These kind of videos are the ones that unknowingly makes future astronomers! I’ve been addicted to binging these videos, they’ve definitely caught my attention.
It is described in The Holy Quran. The travel of Muhammad peace be upon him. Please read the chapter of mehraj and you will astonish to know that the speed of time get slow in heaven.it is already described in Quran Alhamdulilah.
Time is fascinating. I worked the subway stations for nearly 10 years. From one end of the city to the other. Every so often I would notice the city would be saying that, "Today just flew by" or "The day was just dragging along." How can an entire city, with no interaction with each other until they used the subway, complain about the same time paradox unless it was effected by it? Maybe a time distorted bubble the earth passes through in its revolution around the sun. Maybe random waves of time distortion hitting the earth? Maybe they're given off by the sun. Maybe they're from outside our Terran system and reach us in intervals. ???? Ti-i-i-ime, is on my side. Yes, it is.
Oooooo this plus how people tend to act in waves. Like I'll be at work and everyone tends to show up at the same time or not at all. It's different times but always the same pattern. Like everyone got hit with the same idea at once. But I do really like the idea of earth passing through time distortion spots. Especially since time space and gravity are all so linked. It'll absolutely explain why that feeling of time being weird is shared
Or, or, or, a person's perspective of the passage of time, is simply dependent upon their psychological state at the time? I'll go with William of Ockham every time.
@@ruffadamsthegreat.2662a person's perspective of the progression of time may well be altered by their current psychological state, however, a person's perspective of another person's passage of time will always be altered, to an exact precision, by the manner in which they are moving relative to that person... Mr Occam's Razor is, after all, merely a principle. It is not a theory or a law. And so I shall place my money down somewhere much relatively safer - I mean, he _was_ rather fond of trains and time and perspective and all that. You know... that guy Albert.
My favourite visual explanation is the entirety of World Enough and Time. Actually, exploration of their effects is probably the right way of putting it.
Great explainer. So if a person is in a black hole looking out they would see the universe moving alot faster. That would be the best firework show ever!
Visual Learner here - THANK YOU for actually explaining it in a way that makes sense to me! That small visual guide from your 8min video cleared up almost 40 years of my brain trying to comprehend 12 years of science and math from school, lol. Like a newborn shocked and confused that you disappeared by covering your face
HI my name is Joann and i am 13 years old I want to be an astronaut when I grow up, i read about black holes and i have learnt that time slower when you go closer to a black hole ,question 1: how can we learn about black holes if they trap light , and can't actually be seen? 2: how can we close the black holes? 3 does the black holes have any effect on our planets? 4 what is the future of black holes? to every problem there is a solution and a history I Joann promise to stop the black holes , well i am still working on it and finding solutions 🥰🥰
Thank you, Interstellar News; I hadn't heard of Phoenix A until now. I'll have to look it up.👍 (Anybody ever tell you that you sound a lot like Penn of Penn & Teller?)
I had an idea. Is there any chance that black holes could be some kind of telescope or magnifying hole? Imagine if you looked a thousand light years away and your telescope was looking into the lens of another telescope type of hole. I hope this makes since to others.
Vincent van Gogh was a mad man in his time and never rewarderd for his art and thoughts! 200 years later he is populair and rewarded as fuck, you sire are maybe the new Vincent van Gogh and people will see you were right after all! 😜😉
True, one would think black hole is some science fiction stuff. But its actually a reality. I mean, time being relative and length contraction and all would be science fiction but its reality.
Great video. And as expected, if you could see an observer inside the black hole they would indeed appear to stand still, and if the observer from within the black hole could see out the round "window" to the universe wpuld gett smaller and time would appear to speed up. By the time you get closest to the singularity the universe has died and black holes are evaporating from the view inside.
