Did you see Gerald Moore in the audience? At the beginning when the performers came on stage and audience was applauding. Great performance. A tribute to the great composer. They all complimented him.
Best composition on the genre ever. A masterpiece beyond any human definition that lead to us to a unexplained world of dreams and colour, a point without dimensions and time, all this through a work leaded with perfect musical continuity and lyrism. Beethoven is the greatest artist ever.
merci pour ces images de ces merveilleux collegues comme le dit MENUHIN! Du fond de l'ame merci NATALIA!!!!! avec tout mon amour pour cette musique!!!!
This is soo different interpretatively to the Feurmann, or Casals era recordings. Here they make more tempo changes, romantic gestures and make some passages sound almost atonal. Very modern.
Thank you so much for sharing this precious, timeless jewel. What a priviledge (especially in this crazy superficial time we live in) to be able to enjoy a monument of the classic repertoire performed by these three greats. Doesn't get much better than this!!
I'm fortunate to have attended, on separate occasions, Menuhin and Mstilav, once cello, later conducting. Hope humanity will find much needed inspiration.
The andante cantabile is the portal to Late Beethoven. When it came it came from another world - and music would never be the same again. In it Beethoven deploys extended passages that resound as confessions of the soul and then disappear back into the music as happens in one's life, often without forethought or reason but as epiphanies. Here the andante is reverently rendered by all three masters. As for music history, this is one of You Tube's gifts to the world in my view.
beautiful rendition by three giants of classical music (those who dislike them are not aware of history, taking place just before your eyes and ears.) What a way to enter for a cellist, throwing over your chair and not even bother to tune, bravo
Thank you very much to Natalia for posting this exceptional gem, a real 24 karat gold trio,both the work: greatest composer of all time BEETHOVEN and his superb Archduke trio, and in the other hand these three gigantic players: WILHELMINA KEMPF at the piano, YEHUDI MENUHIN at the violin and MTSLAV ROSTROPOVICH at the cello. This is simply ...... SOMETHING ELSE!
My father was financial officer of a university and there met and became friends with Maestro Rostropovich. He said he was very friendly and liked to talk. It is strange because in this trio the piano part is the only part that (to my ears) sounds "Beethoven", almost like a sonata for piano accompanied by violin and cello.
Do you think cello and violin sounded like Brahms? Since I once had a concert for this followed by Brahms piano trio No. 3 matching the same mood seamlessly.
What a treasure this is. Three great inspirational musicians playing live and one of my favourite works by Beethoven to boot. A big thank you to Natalia for rescuing this gem for posterity
Czytając Murakamiego Haruki "Kawka nad morzem" natknęłam się na wątek muzyczny:Bethoven -Trio Arcyksiąże .Włączyłam Internet, poszukałam ,no i się zachwyciłam tym utworem.Różne są ścieżki do poznawania świata muzyki.😃
Sublime! Like an intimate conversation being had between three close friends. The heartbreaking pathos and beauty of the 3rd movement are almost too much to bear. Thank you for sharing this priceless video!
I've been studying classical music over 50 years. During that time I've heard three great musicologists, including Carl Haas, say that the Archduke is one of the beautiful works ever composed.
Apparently, the first performance (with a nearly deaf Beethoven at the piano) was a disaster. He simply ploughed through it, not being able to hear what the others were doing. Thank God we have performances like this!
Evidently, Beethoven heard the reviews. The two inaugural performances of the "Archduke" were the last occasions on which he performed as a pianist in front of an audience.
Good morning. Would you, please, be kind enough to let us know what kind oƒ piano music works (at least a ƒew) you usually play yourselƒ, to help us understand your judgement in ƒull depth ?
It is hard listening to/ watching this and not getting tear in eyes. Knowing this was written by a friend for a friend, both of them extra-ordinary. The music is full of energy, yet dramatic, filled with yearning and depth of a solemn solitude . It is not Blue Danube or 4-Seasons. It reflects Vienna's cold winters when a great character would sit in a shabby house to write the greatest music of his time, "painting" with his notes, not knowing 220 years latter, far after he is gone, it is still great. What was he thinking, how was he feeling when he was scribbling his notes one after another, "his way"? That is always my greatest question. I think Rostropovich and the trio are just asking that same question as they perform those notes.
