Survivor: All-Stars - Player Rankings
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 июн 2024
- In this video, I rank every player from Survivor: All-Stars based on how I feel like they played on this individual season.
Twitch Channel: / themeranianreview
VOD Channel: / @themeranianreviewlive 
Развлечения
I remember Lex saying (whether on a Reddit AMA or another interview) that prior to Jenna M. quitting, Jenna and Colby were targeting each other, and Colby would have gone first as Jenna M, Lex, and Kathy were the core of Mogo Mogo with Shii-Ann as a fourth.
I really wish we could have seen this play out as it seemed like Jenna M was the only former winner who had a solid footing in the game. Would still love to see her play again
It’s cuz she was a low threat winner similar to Sandra. She probably could have kept up with Rob in challenges too. What a shame because even if she didnt quit she probably would have been pulled from the game.
@@raheemfielder-bey998 it would be a cool what if Jenna M didn't quit
Jerri is so underrated in this season she was rational,strategic,beautiful, and a good underdog
The only redeeming thing of Richard Hatch’s gameplay strategy is I think he intentionally didn’t play hard. I think he knew if he tried to strategize hardcore his threat level would increase even further. The only way he could somewhat decrease his threat level was to play the fool, the bumbling fat nudist would be less of a threat then challenge beast Colby. Funnily enough, we saw a similar strategy from one of, if not the greatest players of all time, Tony in WaW. Where he knew his reputation preceded him so he tried to lower everyone’s perception of him by not strategizing hardcore, and by being a comic relief.
I think Rob’s optimal play at the merge round was to vote out Tom. Tell his alliance that he’d learned Tom intended to flip; or better yet, have Amber tell them, since she’d just lived in the camp of the group to whom Tom would be flipping. Tell Lex and Kathy that the only way he could keep his allies from gunning for Lex was to turn them against Tom instead.
This allows Lex to stay in the game, completely neutered, no longer a threat to Rob, able to be eliminated at any time. And Rob can say that he kept up his side of the bargain by doing what he had to do to save Lex for at least one round, which is as long as Lex saved Amber. Lex doesn’t spend the entire jury phase seething, probably taking every opportunity to rail against Rob at Ponderosa, and coming out with a jury speech that is so venomous it drives home the narrative that Rob’s social game was dogshit. (Tom and Alicia both lack Lex’s way with words, so the damage would be less.) Even though this would push Tom’s jury vote even farther out of reach, it would still have given Rob a fighting chance.
I love these player ranking videos
We’re get to the Final 3 of Big Brother Canada 3 Player Rankings Next Year. Each of the Final 3 can win the game against one specific player. I love the way that Anyone can win the game. Sarah beat Godfrey, Godfrey beat Ashleigh, and Ashleigh beat Sarah.
BBCAN3 was the season that got me into Big Brother, so I’m looking forward to when TheMeranianReview finally gets to that review next year.
My Rankings:
1- Rob
2- Amber
3- Jenna L.
4- Rupert
5- Kathy
6- Lex
7- Shii Ann
8- Ethan
9- Colby
10- Tom
11- Jerri
12- Alicia
13- Richard
14- Rudy
15- Tina
16- Rob C.
17- Sue
18- Jenna M.
This should be the list tbh I love these videos tho but this is the wimmer
we WILL be watching
1:00 I think you really put things in perspective. I think what happened to Jenna M potentially impacted the history of Survivor. Had Richard been voted out instead of Jenna leaving the game that episode, the incident of him and Sue wouldn’t have happened. Given the dynamic of this season, I feel like Jenna might have made it pretty far despite being a former winner. I think all 3 people would have been locks to return. Jenna would get more content in all stars and is probably more fresh in people’s minds because of that. Rich and Sue would probably be locks for a season like heroes vs. villains or blood vs. water. Rich was seen as an all time great before all stars and this was really the incident that tainted his reputation with production and fans. This incident seems like something that has kept Sue from ever playing again, so she probably would have wanted to return at a later time.
Also if Jenna M was ranked she would most likely be higher then Sue
Jenna beats Rob by getting Ruperts vote. He said he would have voted for her
Great video my guy! I might have Rupert over lex & Kathy but that's it
Your rankings videos are my all time favorite. Are there any more Big Brother and Survivor rankings coming?