I’m releasing a Short about it soon. There’s not much to tell about it for a full video. Basically most of the internet is obsessed about a black hole whose size is unconfirmed. 🤷🏻♂️
My idea so I get to name it! What I mean is, no one has claimed it so I'm officially calling, "dibs." Voyager 1 is now in Milky Way's interstellar time or "Mikey's Time." "V-ger's" message has sped up now that it's outside our suns time bubble or, "Terran Time." It will be faster still when "V-ger" sends a message from beyond the Milky Way's time bubble. Then there's Outside the Local Group time bubble. So on and so on until we get outside any influence and into the, "True Interstellar Time Standard." Or, "T.I..." ;-P Now that "V-ger" is in interstellar space, it's also in the Milky Way's STANDARD, faster moving, interstellar time or "Mikey's Time." This can be proven by turning off everything except its clock and transmitter. Have "V-ger" read time for as long as possible. They WILL show the flow of time speeds up the further away you get from any celestial bodies. Until you reach the Milky Way's time standard or "Mikey's Time." •Our sun's time bubble: "Terran Time" we know and have measured. •Milky Way's time bubble or "Mikey's Time." The rate/flow of TIME outside any influence but within the Milky Way: We just got there and are still figuring. Wild guess I'd say time will increase in speed, now and until V-ger is outside the Ort cloud .00007-.0007% faster, maybe. Just for reference. •Local Group's time bubble or the rate/flow of time outside of any influence but within the Local Group: Name still open and unknown. Wild guess .08% to a couple seconds faster, maybe. Used just for reference. •Outside any influence in the, "True Interstellar Time Standard." (or T.I...) ;-P This name is NOT up for grabs. The rate/flow of time is fastest here. (Time flows fastest here so it's best to use a motor boat and hold tight. Always applies when you're in T.I....) ;-P A minute is a minute in all. It's the rate/flow I'm talking about. Heck, rivers of time flowing differently might explain dark energy and dark matter. The Milky Way's Interstellar Time Standard will be known as, "Mikey's Time." Pass it on, please and thank you!
Black holes are an event caused by several different things not an object. It's a very powerful event. Also, time is linear and also an event caused by several different things like expansion of space changing and growing. Time leaves scares in space leaving behind evidence of its presence.
Black holes are so strong that light can't escape it Black holes are formed when a stars core collapses and the core sucks the star and turns into a black hole
Almost. When a star uses up all its "fuel" and collapses, if I remember correctly, the core collapses faster than the outer material; and then the core does one of 3 things: It "hits bottom", rapidly forming the elements heavier than iron, and then "rebounds" on the shock wave it created in collapsing, slinging those elements out into space; OR, It collapses into a neutron star; OR, It collapses into a black hole. Which thing it does depends on how massive it was when it began to collapse. Now, I'm pretty sure that white dwarfs and brown dwarfs figure in there someplace, but I don't remember exactly how. Maybe a white dwarf is a star that was too small to one of those other 3 things? 🤔 Maybe. I forget, dangit. And I comPLETEly forget how a brown dwarf forms. Back to the books. 📚 📖 🎓 🏫
A question here You showed that space-time is in 2d(In reality it is 3d). Its like a fabric being warped by an objects gravity. A 2d illustration would not explain how planets orbit stars(Especially close). In a When the object is close a 2d illustration would illustrate a planet orbiting without ever facing the star, reducing its lumiunosity (from other stars) You could at least given a discaimer about the illustration Also, Great video
So basically 50yr around the black hole is not 100yrs at a point in time? can the curvature of the space be such that the spacial dimensions are contracted while the time dimension gets stretched? can a black hole be used to travel into the future???
Great questions! Space and time are linked. Cannot separate them. When one is affected, so is the other. In theory, black holes can create time dilation extreme enough to alter your point in time to an outside observers perspective. To you, time would not feel different at all. But to someone outside of it it would appear as if you’re slowing down. You wouldn’t be “jumping” forward in time, just moving slower through it.
@@officialinterstellarnews So basically no time travelling through black holes. since the same amount of time will pass if both the individual under the sway of the blackhole warping of space time and the observer... relatively... 1hr near a blackhole would still be an HR to the observer on earth... this is different from traveling at luminal speeds yes?