Magistrale interprétation par trois très grands artistes qui ne cherchent pas à se mettre en valeur l'un par rapport aux autres. Cela dit, comment commettre une erreur d'interprétation avec une musique aussi éloquente par elle même. C'est la force de Beethoven. Il parle avec une telle puissance et une telle clarté qu'on ne peut pas se tromper avec lui...
Bonjour, des mains qui ne peuvent s'empêcher de danser sur le clavier, toute la Beauté d'une triple complicité solaire… £e grand Menuhin a, bien sûr, 1.000 x 2.000 x 3.000 ƒois raison de célébrer £a Joie que l'immense Générosité de £udwig van Beethoven créa souvent de rien, puisqu'il en ƒut si cruellement privé lui-même ! "Et cette Joie est une Joie divine", eût dit Bergson. Aujourd'hui, les menaces et les bruits-de-bottes sinistres assourdiront-ils notre planète ? ou exaucerons-nous le vœu ƒinal de nos magniƒiques Amis musiciens : "Espérons qu'un peu de cette atmosphère * Rayonnera * dans le monde ! " Joyeux Noël à tous et Bonne Année 2o22 dans la générosité chaleureuse et créatrice.
Great artists at work here - however, Kempff doesn't sound comfortable, there were many slips and I sensed a few times that Rostropovitch was pulling things back. For contrast Menhuin, Kempff and Fournier did a wonderful set of the Beethoven trios for DeutscheGram around the same time; these recordings are elegant and accomplished.
@@rohanmurti3659 There are four movements in all: No 1 Allegro moderato, No 2 Scherzo (Allegro) and Trio, No 3 Andanre cantabile and No 4 Allegro moderato
@@SonjadeWeerdt 12:49 :-))) (and Menuhin: 22:26, hard to believe, but 33:02... is his best) 23:20... : Watch Rostropovich's facial expressions in response to Menuhin's attempts 30:45 - 31:03 Menuhin's vibrato - and then Rostropovich's Finally, compose a piano sonata just from the notes that mein Kempff missed!
Un naufrage collectif... Menuhin n'est plus que l'ombre de lui-même, Rostro entraîné dans ce désastre joue très mal. Le piano de Kempff en soi non critiquable semble déplacé, sonne bizarre... Curieux moment... Apparemment les spectateurs semblent contents... C'est dire le niveau...
Bonjour, auriez-vous l'extrême obligeance de nous ƒaire un peu connaître quelle sorte de musique vous jouez vous-même, habituellement ? pour tâcher de bien comprendre sur quelles bases repose votre jugement sans concession…
Un troll obsédé de politique, ailleurs sur le web. Une page vide sur RUclips. Probable que ne sait pas lire une note, et avec zéro culture musicale! ;)
Partagez tant que vous voulez mes obsessions politiques, et suivez-les. Je n'y vois aucun inconvénient et en suis même honoré. Mais de grâce, ne polluez pas d'un souffle empoisonné et fétide de petit milicien gestapiste les sujets dans lesquels vous n'avez rien à voir en tant que troll spécialisé en politique. Pensez aux autres, enfin...
Did you see Gerald Moore in the audience? At the beginning when the performers came on stage and audience was applauding.
Great performance. A tribute to the great composer. They all complimented him.
Best composition on the genre ever.
A masterpiece beyond any human definition that lead to us to a unexplained world of dreams and colour, a point without dimensions and time, all this through a work leaded with perfect musical continuity and lyrism.
Beethoven is the greatest artist ever.
THANK YOU ... An immortal Beethoven and three immortal soloists ... !!!
I agree, they became immortal!❤
"Kafka on the shore"✨✨
Crazy how much a book can connect so many people together, same thing with the Kafka on the shore song
merci pour ces images de ces merveilleux collegues comme le dit MENUHIN! Du fond de l'ame merci NATALIA!!!!! avec tout mon amour pour cette musique!!!!
