Pollution in North Macedonia | ARTE.tv Documentary

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 6 сен 2024
  • Igor Smilev's life has been marked by pain and a sense of powerlessness. The 48-year-old lost his parents and sister to cancer and he is convinced that the cause of their illness lies in the air. For decades, North Macedonia has had the worst levels of air pollution in Europe.
    Subscribe to our RUclips channel: / @artetvdocumentary
    Pollution in North Macedonia | ARTE.tv Documentary
    🗓 Available until the 23/05/2025
    ARTE.tv Documentary is here to tell you more about what’s going on in the world of culture, news and current affairs with powerful, refreshing and entertaining docs subtitled in English for our international fans.
    Discover a whole world on #ARTE.tv
    #pollution #artetvdocumentary #northmacedonia

Комментарии • 111

  • @artetvdocumentary
    @artetvdocumentary  Месяц назад +1

    The impact of the climate crisis can be felt in a myriad of ways across the world. 🌎 How is global warming impacting your country?
    For further watching, check out ‘Too Hot to Work’, a film that looks into the lives of workers already impacted by rising temperatures 👉 ruclips.net/video/y_9UHGbqMHI/видео.html
    And for more on the climate crisis, check out our 'Climate Emergency Worldwide' playlist 👉 ruclips.net/video/qEwy5I1mXds/видео.html

  • @laflamablancak.p.3170
    @laflamablancak.p.3170 Месяц назад +89

    I hope someone does something, 30 years of lies and corruption brought us where we are now, we have beautiful nature and mountains, fresh water and fertile soil. Thank you for visiting our country and spreading the word ❤

    • @laflamablancak.p.3170
      @laflamablancak.p.3170 Месяц назад +6

      And not visiting Bitola in regardas to the subject was a miss,we provide 80% of the electricity to the whole country by having a coal plant, but instead of that they burn mud with extremely toxic oil, chemicals and who knows what else...

    • @QuentinBulgaria
      @QuentinBulgaria Месяц назад

      macedonia is bulgaria

    • @DacLMK
      @DacLMK Месяц назад

      @@QuentinBulgaria Bulgaria is Macedonian. You're a brainwashed Macedonian.

    • @Dota-2
      @Dota-2 Месяц назад

      ​@@QuentinBulgaria braindead bulgarian

    • @blagoevski336
      @blagoevski336 Месяц назад

      ​@@QuentinBulgaria loser alert

  • @user-wr1fw6ib6y
    @user-wr1fw6ib6y Месяц назад +64

    Ние неможеме да се избориме со мафијата во судството и основни човекови потреби и права....основна култура за отпад фрлање екологија е виша сила за нас

    • @user-wr1fw6ib6y
      @user-wr1fw6ib6y Месяц назад

      Патем....ние влеговме во НАТО за да бидеме рударски искористени..допрва доаѓа пеколот за нас... западна Македонија нема да биде пипната,само градена за сметка на источна....

  • @blagoevski336
    @blagoevski336 Месяц назад +21

    As a Macedonian this is true

    • @blagoevski336
      @blagoevski336 Месяц назад

      @@pnmetronariston4112 ?

    • @blagoevski336
      @blagoevski336 Месяц назад

      @@pnmetronariston4112 nah

    • @tatjanavelkova5814
      @tatjanavelkova5814 Месяц назад +2

      MAKEDONIJA EXIST 25 CENTURIES from KING FILIP .
      Oto german make Greece before 190 years.