No. You're a little confused. Imagine 2 people the same age. They travel together out into space to a black hole. One stays with the ship, well away from the black hole, the other takes a powerful shuttlecraft to just outside the event horizon of the black hole, and stays there a while. He radios back to the ship to talk to his partner. But his partner APPEARS to be talking too fast for him to understand. Meanwhile, his partner on the ship is saying things like, "Well? Aren't you going to SAY anything?" "Are you gonna make me wait forever??"The guy in the shuttle APPEARS to the guy on the ship to be talking so slowly that he hasn't finished his first word yet. Now if the guy on the shuttle looks at his own clock, it APPEARS to be running normally to HIM. Same for the one on the ship; when he looks at HIS clock, it looks just right to HIM. But to the man on the ship, the clock on the shuttle appears to be almost stopped; and to the man on the shuttle, the ship's clock appears to be running WAY too fast. After the man on the shuttle has stayed close to the event horizon for what HE counts as a few hours, he goes back to the ship, and finds that YEARS have passed for his partner. And neither of them were "right" or "wrong", or fast or slow. What we call "normal" time is just the speed of time where we are at the moment. But your time may look different to somebody in different conditions, like high gravity or high velocity, looking back and watching you. Time runs differently under different conditions. Time is relative to where you are, and what you are doing. That's why it's CALLED "Relativity". ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
And as far as the passage of time is concerned, traveling at close to the speed of light is no different than being close to a black hole. Either way, the effect is the same. Time "slows down" in relation to someone who is NOT traveling fast or under high gravity.
@@kellyrobinson1780 but aren't those effects lost on travelling back. isn't that how relativity works? A second will still remain a second... even though that second is stretched from one person's perspective? hence when the person B who was on the ship around the black hole returns the same amount of time that passed for him is the same amount of time that elapsed for person A observing from earth? or have I misunderstood the concept? I am yet to figure out whether this is the same in FTL conceptual travel? my conclusion is blackhole time travel may not be possible but maybe light speed of ftl travel may have the key to time travel.
Time is directly related to the Earth's revolution around the sun and the Earth turning on its axis. We didn't invent that. So we have 1 revolution around the sun = 1 year. 1 full turn of the Earth on its axis = 1 day ( sub divided into minutes and seconds.) Time would exist differently else where in the universe.
@@EnigmaParadox-pk4ce were the terms and definitions of the words year, hour, minute second present and used by the first human to communicate in English? Time doesn't exist at all anywhere else in the universe only on this planet with the humans who invented the concept of time. Is a human construct and human invention. Yes, the sun rises and the sunsets but that is not predetermined by words in English language or human belief it is an astronomical event. Time was invented by humans to categorize events. Did time exist when the dinosaurs run the Earth? Did they go by the Gregorian calendar and years, months, days, minutes and seconds?
Why should quasar be used if NOT talking about them in any way whatsoever?? 🤔 A quasar is a VERY particular and VERY special arrangement of conditions around a bh which allow for a great deal of energy to be emitted but that has nothing at all to do with bh’s when the bh is not near any large amounts of gas/dust. In such a condition, a quasar has absolutely no relevance whatsoever. 😱 So THAT’S why this vid didn’t mention quasars and nor should it have done so.🤨🤪
So how do we know this? Have tested these theories with a REAL black hole? No we haven’t. And all these fancy images and videos of black holes are just made up since the best pictures we have of a black hole looks like a blurry donut. We don’t really have any real facts so vids like these kinda pisses me of 😒
If black holes are real, entire swaths of stars are missing and space is filled with water, wouldn't the hole be surrounded by water? Why is there still water in space?
Can u comment on this because u are my favorite person to watch when it’s about space. Ur explanation made sense to me, and when u said we need justice for Phoenix A it made me laugh
@@officialinterstellarnews is there any possibility when big bang happened right after that some black holes are formed ... and they have so heavy gravitational pull that we can see the big bang from starting! ! or may be time being stopped 😮😮
No. The "stopping" of time that we see is very localized in the immediate area of the hole itself. I guess it's kind of like feeling the heat from a candle. You only feel the heat when you're very close to it. In the same way, time only "stops" very close to a black hole. The effect isn't big enough to "freeze" the big bang in time. You have to remember that the big bang didn't expand INTO the universe; the big bang WAS the universe; and no black hole is big enough to affect the entire universe, no matter HOW massive it gets.
So if black holes are numerous and some extremely large, wouldn’t the time influence from their gravity affect our calculations of the universe, rendering our estimate of it’s age totally inaccurate?