My ranking:
1. Boston Rob
2. Amber
3. Rupert
4. Jenna Lewis
5. Big Tom
6. Kathy
7. Lex
8. Shii Ann
9. Jerri
10. Ethan
11. Colby
12. Alicia
13. Rob Cesternino
14. Rudy
15. Richard Hatch
16. Tina
17. Sue
18. Jenna Morasca (I guess?)
Ethan should be ranked higher then Jerri he was a winner so there was little he could really do Jerri didn’t have that target on her back she was still voted out high 😂
@@bossjenkins5875The reason both of them got out were due to the fact that Lex was being Lex… so her being voted premerge doesn’t really do anything when neither could avoid it. I still agree that Ethan should be higher than her though
@@kirbster555 good point !
Finally!
I think Richard intentionally played “the fool” to appear less threatening.
Boston Rob’s game in this season is one of the most iconic and memorable of all time.
I mean my only query is tom and the positioning tom had which to me is better than ruperts but is arguable so i understand the logic
How do I become a member of the Chanel
Agree with this for the most part. But Jenna and Shen are ranked too high.
Jenna should be #2, she does win against Boston Rob and beats Amber not to mention her control over the game
Shii-Ann*
@@jasmine1stan857 doesn't most of them win vs him due to overly extreme bitterness though?
yeah jenna at 18 is a little high imo
maybe 19th would be fair
@@thecolombian8909 lol yea she never even wanted to play her 1st time around. pointless.
Please do Heroes vs Villains next!!
He does these at the 20th anniversary of each season
Just wait 6 years
Idk why Amber is rated so high. She didn’t do anything and Rob carried her the whole way. The only thing she did was beg Kathy to keep her over Jerri but anyone would have done that to stay in the game
Yeah Tom, Rupert and Amber were all the same. They all followed Boston Rob and would have won if he chose them to sit at the end with him.
Colby did not vote Amber out!! Tina did that with Keith without Colby.
Statistical rankings, based on vote success rate, how well they avoided votes, longevity, and a point system I came up with that's too complicated to explain in one comment:
1. Amber (9.375)
2. Rob M (9.217)
3. Jenna (8.56)
4. Big Tom + Sue (8.167) (I didn't deduct any points from Sue for quitting because of the circumstances around it)
6. Rupert (8.042)
7. Shii Ann (7.854)
8. Lex (7.279)
9. Alicia (6.938)
10. Jerri (6.812)
11. Kathy (6.805)
12. Ethan (5.133)
13. Colby (4.396)
14. Rudy (4.354)
15. Richard + Tina (0.75)
17. Rob C (0.583)
Unranked: Jenna
This is proof that statistics never tell you the full story and should only be cause for investigation, never definitive proof of anything.
Rudy Martinez and Alicia Martinez kept their familial bond a secret from Shen and Ret
What did jerri actively do to be placed higher then ethan other then not winning her first season lmao genuine question
all stars was edit based on amber and rob perspective. It's hard to rank some players because of the edit. I don't think Jenna should be ranked as high as you did though. Most annoying player of all time. 0 chance to win, even against Boston Rob.
Jenna might win against Rob (his alleged 4-3 win over her is not locked at all and Kathy and/or Rupert easily could've voted the other way) and almost certainly wins against Amber. Her going to final 3 with a couple is a knock but she got screwed into that situation by the Final 4 tiebreaker being presumed to be rocks at the time when it wasn't.
This channel has actually talk about the Amber v Rob v Jenna final 3 before in terms of jury chances. It’s effectively a Rock Paper Scissors scenario where Amber beats Rob, Rob beats Jenna, and Jenna beats Amber, which is a concept I tend to agree with.
But who are you really gonna put above Jenna?
@@drewlmao i was more so acknowledging that Jenna had a real winning scenario at the final 3. i’m not saying she played a particularly good game lol 😅
@@andrewrandolph2547 I was trying to defend Jenna in response to the original comment. She shouldn't be moved lower because it would be kinda silly to have Lex in the top 3
Colby Covington??? Donaldson…
Personally I would switch 2nd and 3rd although both are on the same boat and the gap between 2nd and first is massive.
Kathy and Lex are WAY too high