She hasn't the strongest voice, that's true. But how soft and sweet it is, it's sending a great message and positive vibes. Should I still mention the chills? I love her :)
Z Laila Don't get mad...That's what haters want...But come on , we are Selenators! Haters are jealous of our amazing team...Don't care at all! I am with you girl❤🔒💞🌸
Having a low voice doesn't mean being a bad singer. She sings exactly the way she does in her studio version if you ask me but yeah you can hardly hear her because she has a low voice, she's not the best singer, even Selena says she isn't. But still that was AMAZING.
+DeadSolve EXACTLY? Excuse me but in the studio version she doesn't sound like she has been holding her breath under water for like 30 minutes after finishing a verse. There is no high note, not a very long period of time 'singing' but still she still gasps for air after almost every word!
Alvaro Pizarro she still sounds the same, same notes but not the same air. Have you ever heard about something called stress ? I already can hear you say "Well she was supposed to be in the business for a year at that time and so it wasn't the first time she performed on stage" yes true, but isn't still stressful ? But anyway, how she sounded and how she sounds today are two different things.
She can sing, she has a very special voice. It's not made to be loud and in your face, it's meant to be soothing, it's not her fault. And if you think you can do better, go ahead
At 2:55 she hit a really decent and powerful C5. It was overshadowed by the shit amount of backtrack and backup singers that were overpowered. I think she did good, not great but good. I wish she would sing this song now, I'm curious to see how these awesome C5 studio belts would sound with Selena's current vocal ability.
thanks to everyone that appreciated her voice under this video. she’s singing very well in this video. she’s def not screaming in the chorus SHE’S SINGING. also that high note in the and was NOT her if you listen closely. she sounded really good in here. i love her so much she doesn’t deserve this hate.
Si se dan cuenta al principio ella no suelta mucho su voz, esta muy nerviosa, pero después va agarrando mucha confianza y logra entonar perfecto y hasta pareciera que toda su pena y nerviosismo se va porque se suelta de una manera increíble! Bravo Selena, podrán decir muchas cosas de ti, pero solo tus verdaderos fans sabemos lo que nos haces sentir con tu voz única ❤️
There is absolutely nothing wrong with this performance, i can guarantee the sound technician plugged a 1/4 Jack cable in instead of a M/F XLR and thats why you can't hear her (music tech student)... plus it just shows that she doesn't lipsync
I knew instantly that the sound guy fell asleep. How could that jerk not fix it all the way through. She was brave enough not to stop music and tell him off? wow Go Selena!!
Anybody saying fame is not relative to talent, yes true, but Selena does have talent, just because you cannot enjoy soothing vocals doesn't mean she's not talented, most of her performances she's on key 95% of the time as well.
People need to understand the difference between a bad singer and someone with a weaker voice. Selena is the latter. She can't project her voice that loudly but her singing is still great, in my opinion. She is in tune, after all it is her song. I love her and if she was such a bad singer, she wouldn't have made a career in it.
yes! this is true... Selena hasn't a strong voice like for example Demi, but it doesn't mean she isn't a good singer... Her voice is so beautiful :) She deserve to be a singer :)
She is always a bit too humble... very emotional... shy on stage... never too confident about her voice (thanks to the constant stream of hateful comments on the internet) .... We're not seeing a performance of someone with weaker voice here... Her voice is perfect, which just got a little shaky here due to her shyness... She performs much comfortably better on her tours... 'cause she's just in front of her fans there..without the fear of constantly being judged.
Her voice is just awesome... Soothing... Not bold like other singers and i love this thing about her .... Music is not about shouting which other singers do.... Music should be soothing and selena is a lot soothing....... she is the best.. I love u my cutie pie selena.... U are so good
She is still young and has yet to learn, but every year her voice just gets better and better, I think she's beautiful and talented, Miley and Demi they have the same beautiful voices but do not compare them with Selena, they are different and the song "Year without rain" is difficult especially since she is singing to the audience and that is high pressure.she has a beautiful voice but it has not yet developed Selena I love you, I'm your biggest fan
So sick of seeing ppl hate on her cause shes with justin,, i mean how pathic are you ppl, GET OVER IT, im a Jelena supporter, I love JB and SG, and hope you guys know thats talking crap your prefect little justin sings with a recording to,, if you have seen his shows you would know.. dont get me wrong i love Justin, but damn put someone down just cause she is BEAUTIFUL, great actress and singer and mostly cause justin is in love with her and yall hate it,, truely sad
99% of the comments are arguing if she can sing.... Yes when Disney started off her singing career she could not sing, but she has definitely gotten better. Her latest songs are good.