Suprised he didn't mention the red shift. That's a pretty interesting part of it too. The closer u get to a black hole...if someone was looking at you going in...they would see u or ur ship or whatever, turn to the color red. Because ya know...light wave lengths and all that biz haha.
They absolutely do not! H shouldn’t have even mentioned anything remotely like what you mentioned because it’s completely incorrect and just serves to confuse people. Light is always seen to be going at velocity c, it NEVER changes (when in vacuum). If what he said was actually possible/true, around every bh a photon sphere would be seen. Surprise, surprise, bh’s aren’t showing up as incredibly bright points of light, which is what a photon sphere would look like. This is just one of several concepts that are mentioned in this vid but really shouldn’t have been as they only make the subject needlessly difficult to conceptualise, such as a photon magically appearing to slow down and/or stop. Yeah ok, sure, to everyone else, anyone or anything approaching a bh appears to be redshifted and this is exactly what would happen to a photon, it doesn’t appear to slow down, it appears as though it’s wavelength is constantly increasing, first towards the red end of the spectrum, then onto microwave and radio frequencies until it’s been redshifted so much that it’s no longer detectable (which is when it passes the eh).
Your comment is evidence that you haven't bothered to check out the evidence for their existence, that you don't know what they even are, and don't even know how gravity works. And as long as you have that attitude, it's pretty hard to explain to you. So arrogant!
@@pythondrink What kind of evidence, man?! There is no evidence, perhaps only in the minds of idle physics theorists who want to convince us of something to justify their existence. At the end of his life, Stephen William Hawking himself said that studying black holes caused him to lose a good part of his life, which he now doubts exists...
![The Other Side of a Black Hole [4K]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZVPsNDonA84/mqdefault.jpg)
These kind of videos are the ones that unknowingly makes future astronomers! I’ve been addicted to binging these videos, they’ve definitely caught my attention.
It is described in The Holy Quran. The travel of Muhammad peace be upon him. Please read the chapter of mehraj and you will astonish to know that the speed of time get slow in heaven.it is already described in Quran Alhamdulilah.
@@abdullahsaleem2072Fellow Muslim?
Time is fascinating. I worked the subway stations for nearly 10 years. From one end of the city to the other. Every so often I would notice the city would be saying that, "Today just flew by" or "The day was just dragging along." How can an entire city, with no interaction with each other until they used the subway, complain about the same time paradox unless it was effected by it? Maybe a time distorted bubble the earth passes through in its revolution around the sun. Maybe random waves of time distortion hitting the earth? Maybe they're given off by the sun. Maybe they're from outside our Terran system and reach us in intervals. ???? Ti-i-i-ime, is on my side. Yes, it is.
Oooooo this plus how people tend to act in waves. Like I'll be at work and everyone tends to show up at the same time or not at all. It's different times but always the same pattern. Like everyone got hit with the same idea at once.
But I do really like the idea of earth passing through time distortion spots. Especially since time space and gravity are all so linked. It'll absolutely explain why that feeling of time being weird is shared
Or, or, or, a person's perspective of the passage of time, is simply dependent upon their psychological state at the time?
I'll go with William of Ockham every time.
@@ruffadamsthegreat.2662a person's perspective of the progression of time may well be altered by their current psychological state, however, a person's perspective of another person's passage of time will always be altered, to an exact precision, by the manner in which they are moving relative to that person... Mr Occam's Razor is, after all, merely a principle. It is not a theory or a law. And so I shall place my money down somewhere much relatively safer - I mean, he _was_ rather fond of trains and time and perspective and all that. You know... that guy Albert.
@@simesaid
Oh yes, kinda sweet on that guy Albert.
Makes us wonder if we have the ability to control how we percive time.
This is the best visual explanation of time dilation that I’ve seen in all my years. I majored in physics in college. Well done man.
My favourite visual explanation is the entirety of World Enough and Time.
Actually, exploration of their effects is probably the right way of putting it.
That honestly makes a lot of sense, great explination!
Thank you Jermaine! This was the easiest way I could think of to communicate it. Glad it came across well! 🚀❤️
@@officialinterstellarnewsplz link the sources
Great explainer. So if a person is in a black hole looking out they would see the universe moving alot faster. That would be the best firework show ever!