    • @katerinamakedoniaGreece
      @katerinamakedoniaGreece 11 дней назад

      ​@@tatjanavelkova5814Greece is 4000 years here. Macedonians are Greeks, Hercules descendants and Temenides Dynasty. We are 1000000 Greek Macedonians zwe are living in Alexander's birth town and Philip's palace, we self-determine ourselves Macedonians 2700 years and you with Tito and Stalin can't change world's history because you need our territories to be powerful. It's ridiculous to change the identity of Greatest Greek men that fight Persians empire in the name of Greek civilization and make them Slavs because you like it. We fight to be free from Othomans turks. No Otto and no Tito make us. We gave our blood and we destroyed Othomans empire with our blood. Your ignorance and your megalomania is the problem. All the universe and the universities knows that Alexander was Greek,except your Slavs and Bulgarians descendants. You are a shame and disgraceful team that they don't have any Macedonian territory or town or theaters temples palaces. Just you self-determine yourselves with Comiderns orders. Germans should stop supporting Russians and communists plans and crooks

    • @katerinamakedoniaGreece
      @katerinamakedoniaGreece 11 дней назад

      King Philip was Greek, he spoken Greek and his grandfather and grandmother Evridiki was Greek. Not Slavs and Bulgarians. They didn't speak Cyrillic language. They didn't even knew you because you weren't in Balkans before christ. You came from North Europe to destroy Greece in 700 AFTER christ and you continue to ask territories even from SPARTANs. Enough crooks and imperialists Panslavists. Enough with you

  • @BianconeriDiBelgradoSRB
    @BianconeriDiBelgradoSRB Месяц назад +35

    Same sh*t in Serbia too.

    • @robrob9050
      @robrob9050 Месяц назад +4

      Maybe even worse.

    • @markosarko
      @markosarko Месяц назад

      Serbia is better, Macedonia is bottom .

    • @smejtesemajmuni3589
      @smejtesemajmuni3589 Месяц назад

      Eto nam prava i evropske vrednosti, stavim kurac u iste. Pola drzave siptarima, tiho uvuceni u nato , lgbtqEU mafija na vlasti, zagadjeni vazduh voda i zemlja. Ko nas jebe sad uzivajte u sumpornoj kiselini u plucima.

    • @stormtrooper9404
      @stormtrooper9404 Месяц назад +2

      Don't gave up in your fight!
      Борете се!

  • @sngtimeout
    @sngtimeout Месяц назад +4

    Buildings construction mafia did this in Skopje and it continues with every mayor..

  • @Druze_Tito
    @Druze_Tito Месяц назад +14

    Yeah, sure. Not a word on the diesel crap imported from Germany. I expected better.

  • @eagledon
    @eagledon Месяц назад +6

    You dont havent come yet to Tirana and you will be breathless lol

    • @ChiliM4n
      @ChiliM4n Месяц назад +1

      In serbia too bro. The balkans really need to start improving on the quality of life.

    • @dungeontnt
      @dungeontnt Месяц назад +1

      ​@@ChiliM4nin Skoplje it is cleaned up, in Radoviš where I'm from it was never that bad, plus I live in a village which has great air quality and it's 8km away form the city

  • @remzibajrami7969
    @remzibajrami7969 Месяц назад +2

    The same thing happens in our city Dibër (Debar) the German fabric KNAUF is killing us by the pollution they release all the chemicals and toxins. Cancer is widely spread , asthma, people losing eyesight.

  • @TheAusroar
    @TheAusroar Месяц назад +17

    Thank you for this documentary, it is very enlightening about the situation in our country. As a Macedonian, all I can say is since we lost all the smart sons and daughters to the foreign countries, all we can do is pay a german 10 denars per citizen (1.8 million denars = 300.000 euros) per month, for 1 year they will set us straight, spank us with a slipper and leave. We have definitely almost reached the point of no return and we must do something soon before it is too late.
    Држете ми се, Велешани!

  • @DimitarAtanasov-u9w
    @DimitarAtanasov-u9w Месяц назад

    I absolutely agree and good luck to Gorjan and everyone else fighting this. I left Skopje in 2014 and one of the reasons was that the air quality was horrible.

  • @Commentator541
    @Commentator541 Месяц назад +19

    I mean let us talk about how you forced them to take on another language, be occupied, and even change the name of the country... bad air is least of their problems.

    • @philldonn705
      @philldonn705 Месяц назад

      Lay off the drugs you dellusional human being.

  • @_petar
    @_petar Месяц назад +2

    Come to Sofia please, also check the black clouds behind the cars here but it is your fault, you throw away them here for good money!