well its a slap on those peoples faces who commented onthis video that she cant sing see her NOW! (2015) she is SO CHANGED but still she was also not bad back there she was actually PERFECT to me and still is
I don't think vocally she was weak. A year without rain is a simple and soft song and idk why the sound producers couldn't raise her microphone volume or fix it to where you'd hear the lower parts of the song better . I'll Tell you who was off tho, that background singer who came out of blend at the end😂😂. I know she was supposed to take the higher note but she just ruined the simplicity of it in my opinion they should've had someone with a lighter tone do it
![Charlie Puth & Selena Gomez - We Don't Talk Anymore [Official Live Performance]](/img/1.gif)
She hasn't the strongest voice, that's true. But how soft and sweet it is, it's sending a great message and positive vibes. Should I still mention the chills? I love her :)
Haters can say what they want but Selena still Queen . love her so much !!!
Z Laila a queen because? In acting, okay she's queen. Singing? definitely not. Because she's beautiful? that's not a talent, that's a gift.
Michelle Angelina FOR ME SHE'S QUEEN IN SINGING & ACTING BOTH . & I'M NOT DUMD TO CALL SOMEONE "QUEEN "FOR HER BEAUTY
Z Laila Don't get mad...That's what haters want...But come on , we are Selenators! Haters are jealous of our amazing team...Don't care at all! I am with you girl❤🔒💞🌸
Selenator for life RIGHT GIRL . LOVE U X 💙💙
Selena is a DECEIVER. Disney Illuminati girl who acts goody infront and behind the scenes do blood sacrifices & rituals 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Me at 19: in my bed thinkin how bored is my life
Selena at 18: Singing at the People's Choice Awards and being an icon
Well, make famous yourself.
💗U got a purpose in this life as well. She may tell u this
Having a low voice doesn't mean being a bad singer. She sings exactly the way she does in her studio version if you ask me but yeah you can hardly hear her because she has a low voice, she's not the best singer, even Selena says she isn't. But still that was AMAZING.
+DeadSolve EXACTLY? Excuse me but in the studio version she doesn't sound like she has been holding her breath under water for like 30 minutes after finishing a verse. There is no high note, not a very long period of time 'singing' but still she still gasps for air after almost every word!
Alvaro Pizarro she still sounds the same, same notes but not the same air. Have you ever heard about something called stress ? I already can hear you say "Well she was supposed to be in the business for a year at that time and so it wasn't the first time she performed on stage" yes true, but isn't still stressful ?
But anyway, how she sounded and how she sounds today are two different things.
+DeadSolve hahahaahahahaha funniest fans are Selena fans LMAO
MegaGood5 I know, we're a really funny fandom cuz we're like really cool ! :)
@@r49s14 🤣🤣🤣 in your dreams and delusions only. She lacks singing talent
She can sing, she has a very special voice. It's not made to be loud and in your face, it's meant to be soothing, it's not her fault. And if you think you can do better, go ahead
I agree
perfect way to put it
+Haylee Royale anyone can do better
Agree🐾
Exactly! Not everyone likes every type of voices
stop hate please! selena is a person, she's got a heart! don't hate! please, selena is my idol
Her soft voice is just perf. Soft and mellow I can fall asleep peacefully listening to this ❤️😍
True
😍😍
Yeah,!
Her voice is crystal clear and smoothing
Can't believe its already 8 years ago, she's such a legend 😭 im so proud of u queen
She's legend, everyone know her
10 years now
Honestly the chorus isn’t bad, she actually sang it really well.
Right?! LOVE HER
Yeah!
She is so gorgeous!
At 2:55 she hit a really decent and powerful C5. It was overshadowed by the shit amount of backtrack and backup singers that were overpowered.
I think she did good, not great but good.
I wish she would sing this song now, I'm curious to see how these awesome C5 studio belts would sound with Selena's current vocal ability.
still in love with the dress
lamia habadi saaammmeeeeeee!!!!!!!!!
thanks to everyone that appreciated her voice under this video. she’s singing very well in this video.
she’s def not screaming in the chorus SHE’S SINGING. also that high note in the and was NOT her if you listen closely. she sounded really good in here. i love her so much she doesn’t deserve this hate.