If you were able to survive it for long enough somehow, yes. You’d watch the universe age and unfold before you
briliant @@officialinterstellarnews
@@officialinterstellarnews As a spaghetti
I think it might be better said this way: “If a person is in a black hole…
..“
Visual Learner here - THANK YOU for actually explaining it in a way that makes sense to me! That small visual guide from your 8min video cleared up almost 40 years of my brain trying to comprehend 12 years of science and math from school, lol. Like a newborn shocked and confused that you disappeared by covering your face
This Video doesnt have enough views. Keep up the good work
I appreciate that! Working on it haha. Got some other videos you may like on the channel and would love to know what you think. 🙏🏻🚀
HI my name is Joann and i am 13 years old I want to be an astronaut when I grow up, i read about black holes and i have learnt that time slower when you go closer to a black hole ,question 1: how can we learn about black holes if they trap light , and can't actually be seen?
2: how can we close the black holes?
3 does the black holes have any effect on our planets?
4 what is the future of black holes?
to every problem there is a solution and a history
I Joann promise to stop the black holes , well i am still working on it and finding solutions 🥰🥰
thanks for information ❤❤❤
from Manila Philippines🇵🇭🇵🇭
Thank you, Interstellar News; I hadn't heard of Phoenix A until now. I'll have to look it up.👍 (Anybody ever tell you that you sound a lot like Penn of Penn & Teller?)
I had an idea. Is there any chance that black holes could be some kind of telescope or magnifying hole? Imagine if you looked a thousand light years away and your telescope was looking into the lens of another telescope type of hole. I hope this makes since to others.
That's kind of a scary thought... Isn't it?
@kevinmichael3662 not if it's just a lense illusion
Vincent van Gogh was a mad man in his time and never rewarderd for his art and thoughts! 200 years later he is populair and rewarded as fuck, you sire are maybe the new Vincent van Gogh and people will see you were right after all! 😜😉
True, one would think black hole is some science fiction stuff. But its actually a reality. I mean, time being relative and length contraction and all would be science fiction but its reality.
Great video. And as expected, if you could see an observer inside the black hole they would indeed appear to stand still, and if the observer from within the black hole could see out the round "window" to the universe wpuld gett smaller and time would appear to speed up. By the time you get closest to the singularity the universe has died and black holes are evaporating from the view inside.
That was awesome, you or whoever simplified the explanation did a really good job, even even a kid who just learned physics can understand it.
Thank you so much! 🙏🏻
Make a Video on Phoenix A*
I’m releasing a Short about it soon. There’s not much to tell about it for a full video. Basically most of the internet is obsessed about a black hole whose size is unconfirmed. 🤷🏻♂️
GREAT VIDEO! This was intuitive and simple(ish) to understand. Science communication done RIGHT and brilliantly.
Fascinated by how the Helix Nebula resembles an eyeball
So cool! 👁️
Nasa: were gunna have a good day an ain't nobody gunna die today
Also nasa: time to go curling 🥌
ZA WARLDO Over Heaven 💀
Wow that answer some questions I had but couldn't figure out
Melodysheep's soundtrack, let's gooooo
They’re the best!
Time is a flat ⭕️. ~ Reggie Ledoux
Wow amazing video!
Hey thank you so much! Means a lot! 🙏🏻🚀
Can jwst focus on black hold ?
Credits to cameraman for getting all this footage
Can it the black hole be a portal to like another world(parelell world)or the way into the heaven or hell....???
My idea so I get to name it! What I mean is, no one has claimed it so I'm officially calling, "dibs." Voyager 1 is now in Milky Way's interstellar time or "Mikey's Time."
"V-ger's" message has sped up now that it's outside our suns time bubble or, "Terran Time." It will be faster still when "V-ger" sends a message from beyond the Milky Way's time bubble. Then there's Outside the Local Group time bubble. So on and so on until we get outside any influence and into the, "True Interstellar Time Standard." Or, "T.I..." ;-P
Now that "V-ger" is in interstellar space, it's also in the Milky Way's STANDARD, faster moving, interstellar time or "Mikey's Time." This can be proven by turning off everything except its clock and transmitter. Have "V-ger" read time for as long as possible. They WILL show the flow of time speeds up the further away you get from any celestial bodies. Until you reach the Milky Way's time standard or "Mikey's Time."