  • @user-wj5yz2pw5t
    @user-wj5yz2pw5t Месяц назад +1

    Народ на Балкану има слабу свест о екологији и власт неће да се бави стварима које сам народ не сматра битним.

  • @Love78787
    @Love78787 Месяц назад +8

    MACEDONIA ONLY!!!!!!

    • @katerinamakedoniaGreece
      @katerinamakedoniaGreece 11 дней назад

      Macedonia is in North Greece. In Aeges is Philip's palace where Alexander became king of ALL the Greeks and destroyed Persian emoire and saved EUROPEANS actually. You
      are North of Macedonia and the only that you want is to make Panslavists great and powerful. Go to Russia to find your ancestors and your grandparents. Enough with BS

    • @Love78787
      @Love78787 11 дней назад

      @@katerinamakedoniaGreece Karamanlides and pontians of Turkic and Iranian origin have nothing to do with Macedonia nor Macedonia exists in greece because Macedonia is a former administrative region of greece and existed for the first time in greece in 1988. Today greece has West Macedonia Central Macedonia East Macedonia and Thrace

    • @gocedelcev86
      @gocedelcev86 6 дней назад

      ​@@katerinamakedoniaGreecewho cares, its history

  • @bosnian2339
    @bosnian2339 Месяц назад +2

    Bosnia is probably as bad, if not worse.

  • @jenmu7870
    @jenmu7870 Месяц назад

    😢😢😢

  • @jeromedevotta3406
    @jeromedevotta3406 Месяц назад +2

    too many people smoking too much of you know what 😮😮😮

  • @billba
    @billba Месяц назад +3

    English version?

    • @martinsuperfind7779
      @martinsuperfind7779 Месяц назад +6

      You have subtitles.

    • @billba
      @billba Месяц назад +1

      @@martinsuperfind7779 not the same

    • @DimeIgnjatov
      @DimeIgnjatov Месяц назад

      @@billba NATO threw bombs with depleted uranium on Serbia , Monte negro and fake state Kosovo. Consequences can be felt in Albania , Bosnia and Big time in Macedonia . It's only 10-20 miles away. Wind...?

    • @DimeIgnjatov
      @DimeIgnjatov Месяц назад +1

      @@billba so it isn't bit normal. Pollution exist but mostly thanks to Uranium , you probably know how long Uranium should disentigrate in the atmosphere , but way worst on land . So someone is insane here. German documentary tells "lessons" on pollution , same time , they were the very first state to bomb Serbia as usual...

    • @artetvdocumentary
      @artetvdocumentary  Месяц назад +2

      Hi there! This is ARTE's English-language channel, meaning that all of our programmes are either subtitled or narrated in English. For programmes narrated in English, see: ruclips.net/p/PL-eZcc0GI8-VcE98zONNGBib-ZXfm_8Ba

  • @user-wr1fw6ib6y
    @user-wr1fw6ib6y Месяц назад +1

    Влеговме во НАТО за да бидеме Рудник нивни,допрва ќе го видиме пеколот

    • @sngtimeout
      @sngtimeout Месяц назад

      Нато ли ти ги изгради сите згради во Скопје?

    • @user-wr1fw6ib6y
      @user-wr1fw6ib6y Месяц назад

      @@sngtimeout никогаш не е касно!!!...да се прогласи Велес за главен град на Македонија

  • @vladimirm5402
    @vladimirm5402 Месяц назад

    i klimata e smenta topli zimi zagaden vozduh radi temperaturnata inverzija

  • @dzimidimi09
    @dzimidimi09 Месяц назад +1

    We are all guilty. When we start from ourselves, it is possible to stir things up. But we all want a new car, a holiday on the other side of the Earth, a new wardrobe. a new house with a swimming pool heated in the winter and cold in the summer, food from exotic countries, new ... We have to change our habits. As long as we have this awareness, those who make our wishes come true will be our fault. Big polluters are the product of our selfish behavior. The development of technology currently only contributes to pollution. And the latest green technologies are more like pushing the garbage under the carpet. We may destroy the planet, but it will find a way to heal its scars, as it has done many times before, of course without us.

