnNine 
Спорт
The presence of Tom Morris on this show physically pains me
AGREE
Then don't watch, just go away.
Why the Tom Morris poo poos?
Imagine dickriding tom morris in RUclips comments
Him and that other flog can go fondle each other
Just Jimmy and Leigh in 2025 on this show
If Jesse Hogan gets off for deliberatly punching a guy in the face well off the ball, then there is no way that Heeney can get suspended for that.
The Tribunral is an absolute joke.
So because they made a bad decision they should make only bad decisions now.
Allllerriiigggghhhttt 😅
@@tin-n-tan Except they have gotten butters off based on that too. They have made the precident that its not a suspension
How many fines has Zak Butters had for incidental high contact? Just wonder if a fine might be justified in this case. He had an HIA & blood nose.. not soft as butters to be fair, but if the player has a good record.. hm.
@@Tosicc567 there are no precedents in the AFL tribunal, it's not a court. They have only repeated this over and over and over that each case is heard on its merits independent from other events.
@@tin-n-tan they have gotten players off based on precedent heaps. Butters last strike got off because hogan did, they argue it all the time
Looks to me as Webster is leaning down already, and Heeney is looking for contact to push off and he turns his head as he has made contact and didn’t realise the damage he has done.
If the AFL has any clue, Heeney will be fined and we move on.
“He had a blood nose”
Just sounds so bitchy 😂😂
"We want to let him off because of the brownlow but people are calling out our corruption more these days"
~Afl house this week.
He should be let off because he hit Webster
I think it’s a week all day
Just an accident . Nothing in it !
McDonald's miss was unfortunate, but the responsibility doesn't lie with just one player. It was a near miss, that looked like it was going through for a goal until the last two seconds. Sydney had 27 scoring shots to St Kilda's 19. And that doesn't include Papley's shot that went out on the full. Their inaccuracy cost Sydney dearly yesterday.
It's a Sydney player so it will be a fine.
So its a conspiracy champ? LOL
If it was daicos up there instead of heeney they would have apologised and bought him a car and caravan
This absurd comment has not aged well champ
@@spasticatadisco9571 Apparently according to the Collinwood lobby the little bloke is the best footballer of all time. So a Brownlow is certainty LOL
nothing in it
Lol. Mmmkay.
@@tin-n-tan I agree with you. Nothing in it.
3 weeks and no brownlow lololololol that's enough punishment 😊
@@user-oi9to7ux7k yep, you can belt a dude in the face and it's cool 😎😂
@@paulkyriakopoulos3444 it was an accident mate
My God , there's nothing to this ! Journalists are judge, jury and executioner these days .
Cannot believe people are actually calling for a suspension here. He's trying to push off his opponent and accidentally slaps him in the face. You can see he immediately turns to apologise which says to me it was accidental not intentional like this knob Tom Morris is going on about. Brandon Zerk-Thatcher did the same thing on Saturday and didn't even get cited, so Heeney has nothing to worry about here. Feel free to tell me to take my red and white goggles off here if I'm wrong.
Well the guidelines are pretty clear that the AFL wants players to take caution when fending/pushing off other players to contest the ball, he may not have meant to hurt him, but he did mean to create separation, and in doing so, he struck another player high, in past years its probably rated as careless, given new guidelines its hard to see how it doesn't rate as intentional high contact and an automatic week. Whether he gets off or not is a different question at tribunal, but in a world where the afl is adamant to do what they can to protect the head, some players are gonna end up on the end of some stiff decisions.
Heeney has got to be suspended at least 3 weeks and no brownlow that's enough punishment 👍
He meant to hit him, it wasn't an accident. It doesn't matter if he didn't mean to hit him in the face, by the rule book it will still count as intentional contact
I’m with you mate. I don’t have any dog in the fight personally, other than as a fan of the game as a whole.
I don’t even consider it a hit. I consider it as “making contact”.
And I don’t agree that it should be prohibited either. Just like I don’t agree that raising your knee into a pack of players while running at 30+ km/h should ever be deemed prohibited contact.
Thug Matthews gone soft in his old age .Shut up and go away "Lethal" .
He also took the mark just inside 50 and the ump put the mark at 40
Heeney was swatting away Websters hands as Webster had both his hands on Heeney’s shorts and guernsey. This is so so silly! I just can’t believe that they are doing this to the poor guy. Heeney was in so much shock that he actually even hit Webster because Webster FELL/LEANED FORWARD!
Jimmy: "I genuinely don't know"
Tom Morris: "So what do you think is gonna take place Jimmy"
Jimmy: "I genuinely don't know Tom"
The tribunal must have no idea what to do as apparently, due to a new interpretation, they now have to grade it as intentional rather than careless when a guy swings his arm around to break a hold and accidentally clips a falling guy in the nose 😂
3:06, I got flashbacks.
A fine for that? Ok fair enough. Week’s suspension? That’s getting a bit hot, but ok, careless I suppose so give a week. But linking a single controversial suspension with out of Brownlow contention completely is beyond f*ed!!! The AFL want the Brownlow to be some new wave kindergarten everyone’s a winner bs.
Has to be a week
Brownlow night goings to be interesting
He won't win regardless, his teammates have taken votes off of him, Sydney's mid is stacked.
It wasn't deliberate as Jimmy was grabbing his jumper & Issac went to knock his arm away as you do. You could tell it was a accident by Heeneys reaction. It should be down graded to accidental. I'm a Saint supporter who has eyes and understands the game & played for 20years unlike it seems the tribunal members.
pies fan here, unfortunately it is a fine only
Deserves a week. But the AFL always look after Sydney, so who knows
Not this time dude AFL must suspend him to send a message to the other players. 3 weeks is right. 😊
@@paulkyriakopoulos3444 Still booing your crying coach champ? How is that going? LOL
@@paulmatters2641 no idea what ya talking about knackers.