•Our sun's time bubble: "Terran Time" we know and have measured.
•Milky Way's time bubble or "Mikey's Time." The rate/flow of TIME outside any influence but within the Milky Way: We just got there and are still figuring. Wild guess I'd say time will increase in speed, now and until V-ger is outside the Ort cloud .00007-.0007% faster, maybe. Just for reference.
•Local Group's time bubble or the rate/flow of time outside of any influence but within the Local Group: Name still open and unknown. Wild guess .08% to a couple seconds faster, maybe. Used just for reference.
•Outside any influence in the, "True Interstellar Time Standard." (or T.I...) ;-P This name is NOT up for grabs. The rate/flow of time is fastest here. (Time flows fastest here so it's best to use a motor boat and hold tight. Always applies when you're in T.I....) ;-P
A minute is a minute in all. It's the rate/flow I'm talking about. Heck, rivers of time flowing differently might explain dark energy and dark matter.
The Milky Way's Interstellar Time Standard will be known as, "Mikey's Time."
Pass it on, please and thank you!
The black hole is a Science fiction loop hole. Great CGI!
Excellent video 👍👍👍
Thank you very much! 🙏🏻🪐
Black holes are an event caused by several different things not an object. It's a very powerful event. Also, time is linear and also an event caused by several different things like expansion of space changing and growing. Time leaves scares in space leaving behind evidence of its presence.
Black holes are so strong that light can't escape it
Black holes are formed when a stars core collapses and the core sucks the star and turns into a black hole
Well, that's sort of correct. There's a wee bit more to it, lol.
Almost. When a star uses up all its "fuel" and collapses, if I remember correctly, the core collapses faster than the outer material; and then the core does one of 3 things:
It "hits bottom", rapidly forming the elements heavier than iron, and then "rebounds" on the shock wave it created in collapsing, slinging those elements out into space; OR,
It collapses into a neutron star; OR,
It collapses into a black hole.
Which thing it does depends on how massive it was when it began to collapse.
Now, I'm pretty sure that white dwarfs and brown dwarfs figure in there someplace, but I don't remember exactly how.
Maybe a white dwarf is a star that was too small to one of those other 3 things? 🤔 Maybe. I forget, dangit.
And I comPLETEly forget how a brown dwarf forms.
Back to the books. 📚 📖 🎓 🏫
So from the outside it looks like a black hole is a very hard object, but to an insider it is more fluid than the most viscous stuff?
Yes
Haha! JUSTICE for Phoenix A!
JUSTICE!!!!!
Because they have a TARDIS😂
this is cgi and theory. the real truth is, we never go there.
what about primordial black holes?
Completely different things and still quite a mystery. May be worth doing a video just on those
@@officialinterstellarnews Have you heard the theory of Planet Nine being a primordial black hole?
Great explanation and use of graphics to aid it. This is the first time I have heard it explained using the 3d and 4d perspective.
Thank you! It’s the easiest way I could think to explain it. Glad you enjoyed it!
Agreed!
A question here
You showed that space-time is in 2d(In reality it is 3d). Its like a fabric being warped by an objects gravity. A 2d illustration would not explain how planets orbit stars(Especially close). In a When the object is close a 2d illustration would illustrate a planet orbiting without ever facing the star, reducing its lumiunosity (from other stars)
You could at least given a discaimer about the illustration
Also, Great video
By spacetime, I mean General relativity
its infinite darkness or a bubble of light?! 🤔🤨🤔🤨
Infinite darkness surrounded by a bubble of light. That light is called a quasar. Google it.
So basically 50yr around the black hole is not 100yrs at a point in time? can the curvature of the space be such that the spacial dimensions are contracted while the time dimension gets stretched?
can a black hole be used to travel into the future???
Great questions!
Space and time are linked. Cannot separate them. When one is affected, so is the other.
In theory, black holes can create time dilation extreme enough to alter your point in time to an outside observers perspective. To you, time would not feel different at all. But to someone outside of it it would appear as if you’re slowing down.
You wouldn’t be “jumping” forward in time, just moving slower through it.