Si se dan cuenta al principio ella no suelta mucho su voz, esta muy nerviosa, pero después va agarrando mucha confianza y logra entonar perfecto y hasta pareciera que toda su pena y nerviosismo se va porque se suelta de una manera increíble! Bravo Selena, podrán decir muchas cosas de ti, pero solo tus verdaderos fans sabemos lo que nos haces sentir con tu voz única ❤️
❤️
There is absolutely nothing wrong with this performance, i can guarantee the sound technician plugged a 1/4 Jack cable in instead of a M/F XLR and thats why you can't hear her (music tech student)... plus it just shows that she doesn't lipsync
I think you are right- I perceived that right away. It is a technical problem.
It seems like she either tried to sing louder or they fixed it by the chorus & second verse.
Ryan Morrison i know this comment is 2 years old but i hope u know that most of her performances lip synced
Ryan Morrison thanks for that. Because you're totally right. This performance is just not bad at all.
aurora michelle
Ik this comment is 2 years old but if most of her performances were lip sync than she wouldn’t have a bad singing reputation.
She's just like a doll, perfect!
one of her best performances...tbh
her dress is amazing 😍😍😍 and omg she is completely amazing!!😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
Shes queen
queen without a voice heuheeu
Michelle Rivera kinda seems like she has a voice. I mean I was pretty sure that that's what it's called when you open your mouth and sound comes out.
I LOVE HER DRESSSSSS ! And she is singing good!
She is a real princess. ❤️❤️
Selena gomez live performance is always tuning & beautiful & intriguing :) .i love to see her singing
Selena Gomez is so beautiful
She can sing!
Selena Can sing!
Stop Saying she can't sing!
exactly!
agreed
+Tiffany Byun Well I cant hear singing here. All I hear is whispering and breathing.
+MegaGood5 Her voice is soft and sweet
Right I don't get why people she can't sing. -.- just Cuhs she don't have high pitch voice like Ariana doesn't mean she can't sing.
She has an amazing voice I love its color and how it sounds softly to my ears. I love you Selena.
Those backup singers deserve a raise.
At least she does it LIVE kudos to her
she can sing louder but she's afraid that she make a mistake--' love u selena!
OMG I CAN'T !! SHE'S SO BEAUTIFUL !!!
I knew instantly that the sound guy fell asleep. How could that jerk not fix it all the way through. She was brave enough not to stop music and tell him off? wow Go Selena!!
She is a good actress good dancer good singer good dresser#number 1fan
selena is very beautiful ♥
More than 3 years ago! :') Brings back such memories!
Anybody saying fame is not relative to talent, yes true, but Selena does have talent, just because you cannot enjoy soothing vocals doesn't mean she's not talented, most of her performances she's on key 95% of the time as well.
she is my favorite singer
Kaley Cuoco presenting Selena Gomez I’M LIVING
People need to understand the difference between a bad singer and someone with a weaker voice. Selena is the latter. She can't project her voice that loudly but her singing is still great, in my opinion. She is in tune, after all it is her song. I love her and if she was such a bad singer, she wouldn't have made a career in it.
Yeah ikr the heart wants what it wants was an amazing performance love her (:
yes! this is true... Selena hasn't a strong voice like for example Demi, but it doesn't mean she isn't a good singer... Her voice is so beautiful :) She deserve to be a singer :)
She is always a bit too humble... very emotional... shy on stage... never too confident about her voice (thanks to the constant stream of hateful comments on the internet) .... We're not seeing a performance of someone with weaker voice here... Her voice is perfect, which just got a little shaky here due to her shyness... She performs much comfortably better on her tours... 'cause she's just in front of her fans there..without the fear of constantly being judged.
She would never make a singing show. Part of singing IS projection. Her voice isn't "weaker" it's shaky and breathy. And bad
+Laura McCarthy she sounded good in this performance, in tune and a good pitch. so what's the big deal?
People are going to hate But My Queen Slayys 👏🏼😍👑💗 !!! She beyond beautiful & Talented !!! She has though me to "Kill em with kindness" 😘
👌👌👌
Yaaassss! Slaylena rocks!😊😍
slay the autotune
Michelle Rivera honestly every singer used auto tune so your comment is irrelevant
JAMES ROBIN not the singers i like, they actually have something called "talent" :)
This song hits harder when you're heartbroken...💔
She’s super nice
The first song I ever new from here 😭😭 I memorized the whole song memories !!! That some brings back so many
perfection right there
02:55 i'm in love...