This is soo different interpretatively to the Feurmann, or Casals era recordings. Here they make more tempo changes, romantic gestures and make some passages sound almost atonal. Very modern.
I prefer the other ones.
Thank you so much for sharing this precious, timeless jewel. What a priviledge (especially in this crazy superficial time we live in) to be able to enjoy a monument of the classic repertoire performed by these three greats. Doesn't get much better than this!!
Except had the chap depicted at 0:55 been playing the piano....
I'm fortunate to have attended, on separate occasions, Menuhin and Mstilav, once cello, later conducting. Hope humanity will find much needed inspiration.
O livro "Kafka a beira-mar" trouxe-me até aqui
Thank you RUclips for making such Divine music available to we mere mortals. Could there be such a collection of musical geniuses again.
The andante cantabile is the portal to Late Beethoven. When it came it came from another world - and music would never be the same again. In it Beethoven deploys extended passages that resound as confessions of the soul and then disappear back into the music as happens in one's life, often without forethought or reason but as epiphanies. Here the andante is reverently rendered by all three masters. As for music history, this is one of You Tube's gifts to the world in my view.
beautiful rendition by three giants of classical music (those who dislike them are not aware of history, taking place just before your eyes and ears.) What a way to enter for a cellist, throwing over your chair and not even bother to tune, bravo
Wonderful. See Gerald Moore in the front row.
Ilyen csodálatos előadást ritkán hallunk.
A magnificent coming together of three great artists - a splendid rendition of this sublime trio ♥️
Thank you very much to Natalia for posting this exceptional gem, a real 24 karat gold trio,both the work: greatest composer of all time BEETHOVEN and his superb Archduke trio, and in the other hand these three gigantic players: WILHELMINA KEMPF at the piano, YEHUDI MENUHIN at the violin and MTSLAV ROSTROPOVICH at the cello. This is simply ...... SOMETHING ELSE!
"Wilhelm" is the male version of the name.
1974 the year my son was born.Beethoven always make me cry.Thank you three giants! Call me many beautiful memories.
A trio of legend exactly. What an inspiration in the world of today. Thank you to You Tube for presenting such a performance.
Questa esecuzione è di una tale intensità che non ho mai smesso di piangere dalla commozione per la bellezza
Trois monstres sacres réunis pour interpreter Beethoven, cela mérite bien un commentaire, parce que 10, cela ne le fait pas!
My father was financial officer of a university and there met and became friends with Maestro Rostropovich. He said he was very friendly and liked to talk.
It is strange because in this trio the piano part is the only part that (to my ears) sounds "Beethoven", almost like a sonata for piano accompanied by violin and cello.
Do you think cello and violin sounded like Brahms? Since I once had a concert for this followed by Brahms piano trio No. 3 matching the same mood seamlessly.
Absolutely brilliant! I love the Archduke Trio, and to see it performed by three giants from the past is a special gift! Thanks for posting this.
What a treasure this is. Three great inspirational musicians playing live and one of my favourite works by Beethoven to boot. A big thank you to Natalia for rescuing this gem for posterity
so happy to see it on one video - the legends in what in my opinion is the definitive performance of this classic....
What a privilege to hear this wonderful Beethoven masterpiece performed masterful artists.
Czytając Murakamiego Haruki "Kawka nad morzem" natknęłam się na wątek muzyczny:Bethoven -Trio Arcyksiąże .Włączyłam Internet, poszukałam ,no i się zachwyciłam tym utworem.Różne są ścieżki do poznawania świata muzyki.😃
Sublime! Like an intimate conversation being had between three close friends. The heartbreaking pathos and beauty of the 3rd movement are almost too much to bear. Thank you for sharing this priceless video!
Músicos legendarios, obra genial !
I've been studying classical music over 50 years. During that time I've heard three great musicologists, including Carl Haas, say that the Archduke is one of the beautiful works ever composed.
I agree with them. What do you think about it?
Ростропович, однако, пристроился повыше. Мне кажется, на него Менухин так иронично поглядывает. Кемпфф самозабвенен и виртуозен. Люблю их.
What a trio, the work and the artists, that lives in the playing ... a remarkable video. thank you for sharing
I've played the 'Archduke' a thousand over my life and it never gets old. I'd be happy if it was all I had to listen to.