@@officialinterstellarnews So basically no time travelling through black holes. since the same amount of time will pass if both the individual under the sway of the blackhole warping of space time and the observer... relatively... 1hr near a blackhole would still be an HR to the observer on earth...
this is different from traveling at luminal speeds yes?
No. You're a little confused.
Imagine 2 people the same age. They travel together out into space to a black hole.
One stays with the ship, well away from the black hole, the other takes a powerful shuttlecraft to just outside the event horizon of the black hole, and stays there a while.
He radios back to the ship to talk to his partner. But his partner APPEARS to be talking too fast for him to understand.
Meanwhile, his partner on the ship is saying things like, "Well? Aren't you going to SAY anything?" "Are you gonna make me wait forever??"The guy in the shuttle APPEARS to the guy on the ship to be talking so slowly that he hasn't finished his first word yet.
Now if the guy on the shuttle looks at his own clock, it APPEARS to be running normally to HIM. Same for the one on the ship; when he looks at HIS clock, it looks just right to HIM.
But to the man on the ship, the clock on the shuttle appears to be almost stopped; and to the man on the shuttle, the ship's clock appears to be running WAY too fast.
After the man on the shuttle has stayed close to the event horizon for what HE counts as a few hours, he goes back to the ship, and finds that YEARS have passed for his partner.
And neither of them were "right" or "wrong", or fast or slow. What we call "normal" time is just the speed of time where we are at the moment. But your time may look different to somebody in different conditions, like high gravity or high velocity, looking back and watching you.
Time runs differently under different conditions. Time is relative to where you are, and what you are doing. That's why it's CALLED "Relativity".
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
And as far as the passage of time is concerned, traveling at close to the speed of light is no different than being close to a black hole. Either way, the effect is the same. Time "slows down" in relation to someone who is NOT traveling fast or under high gravity.
@@kellyrobinson1780 but aren't those effects lost on travelling back. isn't that how relativity works? A second will still remain a second... even though that second is stretched from one person's perspective? hence when the person B who was on the ship around the black hole returns the same amount of time that passed for him is the same amount of time that elapsed for person A observing from earth? or have I misunderstood the concept? I am yet to figure out whether this is the same in FTL conceptual travel? my conclusion is blackhole time travel may not be possible but maybe light speed of ftl travel may have the key to time travel.
If this hole is Soo huge with earth and the moon Soo small in comparison, why haven't both been obliterated along with this planet x thingy?
Hmmm, perhaps because it’s nowhere near earth? 😱 And because there’s no such thing as a 10th planet in the solar system.🤪🤪
I still don't get it. And I want to!
Time is a human invention to categorize events. It only exists because we created it.
Time is directly related to the Earth's revolution around the sun and the Earth turning on its axis. We didn't invent that.
So we have 1 revolution around the sun = 1 year. 1 full turn of the Earth on its axis = 1 day ( sub divided into minutes and seconds.)
Time would exist differently else where in the universe.
@@EnigmaParadox-pk4ce were the terms and definitions of the words year, hour, minute second present and used by the first human to communicate in English?
Time doesn't exist at all anywhere else in the universe only on this planet with the humans who invented the concept of time. Is a human construct and human invention. Yes, the sun rises and the sunsets but that is not predetermined by words in English language or human belief it is an astronomical event. Time was invented by humans to categorize events. Did time exist when the dinosaurs run the Earth? Did they go by the Gregorian calendar and years, months, days, minutes and seconds?
Say what now?
🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀
You haven’t used the word quasar even once in a black hole video. Why?
Why should quasar be used if NOT talking about them in any way whatsoever?? 🤔 A quasar is a VERY particular and VERY special arrangement of conditions around a bh which allow for a great deal of energy to be emitted but that has nothing at all to do with bh’s when the bh is not near any large amounts of gas/dust. In such a condition, a quasar has absolutely no relevance whatsoever. 😱 So THAT’S why this vid didn’t mention quasars and nor should it have done so.🤨🤪
@@aaronperelmuter8433 is there a reason you’re using CAPS in your response? Are you Gen Z or younger?
@@aaronperelmuter8433People have asked about light forming around the black hole. I told them it's called a quasar. So it is actually relevant.