@@paulmatters2641 go on I'm waiting who is my coach genius lololololol
@@paulmatters2641 go on I'm waiting who's my coach dude lololololol
Not playing 4 quarter footy again this was their problem last year
If Heeney goes for that honestly the MRO is a joke.
Unfortunately he got banned
@@Charlie58673no way he did
Free kick and that's it. Oh wait..
Typically Victorian response to an incident that other players get off on appeal. Matthews has never liked the Swans....he's a clown. Precedent set with Butters and Hogan....also Cripps the year he won the Brownlow.
No purely because the Port Player who connected with Naughton didn’t have to face any consequences, this is just an over the top media click bait story. Tom Morris need I say more.
I think the swans thought they were in the aflw with those jumpers, what a joke,,,,,,,
Nothing in it
multiple high hits way harder than this havent been suspensions. Hogan, Hewett, butters ect. Its not a suspension based on multiple hits already this year
Whether he meant it or not, he gets a week on the sidelines. Cant have blokes getting punched in the face
whatever the result, he definitely didnt have his colgate game face on
This game has gone stupidly soft, nothing in it. Let's not even talk about the poorly designed swans jersey. Also Jimmy Webster, the same guy that got rubbed out for how long earlier this year? Lol.
No doubt Simkins is distressed by the hit on Jimmy's snoz. LOL
The Swans need a weeks holiday for that Marvin Gaye guernsey. Virtue signaling garbage, The Saints socks as well. LMAO
@@iankearns774 Maybe you should take a longer spell for your homophobia champ. Went out with ankle length boots and Sam Newman.
@@paulmatters2641 It's the sodomite flag -
Could the AFL, the MRO and the AFL tribunal possibly be compared to any other professional sporting organisation on the basis of incompetence. The game is owned and for the fans. As with a large number of other situations and incidents in the game over a number of years now, no fan gives a f..k if Jimmy Webster or any other player, cops a blood nose from unintentional contact to the face by someone trying to stop him from scragging and simply trying to break free to offer a lead to his teammate. It’s a free kick! Maybe we could rule out raising your knee, using your fist to spoil the ball or contest a ruck contest and lord knows whatever else will save a blood nose or a headache or a concussion or a bunch of broken ribs, a punctured lung and a ruptured spleen.
Come on , that was just a love tap . What a politically correct sporting world we live in Now ? Pathetic !
He’ll get off regardless of what he does. Rules are different for Brownlow favourites
Plugger would’ve got 6
It was definitely not intentional.
If he gets reported the whole competition is a joke! It was a clear accident and Zerk Thatcher did the same thing on Saturday and actually concussed Naughton, it’s a contact sport accidents will happen!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Honestly, leave the brown low talks out of this.. Not a fans supporter but i think there was nothing to it.. Just a bit of push n pull, it's a fkin physical game guys
If Mitch Geogeardis gets a week, afraid Heeney should get a week too.
😅 He was not trying to push mate. That was a whack.
he was being scragged, cmon guys, your allowed to push off
Soft incidental contact. A fine at best. Does take much for a nose bleed. Great player feel for him. Saints supporter.
Trial by media
Fire Tom pls. U wont regret it. He’s just gross
Merrett or Cripps will win. Sydney players gonna have their brownlow points yoinked by each other.
Compared to what Cripps did and kept his Brownlow- nothing in it.
yeah true, but the rules have changed a lot since then. if Cripps did something like that this year he would be gone
@@tommytwigglez8314
You would think so.
He's a Sydney academy player. He will get off.
I cannot stand Sydney Swans and don't mind at all if they lose players at the tribunal, however, that is NOT a 1 week suspension. It was soft as hell, the SK player has a "glass nose". 🙂
If it was cripps or don't, the media would be defending him and making sure he gets off
Who is Dont?
@iankearns774 Mate, you're either that stupid, and can't work out a simple autocorrection, and see that the DON'T means BONT, or secondly, you're either that smart, and intellectually intelligent, and superior with your words, that you must work for the grammar CIA, and troll social media to call out any error possible. I understand the skill level and sense to achieve this in life. Well done, champ.
1 week so his chances of a Brownlow are blown.🤣🤣
2 weeks
It’s a week
It’s clearly a suspension but because the afl is a corrupt gambling/entertainment business they will probably let him off due to the brownlow issue. They will have the usual ‘show trial’ to justify it. Rules for some but not others.
How is it clearly a suspension? Webster must be a bleeder as that was a love tap.
I don't know why, if sanctioned, it means ineligible for the Brownlow. If the sanction is 1+ game suspension, then that is game/s in which Brownlow votes won't be awarded to the guilty party. To me, with suspensions, the Brownlow is self-managing. If the sanction is just a fine, then don't know. Maybe a sliding scale where every $1000 cops a -1 Brownlow vote ?
He is a flog and deserves a week for that jumper and haircut alone. Yeah lethal...you do these things....I was at the Geelong game when you hit Bruns....the most gutless act I ever saw in the game....followed closely by Michael Long flattening Simmonds in 2000.
nothing in it morris, move on
We've obviously lost our common sense as the human race is concerned, my god.
Not everything needs to be this complicated or PC, it's not just ruining football, but it's ruining the world, such a BS media circus, he was protecting space, you see people protecting space every week, they need different categories of incidents so players are still eligible for the Brownlow. it wasn't serious, people are over reacting because Sydney are a protected species, I hate Sydney but come on, he is a fair player usually, let him be, it's not even a fine! anyone that says anything different has lost the plot.