What a wonderful recording! Thanks for sharing!
Apparently, the first performance (with a nearly deaf Beethoven at the piano) was a disaster. He simply ploughed through it, not being able to hear what the others were doing. Thank God we have performances like this!
Evidently, Beethoven heard the reviews. The two inaugural performances of the "Archduke" were the last occasions on which he performed as a pianist in front of an audience.
Good morning. Would you, please, be kind enough to let us know what kind oƒ piano music works (at least a ƒew) you usually play yourselƒ, to help us understand your judgement in ƒull depth ?
Sublime, what else?! 🎶🎼🎵❤
This is so beautiful--the music and the geniuses playing it. I cried through the entire piece. Thank you.
It is hard listening to/ watching this and not getting tear in eyes. Knowing this was written by a friend for a friend, both of them extra-ordinary. The music is full of energy, yet dramatic, filled with yearning and depth of a solemn solitude . It is not Blue Danube or 4-Seasons. It reflects Vienna's cold winters when a great character would sit in a shabby house to write the greatest music of his time, "painting" with his notes, not knowing 220 years latter, far after he is gone, it is still great. What was he thinking, how was he feeling when he was scribbling his notes one after another, "his way"? That is always my greatest question. I think Rostropovich and the trio are just asking that same question as they perform those notes.
Un trio de légende
Magistrale interprétation par trois très grands artistes qui ne cherchent pas à se mettre en valeur l'un par rapport aux autres. Cela dit, comment commettre une erreur d'interprétation avec une musique aussi éloquente par elle même.
C'est la force de Beethoven. Il parle avec une telle puissance et une telle clarté qu'on ne peut pas se tromper avec lui...
Que disfrute escuchando a estos grandes maestros.
A trio made in Heaven!
quelle merveilleuse musique
Merci beaucoup pour ce beau partage!
Q hermoso, que musicos!, que calidad!, emocionante como siempre Beethoven y la actuacion de estos genios en vivo!!...Gracias Natalia!
No solo la melodía si no los interpretes que la tocan
bravissimo. greetings from brazil
The sound quality of the registration is very poor, but the performance is unique! Thank you for this incredible event!
THE BEST OF BEST !
This historic concert performance took place in Paris Salle Playel in 1974
kafka on the shore brought me here
me too
Murakimi “Haruki Kafka on the Shore” lead me here! 😊
Three giants!!a superb performance!!!thank you so much for uploading it!!
Four giants. First of all Beethoven.
Agreed!!!but Beethoven rather than a mere giant was a real God!!!
Ах благодарю. Такое же видео с того концерта ищу и Фишера Дискау.
آه که من این موزیک رو با خوندن کافکا در کرانه شناختم و از هاذوکی موراکامی ممنونم.🎐🌬☕️✨️
crikey. I thought this had been lost forever! thank you natalia!!!
Bellissimo
I wonder who the nine philistines are who voted down this heavenly performance.
Too drunk or too myopic to focus on the thumbs up? I can think of no other explanation.
My computer is not registering any dislikes. Quite rightly they have been removed.
動画ありがとうございます！
Thanks a lot.thaok you三人の表情、ハーモニーがとてもすてきです,それぞれの演奏は完璧ではないかもしれません、素人のわたしが言うのは僭越ですが。ただ、とても素晴らしい！何度も見に来ています。
ほんとうに、ありがとうございます！
Thanks X 10000000 !
LEGEND!
Thank you Murakami
Kempff et Menuhin..... love love love.
Extraordinario!!
Proper thing to do is have the page turner take a bow also.
Bravo bravo bravo!!
Kafka on the shore ❤
1:34
11:49
19:05
31:37
Thanks
Hi Mr. Hoshino
Bonjour, des mains qui ne peuvent s'empêcher de danser sur le clavier, toute la Beauté d'une triple complicité solaire… £e grand Menuhin a, bien sûr, 1.000 x 2.000 x 3.000 ƒois raison de célébrer £a Joie que l'immense Générosité de £udwig van Beethoven créa souvent de rien, puisqu'il en ƒut si cruellement privé lui-même !