Yes black holes are dangerous very good source of danger
100% of your Minimum Daily Requirement, AND a good source of fiber, too!😁
So how do we know this? Have tested these theories with a REAL black hole? No we haven’t. And all these fancy images and videos of black holes are just made up since the best pictures we have of a black hole looks like a blurry donut. We don’t really have any real facts so vids like these kinda pisses me of 😒
Time stops inside of a black hole because you're dead
If black holes are real, entire swaths of stars are missing and space is filled with water, wouldn't the hole be surrounded by water? Why is there still water in space?
Think before you speak.
Not water. Space is filled with energy, vacuum energy. Google 'quantum vacuum field.'
First
Nnnnnope.
Black holes leads to final space
Can u comment on this because u are my favorite person to watch when it’s about space.
Ur explanation made sense to me, and when u said we need justice for Phoenix A it made me laugh
Thanks so much! So glad you enjoyed the video and I could help you understand more about black holes and space! 🚀🙏🏻
@@officialinterstellarnews
is there any possibility when big bang happened right after that some black holes are formed ...
and they have so heavy gravitational pull that we can see the big bang from starting! ! or may be time being stopped 😮😮
No. The "stopping" of time that we see is very localized in the immediate area of the hole itself. I guess it's kind of like feeling the heat from a candle. You only feel the heat when you're very close to it. In the same way, time only "stops" very close to a black hole. The effect isn't big enough to "freeze" the big bang in time.
You have to remember that the big bang didn't expand INTO the universe; the big bang WAS the universe; and no black hole is big enough to affect the entire universe, no matter HOW massive it gets.
Earth sounds like Goku’s nimbus cloud
So if black holes are numerous and some extremely large, wouldn’t the time influence from their gravity affect our calculations of the universe, rendering our estimate of it’s age totally inaccurate?
It’s only the local time close to or at the black hole would be effected, from my understanding
No. After all, "you" are the center of "your" universe... At, essentially, *all* (of your) time(s).
No worries, right?
@@christianminor-ov3pw I was referring to the universe age not my own.
why did the photon go down instead of directly in to the black hole?
Suprised he didn't mention the red shift. That's a pretty interesting part of it too. The closer u get to a black hole...if someone was looking at you going in...they would see u or ur ship or whatever, turn to the color red. Because ya know...light wave lengths and all that biz haha.
Black hole: A physical representation of what humans call time.
What i am trying to understand is why the photons seem to stop to the outside observer instead of disappearing into the black hole?
They absolutely do not! H shouldn’t have even mentioned anything remotely like what you mentioned because it’s completely incorrect and just serves to confuse people. Light is always seen to be going at velocity c, it NEVER changes (when in vacuum). If what he said was actually possible/true, around every bh a photon sphere would be seen. Surprise, surprise, bh’s aren’t showing up as incredibly bright points of light, which is what a photon sphere would look like.
This is just one of several concepts that are mentioned in this vid but really shouldn’t have been as they only make the subject needlessly difficult to conceptualise, such as a photon magically appearing to slow down and/or stop. Yeah ok, sure, to everyone else, anyone or anything approaching a bh appears to be redshifted and this is exactly what would happen to a photon, it doesn’t appear to slow down, it appears as though it’s wavelength is constantly increasing, first towards the red end of the spectrum, then onto microwave and radio frequencies until it’s been redshifted so much that it’s no longer detectable (which is when it passes the eh).
@@aaronperelmuter8433There is a photon sphere around some black holes. It's called a quasar. Google it.
Great video
Thank you so much!
Black holes 🕳 = my absolute favorite‼️
It's amazing that you guys are still talking about black holes even though there is absolutely no proof that they actually exist!!
Black holes are proven with strong evidence, not sure what you are talking about when you say there is no evidence.
Your comment is evidence that you haven't bothered to check out the evidence for their existence, that you don't know what they even are, and don't even know how gravity works. And as long as you have that attitude, it's pretty hard to explain to you. So arrogant!
@@pythondrink What kind of evidence, man?! There is no evidence, perhaps only in the minds of idle physics theorists who want to convince us of something to justify their existence. At the end of his life, Stephen William Hawking himself said that studying black holes caused him to lose a good part of his life, which he now doubts exists...