  • @marko1978st
    @marko1978st Месяц назад

    Insane!
    Možete vi to bolje Makedonci! Evropski bespovratni jedan dobar uberite brati!
    Pozdrav!

    • @katerinamakedoniaGreece
      @katerinamakedoniaGreece 11 дней назад

      The Macedonians are living in Greece, in Alexander's birth town, the greatest Greek man. The slavs aren't Macedonians and Greeks and they have no common territories even with Ancient Macedonia. Propaganda of Tito and Stalin was bigger than them. We self-determine ourselves Macedonians 2700 years. And WE ARE the Macedonians Hercules descendants and Temenides Dynasty. Regards to Putin..

  • @martinwrites2236
    @martinwrites2236 Месяц назад +11

    The Arte of Propaganda. Macedonia pollutes way less compared to any given western country. Macedonia’s problem is that pollution gets trapped behind the hills.

    • @bunnywabbit
      @bunnywabbit Месяц назад +2

      Same shit. The point is that there's lots of pollution, and any additional pollutants definitely don't help the situation. I don't know how true that is but it would've been nice to mention that if it is true.

    • @anon_1-n1e
      @anon_1-n1e Месяц назад +2

      You have 16 stations, what propaganda are you dreaming about? I guess you are anti-coal mines closure and anti windmills and other methods that cause less contamination.

    • @robrob9050
      @robrob9050 Месяц назад +1

      @martinwrites2236 Climate changes, there is no excuse (weather) for govermental inaction

    • @nadraksan
      @nadraksan Месяц назад +3

      I am so sad that we are so uneducated in Macedonia. We have so much sensors from pollution from many different organizations governments and private. All of them give data. The data tells you what kind of pollution is out there. But we refuse to look at data and we just call it propaganda. If other countries have it worse that does not mean the air in Macedonia is clean and healthy.

    • @KirilKujundjiev
      @KirilKujundjiev Месяц назад +1

      Do you know that everything that is prohibited to be done in the west is done in Macedonia?

  • @SvilajnacFishing
    @SvilajnacFishing Месяц назад

    Serbia have bigger problem

  • @evgenijalazarova-nousiaine9957
    @evgenijalazarova-nousiaine9957 Месяц назад +2

    Odete na rabota so velosiped ili avtobus. Ne kupuvajte nov mebel za doma, zadovolete se so stariot od vasite roditeli. Fabrikite Treba da se zatvorat na 10 godini. ,

    • @DacLMK
      @DacLMK Месяц назад +1

      Ti normalna li si be? Da ti sedam na iskrsen mebel nikogas. I za koj fabriki zboris? Tuka nitu edna fabrika ne ti raboti. Uste od transicijata se zatvoreni.

    • @MJDahling
      @MJDahling Месяц назад +3

      Ti da odis na 40 stepeni od novo lisice do centar so tocak moze?

    • @HEHOPMALEH
      @HEHOPMALEH Месяц назад

      @@MJDahlingso elektricen skuter ili velosiped ke gi zemam kerkite od gradinka od skolo, soprugata od rabota i ke pazaram za doma. Abe i na odmor ke odam, ke tovaram se i ke zaminam. Kako ne mi tekna? Ovaj mnogu pameten be majku mu

    • @HEHOPMALEH
      @HEHOPMALEH Месяц назад

      I so sekundaren lepak ke se zalepime za asfalt za da preneseme poraka

  • @gocedelcev86
    @gocedelcev86 6 дней назад

    Verry bad

  • @SAT186971
    @SAT186971 Месяц назад

    Veles@@s

  • @bobycool
    @bobycool Месяц назад +8

    Exactly like that watch PROPAGANDA for negative reasons in Macedonia . Italy have a worst air, also North Germany, London...

    • @nadraksan
      @nadraksan Месяц назад +4

      If Italy has worse air, that does not make the air in Macedonia clean and healthy. There is no politics in the quality of air. Either it's healthy or not. Get educated and stay safe.