Best low notes❣️
Haters gonna hate, but I think she sounds amazing, shes truly beautiful and so sweet. A queen 💕
I like this version of this beautiful & adoring performance fr selena
Wtf this performance was great
She is so gorgeous ❤
PERFECTION!!!!
Beauty queen selena gomez
selena gomez is best singer
I remember watching this as a kid 10 years ago 🥺❤️ time really flies
in the beginning it was really weak. but towards the middle of getting better
I adore this..Dress is amazing💜🫧
Her voice is just awesome... Soothing... Not bold like other singers and i love this thing about her .... Music is not about shouting which other singers do.... Music should be soothing and selena is a lot soothing....... she is the best.. I love u my cutie pie selena.... U are so good
she was like whispering her background singers were louder than her
She was pretty good at the end she just needed the comfortablity on the beginning
I actually think they low her mic in the first verse
She's so perfect ♥
She is still young and has yet to learn, but every year her voice just gets better and better, I think she's beautiful and talented, Miley and Demi they have the same beautiful voices but do not compare them with Selena, they are different and the song "Year without rain" is difficult especially since she is singing to the audience and that is high pressure.she has a beautiful voice but it has not yet developed
Selena I love you, I'm your biggest fan
So perfect she is my world :)
Love her soo much.
So sick of seeing ppl hate on her cause shes with justin,, i mean how pathic are you ppl, GET OVER IT, im a Jelena supporter, I love JB and SG, and hope you guys know thats talking crap your prefect little justin sings with a recording to,, if you have seen his shows you would know.. dont get me wrong i love Justin, but damn put someone down just cause she is BEAUTIFUL, great actress and singer and mostly cause justin is in love with her and yall hate it,, truely sad
One of the best performance of her 😞😞❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
I think everybody saying she cant sing must be watching a different video lol...shes great
exactly I mean she's awesome so if they don't like her then why are they watching her lol
+Ariel Warren
I love selena but imma be honest I was expecting more than this .
She's like a princess
Another great music video by Selena Gomez (: !
I don't care but she slays revival
i love her dress ¡¡
she is so pretty
she can sing in live
you are so beautiful selena gomez
Live angel's voice...love you a lot
selena gomez melhor cantora do mundo linda e bonita
selena can sing
99% of the comments are arguing if she can sing.... Yes when Disney started off her singing career she could not sing, but she has definitely gotten better. Her latest songs are good.
Adoro essa música nessa versão.... ❤️❤️❤️
Qual a outra versão.?
well its a slap on those peoples faces who commented onthis video that she cant sing see her NOW! (2015) she is SO CHANGED but still she was also not bad back there she was actually PERFECT to me and still is
She CAN SING.Don't compare her with Demi or Miley.They're different.Their voices are different.
She is Perfect
ITS NOT BAD ITS PERFECTION AND IM A SELENATOR SHE IS PERFECT LIVE ITS HARDER TO SING LIVE THAN YOU THINK.
She look like a disney Princess 💖😘
A day without you is like a year without rain, Selena.😢😭❤
Aayushi Same here!
Demi. Now that girl has a great voice of TALENT.
the thing is, she's SO PRETTY, you cant even focus on her bad singing or whatever lol
SELENA IS THE BEST!! AND SHE CAN SING! In live iS FANTASTIC
Seriously, why all the hate? She is incredible! Love Selena :D
amazing selena gomez
One of my favorite performances 😍
We love Selena, period.❤
Omg! She's so cute 😍
1:58 Que hermosura y que vozarrón 😍
Perfect.
SELENA GOMEZ YOU ARE ABSOLUTELY AMAZING ALWAYS TRULY ENJOY YOUR MUSIC LOVE YA
Love you penny 😂😂😍😘😘
She is so beautiful. A goddess. Still is.
I don't think vocally she was weak. A year without rain is a simple and soft song and idk why the sound producers couldn't raise her microphone volume or fix it to where you'd hear the lower parts of the song better . I'll Tell you who was off tho, that background singer who came out of blend at the end😂😂. I know she was supposed to take the higher note but she just ruined the simplicity of it in my opinion they should've had someone with a lighter tone do it
this really good ... I love all her songs and movies too... I am her number 1 fan
She can sing ..but she can't hit high and powerful notes
Thts the fact
dwi dyyra This is where you are wrong, goes listened to "Sober" in live
dwi dyyra She doesn't need to hit high notes or powerful notes honey
aww!! baby Selena
Love this song. Never get tired of it. #goSELENA!!!