"Et cette Joie est une Joie divine", eût dit Bergson.
Aujourd'hui, les menaces et les bruits-de-bottes sinistres assourdiront-ils notre planète ? ou exaucerons-nous le vœu ƒinal de nos magniƒiques Amis musiciens :
"Espérons qu'un peu de cette atmosphère * Rayonnera * dans le monde ! "
Joyeux Noël à tous et Bonne Année 2o22 dans la générosité chaleureuse et créatrice.
Et t'a moi qui a un test sur les musiques de beethoven demain :/
@Charles Leclerc eu penso que ele quis dizer que esta performance seria uma referência.
Es una pena que no esta completa
Carlos, what is incomplete?
Is that Andre Previn turning the pages?
No
Anyone knows if the person in the public at 40:05 is Daniel Barenboim?
no,Is the arciduca bleandri de bonchant
Start at 1:35
Kafka sur le rivage !!
Got to follow Murakami’s musical references.
0:44
I love RUclips!!!!!!!!! This video should be pay per view!!!!!!!!!!!
11:51
19:05
31:37
Great artists at work here - however, Kempff doesn't sound comfortable, there were many slips and I sensed a few times that Rostropovitch was pulling things back. For contrast Menhuin, Kempff and Fournier did a wonderful set of the Beethoven trios for DeutscheGram around the same time; these recordings are elegant and accomplished.
Which piece do they start playing at 11:50? What's it called?
Rohan Murti this whole recording it’s a piece in 4 movements. At 11:50 they start playing the second movement: Scherzo
@@priscilaoprescu2831 Thanks so much! :)
Could you please tell me the names of the other three movements too? 😬
@@rohanmurti3659 There are four movements in all: No 1 Allegro moderato, No 2 Scherzo (Allegro) and Trio, No 3 Andanre cantabile and No 4 Allegro moderato
Thanks a lot, Keith!
21:00
Rostropovich thinking all the time: OMG, it's a nightmare.... Never again with these guys!
Yet Rostropovich is the only one I saw smiling! Granted it was only once.
@@SonjadeWeerdt 12:49 :-))) (and Menuhin: 22:26, hard to believe, but 33:02... is his best)
23:20... : Watch Rostropovich's facial expressions in response to Menuhin's attempts
30:45 - 31:03 Menuhin's vibrato - and then Rostropovich's
Finally, compose a piano sonata just from the notes that mein Kempff missed!
1:34 - 11:49
31:30
Sorry gals but this illustrates why strong fingers of Rostropovich leads to more masterful cello playing. Sorry to be honest and impolite.
Which "Gals" that apparently don't have strong fingers might you be referring to? Du Pre, Gutman, Kliegel, Han-Na Chang?
Brilliant performers, but atrocious recording!
in all honesty, the only movement i like is the second one.
My condolences for your poor taste.
@@ultimateconstruction that´s rude and i dont even know you.
Un naufrage collectif... Menuhin n'est plus que l'ombre de lui-même, Rostro entraîné dans ce désastre joue très mal. Le piano de Kempff en soi non critiquable semble déplacé, sonne bizarre... Curieux moment... Apparemment les spectateurs semblent contents... C'est dire le niveau...
En tout cas Joel, ça nous renseigne sur le tien, merci.
Pas assez rock pour votre absence de culture musicale ???
Bonjour, auriez-vous l'extrême obligeance de nous ƒaire un peu connaître quelle sorte de musique vous jouez vous-même, habituellement ? pour tâcher de bien comprendre sur quelles bases repose votre jugement sans concession…
Un troll obsédé de politique, ailleurs sur le web. Une page vide sur RUclips. Probable que ne sait pas lire une note, et avec zéro culture musicale! ;)
Partagez tant que vous voulez mes obsessions politiques, et suivez-les. Je n'y vois aucun inconvénient et en suis même honoré. Mais de grâce, ne polluez pas d'un souffle empoisonné et fétide de petit milicien gestapiste les sujets dans lesquels vous n'avez rien à voir en tant que troll spécialisé en politique. Pensez aux autres, enfin...
Awful