    • @maya-sn2hk
      @maya-sn2hk Месяц назад +3

      @bobycool Maybe, but the fact is that waste from the EU is burned all over the Balkans, not only in Macedonia.

    • @petartrajkovski465
      @petartrajkovski465 Месяц назад

      Agree 100 %

    • @sngtimeout
      @sngtimeout Месяц назад +1

      As a macedonian person i need to strongly disagree... Where are you living? People are dying from air pollution in Skopje especially during autumn and winter...

  • @kirokirov-lu8cs
    @kirokirov-lu8cs Месяц назад

    Sad story, but I don't believe this is the reason that they are brainwashed.

  • @miroslavbg2898
    @miroslavbg2898 Месяц назад +1

    These people speak bulgarian

    • @marijamagdalena7156
      @marijamagdalena7156 Месяц назад +4

      Please.. even Bulgarians can't understand themselves..they use dictionary mixed from many languages and none of them is theirs.

    • @miroslavbg2898
      @miroslavbg2898 Месяц назад

      @@marijamagdalena7156 mostly bulgarian with serbian accent and a few serbian words mixed in there. I understand 95% of all they say and im not fluent in serbian.

    • @marijamagdalena7156
      @marijamagdalena7156 Месяц назад +3

      @miroslavbg2898 If you understand, then it's probably the Macedonian roots.
      This language is Macedonian, so if I were you, I'd check if I was taught something wrong.

    • @miroslavbg2898
      @miroslavbg2898 Месяц назад +2

      @@marijamagdalena7156 there is no such thing as macedonian language,just like there is no austrian or american language

    • @milosheski
      @milosheski Месяц назад +1

      @@miroslavbg2898 Your is just funny Macedonian language, we are all laughing when Vulgarians talk

  • @essential.technology
    @essential.technology Месяц назад +1

    Do your survey better.... Kosovo has at least 10x worse air pollution. Go take a walk in and around their capital at winter time, or just about any time of the year.

    • @dungeontnt
      @dungeontnt Месяц назад +1

      Strumica was one of the most polluted

    • @dannyboy-vtc5741
      @dannyboy-vtc5741 Месяц назад +1

      Not really, mostly the same in per capita, but less concentrated, on pollution maps during the winter that entire area is shit, but belgrade is by far the worst, and some other serbian cities, together with some macedonian and bosnian, kosovo never exactly tops the lists, but it's a shit too ofc.

  • @Brainlesssas
    @Brainlesssas Месяц назад +2

    Проблемот е во то шо сите пари одат во Скопје а другите градови тапкат вместо 20 и кусур години. Мора граѓаните а особбено и вработените во државните институции да кренат глас, против они кои ѓи распределват парите односно министерствата ама то е тешко да се случи оти повеќето се плашат да не бидат избркани од работното место, заради то шо нашата држава е комунистичка и главниот во партијата може да вработва и брка од работа. Ако нечини во здравството и нема хемотерапија треба да излезат или петции да се потпишват од здр работници да се поправи тоа. Неможи да снемва хемотерапија и неможи од цела Македонија таја терапија да ја има само во Скопје. Ако е загадувањето во прашање треба советите на сите градови кај шо има загадување да се спротистават на оние во Собранието и Владата, проблемот се решава но потребна е промена во свесното размислување на нашиот народ…

    • @mirabekar6690
      @mirabekar6690 Месяц назад

      Цела Македонија смрди од загадување и ѓубре. А само 2 милиони луѓе сме (еден град е тоа во многу земји)..Волку неодговорен народ и градоначалници кои замижуваат и немаат визија и ум да се справат со ова е погубна реалност. Јас никогаш не сум возела кола и почитувам јавен транпорт но и тоа го уништија. Природата ја бранам но луди се по профит. А за што? Да имаат убава куќа, кола и ќеш и па у истата смрдеа и болна средина да живеат. Ген за самоуништување. А фала ти Игор што не престануваш да се бориш.

  • @Дебарца
    @Дебарца Месяц назад

    Многу арамми имат, само за џебот мислат аер да не видат